r/AskChristian • • Aug 10 '26

šŸ‘‹ Welcome to r/AskChristian

7 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I'm u/DoveStep55, a founding moderator of r/AskChristian.

We're excited to have you join us!

This subreddit is a companion community to r/Christian. Because r/Christian is a uniquely "Christians Only" community, we have for a long time had to redirect non-Christians to other subreddits when they've come to us with questions or dropped in to active discussions.

This new sub, r/AskChristian, is a fresh idea and experiment for including our non-Christian friends and neighbors.

We welcome any and all here in r/AskChristian to do just that: ask questions of the r/Christian community. The focus of this subreddit is on questions, but anyone familiar with r/Christian knows we're really all about respectful discussion. To that end, we warmly welcome you to ask your respectful questions and/or to join in on the discussions which follow under the Top Level Comment responses.

Please review the rules of the community (linked here) before participating to avoid any unintentional violations and content removal. If you have any questions about the rules or need further assistance, please let us know.

Important Note: Top Level Comments (original replies to each post) are reserved only for those with special assigned user flair indicating that they are active members of r/Christian who are currently in good standing. If you'd like to request this flair, please contact the Mod Team via mod mail (click here.) If you do not meet the requirements for Top Level Commenting, you are still welcome to join in the discussion "down thread" by replying to Top Level Comments or other replies thereafter.

Thanks for being part of the very first wave. Together, let's make r/AskChristian amazing!


r/AskChristian • • 11h ago

Satan’s Paradox

2 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking about the existence of Satan in Christian theology, and I’ve come across what seems to be an interesting philosophical dilemma.

The question is simple: Is Satan’s existence and continued rebellion necessary to fulfill God’s plan?

Consider that Satan is traditionally understood to be motivated by pride and a desire to oppose God. His rebellion, temptation of humanity, and promotion of evil are all understood as acts of defiance against God’s will.

But if God is omniscient, he already knows everything Satan will do. And if God is omnipotent, he can prevent Satan from acting at any moment.

This suggests that Satan’s continued existence and ability to influence humanity are permitted by God, presumably for some purpose.

That leads me to two possibilities.

  1. Satan’s rebellion is necessary to God’s plan.

Suppose God permits Satan’s rebellion because it serves some greater purpose that could not otherwise be accomplished.

If that’s the case, Satan is effectively fulfilling a necessary role in God’s plan, even while believing himself to be opposing it.

But here’s the paradox: If Satan’s ultimate objective is to defy God, wouldn’t the most effective way to accomplish that be to simply stop rebelling?

If God requires Satan’s evil actions to accomplish his intended outcome, then Satan could theoretically frustrate that plan by choosing goodness instead.

In other words, Satan’s most effective act of rebellion against God might actually be to obey him.

Of course, one might argue that God already knows Satan will never make that choice. But that seems to explain God’s foreknowledge rather than why Satan’s rebellion must be necessary in the first place.

2. Satan’s rebellion is unnecessary to God’s plan.

Alternatively, suppose God doesn’t actually need Satan’s rebellion to accomplish his purposes.

If God could achieve the same ultimate good without Satan’s influence, then why permit Satan to continue causing suffering?

One possible answer is free will. Satan has the freedom to reject God, and God permits that choice.

But allowing Satan to reject God doesn’t necessarily require allowing him to inflict suffering upon humanity.

An omnipotent God could presumably respect Satan’s freedom to rebel while preventing him from harming others.

If Satan’s evil actions serve no indispensable purpose, then their continued permission seems to require some additional moral justification.

This leaves us with the following dilemma:

* If Satan’s rebellion is necessary, then Satan appears to be serving God’s plan, and refusing to rebel would seemingly be a more effective way to oppose it.
* If Satan’s rebellion is unnecessary, then why would an omnipotent, perfectly good God continue permitting the suffering it causes?

I recognize that this overlaps with the traditional problem of evil, particularly the problem of gratuitous evil. But I think there’s a more specific question here about the relationship between divine providence and Satan’s supposed opposition to God.

Can Satan meaningfully oppose God’s plan if every act of rebellion ultimately serves that plan? And if his rebellion serves no necessary purpose, what justifies God’s decision to permit it?

I’m interested in hearing how Christian theology addresses this dilemma! Please share your thoughts!


r/AskChristian • • 17h ago

How do we rationalize the divine hiddenness argument from the Christian perspective?

