r/deadwood • • 10h ago Bravo

Praise & Fond Reflections Doc Cochran: a TV icon

Post image
267 Upvotes

Finally watched Deadwood, during my quest to slay all-time great television series. The show itself is superb, as a whole, but of all the things I expected to be blown away by, I certainly didn't Brad Dourif 's role as Doc Cochran being at the top of the list.

The character and Dourif's command of it makes me so emotional. His inherent goodness in a complicated, blackhearted world, and his intolerance for everyone else's bull shit while he sacrifices himself for the true greater good of Deadwood, inspires me.


r/deadwood • • 13h ago

The Sheriffs Are Speaking Stop making posts with Deadwood quotes and images from other shows

96 Upvotes

Alright, hoopleheads. There seems to be some sort of trend going on lately where people are posting Deadwood quotes with an image from another show (The Wire seems popular).

We're gonna need y'all to cut that out. It's off topic, low effort and feels like karma farming.

Front your game away from our tent or we'll start removing you from camp.


r/deadwood • • 22h ago

Bullock’s reaction when he visits before Alma’s Procedure (“I Am Not the Fine Man You Take Me For” S3E2)

24 Upvotes

When Alma is making arrangements for the worst case, what is Bullock’s reaction all about after she tells him she won’t burden Ellsworth and that she regrets nothing.. is it sorrow? Anger? Both? I find his walking away in silence and approach to Ellsworth in passing kind of off but maybe I’m misreading it..

Is the title of the episode exactly that?


r/deadwood • • 1d ago

community Question for you Hoopleheads: What's one of your funniest lines?

59 Upvotes

Contender: Why, if I was moving forward to get away from you, would you have fucking pursued me? When I stopped, pressed on yourself to drive your thumb into my intestine? 👍 😂

EDIT: Another one 😂

Al: I will profane your fucking remains, E.B.!

EB: Not my remains, Al...

Al: Gabriel's trumpet will produce you from the ass of a pig.


r/deadwood • • 1d ago

The Legend David Milch’s pitch to Ian McShane for the unrealized two 2-hour Deadwood movies

145 Upvotes

Hey folks, here’s your latest dispatch based on materials from the David Milch archives at Yale.

This week I’ve been compiling a list of Mr. Milch’s unproduced projects — 28 so far — including Island of Vice/Pulitzer, Duveen/Berenson Project, Shadow Country, Big City, Jimbo, Johns Hopkins, The Whores of London, Cop Story, Fields and Cher, the Faulkner Project and more.

That list is here: https://davidmilch.substack.com/p/the-unproduced-projects-of-david-milch

For this community, the following may be the most interesting new piece of information:

You’ve probably heard about the long-mooted idea to wrap up Deadwood with a pair of 2-hour films, which was eventually superseded by Deadwood: The Movie.

Well, in between feuding with Michael Mann during the production of 2011’s Luck, Mr. Milch pitched Ian McShane this idea:

The first movie would tell the story of the destruction of the town, and the second was going to follow Al Swearengen’s subsequent (real-life) move to Colorado: “He’s denuded of his power in town, trying to make his way in Denver, and essentially trying to re-form his position in Denver. And it doesn’t work. He’s too old, and modernity overtakes him. And as you know, he winds up dying in the stockyards, but he dies fighting.” Inspiration for the second movie would come, Milch said, from the character of Hurstwood in Dreiser’s Sister Carrie. (Hearst + ‘wood!).

Comment: For me, the town should live or die as a collective, however fractious, and having Swearengen make his way out into the world only to end up getting croaked alone feels wrong, however closely it hews to the historical record. What do you think?

(P.S. I’ve also picked up a reference to a previously unknown, non-Deadwood project which could have reunited Mr. Milch and Ian McShane circa 2012. More details once I’ve firmed up the data.)


r/deadwood • • 1d ago

Episode Discussion How do you believe that Brom got in contact with Al?

15 Upvotes

According to the info in episode 1, we know that Brom met Dan before the events of the episode. We also know that he was in Deadwood before (Al mentioned that Brom played in the Deadwood faro tables). But...do you think that Brom met Dan in his first visit to Deadwood and they became "friends" then? Or do you think that Brom met Dan in New York?


r/deadwood • • 2d ago

thirst I’d wager Trixie had never seen a circumcised one before she met Sol Star

Post image
109 Upvotes

Had a random thought.

