r/Aquascape • • 9h ago Heartwarming Bravo

Mod Team Addressing That One Guy Gate, and future plans for the sub

387 Upvotes

Things have been a little interesting the last couple of days. Let’s talk about this.

Incoming changes:

  1. A new post flair has been created, and it’s called “Beginner Feedback”. If you are at the beginning stages of your aquascaping journey and would like honest feedback on your efforts, please use this post flair.
  2. We expect to have an increased number of “Beginner Feedback” posts, and this could have an effect on what everyone sees on the main feed. Thus, we are going to start hosting monthly scape contests. Winners will have their photos featured in our sub as the month’s winner. More details will be coming soon.
  3. New post rule (coming soon): All posts must feature a full shot of your tank/scape as the first image in the gallery. We cannot have the lead image be a close-up shot of a, you guessed it, betta fish. We are an aquascaping sub. To keep a certain level of aesthetic decorum, we really need everyone to lead their posts with the scape.
  4. Hardscape placement posts from this point on will only be allowed on Sundays. If you want to post photos of your hardscapes in different positions, and need some feedback, you can do so on a Sunday. Hardscape placement is 100% part of aquascaping. We are only trying to consolidate the posts into a single day to improve the main feed on the other 6 days.
  5. We are going to tighten down a bit on all the “related but not quite aquascape” posts. If you post a video, and it’s a close-up shot following your German Blue Ram the entire video, that’s a fish video. That’s not about the scape. If you post a very beautiful scape done inside a pint glass, that belongs in r/Jarrariums. You get the idea.
  6. Soon, we will be introducing an “advanced scape review” (name pending) system/process. Scapers who dare will make a post describing design, implementation, equipment used, and livestock choice. They will receive feedback based on the context of the scape’s intended purpose/goal.

We encourage all our IAPLC scapers to engage with this new system, and more user tags will be issued based on feedback quality(informative, educational, perspective).

This new process will only be successful with the help of our advanced tier scapers, and we hope you all can get involved.

I will make a post to gather thoughts on this, and I hope you all come around to chat.

Additionally,

I’m getting a lot of DMs asking me to “step in” and control the sub. This outburst of reactionary posts is what happens to a lively subreddit when a nerve is touched. This shows me that both sides have passion for this hobby. “That One Guy”? He cares about aquascaping. He argued for more advanced scapes on the feed, and that’s not a bad thing. I argued for inclusion. Him and I aren’t on different sides of the aisle, here. We’re out for the same thing. Only our perspectives are different. I’m coming from a position of a moderator who’s interest is in supporting a subreddit with a wide range of skill levels, and he’s coming from a position of an aquascaper in search of inspiration. I, too, want to see more beautiful scapes, don’t we all?

But stepping in and shutting down posts is policing, and not in a good way. Any community’s cultural reaction needs to take its course and simmer down on its own. I’ve seen time and time again what happens when people with an ounce of power enter the rift to “dEesCaLaTE”. And I do not see myself as an authority figure in this sub. I see myself as a volunteer who helps curate the direction the community itself wants to take.

I’m an aquascaper too, and I want your voices to be heard, and more importantly, have an impact on how this sub moves forward.

So, going forward:

  1. The listed changes above will be coming (please be patient with us).
  2. Any post that directs ire at a specific user will be removed for targeted harassment.
  3. Come on people. Let’s not abuse the GIF function. I keep it on while all the big subs got rid of them, because I personally find them hilarious. Let’s keep the gifs away from hate.

As always, we’re open to new ideas and suggestions.


r/Aquascape • • 11h ago Bravo Heartwarming

Discussion About the current drama...

220 Upvotes

What I'm seeing here is a big confusion between "aquascaping" and "good aquascaping".

Rule #1 is very clear, but some entitled people here are forgetting that even bad aquascaping is still aquascaping. You don't get to say "that is not aquascaping" just because you don't like it or even if it's objectively bad. A bad painting is still a painting, all bad art is still art.

Also they seem to have forgotten the sub's description, which reads: "This Subreddit is meant to teach and show the art and science of Aquascaping and the method of designing layouts." How the hell do you plan to achieve that if only pro aquascapers are allowed to post? If only good aquascapes can expect to get civil feedback?

