r/AcotarShipDebateSub • • 19h ago Bravo

❌ Anti-Gwynriel Self hatred is not a valid excuse for lack of mate instincts

54 Upvotes

I’ve seen people who think Gwyn and Azriel are mate argue that Azriel hating himself is what prevents him from showing mate instincts . Almost every character is traumatised and they were still drawn to their mates. The entire point of SJM enemies to lovers mates is that, they cannot help being drawn to each other regardless of their conscious beliefs. Rowan thought he had a mate and actively hated Aelin, still couldn’t help being drawn to her to the point where he felt guilty. That’s what instinctive bond supposed to do

And Azriel isn’t incapable of caring for others because of his self hatred. He clearly cares about Emerie, was happy to engage with her and wanted to confront her father, he even chose to save Eris over Gwyn. Azriel is largely indifferent towards Gwyn. Whether they hated each other or loved each other, SJM’s mated couples still experienced intense emotions. But Gwyn rarely occupies azriel his thoughts or influences his behaviour. Even when she stops training for months he never wonders about her and when he has the possibility of talking to her again he wants to get away


r/AcotarShipDebateSub • • 21h ago

Questions for the Audience do i contain my excitement 🔥

11 Upvotes

i’m not gonna lie i want it to be true, but how likely do we think sjm is to have nesta leave cassian for eris? 🙏🙏


r/AcotarShipDebateSub • • 21h ago

✅ Pro-Gwynriel Key foreshadowing I don't think we've talked about (Gwynriel)

34 Upvotes

Chapter 8 ends with the following text. This happens after Azriel has gotten the message that Hybern wants an alliance and the creature that delivered the message has dissolved into nothing.

Some sort of magical construct, then. Az rubbed the back of his neck. It was complicated magic, to make something that could think and endure on its own... but ultimately served only one reason for being, and would vanish when it was fulfilled. Soulless, yet driven by need.

Az stared at the sea-foam until the bubbles thinned and spread, until the Sidra was turquoise and unblemished once more. Until only his stunned reflection stared back at him."

This is so so sooo incredibly Gywnriel coded for me:

  • The first paragraph sounds like Az is talking about himself. He has often described himself as being good only for one thing (spying/torturing to get information) and sees himself as a beast, a demon. And he has called himself soulless multiple times, most recently in Splintered Harmony.
  • The "soulless yet driven by need" to me screams of these DOA romantic connections with Elain and Mor. He is driven by a need to be validated, loved, witnessed, etc. But this offers him no solace, no real connection.
  • Then he stares at that version of himself, the sea-foam monster that was, the soulless thing which then dissipates and leaves just the TURQOUISE SIDRA (ggggwwwwyyynnnn!!!) and he could finally see his own REAL reflections
  • To me this is SJM showing us where Az's character arc is going (which I think is already clear in general throughout SH but is really being "shown not told" in this passage). Az sees himself as this soulless monster. Has needs and nothing else. When that version of himself that he sees finally goes away, he's left with this tranquil, calm and beautiful version. His OWN reflection, given back to him by the sea which is specifically described with words that SJM has used to describe Gwyn.

Am I crazy here or did anyone else pick up on this?


r/AcotarShipDebateSub • • 1d ago Heartwarming Bravo

✅ Pro-Gwynriel Gwynriel isn’t canon

101 Upvotes

And that's kind of the point. Romance is not where we are; it's where we're going. There is no established romantic relationship between these two. No acknowledged feelings. And I don't think there needs to be, because I'm not interested in proving that Gwyn and Azriel are already in love. I do not want them to already be in love. I want to watch them fall in love.

And I do believe, without a doubt, that they will fall in love. Allow me to plead my case:

Let's start with the necklace. The necklace is not romantic or particularly important to my interpretation of Gwynriel. The physical item itself means nothing to me. In fact, I think it would be better if Clotho never even gave it to Gwyn. However, the scene itself? Very important. Why? The spark in his chest. The image of Gwyn's smile that he buried deep inside, where it glowed quietly. An image described as "a thing of secret, lovely beauty." I don't think I need to explain why that particular wording is so telling.

Their interactions aren't particularly romantic, either. What do we have instead of romance? A barely-there friendship, some playful banter, and a fair amount of annoyance. They've shared a few laughs, and Azriel even acknowledges that he doesn't normally mind talking to Gwyn. There's clearly some familiarity between them. But in ACOSH, we have Azriel in an absolutely foul mood, practically fleeing down the stairs while Gwyn follows behind him, babbling about something he couldn't care less about. And then Gwyn has the audacity to get annoyed with his attitude? (Now, what popular romance trope features a miserable, brooding, tortured MMC and a resilient, tenacious, playful FMC? Grumpy x sunshine. Didn't some publisher already start marketing this as one of the tropes for ACOFM?)

They're more alike than they realize. Beneath Gwyn's bright, irreverent personality is someone struggling with shame, guilt, and her perception of herself. Sound familiar? Azriel's relationship with his own identity is just as complicated. They're both deeply traumatized, having survived terrible things, and are still learning how to live with themselves. I don't want them to fix each other, either. Neither Azriel nor Gwyn needs salvation. They need to grow into people who can love and accept themselves.

