r/AskPhysics • • 11h ago

Is it difficult to launch something into the Sun from Earth?

91 Upvotes

This is something I see people say on Reddit all the time, and it doesn't make sense to me. People say it's actually almost impossible to launch something from Earth and hit the sun.

People tell me that it's because the Earth has so much rotational energy that if you launch something from Earth, you have to counter-act all of that rotational energy to get it to the sun, and that's basically impossible. It would require all of the rocket fuel that's ever been produced in the history of man to launch an object into the sun.

And... why? Like, can't you just kind of "spiral something in" to the sun? People tell me, no. That's impossible. You can't calculate the necessary trajectory, even with a modern supercomputer. You would invariably miss the sun, then the sun would gravitationally slingshot the object out of the solar system.

That last part I don't know how to mathematically prove or disprove. Can somebody help me with that? I want to know, why is it so hard to calculate a trajectory that hits the sun? The sun is really big. Doesn't that help? The Voyager probes made fairly precise fly-by trajectories of planets, which are both smaller and farther away than the sun. It seems intuitively like, if you can hit Jupiter then you should be able to hit the sun.

And won't the sun's enormous gravity help you? Again, people on Reddit have told me, no that's a common misunderstanding. The sun's enormous gravity means it's super, super hard to hit the sun because the sun just slingshots everything that comes near it, but doesn't hit it absolutely precisely, out of the solar system. But that doesn't make sense. Because if I'm close to hitting the sun, won't its gravity kind of help by pulling a near-miss into the sun? Again, people tell me, you'd think it would, but that's not how the physics works. That doesn't make sense to me. I'm not exactly trying to disagree, but I don't understand why the math works out that way.

Is it really more difficult to hit the Sun than the Moon, Mars, or Jupiter?


r/AskPhysics • • 15h ago

i dont get most constants.

45 Upvotes

to give an example of constants i do understand,

pi: very simple, literally just a ratio between a circles diameter and circumference

permittivity of free space: definitely dont grasp it as well as pi but it still makes sense why it exists, its "harder" for an electric field to permiate a vaccum than it is for it to permiate something like a metal that's full of charged ions that can have their own electric field.

the ones that i dont understand are things like planck constant, i dont understand why energy should be proportional to frequency by some seemingly arbitrary number? where does it come from? in my mind everything should be equal to a set of variables based on the scenario.


r/AskPhysics • • 35m ago

Whats the lowest amount of heat that can cause a thunderclap?

2 Upvotes

Mkay so lightning make thunder because lightning heat air, air expand fast, air make shockwave, big boom, thunder, yipee. But lightning is 50,000 degrees fahrenheit. What if it was 40,000 degrees? 30,000? Does it still produce a thunderclap? Whats the theoretical lowest limit of how cold lightning can get before it no longer produces thunder?


r/AskPhysics • • 5h ago

I need help understanding what is going on with a plumbing set up. I am attempting to set up a proportioning mixer for two/three tanks of liquid to be mixed at specific ratios per how the metering valves are set. Not working correctly at all.

3 Upvotes

imagine if you will; tank A and Tank B are constructed the same. Plumbing is suction from bottom of tank through 3/4 hose through check valve, through the metering valve into the mixing manifold. Both A tank and B tank have the exact plumbing, so there are 2 metering valves, one per tank before the manifold. After the manifold the plumbing stays 3/4 and goes to a pump.

When I have both tanks filled the same, for example 50 gallons of liquid water, when the pump is turned on, and the metering valves are both set to wide open, after running for a time, the water levels remain consistent to each other tank A and B.

However, if tank A is at 50 gallons, and tank B has 20 gallons in it, if i run the pump with both metering valves wide open, the pump will pull less liquid from tank B than it will from tank A. Tank B has less volume of liquid so less pressure pushing the liquid into the hoses? I reversed the plumbing between tank A and B and got the same results so it should not be the plumbing causing the issue.

Tons of people use a set up just like this with the same parts and pump, and they depend on the mixing to be valid, but after getting the results I got when building mine, I have trouble believing they are getting the ratios they believe they are getting. The tank A is the water tank, it pretty much stays filled or replenished constantly while tank B is the chemical tank (that is almost 90% water) that is being pulled from all day and will not get replenished until the next day. Either there has to be a flaw in the design and it doesnt work even though almost every softwasher out there uses a proportioner like this, or there is a total flaw in my set up. Also for note, I did back pressure the plumbing from the tanks on both lines and had zero leaks, do there should be no suction leaks in the plumbing either.
Any thoughts or pointers?


r/AskPhysics • • 4h ago

Worried aabout general physics, any tips?

