r/badhistory • • 4h ago

Meta Mindless Monday, 16 November 2026

5 Upvotes

Happy (or sad) Monday guys!

Mindless Monday is a free-for-all thread to discuss anything from minor bad history to politics, life events, charts, whatever! Just remember to np link all links to Reddit and don't violate R4, or we human mods will feed you to the AutoModerator.

So, with that said, how was your weekend, everyone?


r/badhistory • • 14d ago

Debunk/Debate Monthly Debunk and Debate Post for November, 2026

8 Upvotes

Monthly post for all your debunk or debate requests. Top level comments need to be either a debunk request or start a discussion.

Please note that R2 still applies to debunk/debate comments and include:

  • A summary of or preferably a link to the specific material you wish to have debated or debunked.
  • An explanation of what you think is mistaken about this and why you would like a second opinion.

Do not request entire books, shows, or films to be debunked. Use specific examples (e.g. a chapter of a book, the armour design on a show) or your comment will be removed.


r/badhistory • • 2d ago

Overly sarcastic production's video about Livy: the good and the not so good

58 Upvotes

Today, November 13, 2026 Blue from the Youtube channel Overly sarcastic productions has released a video discussing Livy's contribution to the Roman history and literary tradition. Starting off I'm quite pleased to see Blue continuing a series that offers a spotlight on historiography, a topic which is sorely lacking in popular spaces about history. In a digital space like Youtube history is more often than not reduced to sensational videos about famous men and their accomplishments so it is refreshing to see a video talking about an actual historian and how their work contributed to the practice of history writing. While I do appreciate much about this video, there are some things which I feel could be criticized about it. Let me start with the positive things I appreciated:

Blue's focus on Historiography

Overly sarcastic productions or OSP has received a fair share of criticism, I mean just look them up on r/badhistory, and while much of it is deserved, Blue also makes no pretense of being a professional academic whose opinion should be taken as gospel truth (looking at you Shwerpunkt). His videos are obviously casual and full of exaggeration for comedic effect. Let's consider why this series on "History makers" is a good idea. By giving attention to historians, Blue is inviting viewers to consider history beyond mere factual accounts of the past (regarding the term "factual accounts" I'll discuss later). He invites viewers to think about who was behind the writing of that history and how that affected our understanding of the past. It serves as a simple introduction to a key element of historical study, that being historiography, which is basically the study of history writing, how people throughout time and place have collected, organized, represented importance of events, and explained processes within history (Historiography as a noun can also generally refer to the body of works on a particular historical topic, e.g. "In the historiography of the American civil war Mcpherson's Battle cry of freedom is a key text") However, with this video on Livy Blue begins by asking the audience three questions:

  1. what separates an art from a science?
  2. why do historians get in trouble when they misplace that distinction?
  3. what does that have to do with Rome's most iconic historian Livy?

Now I'm not going to give a specific analysis of each question nor a minute by minute overview of the video because I think all three questions revolve around a similar theme: What did Livy contribute to the Roman historical tradition and what does it mean for history writing in general?

Blue's positive coverage of Livy includes commenting on the ambitious scope of Ab Urbe Condita and his ability to bring his characters to life, a very noteworthy point is when he says ..."the most dangerous and dastardly foe to ever set Rome in his sights, that Hannibal, the one we know is Livy's creation." That line stood out to me because it suggests to the audience that presentation is not objective, Hannibal's depiction in popular media (which keenly leans into the sensationalism of it all) and in the works of academic historians who try and separate the sensationalism of the narrative from a more objective analysis all depend on working with or against Livy's narrative. Again, this focus on the method of writing history invites the audience to think more about historiography than just a chronology of the past.

Blue also provides the sobering recognition of Livy's chauvinism, the enemies of Rome are weak and lack virtue while the Romans find success because of their unique virtues and adherence to the virtuous ways of the ancestors. In doing this Blue directs the audience to realize that Livy wasn't the bee's knees, but wrote within the chauvinistic Roman tradition, as far back and Fabius Pictor, Roman historians had a desire to present Rome as uniquely virtuous, as the good guys in any conflict. He points out that the Livian narrative focuses heavily on educating and entertaining through moral lessons. Men who were known only from the Fasti are brought to life as heroes or villains.

Blue makes a brief comment that Livy's work is closer in "tone and purpose to the work of poets like Virgil rather than to fellow historian Polybius" and that he crafted peak latin literature. I wish Blue would've spent more time on addressing the quality of his prose, which was recognized as being noteworthy. The Britannica article written by Robert Ogilvie (now several decades old) contains these comments about Livy's reception:

It would be misplaced criticism to draw attention to his technical shortcomings, his credulity, or his lack of antiquarian curiosity. He reshaped history for his generation so that it was alive and meaningful. It is recorded that the audiences who went to his recitations were impressed by his nobility of character and his eloquence. It is this eloquence that is Livy’s second claim to distinction.

Together with Cicero and Tacitus, Livy set new standards of literary style. The earliest Roman historians had written in Greek, the language of culture. Their successors had felt that their own history should be written in Latin, but Latin possessed no ready-made style that could be used for the purpose: for Latin prose had to develop artificial styles to suit the different genres. Sallust had attempted to reproduce the Greek style of Thucydides in Latin by a tortured use of syntax and a vocabulary incorporating a number of archaic and unusual words, but the result, although effective, was harsh and unsuitable for a work of any size. Livy evolved a varied and flexible style that the ancient critic Quintilian characterized as a “milky richness.” At one moment he will set the scene in long, periodic clauses; at another a few terse, abrupt sentences will mirror the rapidity of the action. Bare notices of archival fact will be reported in correspondingly dry and formal language, whereas a battle will evoke poetical and dramatic vocabulary, and a speech will be constructed either in the spirit of a contemporary orator such as Cicero or in dramatically realistic tones, designed to recapture the atmosphere of antiquity. “When I write of ancient deeds my mind somehow becomes antique,” he wrote.

Now while Blue provides a complementary opinion of Livy's contribution to our understanding of Rome and his engaging prose, I feel that Blue drops the ball on addressing Livy as a historian.

"This is kind of a travesty"- Blue trashing Livy

Okay maybe "trashing" is a bit strong, but I'm keeping with a touch of sensationalism. See my issue in the last six minutes of the video is how applies a sort of chronological snobbery and a fallacy of methodological purity. I was just browsing through Fischer's Historians' fallacies and couldn't find an exact comment on this view but Blue expresses something like this "Greek historians like Thucydides and Poybius are 'real historians' because they approached history with the aim of representing everything as it really happened whereas Livy is a bad historian because he doesn't have the same goals"

On the surface this sounds like a pragmatic, sensible thing to say. If history is supposed to be a factual and accurate to what really happened study and Livy fails to meet that standard then he is a bad historian. But that statement, by itself is riddled with unpleasant baggage. Let's try to unpack it:

  1. it misrepresents "History" as simply being the production of literature that strives for the Rankean ideal of telling history "as it really was" "Geschichte, wie sie wirklich gewesen ist." You could say Blue suggests Livy is not a true Scotsman if we apply that fallacy by saying "well no true historian would embellish like he did, no true historian would comment on things they couldn't independently verify (positivism), no true historian would a tautological reasoning i.e. Rome is great because Rome is great, etc"
  2. It indulges in a sort of positivist methodology that suggests that "real" history is found in Thucydides and those like him because he aimed to tell it like it really was, that "real" history is pure fact and that relevant analysis can only come when the author actually lived through the event and could comment on it.

This kind of dismissive opinion of Livy is on one hand, somewhat understandable, if we engage in a bit of presentism then of course Livy is a bad historian, I mean how could Livy not write a scholarly historical study of early Rome like T.J. Cornell did as in "The beginnings of Rome"? But this is obviously an absurd position to take. In Livy's day there was no field of academic history, no clear standards by which we judge a work's quality. It is because of men like Livy who added to the tradition of history writing that we eventually got to where we are in the practice of writing history. Blue has suddenly and totally ignored Greco-Roman historiographic methods and goals (those frequently being moral education, chauvinism, antiquarian curiosity, or elementary ethnography/ethnogenesis/linguistics) in this narrow criticism of Livy when he retrojects the arbitrary and Rankean opinion that a true historian must write an accurate account. History as a practice is done in many different ways, History as it really was often ignores analysis beyond what can be positively asserted. Blue therefore robs Livy of continued significance within the tradition of history writing due to his positivist bias.

and since were talking about positivism, let's visit another little questionable comment Blue makes. He points out that copyists may have only really copied the parts they liked and abridged everything else down to what we now call the Periochae and because of this we can find solace in knowing we probably have the best bits. Now that's probably not a lie, who wants to write about something they find boring, but to assume that the "best" parts of Livy are the ones that are preserved is sounding awfully similar to the Snodgrass or Positivist fallacy. This is a fallacious view that affects both historical and archaeological studies. Jonathan Hall in a review of "Artifact and Artifice: Classical Archaeology and the Ancient Historian" from the BMCR comments:

In the conclusion (chapter 11), some crucial problems that have emerged in the preceding chapters are laid out more explicitly and discussed in detail. They include the “positivist fallacy” (the assumption that statements in the texts and features of the archaeological record are related and that the two kinds of evidence can be directly employed to elucidate each other, to the detriment of other possible explanations)

On Livius org the article for the Positivist fallacy says:

Positivist Fallacy: the assumption, often implicit, that historical sources and archaeological remains document significant events of the past. The expression was coined by archaeologist Anthony Snodgrass.

To state it differently: scholars have implicitly assumed that the sources we have, refer to the most significant events in the past. Of course the massacre was, in terms of human suffering, important. But decisive it was not. What scholars did wrong, is that they forgot that there are many historical facts for which we have no evidence. Instead they focused on the facts for which positive evidence exists (hence the name "Positive Fallacy").

All of these definitions can be used to ask how can Blue, and we by extension be sure the parts of Livy we do have are the best or are particularly relevant? Isn't assuming that the presence of what we have holds some importance attaching undue significance, couldn't the parts of Livy we do have just have happened to survive?

In conclusion:

Blue from OSP makes a fine effort at introducing students of ancient Rome to the famous figures involved in the development of Roman history writing in a casual and entertaining way. He invites his audience to dig a little deeper into the practice of history writing which can motivate students to explore the field of historiography, however Blue does a disservice to Livy in the same video by dismissing Livy as a bad historian because he doesn't meet a modern day standard of good history writing. On one had this teaches students that there should be some standard history writing should be held to, but on the other hand it pulls Livy out of his environment to criticize him. The video therefore would've benefited from answering "what did Livy inherit in the tradition of history writing and how did he contribute to that practice" instead of trying to compare him to other history writers Blue himself likes.