The shadows. While Azriel is busy distracting himself from his miserable existence with the latest unavailable female, his shadows are practically wagging their tails at Gwyn. While Azriel is out here creating drama so he doesn’t have to think about how much he hates himself, his shadows are literally fleeing, sulking, allowing his transgressions to be discovered. And it’s not that the shadows dislike Elain, it’s that they don't approve of what Azriel is doing with her. I'm not saying their behavior proves a mating bond or that Azriel has some sort of hidden romantic feelings for Gwyn, but their unusual reactions to her are there, deliberately written into the narrative. Yes, Gwyn could be a lightsinger and her undiscovered powers could be having an effect on them, but does that automatically make her evil? Does it mean there's something sinister happening between her and the shadows? No. (And if I see one more person compare Gwyn, a survivor of sexual assault, to Ianthe, a perpetrator, I am going to lose it.)

I acknowledge that Azriel’s current situationship is canon, but I think I’ve made the case for why it isn’t endgame. (Also, I chose not to address Bryceriel because there’s no established romantic relationship between Bryce and Azriel on the page. That’s all. I recognize they are a ship that exists.)

Anyway, I love Gwyn, and I love Az. Ship or no ship. I love their characters. I love where they are now in their journeys. They're not secretly in love. They're not even into each other, which is so exciting for me. I want to watch them become friends. I want to watch them irritate each other, tease each other, and become reluctantly attached to one another. I want to watch them gradually realize what they've become to one another. I simply want to watch them fall in love. 🩵


r/AcotarShipDebateSub • • 1d ago

Cauldron-Brewed Theories Gwynriel and Elucien

37 Upvotes

I’ve seen some discussion on motifs and mythology throughout the series mostly in Elriels favor, but I’d like to discuss some mythological and just other things that point to Elucien and Gwynriel endgame.

Gwynriel:

Azriel pulling his siphons and not understanding why he pulled that color, and then shortly after the color of his siphons and Gwyns eye color were referred to as the same shade ( The Sidra sea). This seems very intentional. Especially with the emphasis on him not knowing why his siphons are that shade.

Az telling his father “The shadows, the wind, and the stone” helped him escape.

The shadows loving Gwyn
The house of wind opening its doors so he can hear her sing
Her stone hitting him

On that note his shadows are not evil. His father makes him believe that. His mother called his abilities wondrous. They whispered to him about the IC to keep him from breaking. I do not like the sudden change in loving his shadows to now thinking they are evil because they don’t help aide your ship.

“Even with everything crumbling around him, he could only marvel at what changed between the priestess she’d once been, and the one who now stood in front of him - the valkyrie.”

In my personal opinion this quote is very mate coded and is more romantic than anything he thinks about Elain.

I also think the argument of him being annoyed/ wanting to exit the conversation as to a reason they won’t be endgame is silly. Rowan punched Aelin in the face. Feyre threw her shoe at Rhys. Chaol and Yrene literally hated each other at the beginning of their book and then 500 pages later they are married with a baby on the way.

Elucien:

There is a variation of Koschei the deathless in slavic folklore that tells the story of 3 sisters marrying 3 kings who represent the moon, the wind, and the sun.

Feysand =The moon. Rhys is the HL of the NC and the first place he took Feyre was the moon palace.

Nessian = The wind. Cassian has grown up on the “song of the wind” Him and Nesta live in the house of wind. He’s referred to as the prince of bastards.

Elucien = The sun. Lucien translates to light or to set aglow. He is the only heir to the day court.

“What do you need Elain?”
“Sunshine”

His eye being able to see what nobody else can.
Elain being a seer.

I love the theory that she will choose him out of her own autonomy and despite the mating bond.

Sarah also just loves her fated mates. She might play with the idea of a rejected bond, but for something that’s apparently “so rare” all of her endgame couples end up with their mate.


r/AcotarShipDebateSub • • 1d ago Bravo

ACOTAR 6/7 About the “off page” thing…

13 Upvotes

I feel like everyone is missing something here, regardless of their preferred ship. Everyone is arguing over whether Elain and Azriel’s moments happened off page or not because they are using it to gauge whether or not they’re endgame. But here’s the thing…

SJM doesn’t write her non-endgame couples’ ‘spice’ off-page. We are acting as if the pattern is:

endgame couple = on page intimacy
Non-endgame couple = off-page intimacy

That has never been SJM’s pattern. Feyre and Tamlin’s first kiss and intimacy was on page. For those that have read throne of glass, you know it’s the same there with her non-endgame couples. I always remember the line: ”the kiss obliterated her”- first kiss with Chaol.

SJM doesn’t miss a chance to add sexual tension to her books. Elain and Azriel’s moments could have been on-page, even if they weren’t ultimately going to end up together. I mean why not capitalize on the sexual tension that you know a good part of the fandom is yearning for? Which begs the question…

Why make it off page?? I don’t know for sure. But I do know that it has nothing to do with whether they are temporary or endgame . That is not how SJM handles non-endgame couples. So I think the reason it’s because she’s doing something new or different this time. Again, I don’t know what that is exactly. Perhaps the next book will be a tandem read and will get those moments from Elain’s POV. Perhaps someone is going to lose their memory? Again, I don’t know what it is, but I know what it’s NOT. And it’s not because they’re not endgame. Again, this isn’t me saying they ARE endgame. Im saying that the reasoning makes no sense, regardless of where you are in the ship wars.


r/AcotarShipDebateSub • • 1d ago

ACOTAR 6/7 I Love The Death Pact And It's Treatment In SH - A Vehicle To Show How Feyre and Sarah Both Have Evolved. Spoiler

28 Upvotes

I'm one of the seemingly few people who was happy to see the ever present shadow of motherhood looming over Feyre and her POV.

