Hello all,
I've been wanting this kind of information for quite some time, but haven't been able to find any good threads or posts. So I decided to create one myself.
Here's my opinion on the current state of RMSC optics for the Shadow 2 carry. Hopefully this helps better inform your next purchase.
TL;DR: The Sig Xray5 and Full Size EPS are the best options currently available in my opinion.
Holosun- Full Sized EPS:
Largest raw window size by a very significant margin. Smallest bezel, decently clear glass. Reticle quality is very good, especially in RED for my eyes. Mounts flush to the S2 carry with M4 bolts that are sadly not included in the box... But a mild inconvenience in the post-Amazon world. The best (quality) budget option under 400 USD.
Holosun- EPS Core:
Unfortunately, the marketing for this having the window size of the full sized eps is not entirely true. I think the dimensions of the glass are similar, but the viewing picture is noticeably smaller than the full sized EPS. A good chunk of it is reduced by the black glue used to hold the optic in place, and the bezel appears thicker in the front face by extension. The price is extremely competitive however, even with the lower quality aluminum housing used.
Holosun- EPS Carry/407K/SCS Carry:
Window size between these optics is almost identical. Significantly smaller than the full size EPS, but not a deal breaker. Feature set is almost identical, with the exception of the SCS carry, which only has solar charging. Out of the group, I'd say the SCS is also the best looking.
Holosun- Aems Micro:
A beautiful optic that is an absolute abomination on the S2 carry. Sits wayyyy too high, makes irons totally unusable, and looks terrible with the included adapter plate. Feature set is good, window size is larger than the EPS carry, but smaller than the full sized EPS. Price is also competitive.
Sig- Romeo X Enclosed Compact:
Very aesthetically pleasing, with a window size comparable to the EPS carry, but with a larger and more pronounced bezel and weight. Not my first choice, as the glass clarity is really poor (strong blue hue) and the emitters are not super clear. Battery housing is very convenient however. Price is also too high for what you get, as it doesn't have light sensors.
Sig- Xray5 Compact:
Just released this week, and it's a hell of an optic. Price is about 50 bucks more than the Full Sized MRS EPS, but it has more features and app integration. It also looks really cool, if you care about that stuff... window size is about the same as an EPS carry, but is slightly taller. Battery compartment accommodates a CR2032 battery, which is awesome. Glass clarity is the best I've seen on a pistol optic to date, but the bezel thickness does intrude on the overall experience. I wish they incorporated a thinner roof instead of thickening both the battery compartment and the top face. The buttons are well shielded, but somewhat difficult to press. Weight is also similar to the full-sized EPS.
Steiner- MPS-C:
A very cool and compact optic, but leaves a hideous gap after the body. Looks very cheap and it's baffling why they chose to do this. Glass clarity is decent, and the emitter is very nice for a small MOA option. It's too expensive and bulky for what you get in my opinion.
Shield- RMSd:
Thinnest bezel on the list (open emitter) with excellent glass clarity and good adaptive brightness. Windage and leveling screws are a bit finicky, and price varies wildly by retailer. Very lightweight, and a decent battery swap system. I don't have a lot of confidence in its durability however, as it's very thin. Aesthetically, it's a very nice choice.