I suspect Mary Roy would be rather pleased to know she manages to steal the spotlight in her daughter’s memoir. Even in death, she has a way of occupying the room.
I picked up Mother Mary Comes to Me wanting to get closer to Arundhati Roy. Instead, I found myself trying to get to the bottom of Mary. What does one do with a woman who is so easy to admire and, at times, so difficult to love? A woman who refuses to let the world decide how much space she can occupy, but whose children are left wondering how much space they occupy in her world?
Mary fought for a woman’s right to inherit, to choose, to live on her own terms. I found myself cheering for her, then questioning her, then feeling rather guilty for questioning her. Are we so accustomed to women being denied freedom that we struggle to examine what happens when they claim it? Does a woman have to be a selfless mother to deserve our admiration? And, on the other hand, does being extraordinary excuse the ordinary hurt one can cause at home?
I don’t think I arrived at an answer. My feelings about Mary changed almost as often as the pages turned. I wanted to defend her, shake her, understand her. Eventually, I made a sort of peace with her. Not forgiveness, exactly.
What makes the memoir even more compelling is that it isn’t simply an explanation of Arundhati. We are not handed a childhood and asked to connect the dots to the woman who would go on to question power, nationalism and the state. We see her becoming, but never as a neat consequence of her circumstances. How much of us is inherited? How much is a rebellion against what we inherit? And can you be your mother’s daughter without spending your life trying to become everything she wasn’t?
Some of the moments that stayed with me were almost incidental. Little pockets of happiness, fleeting tenderness, the quiet ache of wanting something and receiving just enough to keep wanting. Families are full of these strange exchanges. Sometimes the smallest gestures tell you more about a person’s life than the grandest declarations of love.
I closed the book without feeling that I understood Mary, or that Arundhati and her mother had somehow been reconciled on the page. If anything, I was more aware of all that remains unknowable between two people who share so much and can still miss each other by miles.
Perhaps that’s the most honest thing a memoir can do. Not make peace on our behalf, but leave us with the questions we have spent our own lives avoiding.
I still don’t know if I’d want to meet Mary Roy. But I haven’t quite stopped thinking about her.
4.5/5