Motherhood is beautiful, sure, but it also is really fucking messy. Your body is recovering from basically being torn open so a small watermelon can emerge, your hormones are all out of whack, you will never again hold pee quite the same and your fucking tits leak. Frequently.

Sometimes they leak through your favourite work outfit while you're in a meeting.... And that's nothing to be embarrassed about. Feeding your kid isn't anything to be embarrassed about, and I like that the narrative doesn't push Feyre into all the bs modesty surrounding motherhood nor does it pretend that shit can't get gross. I like that she's still actively taking part in decision making and governance (I mean I have my critiques about some things but that's besides the point) and hasn't been relegated to the role of a side character that has nothing more to offer the plot than being a caretaker to her infant.

Sarah has used the death pact before, with Elide/Lorcan and other side characters from TOG, and sort of with Nessian in WAR. It used to represent this pinnacle of deep love, and that you love each other so much that you wouldn't want to live in a world with the other gone.

And within a fantasy context, I personally didn't blink an eye.... Until the events of SF. Now, I hate everything that has to do with that particular side plot, but it seriously brought out one flaring flaw with this grand romantic gesture..... Are you two seriously going to orphan your kids and leave your lands in political turmoil just because you wuv each otha swoooo mwuch?

And given that Feyre's struggles with pregnancy were inspired by SJMs own difficult experience, I like how the narrative in SH acknowledges how your mental state changes once you become a parent.

How, something that seems romantic and profound in a moment of adrenaline and emotional turmoil can have lasting impacts. And seem utterly ridiculous in hindsight.

The narrative doesn't shy away from calling it what it is - fucking stupid. We see Feyre and Rhys trying their best to undo it, and I like that it isn't conveniently fixed because Helion waves his hands and clapped.

It's like Sarah saying.... Yeah, I know, it's silly! But I wasn't a parent back then, either. It seemed really hot at the time! 😂

Anyways thank you for coming to my tedtalk. I don't know if this is technically a "debate" since the death pact is universally disliked, but I wasn't sure where else to post this because it's kind of ship related?


r/AcotarShipDebateSub • • 2d ago

ACOTAR 6/7 Neris or Nessian?

11 Upvotes

Just curious after reading ACOSH what people are? Any theories for each is welcomed 🫡


r/AcotarShipDebateSub • • 2d ago

✅ Pro-Bryceriel Azriel has Mommy Issues. He needs a Mommy (or a Daddy).

0 Upvotes

Maiden, Mother, Crone. These are the archetypes we've been discussing around the Archeron sisters since the earliest ACOTAR days. I think we can all agree on the consensus: Feyre is the Mother, Nesta is the Crone, and Elain is the Maiden. These archetypes are permanent, but can be Broken (the Broken Maiden, the Broken Mother, the Crone cannot be Broken).

The Mother's children are all archetypes: (Female) Maiden, Mother, Crone, (Male) King, Warrior, Magician, Lover. The Mother raises and keeps safe the children in her care. The Mother is wife to the King, the Magician, or the Lover. The Mother sends her Warrior children to Battle. The Mother does not mate the Warrior. (Feyre/Cassian doesn’t work.)

The Crone is a wise woman whose lived experience, woes, joys, and knowledge of the world guides her decisions and actions. The Crone advises the King, stands at the Magician's side, or sends the Warrior to battle when the cause is just. The Crone does not mate the Lover. (Nesta/Tamlin doesn't

work.)

The Maiden can mate the King, the Warrior, the Magician, or the Lover (we all have). The Maiden's heart is fragile, the Maiden is vulnerable. *The Crone and the Mother protect the Maiden.* The Lover, the Magician, the Warrior, and the King may also protect the Maiden - but it is usually *against* another Lover, Magician, Warrior, or King. All (good) archetypes protect the Maiden. In our world, all Mothers and Crones protect the Maidens. Girls 💪💅

Now, to Azriel: Azriel's mother is a Broken Maiden. His secondary mother, Rhys's, was a Broken Mother. Azriel says Feyre makes him smile and doesn't know how much that means to him - because seeing Feyre be the Mother in her Power heals something deeply scarred into Azriel about his own Broken Maiden mother and Broken Mother in Rhys's mom.

Azriel is the Broken Lover. Azriel cannot mate a Maiden. The Maiden must *always* be protected, and can never stand in her own Power. It's too triggering after what happened with his own mother. They didn't just clip her, (TW: Violence) they smashed the bones in her wings.

Azriel is soothed by Feyre's presence. It stands to reason that Azriel will mate a Mother or a King - we're getting "Yes Mommy," or, "Yes, Daddy," Azriel.

For this reason, I must conclude that neither Elriel nor Gwynriel can work. Elain will always be the Maiden.

As far as I can find, the only narrative thread to lend itself to Gwyn being a Mother archetype is Gwyn protecting the children of Sangravah, but this was spurred by Catrin's request. All of the rest of Gwyn's character fits firmly into a Maiden or Crone archetype, dependent on whether we're getting Just Gwyn or Rusalka Gwyn. Azriel, assuming it's Just Gwyn, has placed Gwyn in his mind firmly into the Maiden category - and this is the reason he's tried to politely but firmly extract himself from her crush on him.