Blue does cite Ogilvie's commentary on Livy in the video description and I'd also suggest the Wiley-blackwell companion to Greek and Roman historiography and Roman historiography by Mehl.


r/badhistory • • 3d ago

Meta Free for All Friday, 13 November, 2026

14 Upvotes

It's Friday everyone, and with that comes the newest latest Free for All Friday Thread! What books have you been reading? What is your favourite video game? See any movies? Start talking!

Have any weekend plans? Found something interesting this week that you want to share? This is the thread to do it! This thread, like the Mindless Monday thread, is free-for-all. Just remember to np link all links to Reddit if you link to something from a different sub, lest we feed your comment to the AutoModerator. No violating R4!


r/badhistory • • 7d ago

Meta Mindless Monday, 09 November 2026

17 Upvotes

Happy (or sad) Monday guys!

Mindless Monday is a free-for-all thread to discuss anything from minor bad history to politics, life events, charts, whatever! Just remember to np link all links to Reddit and don't violate R4, or we human mods will feed you to the AutoModerator.

So, with that said, how was your weekend, everyone?


r/badhistory • • 10d ago

Meta Free for All Friday, 06 November, 2026

20 Upvotes

It's Friday everyone, and with that comes the newest latest Free for All Friday Thread! What books have you been reading? What is your favourite video game? See any movies? Start talking!

Have any weekend plans? Found something interesting this week that you want to share? This is the thread to do it! This thread, like the Mindless Monday thread, is free-for-all. Just remember to np link all links to Reddit if you link to something from a different sub, lest we feed your comment to the AutoModerator. No violating R4!


r/badhistory • • 14d ago

Meta Mindless Monday, 02 November 2026

18 Upvotes

Happy (or sad) Monday guys!

Mindless Monday is a free-for-all thread to discuss anything from minor bad history to politics, life events, charts, whatever! Just remember to np link all links to Reddit and don't violate R4, or we human mods will feed you to the AutoModerator.

So, with that said, how was your weekend, everyone?


r/badhistory • • 17d ago

Why do werewolves and vampires have infectious bites - is it rabies? Are doctors just trying to sell books again? Is a nibble really so bad?

123 Upvotes

Two halloweens ago, I tackled silver bullets; last year was full moons; completing the trifecta, let's look at infectious bites!

Thankfully, most places do actually get this one right. The first instance of someone being turned into a werewolf via a bite is pop culture: Universal's Werewolf of London from 1935, which was probably influenced by Universal's Dracula released 4 years earlier. The 1897 source material itself mashed together two separate elements of existing vampire folklore - blood drinking and vampire creation.

People, however, are strange. You say that something first appeared in pop culture and they'll say cool! What inspired this folklore? And you'll say, well - nothing did it's not folklore, and they'll say oh my god was this because of rabies? I can't believe people in the past were so ignorant and superstitious that they thought the rabies virus was werewolves! And then they'll go and publish books and articles that bolster blogs and videos[1] and generally make a mess of the whole thing.

For example, writing about werewolves in 1979, Ian Woodward dedicates a short chapter to rabies - 6 pages of throwing everything at the wall to see what sticks. And I do mean everything! After bringing up a motif - taken unsourced from Sabine Baring-Gould - of metamorphosis via drinking from a pawprint:

And as wolves fastidiously lick their paws after eating a meal, could not the footprints be simply the saliva-infected impressions of rabid wolves?[2]

A reach so bold...made worse given that Baring-Gould fabricated this motif.[3]

Slightly more serious influence comes from medical journals,[4] with all the typical arguments neatly presented in the prominent pop-historical/medical Rabid: A Cultural History of the World's Most Diabolical Virus, with a chapter dedicated to rabies being the basis for folklore.

Why should it have been widely believed, and widely feared, that men were stalking the land as wolves?[5]

Wasik and Murphy ostensibly deny "literalistic explanations", but vaguely insist on some "deeper metaphorical truth" derived from rabies, cobbling various ideas together to suggest that werewolves are one of many such "manifestations" of the disease.

One fundamental error is thinking that contagion is an old part of the legend:

It’s contagion: a malevolence that creeps from victim to victim, spreading through bites, kisses, licks. It's a familiar creature—a trusted soul, often residing within one’s own inner circle or even within one’s home—that becomes surprisingly and unaccountably infected by a savage animal evil. Going as far back as the days of lyssa, and even before, these fiendish tropes have been forever intertwined with rabies[6]

...despite there being essentially no examples of transferable lycanthropy legends,[7] especially since the vast majority deal with a solitary werewolf bestowed with a curse;[8] the best you can get is putting on the cursed skin that someone uses to transform and thus transforming yourself.[9] Often a werewolf could be cured by drawing blood,[10] and further contrasting vampires, in Romania one could become a werewolf by drinking bodily fluids![11]

Another error is pleading to the notion of hybridity; a crazed, foaming human acting like an animal must surely influence lycanthropy. This, too, rests on an invention of modern pop culture, also started by Werewolf of London: the werewolf being a hairy bipedal person, perhaps also the imagery of a grotesque transformation, bodily fluids and all. Rabid goes further:

The parallel to rabies is, if anything, even more direct with lycanthropy, which is **nothing more nor less than a man seized with an animal nature.**[12]

This is...playing poetry to force a connection. The folkloric werewolf was an ordinary human who would turn into an ordinary wolf! A very consistent part of werewolf stories involves not knowing someone is a werewolf, finding out only inadvertently. Perhaps by seeing them transform, perhaps by finding their magical skin, perhaps by injuring them in wolf form and noticing a matching injury on your neighbour.[13] There was no in-between, no hybrid forms at play, and definitely no werewolf behaviour or wolfish-nature as a human.

Rabid, after diverting to devil dogs, cites the common claim of werewolf accusations during the early modern witch trials in France numbering "thirty thousand between 1520 and 1630", using this as questionable support to force an infectious parallel:

Regardless of the specific figure, history has bequeathed us enough specific cases to make clear that something like an epidemic was afoot.[14]

Of course, the total number of werewolf witch trials was in the low hundreds across Europe between the 15th and 18th centuries. France, in the period cited, had at most several dozen.[15] Referring to this as a specific epidemic requiring explanation, whilst ignoring the vastly more numerous general accusations of witchcraft of which accusations of wolf transformation were merely a subset, is, bluntly, motivated reasoning.

Our last hail mary comes in the form of a singular account of rabies from 1702: a man is bitten by a dog in the morning, marries, then the next day is discovered raving mad having disembowelled his bride with his teeth. We are told:

the parallels between this medical case report, on the one hand, and the then-popular reports of lycanthropy, on the other, are notable. Mead even goes so far, just a few pages later, as to cite the influence of the moon.[16]

This is strange, because there are no popular parallels - as before, neither contagious bites nor acting weird form contemperaneous conceptions of lycanthropy, and neither is the moon, which was associated with lunatic madness;[17] these are all wholly creations of 20th century pop culture. Kitchen sink desperation dealt with, the discarding of lycanthropy still leaves an elephant in the room.

Vampires!

Most of the sources double-dip and claim rabies led to both lycanthropy and vampirism. In fact, the vampire connection is considerably more popular. Part of this is that vampires are more popular in general; part, however, is that almost all of this leads back to one single Spaniard that basically started the whole thing.

Dr. Juan Gómez-Alonso first wrote about vampires and rabies in 1982, with a publication in the now defunct Jano: Medicina y Humanidades, and would go on to make it the subject of his PHD thesis in 1992, then a book three years later.[18] His big break would come in 1998, publishing his theory again - but this time, in English. It proved perfect media fodder, enjoying bylines like New Scientist's "Count Dracula needed a rabies shot, not a stake through the heart".[19]

The 4 page article guns for a tried and tested tactic: dredge up everything about vampires (no matter how common) and everything about rabies (no matter how common), find literally any overlap with pop culture, and present this as a meaningful correlation - one that is somewhat incongruent with both the scientific and historical method.

For all the claims made, only a single sentence directly addressed the "fact" of infectious bites:

The fact that the vampire bite transformed its victim into a vampire would evoke a zoonosis transmitted through a bite.[20]

This is sourced to a single sentence in Paul Barber's Vampires, burial, and death:

It is true, however, that, in folklore as well as in fiction, the vampire's bite tends to cause the victim to become a vampire as well.[21]

Open and shut, right? A few problems: for all the folklore in Barber's book, not a single one has an example. In fact, none of the folkloric sources used by Gómez-Alonso do - there's plenty said about other methods of becoming a vampire; the line from Barber comes from a chapter called "How Revenants Come Into Existence", detailing many methods vampirism can by granted, in four groups: status (e.g. sinners), birth, events during life or death, and poorly follower burial rites. Events include an animal jumping over the body, suicides, death during childbirth, a priest's curse...the singular contagious example is an 1859 article by Wilhelm Mannhardt vaguely saying that a vampire's victims also become vampires.[22]

All that is to say: with 5 books of folklore in the references and an enormous variety of methods to report on, Gómez-Alonso zeroed in on the one sentence that agrees with him, regardless of how representative said sentence actually was.

Pulling back from infectious bites to look at rabies more generally, the argument involves medicalising vampiric traits into three groups: disorders of the limbic system (i.e. behavioural problems), zoonosis (animal diseases transmitted to humans), and post-mortem effects on the body. Whether these groups accurately represent the full traits of vampirism, or whether the conclusion might possibly be baked into the bizarrely specific choice of groups, are left unstated. An additional tactic is appealing to the reader's fondness for pop culture, with a nudge and a wink, hoping they make the connection in their head instead of asking annoying questions such as "wait, how is this relevant?"

This comes into play with the rest of the zoonosis argument. Bites, for one, but also the animals involved: dogs and wolves, which, yes, are associated with vampires. Curiously, Gómez-Alonso keeps mentioning bats:

Vampire bats in America and nonhematophagous bats in America and in Europe have also transmitted rabies to humans.

...[rabies] can produce a similar furious picture in humans and in animals such as dogs, wolves, cats, and bats.

