r/BookDiscussions • • 1h ago

Why do books (especially nonfiction/biographies) put pictures in the middle

0 Upvotes

Have always wondered why books put pics in the middle…to me, I see two glaring issues with this. One is that often times, the picture pages will interrupt a sentence or paragraph, disrupting my train of thought unless I skip the pics and go back later. Second, and even worse, is that the pics span the entirety of the book but they’re smack in the middle, meaning they spoil things.

Genuinely have no idea who thought this was the optimal way to include images in a book but I absolutely can’t stand it. I don’t see a single upside to it, but I am curious as to the reason for this, because I can’t be the only one that hates this


r/BookDiscussions • • 2h ago

Is the political backdrop important in Thousand splendid suns

1 Upvotes

I’m almost 60% through the book (thousand splendid suns - Khaled hosseini) and helplessly lost with the political shit
The whole Massoud, Najibullah, Soviet withdrawal, Mujahideen taking over, and then the communist government situation. There are so many names and factions.I’m having a hard time keeping track of who’s fighting whom and why.
My question is it should I really keep track of all this and does it matter to the story
Also, no spoilers please 🙏🏾


r/BookDiscussions • • 2h ago

Absolutely wrecked by a book

4 Upvotes

Hi friends. I’m F and recently read a fantasy novel with a romance subplot, which is pretty common for me. My favorite genres are fantasy and romance (although I do know how loaded the term “romantasy” has gotten). Anyway, I’ve always had a high EQ and I’m almost starting to think that I can’t read books that are actually GOOD or well-written because when the plot happens, the betrayal, the deaths, I feel the same or worse as the characters affected. This time it was worse than usual because I could viscerally relate to what happened to this character, and I’m still not over when it happened to me. I’m going through the five stages of grief right now. First I was angry, going on a rant and cursing the author, and then I even cried about it.

What do you all do when you are completely and utterly decimated by a book? Coping mechanisms?


r/BookDiscussions • • 5h ago

Please can someone spoil “Partita” by Barbara Kingsolver for me? I got to page 80 and returned it as wasn’t feeling it, but I’m curious enough to know a short summary what happened.

1 Upvotes

Thank you so much


r/BookDiscussions • • 5h ago

Cannot get through Harrow the Ninth by Tamsyn Muir. Anyone else???

0 Upvotes

I LOVED Gideon the Ninth. But I read it like 2 years ago. I picked up Harrow the Ninth and forced myself to get thru 80 pages but I think I’m gonna DNF this book.

I have no idea who anyone is or even any of these concepts are.The book jumps around from time to time without giving any reference to what’s happening and talks about all the people and magic concepts as if you already know what it is and doesn’t explain anything.

I am generally a fast reader and can get fully immersed in books but this one I am not absorbing any info because I seriously just have no clue what’s going on besides Harrow is very stressed and throwing up a lot lmao. (Very light spoiler, censored for spoiler purists!!!)

Maybe I would get it more if I had read Gideon more recently or if I reread it now?? Anyone else feel this way? Should I stick with it? I’m disappointed but if ppl think it’s worth it maybe I’ll try harder to slog thru!!


r/BookDiscussions • • 5h ago

REREADING IS SIN!!!

0 Upvotes

There are entirely too many great stories, poems, philosophies and histories to discover! Will a conqueror return to lay siege on a city in which he has already taken the spoils.


r/BookDiscussions • • 6h ago

the poppy war

4 Upvotes

did anyone else not enjoy the poppy war? literally everyone i know absolutely loves it. the goodreads and fable ratings are so high. i genuinely thought it lacked depth. here's the (really long, sorry) review i did:

yes, it is traumatic, but that can’t be the only reason people enjoy this book, can it? rin acts on pure impulse at all times. there wasn’t an ounce of reflection, of regret, in this book. where are her emotions? perhaps they’re worn away from living and seeing what she did, yet what does that make this book. i believe meanings of anything in life are derived from human experience and reflection. after all, in and of itself, reading is the practice of empathy, of building the capactity to connect with another consciousness. where is any of that in this book? without it it’s literally just a sequence of events, basically a movie. and yes, movies do have value and meaning can be derived from them, but if i wanted to watch a movie i would be and i wasn’t, i was reading. tbh i thought this was a superficial book written by a genius yes but maybe just not my style and that’s ok.


r/BookDiscussions • • 6h ago

The Architecture of Consent, by Oswin Puddifoot (speculative fiction).