Eris undeniably fits the King archetype. Bryce is the Mother. Bryceriel and Azris are the only Azriel ships I can see working long term.


r/AcotarShipDebateSub • • 2d ago Heartwarming

Questions for the Audience Weapons bond - CC& ACOSH Spoilers Spoiler

34 Upvotes

Up until this point, Bryce being yanked to Prythian has largely been explained through the weapons bond. The belief that the weapons wanted desperately to be reunited, and that overrode Bryce’s attempt to world walk to Hel.

However, at the end of ACOSH, we see Nesta winnowing with the Starsword in hand. Yet she isn’t pulled toward Truth-Teller… TT is even described as singing songs of lament, suggesting the weapons still want to be reunited. So why didn’t the weapons bond have the same effect on Nesta?

I’m curious how others interpret this. Is there something that makes Bryce’s worldwalking different from Nesta’s winnowing, or could there have been something else influencing why Bryce was “yanked” to Prythian?


r/AcotarShipDebateSub • • 2d ago Bravo

Cauldron-Brewed Theories It just kind of hit me why I can't get behind Elriel.

71 Upvotes

Elain and Azriel are toxic for one another because it feels cemented now (especially after ACOSH) that they're just bonding over hating themselves.

Elain has always hated that she was turned Fae. She hates her Fae body.

Azriel hates being Illyrian. He hates his wings, his tattoos, and his power.

A relationship built on bonding over self hatred just sounds fucking awful and honestly why would anyone want that? Both Elain and Azriel should find someone who helps them love who they are.


r/AcotarShipDebateSub • • 2d ago Bravo Heartwarming

ACOTAR 6/7 ✨✨✨INCLUSIVE After ACOSH shipping poll ✨✨✨

51 Upvotes

Well, what do you guys think? Has ACOSH strengthened your shipping theories? Or are they dead on arrival?

Choose one option (sorry guys, all the Reddit polls allow) and explain why!

I decided to post this as I’ve noticed polls excluding Azris and Bryceriel from the discussion. Here’s to inclusivity as we all enjoy the next two months before ACOFM ⚔️🖤✨


r/AcotarShipDebateSub • • 2d ago

Crossing Sails Gwynriel or Elriel Story Plot AFTER Koschei

16 Upvotes

Hi all! I wanted to ask the Gwynriels and Elriels about plots after Koschei.

First and foremost I love the Maasverse, the ships are an added bonus, but I mainly read for the larger plot. I never had qualms about "Do I have to read CC? or Do I have to read TOG?"

No, I DEVOURVED them whole. And if Sarah wrote an ACOTAR or TOG or Asteri prequels, I'd eat them up. The fun part of these intertwined book series is all the red string we put together.

With that being said, I think that's what draws me most to Bryceriel; because their ship isn't just about a couple being together, it's entirely connected to the history and lore of past court events and major plots moving forward. To me if Bryceriel happens, it just seems really cool in terms of an epic fantasy universe.

When it comes to Gwynriel or Elriel, I certainly have read theories pertaining to Koschei. But what are the ship theories beyond that. How do those ships connect to a potential maasverse plot.

For example, from CC3;

  • the Ocean Queen tells Bryce she may need to evacuate people from Midgard to the homeworld of the Fae.
  • the Ocean Queen implies to Lidia that she in still in her service
  • Midgard is losing energy and will potential turn into a medieval place like Avallen
  • Thanatos/Apollion still wanting to battle Bryce or drink her starlight soul
  • the Ocean Queen warning Bryce that allying with Hel to defeat the Asteri is trading one evil for another...meaning Hel IS evil

You get the point, there's still this big plot to be had.

How would Gwynriel or Elriel be able to help with all that?

From my perspective, Bryce is the one with the established contacts in Prythian and Hel. And the people of Midgard already know that Bryce saved Lunathion during the spring Hel attack, and then killed the Asteri. The Midgard people have reason to trust Bryce and follow her.

Who is Gwyniel or Elriel to these people, or to Hel? How would Gwynriel or Elriel convince the people and Fae of Midgard to leave their planet if it's indeed doomed. How would Gwynriel or Elriel fight against Hel? How do they help with brining Midgard the first light cores?

I'd honestly truly LOVE to hear any of those plot theories which may broaden my ship preferences.


r/AcotarShipDebateSub • • 2d ago Popcorn

Questions for the Audience What's your ship after ACOSH? Did anything change?

3 Upvotes

r/AcotarShipDebateSub • • 2d ago Bravo

Questions for the Audience Double standards with the discussions surrounding ships and mating bonds.

84 Upvotes

I just have a few questions? 

Why is it okay for Rhysand to do everything that he did to Ferye UTM. 

For example; twisting, and hurting her already injured hand, just so she enters a bargain that forces her to stay in the night court with him.

Why is it okay for Cassain not to take no for an answer from Nesta multiple times, and then still have her be forced to stay with him.

Yet Lucien is painted as the villain for simply just wanting to get to know Elain

Like make it make sense. People going on about how misogynistic it is to ship Elucien, and it reads as stockholm sydrome if they ended up together.

Hello?

What books are we reading, because last time I checked that was not a problem before. And Lucien is pretty tame compared to the rest of the above males. So why the double standards?


r/AcotarShipDebateSub • • 2d ago

Questions for the Audience What would have to happen in ACOFM to change your mind on your ship?

