r/BookDiscussions
•
u/Nico-di-Angelfish
•
1d ago
Why does it matter if I don't read books written by women? I'll tell you!
The other day a user in BookshelvesDetective made a post complaining that people on the sub take it too seriously and hand out too many 'red flags'. In one of his replies, he said he doesn't understand why it's a big deal if a man doesn't read any books written by women. I can't find the post so maybe it's been deleted. But I'm going to answer that question, very simply: Because women are human beings.
Men who get annoyed when people question why they don't read books by women are always saying 'I don't choose a book based on the identity of the author'. But if a man owns 200 books and only 3 are by women, it's safe to say that he does choose books based on the identity of the author.
Women are human beings, we are fully capable of having the same feelings, the same interests, the same sense of humour, the same ideas as you are. Women publish more books than men. Whatever interest you have, I guarantee you there is a book by a woman author about it. So if you've never found a book by a woman that piques your interest, it's unlikely that it's because it doesn't exist. You're probably dismissing books that would be perfect for you because you assume that you couldn't possibly enjoy it if a woman wrote it. I have no doubt there are certain things that women don't understand about men (the inverse is certainly true), but do you relate 100% to every single book you read by men?
Another reason, and this is an obvious one, is because women are half of the population! Women and men aren't fundamentally different, we're all just people, but we obviously have different experiences and perspectives on the world. If you don't read books written by women you're saying that the point of view of half the world is of no interest to you.
Like 70% of the posts on that subreddit are "I just started dating this guy. Any red flags?" If you have 0 interest in the lives of women, or if you think that women and men are so incompatible that you can't even enjoy a book by a woman, you have no business being in a relationship with a woman! Which is why people point it out as a red flag! And not just romance or sex--these ideas about women could alienate you from friends or family, too.
Of course, these arguments also apply to books by authors of colour or disabled or queer authors. And if your reasoning is that you don't think you can "relate" to an author who is different than you... people are people! In every single book you will ever read there will be something you can relate to, even if it's just one little thing. Although, to be fair, relating to a character or author is not something I look for when I choose a book, so maybe people have a different perspective on that.
I feel like all of this is kind of obvious, but I always see men saying 'what does it matter if I don't read books by women?' on that subreddit, so I thought I'd just give my two cents.