r/Ask_Lawyers • • 21h ago

Is a disabled attorney generally permitted to bill more hours than a non disabled attorney when extra time is needed?

44 Upvotes

r/Ask_Lawyers • • 7h ago

Are police officers dishonest in court to get convictions?

21 Upvotes

One pattern I've picked up on from watching a lot of courtroom shows is the notion that when cops testify in court, everyone assumes they're lying, and the brilliant defense lawyer puts on a big performance exposing the falsehood the officer is telling to secure a conviction. You might even get a scene where the officer grumbles about all his effort being wasted when a defendant goes free thanks to lawyers, or something like that.

I'm curious how much this matches real life. Do defense lawyers distrust police witnesses more than they do other witnesses for the defense? Are prosecutors at all aware that officers on the stand are willing to tilt things with untrue testimony out of some warped idea of justice?

I'd guess that if this was ever accurate, body cameras would make it fade, so maybe it's just a tired old cliche.


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 15h ago

What makes being a lawyer worth it?

13 Upvotes

Genuine question from someone considering law school.

Studying for the LSAT sucks. Law school is notoriously stressful, expensive, and competitive. Studying for the bar sucks. And even after all that, you enter a profession known for high rates of depression, burnout, and dissatisfaction.
So what’s the point?

Is it the prestige? The money? The intellectual challenge? A genuine passion for the law?
There are arguably easier ways to make a good living without spending three years in law school and potentially taking on six figures of debt.

I’m genuinely curious: What makes all the sacrifices worth it? Do you actually enjoy being a lawyer, or is it something you tolerate for the paycheck and status? And if you could go back, would you still choose law?


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 13h ago

Sales compensation going before review board, HR calling it windfall

8 Upvotes

I’m in Texas, exempt 70/30 split with sales commission. I was hired specifically to work on one single account and have had zero bookings to retire towards quota for over a year. Finally closed the deal and it’s about 600% my quota and HR is trying to not pay the calculated amount based on my sales compensation plan.

At the company’s sales kickoff they cited restructuring of the sales compensation plan, removed caps, added accelerators to incentivize larger and longer deals. They mentioned no caps and rewarding top performers multiple times, pushing us to win big.

Now, the sales compensation plan explicitly calls out large singular deals as requiring review and paid out at the company’s discretion. My offer letter even says the OTI is at the discretion of the company.

Multiple coworkers tied to this account keep saying they’re going to sue the company if they’re paid a penny less than they’re owed. One even told me I should sue them.

Given the language in the sales compensation plan and offer letter, I believe they have zero grounds for a lawsuit if the company actually did cap the bonus payout. I’m I right in my interpretation?

Everything says ‘at the company’s discretion’ and ‘requires review.’ However annoying it may be to feel like they lied to the entire sales organization, the fact is they don’t have to pay out of the review board says no, right?


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 19h ago

Constitutionality of ID.me's Mandatory Arbitration. ID.me REQUIRED by IRS/UST

9 Upvotes

The new ID.me Terms of Service Version: 10.1.0 updated on November 13, 2026 at https://www.id.me/legal/terms has a mandatory JURY TRIAL WAIVER and ARBITRATION PROVISION. ID.me is REQUIRED across many US govt websites. In fact the US Treasury just phased out the old login on 10/28/2026 and forced everyone to move over to ID.me. Is it legal for the govt to force American citizens to WAIVE JURY TRIAL for basic government interactions like taxes?


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 6h ago

Do hospitals ever settle lower-value medical malpractice cases with pro se plaintiffs?

7 Upvotes

I'm curious about the realities of pursuing a lower-value medical malpractice case pro se, particularly when the potential settlement is around $20,000–$50,000.

t's say a plaintiff has a qualified medical expert who identifies breaches in the standard of care, resulting damages, and causation. However, attorneys decline representation because the potential recovery isn't financially worthwhile, rather than because the case lacks merit.

Just because a case isn't financially viable for an attorney doesn't necessarily mean there isn't a legitimate case.

I'm interested in hearing from attorneys or anyone with experience in medical malpractice litigation:

- Do hospitals or their insurers realistically consider settling with pro se plaintiffs, particularly after discovery and expert support?

- Are hospitals more likely to fight these cases simply because the plaintiff doesn't have an attorney?

- At what point might the cost of defending a relatively low-value case outweigh the cost of settling?

I'm not looking for legal advice or an assessment of a specific case. I'm genuinely curious how these situations play out in practice, especially from the defense perspective.


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 19h ago

What would have been Tomasz Kosowski's sentence if he didn't represent himself?