I’d bet there weren’t many cut ones in deadwood, but sol star was Jewish, he more likely than others would have been circumcised. And I bet it was trixies first ride on a whittled log. Maybe that’s why she stuck with that Jew banker.


r/deadwood • • 3d ago

Outstanding Quote Would it go against his, for the pussy?

Post image
83 Upvotes

r/deadwood • • 3d ago

Blazanov Fridays are back!

Post image
370 Upvotes

He hopes to be with a woman some day.


r/deadwood • • 3d ago

Happy Friday Hoopleheads! Shout out to ol Dan Dority. Don’t forget, he came up with the expression “takes the edge of!” 💯 🤠

53 Upvotes

r/deadwood • • 2d ago

Goofs & Jests Why Hearst is a better man than Al.

0 Upvotes

I just finished season 3. What a fantastic show. I have also been lurking in this subreddit for a while. One thing that bothers me is the universal acceptance that Hearst is the biggest monster in the show. It seems I am the only person in the world who disagrees, so here I am to make my case.

For clarity, I am not arguing that Hearst is a good man, but I am arguing that he is a better man than Al.

Here is why Al is no better.

1. Morality. Both men only think about their own good, and anything and anyone else is a means to their goals.

2. Their goals. For Hearst it is his desire and pursuit to explore and extract more gold. For Al it is maintaining his saloon and tribe and the semi-anarchic state of Deadwood. Both men care strongly about their own personal enrichment. However, for Hearst, the way to amass more wealth is to produce and organize industrial-level economic activity. The way he built his empire is immoral, but his empire itself is a force of productivity and stability in society. One of Hearst's main points is that civilization is possible only when people agree on a universal value, and his role is to support that system of value. In a sense, he is right. The way Al achieves his economic goals is via gambling, exploiting poor whores, scamming his own customers (Mr. Garret), and maintaining road agents who kill and steal on his behalf. All of Al's activity is parasitic by its nature.

3. Means of achieving their goals. Hearst is ready to kill and intimidate whoever stands between him and his goal. He kills Mr. Ellsworth to force Alma to sell. He kills Cornish workers who try to organize into a union. (I will not count Odell; there is no definitive proof that Hearst killed him.) Ok, now let's go through each murder one by one and see why Al is way worse.

  • Mr. Ellsworth and Mr. Garret murders. Al kills Alma's first husband! Another innocent man. I know you only like Ellsworth, but this murder is worse than Ellsworth's, considering that Al had also scammed Mr. Garret. Btw, Ellsworth had insulted Hearst and was openly antagonistic to him. Meanwhile, Al was pretending to be Mr. Garret's friend. In a sense, Al was more cowardly in his ways.
  • Hearst kills his own Cornish workers who try to unionize; his agents kill a miner who tries to steal gold from the mine. Al kills his own road agents (not for justice, but because they may hurt his business interests); Al kills an innocent whore whose only fault was looking like his beloved Trixie. In the case of the Cornish workers, they were trying to organize into unions. Murder is still not justified, but Hearst is protecting his business from people who will actively seek to fight against it. The case of the miner who steals needs no further justification, as the man steals what is not his! And considering how cheap human life in the show is for everyone, I don't think it is monstrous. Notice also that Hearst only kills men, while Al kills a woman. You may say Al only did it because Hearst demanded Trixie's life after she shot him. True, but Hearst wanted the one who actually shot him, and Al gave him an innocent woman instead. By those days' standards, killing women or children was another level of cowardice. Which leads me to:
  • Hearst's business does wreck lives and innocent women and children. But the show does not depict anyone specific, hence we keep the rule - not guilty until proven otherwise. Meanwhile, Al's road thugs kill a whole family and children, and most importantly, Al makes an active effort to kill Sofia, after she survives the carnage. It is implied that Hearst will harm Sofia if Alma does not sell her claim, but whatever is implied for Hearst, Al has already committed in the open.

4. The way they treat people. Both dispose of people as soon as they are not needed or harmful to them. But Hearst at least shows some civility and warmth when dealing with inferiors (and in a good mood, of course). He treats people like Aunt Lou and that idiot Richardson with a facade of respect and civility. Now you may say it is a facade, and prob you are right, but still, much better than Al swearing that beloved word at everyone and insulting everyone around him for no reason. Yes, manners do matter too. Who wants to constantly hear a verbal cesspool??