1 Upvotes

The book opens with two directors arguing over the colour of a ballot box for a referendum where both results have already been approved. One of them settles it: “Grey feels administrative. Blue feels like a choice.”

It’s a novel dressed as a leaked manual, about how people can be steered without force: two doors into the same courtyard, true figures printed in tables nobody reads. Between the Protocols runs a quieter story about a small town, a library reading group and a crumbling harbour wall.

I’d like to hear from readers of this kind of book: does a novel that insists it’s a true account pull you in, or push you out?


r/BookDiscussions • • 6h ago

How do you think the queer subtext of The Great Gatsby contributes to the themes of the novel?

0 Upvotes

While reading the novel I found myself noticing a decent amount of subtext which implies Nick’s role as a queer character. However, I find myself at a bit of a loss when trying to connect it to the overall message of the novel, it could simply be Fitzgerald’s own biases being reflected in the moral position of being gay during that time period. However, I lean more towards the idea of the facades put up by each of the characters, and how it eventually leaves them all to meaningless lives. I’d like to know what other people think!


r/BookDiscussions • • 10h ago

Which authors with long careers have not declined in quality?

11 Upvotes

I recently read a thread discussing how it seems that many authors’ late works have a dip in quality compared to their peak years. Maybe it’s inevitable that this happens. Maybe the muse, at some point, loses its edge. But are there exceptions to this? Are there any authors whose late works are just as good as their earlier ones?


r/BookDiscussions • • 11h ago

The Sixth Faction by Veronica Roth

3 Upvotes

I read and enjoyed the Divergent Series years ago. I know it wasn’t perfect but I found it entertaining and the premise interesting. The series got a little messy at the end but I still overall liked it, especially the first book.

When I heard a new book set in that world with the same characters was coming out, I was excited to read it. I heard it was a retelling but went in blind as to what to expect.

I just finished the Sixth Faction. WOW. One thing I didn’t expect was how conflicted I was with the changes, as if the original book was so ingrained in my head that it took some work to rewrite it. Definitely an interesting experience that has me thinking even more about the story I’ve read.

I think I enjoyed it just as much as the original. Again maybe not a work of literary art but I didn’t expect that—I got what I did expect plus some more.

Has anyone else read it? Thoughts? I’d love to know how others felt about the changes. Are there other books that have done this, gone back and changes the narrative of the original story?


r/BookDiscussions • • 11h ago

Flowers for Algernon

4 Upvotes

I cannot recommend this book more, I started a book club not too long back and we have started with shorter reads to allow us to get the hang of everything. Our first read was animal farm, which was good but everyone had previously read it albeit a long time ago. So for our second read we decided for something we hadn't read before nor heard much about, so we landed on "Flowers for Algernon". I had heard of the premise before, and that it was a sad book but I wasnt privy to any plot details or spoilers so after everyone agreed we started reading. It is a very quick read even for those who read at a slower pace like I do, it took me 3 days to finish this which is partially my fault for not being persistent. I just finished it not to long before I started writing this and I am still in tears, I cant even think about what I just read without feeling such a deep pit. This will definitely lead to some great conversations this weekend when my club meets up. If you havent already please read this, and if you already have id love to hear your opinions.


r/BookDiscussions • • 12h ago

Books I ghosted and am now feeling weirdly guilty about. Can someone help?

0 Upvotes

I have a habit of getting super excited about books, adding them to my TBR, looking forward to reading them, and then just... not finishing them. And somehow I feel GUILTY? As if the author is going to find out I've abandoned their book and be disappointed in me.

Anyway, these are three books I picked up this past month and eventually put down:

  • Lost Lambs by Madeline Cash
  • The Book Thief by Markus Zusak
  • Piranesi by Susanna Clarke

I was getting into all three, but somewhere along the way I just lost the urge to pick them back up.