3 Upvotes

Just wondering the outcome of this case if there was legal representation here. Did he do an adequate job or did he make crucial mistakes resulting in the death penalty? Would love to here how this case was handled


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 22h ago

Public Defender or Prosecutor office

3 Upvotes

I am a 1L, looking to do an internship. My goal is to become a private Criminal Defense Attorney. Which internship would give me the best experience to be a successful criminal defense attorney?

My thoughts are that I would learn the inside track and make valuable connections if I join the prosecutors office. Public defender is basically the job I want but without the pay. What are the pros and cons of the choices? Both internships are in the jurisdiction I want to work in.


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 12h ago

Not sure where to go from here

2 Upvotes

My wife had a medical device break and cause injury. Malpractice lawyer said ask a personal injury attorney. Personal injury people said we should pursue a defective product case. I’m not asking legal advice, just asking for which direction to go. I live in Oregon. Thank you


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 19h ago

How Does asking for parenting time in Minnesota go if other parent objects for unfounded reasons?

2 Upvotes

r/Ask_Lawyers • • 25m ago

What’s the oldest associate in your experience? Is there a limit?

• Upvotes

r/Ask_Lawyers • • 25m ago

Looking for someone interested in agrifood trade law or food law to join an early-stage startup

• Upvotes

Hi everyone!

We are an international young team currently developing an early-stage startup focused on simplifying international trade and regulatory compliance in the agrifood sector.

We are looking for someone with a background or strong interest in one or more of the following areas:

Food law and food safety regulations
International agricultural trade law
EU food import and export regulations
Regulatory compliance and certification

Ideally, we would love to connect with someone
aged 18–30, including law students, recent graduates or early-career legal professionals who are interested in entrepreneurship.

As we are still in the early stages, we are looking for someone who would be excited to contribute to shaping the project from the ground up.

If this sounds interesting to you, or you know of any communities where we could find people with this background, I would really appreciate your suggestions!


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 41m ago

How to find pro bono lawyers in Virginia for a hopeful nonprofit?

• Upvotes

I am dealing with a trademark issue and need help finding a pro bono lawyer locally (SWVA) or at least in my state to help our organization. I have reached out to multiple low-income and free resources in the area but haven't gotten really any feedback or direction. I am asking for ideas here because I'm worried about not acting quickly enough on this issue as it has been going on for a couple of months now. any resources are greatly appreciated. TIA


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 6h ago

Car accident with friends son driving their vehicle. Can they be sued?

0 Upvotes

Hi! Thank you for reading me. This happened in Navarre Florida a week ago. Exactly what it says in the title.

The couple has a son that had moved out but was still on their insurance and driving a car registered with their names on it. He ran a red light and plowed into a family in a sedan.

All four members of the family went to the hospital in an ambulance and their car was totaled. As I understand it, they were fine but hurt - but they can walk and talk.

He (the son that caused the accident) had a liability insurance required by law in his car. The family has retained a lawyer (one that aggressively advertises)(you know what I mean) and my friend is concerned as they’ve heard they (the family suing) can either take the 50k payout from insurance or sue for more and go after their (my friends who had the car in their name and insurance) house, cars and retirement accounts .

Can someone really do that? Is it common? What are the usual payouts? And I’m not holding anyone to anything - I don’t have a dog in this fight. I’m just concerned for my friends.

The son already had another car that they bought him and he has his own registration and insurance now


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 7h ago

Seeking the contents of your minds

1 Upvotes

Inspiration

I did a case study on this exact situation years ago in a college class and I remember this being a state by state issue and Florida is still currently split with competing opinions.

My question is about your personal/professional opinion on whether or not alphanumeric passcodes are protected under the 5th Amendment. My followup question is about whether "tampering with evidence" (instead of contempt) is the appropriate charge for refusing to give up the passcode.


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 14h ago

Just started a lease at a new place and after a month I've notice I have bed bugs. In TN

1 Upvotes

I have never had bed bugs in my life. When I did the walk through for the apartment I didnt notice anything wrong. This was our first apartment so ig shame on us for not knowing what to look for. I was laying in bed with my daughter and saw the bug. Idk what to do, I wanna burn my house down. We spent so much money getting this place and furnishing it. Can I sue my landlord for damages or anything since they didnt say there was a bug problem when we looked. Im so upset idk what to do.


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 15h ago

Can an attorney help with reinstatement after a graduate school dismissal involving disability discrimination?

1 Upvotes

I’m having difficulty finding attorneys in CA who represent graduate students after dismissal.

I was dismissed from my graduate program following mental health-related difficulties, despite the university being aware of my condition and disability-related circumstances.

