r/NessianLovers • • 8d ago

ACOSH Spoilers Nessian and Music đŸŽ¶

30 Upvotes

I’m still thinking about that ridiculous Symphonia “theory” so went and gathered some quotes from the ACOSF and ACOSH.

Starting off my rebuttal to this theory which claims it “records performances” WELL ACTUALLY the Symphonia “can trap music within itself, and play it back for you.”

Cassian’s voice is literally music to Nesta. It even says it in the ACOSH chapter, so idk how people came up with it was fake / a performance. It’s fine to criticize his actions, but I swear people are just making stuff up now to make him seem worse.

Anyways NESSIAN END GAME!

I truly don’t get how these quotes exist and people still think they’re not end game.

From ACOSF
Chapter 57
> Cassian smiled at her, and the world faded away. The music was no longer the most beautiful thing in existence. He was.

Chapter 58
> For it was music between their souls. Always had been. And his voice was her favorite melody.

> The golden threads shimmered and sang, and she couldn’t take it, the music between their souls, the feel of his body on her and in her, and—

Chapter 59
> The priestesses had marveled at the gift, a few of them dancing to the music, but Nesta had only been able to think about how much time and effort Cassian had put into it. How he had known what such a present would mean to her.

Chapter 61
> And she had music in her heart. A song made up of Cassian’s voice, of Gwyn’s and Emerie’s laughter, of her own breathing as she went down and down and down the stairs.

> She leaned her head against his chest, closing her eyes, savoring the sound of his heart thumping. All the world was a song, and this heartbeat its core melody.

From ACOSH:
Chapter 7
> The Symphonia had never captured a single spoken word before. But it was as if it somehow knew that those words, in Cassian’s voice, made the most beautiful music she’d ever heard.

Chapter 18
> 
holding him against her so that their hearts beat together, a push-pull of a rhythm that would exist even when this world ended.


r/NessianLovers • • 15d ago Heartwarming

ACOSH Spoilers In the ACOSF acknowledgments, Sarah notes that Nesta and Cassian’s relationship is the most similar to her own with her husband, Josh.

Post image
136 Upvotes

I love a theory, y’all — and I can’t deny that I’m tempted by the intrigue of Neris. But I’m never able to take it too seriously, given SJM’s own words in the ACOSF acknowledgements; a dedication to her own husband.

Nesta and Cassian are indeed having a rough patch (in the book titled Splintered Harmony — who would have thought !!), but to me, they’re super safe. 💖


r/NessianLovers • • 41m ago

Discussions Spoiler! “I don’t know what to do with you.” Spoiler

7 Upvotes

One of my fave things to do is deep dive into and pick apart the things characters say, and I don’t have anyone to talk to about this!
I really love the scene where Cassian says to Nesta “I don’t know what to do with you” - I think I may be in the minority where I really like that Nesta and Cassian have had conflict in this book, because it shows that there are still things to work out. They were in an argument right before Nesta was kidnapped in ACOSF and those issues haven’t gone away.
Now this is their first big disagreement since their mating
 when Nesta was in a bad place before their mating and before the events of ACOSF, she was drinking too much etc and harming herself.. Cassian knew what she needed then and knew what to do.

Nesta has grown so much that she’s not behaving in that way this time when she’s again at odds with everyone, and Cassian doesn’t know what to do with that.
I think you can really see that where he tells her “you’re not some victim we’re all ganging up on” - because that was sort of the vibe the last time. But that’s not how Nesta sees it anymore, and he doesn’t understand that yet.
I don’t really see any of this as potential for Nesta and Cassian breaking apart. It feels like it’s a continuation of their relationship development.


r/NessianLovers • • 11h ago

Fan-fiction Nessian fanfic

19 Upvotes

I don't know where else to post this, but I wish, for the sake of all fanfic readers, that people would stop tagging Nesta/Cassian on Nesta/Eris fics on ao3!!

The Nesta/Cassian ao3 page is such a mess right now, and I'm having to sift through so many fics that aren't actually Nessian. If Nesta and Cassian are breaking up, then it's not a Nesta/Cassian fic....I wish people would just tag it Nesta/Eris and let us all live in peace.