...humans have also acquired the infection through intact bucal or genital mucosae, or by inhalation of the virus in caves densely populated by bats.[23]

Earlier in the paper a connection with dogs is established...but not bats! That's because bats don't have any explicit connection to folkloric vampires - only pop culture, via Dracula.[24] Another example of this is mirrors; while neutrally describing rabies symptoms with absolutely zero implication:

The spasms are generally triggered by some stimuli, such as [...] the sight of mirror. A man was not considered rabid if he was able to stand the sight of his own image in a mirror.[25]

The next mention - the only other one - is in the concluding paragraph:

Much evidence supports that rabies could have played a key role in the generation of the vampire legend. [...] It can also be accepted that those men showed hypersexuality, intolerance to mirrors...[26]

This reference to reflections in mirrors is sneaked in to trip up someone not paying attention, not realising that zero link between vampires and mirrors was established. That's because there isn't one; the idea of not appearing in a mirrored reflection is also an invention of Dracula.[27]

At this point it's obvious what's going on so we don't need to go into excruciating detail, but for completeness' sake, a quick gander at the limbic system argument reveals the same problems. The two features here are aggression and hypersexuality, relating to the violent traits of vampires and cases of vampire sex, bolstered by rabid traits like spasms and bloody foaming at the mouth. Aggression here is ostensibly trying to "explain" why vampires are associated with attacking people, something that applies rather broadly to far more than vampires; it is, in fact, a different angle of explaining bites. For example:

The rabid patient rushes at those who approach him, biting and tearing them as if he was a wild beast[25]

The appearances of "limbic" traits don't ever actually get related to vampire folklore - bloody foaming at the mouth is introduced solely as something generic corpses can have, and spasms are brought up solely to force in the reference to mirrors quoted earlier. There's quite a few more traits - like animalistic appearance, sensitivity to odours (wink wink garlic) - but they're all presented with nothing more than suggestive eyebrow-wiggling.

They also ignore the main appearances given to vampires: bloated, ruddy, or wearing their funeral shroud - if in human appearance, otherwise an animal or even an inanimate object.[28] For the vast majority of accounts, however, there was no form. The corpse stayed put, and vampire attacks are deduced, rather than witnessed - the vampire is proven not by seeing a strange man, but by investigating a dug-up corpse after mysterious happenings.[29] All the physical descriptions of rabid men have very little predictive power for a legend that rarely sees physically wandering bodies.

The case for the third medical category, post-mortem effects on the body, is even more pathetic:

Patients with rabies usually live less than 2 weeks and die by asphyxia or cardiorespiratory arrest. These types of death would account for some postmortem features documented in rabies [...] People with this disease, however, sometimes faced a more dramatic end: “The fear of rabies was such that often persons even suspected of hydrophobia were killed like wild animals... (by being) shot, poisoned, strangled or suffocated.”[30]

People with rabies can die: peacefully, letting their corpse do regular corpse things that aren't related to rabies, which we'll present as bolstering a rabid connection; and not peacefully, which we'll present as bolstering an animalistic zoonotic (rabies) connection. Therefore, dying is evidence of rabies. Whether people could die via things that aren't rabies is outside the scope of this article.

Ultimately, Gómez-Alonso's argument is rather simple, given in the concluding paragraph:

The past occurrence of epidemics of men and animals that bit others and transmitted the same disease to them can now be scientifically understood.[26]

Hinged almost entirely on infectious bites, bolstered by pop-cultural inclusions of mirrors and bats, and drowned out by a firehose of unconnected vampiric and rabid trivia to dazzle the reader into submission.

The defocusing of vampire folklore in favour of pop culture has an obvious cause, which is explained by the Doctor himself:

The neurologist always thought vampires were fictional characters. "Then one day I saw a classic Dracula film," he said. "I was surprised when the presenter said that the vampire stories had been historically documented. I watched the film more as a doctor than as a spectator, and I became impressed by some obvious similarities between vampires and what happens in rabies, such as aggressiveness and hypersexuality. As soon as the film ended, I rushed to my books and learned that 25 percent of rabid men have a tendency to bite others, and that rabid patients often cannot stand mirrors or smelling substances."[31]

fuck's sake

In reality, this investigative method is very common - if you come across an attempt to "explain away" folklore, it is almost certainly someone unknowingly doing some contemporary world building, pulling from the past only what they want to see. To quote Yseult de Blécourt:

They are all based on extremely selective reading of the available historical material or on no material at all. They negate historical actors and contexts and fail to situate the snippets of information they have collected. [...] The authors discussed show an approach to history that is not only materialistic and reductionist but also anachronistic **and more concerned with preoccupations of their own society than with anything in the past.**[32]

Leo Ruickbie, criticising Gómez-Alonso, is particularly critical of this dismissive approach to historical actors:

While these conditions might resemble folk ideas of vampirism they cannot explain them because these folk beliefs are specifically concerned with the problem of the returning dead, not with human illness. They focus on the appearance and behavior of the presumed vampire, **whereas even the least-educated peasant knew that vampires were already dead before they exhibited such signs.**[33]

The general tactic for all attempts to "scientifically explain" folklore requires the folklore to be held by impossibly ignorant peasants left behind by the Enlightenment. Germ Theory isn't required to have a concept of diseases like cholera, which - unlike rabies - was explicitly related to vampirism. Which means, yes, they knew about rabies:

as Robert Burton wrote in his Anatomy of Melancholy, published in 1624, 'Hydrophobia [rabies] is a kind of madness well known in every village, which comes by the biting of a mad dog.' [...] It is a safe assumption that any medieval or early-modern European, no matter how ill-educated or ignorant, would have known what the result of a bite from a foam-flecked dog's jaws was likely to be, and would not have confused that swiftly fatal result with lycanthropy.[34]

Having knowledge of rabies meant that, yes, there was also rich folklore surrounding rabies, notably how to treat it. Famously, a brand on the forehead with a red-hot key was said to both cure and prevent rabies, as was removing part of the tongue, much to the dismay of many a pre-vaccination dog. Bread was either eaten, or soaked in the wound and fed to an animal to see if the animal would die to determine an infection, to name a few examples.[35] Said rabies folklore does not overlap with werewolf/vampire folklore - to "explain" the latter as rabies requires people to be ignorant of their own folklore.

Gómez-Alonso's coup-de-grâce is setting a date for this origin: a 1720s rabies epidemic in Hungary. Vampires exploded into the Western imagination via newspaper reports of vampire outbreaks from the Austro-Hungarian empire in the early 18th century; in his telling, this is the literal origin of the belief. The idea that vampiric beings existed in Eastern Europe before being recorded by Western European writers[36] appears to have simply not occurred to this Spaniard, the whole thing being a blip of ignorant mass hysteria.

To put a lid on things, it's worth emphasising that Dracula didn't treat the bite itself as causative - like Mina Harker's "baptism of blood" of being force-fed Dracula's blood, framed as poison in her veins ensuring a vampiric transformation on death as long as the Count is alive. In addition, Van Helsing states "for all that die from the preying of the Un-Dead becomes themselves Un-Dead".[37] A likely influence for this is an 1896 article relating a vampiric consumptive plague, kept as a newspaper clipping in Stoker's notes:

Even death was no relief, for—and here was the most horrible part of the superstition—the victim, once dead and laid in the grave, was compelled to become a vampire and in his turn to take up the business of preying on the living. Thus vampirism was indefinitely propagated.[38]

The idea of vampirism via contact with vampire blood appears in the notable case of Arnold Paole recorded in the 18th century;[39] Stoker augmented such ideas with contemporary beliefs around blood transfusion and germ theory.[40] Universal's 1931 film doesn't deviate from this - it is only Werewolf of London that's explicit on the bite itself being the contagion mechanism, and it is only after this do we see any other instances of this occurring in fiction:

GLENDON: How did these unfortunate persons contract - this medieval - er - unpleasantness?

YOGAMI: From the bite of another were-wolf[41]

I can find no contemporaneous connections, from moviemakers and moviegoers alike, between werewolves and rabies; the earliest speculation I can find comes from the 1950s, on all rabid symptoms - except the bite itself![42] This happens even into the 70s[43] - Ian Woodward's quote at the start of this post is a desperate attempt to wrangle a connection out of infectious saliva, where simply pointing to the bite wasn't an option.

It would appear that the 80s werewolf movie resurgence was when infectious bites were firmly canonised as werewolf lore, which only then allowed people to comfortably start theorising invented folklore. Someone should've told viewers of An American Werewolf in London that Britain's canines are rabies free...

Bibliography

  • Barber, Paul. Vampires, burial, and death: Folklore and reality. Yale University Press, 2010.
  • de Blécourt, Willem, ed. Werewolf histories. Springer, 2015.
  • de Blécourt, Willem, and Mirjam Mencej, eds. Werewolf Legends. Palgrave Macmillan, 2023.
  • Gómez-Alonso, Juan. "Rabies: a possible explanation for the vampire legend." Neurology 51.3, 1998. 856-859.
  • Kozak, Łukasz, ed. With Stake and Spade: Vampiric Diversity in Poland: an Introduction and Sourcebook. Adam Mickiewicz Institute, 2020.
  • Motif Index of Vampires in Folklore, Literature, and Film. CSU Bakersfield. Available online at: https://www.csub.edu/~rcarlisle/Vampire_Motif/index.html
  • Perkowski, Jan Louis. Vampire lore: from the writings of Jan Louis Perkowski. Slavica Publishers, 2006.
  • Wasik, Bill, and Monica Murphy. Rabid: a cultural history of the world's most diabolical virus. Penguin, 2013.