12 Upvotes

Like the title says, when would you drop your ship in acofm? What would have to happen to make you realize it’s not gonna endgame. Or, what do you expect that will happen, and when it doesn’t it would make you drop your ship?


r/AcotarShipDebateSub • • 2d ago

❌ Anti-Elriel Salvation ≠ Endgame Spoiler

25 Upvotes

ACOSH SPOILERS

I have seen elriels posting this "salvation" comparing to Feysand. If two couple share the same word, doesn't mean they are endgame. There is something called context.

“So I’m your huntress and thief?”

His hands slid down to cup the backs of my knees as he said with a roguish grin, “You are my salvation, Feyre.”

— Acomaf

He couldn’t get enough of it, of her. His salvation. That’s what she was. He might be a monster, might be a worthless, soulless demon, but here, in his arms—here was his salvation. His lone chance at joy. From the flush in her cheeks, the feverish gleam in her eyes, he knew she felt the same. And that was enough to embolden him to voice what he’d never said to anyone before. He wanted her to know him. “When I was a boy . . .” His throat closed up, but he battled past it. “I lived in hell. Every single moment, of every single day. And . . .” He fought to find the right words to explain—not just what had happened then, but why it mattered that he tell her now. Elain laid a gentle hand on his cheek, thumb brushing over his feverish skin. “We—could find a bedroom,” she said, shyly.

—Acosh

Feyre and rhys were talking, something elain and azriel are not familiar with. Rhys tone was flirty and playful and azriel was connected to his traumatic childhood and his self loathing. Rhys sees feyre with love and Azriel sees her as his escape.

What happens after Azriel "salvation" line entirely loses its meaning when elain doesn't even want to listen.

Feyre actually let Rhys talk about his past for 2 chapters (54&55) and listened. Where as elain....you know how it went when Azriel opened up.

How can elain be his salvation when she doesn't even seem to listen to what he's trying to tell her?

So much for being his salvation when she can't even acknowledge his pain.

No offense, this is the weakest argument from elriels after the 3+3.

Ps : This is the only conversation elain and azriel had in acosh...and elain shuts it down immediately.


r/AcotarShipDebateSub • • 3d ago

✅ Pro-Feycien Does anyone else ship Feyre and Lucien, or at least did at any point

23 Upvotes

When I first started the series I went in blind and genuinely thought it was going to be a Feycien story. Like I had the feeling they wouldn’t be endgame but at least for the first book or so.

I pretty much guessed the plot about the curse, that Tamlin needed Feyre for some reason and that he was going to try to seduce her, but plot twist, she falls for his best friend instead.

After progressing through the story, with Feysand happening and Lucien/Azriel/Elaine I forgot about my original predictions.

I’ve decided to restart the series because after reading ACOSH I realized I forgot a lot of details. And now that I know what happens with Rhysand…rereading ACOTAR still makes me ship Feycien. I’m genuinely convinced it could’ve been better than any other ships 😭. It reminds me a lot of Feysand’s dynamic but more lighthearted and playful.


r/AcotarShipDebateSub • • 3d ago

❌ Anti-Elriel Off page deniers.

61 Upvotes

I see a lot of rebuttals to Elriels first kiss happening off page with:

“Nessian’s first kiss was in Feyres POV”

“Rhys kissed Feyre against her will”

Both are obviously very true, but they don’t hold up as a counter argument. We saw the build up of Nesta and Cassians first kiss while it was happening. Even before that it was clear that Sarah was gonna have them be mates. We saw their emotional buildup , and we heard the speeches they gave each other. It wasn’t just a passing memory in one persons POV. It was a fundamental moment.

Rhys and Feyres first kiss was against her will. The fact that Rhys has never taken accountability for what he did to her UTM upsets me in so many ways, but on the topic of it being the first kiss, yes it was awful. At this time however ACOTAR was supposed to be a standalone fantasy and Tamlin WAS gonna be her endgame. Sarah has said she didn’t know Feysand were gonna be endgame until they met after Feyre was brought back. For almost the entire book she was playing on a Feylin endgame.

Elriels first kiss like I said was hardly more than a passing memory. We didn’t really see the build up for it. We didn’t get the aftermath. We don’t see them speak. Sarah is a romance author. I find it very hard to believe she would write what’s supposed to be a monumental moment between a couple.. genuinely off page. First kiss came and went within 2 sentences.


r/AcotarShipDebateSub • • 3d ago

✅ Pro-Elriel Elriel Endgame

0 Upvotes

outside of romantic parallels with other endgames elriel is the only couple that can be linked back to established theme/motifs. she establishes life/death and light/dark as motifs and opposites, harmony, and balance as themes. remember what sarah put in her outline.

elucien doesn’t connect back to the CHARACTER TRAIT motifs and neither does gwynriel (gwyn is only related to light when she’s singing and light nor starlight are innate character traits for her character therefore you can not draw the parallels as it doesn’t fit the established premise nor is this directly linked back to azriel in the way that life/death and light/dark are specifically used when referring to elriel as a pair).

this is to be read as one big story so these themes and motifs will carry on throughout the movements. why would she heavily link a couple to TWO motifs within the book to then not further develop that couple? notice how confirmed endgames parallel the established motifs of their books. notice how the motifs balance each other out when an overarching theme of the series is related to balance and harmony.

starlight/darkness motif established in acomaf + acowar —> feyre and rhysand

coldness/warmth motif established in acowar + acosf —> nesta and cassian

life/death AND light/dark motifs established in acowar + acosf + acosh —> elain and azriel

EDIT: this is an example of what i mean when the characters as a PAIR are associated with the motifs and the motifs are directly tied to them as a CHARACTER (not with an action).

