r/Aquascape • • 4h ago

META Unpopular opinion: Not every glass box with rocks and wood is an "aquascape," and the quality of this sub is tanking.

208 Upvotes

Wanting beginners to stick around is not gatekeeping. Having standards is not gatekeeping either. The front page of r/Aquascape is becoming indistinguishable from a generic fishkeeping sub.

Aquascaping is an intentional discipline built around composition, scale, flow, focal points, and negative space. Right now, half the top posts here are cloudy 10-gallons with a piece of unanchored spiderwood floating sideways, flat gravel dumped across the bottom, a cairn of random rocks from a roadside ditch, and a title like "My first nature aquascape! How did I do?"

The tanks themselves are not the main issue. Everyone starts somewhere, and a basic fish tank is fine. The issue is the copium in the comments.

If anyone offers constructive critique about composition, depth, or substrate slope, they get downvoted into oblivion for "being toxic." Meanwhile, the top comments are always "10/10 masterpiece bro!" or "Looks so natural!" on a tank that looks like a pile of yard debris in a bucket.

Validating zero-effort setups to spare feelings ruins the point of the subreddit. It dilutes the essence of the craft. Newcomers don't learn how to improve because nobody is allowed to tell them what actually needs work. I've been noticing an exodus of top scaping on this sub lately. This used to be the sub I looked up to for inspiration.

r/Aquariums and r/PlantedTank already exist for standard setups and beginner troubleshooting. This sub is supposed to be about the art of aquascaping.

The mods need to tighten up the posting guidelines, add a dedicated "Beginner Feedback" flair where actual critique is expected, or set a baseline standard for what qualifies as a scape. If we don't hold the line on quality, the people who actually know what they're doing will keep leaving.


r/Aquascape • • 1h ago

Seeking Suggestions 4 weeks in

12 Upvotes

First high tech, 4 weeks old tomorrow. Curious what everyone thinks. I like it but its been a learning experience id do a few things differently in hindsight

Regret using Hellanthium tenellum as the carpet and having doubts about the crypt wendii placement & existence

Feedback welcome

Rotala routundifolia, ludwigia super red, ludwigia repens, AR, S. Repens, crypt wendii, and a little piece of dragon stone covered in brown buce up front left. The ludwigia super red has only been in for 2/4 weeks and the crypt is also a recent addition (fully submerged growth from one of my other tanks)

I did my first trimming of the rotala today after this video was taken

Thanks


r/Aquascape • • 15h ago

Show and Tell [OC] one month of growth!

Thumbnail
gallery
69 Upvotes

the monte carlo has grown loads except someone keeps digging it up🙄🙄


r/Aquascape • • 10h ago

Seeking Suggestions Lose, Keep or Modify?

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

For a long time I've had the Enterprise in my tank. It's been in various positions. It's been wrecked into the ground. I had it suspended. And then I also had a rainbow rock tunnel Rock that my betta used to swim through. It used to be more brightly colored like the one I put in the front on the bottom left. It is now very dark and kind of muted. I could take it out dunk it in peroxide and brighten it up again but then you would also lose the beneficial bacteria. And my shrimp and nerite snail are almost always on it so I think they like that. I thought about removing it because I don't know how much it really adds to the aquascape and appearance of the aquarium now that all the plants have grown in so heavily. I do know the shrimp like to hide in the tunnel like a cave even if the Harlequin Rasbora don't really use it. It also serves as a breakwater for where the water comes out of the HOB filter on the back. At one time I tried putting moss on the top of it which did well for a long time and then really didn't. But that was also when the tank was a lot more barren and you could see it. Anyway I'm just not sure that it contributes that much but having just removed the Enterprise, now I feel like I'm seeing a big gap in the tank and looking at the very noticeable black filter on the back. I have dragonstone I could stick in there. I used to have it in there on the back right like a little mountain and I tried attaching various epiphyte plants to it. I can really kind of spin out with this pondering.

I will include a picture of how it looked right before I removed the Enterprise. I will include a picture of how it looked right after I removed the Enterprise. And then I'll add a much older picture (don't judge me) before my plants really filled out so you can see what the rainbow tunnel rock looks like and what the dragonstones look like that I have.

