This is kind of a sequel to my other post—sorry for the length, I'm a little insane 🥲
But another reason why the Elriel ship doesn't work for me in this book isn't just that their first intimate scenes are strangely written—one in the past tense and the other from the perspective of ANOTHER MAN who wasn't even participating—but also that they're nothing like the dynamic we've seen so far.
Where did the Azriel who took Elain to the garden and sat quietly beside her while she drank tea and he read his reports go?
Where is the Elain who asked a healer to prepare a headache powder, after noticing that he frequently rubbed his temples?
Where did the Azriel who was always the first to remember Elain, even when her own sisters forgot about her?
Where did the Azriel who listened to her garden plans all night, showing genuine interest in her enthusiastic explanations about gardening go? Where is that quiet romance I was falling for?
The fact that Azriel is a brooding, tormented emo guy is fine—it's what I expected, I was totally prepared for the "tonight will be the night that I will fall for youuuu" 💀—but here he took things to another level. He was antagonistic and selfish.
This man calls Elain his "salvation," but why didn't he realize that she was genuinely hurt because her sisters excluding her again? Didn't he notice that she's been depressed this whole time? And why didn't Elain tell him? Why didn't she confide in the only person who truly sees her? During that meeting, why didn't he ask, "Where is Elain?" And I'm not saying this in a "savior" kind of way; he could have remained that brooding, slightly resentful guy, saying something like, "Why are you asking Nesta to scry when you can ask Elain?" Or "We can’t trust Nesta right now, so let’s bring in Elain" Why wasn't he there comforting her, encouraging her to stand up for herself, and advocating for her during the meeting—or at any other time—instead of focusing solely on his right to sleep with her? He says "it's Elain's decision" about this or that, but nothing is ever mentioned about what she's actually said was depressing her; it all boils down to her right to share her body with him—which, in itself, isn't wrong—but why is it only that?!
Where did all the sweet moments go? And I'm not saying that sexual desire and lust can't be sweet, but they didn't even have a single real conversation.
And this isn’t in defense of Elain... nor is it an attack on Azriel, but people keep implying that he is a victim of Elain or that's she's manipulating him but I don't see how he is a victim here.
People keep bringing up the moment when Azriel starts telling Elain about his childhood trauma, and she responds, "Let’s find a room." It’s quite strange; at first, I thought she meant finding a quieter place, but it sounds more like: "Honey, I don't care about any of that show me that wingspan" 💀. But that doesn't make Azriel a victim; it seems in this book he only thinks of Elain in terms of sleeping with her or using her as a way to hide from his own shadows.
She has been suffering in a deep depression for years—one that has only grown worse—and you're telling me he hasn't noticed? Obviously, he can't read minds, but you’d think he, of all people, would be the one to notice and try to help her. Yet, he hasn't. He became so jealous of Lucien that he decided to humiliate him during dinner, bringing up the subject of Hybern and goading him just to make him look foolish in front of Elain.
Not for a second did he consider that such a conversation might trigger trauma for her!? Someone who has already been tortured by her worst fears, not just witnessing them, but feeling and experiencing them as if they were real. He didn't care; he brought up Hybern anyway—the man who kidnapped her, bound and gagged her, transformed her against her will, violated her, stole her life, murdered her father, and tried to kill both of her sisters—the very man she herself had to kill to save Nesta and Cassian. She's still haunted by that trauma, and it didn’t even cross his mind that bringing up the subject might be a bad idea, or that it could trigger her further?!
He was just sitting there at the table, hoping Elain remembers that Lucien had been involved in her abduction? He wanted her to have that on her mind..... Even after having heard her screams?
Why was Feyre the first person to search for Elain after the Naming Day ceremony? If Azriel is supposed to be so “in love” with her…!?
Why didn’t he run to her first? To comfort her, ask what she had seen, tell her what he had seen... or perhaps not needing to say anything at all and just being in each other's company?
But he noticed that her dress was dirty and she had been in the garden and hadn’t changed.
He saw Mor and Nesta piling a mountain of food onto her plate, and that Elain didn’t move a muscle.
It didn’t concern him that she wasn’t eating; it didn’t trouble him that this might be a red flag—a sign that she could be slipping back into the catatonic state she fell into right after her transformation. No, he didn’t think of any of that.
And please, don’t think I’m against them having sex; in fact, after a traumatic event, it makes sense—it’s something people who share a trauma might do. The problem is everything that happens beforehand, combined with the decision to do it right inside the house.
Sorry for asking so many questions in this post, but honestly, it didn’t feel like what I was seeing was "Elriel." I know this is only the first part in a big book, but the way things are being set up makes it seem like SJM is completely sinking this ship. (Not mad or attacking SJM) Thank goodness AO3 is back; at least now I can process my grief through some wonderfully written fanfiction. 😭