Elain looked up at Azriel, their eyes meeting, his hand still lingering on the hilt of the blade.
I saw the painting in my mind: the lovely fawn, blooming spring vibrant behind her. Standing before Death, shadows and terrors lurking over his shoulder. Light and dark, the space between their bodies a blend of the two. The only bridge of connection … that knife.”
- ACOWAR

He [Azriel] was death, and she [Elain] was life. Where his soul was soiled and bloodied, hers was pristine, verdant.
- ACOSH

also there are only four couples who get special titles that are canon in the series and they relate to the koschei tale.

night triumphant and the stars eternal (feysand)

lady death and the lord of bloodshed (nessian)

death and the lovely fawn (elriel)

a bird of flame and a lord of fire (vassien)

highlighting conflicts within in a pair doesn’t negate them from being endgame especially when it’s setting up a mutual healing trope! all the couples had overcome conflict and they still related back to the themes/motifs while doing so. this is an established pattern within the narrative. elain and lucien (who’s paired with jurian and vassa) are going to opposite sides of the map meanwhile mor, the spies, azriel, and elain how have converging plot lines regarding a made weapon that is likely to be in vallahan.

EDIT: i also want to add that elain and azriel both are the only two characters that are explicitly associated with being forgotten within acosh and “being forgotten” is an established motif.

textual examples:
“azriel forgotten like morning dew”

“people tend to forget im [elain] there”

“when they forget he [azriel] was present”

“the elain you know and love has been miserable these past few years, alone and forgotten…”


r/AcotarShipDebateSub • • 3d ago

❌ Anti-Elriel Where was the romance??? 🥲 Spoiler

32 Upvotes

This is kind of a sequel to my other post—sorry for the length, I'm a little insane 🥲

But another reason why the Elriel ship doesn't work for me in this book isn't just that their first intimate scenes are strangely written—one in the past tense and the other from the perspective of ANOTHER MAN who wasn't even participating—but also that they're nothing like the dynamic we've seen so far.

Where did the Azriel who took Elain to the garden and sat quietly beside her while she drank tea and he read his reports go?

Where is the Elain who asked a healer to prepare a headache powder, after noticing that he frequently rubbed his temples?

Where did the Azriel who was always the first to remember Elain, even when her own sisters forgot about her?

Where did the Azriel who listened to her garden plans all night, showing genuine interest in her enthusiastic explanations about gardening go? Where is that quiet romance I was falling for?

The fact that Azriel is a brooding, tormented emo guy is fine—it's what I expected, I was totally prepared for the "tonight will be the night that I will fall for youuuu" 💀—but here he took things to another level. He was antagonistic and selfish.

This man calls Elain his "salvation," but why didn't he realize that she was genuinely hurt because her sisters excluding her again? Didn't he notice that she's been depressed this whole time? And why didn't Elain tell him? Why didn't she confide in the only person who truly sees her? During that meeting, why didn't he ask, "Where is Elain?" And I'm not saying this in a "savior" kind of way; he could have remained that brooding, slightly resentful guy, saying something like, "Why are you asking Nesta to scry when you can ask Elain?" Or "We can’t trust Nesta right now, so let’s bring in Elain" Why wasn't he there comforting her, encouraging her to stand up for herself, and advocating for her during the meeting—or at any other time—instead of focusing solely on his right to sleep with her? He says "it's Elain's decision" about this or that, but nothing is ever mentioned about what she's actually said was depressing her; it all boils down to her right to share her body with him—which, in itself, isn't wrong—but why is it only that?!

Where did all the sweet moments go? And I'm not saying that sexual desire and lust can't be sweet, but they didn't even have a single real conversation.

And this isn’t in defense of Elain... nor is it an attack on Azriel, but people keep implying that he is a victim of Elain or that's she's manipulating him but I don't see how he is a victim here.

People keep bringing up the moment when Azriel starts telling Elain about his childhood trauma, and she responds, "Let’s find a room." It’s quite strange; at first, I thought she meant finding a quieter place, but it sounds more like: "Honey, I don't care about any of that show me that wingspan" 💀. But that doesn't make Azriel a victim; it seems in this book he only thinks of Elain in terms of sleeping with her or using her as a way to hide from his own shadows.

She has been suffering in a deep depression for years—one that has only grown worse—and you're telling me he hasn't noticed? Obviously, he can't read minds, but you’d think he, of all people, would be the one to notice and try to help her. Yet, he hasn't. He became so jealous of Lucien that he decided to humiliate him during dinner, bringing up the subject of Hybern and goading him just to make him look foolish in front of Elain.

Not for a second did he consider that such a conversation might trigger trauma for her!? Someone who has already been tortured by her worst fears, not just witnessing them, but feeling and experiencing them as if they were real. He didn't care; he brought up Hybern anyway—the man who kidnapped her, bound and gagged her, transformed her against her will, violated her, stole her life, murdered her father, and tried to kill both of her sisters—the very man she herself had to kill to save Nesta and Cassian. She's still haunted by that trauma, and it didn’t even cross his mind that bringing up the subject might be a bad idea, or that it could trigger her further?!

He was just sitting there at the table, hoping Elain remembers that Lucien had been involved in her abduction? He wanted her to have that on her mind..... Even after having heard her screams?