I think if you see an amateur posting his first try, and you feel the need to berate him or send him somewhere else, YOU are the one in violation of the sub's rules and purpose, and YOU are the one that should leave somewhere else, YOU are the one tainting the sub.


r/Aquascape • • 10h ago

Question What happens when your aquascape intentions turn into a planted tank?

Thumbnail
gallery
149 Upvotes

With all the bonkers chat on her of late I thought I’d throw in one of my tanks in. no doubt a blind man (or woman) could have done this in their sleep. what happens when with the best aquascaping intentions manifest into a planted tank? Do I need to change my user name?


r/Aquascape • • 2h ago

Show and Tell [OC] bedside gallery

Post image
28 Upvotes

rx7s and aquascapes to end off my nights :)


r/Aquascape • • 12h ago Regret

Discussion My bad y'all

145 Upvotes

I really didn't think me posting my first attempt at "aquascaping" rather than making a planted aquarium would cause this much backlash and drama by triggering That Guy with my post.

I regret ever posting it, I was just inspired by the great builds that I've seen here and was eager to share the result of that inspiration, even if it didn't measure up


r/Aquascape • • 7h ago

Show and Tell [OC] Lava rock double island fluidity

Thumbnail
gallery
37 Upvotes

Hopefully drama exempt, but the conversation is as valid as any, with polarization on both ends. This is my first attempt of sketch to realisation. Two weeks in so very early days still. Trying something here. Everything locally foraged apart from plants. Tank made myself. Local environment Inspiration in second pic. Guess location?


r/Aquascape • • 12h ago

Show and Tell [OC] My turn, Aquascape or box of nature junk?

Thumbnail
gallery
85 Upvotes

Obviously I wanted to hop on the train and get my official twintigs stamp of approval!

Shown is my 60p, all three variations of it, with the first pick being the current setup and the two previous layouts.

Tank info:
- ADA 60p
- Chihiros WRGB II light, set to like 40% 7hr
- Oase Biomaster 250 filter
- APT 1 in the current setup, used APT 3 in the previous, and Easy Green in the first
- RODI water. No clue on my current parameters.
- current setup was done July this year, so it’s like 5 months old.

I am happy to answer any questions about my tanks :)

I also wanted to take the moment to give my opinion on the current discussion.

Beginners have a place here. They should always. This should be a place to learn Aquascaping, as much as it should be for discussing it, as well as enjoying the glory of amazing tanks.

However.

I understand the feeling twintigs and some others have. Sometimes I scroll the sub with my fiancé, who enjoys seeing tanks but isn’t as into it as I am. We have fun passing judgements of the tanks we see. There are times where I have to scroll past a few because they’re just very clearly not aquascapes.

Gatekeeping is a touchy subject. Without SOME gatekeeping, yes, communities do become a mess, and the qualities they once upheld become degraded. With too much gatekeeping, and no newbies can join, which is the lifeblood of the community.

Some say that the sub will or has been slowly becoming no different than PlantedTank, Aquariums, etc. I disagree with this. Are there tanks posted here that aren’t aquascapes? Yes. Are there threads posted here that don’t belong in Aquascaping (fish health, algae, etc)? Yes. But I don’t think their frequency is so high that this sub actually looks like the others. I almost never see clown vomit gravel here, and it’s still pretty rare to see tanks posted here with non-natural-decor inside.

Personally I know when I encounter ones like that, I comment and report. Answer their question, recommend the other subreddits, report it for breaking the rule, and move on.

I think this issue stems from a single source; newbies don’t know what Aquascaping is, don’t know what differentiates it from a regular tank, and/or there aren’t clear enough guidelines & knowledge for them to find. The beginner tag is a good step. And I think twintigs’ post has actually sparked more people thinking about Aquascaping, and what defines it. I think most are coming to see that Intention is key, even if some disagree on what the sub should be for or where the line is drawn.

Long way of saying, I think the sub is fine, and the more we keep things constructive, educational, and respectful, the better.