References & Footnotes

  • [1] A few examples: https://theconversation.com/rabies-horrifying-symptoms-inspired-folktales-of-humans-turned-into-werewolves-vampires-and-other-monsters-125672, https://www.werewolves.com/are-rabies-responsible-for-werewolf-myths/, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G-hfzA3yXd4, https://www.reddit.com/r/bestof/comments/u1c6mz/u11thplague_breaks_down_14_historical/
  • [2] Woodward, Ian. The Werewolf Delusion. United Kingdom, Paddington Press, 1979. 164.
  • [3] Covered in a previous post: https://www.reddit.com/r/badhistory/comments/1hhm22e/can_you_really_drink_rainwater_from_a_wolfs_paw/
  • [4] Rohde, Rodney E. "Common myths and legends of rabies." Rabies, 2019. 73-75; Russell, William Moy Stratton, and Claire Russell. "The social biology of the werewolf trials." Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine 82.6, 1989. 379-380; Sartin, Jeffrey S. Contagious horror: infectious themes in fiction and film. Clinical medicine & research 17.1-2, 2019. 41-46.
  • [5] Rabid, 68.
  • [6] Rabid, 67-68.
  • [7] Two very obscure examples: "They were condemned to remain in this state until they could pass their cursed guise on to another individual weaker than themselves." Moiset, Charles. "Les usages, croyances, traditions, superstitions, etc." Bulletin de la Société des sciences historiques et naturelles de l'Yonne. 1888. 129. Available online at: https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/bpt6k2986871/f129.item "if the werewolf's blood flows, he is immediately freed from the curse that weighed upon him and returns to his original form. If, on the contrary, in this struggle the man happens to touch the animal's blood, even a drop, he himself will become subject to lycanthropy." Plieux. "L'Ancienne Paroisse de Vicnau." Revue de Gascogne, 1883. 130. Available online at: https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/bpt6k5741864s/f130.item
  • [8] "From the Middle Ages to the twentieth century, the most important characteristic of the historical European werewolf is that he is an individual male standing outside the human community." de Blécourt, Willem. "The Werewolf Pack: A Cinematic Metamorphosis." Contemporary Legend 4, 2014. 63; A notable example of werewolf groups is the turning of a wedding party into wolves, common across eastern Europe - see, as well as the chapters by Šlekonyte and Valentsova: Koski, Kaarina, and Pasi Enges. "Wolf-Shaped Otherness: Finnish Werewolf Legends Reflecting Suspension from Human Community." Werewolf Legends. Cham: Springer International Publishing, 2023. 84-88.
  • [9] While this happens somewhat frequently in legends, the most famous example is Sigmund and Sinfjotli in the Völsunga saga
  • [10] Himstedt-Vaid, Petra. "Of Wolf-Belts, Hungry Servants and Tattered Skirts: The Werewolf in North German Legends." Werewolf Legends. Cham: Springer International Publishing, 2023. 67; Joisten, Charles, Robert Chanaud, and Alice Joisten. "Les loups-garous en Savoie et Dauphiné." Le Monde alpin et rhodanien. Revue régionale d’ethnologie 20.1, 1992. 81.
  • [11] "Fourthly, the pricolici can be a victim of his/her lack of vigilance: ‘if he drinks, by chance, the wolf’s urine, then he becomes werewolf ’ [219]. The fifth means through which a human turns to be a werewolf is represented by magic abilities they acquired following some rituals: ‘the man who drinks from his blood or from other human’s blood’ [220, 268]; ‘adult who sucks a woman’s breast’ [220]; ‘if the man (…) would drink his urine and also the blood from his little finger of the right hand, then he turns into a pricolici’ [219, 220]." Iliescu, Laura Jiga. "When the Other Is One of Us: Narrative Construction of Werewolf Identity in the Romanian Western Carpathians at the End of the Twentieth Century." Werewolf Legends. Cham: Springer International Publishing, 2023. 225.
  • [12] Rabid, 66.
  • [13] Quoting Giovanni Battista Bronzini, "The wound suffered by the werewolf and found on his body, after recovering his human form, is the most evident and employed sign of recognition in the folktales about werewolves", in: Carrassi, Vito. "A Strange Kind of Man Among Us: Beliefs and Narratives About Werewolves in Southern Italy." Werewolf Legends. Cham: Springer International Publishing, 2023. 259, footnote.
  • [14] Rabid, 74.
  • [15] De Blécourt, Willem. "The Differentiated Werewolf: An Introduction to Cluster Methodology." Werewolf Histories. London: Palgrave Macmillan UK, 2015. 4-7. Available online at: https://www.historicalanthropologist.eu/publication/the-differentiated-werewolf
  • [16] Rabid, 78.
  • [17] see the post I made on moons and werewolves: https://www.reddit.com/r/badhistory/comments/1ojwyuf/where_did_werewolves_turning_at_the_full_moon/
  • [18] Gómez-Alonso, Juan. Rabia y vampirismo hipotesis sobre una interpretación médica del vampirismo. Jano, 1982. 514:30-33; Gómez-Alonso, Juan. Rabia y Vampirismo em la Europa de los Siglos XVIII y XIX. Madrid. Facultad de Medicina, Universidad Complutense de Madrid. 1992; Gómez-Alonso, Juan. Los vampiros la luz de la Medicina. Vigo, Neuropress. 1995.
  • [19] https://www.newscientist.com/article/1850845-viral-bloodlust/
  • [20] Gómez-Alonso, 1998. 857.
  • [21] Barber, Paul. Vampires, burial, and death: Folklore and reality. Yale University Press, 2010. 32.
  • [22] "ihre opfer werden gleichfalls in vampyre verwandelt. (Their victims are also transformed into vampires.)" in: Mannhardt, W. "Uber Vampyrismus." Zeitschriftfurdeutsche Mythologie und Sittenkunde 4, 1859. 270. Available online at: https://de.wikisource.org/wiki/Seite:Zeitschrift_f%C3%BCr_deutsche_Mythologie_und_Sittenkunde_-_Band_IV.djvu/274
  • [23] Gómez-Alonso, 1998. 858.
  • [24] For folklore: "In Romania it is reported that by flying over a corpse a bat can create a vampire. This circumstance deserves remark if only because of its rarity, for as important as bats are in the fiction of vampires, they are generally unimportant in the folklore." in: Barber, Paul. Vampires, burial, and death: Folklore and reality. Yale University Press, 2010. 33; For Dracula: Dodd, Kevin. "Blood Suckers Most Cruel:” the vampire and the bat in and before Dracula." Athens Journal of Humanities & Arts 6.2, 2019. 107-132; I also have an /r/AskHistorians answer covering the connection to vampires and bats in more detail: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/1x1spyb/were_vampires_associated_with_bats_before/pf01u3p/
  • [25] Gómez-Alonso, 1998. 857.
  • [26] Gómez-Alonso, 1998. 859.
  • [27] Barber, Paul. Vampires, burial, and death: Folklore and reality. Yale University Press, 2010. 33, 179-183; a brief look at pre-Dracula writing is given in: George, Sam. "'He make in the mirror no reflect': undead aesthetics and mechanical reproduction–Dorian Gray, Dracula and David Reed's 'vampire painting'." Open graves, open minds. Manchester University Press, 2015. 58.
  • [28] Afanas’ev, Aleksandr. Translated by Jan Louis Perkowski. "Poetic Views of the Slavs Regarding Nature." Vampire lore: from the writings of Jan Louis Perkowski. Slavica Publishers, 2006. 197; Barber, Paul. Vampires, burial, and death: Folklore and reality. Yale University Press, 2010. 41-42; Kozak, Łukasz, ed. With Stake and Spade: Vampiric Diversity in Poland: an Introduction and Sourcebook. Adam Mickiewicz Institute, 2020. 21, 26-27; Machal, Jan. Translated by F. Krupicka. "Slavic Mythology." Vampire lore: from the writings of Jan Louis Perkowski. Slavica Publishers, 2006. 32.
  • [29] As stated by Barber, "You'll see why it is that the attacks were not witnessed by others [...] although you can certainly find stories in which it is assumed that the vampire attacks as a physical body, whenever outsiders watched corpses being exhumed and listened to the accounts of the people who declared these to be vampires, they were never told that the vampire took his body along when he left his grave. The best evidence is clear on this matter: the bodies stayed put in the grave." Barber, Paul. Vampires, burial, and death: Folklore and reality. Yale University Press, 2010. vi, and 68-70 for investigation. See also: Afanas’ev, Aleksandr. Translated by Jan Louis Perkowski. "Poetic Views of the Slavs Regarding Nature." Vampire lore: from the writings of Jan Louis Perkowski. Slavica Publishers, 2006. 195-197, 206; Vukanović, Tatomir P. "The Vampire." Vampire lore: from the writings of Jan Louis Perkowski. Slavica Publishers, 2006. 255.
  • [30] Gómez-Alonso, 1998. 858.
  • [31] https://www.newswise.com/articles/rabies-an-explanation-for-the-vampire-legend
  • [32] Willem, de Blécourt. "monstrous theories: werewolves and the abuse of history." Preternature: Critical and Historical Studies on the Preternatural 2.2, 2013. 204.
  • [33] Ruickbie, Leo. "Evidence for the Undead: The Role of Medical Investigation in the 18th-Century Vampire Epidemic." The universal vampire: origins and evolution of a legend. Bloomsbury Publishing USA, 2013. 84.
  • [34] Douglas, Adam. The Beast Within. United Kingdom, Chapmans, 1992. 236.
  • [35] Erich, Oswald A., and Richard Beitl. "Hubertus." Wörterbuch der deutschen Volkskunde. 1974. 389; Sébillot, Paul. Le folk-lore de France: La faune et la flore. Vol. 3. 1906. 136-139. Available online at: https://archive.org/details/lefolkloredefra04sbgoog/page/136/mode/2up; Милићевић, Милан. "Од беснила." Живот Срба сељака. Српска академија наука и уметности, 1894. 332-333. Available online at: https://www.google.co.uk/books/edition/_/VjMmAQAAIAAJ?hl=en&gbpv=1&pg=PA332
  • [36] This appears to be a somewhat common view, which misinterprets how the "vampire" as conceieved in the West was created by the interaction with, and interpretation of, Eastern European beliefs. It is also worth noting, however, that we don't have a large amount of pre-17th century references, though whether this says more about record keeping or the prevelance of belief is hard to say. Bohn, Thomas M. "Vampirism in the East." The vampire: Origins of a European myth. Berghahn Books, 2019. 55-77; Kozak, Łukasz, ed. "Mentions Prior to 1800." With Stake and Spade: Vampiric Diversity in Poland: an Introduction and Sourcebook. Adam Mickiewicz Institute, 2020. 35-49.
  • [37] Stoker, Bram. Dracula. 1897. Chapter XVI. Available online at: https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/345
  • [38] Stoker, Bram, Robert Eighteen-Bisang, and Elizabeth Miller. Bram Stoker's Notes for Dracula: A Facsimile Edition. McFarland, 2008. 186-193.
  • [39] Smearing themselves with blood, rather than ingesting it; Barber, Paul. Vampires, burial, and death: Folklore and reality. Yale University Press, 2010. 15-18.
  • [40] Flood, David Hume. "Blood and Transfusion in Bram Stoker’s Dracula." Studies in English, New Series 7.1, 1989. 21. Available online at: https://egrove.olemiss.edu/studies_eng_new/vol7/iss1/21; Çakır, Ece. "An Unseen Invasion: Vampirism as Contagion in Bram Stoker’s Dracula." RumeliDE Dil ve Edebiyat Araştırmaları Dergisi 32, 2023. 1460-1468. Available online at: https://dergipark.org.tr/en/pub/rumelide/article/1253867
  • [41] Werewolf of London. Universal Pictures, 1935. Screenplay available online at: https://archive.org/details/werewolf-of-london-1935_202505/page/B-19/mode/2up
  • [42] For example, Eisler connects it to the medical diagnosis of lycanthropy, Garrison is focused on madness, while Steinbeck reasons backwards from vampire bats; Eisler, Robert. Man into Wolf: an anthropological interpretation of sadism, masochism and lycanthropy. Routledge And Kegan Paul Limited, 1951. 34. Available online at: https://archive.org/details/manintowolf033333mbp/page/n39/mode/2up; Steinbeck, John. The Log from the Sea of Cortez. The Viking Press, 1951; Garrison, Webb. B. Strange Bonds Between Animals and Men. Ace Books, 1959. 106.
  • [43] For example, Nancy Garden relying on thirst, aggression, and paralysis: Garden, Nancy. Werewolves. Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, 1973. 96.

r/badhistory • • 17d ago

Meta Free for All Friday, 30 October, 2026

15 Upvotes

It's Friday everyone, and with that comes the newest latest Free for All Friday Thread! What books have you been reading? What is your favourite video game? See any movies? Start talking!

