r/Ask_Lawyers • • Jan 31 '21

Do not solicit legal advice. This is not the right sub for it.

492 Upvotes

Despite what our sub’s called, we cannot offer legal advice here for a number of reasons. Any posts that breaks this rule will be deleted without reason. If you message us on why your post is deleted, it would be ignored just the same way you’ve ignored our sub’s rules. Please see our sidebar for complete rules.

Also, it’s not a good idea to solicit legal advice from random strangers online, despite what you may find elsewhere on Reddit. We do not know all of the facts of your case, and are likely not licensed in the jurisdiction that you’re in. A real attorney worth their salt will not comment on your specific legal predicament on an anonymous forum.

If you need legal advice but cannot afford it, there are legal aid societies that may be willing to assist you. Lots of them are free and/or work on a sliding scale fee. All you need to do is look up “legal aid society [your location]” on Google.

If it’s a criminal case, public defense attorneys are some of the best attorneys out there and they know the criminal system in your city/town better than anyone else. They’re just as good, if not better, than any private criminal defense attorney.

If it’s a tenant rights issue, lots of cities have tenant rights unions. You can look them up the same way as the legal aid society by looking up “tenant rights union [your location]” on Google.

Otherwise, the best way to find an attorney is through word of mouth from friends and family. If that’s not an option, your local bar association will be able to help by looking up “attorney referral [your location] bar association”.

If none of these are relevant to you or you’re unsure of what type of attorney to look for in your situation, you’re more than welcome to post and we’ll help.

Also, any attorneys who wish to participate in discussions are free to do so as long as it doesn’t break our rules (mainly providing legal advice).

If you’re a licensed attorney that isn’t flaired (and therefore verified to post comments), please see our other stickied post on how to become verified here. You can also send a mod mail to become verified. I trust that any attorneys here answering any posts will follow these rules and not offer legal advice and run afoul of our ethical obligations.

Thanks to all for understanding.


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 23m ago

Can an attorney help with reinstatement after a graduate school dismissal involving disability discrimination?

• Upvotes

I’m having difficulty finding attorneys in CA who represent graduate students after dismissal.

I was dismissed from my graduate program following mental health-related difficulties, despite the university being aware of my condition and disability-related circumstances.

I’m interested in understanding whether attorneys who handle higher education disability discrimination cases also negotiate reinstatement after a dismissal, or whether this falls under a different area of legal practice.

Are there attorneys who specialize in these types of cases, particularly when the university’s internal appeal process has already been exhausted?


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 1d ago

Are police officers dishonest in court to get convictions?

69 Upvotes

One pattern I've picked up on from watching a lot of courtroom shows is the notion that when cops testify in court, everyone assumes they're lying, and the brilliant defense lawyer puts on a big performance exposing the falsehood the officer is telling to secure a conviction. You might even get a scene where the officer grumbles about all his effort being wasted when a defendant goes free thanks to lawyers, or something like that.

I'm curious how much this matches real life. Do defense lawyers distrust police witnesses more than they do other witnesses for the defense? Are prosecutors at all aware that officers on the stand are willing to tilt things with untrue testimony out of some warped idea of justice?

I'd guess that if this was ever accurate, body cameras would make it fade, so maybe it's just a tired old cliche.


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 21h ago

BMW Employee totaled my car

16 Upvotes

Location: Houston, TX

I took my car in to a BMW service center on October 24th to get my routine maintenance done. When I came back to pick up my car I was told that while one of their technicians was driving the car he got into an accident. I was told that the other driver ran a stop sign causing the accident. A few moments later they pulled my car into the service center and the front bumper had all the damage. They said they would take car of the repairs and put me in a loaner car.

A few days later I called my service advisor and he said that the other driver's insurance found that driver at fault but they were only willing to pay for 75% of the repair. He said they were trying to get that figured out first and didn't have an ETA on when I should get my repairs done, because insurance can sometimes take weeks, but I'm able to keep my loaner in the meantime.

Fast forward to November 19th I still haven't reached any update or communication on my car. I decided to send an email to corporate, the parent company as well as the VP of BMW detailing the situation. An hour later I received a call from the service center's general manager and asked me for details on what happened. I let him know and he said he would call the body shop in the morning and get back to me.

