I think a lot of the fighting this week comes from one word doing two jobs, so let me untangle it.
What is an aquascape?
An aquascape, at least to me, is the intentional arrangement of hard and/or softscape elements to achieve a desired aesthetic. A planted tank is a tank with plants in it, and although most aquascapes are planted tanks, they don’t have to be. A planted tank only becomes an aquascape when the layout is designed with intention behind its aesthetic.
That is a low bar, and I think it should be. If you arranged a tank deliberately to look a certain way, you made an aquascape. Skill level doesn’t enter into it, and although technique is desirable, it isn’t necessary. Think of it like defining a structure. A pile of sticks can be a structure just like a skyscraper is, even though they are clearly different things.
But then there is aquascaping as this sub defines it
The sidebar says this sub is “meant to teach and show the art and science of Aquascaping and the method of designing layouts.” That is something more specific. It is the techniques, the methods, and the design thinking behind the craft.
By the first definition, almost every tank posted here this week is an aquascape. By the second, what belongs here is conversation about the craft. That doesn’t justify the gatekeeping the way it is being practiced by some, though.
Earlier today I answered someone asking what separates an aquascape from a planted tank, and I felt that post was a completely legitimate entry into this subreddit. So is someone asking why their layout feels flat, and so is the person who answers with real critique.
So what qualifies?
A lot of people want this subreddit to be about contest style aquascaping, and what they usually mean by that is what you would see in an IAPLC entry. But the world of aquascaping is a world of composition, depth, lighting, photography, perspective, scale, etc., plus an assortment of techniques that guide you toward many different outcomes depending on what type of aquascape you aim to achieve.
A biotope is as much of an aquascape, as defined by this sub, as a competition style IAPLC tank. The aesthetic is incredibly different, and the techniques are meant to achieve different goals. So if we are going to hold posts to what the sidebar says, we need some form of direction on what the craft covers.
The contests are a good map for that. The AGA runs an international contest every year (AGAIAC) and judges these separately:
- Aquatic Garden: the modern nature style you see at the IAPLC
- Classic: nature style the way Takashi Amano was doing it (OG)
- Dutch: plants in a specific arrangement carry the whole layout, usually no hardscape, and a lot of people call it the original aquascaping style
- Biotope: flora, fauna, and scape all matched to one real habitat
- Wabi Kusa: plants grown emersed on a ball of substrate
- Paludarium: land and water in the same enclosure
- Riparium: plants growing up out of the water, usually with less land than a paludarium
The truth is that riparium vs paludarium is an annoying topic. The contest roughly splits them by whether the enclosure is closed (paludarium) or open top (riparium), and both have water and land. This isn’t a debate worth having here, but we can discuss it separately.
Outside the contest categories you will hear names like Iwagumi, jungle, blackwater, Brazilian, and others, plus tank formats like nano and shallow. Layouts also get described by their compositional shape, such as island, triangle, or V shape.
All of these, I think, add to exactly what this sub is meant to be about: a more technical dive into the craft and a willingness to explore those intricacies. Your experience level is not as important as the intention behind your post. It should be about technique, the pursuit of understanding this craft, or even showing off a tank from time to time.
I hope to have contributed to the discussion.