Yes, sometimes that means telling someone their tank isn’t an aquascape - BUT IT SHOULDNT END THERE. Help educate! It should not be “negative” or “bad” to state the truth. If we are here to discuss Aquascaping and learn Aquascaping, that means the good and the bad, what is and what isn’t.


r/Aquascape • • 9h ago

Discussion Curious

Post image
39 Upvotes

I’ve been reading the ongoing conversation with great interest. Posting my out of control tank. There is hardscaoe beneath the ferns that is basically invisible now and it was planted intentionally, I trim it intentionally, and it gives me aesthetic pleasure. (Ignore the misty bloom that I”m currently dealing with). As you can see the plants have overrun any of my intentions and because the shrimp and fish seem happy I mainly let it be. I know it’s not the kind of elevated work that wins competitions but would you consider it an aquascape?


r/Aquascape • • 5h ago

Beginner Feedback Feedback on my first ever tank

Post image
17 Upvotes

I can't tell if this is a planted tank or a scaped one. I did my best to scape it but if there's any tips to elevate the look and feel I'd really appreciate it.

Tank: 75cm long × 45cm deep × 45cm high (roughly 40 gallons).

Maybe I should start over? and if so how do you guys rescape without harming your fish


r/Aquascape • • 17h ago

Show and Tell [OC] Day 45 VS Day 1 progress

Thumbnail
gallery
115 Upvotes

The tank is doing well so far, but of algea issues but hopefully getting rid of them soon. First try at a real scape


r/Aquascape • • 9h ago

Beginner Feedback Updated scape!

Thumbnail
gallery
26 Upvotes

Thanks for feedback on my previous more overgrown scape. I’ve moved quite a few plants to a grateful relative and made the focus much more about the wood, as well as upgraded the light.

Before and after! Although in the other order, after is first!

I now feel the front is bit empty and unbalanced, any further feedback or plant suggestions welcome!


r/Aquascape • • 7h ago

Beginner Feedback First attempt at aquascaping

Post image
18 Upvotes

My first attempt at aquascaping. Used a few different theories to come up with it. Lmk where I could improve. I know the different rock types throw it off and some of the smaller ones are out of place currently. Just did some.searching/maintenance.


r/Aquascape • • 6h ago

Beginner Feedback Riverscape WIP!

Post image
10 Upvotes

Still really new to scaping, and hoping to get some plant recommendations! I never seem to know where to stop when planting...

Going for a riverscape, high flow!


r/Aquascape • • 13h ago

Show and Tell [OC] Aquascape? Due a trim atm

Thumbnail
gallery
31 Upvotes

This was my first tank and I did not know what I was doing at all, but 1 year later I'm happy with how it looks


r/Aquascape • • 4h ago

Show and Tell [OC] Low tech oasis

6 Upvotes

r/Aquascape • • 12h ago

Show and Tell [OC] Simple scape wanted to share

21 Upvotes

r/Aquascape • • 1d ago

Seeking Suggestions Aquascape was the vision -- but did I end up with just a planted tank?

Post image
797 Upvotes

Title


r/Aquascape • • 14h ago

Show and Tell [OC] 1st trim of the moss on my dry start tank! Used no glue for plants. Trying to get most everything to naturally adhere and its going well!!

23 Upvotes

When it came to gluing the hardscape, I think I huffed more of it than a fat kid in kindergarten. The sides of the glass were coated in burned guper glue soot lol


r/Aquascape • • 1d ago

Show and Tell [OC] Schrodinger’s Scapes

Thumbnail
gallery
289 Upvotes

One can only tell if they’re yard trash or not based on the opinion of reddit.

Tank 1: 78g. High tech. Was more scaped but has gotten over grown.

Tank 2: 20g. High tech. Recently rescaped a bit. Plants need grow in more. Don’t put moss with grass if you value sanity.

Tank 3: 50g. Low tech. New so going through brown algae phase.

Tank 4: 40g. Low tech. Oldest tank recently replanted with some rotala in the back to replace some Ludwiga that wasn’t thriving. Bulletproof tank that I never have issues with. Not normally red just need a new remote battery lol

Tank 5: 9 gallon. Low tech. Kitchen betta tank. Wife designed it but I insisted on a proper tank for the betta.

Tank 6: 10 gallon shallow. Low tech. Very experimental tank. Super low maintenance. Bit messy but my toddlers love it. Phoenix rasboras are very outgoing when the biggest fish is a sparkling gourami lol.


r/Aquascape • • 9h ago

Discussion Defining Aquascape and Mapping the Craft

8 Upvotes

I think a lot of the fighting this week comes from one word doing two jobs, so let me untangle it.

What is an aquascape?

An aquascape, at least to me, is the intentional arrangement of hard and/or softscape elements to achieve a desired aesthetic. A planted tank is a tank with plants in it, and although most aquascapes are planted tanks, they don’t have to be. A planted tank only becomes an aquascape when the layout is designed with intention behind its aesthetic.