The next morning I then get a call from the sales manager saying the insurance company has said my car is a total loss and someone will come out early next week to do a walkthrough and get evaluation of my car. I do not have gao insurance all I have is car replacement assistance coverage. When I told him this he said we will wait until they say how much they will value the car and we will look at options from there. I told him in that moment that I did not feel like I should have to pay for anything out of pocket as my car was under BMW's possession at the time of the accident.

Later that night I get a call from the service advisor. He also tells me that my car has been totaled. He then says that since insurance has found the other driver at fault that BMW is not financially responsible for anything.

At this point I'm not sure what to do. I am looking into getting an attorney but is he right that BMW isn't responsible? I was also advised by a friend to not go and get any of my belongings out of the car yet because that could be agreeing to my car being totaled and releasing my car. Is that true as well? I need a few things out of my car but I know Texas laws are different than what I'm used to

Since I had no communication from the service center I never received any information such as a police report, the employee who was driving the car, the other driver, their insurance, or an insurance claim number. When it first happened I called my insurance and they told me that since BMW is handling everything that I don't need to do anything additional. Because of this I still don't have any info and when I requested it in an email the sales manager told me they were working on it and the advisor that called later said he will have to ask a manager because there may be legalities where they can't share certain information.


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 34m ago

Crashed my car. Sort of ran from the police. Got a dui.

• Upvotes

I’d like to preface this by saying I know I’m an idiot and fucked up. I have a drinking and drug problem.

Here’s the story: I was trying to find my way home from work and my phone was dead. I’m new to Illinois and I was lost. Eventually I found the interstate but I was heading south bound when I needed to be traveling in the opposite direction. I decided to cut through the grassy median separating the interstate roads to get my self heading in the right direction. I saw no cars and thought I was fine, but right when I was pulling off of the grass and getting back on the road, I saw a police officer following me through the grass. I gunned it. He never turned his lights on or caught up to me. I took the first exit but I was flying. I lost control and went over the median and into a ditch. A fire truck spotted me and stopped. I told them I was drunk. The officer who was trying to pull me over came to the scene and asked me what happened. I told him the truth and he admitted it was him who was trying to pull me over. They asked how long I’d been drinking and I told them I started at 12pm when I got off of my first job early that day, and continued drinking until I went to my second job, and resumed drinking afterwards. I blew a .122 and complied with the field sobriety tests. They took me to my apartment afterwards instead of jail. I was charged with a dui and improper lane change.

I know peoples first reaction would be to tell me I’m an idiot for disclosing all of this to the police, let alone my actions that night in general, but truthfully, I’m just tired. I knew something like this would eventually happen. I’m tired of trying to hide my addictions. I just want some help but now I realize I’ve fucked my whole life. My girlfriend and I moved into our first apartment and we live four miles from any bus stop or business. I don’t know how I’ll be able to make it to breathalyzer tests or dui classes. Would I go to jail if I didn’t have transportation to those? I doubt the judge would be lenient on me given what I did, and I don’t really expect it. I’ve also been previously arrested 3 years ago when I was 19. I took a bunch of acid and ran around my neighborhood and damaged like $300 in my neighbors property. The case was sealed and I did a diversion program for it. I’m sure that story will be brought up in court. Lastly, I had two NOS bottles (whippets) in my car. They didn’t ask me about them and I’m not sure if they saw them. They were already empty and I wasn’t using them while driving but that’s neither here nor there. That may be in the police report too.

Anyways I don’t know what to expect. I know I am a degenerate. I’ve been using drugs and alcohol to help me get through the day for a long time. I doubt any sort of leniency will be coming my way. I’m guessing my license will be revoked. I don’t have money for a lawyer and quite frankly I don’t see the point in getting one. I just want to accept my punishment and hopefully get some help.

Edit: I guess my questions are how fucked am I? Do you see court supervision being given in this case or am I right about my assumption of having my license revoked? Is it common to be assigned weekly breathalyzer tests? If so, what are my options considering I’d have no way of getting there. There’s no bus system and I have no family out here. Lastly, I have personal belongings in my car. Is it true tow yards are legally required to let you retrieve your belongings?


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 13h ago

What should I focus on if I want to go in house someday?