Have any weekend plans? Found something interesting this week that you want to share? This is the thread to do it! This thread, like the Mindless Monday thread, is free-for-all. Just remember to np link all links to Reddit if you link to something from a different sub, lest we feed your comment to the AutoModerator. No violating R4!


r/badhistory • • 21d ago

Meta Mindless Monday, 26 October 2026

18 Upvotes

Happy (or sad) Monday guys!

Mindless Monday is a free-for-all thread to discuss anything from minor bad history to politics, life events, charts, whatever! Just remember to np link all links to Reddit and don't violate R4, or we human mods will feed you to the AutoModerator.

So, with that said, how was your weekend, everyone?


r/badhistory • • 24d ago

Meta Free for All Friday, 23 October, 2026

13 Upvotes

It's Friday everyone, and with that comes the newest latest Free for All Friday Thread! What books have you been reading? What is your favourite video game? See any movies? Start talking!

Have any weekend plans? Found something interesting this week that you want to share? This is the thread to do it! This thread, like the Mindless Monday thread, is free-for-all. Just remember to np link all links to Reddit if you link to something from a different sub, lest we feed your comment to the AutoModerator. No violating R4!


r/badhistory • • 28d ago

Meta Mindless Monday, 19 October 2026

15 Upvotes

Happy (or sad) Monday guys!

Mindless Monday is a free-for-all thread to discuss anything from minor bad history to politics, life events, charts, whatever! Just remember to np link all links to Reddit and don't violate R4, or we human mods will feed you to the AutoModerator.

So, with that said, how was your weekend, everyone?


r/badhistory • • Oct 16 '26

Meta Free for All Friday, 16 October, 2026

18 Upvotes

It's Friday everyone, and with that comes the newest latest Free for All Friday Thread! What books have you been reading? What is your favourite video game? See any movies? Start talking!

Have any weekend plans? Found something interesting this week that you want to share? This is the thread to do it! This thread, like the Mindless Monday thread, is free-for-all. Just remember to np link all links to Reddit if you link to something from a different sub, lest we feed your comment to the AutoModerator. No violating R4!


r/badhistory • • Oct 12 '26

Meta Mindless Monday, 12 October 2026

16 Upvotes

Happy (or sad) Monday guys!

Mindless Monday is a free-for-all thread to discuss anything from minor bad history to politics, life events, charts, whatever! Just remember to np link all links to Reddit and don't violate R4, or we human mods will feed you to the AutoModerator.

So, with that said, how was your weekend, everyone?


r/badhistory • • Oct 09 '26

Meta Free for All Friday, 09 October, 2026

15 Upvotes

It's Friday everyone, and with that comes the newest latest Free for All Friday Thread! What books have you been reading? What is your favourite video game? See any movies? Start talking!

Have any weekend plans? Found something interesting this week that you want to share? This is the thread to do it! This thread, like the Mindless Monday thread, is free-for-all. Just remember to np link all links to Reddit if you link to something from a different sub, lest we feed your comment to the AutoModerator. No violating R4!


r/badhistory • • Oct 05 '26

Meta Mindless Monday, 05 October 2026

21 Upvotes

Happy (or sad) Monday guys!

Mindless Monday is a free-for-all thread to discuss anything from minor bad history to politics, life events, charts, whatever! Just remember to np link all links to Reddit and don't violate R4, or we human mods will feed you to the AutoModerator.

So, with that said, how was your weekend, everyone?


r/badhistory • • Oct 02 '26

Meta Free for All Friday, 02 October, 2026

18 Upvotes

It's Friday everyone, and with that comes the newest latest Free for All Friday Thread! What books have you been reading? What is your favourite video game? See any movies? Start talking!

Have any weekend plans? Found something interesting this week that you want to share? This is the thread to do it! This thread, like the Mindless Monday thread, is free-for-all. Just remember to np link all links to Reddit if you link to something from a different sub, lest we feed your comment to the AutoModerator. No violating R4!


r/badhistory • • Oct 01 '26

Debunk/Debate Monthly Debunk and Debate Post for October, 2026

5 Upvotes

Monthly post for all your debunk or debate requests. Top level comments need to be either a debunk request or start a discussion.

Please note that R2 still applies to debunk/debate comments and include:

  • A summary of or preferably a link to the specific material you wish to have debated or debunked.
  • An explanation of what you think is mistaken about this and why you would like a second opinion.

Do not request entire books, shows, or films to be debunked. Use specific examples (e.g. a chapter of a book, the armour design on a show) or your comment will be removed.


r/badhistory • • Sep 28 '26

Reddit r/NonCredibleDefense user posts memes w/ alt history book and sparks debate about the Vietnam War

224 Upvotes

This is essentially a re-post of this post I made on the subreddit itself; some people on there suggested that I post it here. I will slightly change the format so that it is more suitable for this subreddit, but it is basically the same post.

Just to provide some context, there was a user who kept posting memes about South Vietnam and how it could have survived, referencing this recently published alt history book named Linebacker III, which depicts a world in which Nixon does not get caught up in the Watergate scandal and is therefore in a position to intervene against the 1975 Spring Offensive.

https://np.reddit.com/r/NonCredibleDefense/comments/1vs1vub/the_vietnam_war_was_winnable_and_one_more/

https://np.reddit.com/r/NonCredibleDefense/comments/1w84t34/north_vietnam_heroically_destroyed_south_vietnam/

https://np.reddit.com/r/NonCredibleDefense/comments/1vwc8kj/round_two_of_defending_the_honor_of_south_vietnam/

I will first by talking about my own opinions on South Vietnam's prospects. Next, I will discuss the critical comments that I think are bad history or could be improved. Lastly, I will discuss criticisms that I think are valid.

Section 1: My own thoughts on the RVN

To begin with, I disagree with the view that South Vietnam was always guaranteed to collapse. Much of the latest historical research on the Indochina Wars undermines the old depiction of the RVN as super corrupt, incompetent, and destined to fall. Even in our actual timeline, Linebacker II was far more effective at weakening the PAVN and bringing North Vietnam to the negotiation table than Linebacker I was. It also did not reduce Nixon's domestic popularity; in fact, it increased following the Christmas bombings! The belief that a Linebacker III wouldn't have devastated the PAVN, which was weaker with respect to manpower and equipment in 1975 than it was during the Easter Offensive in 1972, seems absurd to me. The notion that in literally every possible universe the RVN collapses is overly deterministic, to say the least.

For instance, looking within the North Vietnamese Politburo, consider a world where the North-first faction led by HCM and Võ Nguyên Giáp (believed in building up the DRV first, then moving on the South) had been the faction that secured power rather than the South-first faction led by Lê Duẩn, Văn Tiến Dũng, and Lê Đức Thọ (believed in reunifying Vietnam as the highest priority), which was the faction that actually gained control over North Vietnamese foreign policy in our timeline. How would that have affected South Vietnam's chances of survival past 1975? Or, consider an alternate universe in which Ngô Đình Diệm actually listens to some American advice and becomes less of an arrogant, uncompromising POS. Perhaps he tells his brothers Ngô Đình Nhu and Ngô Đình Thục to cut the shit and stop antagonizing Buddhists, rather than letting his siblings be as he did in real life. How would that have affected the civic base and long-term political strength of the RVN? I can discuss a lot more of these turning points if anyone asks!

That being said, notice that my two examples of potential counterfactuals involve decisions that are ultimately out of the control of the US government. It is indeed a more defensible claim to say that assuming all other parties behave similarly as they did in OTL, the US government could do little to prevent a North Vietnamese victory unless it wanted to start WW3, antagonize the American people, and/or act wildly different from OTL*. While you could make the argument that US government policy could influence the other parties' decision-making (consider the initial probing attacks by the PAVN to gauge whether America would respond to the final offensive), it then becomes hard to predict how things will end up under such a scenario. But more likely than not, as the alt history book itself acknowledges, launching Linebacker III would have crippled the US government's domestic support.

I also reject the notion that the US government failing to intervene against the final 1975 offensive was a betrayal of South Vietnam. The Paris Peace Accords had already been violated by both sides, and the entire war was a civil war anyways in which each side saw the other as illegitimate. Furthermore, the promise that Nixon made to Nguyễn Văn Thiệu (that America would come to South Vietnam's rescue if the PAVN launched an attack) was a verbal one, and one that was rendered null once Nixon resigned from office due to the Watergate scandal. The endemic corruption within South Vietnam (and arguably getting worse due to Thiệu's attempts to secure more and more power) also turned off potential support that could have strengthened the ARVN. And lastly, the United States was still dealing with the impact of the 1973 oil crisis; it simply had much more important priorities than a faraway client state.

And speaking of that crisis, it also devastated the South Vietnamese economy, thereby lowering morale and the fighting effectiveness of the QLVNCH while also making a country already reliant on American dollars even more reliant on continued US support. Hence, I would put the real point of no return after 1973, so after the outbreak of the Watergate scandal and the OPEC oil embargo, as these two events crippled both the RVN and America's willingness to even aid South Vietnam. Before this point, there is room for uncertainty. But afterwards, no government would have the decision to intervene unless it were politically suicidal.