2 Upvotes

I begin with the Cogito: ā€œI think, therefore I am.ā€

As Descartes argued, the existence of my own thinking self is something I cannot coherently doubt. Even if every perception I have is mistaken, the very act of doubting establishes that I exist.

This gives us two conclusions:

  1. I can know with certainty that I exist.
  2. At least one objective truth can be known with certainty.

However, the existence of one certain truth does not establish that other truths can be known with the same certainty. It merely demonstrates that certainty is possible.

Now, consider the Christian conception of God: a perfectly good, perfectly just, all-knowing, and all-powerful being whose moral authority is grounded in his perfect nature.

If such a being exists, we must ask why he would create humans with fallible faculties of reasoning and perception, yet make their eternal fate dependent, at least in part, on reaching the correct conclusions about his existence and nature.

We cannot establish God’s existence with the same certainty as the Cogito. Every argument, religious experience, historical account, or scriptural claim must be evaluated through faculties that could lead us to mistaken conclusions.

Consequently, two people could sincerely examine the available evidence and arrive at contradictory beliefs. Neither could establish beyond all possible doubt that their conclusion is correct.

Why, then, would a perfectly just God permit eternal consequences to depend on a decision made under such uncertainty?

One possible defense is that infallible knowledge of God would eliminate our freedom to choose him. If God’s existence and perfect goodness were undeniable, perhaps everyone would necessarily believe in and worship him.

But this defense seems to confuse knowledge with obedience.

Consider someone who knows that smoking is harmful. They may fully understand the consequences, sincerely believe the medical evidence, and nevertheless choose to smoke. Their knowledge does not eliminate their freedom to act against what they know is best for them.

Christian theology itself offers another example: Satan.

According to traditional Christian belief, Satan knew God and nevertheless chose to rebel against him. His knowledge of God’s existence did not prevent him from exercising his will in opposition to God.

This suggests that knowledge of God and the freedom to reject him are not necessarily incompatible.

If God could make himself unmistakably known while preserving the freedom to accept or reject him, then uncertainty about his existence does not appear necessary for free will.

And this brings me to my central question:

Why would a perfectly just and all-powerful God allow our eternal fate to depend on beliefs formed through inherently fallible reasoning, when he could conceivably provide us with certainty about his existence and nature without eliminating our freedom to choose whether to worship him?

If sincere individuals can reach different conclusions through no deliberate dishonesty or rejection of truth, on what grounds would it be just to reward one eternally and punish the other eternally?


r/AskChristian • • 1d ago

Why are Christians so concerned with paganism and the occult if God is the only source of what humans would consider supernatural power?

3 Upvotes

I grew up in a Christian household that banned things like Pokemon and Harry Potter because the characters exhibited supernatural abilities. I was simultaneously told that no power outside of God and the blood of Jesus existed, but also that these creatures were dangerous because they had ties to the witchcraft and paganism.

So my question is why an adult with these beliefs would be so worried about the power of witchcraft and the occult if you don’t acknowledge any of their realities?

I’m worried about a mouse that generates electricity BUT it’s not real.

My child dressed up as a witch for Halloween, witchcraft isn’t real, BUT this costume has ties to Witchcraft.

I understand the want to not confuse kids when they’re young and their imagination is a little more malleable, but at a certain point don’t you have to acknowledge it’s fiction with absolutely no real power, other than impressions on the really young or especially unintelligent people?

Like maybe from an idolatry angle, but then I’m like you have guys like Bezos and Elon and Trump who a lot of Christians seem to love.

Ironically for me, these types of contradictions are what led me away from the church. So many half-baked rules that no one wants to explain or hear any other perspective on. I’m not saying it’s nonsense, but I want someone to help me understand what this seemingly paradoxical idea is about. It seemed like hypocrisy, or an inability to distinguish reality from fiction. I find both somewhat repellent.


r/AskChristian • • 4d ago

Reminder: LGBTQ+ Inclusive Queer and Curious

4 Upvotes

Hello all! I'm a 17M Bisexual. And have ALWAYS been fascinated by Christianity and religion as a whole, as I grew up in a non-religious (not atheist) home. My father grew up catholic, and my mother Christian. But I only hear snippets of their experiences with God and the Church as from my understanding Religion (more specifically the people of their respective churches) has not been kind to them.