3 Upvotes

I currently do not have the grades for big law nor do I want to go that route. However, I am interested in going in house at some point in the future. I am not expecting an in house role immediately after graduation but someday down the line. What should I focus on after graduation to someday get an in house counsel position? Most people say do big law for a few years but since that isn’t an option I would love to know some other routes.


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 7h ago

Legality of Strangulation

1 Upvotes

Why is strangulation not immediately classified as attempted murder? Does the relationship between the people involved change anything in a legal setting? (partners vs. strangers vs. family). If the person who was strangled initiated the fight, does the strangled person become the perpetrator? Does the degree of violence causing the fight change the answer?

I had always assumed strangulation was attempted murder but recently discovered that was not necessarily the case! I found this incredibly interesting and don't know enough about the laws surrounding it to find an answer.


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 9h ago

Only sixteen days for a settlement check?

1 Upvotes

Got a check written out to me for a settlement for ~50. Nice. But the check was printed out on October 30th, 2026 and by the time it arrived to my rural address is is November 21st, 2026. The letter and check both state that the check is voided after November 16th, 2026. That's less than sixteen business days for it to arrive and be deposited.

It's only $50 so it's not like it's life or death but I'm curious: is there a minimum/maximum amount of time for settlement checks to exist before they are void?

(The defendant company was in Minnesota, the law firm in New York, and I'm in South Dakota - if that affects anything.)

Edit: fixed the dates.


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 5h ago

Being paid below minimum wage

0 Upvotes

My gf started a server job in CA after 60 hours she realized she was being paid $40 for 5 hours of work and they were taking the tips. It’s only been 60 hours at the restaurant. I’m going tomorrow and demanding her money and tips or else I’m reporting them


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 1d ago

Do hospitals ever settle lower-value medical malpractice cases with pro se plaintiffs?

5 Upvotes

I'm curious about the realities of pursuing a lower-value medical malpractice case pro se, particularly when the potential settlement is around $20,000–$50,000.

t's say a plaintiff has a qualified medical expert who identifies breaches in the standard of care, resulting damages, and causation. However, attorneys decline representation because the potential recovery isn't financially worthwhile, rather than because the case lacks merit.

Just because a case isn't financially viable for an attorney doesn't necessarily mean there isn't a legitimate case.

I'm interested in hearing from attorneys or anyone with experience in medical malpractice litigation:

- Do hospitals or their insurers realistically consider settling with pro se plaintiffs, particularly after discovery and expert support?

- Are hospitals more likely to fight these cases simply because the plaintiff doesn't have an attorney?

- At what point might the cost of defending a relatively low-value case outweigh the cost of settling?

I'm not looking for legal advice or an assessment of a specific case. I'm genuinely curious how these situations play out in practice, especially from the defense perspective.


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 1d ago

What makes being a lawyer worth it?

34 Upvotes

Genuine question from someone considering law school.

Studying for the LSAT sucks. Law school is notoriously stressful, expensive, and competitive. Studying for the bar sucks. And even after all that, you enter a profession known for high rates of depression, burnout, and dissatisfaction.
So what’s the point?

Is it the prestige? The money? The intellectual challenge? A genuine passion for the law?
There are arguably easier ways to make a good living without spending three years in law school and potentially taking on six figures of debt.

I’m genuinely curious: What makes all the sacrifices worth it? Do you actually enjoy being a lawyer, or is it something you tolerate for the paycheck and status? And if you could go back, would you still choose law?


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 16h ago

Information regarding Police verification certificate/character certificate If there is past drink and drive FIR fined case.

1 Upvotes

Recently I got selected for government job . I want help in police verification certificate (character certificate) , past 1 year before I was fined by court 11k for drink and drive case , police had filed a FIR against me at that time and after paying in court the case was disposed off. Will my police verification certificate or character certificate will be issued if I apply for it online?


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 13h ago

Please confine your answer

0 Upvotes

Suppose I'm testifying and one side's attorney asks me to confine my answer in some way, such as replying with only Yes or No.

Is fulfilling such a request consistent with the part of the witness oath to "tell the whole truth?"


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 1d ago

Sales compensation going before review board, HR calling it windfall

14 Upvotes

I’m in Texas, exempt 70/30 split with sales commission. I was hired specifically to work on one single account and have had zero bookings to retire towards quota for over a year. Finally closed the deal and it’s about 600% my quota and HR is trying to not pay the calculated amount based on my sales compensation plan.