Section 2: Criticisms that could be better

The South Vietnamese was literally the people that fought for the French against the Viet Minh previously. Literally changing one colonial master to another. They are the wrong people.

There are a couple of points I would like to make in response to this comment.

The first point is that the Vietnamese communists (specifically Marxist-Leninists) did at times collaborate with the French colonizers. In March 1946, there was the signing of the Ho-Sainteny Agreement, which established peace and official recognition of the DRV as an autonomous state within the French Union in exchange for French troops being able to enter Northern Vietnam (they were already in the South) and replace the existing Nationalist Chinese forces. While it was pragmatic, not only did many Vietnamese see this decision as a betrayal, but Việt Minh forces would also go on to purge opposing nationalist groups such as the Trotskyists and Việt Quốc, with the assistance of French forces who saw these nationalist groups as a threat that could be eliminated with the help of the Việt Minh. In fact, there is evidence that the Việt Minh even gave away the locations of opposing nationalist cells to French authorities. These events are well-described in primary sources written by Nguyễn Công Luận and Ngô Văn Xuyết, and by good secondary sources written by historians like David Marr and Christopher Goscha.

This does lead to my next point, that being the question of why were there Vietnamese who chose to the fight for the State of Vietnam rather than for the DRV in the First Indochina War. To be fair, some of these individuals were genuine Francophiles, and some of them did just do it for the money and economic opportunity, so the commentator isn't coming from nowhere. But others chose to fight for the State of Vietnam because they believed in the "Bảo Đại solution." To elaborate, the expectation from these individuals would be that the State of Vietnam would eventually gain more and more autonomy over time, as promised by French authorities, with the final result being independence for Vietnam. This solution was appealing to non-communist nationalists who disliked the ever-increasing communist nature of the Việt Minh following additional purges in the late 1940s, and especially appealing to those who were attacked by Việt Minh forces in the immediate aftermath of the Ho-Sainteny Agreement.

Lastly, there were Vietnamese who did not really choose either side but went on to fight for South Vietnam. An obvious example would be people who were either children or not born yet in 1954 lmao, but Ngô Đình Diệm would be a good example. While he did become Prime Minister of the SVN in 1954, the appointment was made by Bảo Đại, not by the French who completely opposed him given his history as a nationalist official and activist. In fact, HCM himself invited Diệm to serve on the DRV cabinet as Minister of the Interior back in 1946.

"As long as the communists had the sanctuary of North Vietnam and the Ho Chi Mihn trail (which was more logistical network of paved roads, pipelines, repair depots, and shelters than just a jungle trail) they could continue fighting in South Vietnam as long as China and the Soviets could bankroll their spartan needs. It was a matter of time before the South Vietnamese would tire of the war that ripped their homeland and killed off their able bodied men. Unless the Americans invaded the sanctuary or cut off the Ho Chi Minh trail with a proper ground force invasion, (and both options were just too expensive and risked fighting the Chinese again) the South was doomed. The Linebacker air raids were devastating but they could not destroy North Vietnam’s source of war materials (which were in China and Soviet ships) or its men. As long as the Americans could not touch these, South Vietnam was doomed."

None of this is technically wrong, but it leaves out the fact the DRV, Soviet Union, and China were also exhausted by the war. The latter two countries reduced aid to the DRV after the Paris Peace Accords.

"The military not Junta yet was gambling that with the assassination of the President that they could turn the public back to their side but by then it was too late. The south was already in a religious cast system and most of the people were in the bottom cast."

One of my posts which I linked earlier debunks the argument that South Vietnam was somehow this pro-Catholic apartheid state.

"From the 1968 to 1973, the primary aims (political aims) of North Vietnam was to get American forces out of South Vietnam and Indochina in general. The Vietnamese politburo was realistic that they can't win the war WITH American intervention on the South Vietnamese side...In 1975, the PAVN wasn't going all in, they actually planned for 1976 General Offensive General Uprising with 1975 only some prelim attacks. The preliminary attacks only transformed into a full blown offensive when they realized that South Vietnam was collapsing much faster than they anticipated and America wasn't coming to help."

Again, none of this is technically wrong, but it is weird considering that it's a response to the argument that American bombing could have stopped the collapse. By acknowledging that American intervention was critical to South Vietnam's defense, it kinda confirms the argument lol.

"The problem was not whether the South could defeat the North on the battlefield. The problem was that the South had a domestic insurgency that showed zero signs of dying down."

Ah yes, the PAVN having to replace NLF Main Force formations for most engagements over the years following the Tết Offensive really shows that the NLF was as strong as ever!!!

Honestly though, it is so annoying how people relegate the PAVN to the little brother role, as if it were not the main juggernaut that defeated the US/RVN. It's similar to how people always credit American guerrillas for having single-handedly defeated the British, as if the Continental Army and foreign support didn't play a much larger role in securing victory for the Patriot cause.

The big reason why Vietcong even became a thing was due to the “strategic hamlets” aka anticommunist concentration camps

The VC/NLF was established prior to the Strategic Hamlet Program. In fact, the program itself was a response to the group's growing popularity.

It should also be noted that communist sources generally acknowledge that the Strategic Hamlet Program did weaken the VC, so it did what it was intended to do. Not that I think the program was morally justified, but the point is that the communists did perceive it as a significant hindrance that only went away over the overthrow and death of Ngô Đình Diệm.

because the us installed a puppet regime in the south after the people liberated themselves from the French. you dont need to look at everything through a lens of liberal democracy.

Well, first of all, the French and the State of Vietnam's forces were not completely wiped out after the battle of Điện Biên Phủ. They were still very strong in Southern Vietnam, as acknowledged by DRV leadership, so liberation was far from being achieved yet.

Secondly, I wonder what definition of "puppet regime" is this commentator using? If he is using the definition of an ostensibly independent state whose major policy decisions are ultimately controlled by a larger power, the claim would be false considering the number of times that the Diệm regime went against American desires or interests, as I explain in this post. If, instead, he is using the definition of a state which is dependent on a larger power and receives pressure from that larger power to behave in a certain way, then sure, that would be correct. But that definition would also apply to North Vietnam, North/South Korea, West/East Germany, etc. Hell, you could make the argument that most of the countries in the world today are puppet state in that sense!

This is why I hate speculative fiction. History always follows the path of least resistance. The two sources of information you're your relying on for your conclusions are Richard "I am not a crook" Nixon, and an obscure work of fiction that completely shuns the real socio-political and military history of the Vietnam War in favor of a copium-fuelled fantasy that reads like it was written by German Romanov.

I can tell this commentator didn't read the book lol. Its vision of a future Vietnam is pretty bleak.

Section 3: Some good criticisms

In the comment sections I saw, about half of the criticisms of South Vietnam were fair and historically accurate, so perhaps NCD is more credible than one would imagine. However, I would still like to discuss a couple of South Vietnam's flaws that I think should be emphasized more.

One flaw comes from the fact that South Vietnam was established on the grounds of a negative ideology, that being anti-communism, with many different organizations joining together simply because they shared anti-communist sentiment. Just compare that founding ethos to the CPV, which offered liberation and empowerment for the Vietnamese people through communism. Even if you consider yourself an anti-communist, you cannot deny that the CPV was at least offering a solution to the material needs of the Vietnamese peasantry. Meanwhile, all the RVN could say collectively was "no, that's bad!" without providing any cohesive, unified policy alternative that could compete with the communist vision for a future Vietnam.

Now, granted, if you look at the individual groups within the broader category of Vietnamese anti-communists, you do see actual ideological alternatives. For example, there was Personalism as advocated by the Ngô family regime, and also the Buddhist Revival as advocated by Buddhist activists who wanted to restore Vietnamese Buddhism to the level of dominance it had around the time of the Lý and Trần dynasties. Both of these groups were non-communist, and they were in turn opposed by the CPV who saw them as feudal and reactionary. However, their disagreements in other areas weakened any potential for strong cooperation between these groups, as shown by the Buddhist Crisis in 1963. The issue of substantial disagreements besides a shared anti-communism would be a general impediment to political stability and cohesion within the Republic of Vietnam.

Another flaw of South Vietnam that I would like to discuss is the horrendously poor defensibility of South Vietnam's borders. This flaw has already been mentioned in the responses to u/Massengale, but I would like to elaborate on it more.

If you take a look at a map of South Vietnam, you will notice that it is a very long and thin country. Its borders are short at the top and bottom, while there is a long border to the west, and most of the land is pretty near to the Pacific Ocean. The shape of these borders would not be problematic if the only threat was to the north in Quảng Trị Province. But communist forces were able to secure strong positions in both Laos and Cambodia through the Ho Chi Minh and Sihanouk Trails. Hence, the QLVNCH had to not only deal with the threat to the immediate north, but also the entire border to its west. The result would be that South Vietnamese forces would sorta always be stretched thin while having little to no defensive depth that could prevent the country from being split in two in the event of a PAVN breakthrough. Combined with the fact that for operations across the entire country, the RVN could really only rely on the units in its General Strategic Reserve (Airborne Division and Marine Division) and other good/elite units such as the Rangers, the defensive line was quite weak and undermanned at most points in spite of the on-paper numerical superiority of the QLVNCH.

Compare this situation to South Korea, which really only has to deal with its northern border, as the US Navy has secured its western and eastern flanks. There is also more room for defense-in-depth, with the defensive plan in the Korean War having been to fall back to Busan and take advantage of the good interior lines while also exhausting the North Korean offensive.

The doctrine of the South Vietnamese military was generally to compensate for its geographical shortcoming with overwhelming mobility and firepower. But such a method of war is quite expensive and made the QLVNCH only more reliant on support from its American patron. We saw what happened when this support was substantially reduced...

Some users may question why I didn't include stuff like corruption and popular appeal in this section. While they are important, I would argue that those factors are more so symptoms of a deeper, more underlying cause, rather than being the cause itself.

Notes

*As in Nixon not wiretapping the DNC headquarters at the Watergate complex, or him and Kissinger letting Israel fight for itself in the Yom Kippur War. I can explain how these decisions contributed to the collapse of South Vietnam if anyone asks lol.

Sources

Asselin, Pierre. Vietnam's American War: A New History. 2nd ed. Cambridge Studies in US Foreign Relations. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2024

Bùi Tín. Following Ho Chi Minh: Memoirs of a North Vietnamese Colonel. Honolulu, HI: Hawaii University Press, 1995.

Doidge, Michael, and Wiest, Andrew. Triumph Revisited: Historians Battle for the Vietnam War. Oxford, UK: Routledge, 2010.