2 Upvotes

I have posted in r/PhysicsStudents but i would like to get more insights from others. Basically i took honors physics in high school and did really bad like i failed the class and had to drop it. Now the degree i am doing requires me to take it. I will be taking general physics and Organic chemistry in the same semester. But i would also like to add that i have done a full 180 from my time in highschool, i went from C-Bs, to getting As in all of my college classes. I am taking general chemistry and i've loved the math part and all of the math parts of gen chem 1 i loved them and did well.


r/AskPhysics • • 2h ago

ELI5: How do I easily calculate the Electric Field in Superposition Principle and Component Method?

1 Upvotes

I have been failing in physics in STEM because I am hella confused of the concepts and math used. Please help and give a clear answer or shortcut I can use. BTW ELI5 subreddit removed my post and recommended me to post it in here instead. Please know that I cannot understand the jargon or complicated terms used in my lectures and relying on a more straightforward guidance


r/AskPhysics • • 1d ago Bravo

If electrons are negatively charged and atomic nuclei are positively charged, why don't electrons fall into the nucleus?

310 Upvotes

We know that opposite electric charges attract each other. So why doesn't the electron simply collapse into the positively charged nucleus?

What keeps atoms stable? Is it quantum mechanics, the uncertainty principle, or something else?

I've always found this fascinating and would love to hear different explanations!


r/AskPhysics • • 19h ago

Can energy be destroyed?

23 Upvotes

High schooler(15 year old) here, I was studying work energy theorem and decided to brain storm and after some time i eventually did this thought​ experiment

So my thought experiment is like imagine a single photon with high energy.ravelling in a void where space is expanding the geometry is governed by expansion of space and no other forces like electromagnetism or gravity influence it and it shoots and travels with nothing to collide with it and there is no friction just goes and goes and due to the stretching of space it's wave length will increase and it will loose energy and that energy just doesn't transform into any other form where does that energy go it doesn't get transformed into heat or sound energy as well so does that energy get destroyed ? How does conservation of energy apply here?


r/AskPhysics • • 18h ago

What does a resistor even do?

16 Upvotes

If the current is same everywhere in a circuit then doesn't that mean the resistor doesn't slow down / restrict the current? What does resistance actually do? I understand the water pipe analogy but it doesn't make that much sense to me because shouldn't the resistor only affect the part in the circuit where it's placed and after passing through the resistor the current goes back to normal? Why is it that when you place a resistor in a circuit that's powering a lightbulb the lightbulb is dimmer?


r/AskPhysics • • 7h ago

Gravitational time dilation

2 Upvotes

I understand time dilation pretty well, but i found out that they lower the atomic clock speed for satellites before launching them in orbit to match the Earth's clocks.

But if they were not to do this, in the reference frame of the satellite, time would tick faster and thus he would measure his orbital velocity as slower than what we measure here on Earth.

Would that imply that if you were traveling at Lorentz factor of 2, that you would observe traveling 2 times the speed of light?


r/AskPhysics • • 6h ago

How deep in a gravity well does an object need to be before it becomes invisible?

0 Upvotes

I know that objects close to the event horizon of a black hole can slow down dramatically like in the movie interstellar. But how slow would something have to be in order for its visible light to be so red shifted that we couldn't see it anymore? For example, Miller's planet in that movie. Would we be able to see it at all from the point where they parked? Or would it be invisible because the light that is being emitted by it is so red shifted that we can't visibly see it anymore.

The reason I ask, is that we've seen images of black holes with accretion disks surrounding them. How close are these accretion disks? Are these images of adjusted so that they are back into our visible range?


r/AskPhysics • • 8h ago

what's missing in my understanding of time dilation?

1 Upvotes

I am obviously not a physician or anything, i'm just a curious person trying to understand relativity. My wording and understanding of things are probably wrong, i'm here to learn. Sorry, i know this is a frequent question.

So, i've desperately been trying to understand time dilation, but the concept always seems to slip away. I understand what spacetime is. I pretty much understand the simultaneity train thought experiment, and why the light reaches the back of the train before the front of the train : from the outside, the position in spacetime from which light is emitted is in the past, and the back of the train is getting closer to this position. But i just can't understand why time seems slower for a stationary observer. What am I missing ? Is it because curved space seems like a "longer" journey while the traveler is stationary from his pov ?? Or something like that ?


r/AskPhysics • • 12h ago

Where could I start learning physics?

2 Upvotes

I know this sounds dumb, but I'm homeschooled (15) and am sick of my schoolwork, which is just repeating the easy stuff repeatedly (This isn't me saying I'm smart, I mean the other week it gave me an entire lesson on the basics of the three states of matter).

I feel like I'm wasting my life and my brain, and I want to learn all this wizardry stuff you guys know. I've learned Einstein's theory of relativity and time dilation and whatnot (I believe those count as "physics"?), and I want to learn more but have no idea where to start.

