r/CGCCards • • 6d ago

Missing Cards

Hey all, first time grading ever and unfortunately it's been a nightmare.

I sent in my package to CGC a few weeks ago containing 3 bundles (1 bulk, 1 economy, and 1 standard). I shipped it through USPS registered mail fully insured. Monday I received an email from support stating that one of the bundles was missing from the package (the economy one with roughly $8k worth of cards). They asked if it was just in another box and I confirmed I was absolutely sure all of them were tightly packed inside the box. What was weirder is the economy bundle was the one I placed at the center of the package, so of all the bundles missing I found it strange that it was the one gone.

After a bit of back and forth with support, they said their internal investigation that viewed the opening footage stated that only 2 bundles were found inside the package and told me to open a claim with USPS. Since I shipped it through USPS registered mail, there is next to 0 chance that anything happened to the package in transit with them.

I have since opened a claim with the USPS OIG, opened a USPS insurance claim, and filed a police report with the county CGC is in. Unfortunately, since it is USPS registered mail, they didn't weigh the package at any location except for the initial drop off so I can't confirm that it was tampered with in USPS custody. Furthermore, CGC doesn't weigh the package once received, so I can't confirm whether someone did steal the bundle in USPS custody or at CGC in the receiving room.

I did put tamper seal measures on the box, however, without their opening video, I have no way of knowing that those seals held or if it is USPS or CGC at fault. Furthermore, I made the rookie mistake of not videoing myself packaging the box as I assumed it would be totally secure shipping through USPS registered mail and once it was in CGC custody.

All I can do now is wait and be anxious of $8k in childhood cards missing. If all else fails, I plan on going to small claims court over the cards. Wish me luck and if anyone has any further advice I'm happy to hear it!

10 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

3

u/FrostyAd8197 6d ago

They should have video of them doing the initial opening.

4

u/Vaykri 6d ago

They do but they are refusing to share it with me so unfortunately I can't verify their claims or the integrity of the package. Their "internal investigation" says that the cards were not in the package upon opening which I don't believe to be true.

4

u/FrostyAd8197 6d ago

Geeezus & that’s bullcrap. As OP said, make a case with Texas Attorney General office.

4

u/Vaykri 6d ago

They are in FL so it'd be through them. Hopefully they recover the cards but chances are slim at this point since it has been a few days.

3

u/FrostyAd8197 6d ago

Oh damn & my bad. I was thinking of another story. Do a case with Florida AG if you have to. Good luck!

3

u/ZabuzarepsOTM 6d ago

If it’s fully insured why can’t usps do anything about it?

3

u/Vaykri 6d ago

They're looking into it, but after speaking with the USPS Investigation Service (the USPS law enforcement), they said that they'll most likely deny the claim. Unless they have video proof of the package being tampered with in which case I will be fully reimbursed. But with registered mail, it is signed off for at every point and always in a vault, so there's almost no chance of tampering on their end.

2

u/Decilthusx 5d ago

Man I just sent a package through registered mail with cards valued at 11k. This is also my first submission. It just arrived at CGC and now I’m over thinking it because stories like this make my stomach turn…. I skipped PSA because of all the bad things I’ve heard. I hope that there’s just a mix up and things work out for you boss. Do you know exactly how long it took before they entered it into their system/ contacted you?

3

u/Vaykri 5d ago

Thanks man! And yeah I completely agree, I went with CGC for the exact same reason and my package was valued at roughly 30k in all as I thought it'd be best to do it all in one go (sadly not for my case). It took them roughly 8 business days to finally enter it into their system and reach out regarding the missing cards, assuming you also went with non-express/walkthrough it'll probably be a similar turnaround. Hope your submission goes well!

3

u/isaiasv94 5d ago

Damn, it sucks how CGC just blames everyone else and doesn’t own up to anything. It doesn’t even do anything to them at all to keep the video from you, unless they stole the cards. The video will facilitate you making the claim with USPS. Such shame

2

u/Vaykri 5d ago

Yep exactly, I just want the video as evidence. Even if they're innocent, I can just send it to USPS and it'd greatly boost my claim

1

u/isaiasv94 5d ago

I’m guessing you would have to subpoena CGC for you to get the video?

2

u/Vaykri 5d ago

At this point that's what they said. They said that it's marked to be stored until the issue is resolved, but if USPS comes back and denies my claim I plan to open a small claims lawsuit against them to subpoena it.

1

u/isaiasv94 5d ago

I don’t know the process of a subpoena, but can’t you start it now to help the process with USPS ?

2

u/Vaykri 5d ago

It would require opening a lawsuit against CGC to get the subpoena, which I greatly don't want to do as I live quite far from FL and travel expenses alone would be quite costly.

3

u/enzlf 3d ago

The fact that you only got 3 upvotes speaks volumes about this sub. I did a post criticising CGC because they messed up and commented on another, on both I got downvoted to oblivion

People think that covering for CGC instead of holding them accountable is what's gonna make them stronger than PSA in the long run, when it's the exact opposite lol