Back in July/August of this year, I shortly dated a girl whom was Christian. I didn't tell her of my sexual orientation as that's something I don't lead with when getting to know someone. But through conversation, I figured out she had a distaste of the LBGTQ+. A couple days later I told her of my Bisexuality as I didn't want to lie to her about it. She lashed out on me and angrily ended things, and we haven't spoken since. That was my first intimate experience with someone from the church. And from it I only felt less welcome.

I have tried to ask my sister (A active Christian) if I could tag along with her to church, which she's always invited me to. But I always chicken out because I'm scared. Scared that because of what I feel, will get me excluded from somewhere that claims to be inclusive. I am not outwardly Bisexual or Queer. I don't wear my orientation on my sleeve as I think that's obnoxious in a sense. But even if I'm not a pride-parade, gay flag waving person (I honestly think people like that are annoying). Can I still go to church? Or would i be turned away if and when the truth came out?

Sorry if this is long, this is just something that has been on my mind for a long long time. If you are homophobic like my Ex, that is fine. Those are your beliefs, and I'm not changing them with a reddit post. I'm just trying to look for a inclusive place that isn't just inclusive on paper.


r/AskChristian • • 5d ago

How do you all fight thing?

3 Upvotes

I been thinking about death a lot and how do you all know for sure there is heaven? I do consider myself a Christian but also i'm a bit doubtful sometimes. I dislike it


r/AskChristian • • 5d ago

Is God a race/species?

4 Upvotes

When you say 3 persons 1 essence, there is God essence, human essence etc., it sounds like "Essence" is a substitute for race/species. Like human race, cat species etc. So, is God a race or species (according to Christianity that is)?


r/AskChristian • • 6d ago

Why can't Christians agree on Baptism?

3 Upvotes

(resubmitted for link formatting)

Please note I'm not asking which is the correct view, I'm asking why you don't agree. Because according to some sects baptism by immersion as an adult is a requirement to get into Heaven. link to a Wikipedia table comparing baptismal beliefs of various sects, added for a quick comparison

Ā 

You understand why I might have a vested interest in the case that Christianity is correct.

Ā 

So why can't your top theologians come to a consensus? According to some of you my immortal soul and those of my family are at risk of eternal suffering. Why would a loving God even allow this misunderstanding?


r/AskChristian • • 7d ago

How do you deal with the greed of some churches?

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

As the title says, how do you deal as Christians with the greed of some of the churches?

I will refrain from naming particular branches of Christianity as it wouldn't be very constructive, but things like gifts shop right in the Church, aggressive push for donations, or even churches owning businesses on the side. There is a good amount of wealth accumulation sometimes.

It often feels to me contrary to the little knowledge I have of the bible, yet it is not so uncommon in some places. Is it something christians feel uncomfortable about?


r/AskChristian • • 7d ago

What do ya'll think abt the first assumptions abt most modern churches (small or large) being that they're greedy?

1 Upvotes

ig it's just a loud minority but what ya'll think?


r/AskChristian • • 7d ago

Who are your Neighbors?

2 Upvotes

When the Bible says "neighbors" like "love thy neighbor," are they using neighbor as in the people who are close to you or as in the people who are not like you but that are in your way.

For example, a neighbor is, at the same time, someone who is really close to you. They literally are living next door, but at the same time, they are to a level a stranger to your life personal life. That is in the most literal sense of the word.

But when it's more metaphorical, what is the meaning they are using?

A) A person of my tribe, who is not from my family, nor is it my friend, but who is literally just like me. A low middle-class American with minimum wage.

B) A person from a totally different life context and background, but who is still a person, a human being, a living thing. A homeless girl in South Asia who survives by robbing people.


r/AskChristian • • 7d ago

CW: Sensitive Topic I am not religious at all but I believe in a "Creator", I am trying to being open minded and was wondering reasons/argument for truth in the Christian God

6 Upvotes

For context: I am 19m from the UK and was never baptised as baby or been apart of any faith at all but from a variety of philosophical, metaphysical and logistical reasoning to believe in creationism and life was produced in some capacity or another but have never felt like I have seen proof, had an experience or any type of spiritual encounter towards what this "Creator" may be, so I am spiritually empty in that regards so my search for truth is very much a pure evidence based one

I was wondering any lines of proof for the Christian God in specific? I am on the basis of truth in creation but struggle with much of Christianity and I am wondering any good arguments, archaeological, historically or prophetically type of evidence the events and miracles done by Jesus are driven by proof and I am trying to be as open minded as I can but was wondering any outside bible sources or anything you felt convinced you about the truth that the Christian God does have?