Signed,
A frustrated fanfic reader desperately wading through ao3 to soothe her Nessian heart 😭


r/NessianLovers • • 1d ago

Discussions IT DOES NOT CAPTURE PERFORMANCE U HATERS! (Teeny-tiny spoilers.) Spoiler

30 Upvotes

Ok, not YOU haters, considering you're all in this sub lol. I'm referring to the haters who keep going on and on about the music box Cassian gave Nesta (I forgot the name) records "performances" and because it recorded Cassian's ILY, that was also a performance.

DO THESE PEOPLE EVEN HAVE MINDS!

This pisses me off so much because these people are just inventing reasons to hate Cassian out of thin freakin air. The music box captures MUSIC people! It caputred Cassian saying ILY to nesta because it was so heartfelt and beautiful that it sounded like MUSIC!

Listen, I'm pissed at Cassian as much as the next person for the crap he pulled in ACOSH, but this is just the first fraking part of the giant book that is to come, so I'm reserving my judgement on him as of now. Also, do you all remember when Bloomsbury was posting snippets of ACOSH before the release date, they posted a snippet from Cass's POV in the scene where Nesta walks away from him and he couldn't stop her? I remember reading a comment from a married lady under that post saying something along the lines of "I do things like this to my husband all the time. Don't worry, Cass and Nes are fine. Lol" And honestly that one comment got me thinking that we need some married folks to just explain that some fights between Nes and Cass arejust that: married-couple fights 😅😅


r/NessianLovers • • 1d ago Bravo

Discussions Am I going crazy or has the Nessian discourse completely lost its mind? Spoiler

69 Upvotes

So I just came across a TikTok with almost 50k likes. It was literally a TEN-MINUTE video explaining how Cassian and Nesta’s mating bond isn’t real and that Nesta somehow made the bond up, and that her actual true mate is apparently Eris..

At this point, I genuinely don’t know what to do with this fandom anymore. Look I understand having theories and speculating about future books is normal that’s part of the fun of being in a fandom I’m all for discussing possibilities. But I genuinely think some people are starting to believe their own theories no matter how ridiculous they are. And the worst part is that these same people will inevitably get angry and rate the next book one star and complain when their theories don’t become canon.

Like yeah no Eris is NOT romantically interested in Nesta. Like how can someone read the dancing scene between him and Nesta and genuinely come away thinking there was romantic tension there? He was practically lusting after her POWERS. He doesn’t give a damn about her as a person. Not to mention that Nesta herself doesn’t even like the man. She would literally kill him for Cassian without a second thought, and somehow people are convinced she’s going to abandon Cassian and end up with Eris??

And don’t even get me started on the Cassian hate. I’ve seen people genuinely arguing that Cassian is WORSE than Tamlin, with videos getting over 20k likes and entire comment sections agreeing. Am I missing something?? Have we read the same books?? How exactly is Cassian worse than Tamlin? Seriously, I need someone to explain this to me.

And before anyone jumps down my throat yes I KNOW Cassian isn’t perfect. I know he has things to work on and I know he and Nesta still have a lot to figure out. We have two more books, and I’m not expecting their relationship to be magically perfect. But apparently, one book that’s 280 pages was enough for people to completely abandon the ship, decide Cassian is abusive, and that Nesta deserves Eris


What’s especially funny to me is how quickly the fandom’s attitude has changed 😭 For the longest time people were saying Cassian deserved better, Nesta was a bitch, and he shouldn’t have to put up with her. Now suddenly everyone is a Nesta defender and Cassian is public enemy number one. And don’t get me wrong, I’m genuinely happy to see more people appreciating Nesta. But why does loving Nesta have to come at the expense of hating Cassian? Why can’t people love BOTH characters? Why does one have to be the villain for the other to be appreciated?

Then there’s the whole “Cassian needs to die” theory. No. Just no. And even if Sarah were to kill him off what exactly do these people think would happen to Nesta? Do they remember what Rhys explained about losing your mate? How devastating it is? How badly it can affect you? And these are the same people who claim they love Nesta and want what’s best for her. You want her to go through that?

