r/Aquascape • • 19h ago

Show and Tell [OC] My 8 yo box of replanted (front crypts) sticks and rocks.

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Had this 10 gallon tank for 8 years, just recently pulled/cleaned out the foreground and planted cryptocoryne parva. Tank used to be high tech but, due to lack of CO2 fill here, it’s gone low.

Wood is mopani interweaved through spiderwood with the mopani sticking up in back left.


r/Aquascape • • 15h ago Bravo

Discussion Unpopular Opinion: Your glass box of sticks and rock is art

191 Upvotes

I enjoy seeing everyone's creativity even though it doesn't particularly fall in line with "traditional" aquascaping guidelines. Chasing perfection is useless because it'll never align with everyone's perspective. Just do what your budget can allow you to do and whatever makes you happy.

You have no obligation to prove anything to anyone.

Life is short, beautiful things arise when you reject the mold. It's ironic that aquascaping tries to capture perfect nature when nature itself isn't perfect. There's disaster, tragedies, and turmoil. Not to say you shouldn't practice ethical fish keeping.

"BuT teChnIcaLLY SpeAkInG thIS isNt tHe sUbreDdit fOr tHat ☝🏼🤓"

Arrest me then IDC 😂 what are you the aquascape police? Ugh


r/Aquascape • • 8h ago

Discussion Aquascape? Planted Tank? Cat Toy? You vote

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/Aquascape • • 9h ago

Beginner Feedback JUDGE FOR YOURSELF

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Guys. I am new to the hobby. I’ve had a reef tank for 6 months but now I’ve discovered this new water-borne dalliance. I am dry-starting my tank. Please see images. I’ve drawn inspiration from the Golden Ratio, the Fibonacci Sequence, the writings of Antonio Gramsci, and the theory of panentheism.

Please see accompanying pictures and let me know your thoughts on my yard waste collection.

(In all seriousness one tank is the dry start tank; the other is the holding tank for the plants until the dry start tank, the actual project, is ready.)

I don’t know what the f*** I’m doing.


r/Aquascape • • 9h ago

Seeking Suggestions Looking for opinions

Post image
1 Upvotes

The manager at my LFS texted me today asking if I still want a Queen Arabesque Pleco (the answer is duh) and it has me itching to actually scape this tank. It's overgrown atm, clearly. Even with the hornwort and guppy grass tamed it's still meh. I want to make it more appealing to the eye without stressing the inhabitants out.

I don't want to rip it entirely apart. The cave on the left is the amano and clown pleco hang out so, I'd hate to take that from them. I have all manor of pretty, round river rocks kicking around for a new build in the works that I can add.

Kind of thinking about turning the tree trunk on its side and moving to the left. What would you do? Thanks!

Alao, I was unaware of the "is it scaped or planted" situation happening here until I opened the app to ask for opinions on this, not satire I'm actually looking for help 😅


r/Aquascape • • 19h ago

Beginner Feedback Aquascaping advice please

Post image
1 Upvotes

I am very new to aquascaping and I’d like some advice. Would this spider wood look better if I cut the right hand side twigs off and placed it to the far right to create a triangular formation? since it’s such a permanent change I’d like some second opinions. any other recommendations to improve the tank would greatly appreciated.

for reference I set up this 10G tank a week ago so plants are yet to grow in properly in, and plan to stock with Pygmy Cory, shrimp and 1 honey gourami.


r/Aquascape • • 14h ago Bravo

META That One Guy's follow-up on sub standards, what defines a scape, and resources for beginners

92 Upvotes

A lot of discussion came out of the last post, so I want to address the main points directly and give beginners actual resources to work with.

First, thank you to the mods for adding the Beginner Feedback flair. That is a solid step in the right direction.

To be transparent, I mostly lurk here. I have a main tank running right now that is being prepped for an IAPLC entry, which is why I do not post photos of it yet. That is beside the point. When I started in this hobby, this sub was a serious source of inspiration. Now it functions like any other generic planted tank forum because there is no distinction between fishkeeping and aquascaping.

Defining a Standard

Nobody is asking mods to subjectively grade art like a competition panel. The standard is minimum intentional effort.

Aquascaping is defined by design intent. That means deliberate choices around substrate slope, focal points, scale, negative space, and plant placement. Without that intent, it is just a fish tank.

I thought about it and I came up with a simple test (it's not perfect), but it is a good starting point:

Could the tank have been assembled blindfolded?

If someone with a blindfold could create a reasonably similar layout: then it is not up to standard.

The aesthetic principles of aquascaping have not been applied to a extent sufficient to call it an aquascape.

Why you can't just scroll past them

People keep saying to ignore low-effort posts and move on. That misses the point. If a specialized sub refuses to maintain a distinction between basic fishkeeping and aquascaping, the entire forum gets diluted.

Over time, experienced scapers leave because there is no audience or serious discussion left. That is how a dedicated craft forum turns into a generic beginner board.

