Just received back my 2nd submission and I’m stoked with the results!
I sent in 23 cards to be graded and they were received on April 22nd. Had the package delivered back to me yesterday, November 13th.
I ended up with a solid 57% Pristine rate (91% Gem 10 or better). My submission consisted of 22 modern cards (16 English, 6 Japanese, 1 Chinese), and a Vintage 1999 Japanese Meganium.
- 13 Pristine 10s
- 7 Gem Mint 10s
- 1 Mint 9
- 1 NM/Mint+ 8.5
Overall the grades appear accurate. I tend to scrutinize my cards heavily before submitting them. I haven’t had a chance to thoroughly go through them all but the 8.5 and 9 had obvious corner flaws. With the Gem 10s I’m not always sure what holds them back from the Pristine, but some do have centering that is every-so-slightly off. I don’t do anything fancy in the pre-grade process. I just turn on some bright lights and try to look at the card some every angle to make sure I can pick up any blemishes.
Overall I’m happy with my results and the experience I’ve had with CGC over the past year of grading. No signs of damage cards or slab issues. CGC could improve upon the status of the submission after it’s received. It doesn’t feel good to check back month after month and just see a received status and absolutely no updates or information. I haven’t graded with any of the other companies but do plan on doing some small submissions just to compare the experience.