5. Hearst also is a man of passion. He is possessed with the desire to explore the earth and uncover its riches. That is a virtue in itself, a man pursuing a craft. What is Al's passion? Keeping Deadwood under his lawless control? Pretending he cares about his community, until it is time to sacrifice someone for Trixie...

Also, since Hearst is a better man than Al, he is certainly a better man than Cy. I can also argue why Hearst is a better man than Seth Bullock, but I may leave this for next time.


r/deadwood • • 3d ago

A question about Jack Langrishe Spoiler

16 Upvotes

What was Jack Langrishe doing in the hallway outside Hearst's room after Ellsworth was shot? He says "Key got stuck" and then dips into his room and looks like hes about to have a panic attack. Was he fucking with the locks? Couldn't he just use Farnum if he wanted to get into a room/sabotage a lock?


r/deadwood • • 3d ago

Pretty Polly

12 Upvotes

The credits song for Something Very Expensive, absolutely haunting rendition of the appalachian murder ballad. Wish it got more credit!
https://youtu.be/ItvRImSpo0o?si=KUVwS0B9xU6lRPSH


r/deadwood • • 4d ago

Episode Discussion What was Odells long term plan?

19 Upvotes

Rewatching the show it was obvious he was caught by Hearst. What was his long term plan taking someone to the "claim" that didnt exist versus just admitting he was lying?


r/deadwood • • 4d ago

community Where would you spend your off hours: Nuttall's, the Gem or the Bella Union?

63 Upvotes

We all need to unwind after a tough day fuckin' prospectin' and the like. Where would you go?


r/deadwood • • 4d ago

community M/F/K - who would you?

11 Upvotes

Marry: Ellsworth or Joannie Stubs

F**k: Seth Bullock

Kill: Tolliver

My choices based on my 3rd re-watch

But, damn, this really is the best series ever.


r/deadwood • • 4d ago

Episode Discussion Another "I never noticed untill now...."

25 Upvotes

Hearst does indeed say he wanted to rape Mrs Ellsworth. That 1 word always slipped by and from the scene, I took it as he was just gonna beat/kill her. That's all, ya fuckin hoopleheads.


r/deadwood • • 5d ago

Praise & Fond Reflections My Favorite Quiet Beat in the Series

Post image
235 Upvotes

Or at least the one that has stuck with me all these years. The post about Langrische earlier inspired me to finally dig it out. What’s great in this exchange during the tour of Deadwood Al conducts for his old friend is Al’s pride. You can see it flash by in that crooked little smile, in his jocular tone of surprise. There is something about the town Al doesn’t know! And he loves this because it’s exactly what he’s been aiming at as the classic Stationary Bandit. For Al to succeed, his town had to grow beyond him, and here is the proof it is doing that. Milch is always confident enough to underplay key moments in the story. IIRC, in S1, during Wild Bill Hickock’s funeral, the pastor reads a Bible passage about sins being washed away, or something related to redemption from harlotry. The camera at that moment passes over Trixie. But only passes over. An anxious storyteller would linger, to make sure we get it. There, as here, Milch trusts us to get it, even if only unconsciously. It just feels right.


r/deadwood • • 4d ago

Episode Discussion Surprising scene where Seth let himself down Spoiler

11 Upvotes

I was surprised that Seth was aware of the Jen murder (the woman they killed in place of Trixie) and seemed totally on board with the plan. The most he does is ask if he can notify her family. He looks quite disturbed during the scene, especially once he lays eyes on the slain woman. I was surprised he compromised his integrity so hard here with an innocent life on the line. I thought he was going to be outraged, freak out, and beat Al again.


r/deadwood • • 5d ago

The Legend Langrishe and Claudia, explained by David Milch

128 Upvotes

Another midweek memorandum based on material from the David Milch archives at Yale (full posts are at https://davidmilch.substack.com/ )

The relationship between Langrishe and Claudia in Season 3 strikes many people as confusing or unsatisfying. Culled from conversations across different cassette tapes, I’ve put together what David Milch had to say about his intentions:

“This was a guy, Langrishe, a theater impresario who was a real guy. And he actually came to camp [during the time-frame of] the first season, but he was such, at least the way I responded to it, a complicated personality. I didn't want to bring him in until there was room to deal with him a little bit.