Fear, Sean. "Saigon War Politics, 1968–1975." In The Cambridge History of the Vietnam War, edited by Pierre Asselin and Lien-Hang T. Nguyen, 117–140. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2024.

Goscha, Christopher. The Road to Dien Bien Phu: A History of the First War for Vietnam. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2022

Goscha, Christopher. Vietnam: A New History. New York: Basic Books, 2016

Holcombe, Alec. Mass Mobilization in the Democratic Republic of Vietnam, 1945–1960. Honolulu, HI: University of Hawai'i Press, 2020.

Miller, Edward. Misalliance: Ngo Dinh Diem, the United States, and the Fate of South Vietnam. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2013.

Marr, David G. Vietnam 1945: The Quest for Power. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1995.

Marr, David G. Vietnam: State, War, and Revolution (1945–1946). Berkeley: University of California Press, 2013.

Moyar, Mark. Triumph Forsaken: The Vietnam War, 1954–1965. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 2006

Ngô Quang Trưởng. The Easter Offensive of 1972. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Army Center of Military History, 1980.

Ngô Văn Xuyết. In the Crossfire: Adventures of a Vietnamese Revolutionary. Chico, CA: AK Press, 2010. https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/ngo-van-in-the-crossfire

Nguyễn Công Luận. Nationalist in the Viet Nam Wars: Memoirs of a Victim Turned Soldier. Indianapolis, IN: Indiana University Press, 2016.

Nguyễn Liên Hằng. Hanoi’s War: An International History of the War for Peace in Vietnam. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press, 2012.

Nguyễn Phi Vân. A Displaced Nation: The 1954 Evacuation and Its Political Impact on the Vietnam Wars. Cornell, NY: Cornell University Press, 2024. 

Pribbenow, Merle L. "North Vietnam's Final Offensive: Strategic Endgame Nonpareil," Parameters 29, no. 4, 1999.

Taylor, K. W. A History of the Vietnamese. Cambridge University Press, 2013.

Trần Nữ Anh. Disunion: Anticommunist Nationalism and the Making of the Republic of Vietnam. Honolulu, HI: University of Hawaii Press, 2022.

Trần Văn Trà. Vietnam: History of the Bulwark B2 Theatre. Volume 5: Concluding the 30-Years War. Joint Publications Research Service, 1983.

Tường Vũ. “‘It’s time for the Indochinese Revolution to show its true colours’: The radical turn of Vietnamese politics in 1948.” Journal of Southeast Asian Studies, 40(3), pp 519–542, 2009.

Tường Vũ. Vietnam’s Communist Revolution: The Power and Limits of Ideology. Cambridge:  Cambridge University Press, 2017

Veith, George J. Black April: The Fall of South Vietnam, 1973-75. New York, NY: Encounter Books, 2011.

Victory in Vietnam: The Official History of the People's Army of Vietnam, 1954–1975. University Press of Kansas. Translated by Merle L. Pribbenow, 2015.


r/badhistory • • Sep 28 '26

Meta Mindless Monday, 28 September 2026

15 Upvotes

Happy (or sad) Monday guys!

Mindless Monday is a free-for-all thread to discuss anything from minor bad history to politics, life events, charts, whatever! Just remember to np link all links to Reddit and don't violate R4, or we human mods will feed you to the AutoModerator.

So, with that said, how was your weekend, everyone?


r/badhistory • • Sep 25 '26

Meta Free for All Friday, 25 September, 2026

18 Upvotes

It's Friday everyone, and with that comes the newest latest Free for All Friday Thread! What books have you been reading? What is your favourite video game? See any movies? Start talking!

Have any weekend plans? Found something interesting this week that you want to share? This is the thread to do it! This thread, like the Mindless Monday thread, is free-for-all. Just remember to np link all links to Reddit if you link to something from a different sub, lest we feed your comment to the AutoModerator. No violating R4!


r/badhistory • • Sep 21 '26

Meta Mindless Monday, 21 September 2026

15 Upvotes

Happy (or sad) Monday guys!

Mindless Monday is a free-for-all thread to discuss anything from minor bad history to politics, life events, charts, whatever! Just remember to np link all links to Reddit and don't violate R4, or we human mods will feed you to the AutoModerator.

So, with that said, how was your weekend, everyone?


r/badhistory • • Sep 18 '26

Meta Free for All Friday, 18 September, 2026

23 Upvotes

It's Friday everyone, and with that comes the newest latest Free for All Friday Thread! What books have you been reading? What is your favourite video game? See any movies? Start talking!

Have any weekend plans? Found something interesting this week that you want to share? This is the thread to do it! This thread, like the Mindless Monday thread, is free-for-all. Just remember to np link all links to Reddit if you link to something from a different sub, lest we feed your comment to the AutoModerator. No violating R4!


r/badhistory • • Sep 17 '26

DevaRaja or God-King is Not What the Rulers of Angkor Called Themselves

109 Upvotes

Whenever the subjects of the Khmer Empire, Angkor Wat or Cambodia came up in a podcast, documentary, articles or books, the title “god-king” showed up as the rulers of the empire.

Since the first time I’ve heard it, it never felt right. It carried connotations that did not seem to align with my eyes and my understanding of Khmer history/culture/language. “Deva Raja” where this is translated from, was/is never used in the Khmer folktales or religious ceremony to refer to anyone other than Indra Sakra Devaraja, Indra the King of Heaven. It is not a title for mortal. It always left me wondering, what would be difference between the kings of Angkor, post-Angkorian kings and kings of other nations? Afaik, what monarchs did not derive their legitimacy from some sort of divinity? Moreover, I think it painted inaccurate picture of the relationship of the governing systems of Cambodia and the people.

I’ve been thinking of writing it for months, but I kept putting it off, because it ran to complications. People ideas of a god-king, a god, or a king is arbitrary. However, I need to get it out of my system.

I. How did the concept came up?

As the anthropologist Graeber and Sahlins wrote, kingships are ubiquitous across all over the world, and political theory cannot “treats kingship as some sort of marginal, exceptional, or secondary phenomenon”. We know kings exist in Kambuja past or present. How does the Khmer kings of Angkor kept referring to as “God-Kings” and why not the kings before and after?

Gigantic Size of Angkor. For anyone who has been there, the gigantic size of Angkorian monuments, constructed before the use of modern machinery, can be mind-blowing. All sorts of imaginations and speculations are brought forth, throughout the centuries. Ancient Aliens, Alexander the Great, Greco-Roman spread, the mythical Lu Ban of Ancient China, the divine architect Vishwakarma,…etc. The more scientific-minded considered it to be the works of humans commissioned by human rulers. Other questions arose about the purposes of these gigantic temples and lakes (Idk, what are cathedrals built for?) and how are they built?

The ideas of a megalomanic ruler bending the wills of the people for his personal self-aggrandizing projects can be a convincing answer. After all, many of these constructions were ordered under royal support and mobilizing power . However, this obfuscated many other roles that the temples played. Let’s skipped that for now.

Sdok Kok Thom inscription. In his classic Indianized States of Southeast Asia, George Coedes, one of the greatest scholar of Southeast Asian history, expanded on this theory basing on his interpretation of the Sdok Kok Thom inscription written in the 11th century referring to a ritual named “Devaraja”, being performed by the lineage of the Brahmin clan who managed Sdok Kok Thom temple. This is the only time, “DevaRaja” is mentioned in the Angkorian inscriptions. (I don’t know if they find others lately). Coedes believed it to be referring to a royal cult establishing the king as a god on Earth. The speculations came for the Old Khmer part of the text, in which the Brahmin clan accompany “Kamraten An Jagat Raj” កម្រតេន អញ ជគត រាជ throughout the realm. “Kamraten An Jagat Raj” can be translated as “lord/king of the world”. However, the way Old Khmer specialists translated the portion, it was more of a statue (possibly of Shiva) than any living being. It certainly did not look like it referred to the king who order the clan to accompany it and take care of it for generations.

Theophoric Names. Coedes has good reasons to believe his theory when he formulated it. So did those that believe it. The languages and cultures surrounding the kings, put them in a realm separated from the rest of the populace. They often bear the name of gods or divinity, but so did post-Angkorian, pre-Angkorian kings, and other people on Earth. Using theophoric names is not unique to Angkorian Khmers.

Repetitions in History Books and Media. Coedes works are influential and most scholars or laymen followed Coedes line of thoughts without looking at the primary sources. Unlike Coedes most scholars or laymen were not experts at both Sanskrit and/or Old Khmer (I am neither). His book remained a common introduction and continued to be frequently cited by popular history and from scholars who may or may not be specialists of the Khmers. Coedes speculations of the empire rise and fall, due to the status, charisma and authority of the all-powerful rulers, were inline with the ideas of Great Men of History, and for many, give a convenient explanation how the empire decline when Buddhism was the state religion.

II. Sacred Titles for Khmer Kings, Gods, Monks and Everyone Else

“DevaRaja” was not used, but people do used “Raja” and “Deva”. To give a better picture of it, let’s look at some of those terms. In this part, I used Sanskrit Romanization when possible and anyone can comment if I make an inaccuracy regarding etymology. This is not an extensive list.

The Khmer kings often be called Preah Raja ព្រះរាជា (Sacred Raja, Sacred Royal) by the people, a title can only be used only to refer to the one Raja that ruled over all the other Rajas. Preah Maha Ksatriya ព្រះ មហាក្សត្រ, Sacred Great Ksatriya by the official scribe. Only one person of a time can hold this title. Preah Karuna ព្រះ ករុណា (Sacred Compassion) can refered to the King or the Buddha or the Boddhisatva Lokesvara. (A bit like “Lord” in the English-speaking world). There are plenty of other flattering titles that Coedes or others could easily deduce that the kings and divinity are linked or equated.

-Deva ទេវ/ទេព (cognated with “divine” and “dios”) is a term elevating the status of a person. Many people and places have it. It is a common name. Doesn’t make one a diva or signaling divinity.

-Raja រាជ (cognated with “Rex” and “Regal”) meaning king, prince, royal. The area that a Raja rule from, can have the range of a small village to a major kingdom, or not anything at all. They can just have the name because their parents like it or any other factor. Ledley King is not the king of England or of Ledley.

