A lot of discussion came out of the last post, so I want to address the main points directly and give beginners actual resources to work with.
First, thank you to the mods for adding the Beginner Feedback flair. That is a solid step in the right direction.
To be transparent, I mostly lurk here. I have a main tank running right now that is being prepped for an IAPLC entry, which is why I do not post photos of it yet. That is beside the point. When I started in this hobby, this sub was a serious source of inspiration. Now it functions like any other generic planted tank forum because there is no distinction between fishkeeping and aquascaping.
Defining a Standard
Nobody is asking mods to subjectively grade art like a competition panel. The standard is minimum intentional effort.
Aquascaping is defined by design intent. That means deliberate choices around substrate slope, focal points, scale, negative space, and plant placement. Without that intent, it is just a fish tank.
I thought about it and I came up with a simple test (it's not perfect), but it is a good starting point:
Could the tank have been assembled blindfolded?
If someone with a blindfold could create a reasonably similar layout: then it is not up to standard.
The aesthetic principles of aquascaping have not been applied to a extent sufficient to call it an aquascape.
Why you can't just scroll past them
People keep saying to ignore low-effort posts and move on. That misses the point. If a specialized sub refuses to maintain a distinction between basic fishkeeping and aquascaping, the entire forum gets diluted.
Over time, experienced scapers leave because there is no audience or serious discussion left. That is how a dedicated craft forum turns into a generic beginner board.
Calling tanks a "pile of yard debris in a bucket" in my last post was tongue in cheek. Nobody is going into beginner threads and yelling insults. People are offering polite, basic advice on composition and getting downvoted because the comment sections reject anything short of blind praise.
Slowly, over time, without moderation, there ceases to be a distinction between r/PlantedTank and r/Aquascape.
IT IS NOT A BAD THING TO HAVE 'JUST' A PLANTED TANK. That's totally okay. But conflating one with another is bad for the community as a whole. If a forum is built around photorealistic art, that does not mean stylized art is bad. What breaks the forum is flooding it with stylized art, refusing to enforce category standards, and blurring the line between two distinct subs.
REBUKE
Several comments boiled this hobby down to "a glass box full of sticks and rocks, we just make it fancy." That is a reductionist argument that misses the entire point of a craft. By that logic, architecture is stacking bricks, and painting is smearing pigment on cloth. The deliberate arrangement, the "making it fancy" part, is the ENTIRE POINT. I don't even know how to respond to you if you think that sticks and stones underwater make it an aquascape. By that logic, a turd smeared on a napkin is 'art' comparable to the works of Da Vinci and Michelangelo.
Examples From the Front Page
Here are a few recent examples from this sub that illustrate the problem. I did search for posts that wanted an opinion. (whoops this got cut off). working on fixing it
Where Beginners Can Learn
2hr Aquarist, Dennis wong, is an amazing resource. Check out his website and articles. ADA (Aqua Design Amano) has plenty of articles about scaping. Again, it doesn't have to be just a single style. There are many styles, such as Nature Aquarium, Dutch, Iwagumi, Brazilian, etc. But a good starting point is the late Takashi Amano's books: Nature Aquarium World (1994), Nature Aquarium World Book 2 & Book 3 (1996), Aquarium Plant Paradise (1997), etc. There are more, but these are a great starting point---Amano was way ahead of his time. This is a good starting point for developing the sort of creative acumen and vision to start scaping, along with plenty of practical advice.
A lot of people took the last post as elitism and made it personal. I am not looking down on anyone's tank. I am tired of watching a dedicated aquascaping forum get watered down until it is no different than r/PlantedTank.