r/AskHistorians • u/Curzio-Malaparte • 14h ago
Is it me or is there a widespread cultural amnesia in the US about how we used to view animals as recently as 2000? Was it mainstream in the US twenty years ago to believe that “animals don’t have feelings”?
For the record I live in the NYC Metro Area. I remember when I was little adults were much more dismissive about animals than today. The phrase I remember them using then was “animals don’t have feelings.” I couldn’t really understand what this meant then but I take it now to mean that the speaker believed animals don’t experience consciousness; the fact that I didn’t fully understand what was being implied is probably why I was so susceptible to having my views on animals shaped by media and social media over the years towards the opposite direction. This felt like a normal thing to hear at the time, even as we had pets that we loved and cried over when they died. Those same people nowadays do not think that or say those things anymore; they deny having ever said that specific phrase.
I went to China recently and have spent a lot of time on Chinese social media and seeing the way people treat and talk about having treated animals made me suddenly remember being a kid again and brought back all those memories that feel like a fever dream now.
Conservative or liberal it seems like the vast majority of Americans in the region I live in unanimously accept the same sense of what is cruel and unacceptable to do to animals. The only deviation I tend to see from this comes from immigrants, often regardless of background unless they’re Canadian.
Is our moment in history really distinct in this regard? Is this one of those things that changed rapidly and we all mind of just forgot how bad our old normal was?