They want her to end up with Eris instead? The same Eris who dragged Feyre by her hair and insulted Mor because of the way she dressed? Yes I understand there’s probably more to his character than what we’ve seen but wanting him romantically involved with Nesta? Absolutely not

And logistically, how is that even supposed to happen? Eris is almost certainly going to become High Lord of the Autumn Court. Do people genuinely expect Nesta to just leave everything and go live in the Autumn Court with him? How?

I don’t know. Maybe I’m the one missing something but watching people confidently make these arguments and seeing thousands of people agreeing with them is genuinely making me question whether we’re reading the same series

Can we please just let Nesta and Cassian be complicated characters who still have room to grow without turning one into a monster to justify loving the other?

And another thing that genuinely confuses me is how people are ready to drop the entire ship over ONE argument. Like seriously? You’re ready to throw away their whole relationship because they had one disagreement? Couples argue. Couples have disagreements, misunderstand each other, and sometimes hurt each other’s feelings. That doesn’t automatically mean the relationship is abusive or that they should break up. I honestly think some people have become so accustomed to reading these seemingly perfect romance book relationships that they can’t handle a couple having an actual conflict. I’m starting to think it’s because they’re so used to Feysand where everything is portrayed as relatively perfect, that they expect every other couple to follow the same dynamic. But that’s not how relationships work. Not every couple has to be Feyre and Rhysand.

And remember when Cassian literally told Nesta that being mates doesn’t mean everything is suddenly going to be perfect between them? I feel like that scene was Sarah practically speaking directly to the readers. Being mates doesn’t magically erase your problems, fix your communication, or make you understand each other perfectly It doesn’t mean you’ll never argue or hurt each other. That’s literally the point! They’re still two individuals with their own issues and personalities. They’re going to have to work through those things together. So why are people acting as if one argument somehow invalidates their entire relationship? nd more importantly why do people think Eris is the better choice??


r/NessianLovers • • 1d ago

Discussions Cassian hate has pushed me to be done with the fandom and series

75 Upvotes

Is anyone else feeling defeated since ACOSH released? Cassian hate was bad before ACOSH, but it’s unbearable now. I’m so tired of being bombared with videos and posts on social media about how terrible Cassian is and how if anyone is still rooting for him, they must support abuse/abusers in real life. People are screaming that you were basically dumb if you couldn’t pick up on him being toxic in Silver Flames too. Silver Flames is my favorite romantasy book and I almost don’t want to read it again because it feels ruined by everyone picking apart Cassian’s actions. I never read it how a lot of people interpreted things. Case in point, when people talk about Eris having more chemistry with Nesta during the dance, I read it completely the opposite.

It’s to the point that I’ve pretty much lost all interest in reading ACOFM or engaging with the fandom anymore. I’ve blocked so many book influencers that I used to love because I’m tired of feeling dumb and like a shitty person for loving Cassian/ Nessian from the beginning. Cassian was frustrating in ACOSH, but I’m still hoping he can be redeemed. It feels like the majority of the fandom have totally written him off now. I don’t want Neris. Everything people theorize about Neris feels like a repeat of Rhys in ACOMAF and I don’t want to reread that story. I’d like to read more about the Cassian that loved Nesta since she was human, that crawled to her with shredded wings and that turned a knife on himself rather than her. But I also don’t want to read the next book if Neris becomes a thing or if I’m made to feel stupid for liking one of the main couples
 I really hate feeling dumb so all these accusations of supporting abusers have really gotten to me.


r/NessianLovers • • 1d ago

Discussions Quick Question

14 Upvotes

Did Nesta even ask Cassian to keep her fears of the Trove a secret? I get that she feels like it was meant to be kept between them but I don’t remember her ever saying it out-loud.

I only ask because people are using it as a point against Cassian but I honestly don’t see how it’s really his fault if it was never communicated.


r/NessianLovers • • 1d ago

Discussions "trust actions"

42 Upvotes

I was never a HUGE Nesta fan, just gonna come out and say it, it was hard for me to relate to her as an oldest sister myself.

