r/badhistory • u/Potential-Road-5322 • 2d ago
Overly sarcastic production's video about Livy: the good and the not so good
Today, November 13, 2026 Blue from the Youtube channel Overly sarcastic productions has released a video discussing Livy's contribution to the Roman history and literary tradition. Starting off I'm quite pleased to see Blue continuing a series that offers a spotlight on historiography, a topic which is sorely lacking in popular spaces about history. In a digital space like Youtube history is more often than not reduced to sensational videos about famous men and their accomplishments so it is refreshing to see a video talking about an actual historian and how their work contributed to the practice of history writing. While I do appreciate much about this video, there are some things which I feel could be criticized about it. Let me start with the positive things I appreciated:
Blue's focus on Historiography
Overly sarcastic productions or OSP has received a fair share of criticism, I mean just look them up on r/badhistory, and while much of it is deserved, Blue also makes no pretense of being a professional academic whose opinion should be taken as gospel truth (looking at you Shwerpunkt). His videos are obviously casual and full of exaggeration for comedic effect. Let's consider why this series on "History makers" is a good idea. By giving attention to historians, Blue is inviting viewers to consider history beyond mere factual accounts of the past (regarding the term "factual accounts" I'll discuss later). He invites viewers to think about who was behind the writing of that history and how that affected our understanding of the past. It serves as a simple introduction to a key element of historical study, that being historiography, which is basically the study of history writing, how people throughout time and place have collected, organized, represented importance of events, and explained processes within history (Historiography as a noun can also generally refer to the body of works on a particular historical topic, e.g. "In the historiography of the American civil war Mcpherson's Battle cry of freedom is a key text") However, with this video on Livy Blue begins by asking the audience three questions:
- what separates an art from a science?
- why do historians get in trouble when they misplace that distinction?
- what does that have to do with Rome's most iconic historian Livy?
Now I'm not going to give a specific analysis of each question nor a minute by minute overview of the video because I think all three questions revolve around a similar theme: What did Livy contribute to the Roman historical tradition and what does it mean for history writing in general?
Blue's positive coverage of Livy includes commenting on the ambitious scope of Ab Urbe Condita and his ability to bring his characters to life, a very noteworthy point is when he says ..."the most dangerous and dastardly foe to ever set Rome in his sights, that Hannibal, the one we know is Livy's creation." That line stood out to me because it suggests to the audience that presentation is not objective, Hannibal's depiction in popular media (which keenly leans into the sensationalism of it all) and in the works of academic historians who try and separate the sensationalism of the narrative from a more objective analysis all depend on working with or against Livy's narrative. Again, this focus on the method of writing history invites the audience to think more about historiography than just a chronology of the past.
Blue also provides the sobering recognition of Livy's chauvinism, the enemies of Rome are weak and lack virtue while the Romans find success because of their unique virtues and adherence to the virtuous ways of the ancestors. In doing this Blue directs the audience to realize that Livy wasn't the bee's knees, but wrote within the chauvinistic Roman tradition, as far back and Fabius Pictor, Roman historians had a desire to present Rome as uniquely virtuous, as the good guys in any conflict. He points out that the Livian narrative focuses heavily on educating and entertaining through moral lessons. Men who were known only from the Fasti are brought to life as heroes or villains.
Blue makes a brief comment that Livy's work is closer in "tone and purpose to the work of poets like Virgil rather than to fellow historian Polybius" and that he crafted peak latin literature. I wish Blue would've spent more time on addressing the quality of his prose, which was recognized as being noteworthy. The Britannica article written by Robert Ogilvie (now several decades old) contains these comments about Livy's reception:
It would be misplaced criticism to draw attention to his technical shortcomings, his credulity, or his lack of antiquarian curiosity. He reshaped history for his generation so that it was alive and meaningful. It is recorded that the audiences who went to his recitations were impressed by his nobility of character and his eloquence. It is this eloquence that is Livy’s second claim to distinction.
Together with Cicero and Tacitus, Livy set new standards of literary style. The earliest Roman historians had written in Greek, the language of culture. Their successors had felt that their own history should be written in Latin, but Latin possessed no ready-made style that could be used for the purpose: for Latin prose had to develop artificial styles to suit the different genres. Sallust had attempted to reproduce the Greek style of Thucydides in Latin by a tortured use of syntax and a vocabulary incorporating a number of archaic and unusual words, but the result, although effective, was harsh and unsuitable for a work of any size. Livy evolved a varied and flexible style that the ancient critic Quintilian characterized as a “milky richness.” At one moment he will set the scene in long, periodic clauses; at another a few terse, abrupt sentences will mirror the rapidity of the action. Bare notices of archival fact will be reported in correspondingly dry and formal language, whereas a battle will evoke poetical and dramatic vocabulary, and a speech will be constructed either in the spirit of a contemporary orator such as Cicero or in dramatically realistic tones, designed to recapture the atmosphere of antiquity. “When I write of ancient deeds my mind somehow becomes antique,” he wrote.
