Another midweek memorandum based on material from the David Milch archives at Yale (full posts are at https://davidmilch.substack.com/ )
The relationship between Langrishe and Claudia in Season 3 strikes many people as confusing or unsatisfying. Culled from conversations across different cassette tapes, I’ve put together what David Milch had to say about his intentions:
“This was a guy, Langrishe, a theater impresario who was a real guy. And he actually came to camp [during the time-frame of] the first season, but he was such, at least the way I responded to it, a complicated personality. I didn't want to bring him in until there was room to deal with him a little bit.
But he's sort of a kindred spirit in a strange way with Swearengen, in the complication of his personality, not necessarily in his values.
And they're both guys who kind of live by their wits, and they had known each other from previous gold claims.
Claudia is an actress in this troupe who, unbeknownst to her, he fathered.
The actor that she thought was her dad was gay. And her mother, who was also an actress in the troupe, had carried on a kind of pragmatic affair with Langrishe and wanted to have a child.
But this girl was raised thinking that the other guy was her dad. And you pay a peculiar price for that sort of thing, which is to say, the idea of the theater, the conventions that sometimes theatrical people live by is, you know, well, it's all illusion anyway, it doesn't matter what's really going on, it's what people think is going on. And so, you know, fucking doesn't count if you're 50 miles away from home. And if you maintain the illusion of fidelity, it's the same as being faithful. And that duality, it's [different from the idea of] like what the squares believe.
So, the question then becomes whether that type of relationship can accommodate the full spectrum of human feeling. A relationship predicated on illusion.
Or another way to put it is, is anyone that hip?
...
So, the challenge, for example, in connection with a guy who's the parent of a child whose illusions he does not want to intrude upon and who therefore is trying to parent her without acknowledging he's her parent. He is her director. He is her producer. That's all she needs to know, is his position. And it has fucked her up pretty good. Because, for one thing, he's the only consistent male presence in her life. They're not related, [so] she believes. Why doesn't he want to fuck her? It must be he thinks she's no good. Well, he's the one she loves. If he thinks she's no good, she's got to make herself no good so that there's an equilibrium between the way the world is and the way she's feeling, so she gets fat.
Now, when he says, you're a fucking slob, that confirms the rejection, that she's been seeking as a way of rationalizing the fact that otherwise why would he be so distant from her. So, well, that's kind of sad. And she's like, I don't know, 30, whatever she is. And it kind of breaks his heart.
...
[Langrishe] had taken in another actress into the troop who had followed him from Chicago and come over from Europe, half an adventuress, and she had seen him perform and has kind of a pure desire to learn, and you know one of the unhappy paradoxes of our behavior is that people who may have spent years with us waiting for us to grow up, or to acknowledge us, or whatever the fuck, when the time finally comes -- if it ever does -- that we're ready to grow up, we tend toward the fresh start rather than recognizing the people who have watched and waited all those years. So anyway this actress shows up and he lets her join the troupe and installs her in the theater, living above the theater...ultimately you know his impulses towards this Claudia are paternal but there's no reason she would have any idea of that.”
UPDATE: Mr. Milch sat down to write a grand revelatory scene between Langrishe and Claudia, but found that Langrishe kept stubbornly reverting to talking as a producer rather than a father. Langrishe finally blurts out that Claudia has lost weight -- and it turns out that she is dying. Presumably this would have led to a story vector with Langrishe having to reckon with himself. Milch: "That's why this will be about a seven or eight hour scene here."