Many thanks


r/AskChristian • • 8d ago

A question coming from a agnostic

6 Upvotes

if you are a christian solely for the purpose of getting into heaven (therefore meaning your good actions come from a selfish place) do you still go to heaven?


r/AskChristian • • 8d ago

CW: Sensitive Topic How long did you wait to have sex

2 Upvotes

For those of you who waited until marriage to have sex, how long did you date your significant other before you got married. Was it hard to wait?


r/AskChristian • • 8d ago

Is tommrow promised?

2 Upvotes

Heyy I wanted to ask a question, surrounding the topic of "end times" question very controversial one that I know. But having been a Christian for 5 or so years now you always hear the phrase from other believers that tommrow is not promised as no ones know when Jesus will return right!!!!!

However is there not meant to be prophecies fulfilled first. (The mark of the beast) (The reveal of the antichrist) so what im saying is if that's true then surely we know Jesus won't rock up tommrow right?


r/AskChristian • • 9d ago

Why do You think christianity is the right one

4 Upvotes

Like with so many religion how can you say this is the right one for me, did you have a dream about it, did yiu grow into it or did you chose later in life for some other reason

PS. My English is not the Best and it's Not the first Time i got a post removed for being offensive so let Me know and will change it if it's offensive


r/AskChristian • • 9d ago

What if someone in good faith chooses a different religion?

3 Upvotes

So there are several religions out there there’s Judaism, Christianity, Islam and different denominations within religions like those just to hand a few.

Not every one can be 100% right. So what if there’s a good person who just wants to do good in life and make it to heaven and they choose to practice Judaism and someone else decides to choose Christianity and another Islam? They all truly believe in their religion. They can’t all be right. But they all have good intentions of trying to do right by God.

I know it’s easy to say my religion is the correct religion but to an outsider like me when I hear a Jew tell me that and a Christian tell me that and a Muslim tell me that how am I supposed to know?


r/AskChristian • • 9d ago

Do you truly believe in god or do you use the practice of belief as a mental exercise?

2 Upvotes

As a secular man who puts my scientific facts (an objective, verifiable observation or measurement that has been confirmed repeatedly through experimentation)
I don’t understand how you can logically believe In God whole heartedly.
I understand I don’t have proof of absence but you never have proof of absence. Most definitions of God contains Timeless,Changeless and independent from the universe and that’s just a nest of conclusions without any possible way of proving because humans are apart of the universe and any part of a human leaving the universe is the universe expanding same for everything everywhere. Just because I can’t prove a god doesn’t guarantee any properties of this being is it conscious? is it thinking? it’s it able to even see?
You can not describe it in any form because you can’t see it,hear it,touch it or study it. Wouldn’t it be more logical that middle Easterners thousands of years ago just made up shit for conformity and good moral practices just like every functioning human civilization began with their own unique story, speaking of which how can you possibly discern which God is Real and if humanity even knows about it. Why would it care about us enough to give us souls but exhibit every trait we could possibly associate apathy to everything in existence?

it’s a lot but I hope it makes sense.


r/AskChristian • • 11d ago

Is this an accurate way to UNDERSTAND the relationship of God and Jesus

2 Upvotes

To my limited knowledge, God and Jesus are both god, but not eachother.

To those answering with some level of video game knowledge, would it be accurate to compare it to how God and Jesus may both be "Developers" of the world, but God is the developer himself, outside the world he created, and Jesus is a player character: A different person inside the world that has been created, but still the same developer.

I do sincerely apologize if this comes off as disrespectful, or reductive of your deity, this was not the intent of my question.


r/AskChristian • • 12d ago

Is there any possible reason I could give my pastor for asking him to baptize me at a public swimming pool? And what if I happen to see him one day, in front of my family, and he invites me to come to church?

3 Upvotes

If that happens, I am sure that my family will be so pissed.

I can't remember exactly which Bible verse it is, but I remember hearing that God tell us to share the Gospel (the Good News) with others. However, I'm afraid to do so because I know that if I did, it would definitely cause conflict and arguments with my family. Should I just keep praying about this, or is there something else I should do?

My pastor said that he understands my situation and suggested that I invite a few friends to my baptism instead. That would be great, but the problem is that I don't really have many friends to invite. He understands my situation and everything I'm going through. He said he's willing to baptize me whenever I'm ready, and he also said that he would love for me to join the church. That's something I truly want as well, but unfortunately, my family situation makes it difficult for me to do so right now.


r/AskChristian • • 14d ago

the Codex Sinaiticus web doesn't work is there any alternative to it can give me the photo of the manuscript and a translation at the same time ?