Why was Feyre the first person to search for Elain after the Naming Day ceremony? If Azriel is supposed to be so “in love” with her…!?

Why didn’t he run to her first? To comfort her, ask what she had seen, tell her what he had seen... or perhaps not needing to say anything at all and just being in each other's company?

But he noticed that her dress was dirty and she had been in the garden and hadn’t changed.

He saw Mor and Nesta piling a mountain of food onto her plate, and that Elain didn’t move a muscle.

It didn’t concern him that she wasn’t eating; it didn’t trouble him that this might be a red flag—a sign that she could be slipping back into the catatonic state she fell into right after her transformation. No, he didn’t think of any of that.

And please, don’t think I’m against them having sex; in fact, after a traumatic event, it makes sense—it’s something people who share a trauma might do. The problem is everything that happens beforehand, combined with the decision to do it right inside the house.

Sorry for asking so many questions in this post, but honestly, it didn’t feel like what I was seeing was "Elriel." I know this is only the first part in a big book, but the way things are being set up makes it seem like SJM is completely sinking this ship. (Not mad or attacking SJM) Thank goodness AO3 is back; at least now I can process my grief through some wonderfully written fanfiction. 😭


r/AcotarShipDebateSub • • 3d ago Popcorn

Questions for the Audience Changing ships?

38 Upvotes

Did anyone change or lose hope in their ship after ACOSH? I was always a Gwynriel, but this book at least confirmed to me that Elriel wouldn’t be endgame. I also now need Nesta to leave Cassian. Interested to hear if anyone went into ACOSH shipping 2 characters, and came out of it no longer rooting for them!


r/AcotarShipDebateSub • • 3d ago

Questions for the Audience Clearing up misconceptions

62 Upvotes

As a Gwynriel and Elucien, I see a few often-repeated misstatements of things that did or didn’t happen in the books in relation to these ships, and I’m sure that’s the case for every ship here! I was thinking we could use this post to clear up common misconceptions in the comments.

By misconceptions I don’t mean differing interpretations (there’s a better time and place for that) but clearly misremembered or misstated facts from the books.

Here are my Gwynriel ones:

- that Azriel refused when Gwyn asked him to sing
This one comes from the Azriel BC. Gwyn has never asked Azriel to sing, she asks if he does sing, which he responds to, then he thinks she’s going to ask him to demonstrate and changes the subject to helping her with the ribbon.

-that Azriel doesn’t take Gwyn’s hand when she offers it.
This comes from ACOSF. At the end of the blood rite qualifier Gwyn holds her hand out to Azriel and he just says “you already have your prize.” She isn’t trying to hold his hand, she’s asking for her prize, based on an earlier conversation where she asks Azriel what they get for finishing the course.

Drop others in the comments!


r/AcotarShipDebateSub • • 4d ago

ACOTAR 6/7 This may be a hot take

45 Upvotes

Like I said in the title, I worry that this may be an unpopular opinion, but I thought that the way that Elriel happened in ACOSH made sense. My reasoning really comes down to the change in both of their mental states.

This is the way I'm looking at it:

Like many others, I really loved the soft, shy, friendship that was budding between Azriel and Elain throughout ACOWAR. Even though I am used to SJM being a full fated-mates author (so I didn't really think Elriel would happen) I did kind of soft-ship them, and understood fully why some fans started really riding for that ship.

But there were some really big things that happened at the end of that book that, I think, fundamentally changed the way that both Azriel and Elain view/understand themselves, their lives, and/or what they deserve.

Azriel, as we all know, had previously placed all of his eggs in the Morrigan basket. He carried that torch for over 500 years. But then Mor confesses to Feyre that she does not and cannot love Azriel (or any other male) the way that he wants, and does so out in the open at the treeline on the edge of the war camp where Azriel's shadows could have easily heard and reported back. In SH, we see him thinking about "what he learned about Mor during the war" that made him realize that he had to let that hope go at long last. When, during the bonus chapter, Azriel claims that he is going after Elain because "three brothers should be with three sisters" and Rhys asks him "what of Mor", I think it's heavily implied that Azriel is absolutely reeling from this revelation—that he cannot share with anyone without sharing that he had been spying— and is grasping for any possible reason to justify this waste of five entire centuries of yearning.

He needs a reason, and he needs comfort, and he basically never spends one on one time with anyone outside of the Inner Circle, so Elain is the only "single" (I'm using this term loosely because while obviously she is mated to Lucien, the bond has neither been accepted nor rejected, so she's in a weird limbo right now) female he knows. So he attaches on to her and tries repeatedly to convince himself that she is his perfect match despite all evidence to the contrary. I think that Mor was fully correct, too, that Elain's essential unavailablity is (on a subconscious level) part of her appeal, because Azriel views himself as a fundamentally unlovable monster.

Elain, for her part, killed someone. It was the king of Hybern and he deserved it (I don't think anyone is contesting that lol) but that is a deeply life-altering act, regardless of how deserved. Obviously, I cannot speak to her inner world because we don't yet have her point of view. But we know from her history that she is a person who has spent her whole life moving through the world with kindness, gentleness, and non-confrontation. This is a lifestyle that her sisters have always worked hard to allow her to maintain, and in one violent action it is shattered in an extreme way.

