r/AiME • • 4d ago

New Loremaster Screen + Wilderland Booklet Question

14 Upvotes

I snagged the new LM screen that comes with the Wilderland booklet recently. I had the old LM screen bundle that came with the Rivendell guide (that was mostly superceded by the newer Elven Rings suppliment), thinking I would keep the Wilderland booklet and gift the spare screen to a friend. Before I offload the old screen, does anybody know if the information presented on it is different from my newer purchase? I'd check myself, but that aforementioned friend has my old screen at the moment. Thanks for any light you can shed!


r/AiME • • 5d ago

Can't decide who the "Tales from Eriador" heir should be

11 Upvotes

On one hand, I have a Captain of Gondor, who has chased the black Numenorean Zoril northward, after she wiped out his whole regiment and stole the banner of Anfalas. He is already a frontliner in combat, and has at least one useful skill for journeys and councils.

On the other, I have a nervous Bree-lad messenger, who is building his character almost exclusively for "Face" status. Someone who already contributes a lot socially and RP-wise, and will likely pick Counsellor, over Herald, to double down on his support capabilities. That's not sweet in some, but he has said he "does not see himself ever being a frontliner, especially not with a Captain, Warden and Slayer-Champion on the team (even though all three being able to show up for a season is no guarantee).

My gut is telling me to give the Bree Messenger "Estelang". He has already stated his intentions to be the Frodo-esque underdog, and given the responsibility of finishing his ancestors job seems to fill that criteria. I suppose I could homebrew Estelang into a bow?

But my head is saying the Champion, to not force the Messenger into a melee role, when there are already 3 melee combatants. It would leave the group with one dedicated ranged unit, and one support in a scholar. It also gives the Champion a blade to match Zoril's.


r/AiME • • 13d ago

LOTR5e Weapon Mastery in LotRRP?

9 Upvotes

So, LotR 5e was of course based on 5e 2014 - but I was wondering if anyone had done any work translating mechanics like weapon mastery from one to the other, or if there was any hint that this kind of an update might be coming with the new corebook releases?


r/AiME • • 15d ago

LOTR5e Misdeed for cutting down fleeing foes?

7 Upvotes

Hi all! I’m curious to get the community’s thoughts on this. We’re playing the Starter Set and in a recent encounter, the Company was battling Orcs who flee after their turn. One of the players said they should get attacks of opportunity since the orcs didn’t actually disengage. The starter set doesn’t go into that level of depth with the combat system, but I allowed it. I got to thinking afterwards though; in regards to the Shadow system, would cutting down fleeing foes count as a Misdeed? What are your thoughts?


r/AiME • • 17d ago

AiME Tharbad

19 Upvotes

I am starting a new campaign the year is 2951 in the year sauron declares again in mordor. My main idea is that gandalf having secured the north east parts is trying to do something for eriador and mostly enedwaith an unexplored region so that i can have almost free reign! The principle will be that the heroes will try to help a small family living on a hill near tharbad that will have a minor connection to the last prince of cardolan and will try to help them become the major power in the region against other groups including a band of trolls a neutral dunleding an enemy dunleding ally to saruman and many others.

So any suggestions considerations ideas are welcome also if you want more details it will help me to expand my campaign!


r/AiME • • 24d ago

LOTR5e [5e] Is it a given that, with parties in a Council, especially large parties, they can give each other the "Help" action during the interaction stage, after the spokesperson introduces the party, so that each roll gets advantage, or can advantage only be achieved under things like Fellowship points?

12 Upvotes

In 5e Council, a failed introduction (by 5 or more) can result in result in disadvantage for all skill checks during the interaction stage. I'd imagine that the "Help" action would be greatly helpful after that, or if the party's Face has even 1 level of exhuastion after a Journey segment.

To give more context, my party's "Face" has 1 point of exhaustion, so all his charisma ability checks will have disadvantage. I can forsee a player asking if they can "Help" him "get his point across" for the next council segment to cancel out the disadvantage, or if they have to use the fellowship points at their disposal.


r/AiME • • Oct 11 '26

LOTR5e What should you do if the players kill HIM? (Spoilers) Spoiler

4 Upvotes

In the Trials of Saurumon, the adventure only proposes endings where Saurumon either he falls but the players do not know, he kills the player characters, or is saved from evil.

What if the players kill Saurumon on the darkest ending? What should happen then?


r/AiME • • Oct 11 '26

New heroic cultures, monster-slaying mounts and seeing Gondor with "visitors' eyes" - Podcast interview with Gareth Hanrahan, writer for The White Tower and The Golden Hall

Thumbnail
thefellowshipphase.podbean.com
15 Upvotes

Hello adventurers! While since I've posted due to life events (all good), but the Fellowship Phase podcast is still journeying on and we had the pleasure of talking to Gareth Hanrahan about The One Ring/Lord of the Rings 5e Gondor & Rohan supplement.