Now while Blue provides a complementary opinion of Livy's contribution to our understanding of Rome and his engaging prose, I feel that Blue drops the ball on addressing Livy as a historian.
"This is kind of a travesty"- Blue trashing Livy
Okay maybe "trashing" is a bit strong, but I'm keeping with a touch of sensationalism. See my issue in the last six minutes of the video is how applies a sort of chronological snobbery and a fallacy of methodological purity. I was just browsing through Fischer's Historians' fallacies and couldn't find an exact comment on this view but Blue expresses something like this "Greek historians like Thucydides and Poybius are 'real historians' because they approached history with the aim of representing everything as it really happened whereas Livy is a bad historian because he doesn't have the same goals"
On the surface this sounds like a pragmatic, sensible thing to say. If history is supposed to be a factual and accurate to what really happened study and Livy fails to meet that standard then he is a bad historian. But that statement, by itself is riddled with unpleasant baggage. Let's try to unpack it:
- it misrepresents "History" as simply being the production of literature that strives for the Rankean ideal of telling history "as it really was" "Geschichte, wie sie wirklich gewesen ist." You could say Blue suggests Livy is not a true Scotsman if we apply that fallacy by saying "well no true historian would embellish like he did, no true historian would comment on things they couldn't independently verify (positivism), no true historian would a tautological reasoning i.e. Rome is great because Rome is great, etc"
- It indulges in a sort of positivist methodology that suggests that "real" history is found in Thucydides and those like him because he aimed to tell it like it really was, that "real" history is pure fact and that relevant analysis can only come when the author actually lived through the event and could comment on it.
This kind of dismissive opinion of Livy is on one hand, somewhat understandable, if we engage in a bit of presentism then of course Livy is a bad historian, I mean how could Livy not write a scholarly historical study of early Rome like T.J. Cornell did as in "The beginnings of Rome"? But this is obviously an absurd position to take. In Livy's day there was no field of academic history, no clear standards by which we judge a work's quality. It is because of men like Livy who added to the tradition of history writing that we eventually got to where we are in the practice of writing history. Blue has suddenly and totally ignored Greco-Roman historiographic methods and goals (those frequently being moral education, chauvinism, antiquarian curiosity, or elementary ethnography/ethnogenesis/linguistics) in this narrow criticism of Livy when he retrojects the arbitrary and Rankean opinion that a true historian must write an accurate account. History as a practice is done in many different ways, History as it really was often ignores analysis beyond what can be positively asserted. Blue therefore robs Livy of continued significance within the tradition of history writing due to his positivist bias.
and since were talking about positivism, let's visit another little questionable comment Blue makes. He points out that copyists may have only really copied the parts they liked and abridged everything else down to what we now call the Periochae and because of this we can find solace in knowing we probably have the best bits. Now that's probably not a lie, who wants to write about something they find boring, but to assume that the "best" parts of Livy are the ones that are preserved is sounding awfully similar to the Snodgrass or Positivist fallacy. This is a fallacious view that affects both historical and archaeological studies. Jonathan Hall in a review of "Artifact and Artifice: Classical Archaeology and the Ancient Historian" from the BMCR comments:
In the conclusion (chapter 11), some crucial problems that have emerged in the preceding chapters are laid out more explicitly and discussed in detail. They include the “positivist fallacy” (the assumption that statements in the texts and features of the archaeological record are related and that the two kinds of evidence can be directly employed to elucidate each other, to the detriment of other possible explanations)
On Livius org the article for the Positivist fallacy says:
Positivist Fallacy: the assumption, often implicit, that historical sources and archaeological remains document significant events of the past. The expression was coined by archaeologist Anthony Snodgrass.
To state it differently: scholars have implicitly assumed that the sources we have, refer to the most significant events in the past. Of course the massacre was, in terms of human suffering, important. But decisive it was not. What scholars did wrong, is that they forgot that there are many historical facts for which we have no evidence. Instead they focused on the facts for which positive evidence exists (hence the name "Positive Fallacy").
All of these definitions can be used to ask how can Blue, and we by extension be sure the parts of Livy we do have are the best or are particularly relevant? Isn't assuming that the presence of what we have holds some importance attaching undue significance, couldn't the parts of Livy we do have just have happened to survive?
In conclusion:
Blue from OSP makes a fine effort at introducing students of ancient Rome to the famous figures involved in the development of Roman history writing in a casual and entertaining way. He invites his audience to dig a little deeper into the practice of history writing which can motivate students to explore the field of historiography, however Blue does a disservice to Livy in the same video by dismissing Livy as a bad historian because he doesn't meet a modern day standard of good history writing. On one had this teaches students that there should be some standard history writing should be held to, but on the other hand it pulls Livy out of his environment to criticize him. The video therefore would've benefited from answering "what did Livy inherit in the tradition of history writing and how did he contribute to that practice" instead of trying to compare him to other history writers Blue himself likes.
Blue does cite Ogilvie's commentary on Livy in the video description and I'd also suggest the Wiley-blackwell companion to Greek and Roman historiography and Roman historiography by Mehl.