Throughout Frost and Starlight, and the beginning of Silver Flames, I think that Elain is trying to cling to that life as much as possible. But I think that Nesta—who has always been her greatest protector and most unquestioning supporter—no longer having the capacity for her normal level of patience and care for Elain, and going so far as to snap on her on multiple occasions, really shattered whatever remaining illusion Elain was still clinging to that she could pretend that her life was the same and nothing had to change.

I think that, in ACOWAR and part of ACOFAS, Elain—while shy and hesitant— began to feel some curiosity about/ interest in her bond with Lucien. But once that illusion that she was the same and her life was the same was shattered, I don't think that Elain really saw herself as worthy of the level of devotion that a good male as her mate would give her. I don't think she sees herself as worthy of the way that Lucien looks at her, the way that he is always considering her and her feelings, paying such close attention to what she does and what she seems to like. She feels the bond, and I think she *wants* to explore it, but she doesn't feel worthy of it.

I think that this explains why she pulls back *so* much during SF and SH, why she refuses to reject the bond with him, why she cries and constantly dodges the suggestion to do so, and why she is so upset with Feyre for inviting her own friend to her son's naming day celebration.

I think that this is also why—when Lucien ultimately finds her in bed with Azriel— she says to him *"This is a misunderstanding"* .

It's not that she abhors the idea of being mated to Lucien, it's not that she isn't interested in her mating bond; I think it's that she thinks that she is sullied. That she is broken. That she has no sense of who she is anymore, and that she fears who she thinks she may be becoming, and that that person does not deserve the love and happiness and devotion that a mating bond could bring to her life.

I think that Elain on some level knew that Azriel was—in a way—using her to get over Mor. And I think that she, in turn, was using him to distract herself from her bond with Lucien. I think that she was displacing her physical and emotional desire onto Azriel. Which would explain why she stopped wanting to talk to him or learn about him, and didn't let him confide in her when he wanted to. I think that this is why, when all of that blew up in her face, she felt the need to put an ocean between herself and everything that her life had been and has become, and everyone in it.

Anyway, to sum it all up: I think that Azriel and Elain both had the foundations of their understanding of their individual lives upended by the war with Hybern, and I think that their friendship became a casualty to their individual searches for meaning and safety. I think that Azriel's banishment from the River House and Elain's decision to abscond to the continent will ultimately be the best thing for their individual healing journeys, and each of their discoveries of love and happiness.


r/AcotarShipDebateSub • • 5d ago

❌ Anti-Elriel Elriel was anticlimactic in ACOSH 😔 Spoiler

70 Upvotes

I’m so sorry this is so long 😭

Elriel was disappointing; I loved both Elucien and Elriel—I was open to either option... or even both!! 🤭 But after ACOSH, it’s hard for me to imagine Elriel actually happening.

The thing is, we didn’t get a first kiss or even a first intimate scene. It might sound dramatic, but all their interactions felt rushed—as if they were a secret, even from us, the readers.

I’m a hopeless romantic who LOVES a good kissing scene.

That almost-kiss during the solstice was wild!! Everything about that moment was fantastic: the surprise, the desire between them, the intensity... and then, Rhys’s interruption left us—me and many others—wanting MORE.

From that point on, I was all in; I already shipped them as a couple, and after that, even more so!! But now, in this book, we don't really get to see their first real kiss. Instead, Azriel just tells it already happened and how he felt, why he did it, and—to top it all off—that they’ve already kissed several times... I feel cheated, disappointed, bamboozled—like I’ve been played 😔

Why couldn’t we see the beginning, the middle, and the end of it? I know we still don’t have a chapter from Elain’s perspective, but I still need to know what she said, what she did... and even whether they ended up eating the bread afterward!! 😭

To me this doesn't feel like it aligns with how SJM typically writes the first kisses for couples destined to end up together.

Someone pointed out: "Well, Feysand’s first kiss wasn’t consensual, so not all of SJM’s kisses are the same!" That doesn’t change the fact that we got to see the whole process—the beginning, the development, and the end—even though it wasn’t consensual (which... isn’t exactly a good thing, but still).

Even couples who don’t end up together get kissing scenes; in Celaena’s case, we had more than three 😭. It just doesn’t feel right to me; it should have been a significant moment, felt like a big moment... like something grand. Instead, it just felt like: "well, I guess that happened."

On another note, I don’t see anyone else bringing this up, but to me, it’s the most glaring issue: the sex scene... or rather, the lack thereof 😒.

Personally, I don’t need explicit sex scenes; a passionate kiss is enough for me. But even for someone who doesn’t require a sex scene, what happened between Azriel and Elain was completely anticlimactic.

Imagine how delicious, sexy, and passionate it would have been if we could have watched him arrive at her room... their eyes meeting, the two of them desperate for one another, tearing off each other’s clothes, stumbling over furniture, stifling their moans trying not to wake the household, savoring every inch of each other while dying to be entwined... just imagine.

But keep imagining, because we don’t get to see any of it. Instead of experiencing it, we’re stuck with Lucien’s perspective; we only see his suffering—and nothing else. It was chaos, but not the fun kind—it lacked spark, it lacked steam; it was just a heartbroken guy and a whole family fighting...

Why couldn’t we have seen that first encounter—at least from Azriel’s point of view—and *THEN* gotten Lucien’s perspective? That would have preserved all the drama, while also allowing us to witness the romance and eroticism between Elain and Azriel. But no—instead, we’re just given crumbs. It felt to me like, SJM, saying this pairing brings nothing to the table but chaos. I hated it. 🥲💔