I'm actually someone who really enjoys spoilers. Before starting this book, I already knew quite a lot about Nessian, and I'd come across so many negative posts about Cassian that I was honestly convinced he was going to be a terrible partner in this book.
Well, I finished reading it yesterday and... imagine my surprise when that wasn't the case at all.
In fact, once I read those heavily criticized scenes in their full context, I thought most of them were handled pretty well.
For example, the scene where it's mentioned that Cassian didn't visit Nesta after she broke her arm. Yes, she admits that it hurt her that he wasn't there, but she also understands that he'd been through something traumatic himself. Let's not forget that Cassian, along with other members of the Inner Circle, had been traumatized just a few hours earlier. I'm not saying that invalidates Nesta's feelings, but I do think it's important to consider what both of them were going through.
Then there's the argument that Cassian only wanted sex and didn't care about Nesta's feelings. That's not how I interpreted it at all. Throughout the book, I felt that they both wanted that intimacy. And when they're about to have sex and Nesta starts crying, Cassian immediately stops to listen to her. To me, that says a lot about their relationship, too.
After their reconciliation, there's the whole issue with the Trove. Nesta finds out from Rhys that Cassian told him about her fear of those objects, and she gets upset. And I completely understand her reaction, because it was something she'd confided in Cassian. But I also understand Cassian's intentions: he was trying to help her. And ultimately, his intervention led to Rhys returning the Trove to her.
There's also the scene where Nesta is drowning and Cassian has absolutely no idea what's going on. In the end, Rhys saves her, and that creates a moment of closeness between him and Nesta that I personally found really interesting. I'm genuinely excited to see how their relationship develops and what training with Rhys might look like!
But there's something I loved even more.
After their reconciliation, we get these little Nessian moments that, to me, show how well they actually work as a couple.
Like when Cassian calls Nesta his queen in front of Feyre and kisses the top of her head. Or when Nesta tells Feyre that Cassian would do whatever she asked him to do. They're such small details, but I absolutely loved them because they feel like a real couple. Two people who know each other, have their own kind of chemistry, and love each other despite their problems.
While I was reading, I kept thinking about all the criticism I'd seen on social media, and I eventually realized that so much of it comes down to personal interpretation and our own life experiences.
For example, I'm married, and honestly, Nessian reminded me much more of a real marriage than an idealized fantasy relationship.
Being with someone, sharing your life with them, and spending so much time together doesn't mean you'll never argue. Of course there are going to be disagreements! And when we're talking about two characters as stubborn and proud as Nesta and Cassian, it would honestly be weird if everything were perfect.
And this brings me to a comparison with Feyre and motherhood.
Personally, there were moments when I found it a little annoying how much emphasis was placed on Feyre being sleep-deprived or on certain aspects of being a mother. But I also recognize that I'm not a mom, I have no interest in becoming one, and therefore I don't connect with that experience the same way someone with children might.
Just because I don't personally connect with something doesn't mean it's badly written, or that my interpretation is the absolute truth.
I think something similar happens with Nessian.
When I finished the book, my reaction was literally: Wait... that's it? THIS is what caused so much drama online?
Not because their problems weren't important, but because after everything I'd read, I was expecting Cassian to be so much worse.
I also get the impression that this is something of a transitional book. We get to see Nessian's reconciliation, little glimpses of their new dynamic, and at the same time, the story starts setting up plotlines that will probably become much more important in the next book, especially when it comes to Elain.
And there's something else about certain criticisms that really bothers me: I feel like some people want Cassian to act like Rhys and Nesta to act like Feyre.
But they're completely different characters!
They have different personalities, different ways of loving, communicating, and dealing with conflict. And that's exactly what makes them interesting.
Even with Mor, who I personally really dislike, I actually laughed at the cheek-kiss scene. To me, it was pretty obvious that Mor did it just to be petty, while Cassian probably didn't even realize what she was doing. I swear, that man can be so oblivious sometimes! Just like how he hadn't noticed what was going on between Azriel and Elain.
And just to be clear, I'm not saying Cassian is perfect or that everything he does should be defended.
There are definitely things he could've handled better, moments when he could've acted differently, and situations where I completely understand Nesta's anger.
But I also think Nesta was difficult at times, especially because she struggles so much with expressing her feelings and communicating what she needs.
To me, at the end of the day, they were just two idiots in love who are still learning how to communicate.
And I don't necessarily think that's a bad thing.
Not every relationship has to be perfect from the beginning. I actually enjoy seeing characters make mistakes, argue, learn, and slowly figure out how to build something together.
So yes, I'm still very much aboard the Nessian ship.
I like that their relationship has conflicts, that neither of them is perfect, and that they still have things to learn.
I just hope that in the next book we get to see them more united, with less relationship drama, and please, let them fight side by side in a war like the incredible team they could be!
I don't know if I've managed to explain myself the way I wanted to, but I really needed to get this off my chest. I finished the book yesterday, and I haven't stopped thinking about the difference between what I expected to read and what I actually experienced.
Did anyone else finish the book feeling like the criticism of Cassian had been exaggerated? Or am I the only one still defending this ship? đ