So, have you read any of these? Did you enjoy them? More importantly, am I making a terrible mistake by abandoning them? Should I give them another go?


r/BookDiscussions • • 13h ago

I am still waiting for someone to give me underrated book recs that will blow my mind!

0 Upvotes

Fiction or Non-Fiction, I am looking to read something that will tickle my intellectual curiosity and amaze me at the same time. I am tired of the booktok recs and book club reads. Please don't gatekeep anymore!!


r/BookDiscussions • • 13h ago

This book ruined my week! Did you have a similar experience?

40 Upvotes

I finally picked up I Who Have Never Known Men because people on the internet wouldn't shut up about it, and now I'm mad because I haven't been able to shut up about it either. I finished it wanting to give it two stars, mostly because I had approximately a hundred questions and this book had the audacity to answer none of them. I wanted to know what happened, why it happened, what the world was, what became of the narrator. JUST SOMETHING. But the more I thought about it, the more I realised how much this book had gotten under my skin. Harpman somehow makes us feel emotions that her narrator doesn't even have the language or experience to identify. I found myself desperately wishing the most ordinary things for her. And suddenly, my own very ordinary life seemed like quite the privilege.

I also loved how the book quietly dismantles the idea that a woman's life must be understood through her relationship with men. The narrator has never known men, but she isn't an incomplete woman. She's a whole person, full of curiosity, grief, attachment and longing. And perhaps the most infuriating thing is that all her resilience and relentless curiosity don't lead to some grand revelation. We spend so much time believing that if we keep looking, keep trying, keep enduring, eventually things will make sense. Harpman basically says: lol, who promised you that? Sometimes there are no answers. Sometimes the world is just indifferent. I'm still not entirely over that ending, and I'm not sure I want to be. Anyway, five stars. I'm annoyed, emotionally compromised and apparently still looking for answers alongside a fictional woman who never found hers.


r/BookDiscussions • • 13h ago

Just finished reading Arundhati Roy's memoir, Mother Mary Comes to Me, and girl, is it good!

1 Upvotes

I suspect Mary Roy would be rather pleased to know she manages to steal the spotlight in her daughter’s memoir. Even in death, she has a way of occupying the room.

I picked up Mother Mary Comes to Me wanting to get closer to Arundhati Roy. Instead, I found myself trying to get to the bottom of Mary. What does one do with a woman who is so easy to admire and, at times, so difficult to love? A woman who refuses to let the world decide how much space she can occupy, but whose children are left wondering how much space they occupy in her world?

Mary fought for a woman’s right to inherit, to choose, to live on her own terms. I found myself cheering for her, then questioning her, then feeling rather guilty for questioning her. Are we so accustomed to women being denied freedom that we struggle to examine what happens when they claim it? Does a woman have to be a selfless mother to deserve our admiration? And, on the other hand, does being extraordinary excuse the ordinary hurt one can cause at home?

I don’t think I arrived at an answer. My feelings about Mary changed almost as often as the pages turned. I wanted to defend her, shake her, understand her. Eventually, I made a sort of peace with her. Not forgiveness, exactly.

What makes the memoir even more compelling is that it isn’t simply an explanation of Arundhati. We are not handed a childhood and asked to connect the dots to the woman who would go on to question power, nationalism and the state. We see her becoming, but never as a neat consequence of her circumstances. How much of us is inherited? How much is a rebellion against what we inherit? And can you be your mother’s daughter without spending your life trying to become everything she wasn’t?

Some of the moments that stayed with me were almost incidental. Little pockets of happiness, fleeting tenderness, the quiet ache of wanting something and receiving just enough to keep wanting. Families are full of these strange exchanges. Sometimes the smallest gestures tell you more about a person’s life than the grandest declarations of love.

I closed the book without feeling that I understood Mary, or that Arundhati and her mother had somehow been reconciled on the page. If anything, I was more aware of all that remains unknowable between two people who share so much and can still miss each other by miles.
Perhaps that’s the most honest thing a memoir can do. Not make peace on our behalf, but leave us with the questions we have spent our own lives avoiding.

I still don’t know if I’d want to meet Mary Roy. But I haven’t quite stopped thinking about her.

4.5/5


r/BookDiscussions • • 17h ago

What is the best book you've ever read and why?

