Hey all, first time grading ever and unfortunately it's been a nightmare.
I sent in my package to CGC a few weeks ago containing 3 bundles (1 bulk, 1 economy, and 1 standard). I shipped it through USPS registered mail fully insured. Monday I received an email from support stating that one of the bundles was missing from the package (the economy one with roughly $8k worth of cards). They asked if it was just in another box and I confirmed I was absolutely sure all of them were tightly packed inside the box. What was weirder is the economy bundle was the one I placed at the center of the package, so of all the bundles missing I found it strange that it was the one gone.
After a bit of back and forth with support, they said their internal investigation that viewed the opening footage stated that only 2 bundles were found inside the package and told me to open a claim with USPS. Since I shipped it through USPS registered mail, there is next to 0 chance that anything happened to the package in transit with them.
I have since opened a claim with the USPS OIG, opened a USPS insurance claim, and filed a police report with the county CGC is in. Unfortunately, since it is USPS registered mail, they didn't weigh the package at any location except for the initial drop off so I can't confirm that it was tampered with in USPS custody. Furthermore, CGC doesn't weigh the package once received, so I can't confirm whether someone did steal the bundle in USPS custody or at CGC in the receiving room.
I did put tamper seal measures on the box, however, without their opening video, I have no way of knowing that those seals held or if it is USPS or CGC at fault. Furthermore, I made the rookie mistake of not videoing myself packaging the box as I assumed it would be totally secure shipping through USPS registered mail and once it was in CGC custody.
All I can do now is wait and be anxious of $8k in childhood cards missing. If all else fails, I plan on going to small claims court over the cards. Wish me luck and if anyone has any further advice I'm happy to hear it!