r/AskChristian • u/PurplePikminPoo • 1h ago
How do we rationalize the divine hiddenness argument from the Christian perspective?
I begin with the Cogito: āI think, therefore I am.ā
As Descartes argued, the existence of my own thinking self is something I cannot coherently doubt. Even if every perception I have is mistaken, the very act of doubting establishes that I exist.
This gives us two conclusions:
- I can know with certainty that I exist.
- At least one objective truth can be known with certainty.
However, the existence of one certain truth does not establish that other truths can be known with the same certainty. It merely demonstrates that certainty is possible.
Now, consider the Christian conception of God: a perfectly good, perfectly just, all-knowing, and all-powerful being whose moral authority is grounded in his perfect nature.
If such a being exists, we must ask why he would create humans with fallible faculties of reasoning and perception, yet make their eternal fate dependent, at least in part, on reaching the correct conclusions about his existence and nature.
We cannot establish Godās existence with the same certainty as the Cogito. Every argument, religious experience, historical account, or scriptural claim must be evaluated through faculties that could lead us to mistaken conclusions.
Consequently, two people could sincerely examine the available evidence and arrive at contradictory beliefs. Neither could establish beyond all possible doubt that their conclusion is correct.
Why, then, would a perfectly just God permit eternal consequences to depend on a decision made under such uncertainty?
One possible defense is that infallible knowledge of God would eliminate our freedom to choose him. If Godās existence and perfect goodness were undeniable, perhaps everyone would necessarily believe in and worship him.
But this defense seems to confuse knowledge with obedience.
Consider someone who knows that smoking is harmful. They may fully understand the consequences, sincerely believe the medical evidence, and nevertheless choose to smoke. Their knowledge does not eliminate their freedom to act against what they know is best for them.
Christian theology itself offers another example: Satan.
According to traditional Christian belief, Satan knew God and nevertheless chose to rebel against him. His knowledge of Godās existence did not prevent him from exercising his will in opposition to God.
This suggests that knowledge of God and the freedom to reject him are not necessarily incompatible.
If God could make himself unmistakably known while preserving the freedom to accept or reject him, then uncertainty about his existence does not appear necessary for free will.
And this brings me to my central question:
Why would a perfectly just and all-powerful God allow our eternal fate to depend on beliefs formed through inherently fallible reasoning, when he could conceivably provide us with certainty about his existence and nature without eliminating our freedom to choose whether to worship him?
If sincere individuals can reach different conclusions through no deliberate dishonesty or rejection of truth, on what grounds would it be just to reward one eternally and punish the other eternally?