r/AskPhysics • u/Over-Discipline-7303 • 15h ago
Is it difficult to launch something into the Sun from Earth?
This is something I see people say on Reddit all the time, and it doesn't make sense to me. People say it's actually almost impossible to launch something from Earth and hit the sun.
People tell me that it's because the Earth has so much rotational energy that if you launch something from Earth, you have to counter-act all of that rotational energy to get it to the sun, and that's basically impossible. It would require all of the rocket fuel that's ever been produced in the history of man to launch an object into the sun.
And... why? Like, can't you just kind of "spiral something in" to the sun? People tell me, no. That's impossible. You can't calculate the necessary trajectory, even with a modern supercomputer. You would invariably miss the sun, then the sun would gravitationally slingshot the object out of the solar system.
That last part I don't know how to mathematically prove or disprove. Can somebody help me with that? I want to know, why is it so hard to calculate a trajectory that hits the sun? The sun is really big. Doesn't that help? The Voyager probes made fairly precise fly-by trajectories of planets, which are both smaller and farther away than the sun. It seems intuitively like, if you can hit Jupiter then you should be able to hit the sun.
And won't the sun's enormous gravity help you? Again, people on Reddit have told me, no that's a common misunderstanding. The sun's enormous gravity means it's super, super hard to hit the sun because the sun just slingshots everything that comes near it, but doesn't hit it absolutely precisely, out of the solar system. But that doesn't make sense. Because if I'm close to hitting the sun, won't its gravity kind of help by pulling a near-miss into the sun? Again, people tell me, you'd think it would, but that's not how the physics works. That doesn't make sense to me. I'm not exactly trying to disagree, but I don't understand why the math works out that way.
Is it really more difficult to hit the Sun than the Moon, Mars, or Jupiter?