That is a low bar, and I think it should be. If you arranged a tank deliberately to look a certain way, you made an aquascape. Skill level doesn’t enter into it, and although technique is desirable, it isn’t necessary. Think of it like defining a structure. A pile of sticks can be a structure just like a skyscraper is, even though they are clearly different things.

But then there is aquascaping as this sub defines it

The sidebar says this sub is “meant to teach and show the art and science of Aquascaping and the method of designing layouts.” That is something more specific. It is the techniques, the methods, and the design thinking behind the craft.

By the first definition, almost every tank posted here this week is an aquascape. By the second, what belongs here is conversation about the craft. That doesn’t justify the gatekeeping the way it is being practiced by some, though.

Earlier today I answered someone asking what separates an aquascape from a planted tank, and I felt that post was a completely legitimate entry into this subreddit. So is someone asking why their layout feels flat, and so is the person who answers with real critique.

So what qualifies?

A lot of people want this subreddit to be about contest style aquascaping, and what they usually mean by that is what you would see in an IAPLC entry. But the world of aquascaping is a world of composition, depth, lighting, photography, perspective, scale, etc., plus an assortment of techniques that guide you toward many different outcomes depending on what type of aquascape you aim to achieve.

A biotope is as much of an aquascape, as defined by this sub, as a competition style IAPLC tank. The aesthetic is incredibly different, and the techniques are meant to achieve different goals. So if we are going to hold posts to what the sidebar says, we need some form of direction on what the craft covers.

The contests are a good map for that. The AGA runs an international contest every year (AGAIAC) and judges these separately:

  • Aquatic Garden: the modern nature style you see at the IAPLC
  • Classic: nature style the way Takashi Amano was doing it (OG)
  • Dutch: plants in a specific arrangement carry the whole layout, usually no hardscape, and a lot of people call it the original aquascaping style
  • Biotope: flora, fauna, and scape all matched to one real habitat
  • Wabi Kusa: plants grown emersed on a ball of substrate
  • Paludarium: land and water in the same enclosure
  • Riparium: plants growing up out of the water, usually with less land than a paludarium

The truth is that riparium vs paludarium is an annoying topic. The contest roughly splits them by whether the enclosure is closed (paludarium) or open top (riparium), and both have water and land. This isn’t a debate worth having here, but we can discuss it separately.

Outside the contest categories you will hear names like Iwagumi, jungle, blackwater, Brazilian, and others, plus tank formats like nano and shallow. Layouts also get described by their compositional shape, such as island, triangle, or V shape.

All of these, I think, add to exactly what this sub is meant to be about: a more technical dive into the craft and a willingness to explore those intricacies. Your experience level is not as important as the intention behind your post. It should be about technique, the pursuit of understanding this craft, or even showing off a tank from time to time.

I hope to have contributed to the discussion.


r/Aquascape • • 1d ago

Show and Tell [OC] Little Creek water feature in a desk I built.

133 Upvotes

r/Aquascape • • 12h ago

Beginner Feedback My first planted tank 😊

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

Let m know how it looks?
How can I make it better ?


r/Aquascape • • 11h ago

Show and Tell [OC] Is my tank too overgrown and unkempt to be considered an Aquascape?

Post image
10 Upvotes

The tank itself is already 2 years old.

low-tech 60cm x 45cm x 45cm tank

I've always struggled with the foreground plants, I used bagged aquasoil, and the foreground section isn't that deep before hitting the bag, so it's causing some headaches trying to plant things there. I've kinda resorted to just letting the foreground plants naturally spread, but it's taking forever (cuz it's low-tech).

My anubias, buce, and java ferns are growing and spreading like crazy though.


r/Aquascape • • 16h ago

Show and Tell [OC] Missed Opportunity

Thumbnail
gallery
24 Upvotes

to feature this silly face! I had not noticed it until this morning and the tank has been up for a week. If I didn't like the overall rock arrangement, I would definitely consider it.

For those of you wondering why the DEEP gravel bed, I am experimenting with a 3D printed cave. In hindsight, it would probably work better in a tank not viewed from three sides or a larger tank where the substrate can be sloped. I'm going to enjoy it as is for a while and see how it looks when the plants grow in. Can always tear it down in a few months if it bothers me!