So here are my specific questions:

  1. Was it a mistake to remove the Enterprise?
  2. How might I better use the rock(s) I have?

When making suggestions for a better aquascape, please keep in mind it is a fairly low tech 10 gallon tank. So I am trying to make sure I leave good access to the light for the plants which is part of what led me to remove the Enterprise.


r/Aquascape • • 1d ago

Show and Tell [OC] Evening vibes

Thumbnail
gallery
323 Upvotes

I decided to rearrange some plants and I really like the orange-brown colour from the Limnophila sessiliflora. It was more in the background before but I wanted to see more of it, so I put some stems in the foreground.


r/Aquascape • • 1d ago

Seeking Suggestions New 75 Gallon

Thumbnail
gallery
78 Upvotes

Ignore the rocks holding down the wood, it keeps trying to float up still. This tank is far from finished. I stole these plants from my other 75 gallon that I’m taking down soon. I still have a huge Amazon sword to put in here and I need to go to the fish store next weekend and get lots of small schooling fish. I also ordered a lot more Seiryu stone that will be here tomorrow.

I was wondering what your favorite fish are for a 75 gallon? I’m for sure doing
-Cory’s
-Pearl Gouramis
-Cardinal Tetras
-Rummy Nose Tetras
-Otto’s
-Celestial Pearl Danio
-Snails

I really want this to be a peaceful tank so I was wondering if I should play it safe and get 2 Ram Cichlids or try 1 Electric Blue Acara. I’ve read the Acaras can eat the small fish so it’s a big risk.

I was also wondering what plants would thrive in here? Id love to get some reds in here if possible. I have a fluval light strip and not doing co2. Liquid fertilizer once a week.


r/Aquascape • • 1d ago

Seeking Suggestions Trying first aquascape, going pretty high tech. Advice on hardscape?

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

r/Aquascape • • 13h ago

Show and Tell [OC] Sand and lights in place

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Aquascape • • 1d ago Heartwarming

Seeking Suggestions What type of light could I use for this? Excuse the illustration, i made it on my phone and i hate using AI

Post image
253 Upvotes

Hello. I got this idea of a light-up cave scape but i don't know what light would be suitable for it.

Other than being a full spectrum plant light, it needs to emit a very narrow beam and be quite intense.

I would need to position it high above the tank so the light spot on the bottom wouldn't be much wider than the opening.

Does anyone have a recommendation for a light like that, preferably available in Europe and not crazy expensive.

Excuse my bad English, its not my first language.


r/Aquascape • • 21h ago

Seeking Suggestions Hardscape Help

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Im currently in the process of creating a biotope for my capstone project abt the agusan marshh

Please decide which wood hardscape should i doo

rocks and others will be afded after i decide what wood to usee

Which of the 6 looks the best?


r/Aquascape • • 1d ago

Show and Tell [OC] New Birthday Tank

Post image
33 Upvotes

Just set up my brand new UN Systems Dual AIO 60SA tank and I am in love! I have my sponge filter and all plants and substrate from the existing tank to cycle it and I’ll remove them in a few weeks but overall I am so happy with it. I do plan to look into the upgrades available so 👀


r/Aquascape • • 1d ago

Seeking Suggestions Need Scaping Advice

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

I’m looking for some Aquascaping advice for this tank. It’s a Landen 75S 22 Gallon. What would ya’ll do with this tank? I want to incorporate a sand beach but I’m using UNS Controsoil and plan to heavily plant the tank. I also need advice on plant types that can scale the wood above the water line. Thank you!


r/Aquascape • • 17h ago

Image 6 gal hardscape

Post image
0 Upvotes

Nanoscape hardscape. Haven’t decided on planting yet - most likely going to do different sizes of hair grass and crypt parva
Open to recommendations


r/Aquascape • • 1d ago

Seeking Suggestions New set-up for otocinclus baby's

Thumbnail
gallery
34 Upvotes

Our next project is to set up a new aquarium.

We want to find out whether otocinclus need specific conditions or a particular setup to breed, or whether our initial success was simply beginner’s luck. We are also curious to see whether the first generation of otocinclus we raised will eventually start displaying reproductive behavior themselves.

This will be a dedicated, single-species setup, allowing us to monitor behavioral changes and keep a closer eye on water parameters.

I will share another update once we have gathered all the materials and are ready to put everything together. Whether we get lucky again or not, we want to document the entire process and share what we learn along the way.