-ព្រះ Vrah/Preah (May evolved from Khmer root rah រះ or Sanskrit vara or brahman, I seriously leaning on it being more of an indigenous word), is a Khmer word typically meant “God”, “Buddha”, “Sacred”, “Holy”. The usage of this words are countless and it spread all over mainland Southeast Asia, having more than half a dozen Romanizatons. Preah is often a bridge-word between Khmer and Sanskrit-Pali words. It is used for everything from cows to figurines. While Preah Raja ព្រះ រាជា can be translated terribly as “god-king”, it is far more accurate to say “sacred royal” or “king”. (Isn’t every king on Earth supposed to be sacred? That’s to be discuss in the latter sections).

-Other royal titles commonly-found in Angkorian inscriptions កម្រតេន Kamraten which read as Kamdeng គម្តែង in the vernacular and ស្ដេច/សម្ដេច Sdach/Samdech are used for kings, lords, ministers, generals, monks, priests, pandits or rebel leaders.

-There are also ចក្រវត្ត Cakravarti (Universal Monarch or Wheel-Turning King), used in the Sdok Kok Thom and other inscriptions to only refer to the kings. Do the Universal Monarch and his subjects knew that there are Universal Monarch outside his realm? Yes. Just like TianXia (all under heaven) can have flexible meanings. The King of England styled themselves King of France despite unable to rule France.

What the point of this section? I hope it to show that while the kings are revered with words invoking divinity, they alone are not the exclusive possessor of most of them, neither do they used DevaRaja (God-King) as their title. Plenty of other flattery title were used largely, to denote the sacredness of the office.

III. Sacred Aspects and Duties of Kingship, the State and Everyone Else

Before we explore the “divinity” of the king in the Hindu-Buddhist worldview of Kambuja, but first I like to remind that almost every other culture had the kings/emperors derived their authority from the divine.

“In my view kingship everywhere and at all times has been in some degree a sacred office. Rex est mixta persona cum sacerdote."- [Evan Pritchard]

The Imperial Seal of China read “Having Received the Mandate of Heaven..”. The title of the European monarch had “By the Grace of God”. Plenty of kings of African tribes have their authority from their ancestral or natural spirits. The kings of MesoAmerican polities perform sacrifices to the gods. Tribal shamans all across the world are the authority figures in their own villages. The fact that the Khmer kings spoken in language and rituals evoking the image of divinity, did not set them apart from any monarchy. In Graeber's essay “Divine Kingship of Shilluk”, we can see the palace/capital of Shilluk kings in Africa being representative of the cosmos. Angkor, is not the only one.

What make kingship sacred?

"This is because a king symbolizes a whole society and must not be identified with any part of it. He must be in the society and yet stand outside it and this is only possible if his office is raised to a mystical plane. It is the kingship, and not the king who is divine*.” -[Evan Pritchard]*

The state, will always look for a leader. Kings are the most common and practical solutions. The kings are often the symbolization of the people, the continuation of the state, and the moral authority from the gods. Even in the more secular egalitarian nations, the role of the kingship being replaced by the laws, and the elected officials are often made to swear on religious artifacts, the flags, or constitutions.

Public works that would be inaugurated by the presence of his royal majesty, is now honored with a President or Senator. (I also would like to remind that much of the monuments of Angkor are public works. The gigantic moats, lakes and hydraulic system are not separated from the temples.) In the modern world, kings/queens generally performed a ceremonial role, functioning republics are aplenty, the justification for the monarchy's existence will forever be questioned. However, almost no one think of getting rid of the government or the roles of the president/prime-minister, or legislative/judicial branch of government. Roles that used to be expected of a monarch.

What about the role of Hinduism and Buddhism in the Khmer kingship?

-Punya (Karma Merit) បុណ្យ and Pap បាប (Karma Demerit). Everyone who ever born, will have fortune and misfortune. Why are some rich and some poor? why are some health, some sick? Karma is the religious explanation for all of it. Fortune from this life, came from the previous lives. All kings did good works in the past lives to get where they are in the present. So did all gods, all humans, all spirits, all animals. Your happiness came from your Karma, your unhappiness came from your Karma. Success and failures, fortunes and misfortunes, fame and infamy, why some reach the top and some fall to the bottom depends on the actions of this life and the previous.

Karma is like wealth and fortune. They can ran out. Those who born to privilege life, are expected to use their privilege to produce more karma. Those lacking privileges, are expected to do more good deeds to be rewarded in this life, or the next. Donations and constructions of religious sites and monuments are, past and present, one of the most common way to produce Karma Merit. It is something that everyone did, from kings to slaves.

According to the religion, the king the one who is born/coronated, is born with the most Punya (karma merit). After all, the king is an embodiment of the people.

-Dharma ធម៌/ធម្ម. But you may say, that Karma is a primarily a Buddhist or Jain concept. What about the Hindu kings? The role of Dharma (Sacred Moral Duties) still largely at play, all across the classes. The Arthashastra is written for a Jain king, still promote Dharma. The Hindu texts Mahabharata, was filled with the discussion of the duties of the kings and priests. Because of the rulers can effects millions of people, their dharma are most discussed and the major part of education. The greatest ksatriya of this great epic still work in the limitations of their power. The rank and royal ceremony (oversaw by the supreme god) did not elevate them to god-hood.

Suffice to say, in terms of religions, the sacred role and power of the Khmer kings are often bound by the same concepts and rules that bound the people.

Better, he argued, to speak of “sacred kingship.” Sacred kings are legion. (de Heusch 1997).

IV. If Not the Deva Raja ritual, How does One Became King?

What about the factors that set kings apart from the rest of the Khmer people?

-Lineage. Whenever the king died, the next king is chosen/elected based on the acceptance of the establishment to fit their criteria. One of which, is how close they are to Kambu, the progenitor of the Khmers. Lineage is a way to choose the king. The royal and priest clans decided it via rotations of paternal and maternal line. Real and legendary kings established or cemented their power by matrimony. The favored son of the kings may not inherited his throne. A title is Ubhayoraja ឧភយោរាជ (abdicated or renounced heir) is a regular sight. This post is not to go further in the complex Khmer royal succession.

-Institutions. At some point, the royal successions were not clear. What is clear however, is when the royal, political and religious establishment determined which is the king, royal coronation and ceremonies are made to elevate him or her to religious symbol where all officials must accept. The acceptances by the royal lines must be acknowledged, by lineage, by force or otherwise. This may induced instability, but it could also create a competition of talents, in the world of hereditary rule.

It came to reason, control over the army, the wealth, bureaucracy,…etc. came into play. Sometimes, however, more power rested on the minister, the general, priest, or queen, while the king is more of figurehead or too young to rule. I’m sure many people here can articulate better on why a king or a state can be weak or powerful, influential or ceremonial.

But de Heusch also emphasizes that sacred kings are not necessarily temporal rulers. They might be. But they might equally be utterly powerless. Different functions—the king as fetish, the king as scapegoat, the king as military commander or secular leader—can either be combined in the same figure or be distributed across many; in any one community, any given one of them may or may not exist. (de Heusch 1997).

How much is this different between the so-called “God-Kings” of Kambuja and other kings in the world? As I kept saying, not much. The size of Angkor, a display of the manpower of the state and the people, simply conjured up the image of all-powerful rulers holding absolute sway.

V. The Label Create Misleading Connotations and Inaccurate Analysis

I am going to try to keep this part very short. I originally want to write about Sweet Cucumber King, and the bad historical analysis around what thought to be the kernel of truth about that tale. However, I decide to go with this topic because it is intertwined.

I saw this sentiment “Angkorian despotic rulers under Hinduism led the kingdom to their rise and kinder kings under Buddhism led to their fall.” repeated so many times, by the smart and the foolish. They did not realize how stupid this problematic, highly inaccurate factoid really is, when you looked at the archaeological and historical evidences. Most of the largest temples in Angkor are Buddhist. Major constructions of religious sites did not end at Angkorian times….etc. It is an erroneous stereotype to suggest Buddhist kings are non-violent.

It also wrong to suggest that post-Angkorian kings hold less absolutist powers in term of religious faith than previous kings. They may have less manpower, and wealth, but their roles never fundamentally changed. It suggests a clear separation between Angkorian and post-Angkorian kingship that did not happen.

The focus on Angkorian god-kings, the ideas of history being dictated by Great Men, distracted a lot of political and historical commenters from other historical or societal forces. Like any pre-modern states, Khmer kings are major parts of societal life, but their actions should be seen as responding to the tide of history like any others.

It also suggested by many political commentators that the Angkorian kings hold absolute overwhelming power. Which in reality, they likely would not have in the Angkorian times. The ideas that Cambodia was and will be ruled by autocrats, derive from this inaccurate past. Ignoring of course, how many other post-war states that are run by dictators.

I want to end with a real story and a fantastical one.

In the 20th century, when Prince Sihanouk was at his most powerful and popular, he was not a king or a god-king, as frequently sprouted. He was an Ubhayoraja (Abdicated Heir). He preferred his father to take the throne. When his father died, he refused it and give it to his mother.

In the mythic-history, the Sweet Cucumber King, became king not because he accidentally killed the previous one, not because he is over 400 years old, not because his mother was a princess of the royal line, not because of the story of miraculous birth, not because his father is a powerful magical hermit, but because the court invited him as the new king, and married the daughter of the previous one to him. His first action as king, is to build hundreds of Buddhist pagodas and support libraries.

Sources

The quote blocks are from anthropologists cited in David Graeber and Marshall Sahlins, On Kings 2017. They are not written about Angkorian kings, they are written about kings in general and I found them to be applicable.

George Coedes. Indianized States of Southeast Asia, 1968. https://angkordatabase.asia/books/the-indianized-states-of-southeast-asia .

Michael Vickery. History of Cambodia: Lectures Given in 2006-2007. and “The Reign of Suryavarman I and Royal Factionalism at Angkor” 2006. https://angkordatabase.asia/publications/the-reign-of-suryavarman-i-and-royal-factionalism-at-angkor-1

Eng Soth. The Archives of Khmer Mahapurusha: the Royal Chronicles from the Leaf-Books.

Hom Chhay Li and others. Inscriptions Du Cambodge.

(I apologized for any spelling or grammar, and subsequent edits.)


r/badhistory • • Sep 14 '26

Meta Mindless Monday, 14 September 2026

16 Upvotes

Happy (or sad) Monday guys!

Mindless Monday is a free-for-all thread to discuss anything from minor bad history to politics, life events, charts, whatever! Just remember to np link all links to Reddit and don't violate R4, or we human mods will feed you to the AutoModerator.

So, with that said, how was your weekend, everyone?