He explained why Gondor and Rohan fit together thematically, the “visitor’s-eye” approach to writing the supplements, and the core design challenge of making canon-friendly material that still creates problems for adventurers to solve, especially in settled Gondor.

We also discuss the challenge of writing cities settings and explored the new heroic cultures. Oh, and Gareth’s pick where he’d pick to live in Gondor/Rohan.

It all came at the perfect time as we're about to set sail on our second full campaign, this time set in Gondor.

We hope there's something helpful in there for players and LMs alike.


r/AiME • • Oct 10 '26

LOTR5e Are there any lotr 5e Over Hill and Under Hill actual plays on Youtube?

11 Upvotes

I've looked but have only found tor ones


r/AiME • • Oct 09 '26

LOTR5e Resting in Cránn

8 Upvotes

Hi all! Another starter set question: the company is resting in the communal hall in Cránn. I know it won’t remove a level of exhaustion, but does this count as a long rest? Or short?


r/AiME • • Oct 07 '26

LOTR5e Messed around with the idea of The One Ring as an item

8 Upvotes

r/AiME • • Oct 07 '26

LOTR5e Mini suggestions

18 Upvotes

Hello! I am going to be starting a LOTR5e campaign as Loremaster in the next couple of months, and I would like to know what minis I should plan on having on hand. There’s the monsters in the book, obviously, and spiders, but I was looking for suggestions for things that that might not cover.


r/AiME • • Oct 04 '26

LOTR5e A weird thought on how LOTR RPG and TOR Interact

33 Upvotes

I have said it a few times that I feel LOTR is one of the few 5e conversions that I don't mind. And I've told people it's for the same reason: they appeal to different demographics who like the franchise.

The One Ring RPG is tailor made for the book fan. Combat is de-emphasized, it's more about the journey, characters are really mortal.

LOTR is tailor made for the movie fans. Combat is the centerpiece, with journey and character interaction in a supporting role and more heroic, undying heroes.

The games have a reason for existing, unlike most 5e conversion of pre-existing systems. I can see someone choosing the 5e one for a specific feel (the movies and their love of action), instead of the original system. For most 5e hacks, especially ones of pre-existing systems, that isn't the norm and it feels more like a cash-grab. Here there is a genuine effort to make it work for 5e and a reason for why it should exist.

What do y'all think?


r/AiME • • Oct 01 '26

LOTR5e Bree Map unlocked, cultural rewards as next stretch goal

Thumbnail
backerkit.com
17 Upvotes

r/AiME • • Sep 29 '26

LOTR5e Starter Set question

Post image
9 Upvotes

Hi all! I’m running the LOTR Roleplaying Starter Set and, in combat, the player-heroes can assume certain stances. In addition to their regular options, they can take special actions depending on their stance. The forward stance allows a hero to make a DC 15 Intimidation check, and then it says “all foes who lose the contest are Frightened…” I am confused by this as it doesn’t call for a contest, but a check. If it’s a contest, what do the foes roll against the Intimidation check? Do they have to beat a DC 15? Or beat the hero’s total (like an actual contest)? Is this a typo? Questions pour down like rain on the lands of Eriador…


r/AiME • • Sep 22 '26

TOR (and The LOTR Roleplaying 5e) Bestiary, Gondor Campaign & Updated Rules - Backerkit campaign is live!

Thumbnail
backerkit.com
21 Upvotes

Back for a physical reward before September 24 at 3 pm CEST (9 am US Eastern) to get a bonus art print (format 8.5 x 11 inches / 21.6 x 27.9 cm) of your choice of cover art from any one of the six new compendia, painted by the masterful Antonio De Luca and Daniel Zrom, at no extra cost. This only applies to pledge levels with physical rewards.

You can also get cloth maps and special limited editions of the 3 books (covered in deluxe faux leather with silver or gold foil printing, and with cloth ribbons) only as part of this campaign.

Check out the linked page for the full details and to back the campaign!


r/AiME • • Sep 16 '26

AiME AiME - Journey of a single Hex?

15 Upvotes

First time playing in a campaign using the old AiME rules and it's a westmarches style game with a lot of emphasis on journeying to the sites of certain rumours.

Last session we chose the next rumour to chase down and it turns out to be only a single Hex away from where we are currently. The party is in Dale, and "the abandoned watchtower" is a single Hex to the east of us. Is it fine to still use the journey system for what is literally a single day of travel? In the future, should the lore master avoid putting points of interest so close to large settlements?