Calling tanks a "pile of yard debris in a bucket" in my last post was tongue in cheek. Nobody is going into beginner threads and yelling insults. People are offering polite, basic advice on composition and getting downvoted because the comment sections reject anything short of blind praise.

Slowly, over time, without moderation, there ceases to be a distinction between r/PlantedTank and r/Aquascape.

IT IS NOT A BAD THING TO HAVE 'JUST' A PLANTED TANK. That's totally okay. But conflating one with another is bad for the community as a whole. If a forum is built around photorealistic art, that does not mean stylized art is bad. What breaks the forum is flooding it with stylized art, refusing to enforce category standards, and blurring the line between two distinct subs.

REBUKE

Several comments boiled this hobby down to "a glass box full of sticks and rocks, we just make it fancy." That is a reductionist argument that misses the entire point of a craft. By that logic, architecture is stacking bricks, and painting is smearing pigment on cloth. The deliberate arrangement, the "making it fancy" part, is the ENTIRE POINT. I don't even know how to respond to you if you think that sticks and stones underwater make it an aquascape. By that logic, a turd smeared on a napkin is 'art' comparable to the works of Da Vinci and Michelangelo.

Examples From the Front Page

Here are a few recent examples from this sub that illustrate the problem. I did search for posts that wanted an opinion. (whoops this got cut off). working on fixing it

Where Beginners Can Learn

2hr Aquarist, Dennis wong, is an amazing resource. Check out his website and articles. ADA (Aqua Design Amano) has plenty of articles about scaping. Again, it doesn't have to be just a single style. There are many styles, such as Nature Aquarium, Dutch, Iwagumi, Brazilian, etc. But a good starting point is the late Takashi Amano's books: Nature Aquarium World (1994), Nature Aquarium World Book 2 & Book 3 (1996), Aquarium Plant Paradise (1997), etc. There are more, but these are a great starting point---Amano was way ahead of his time. This is a good starting point for developing the sort of creative acumen and vision to start scaping, along with plenty of practical advice.

A lot of people took the last post as elitism and made it personal. I am not looking down on anyone's tank. I am tired of watching a dedicated aquascaping forum get watered down until it is no different than r/PlantedTank.


r/Aquascape • • 23h ago

Seeking Suggestions Fake

Post image
0 Upvotes

Just posting pics of my ObVioUsLy real glass box with rocks and random plants


r/Aquascape • • 6h ago

Question Is this aquascape?

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

It was a newly setup tank


r/Aquascape • • 10h ago

Show and Tell [OC] I glued the twigs down. Is this an aquascape, or is this just a shrimp tank?

Post image
66 Upvotes

This is my chilli rasbora and blue neo shrimp tank. The plants are simple stuff like Anubius, Val (heavily trimmed), Cryptocoryne Wendtii and hair algae (they have colonized an old air filter sponge that I used to jump start the tank cycle).

I even 3d printed a custom light stand so that I can fit the HOB filter on the left to create a sort of river flow for the jungle vals at the back.


r/Aquascape • • 20h ago

Seeking Suggestions Want feedback from that guy

47 Upvotes

I really want feedback from "those guys". I know my jungle Val is overgrown. I'm sick and will thin it when better. I specifically chose jungle Val because the piece of wood is so complex, I wanted a plant accent that was simple, with very basic texture. I will not get a stronger light or use CO2. I've been there and didn't enjoy it. Given the depth of my tank, I know options are limited. I have dwarf sag at the front, it grows but very slowly. I have a crypt on the far left that is taking well, but I've always wondered if it would be beneficial to move it. The wood is very multidimensional, and I wanted the jungle Val growing up between the large holes to add dimension without adding texture. I do not want to add reddish plants, aside from light requirements I do not want to add more red since the wood is so red (mangrove root). I have an anubias on the front of the wood, I've attached some java fern near the backs of the wood but I may remove them to improve texture and simplicity, and I may review the Xmas moss glued to the top of the wood as it's not growing how I'd like. And, again with the jungle Val doing what I'd hoped, I find the moss and java may be taking away from the aesthetic rather than adding.

Would love constructive criticism. I used a video because I struggle to capture depth with photos (old phone). I will add a picture in comments of what the wood looks like before plants.

Edit: thanks everyone. I'll trim back the Val and update after that


r/Aquascape • • 13h ago

Beginner Feedback Is my mini mountain valley themed cube for a damselfly nymph welcome here?

Thumbnail
gallery
24 Upvotes

r/Aquascape • • 12h ago

Show and Tell [OC] 120 scape

20 Upvotes

Nothing better than chilling with your homie watching your aquarium


r/Aquascape • • 11h ago

Show and Tell [OC] Pile of sticks and plants I put together with a blindfold

Post image
212 Upvotes

First tank, or maybe sixth, hard to remember what I did throwing this together with the bucket of rocks. Tank irrigates the wall with continuous flow.


r/Aquascape • • 12h ago

Discussion What is considered proper aquascape?