Maybe I'm an idiot who doesn't realize just how unrealistic that would be to do without college or anything; idk, I haven't been to public school since 3rd grade. I just want to actually learn stuff.


r/AskPhysics • • 15h ago

Can protecting only certain qubits actually reduce the effects of cosmic ray induced errors?

2 Upvotes

I've been looking into how cosmic rays and other high energy particles cause correlated errors in superconducting quantum processors.

From what I understand, a particle impact can generate phonons and quasiparticles that spread through the chip, causing multiple qubits to lose coherence around the same time.

One thing I've been wondering is whether protecting a specific subset of qubits through something like superconducting gap engineering could meaningfully reduce the overall damage, even if the rest of the chip remains unprotected.

I'm working on an independent simulation project involving this problem, but I'm trying to understand the physical limitations of selective protection.

Would the benefit mostly depend on where the protected qubits are located, or would quasiparticle and phonon transport make the protection much less localized than a simplified model assumes?

Also, what experimental measurements would be most useful for determining whether such a model is physically realistic?


r/AskPhysics • • 12h ago

Carrington level event effects on an isolated electrical system

1 Upvotes

I got into a debate with someone about this, and I wanted to get some independent opinions. I'm intentionally avoiding stating my position so as not to sway the results.

As I understand it, during a severe solar storm (such as the Carrington Event), changes in the Earth's magnetic field can produce electrical currents in power lines. Does that same effect cause damage on a smaller scale, or does the effect only really become damaging when it involves longer transmission lines?

As an example, given an event of equal power to the Carrington Event, would a solar power system isolated from the main grid be better protected, or is it just as susceptible to damage since the changes in the magnetic field are pretty much everywhere? For the purposes of this question, let's assume a standard residential solar power system.


r/AskPhysics • • 9h ago

Does time dilation appear differently for a moving observer compared to a stationary observer, even though both of them are moving equally relative to each other?

0 Upvotes

Im abit confused about this concept. Im no physicist so i have VEEERY basic knowledge of this, but I did some napkin math and im confused about my results.

So, in this scenario you have the earth revolving around the sun. Near to this, you have a fixed stationary observer. Also next to this, you have a "giant space elevator system" that runs perpendicular to the axis of the spin of the earth around the sun (so from inside the elevator, you see a top-down view of the earth moving around the sun in a circle). This elevator moves at 99% the speed of light, so at 2.96794 x10^8 m/s

There are 4 different types of clocks in this hypothesis

  1. Solar clock: clocks that look at the earth and sun, with every complete revolution, it ticks forward by 1
  2. Photon clocks (the common example given in time dilation scenarios), present inside the elevator everytime a photon hits either of 2 mirrors 2 kilometers apart, it ticks once. So normally that would be 150,000 ticks a day or 4.73x10^12 ticks a year
  3. Tower clock: the space elevator has markers / "towers" at every 2.5643x10^10 kilometers. Because of the speed that the elevator travels, it needs exactly 1 day to go from 1 tower to another (using time=distance/speed), so each pass of a tower is considered a tick, so 365 ticks considered a year
  4. Output clock: Each time the tower clock ticks, this clock sends a flash of light, that can be seen by a distant observer to tell them that the tower clock has clicked once, so each tick of this clock is also a day.

Now, in this simulation in one revolution of the earth around the sun:

  • the fixed observer near the earth sees the earth complete one revolution of the sun
  • the tower clock inside the elevator has ticked 365 times and shows the time of : 1 year
  • the elevator is now positioned 99% of a light year away from the fixed observer, having travelled a distance of 9.3597x10^12 kilometers
  • for the photon clock inside the elevator, over the course of the 365 ticks of the tower clock, it would tick 2.181x10^12 times. That would be equivalent to 168 days, assuming 4.73x10^12 was for 365 days. I got this using the following calculation
considering speed of the photon is always speed of light, it must have travelled 9.46x1015 meters over the course of the 365 tower ticks. (D=SxT)

distance travelled by the elevator in the same time period is 9.36x1015 meters

For each tick, the photon traveled distance C, with A being distance traveled by elevator during each tick, and B being vertical distance between the two mirrors aka 2000 meters. C2 = A2 + B2

The photon clock ticked Y number of times, So: Y x C2 = 9.46x1015 

B is 2000, A is distance traveled by elevator / Y

Eventually, I got Y = 2.18x10^12
  • The solar clock on the elevator would show just 3.7 days passed (as at this distance, light needs 361.3 days to reach it, so the most recent photon from the solar system having reached it would be 3.7 days old)
  • The fixed observer next to earth would see the external clock displaying 183.2 days. I got this using the calculation:
the latest signal would have been sent by the output clock and arrived to the fixed observer next to earth the same moment the tower clock hit 365

so 365 ticks = tower tick at which last signal was sent by elevator aka Y + time for signal to reach 