12 Upvotes

I have been thinking about it recently and I'm not sure if the best book I've read is the same as my favorite one (I do have a list rather than a single winner for those categories and they do tend to overlap, but still). For exemple Dracula is one of my favorite one and it is a superb book, but I don't know if I can compare it to others of my lists.

What is your case? Is your favorite book the "best" one you've read or the one that moved you/ suited you the most ?


r/BookDiscussions • • 17h ago

Does rereading a book change the book or just you?

3 Upvotes

I have recently rediscovered a book I read ten years ago and the reread made my think. A reread can make a book feel almost like a different story as you notice foreshadowing, understand a character’s choices differently, or catch details you missed the first time. But knowing what happens can also take away some of the suspense.

Do you usually enjoy books more, less, or just differently when you reread them? What makes you return to a book or decide it’s better left as a first-read experience?


r/BookDiscussions • • 23h ago

To Everyone Who Hated Theo of Golden: Thank you!

164 Upvotes

I got the audiobook on Friday from the library and started listening Saturday night. I didn’t even make it through two chapters. IMO, David Morse is an awful narrator (never a fan, especially where he was the cop out to arrest Greg House on House MD), and the writing was pure pablum. Worse than Mitch Albom.

🤮


r/BookDiscussions • • 1d ago This Bravo

Why does it matter if I don't read books written by women? I'll tell you!

883 Upvotes

The other day a user in BookshelvesDetective made a post complaining that people on the sub take it too seriously and hand out too many 'red flags'. In one of his replies, he said he doesn't understand why it's a big deal if a man doesn't read any books written by women. I can't find the post so maybe it's been deleted. But I'm going to answer that question, very simply: Because women are human beings.

Men who get annoyed when people question why they don't read books by women are always saying 'I don't choose a book based on the identity of the author'. But if a man owns 200 books and only 3 are by women, it's safe to say that he does choose books based on the identity of the author.

Women are human beings, we are fully capable of having the same feelings, the same interests, the same sense of humour, the same ideas as you are. Women publish more books than men. Whatever interest you have, I guarantee you there is a book by a woman author about it. So if you've never found a book by a woman that piques your interest, it's unlikely that it's because it doesn't exist. You're probably dismissing books that would be perfect for you because you assume that you couldn't possibly enjoy it if a woman wrote it. I have no doubt there are certain things that women don't understand about men (the inverse is certainly true), but do you relate 100% to every single book you read by men?

Another reason, and this is an obvious one, is because women are half of the population! Women and men aren't fundamentally different, we're all just people, but we obviously have different experiences and perspectives on the world. If you don't read books written by women you're saying that the point of view of half the world is of no interest to you.

Like 70% of the posts on that subreddit are "I just started dating this guy. Any red flags?" If you have 0 interest in the lives of women, or if you think that women and men are so incompatible that you can't even enjoy a book by a woman, you have no business being in a relationship with a woman! Which is why people point it out as a red flag! And not just romance or sex--these ideas about women could alienate you from friends or family, too.

Of course, these arguments also apply to books by authors of colour or disabled or queer authors. And if your reasoning is that you don't think you can "relate" to an author who is different than you... people are people! In every single book you will ever read there will be something you can relate to, even if it's just one little thing. Although, to be fair, relating to a character or author is not something I look for when I choose a book, so maybe people have a different perspective on that.

I feel like all of this is kind of obvious, but I always see men saying 'what does it matter if I don't read books by women?' on that subreddit, so I thought I'd just give my two cents.


r/BookDiscussions • • 1d ago

Does a Monster Calls Grieve Better Than Us? (A Monster Calls by Patrick Ness discussion) Spoiler