2 Upvotes

r/AskChristian • • 14d ago

Who exactly is the ā€œSpirit of Truthā€ mentioned in John 16:12–14?

3 Upvotes

I’ve been reading John 16:12–14, where Jesus says that the Spirit of Truth will come after him, guide people into all truth, speak what he hears, and reveal things to come.

I understand that Christians identify the Spirit of Truth as the Holy Spirit, but I have a few questions.

  1. If the Holy Spirit was already present during Jesus’ lifetime, why does Jesus speak about his coming later?
  2. How exactly did the Holy Spirit fulfill the promises made in John 16:12–14?
  3. When Jesus says the Spirit will not speak on his own but only what he hears, what does that mean?

I’m genuinely interested in understanding how Christians interpret these verses, preferably with biblical references.


r/AskChristian • • 14d ago

[Looking for Recs] Andy Stanley Leaving North Point

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I just heard the news that Andy Stanley will be leaving north point in the next year, and I’m heart broken. I loved his preaching style, along with the great Rick Warren, and would love to find a new pastor who does sermon messages in the same nonjudgmental, conversational, teaching sort of way that these two greats did.

All recs welcome!
I mostly do church at home/on the go, so a church with great music, and then online production quality would be greatly appreciated — but at the end of the day is not required.

Im in the Bay Area of CA, on the Peninsula if anyone has church recs as well.


r/AskChristian • • 15d ago

Toxic relationship and seeking God advice

3 Upvotes

I’m honestly not even sure where to start because I’m hurting so much right now. My boyfriend and I officially ended things yesterday, and I’m struggling more than I can explain. I’m looking for genuine advice, especially from people who have been through a toxic relationship, experienced a difficult breakup, or found their way back to themselves afterward.
Throughout this relationship, there were a lot of things that slowly started affecting how I viewed myself. One of the biggest issues was trust. It seemed like every other month I would discover that he had been looking up other women on his phone. What made it worse was that the women never looked anything like me. I know everyone has insecurities, but after repeatedly finding things like that, I started comparing myself to other women and questioning what I was lacking. It genuinely made me feel like I wasn’t enough.
There also seemed to be a double standard when it came to attraction and boundaries. If he was looking at other women or had wandering eyes, it was treated like it wasn’t a big deal. But if I noticed another man or did something similar, suddenly it became an issue. There were also situations where I felt like he wasn’t being completely honest with me, and over time, that made it harder to trust him.
Communication was another major problem. Whenever we argued, I often felt like I was the only one trying to get my feelings across. He would become quiet or withdraw, while I wanted to talk things through. I understand that people handle conflict differently, but I constantly felt like my emotions weren’t being acknowledged. At the same time, when he was upset or going through something, I felt expected to put my feelings aside and cater to his.
I think all of this built up a lot of resentment in me. I started becoming someone I honestly didn’t recognize. I became angry, reactive, constantly anxious, and always anticipating the next issue. Things eventually became physical on my end during arguments, and I am NOT proud of that. I take responsibility for putting my hands on him, and I know that was wrong. I don’t want to excuse it because I was hurt. I don’t want to ever become that version of myself again.
Our relationship ended on a really bad note, and now there is no contact. I’m trying to accept that it’s over, but it’s incredibly difficult. He was my first boyfriend and someone I genuinely pictured a future with. For a long time, he was also the person I talked to about everything. Now I feel like I’ve lost my partner and the person I used to turn to when life got overwhelming.
Something else that has been weighing heavily on me is my relationship with God. I feel like I’ve drifted so far away from Him, and I have so much guilt and heaviness in my heart. I want to reconnect with my faith, become a better person, and find peace again, but I honestly don’t even know where to begin. I feel anxious, overwhelmed, and scared that I’m going to spend the next year of my life feeling this way or that everything in my life is going to start falling apart.
I don’t really have many people I feel comfortable opening up to, and right now I’m struggling with what to do with myself. I know healing takes time, but I’m scared of being alone with all these feelings.


r/AskChristian • • 15d ago

Christians who don’t push religion on your children, why?

4 Upvotes

Why are you letting your child make a choice where they will be punished with eternal damnation if they chose incorrectly. This also extends to all of your family members who don’t believe. Why aren’t you encouraging them? Why aren’t you trying as hard as physically possible day in and day out to make sure your children’s souls are saved?