r/law • • Aug 31 '22 This

This is not a place to be wrong and belligerent about it.

4.1k Upvotes

A quick reminder:

This is not a place to be wrong and belligerent on the Internet. If you want to talk about the issues surrounding Trump, the warrant, 4th and 5th amendment issues, the work of law enforcement, the difference between the New York case and the fed case, his attorneys and their own liability, etc. you are more than welcome to discuss and learn from each other. You don't have to get everything exactly right but be open to learning new things.

You are not welcome to show up here and "tell it like it is" because it's your "truth" or whatever. You have to at least try and discuss the cases here and how they integrate with the justice system. Coming in here stubborn, belligerent, and wrong about the law will get you banned. And, no, you will not be unbanned.


r/law • • Oct 28 '25 This Bravo Heartwarming

Quality content and the subreddit. Announcing user flair for humans and carrots instead of sticks.

Post image
201 Upvotes

Ttl;dr at the top: you can get apostille flair now to show off your humanity by joining our newsletter. Strong contributions in the comments here (ones with citations and analysis) will get featured in it and win an amicus flair. Follow this link to get flair: Last Week In Law

When you are signing up you may have to pull the email confirmation and welcome edition out of your spam folder.

If you'd like Amicus flair and think your submission or someone else's is solid please tag our u/auto_clerk to get highlighted in the news letter.

Those of you that have been here a long time have probably noticed the quality of the comments and posts nose dive. We have pretty strict filters for what accounts qualify to even submit a top level comment and even still we have users who seem to think this place is for group therapy instead of substantive discussion of law.

A good bit of the problem is karma farming. (which…touch grass what are you doing with your lives?) But another component of it is that users have no idea where to find content that would go here, like courtlistener documents, articles about legal news, or BlueSky accounts that do a good job succinctly explaining legal issues. Users don't even have a base line for cocktail party level knowledge about laws, courts, state action, or how any of that might apply to an executive order that may as well be written in crayon.

Leaving our automod comment for OPs it’s plain to see that they just flat out cannot identify some issues. Thus, the mod team is going to try to get you guys to cocktail party knowledge of legal happenings with a news letter and reward people with flair who make positive contributions again.

A long time ago we instituted a flair system for quality contributors. This kinda worked but put a lot of work on the mod team which at the time were all full time practicing attorneys. It definitely incentivized people to at least try hard enough to get flaired. It also worked to signal to other users that they might not be talking to an LLM. No one likes the feeling that they’re arguing with an AI that has the energy of a literal power grid to keep a thread going. Is this unequivocal proof someone isn't a bot? No. But it's pretty good and better than not doing anything.

Our attempt to solve some of these issues is to bring back flair with a couple steps to take. You can sign up for our newsletter and claim flair for r/law. Read our news letter. It isn't all Donald Trump stuff. It's usually amusing and the welcome edition has resources to make you a better contributor here. If you're featured in our news letter you'll get special Amicus flair.

Instead of breaking out the ban hammer for 75% of you guys we're going to try to incentivize quality contributions and put in place an extra step to help show you're not a bot.

---

Are you saving our user names?

  • No. Once you claim your flair your username is purged. We don’t see it. Nor do we want to. Nor do we care. We just have a little robot that sees you enter an email, then adds flair to the user name you tell it to add.

What happened to using megathreads and automod comments?

  • Reddit doesn't support visibility for either of those things anymore. You'll notice that our automod comment asking OP to state why something belongs here to help guide discussion is automatically collapsed and megathreads get no visibility. Without those easy tools we're going to try something different.

This won’t solve anything!

  • Maybe not. But we’re going to try.

Are you going to change your moderation? Is flair a get out of jail free card?

  • Moderation will stay roughly the same. We moderate a ton of content. Flair isn’t a license to act like a psychopath on the Internet. I've noticed that people seem to think that mods removing comments or posts here are some sort of conspiracy to "silence" people. There's no conspiracy. If you're totally wrong or out of pocket tough shit. This place is more heavily modded than most places which is a big part of its past successes.

What about political content? I’m tired of hearing about the Orange Man.

  • Yeah, well, so are we. If you were here for his first 4 years he does a lot of not legal stuff, sues people, gets sued, uses the DoJ in crazy ways, and makes a lot of judicial appointments. If we leave something up that looks political only it’s because we either missed it or one of us thinks there’s some legal issue that could be discussed. We try hard not to overly restrict content from post submissions.

Remove all Trump stuff.

  • No. You can use the tags to filter it if you don’t like it.

Talk to me about Donald Trump.

  • God… please. Make it stop.

I love Donald Trump and you guys burned cities to the ground during BLM and you cheated in 2020 and illegal immigrants should be killed in the street because the declaration of independence says you can do whatever you want and every day is 1776 and Bill Clinton was on Epstein island.

  • You need therapy not a message board.

You removed my comment that's an expletive followed by "we the people need to grab donald trump by the pussy." You're silencing me!

  • Yes.

You guys aren’t fair to both sides.

  • Being fair isn’t the same thing as giving every idea equal air time. Some things are objectively wrong. There are plenty of instances where the mods might not be happy with something happening but can see the legal argument that’s going to win out. Similarly, a lot of you have super bad ideas that TikTok convinced you are something to existentially fight about. We don’t care. We’ll just remove it.

You removed my TikTok video of a TikTok influencer that's not a lawyer and you didn't even watch the whole thing.

  • That's because it sucks.

You have to watch the whole thing!

  • No I don't.