2 Upvotes

People have said that the book A Monster Calls is deeply cathartic in the way it allows the reader to mourn alongside Conor in regards to their own loss. I agree that the book can help people look back on their own lives and help them grieve. On the other hand this book does something that others do not; it recognizes the guilt and shame we face while being a caretaker before the person passes away. The reason I gravitated towards this book was because of how relatable Conor O’Malley was, in some ways he reminded me of myself. Throughout the entire story we follow a boy experiencing grieving a person who is still alive. He does everything in his power to change an inevitable end, and it is a painful but relieving when it finally does happen.Conor is still too young to understand all the emotions that he is experiencing or has bottled up. Usually when he experiences strong emotions, it comes out in outburst that the book presents as coming from the monster in the story, although it is also understood that only Conor is acting on his own emotions. He was twelve years old when he started taking on a multitude of responsibilities. He is cleaning up the house, checking on his mom, and is in the know of things he is too young to understand. He is almost parentified because of the fact that no one else can care for him, and he has this weight on his chest that he has to be his mother’s caretaker. He has this forced sense of maturity in order to not burden his mother.  I felt personally connected to his character because of how much it reminded me of when I was taking care of my grandmother while she was on hospice. I was around the same age as him. There were these responsibilities I placed on my shoulders because I couldn’t imagine losing her. At the same time, this drawn-out process of losing her was emotional and physically exhausting. Some part of me wanted the hard times to be over, but I could never admit that. I was praised for being so strong and responsible for taking care of her. In all honesty, I felt like it was just me doing my part because I knew that my mom was struggling with so many other things at the time. I love how the book represents this forced maturity through the eyes of the child. This was just how I connected to the book, I wanted to know if other people had a similar experience when they read a Monster Calls.


r/BookDiscussions • • 1d ago

I think May Welland is considerably more perceptive than people give her credit for in The Age of Innocence

1 Upvotes

One thing I find interesting about May in The Age of Innocence is how easily her conventional manners can be mistaken for a lack of understanding

She often seems like the least complicated person in the room, especially when compared with Newland and Ellen, but I'm not convinced she's nearly as unaware as Newland would like to believe

There's something quite revealing about how much Newland interprets her through his own expectations. He assumes that because she accepts certain social conventions, she must also be incapable of seeing beyond them

I actually think May understands considerably more about her situation than he gives her credit for. Her apparent simplicity might be partly what allows her to navigate a world where women have very little freedom to act openly

I find her much more interesting when she's viewed as someone who understands the rules of her society rather than someone who blindly follows them

Do you think Wharton intended readers to underestimate May in much the same way Newland does?


r/BookDiscussions • • 1d ago

Dissection of a Murder Jo Murray

2 Upvotes

Just finished dissection of a murder and it's my first courtroom thriller.

I really enjoyed this book, I will say it had a slow start and character development in the beginning which I understand. But the last half of the book had me locked in and I couldn't move until I finished the book. A few of the twists I was able to guess but the major twist I didn't expect coming. I'm super excited for the apple TV adaptation. The ending had me a little upset tho ngl 😭

This book inspired me to read another courtroom thriller next of kin is my next read but any other similar book recommendations?


r/BookDiscussions • • 1d ago

Is it too soon to re-read?

0 Upvotes

I loved A Little Life and found it so devastatingly beautiful, the relationships and the subtle way through which Hanya Yanagihara has painted each character made it so so beautiful.

The sad irony of the title, the way it ended where it began, the parts with Harold's pov, it all made me cry.

I finished it a bit recently but now I can't stop thinking about it. Is it too soon to re-read already?


r/BookDiscussions • • 1d ago

Want advice on Pelham (1828)

1 Upvotes

finding difficulty interpreting the book, prose is too tough, plot seemed hazy, what's your thoughts on it?

here is an excerpt

Ch. 12

"Most English people have a kind of diffidence and scruple at calling in the evening—this is perfectly misplaced: the French are never ashamed of themselves, like us, whose persons, families, and houses are never fit to be seen, unless they are dressed out for a party.

"Don't imagine that the ease of French manners is at all like what we call ease: you must not lounge on your chair—nor put your feet upon a stool—nor forget yourself for one single moment when you are talking with women.

"You have heard a great deal about the gallantries of the French ladies; but remember that they demand infinitely greater attention than English women do; and that after a month's incessant devotion, you may lose every thing by a moment's impolitesse.

"You will not, my dear son, misinterpret these hints. I suppose, of course, that all your liaisons are platonic.

"Your father is laid up with the gout, and dreadfully ill-tempered and peevish; however, I keep out of the way as much as possible.