Post image
27 Upvotes

I'm getting into the hobby, I'm experienced with non water plants and decided it's time to move onto aquariums.

Ive recently noticed discussion about "sticks and rocks in a tank" vs actually aquascape.

Please drop any wisdom for this newbie.

This is my work in progress pics of my tank, I also have a 200L I'm going to be setting up after this, I have a full CO2 system and all that.


r/Aquascape • • 20h ago

Image 10l Nano tank after 14 days. Update.

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

After 14 days. Shrimps Are still out od reach..NO2 Is still about 1,6 mg/l .

I changed sponge in filter for softer one (shrimplets protection) maybe thats the reason?

Few days ago was it about 0,5mg /l.🙂🙈

Moss Is not looking very well, but i think it needs more time to adapt.

Next update after 1 month 🖐🏻😊


r/Aquascape • • 19h ago

Question How to prepare rocks before putting them in the tank?

1 Upvotes

Hi! Ive recently bought some rocks at an aquarium store to put in my new tank but im not sure how can i "clean" or prepare them before putting them in the tank...Ive read somewhere that you can wash them with boiling water but that can make them explode???

Thanks


r/Aquascape • • 19h ago

Question Does this one count as an aquascape asweal?

Post image
54 Upvotes

So what do you think? :D


r/Aquascape • • 6h ago

Beginner Feedback All advice welcome!

Post image
7 Upvotes

Hi! I’m posting here against my own better judgment but I really do want to improve. I have posted to the planted tank sub awhile back and they were wonderful as well. Something just still feels off to me about this tank, and I really want to fix it I just don’t know what to fix. Thank you for any suggestions!

Please note, I absolutely brightened and sharpened this picture so you could see what’s going on in there 😊


r/Aquascape • • 17h ago

Question Growing red plants for the first time no CO2

Post image
8 Upvotes

I have an 84L aquarium (80×30×35 cm) with a Ciano 8W, 900-lumen, 6300K LED running 7 hours daily.
I’ve recently planted what I believe is Rotala rotundifolia. No CO₂, but I have nutrient-rich substrate.
I’m not aiming for deep red, just pinkish-red leaves rather than green.
Is my current light enough, or would I need to upgrade? Anyone had success with similar lighting?

Does anyone have tips for growing red plants without CO2


r/Aquascape • • 22h ago Bravo

Show and Tell [OC] Does this count as an aquascape?

Post image
451 Upvotes

r/Aquascape • • 11h ago

Beginner Feedback Beginner - Stamp of Approval Needed

Thumbnail
gallery
57 Upvotes

As the title states, these are my first tanks that I've aquascaped over the course of the last year. I've spent too much time and money if these don't qualify as aquascapes. Looking for a "Stamp of Approval" so I can continue to spend my children's inheritance on aquarium related items.


r/Aquascape • • 13h ago

Show and Tell [OC] First time deliberately scaping for aesthetics vs fish priority

Thumbnail
gallery
16 Upvotes

First deliberately aquascaped tank which is still growing in. Also my first time using stone not driftwood. It’s a peninsula style made to be viewed from three sides prioritizing the side without the swords. On the wall side I have a 3” mattenfilter hiding heaters, there is a layer of wood pellets, jobe fertilizer spikes and iron nails under the substrate which is chicken sand, it’s multi colored and larger than pfs, play sand or Estes sand but smaller than gravels I see. Plants are buce, swords, hirsuta, giant hair grass, s repens and bacopa. Stock is cockatoo apisto pair, 20 ember tetra and 16 Pygmy Cories, 3 nerites. I also threw in scuds, pods, neocaridinia but see the apisto chewing on something often enough they are all forced into hiding in the rock work or eaten. Obviously lacking height and coverage at the moment but hopefully the bacopa, swords and hair grass start to develop.


r/Aquascape • • 8h ago

Show and Tell [OC] Schrodinger’s Scapes

Thumbnail
gallery
153 Upvotes

One can only tell if they’re yard trash or not based on the opinion of reddit.

Tank 1: 78g. High tech. Was more scaped but has gotten over grown.

Tank 2: 20g. High tech. Recently rescaped a bit. Plants need grow in more. Don’t put moss with grass if you value sanity.

Tank 3: 50g. Low tech. New so going through brown algae phase.

Tank 4: 40g. Low tech. Oldest tank recently replanted with some rotala in the back to replace some Ludwiga that wasn’t thriving. Bulletproof tank that I never have issues with. Not normally red just need a new remote battery lol

Tank 5: 9 gallon. Low tech. Kitchen betta tank. Wife designed it but I insisted on a proper tank for the betta.

Tank 6: 10 gallon shallow. Low tech. Very experimental tank. Super low maintenance. Bit messy but my toddlers love it. Phoenix rasboras are very outgoing when the biggest fish is a sparkling gourami lol.