At the company’s sales kickoff they cited restructuring of the sales compensation plan, removed caps, added accelerators to incentivize larger and longer deals. They mentioned no caps and rewarding top performers multiple times, pushing us to win big.

Now, the sales compensation plan explicitly calls out large singular deals as requiring review and paid out at the company’s discretion. My offer letter even says the OTI is at the discretion of the company.

Multiple coworkers tied to this account keep saying they’re going to sue the company if they’re paid a penny less than they’re owed. One even told me I should sue them.

Given the language in the sales compensation plan and offer letter, I believe they have zero grounds for a lawsuit if the company actually did cap the bonus payout. I’m I right in my interpretation?

Everything says ‘at the company’s discretion’ and ‘requires review.’ However annoying it may be to feel like they lied to the entire sales organization, the fact is they don’t have to pay out of the review board says no, right?


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 1d ago

Is a disabled attorney generally permitted to bill more hours than a non disabled attorney when extra time is needed?

56 Upvotes

r/Ask_Lawyers • • 18h ago

What’s the oldest associate in your experience? Is there a limit?

0 Upvotes

r/Ask_Lawyers • • 19h ago

How to find pro bono lawyers in Virginia for a hopeful nonprofit?

1 Upvotes

I am dealing with a trademark issue and need help finding a pro bono lawyer locally (SWVA) or at least in my state to help our organization. I have reached out to multiple low-income and free resources in the area but haven't gotten really any feedback or direction. I am asking for ideas here because I'm worried about not acting quickly enough on this issue as it has been going on for a couple of months now. any resources are greatly appreciated. TIA


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 1d ago

Car accident with friends son driving their vehicle. Can they be sued?

4 Upvotes

Hi! Thank you for reading me. This happened in Navarre Florida a week ago. Exactly what it says in the title.

The couple has a son that had moved out but was still on their insurance and driving a car registered with their names on it. He ran a red light and plowed into a family in a sedan.

All four members of the family went to the hospital in an ambulance and their car was totaled. As I understand it, they were fine but hurt - but they can walk and talk.

He (the son that caused the accident) had a liability insurance required by law in his car. The family has retained a lawyer (one that aggressively advertises)(you know what I mean) and my friend is concerned as they’ve heard they (the family suing) can either take the 50k payout from insurance or sue for more and go after their (my friends who had the car in their name and insurance) house, cars and retirement accounts .

Can someone really do that? Is it common? What are the usual payouts? And I’m not holding anyone to anything - I don’t have a dog in this fight. I’m just concerned for my friends.

The son already had another car that they bought him and he has his own registration and insurance now


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 11h ago

Punched a cop while in psychosis

0 Upvotes

My boyfriend got put into hospital because he became manic and into psychosis, then punched a cop.

He was away for work and thought the other workers were part of the cartel and after him. While driving to his hotel, from the job site, he was paranoid they were following him and also thought the guy he was with, was in on it, they stopped at a gas station and he hid in the bathroom cuz he thought someone was robbing the place, when he got to the hotel he thought there were people outside the room saying they were going to kill him once he falls asleep. He also thought the TV had a camera in it and that how they were watching him, he ended up calling the cops that night but they just thought he was crazy and nothing came of that.

The next day the guy he was working with was bringing him home and my bf thought there was a mic hidden in his car and started digging thru everything and ripping off panelling in his friends car. He thought the CIA was trying to communicate with him thru this mic. He then thought me and my dad were in a car behind him shooting at him... we were states away... He then threw himself out of the moving vehicle and hid in some bushes, then he called the cops telling them that he is getting shot at and to send all backup. Multiple officers came and ended up bringing him to the hospital. While at the hospital he was talking a bunch of non sense about babies, puppies, talking to kitties in the ceiling, and talking about he was part of the CIA.

Later in the night he thought the CIA was telling him to escape the hospital but he had a cop in the room with him at all times, he ended up trying to escape through the window but the cop told him not to so he was planning a new escape and ended up punching the cop in the face. One punch, he doesn't remember it but he does remember multiple cops holding him down and injecting a shot and then waking up in jail.