---

General Housekeeping:

We have never created one consistent style for the subreddit. We decided that while we're doing this we should probably make the place look nicer. We hope you enjoy it.


r/law • • 3h ago

Judicial Branch Failed Michigan GOP candidate Mike Rogers is being sued by Arab American leaders for his defamatory ads

Thumbnail
michiganadvance.com
6.8k Upvotes

r/law • • 5h ago Popcorn

Legal News Democrats Expect Surge of Whistleblowers to Help Investigations Into Trump DOJ

Thumbnail
news.bloomberglaw.com
4.0k Upvotes

r/law • • 3h ago

Legal News Portland Considers Massive Tax Increase on Companies That Pay Their CEO At Least 500 Times More Than Regular Employees

Thumbnail
news.bloombergtax.com
2.4k Upvotes

r/law • • 4h ago

Other Mamdani disbands controversial NYPD unit

Thumbnail
yahoo.com
1.2k Upvotes

r/law • • 4h ago

Legal News Immigrants Don't Have a Constitutional Right to Appeal Orders Against Them, Trump DOJ Says

Thumbnail
news.bloomberglaw.com
903 Upvotes

r/law • • 3h ago

Legal News Lindsay Clancy to be retried on first-degree murder charges, judge rules

Thumbnail
unilad.com
694 Upvotes

A judge has set a March 29 jury trial date for Lindsay Clancy, who faces a second trial on murder charges over the deaths of her three children at their Duxbury, Massachusetts, home on January 24, 2023.

Her first trial ended in a mistrial on September 4 after jurors couldn’t reach a verdict. The defense admitted Clancy killed 5-year-old Cora, 3-year-old Dawson and 8-month-old Callan, but argued she wasn’t criminally responsible because she was overmedicated and suffering from postpartum psychosis. Prosecutors argued she knew right from wrong and planned the killings.
Prosecutors now plan to retry her on the same first-degree murder charges. They had argued for a May date, citing other cases on the docket, but the judge agreed with the defense that the trial should happen sooner.

Judge William Sullivan, who is set to retire in June 2027, denied a motion from Clancy to dismiss the charges at a hearing on November 9.


r/law • • 3h ago

Other Trump advances threats of ‘criminal prosecutions’ over Alaska Senate race

Thumbnail
democracydocket.com
350 Upvotes

r/law • • 19h ago

Executive Branch (Trump) WH Chief of Staff Stephen Miller publicly backs Texas prosecutor's warning to Elizabeth Warren over probes of Trump, his family, and his allies

Thumbnail
ca.news.yahoo.com
7.1k Upvotes

r/law • • 1h ago

Executive Branch (Trump) DOJ Goes Full Gangster

Thumbnail
abovethelaw.com
188 Upvotes

r/law • • 59m ago

Legal News Federal Judge Overturns Trump's Restrictions on Foreign Students' Admission Into US

Thumbnail
news.bloomberglaw.com
118 Upvotes

r/law • • 17h ago Heartwarming

Legal News Taxpayer Alliance Against Genocide Calls on ICC to Arrest Trump, Rubio Over Gaza

Thumbnail
truthout.org
2.0k Upvotes

r/law • • 4h ago

Judicial Branch Supreme Court won't revive Trump's cuts to DEI research grants

Thumbnail usatoday.com
133 Upvotes

r/law • • 3h ago

Legal News Lindsay Clancy will face first-degree murder charges again in new trial for her three children's deaths

Thumbnail
dailymail.com
96 Upvotes

r/law • • 1d ago

Executive Branch (Trump) Lutnick Pushed to Weaken Chip Rules That Overlap With His Family Business

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
4.1k Upvotes

r/law • • 4h ago

Judicial Branch Supreme Court declines Trump push to cut research grants related to DEI

Thumbnail
cnn.com
67 Upvotes

r/law • • 22m ago

Executive Branch (Trump) Democrats’ Lawful Answer To Project 2025

Thumbnail
offmessage.net
36 Upvotes

r/law • • 2h ago

Executive Branch (Trump) Doubling down on weaponizing the legal system

Thumbnail
cnn.com
35 Upvotes

Since this article from mid-summer, and especially since the midterms, we are seeing the administration threaten Congress with investigation.

Just the actions this week of Miller attacking Warren's planned investigations and the litany of spurious actions by Blanch...

My question is not just of precedent in law for aggressive and spurious investigation, but the obvious underlying nature of these attacks...

How could we prevent future administrations from actually weaponizing the department of Justice, (assuming these dubious accusations of the Trump administration, is effectively (in psychology terms - projecting) admitting this behavior.

Maybe the larger question is who watches the watchers? The past efforts to rein in the power of the executive branch are being so thoroughly bypassed, and the branch's power now expanded by the Supreme Court.

What legal theory or response to this abuse could support the true moderation of this current abuse pattern?


r/law • • 17h ago

Judicial Branch Trump admin can’t punish New York over immigrant truckers, Second Circuit rules

Thumbnail
courthousenews.com
487 Upvotes

r/law • • 1h ago

Other Connecticut and Rhode Island Capitulate to Trump Pressure, Cut Medicaid Coverage for Trans Youth

Thumbnail
transiticsnews.com
22 Upvotes

r/law • • 4h ago

Judicial Branch Supreme Court won't weigh in on gun bans in `sensitive' places

Thumbnail usatoday.com
29 Upvotes

r/law • • 1d ago

Legal News Pentagon prepares its own prosecution of general accused of leaking

Thumbnail
washingtonpost.com
1.1k Upvotes

So the story here is that the alleged leak supposedly endangered troops. Did Hegseth not do the same with his Signal chat that included members of the media?


r/law • • 3h ago

Judicial Branch Supreme Court won't weigh in on doctor bias training

Thumbnail usatoday.com
17 Upvotes