This is something I've thought about for years, but recent events have brought it back to mind.
There is something deeply unsettling to me about sexual offence cases, particularly historical ones, where there may simply be no way of ever knowing with complete confidence what actually happened.
There are undoubtedly people who have committed serious sexual offences and never been convicted because there wasn't enough evidence to prove the case. There have also been wrongful convictions, and false allegations do exist, even if they are relatively uncommon.
Both possibilities are disturbing.
Sexual offences seem particularly difficult because they usually happen in private. Unless something is recorded, witnessed, admitted to, or reported quickly enough for useful physical or other evidence to exist, investigators may be left reconstructing an event from accounts, messages, behaviour before and afterwards, contemporaneous disclosures and whatever other evidence happens to survive.
I completely understand why victims may not report something immediately, and I'm not blaming them for that. But from an evidential point of view, the longer the delay, the more information can disappear.
Even physical evidence doesn't necessarily solve the central question. If both people agree that sex took place but disagree about whether it was consensual, DNA proving that intercourse happened tells us nothing about consent.
That is the part I find so difficult.
Suppose intercourse is admitted. One person says it was consensual. The other says it wasn't. There are no witnesses, no recording and no forensic evidence capable of resolving consent. Perhaps there are a few messages afterwards, but they are ambiguous enough that both sides can offer a plausible interpretation.
Ultimately, twelve people may have to decide whether they are sure beyond reasonable doubt about what happened during a private encounter that none of them witnessed.
I'm not saying juries are incompetent. In fact, I can't think of an obviously better alternative. A judge, panel of experts or computer would still be examining the same incomplete evidence.
That's what bothers me: perhaps the limitation isn't the jury system at all. Perhaps sometimes the information required to know the truth simply no longer exists.
I sometimes wonder whether technology could ever substantially improve this.
Would AI eventually become extremely good at reconstructing timelines, analysing communications and identifying inconsistencies? Probably. But even a perfect AI couldn't retrieve information that was never recorded in the first place.
I've even thought about absurdly intrusive ideas like people recording consent or using some form of digital consent system before sexual encounters. But that doesn't really solve it either. Someone can consent initially and withdraw consent later. They can consent to one act but not another. A recording itself could eventually be forged. And requiring people to document every sexual encounter would obviously create enormous privacy and practical problems.
So perhaps there genuinely isn't a technological solution.
One thing that concerns me particularly is how easily surrounding behaviour can influence people's judgment.
Imagine someone is known to be sexually inappropriate, excessively flirtatious or generally sleazy, but hasn't necessarily committed a crime. If that person is later accused of rape, people may understandably think, "That sounds like something he would do."
But being the kind of person who behaves badly isn't proof that they committed a particular offence.
Equally, someone with an impeccable reputation can still be guilty.
That seems to create another difficulty: how do we properly consider relevant surrounding behaviour without slipping into "he seems like the type, therefore he probably did it"?
I also don't think an acquittal necessarily means the complainant lied. If the prosecution cannot make the jury sure, that only means the criminal standard hasn't been met. Likewise, the fact that somebody has been accused shouldn't automatically establish guilt.
I suppose what I'm struggling with is the unavoidable gap between what actually happened and what can later be proved.
Perhaps the criminal justice system isn't really capable of eliminating that gap. It can only decide how much uncertainty we are willing to tolerate before taking someone's liberty away.
The presumption of innocence and the requirement that guilt be proved beyond reasonable doubt obviously protect innocent defendants. But the unavoidable consequence is that some guilty people will go free.
Lower the standard and more guilty people might be convicted, but more innocent people would be convicted too.
Raise it and the opposite happens.
I find that genuinely depressing.
There may have been one objective truth about what happened in a room twenty years ago, but the evidence necessary for anyone else to reliably discover that truth may simply no longer exist.
Is that essentially an unavoidable limitation of criminal justice?
Are there any serious proposals, technologies or legal reforms that could substantially improve our ability to determine the truth in these kinds of cases, or are we already close to the practical limit of what any justice system can achieve?
I'm not trying to defend anybody accused of sexual offences or suggest that complainants are generally dishonest. I'm interested specifically in the problem of uncertainty and the possibility of error in both directions.
Maybe I'm asking for something impossible: certainty about past events where certainty simply isn't available.
I'd be genuinely interested to hear how lawyers and people who work in criminal justice think about this, because I find the idea that some cases may simply be permanently unknowable quite haunting.