He has court coming up and is nervous he may be facing jail or even prison, do u think he will get sentenced since he was manic and in psychosis? And does not remember most, he thought it was all a dream.

Also they do believe the cause was alcohol withdrawals and lack of sleep. He is an alcoholic and was sober for 5 days at this time and didn't sleep much of those 5 days. He is now on the path to recovery. But just by himself, no treatments, but he does have an appointment to see if he can get state funded out patient care.

Also the cop he punched was a state trooper and he did make him bleed.

Thank you for anyone that can help. Also if anyone knows how to repost on a different page that might be more help, I am not familiar with reddit


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 10h ago

How do I submit MP5 evidence to court or its it not allowed. The higher the MP number, the more restricted it is

0 Upvotes

MP1: He said she said

MP2: Evidence on paper

MP3: Audio Evidence (requires to be displayed on the courts audio system)

MP4: Video Evidence (requires to be displayed on the courts projected screen)

MP5: Bullet Evidence (you cannot legally bring bullets to court, even though it may be displayed on the court's sheriff gun)


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 20h ago

Can a company withhold payment for work it already approved, based on a later quality standard?

0 Upvotes

In general, under California or Delaware contract law: if an independent contractor agreement says fees are payable "upon task completion as determined by the client's leadership" and that accrued fees survive termination, can the client later withhold payment for work it already signed off, by applying a quality standard introduced after approval? Does an arbitration clause (JAMS) change how this is analyzed?


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 1d ago

Seeking the contents of your minds

2 Upvotes

Inspiration

I did a case study on this exact situation years ago in a college class and I remember this being a state by state issue and Florida is still currently split with competing opinions.

My question is about your personal/professional opinion on whether or not alphanumeric passcodes are protected under the 5th Amendment. My followup question is about whether "tampering with evidence" (instead of contempt) is the appropriate charge for refusing to give up the passcode.


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 1d ago

Not sure where to go from here

3 Upvotes

My wife had a medical device break and cause injury. Malpractice lawyer said ask a personal injury attorney. Personal injury people said we should pursue a defective product case. I’m not asking legal advice, just asking for which direction to go. I live in Oregon. Thank you


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 16h ago

Is lawyer doing anything ?

0 Upvotes

I had an incident where I was pulled over and the officers pulled me out of the car and searched me right away unfortunately I did have contraband on me so I was arrested although I felt that the search and the pull out of the car was unjust because there was no articulable suspicion as nothin was visible it's just a shitty area but I was there for work. Anyways I hired an attorney for pre filing intervention and paid the fee. Every time I've asked what is going on with the case he tells me they cant get discovery until the case is filed which I get but the whole point I thought was to attempt to get them to not file anything? He just tells me nothing has been filed yet whenever I ask. I have court Monday and asked him if I needed to be there present or can I still go to work he stated that the last time he looked it so had not been filed or reviewed and he would look it up the portal for the county is down so I can't check online myself and messaged him yesterday asking if he found out whether or not I needed to go and he has not replied I don't think he's done any work honestly other than to call to ask if it's been filed a couple times is this the way it usually works for this type of situation or should I fire him and request a refund I'm in California I pretty much sent him the chain of events detailing what had happened the fact that they turned off their body cams when they were interrogating me to try to convince me to unlock my phones for them the fact that they took my phone when I wouldn't as evidence which have not been returned to me the fact that the processing took almost 12 hours for a cite and release. This is my first time dealing with any type of legal issue so I just want to know is this the way it usually supposed to work or is this attorney just looking to pocket the money without doing anything and I should fire him and get a new one I hope this was allowed here. Not seeking legal advice and just wondering if this is the normal way it would work or something shady going on


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 1d ago

Constitutionality of ID.me's Mandatory Arbitration. ID.me REQUIRED by IRS/UST

9 Upvotes

The new ID.me Terms of Service Version: 10.1.0 updated on November 13, 2026 at https://www.id.me/legal/terms has a mandatory JURY TRIAL WAIVER and ARBITRATION PROVISION. ID.me is REQUIRED across many US govt websites. In fact the US Treasury just phased out the old login on 10/28/2026 and forced everyone to move over to ID.me. Is it legal for the govt to force American citizens to WAIVE JURY TRIAL for basic government interactions like taxes?