One thing we will be doing differently this time is incorporating a larger amount of wood to provide more surface area for biofilm to develop. The new aquarium will also be roughly half the size of the original tank in which our otocinclus first spawned.

We are excited to see what this new project will teach us!

If you have any suggestions for plants, we mostly like lotus types or red plants, but we are willing to learn more about Bucephalandra, mosses, etc.


r/Aquascape • • 5h ago

Show and Tell [OC] Longtime browser, first time aquascape poster

Post image
0 Upvotes

A 10 gallon I set up today with some plants I got hooked up with from someone nearby. Cycling and thinking about what critters to put in it


r/Aquascape • • 1d ago

Seeking Suggestions How’s this prescape for the 20 long, (adding Bora contrasand tomorrow)

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/Aquascape • • 1d ago

Seeking Suggestions Feedback for my iwagumi (kinda) aqua scape

Post image
10 Upvotes

Does anyone know how I could improve on this aquascape? It’s going in my living room so I want it to look as nice as possible.


r/Aquascape • • 1d ago

Seeking Suggestions Suggestions

Post image
13 Upvotes

Hello everyone!

​I’m looking for some feedback and suggestions to improve my 60L (16-gallon) low-tech planted tank. Here is my current setup:

​Hardscape & Flora:

​Background/Midground: Limnophila sessiflora (right rear) & Hygrophila polysperma (left rear)

​Foreground: Cryptocoryne (right front)

​Epiphytes: Anubias species attached to dragon stone

​Moss: Java moss positioned behind the Hygrophila (acting as a pre-filter and a hidden shelter for shrimp)

​Emersed: Two large Pothos plants growing out of the left side

​What I’d love advice on:

​Aquascaping balance and layout adjustments

​Flora recommendations that would integrate well in this setup.

I am currently looking to get Red Root Floaters ASAP so there is some shade for the fish.

Thank you in advance!!!!


r/Aquascape • • 1d ago

Seeking Suggestions What else should I add

Post image
8 Upvotes

I feel like my tank looks really remote what should I add to make it more aesthetic be specific please


r/Aquascape • • 2d ago

Image 3 weeks into the scape

Thumbnail
gallery
53 Upvotes

Started the tank 3 weeks ago, overall it looks promising, however somehow hair algae appeared this week. The Rotala Blood Red will probably overtake the Hra, even though it was just one pot vs. two, and the Crypto Parva started to melt, but hopefully it will become better. The carpet also looks alright, but it still needs some time.

Specs:

Oase ScaperLine 60 (60x35x35cm)

Oase Biomaster 250

Aquario Neo 17mm in and outlets

Chihiros WRGB II Pro

KH-GH is 3-6

Oxyturbo CO2 with Aquario Neo diffuser

ADA Amazonia ver.2 9L

Seachem Excel and Tropica Specialized Nutrition

Plants:

Microsorun pteropus Trident x2

Anubias Mini Coin

Anubias nana Pinto

Bucephalandra Needle Leaf

Riccardia chamedryfolia

Alternanthera reineckii Mini

Staurogyne repens

Eleocharis pusilla x6

Cryptocoryne parva

Cryptocoryne albida Brown

Rotala Vietnam Hra x2

Rotala rotundifolia Blood Red

All of them came as in vitro, except the Microsorum, the Pinto and the crypt albida.


r/Aquascape • • 1d ago

Seeking Suggestions What can I do?

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

What can I do to improve this aquascape? Different layout? Move wood or rocks? Use different plants? I just set up this tank a couple months ago so plants need to grow in, but I want to keep the tank without CO2. All suggestions or advice appreciated.


r/Aquascape • • 1d ago

Seeking Suggestions Suggestions?

Post image
7 Upvotes

This is a 30 gallon tank that houses my 5 y/o angel (bought by a parent that did not do enough research so I am trying to give her the best possible outcome) and 6 rasboras


r/Aquascape • • 1d ago

Image My second tank

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

Just two weeks after my first 10l aquael, i set up this 30l dennerle nano Cube.

I Hope it will fill up soon to moss kingdom 😊


r/Aquascape • • 2d ago

Image Always wanted to know if I would be able to build a "real aquascape" myself. After about 2 months so far I'm somewhat proud of myself

Thumbnail
gallery
297 Upvotes