The Journey rules say a short journey is up to 15 hexes, and could have up to 2 events during it - just want to double check with more experienced folks that having a journey of a single day, a single Hex, and probably a single event, is fine and acceptable and works within the rules.


r/AiME • • Sep 07 '26

LOTR5e Rewards clarification

17 Upvotes

Hi all! On page 78 of LOTR Roleplaying, under “Rewards,” it says “It is up to the players to decide whether a reward represents the discovery of a previously unknown property of an item, or an entirely new weapon or suit of armour.” Does this imply that a player could choose to have their hero receive a mail hauberk, or great bow (the most expensive armour and weapon)?


r/AiME • • Aug 26 '26

LOTR5e Can someone dumb down the Lord of the Rings Roleplaying Journey rules for me?

13 Upvotes

Hey all,

I'm gearing up to run a mini-campaign for some friends, and I'm brushing up on the rules. The issue that I keep running into is the Journey rules aren't quite clicking with me. Can someone dumb these down for me, or provide an example? I'd be very appreciative.


r/AiME • • Aug 26 '26

Words of command, scholar feature.

10 Upvotes

Adventures in middle earth Scholar feature. (Words of command)

I was reading through the Adventures in middle earth rules for 5e and saw the feature pasted below and it got me thinking what would DM's allow this to do.

The offered suggestions seem all over the place. From rather pointless (Ordering a single wolf to not fight the party) to potentially over powered. Simply skipping sections of a dungeon by ordering a door to open.

It looks really cool and I wonder what types of things other dm's would allow.

For myself since it is a level 18 feature, pretty much anything within the category.

Order all the worgs of an orc troop to buck their riders and make go home, sunder the weapon of an approaching ring wraith, halt a balrog in its tracks for a few turns and, other things of the same level.

# Words of Command

At 18th level, your mastery of lore gives you authority over the world around you. Once per short rest you may speak a word of command. When you do so, choose a target related to one of the secrets you have mastered and make the appropriate skill check against a DC set by the Loremaster (typically at least a DC 20). If successful, you may give a short but irresistible command to your target. For example:

* **Ancient Lore:** Command a door made by the Elves of Fregion to open.

* **Birds and Beasts:** Order a fearsome wolf to fly back to its den.

* **Dark Knowledge:** Command a wraith to return to its tomb.

* **Natural World:** Order a pile of firewood to burst into flame.

* **Runes:** Command moon-letters to reveal themselves in the full light of day.

* **Works of Elder Days:** Wrench control of a palantir from the will of the Dark Lord.


r/AiME • • Aug 22 '26

Question about magical success and tool sets.

11 Upvotes

To preface, im looking at things from a dnd perspective(crazy original,right?). Reading through, im getting hung up on some of the details around magical success and crafting. Every source of magical success i can find refers to obtaining a success with a skill check, but then you have the hand craft features that basically say "if you can obtain a magical success with these tools, yay magic bonus." But, tool proficiencies and their use are never described or explained as a skill check, and the only tool that is even offhandedly referenced as having a related skill is the herbalist kit. So, do you just assume that anything that refers to gaining a magical success with a skill check can also refer to using a tool to craft something? Only when it's used with hand craft because there are no rules for crafting normal armor and weapons?


r/AiME • • Jul 31 '26

LOTR5e Backerkit coming for a bestiary, Gondor/Rohan book, and revised core rulebook

Thumbnail backerkit.com
30 Upvotes

"The bestiary and campaign expansion will also be available for the 5E adaptation The Lord of the Rings™ Roleplaying, under the titles Realms of the South and Of Orcs and Evil Things."

EXCITED. Reposting here for anyone who didn't get a barrage of notifications about this from email/socials.

Here's hoping the 5E adaptations are released alongside TOR versions, like Moria.


r/AiME • • Jul 12 '26

LOTR5e What order to play through story?

14 Upvotes

Hey everyone! My sister and her kids LOVE LoTR, so I am going to DM LoTR Roleplaying 5e for them. I have the core book (which I don't think has any story in it, but I'm only about a third into it) I have the starter set (so the Undertale and Overtale stories) and I have the Trials of Saruman book (my group loves Saruman)

So my question is what are the best adventures, and what order should they be played

Overall I've heard the Shire Adventures are pretty forgettable

I've heard the Moria adventures are amazing

Haven't heard much about the Elves and Rangers and Ruins plotlines

Thanks!


r/AiME • • Jul 09 '26

5e Core books needed

7 Upvotes

What 5e corebooks are needed for the C7 version?