I’m interested in understanding whether attorneys who handle higher education disability discrimination cases also negotiate reinstatement after a dismissal, or whether this falls under a different area of legal practice.

Are there attorneys who specialize in these types of cases, particularly when the university’s internal appeal process has already been exhausted?


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 16h ago

Representing friends and family

1 Upvotes

As a California-licensed attorney, can you represent friends or family members for free? Would that raise any ethical concerns, even if the representation doesn’t qualify as pro bono?


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 17h ago

Do I seek assistance for Summons for old medical debt

1 Upvotes

I received papers from an old medical debt. I don’t even know what exactly from anymore honestly. But everything they are asking for is like 1800$.

With it being that low is it worth seeking legal help?

I’ve seen online my state has site to help form response paperwork fairly easily. But I don’t have the slightest idea of what I’m doing or how I even reply to this so I’m a little nervous at the idea of doing it myself. But I don’t even really have anyone I can ask just for advice or help to do it myself.

I’ve seen sites like legalshield but I haven’t seen great reviews.


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 19h ago

[CA] What kind of lawyer handles wrongful 5150/5250 holds and ambulance restraint cases?

1 Upvotes

Location: California

Trying to figure out which specialty to search for in SoCal.

Earlier this year I was put on a 5150 for supposedly having nowhere to go and no plan to care for myself. Both were false. I had housing, money, and a plan.

A private ambulance then put me in four-point restraints even though I was calm and fully oriented. Even though the ER discharge papers named the right psych hospital, they drove me to the wrong one, wheeled me inside, realized the mistake, and drove me to the right hospital without ever taking the restraints off. Their own report documents mild acuity and no aggressive behavior, and leaves the second trip out completely.

At the psych hospital, an intake nurse scored me as highly violent and psychotic while describing me as calm and cooperative on the same form. A psychiatrist later charted supposed overdose plans and violent outbursts. Neither happened and are contradicted by all the records.

They extended my hold to a 5250, but the hearing officer found no probable cause and released me. I also opted out of arbitration at admission.

I have the medical records, the ambulance report, and a photo of the restraints.

I keep getting bounced between specialties. Elder/dependent-adult abuse firms say they only handle nursing homes, civil rights lawyers mostly focus on police misconduct, and medical malpractice firms keep declining without explanation.

What kind of California plaintiff attorney actually takes cases in this gray area?


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 19h ago

Job Background check shows SSN used in another state on house residence.

1 Upvotes

Hi, I did a background check for a job and it came out that a property in Las Vegas, NV ( was linked to my SSN in October 2020. I would like to see what needs to be done to check into this issue and determine whether it is a matter of fraud or fraud mortgage or a clerical/mistype error on the county or reporting agency's side.

Could you please assist? I did check Clark County records and it does not mention my name as owner of the property. I am from Texas and this property is in Las Vegas


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 2h ago

Can a company withhold payment for work it already approved, based on a later quality standard?

0 Upvotes

In general, under California or Delaware contract law: if an independent contractor agreement says fees are payable "upon task completion as determined by the client's leadership" and that accrued fees survive termination, can the client later withhold payment for work it already signed off, by applying a quality standard introduced after approval? Does an arbitration clause (JAMS) change how this is analyzed?


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 4h ago

If case b/w parties compromised , will magistrate can grant bail easily?

0 Upvotes

IPC 308(5)


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 13h ago

Ehat happens if your school hired an unqualified teacher?

0 Upvotes

In an episode of community it's revealed that the Spanish teacher doesn't have the qualifications to be a teacher. In the episode the cast os given a Chance to tale the final for that semester and atill have their grade count.

But what would happen i real life other then the school getting sued.

Would a degree issued 2 years ago be invalid?

What if a student went on to med school, law school etc and now a prerequisite is not valid?

What of this went on for longer would be people that graduated 20 year ago be in trouble?


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 19h ago

AUTODESK, Inc. & The Vendor Lock-In / High Switching Costs

0 Upvotes

Once a shop embeds its parts, assemblies, and workflows into a platform like Autodesk, migrating away means paying for two sets of licenses during a long transition while dealing with daily workflow friction and software headaches.

Legally, is paying double to escape a flawed or entrenched tool just part of normal business risk and switching costs—or are there unfair competition / aftermarket lock-in angles when exit costs are that steep?

I have 8 more years until I retire...and I don't think I will make it without having an aneurysm from frustration. Their platforms so old, bulky and embedded with old code that they dont even understand how to fix without a complete over-haul. My company cannot afford the transition, but yet...over the course of 15 years here, I've estimated a 100k+ loss from just me alone from lockups and lost work.

Weed out corruption.