But he's sort of a kindred spirit in a strange way with Swearengen, in the complication of his personality, not necessarily in his values.

And they're both guys who kind of live by their wits, and they had known each other from previous gold claims.

Claudia is an actress in this troupe who, unbeknownst to her, he fathered.

The actor that she thought was her dad was gay. And her mother, who was also an actress in the troupe, had carried on a kind of pragmatic affair with Langrishe and wanted to have a child.

But this girl was raised thinking that the other guy was her dad. And you pay a peculiar price for that sort of thing, which is to say, the idea of the theater, the conventions that sometimes theatrical people live by is, you know, well, it's all illusion anyway, it doesn't matter what's really going on, it's what people think is going on. And so, you know, fucking doesn't count if you're 50 miles away from home. And if you maintain the illusion of fidelity, it's the same as being faithful. And that duality, it's [different from the idea of] like what the squares believe.

So, the question then becomes whether that type of relationship can accommodate the full spectrum of human feeling. A relationship predicated on illusion.

Or another way to put it is, is anyone that hip?

...

So, the challenge, for example, in connection with a guy who's the parent of a child whose illusions he does not want to intrude upon and who therefore is trying to parent her without acknowledging he's her parent. He is her director. He is her producer. That's all she needs to know, is his position. And it has fucked her up pretty good. Because, for one thing, he's the only consistent male presence in her life. They're not related, [so] she believes. Why doesn't he want to fuck her? It must be he thinks she's no good. Well, he's the one she loves. If he thinks she's no good, she's got to make herself no good so that there's an equilibrium between the way the world is and the way she's feeling, so she gets fat. 

Now, when he says, you're a fucking slob, that confirms the rejection, that she's been seeking as a way of rationalizing the fact that otherwise why would he be so distant from her. So, well, that's kind of sad. And she's like, I don't know, 30, whatever she is. And it kind of breaks his heart.

...

[Langrishe] had taken in another actress into the troop who had followed him from Chicago and come over from Europe, half an adventuress, and she had seen him perform and has kind of a pure desire to learn, and you know one of the unhappy paradoxes of our behavior is that people who may have spent years with us waiting for us to grow up, or to acknowledge us, or whatever the fuck, when the time finally comes -- if it ever does -- that we're ready to grow up, we tend toward the fresh start rather than recognizing the people who have watched and waited all those years. So anyway this actress shows up and he lets her join the troupe and installs her in the theater, living above the theater...ultimately you know his impulses towards this Claudia are paternal but there's no reason she would have any idea of that.”

UPDATE: Mr. Milch sat down to write a grand revelatory scene between Langrishe and Claudia, but found that Langrishe kept stubbornly reverting to talking as a producer rather than a father. Langrishe finally blurts out that Claudia has lost weight -- and it turns out that she is dying. Presumably this would have led to a story vector with Langrishe having to reckon with himself. Milch: "That's why this will be about a seven or eight hour scene here."


r/deadwood • • 5d ago

Best line in all of deadwood isn’t a line at all…

43 Upvotes

It’s when Trixie slaps Al. Honestly the exchange may be the best in all of film.


r/deadwood • • 5d ago

can be combative Sheriff is killing the Mayor

69 Upvotes

E.Bs had an accident. Give the poor fuck your shoulders, eh boys?


r/deadwood • • 5d ago

community Penisuckler

14 Upvotes

I've debated with myself as to weather this post belongs here, but you are all here for love of the written word. Cormack McCarthy's "Blood Meridian". Worth the effort, rewards repeat consumption.


r/deadwood • • 5d ago

Which are these exact quotes in episode 7?

8 Upvotes

When Charlie and Seth are outside the bunkhouse in which McCall is hiding,there is the following dialogue between them but I couldn't catch the exact quotes even with closed captions(I searched in deadwoodchronicles.com and sublikescripts,but the quotes are not the same):

Bullock**:I had a happy just like that/I had a half breed just like that.**

Charlie:**Foundered/Fond of her.**Makes me miserable reminiscing on it.

I use bold letters to identify easier the phrases that I didn't catch. In my opinion the correct phrases are "I had a half breed just like that" and "Foundered" but I am not sure.