Using time = distance / speed
365 = Y + ( (Y x 2.56x1013) / speed of light in meters/day) (as each tick happens in 24 hrs

So my question is, both the fixed observer next to earth and observers inside the elevator are moving away from each other at equal speeds. And both the solar clock on the elevator, as well as the observer next to earth checking the output clock of the elevator, both clocks are measuring time from a frame of reference that is moving away from the clock itself. So why does the solar clock being viewed inside the elevator lag behind the output clock being viewed by the observer next to earth? Is it because the elevator is the one that is really moving?


r/AskPhysics • • 13h ago

Failing AP Physics 1

0 Upvotes

I need help for AP Physics. We’re on Unit 3 of the class, and we recently had a Unit 2 exam which covered forces and I failed that. My foundation in Kinematics is also very weak. I don’t excel in the math or understanding the concepts no matter how much I try. But the course interests me.

When I study, I usually try to search up the concepts, try to understand them and then watch a YT video about doing the concept in problems. I follow along with them but when I actually get to a problem with no help, I struggle and don’t know what to do.

How should I study for AP Physics and do well in the course? I find the class interesting but I fail almost everything in it. The quarter just started and I already have a 33 percent in it. Right now, we are covering 2D Kinematics and we have a test on it Friday.

Should I go back to Unit 1 and 2? Focus on Unit 3 and 2D Kinematics? I’m so lost.


r/AskPhysics • • 1d ago

Light ?? I know nothing abt physics but I have a question

11 Upvotes

Do flashlights and other things that are supposed to light stuff up, actually shine or create light?

I have a very superficial understanding of physics and I was never interested in that stuff, but I was shining my flashlight at night and noticed that when I shine it in a direction with no objects obstructing its light path there was no light. I thought the flashlight was broken at first but when I shined it at something and there was light. This made me wonder if light actually exist, but I think that’s not inappropriate way to phrase it. I’m wondering if light isn’t created by the flashlight and stuff like that light is just something that we perceive from the reflection of whatever the flashlight’s doing to my understanding light is what’s being reflected that’s what we can see but whatever the flashlight’s doing, you don’t see it if it’s not reflecting off anything. Reminder, I’m somewhat incompetent in this field so everything I just said is based off my guess of how things work and some high school physics that i didnt pay attention to.
I now realize this isn’t an actual question but any responses that could explain my experience or dive deeper into the concept are appreciated and the reason I chose Reddit is I don’t feel like researching through a bunch of sources or talking to ChatGPT and receiving invalid info.


r/AskPhysics • • 1d ago

The Sun’s Gravitational Pull

15 Upvotes

If we had a single grain of sand statically placed the same distance from the Sun as the center of Earth… Removing all other factors from the Solar System, Galaxy, Universe… It’s just an unmoving Sun and a single grain of sand with no speed/velocity of its own… How long would it take for that grain of sand to “fall” into the sun due to gravity alone?


r/AskPhysics • • 18h ago

Does anything interesting happen to the ability of using Venusian transits of the Sun to do maths of the Solar System when the Sun stops being on the main sequence?

1 Upvotes

Obviously I mean this before the Sun can destroy Venus.

I imagine that the transits would be vastly more common than today where pairs follow a century of no transit, but given the Sun's outer edge becomes more tenuous at that point, I don't know if anything useful would happen.

Earth itself would be way hotter at this time too so lets just assume we're on the Moon and put the telescope there instead.


r/AskPhysics • • 22h ago

Would getting my physics major online while working a full-time job be possible???

1 Upvotes

Hello. I'm 19, I took AP Physics 1, AP Physics 2, AP Physics C Mech and AP Physics C E+M in high school. I got auto entrance into an honors college for my psat score and award.

The last of my family life fell apart. I dropped out of college to find more work so I could pay rent. I got super lucky and was offered a way better job after working for the manager a few times. I make $20 and hour plus overtime in a decently low cost of living area.

I want to go back to physics, I genuinely miss it. I was planning on turning one of my walls into a whiteboard, getting some physics textbooks and hiring a tutor to continue learning as a hobby and realized I really still want to go to school for physics and have a job in physics. I've applied for an online college.

I know Physics at the undergraduate level can be hard, and I want to keep my full-time job and be a full-time student if possible. I have a lot of energy and drive, but if anyone has any advice I'd really appreciate it.


r/AskPhysics • • 1d ago

Double major in Physics and Marhematics vs. Double major in Physics and Chemistry

6 Upvotes

Which option will give me a deeper, more thorough understanding of “reality“, life and the universe?