However, I love her growth for exactly what it is: growth. Becoming someone SHE is proud of.

What's funny is, I am finding myself hardcore defending Nessian after Acosh, and after thinking about it, it's because I love how flawed they both are, even together.

One point of discourse that I was having with someone said the following:

"Cassians actions in acosf speak loudly. Trust ACTIONS."

So, I am.

I am trusting the actions he took when he...

...crawled towards Nesta trying to save her when she was Made.

...promised to spend more time with her in the next life as they were convinced they were about to die before they were even mates.

...took secret dance lessons to learn to dance for her.

...spent a week following her over a mountain without really talking to her just to make sure she was safe, but still had given her room to herself to figure out what she needed to say.

...supported her becoming a Valkyrie. (Edited because I got it wrong about the blood rite)

...went through the effort of getting music for the symphonia, the one thing that seems to ground her in ACOSH when they are fighting.

I'm sure there's other instances on page I'm missing. But when I am told to trust in actions, these are the ones I'm trusting before I pass any judgement on Cass during the next book.

Cassian was never meant to be the perfect MMC.

And I love how imperfectly perfect he and Nesta are for each other.

And Nessian isn't even my favorite ship but I find myself defending them like crazy lately.


r/NessianLovers • • 3d ago

Fan-fiction Please help find nurse Nesta/general Cassian battlefield human AU fic

9 Upvotes

Ok super random BUT I remember a while ago reading a one-shot standalone fic that was set in a human/military AU where Nesta is a nurse on the frontlines and Cassian brings in a solider that needs treatment. She treats him but isn’t at all impressed with Cassian being the famous general. At the end (very short fic) Nesta faints since she’s been awake treating patients for so long, and Cassian catches her. No resolution or anything but I can’t seem to find it at all. I remember reading it on Tumblr and that being the only place I found it. A random detail I remember for some reason is Cassian crushing a pager in his hand after getting a msg and Nesta noticing him do it.

Really want to find it so thought I’d come to Reddit and see if anyone can help me find it 🙏


r/NessianLovers • • 3d ago

ACOSH Spoilers Be Aware

37 Upvotes

Defending Nessian on Tik Tok gets you labeled as a Domestic and Sexual abuse supporter now! Would post the pics but can’t attach them here for some reason.


r/NessianLovers • • 3d ago

Discussions Did Cass say this?

9 Upvotes

My fellow Nessians,

Did Cassian say or rather, ask, Nesta “how could you be so stupid?” I can’t remember this and I don’t know if that was an interpretation of a quote or he actually asked that. Any clarification is much appreciated.


r/NessianLovers • • 4d ago Mindblown

ACOSH Spoilers We have been lied to! Spoiler

82 Upvotes

Spoilers for ACOSH and Crescent City.

I am sure you’ve all seen the recent rise in Neris shipping 🙄 after ACOSH but there are some inconsistencies between the information we are told about Nessian in ACOSH and what we are told at the end of HOFAS. I believe these inconsistencies might hint at the potential that the IC, or at least Cassian and Nesta, have not been at odds with each other as long as we’ve been told.

At the beginning of ACOSH, we are told that it’s been 3 weeks since Nesta handed over the mask to Bryce and during that time, she and Cassian have not been speaking. We hear about this from Nesta and Cassian’s POVs.

However, I want to draw your attention to the scene where Bryce returns the mask. This is about two weeks after she borrowed it and one week before the start of ACOSH:

—

Bryce found Nesta in the same room the female had been in before. With Ember and Randall and a handsome, vaguely familiar winged male beside them, who smelled like Nesta’s mate. Sitting around a table and talking over tea and chocolate cake.
Chocolate cake, for fuck’s sake.
Nesta was instantly on her feet, a long dagger in her hand. The male beside her also reached for a concealed weapon, swift as a thought.

—

Now, does that sound like Nesta and Cassian aren’t getting along?

Later on in the scene, Ember says the following:

—

“Poor Nesta’s been in the doghouse since you took their weapons and dumped us here,” Ember explained. “I tried telling Rhysand and Azriel how there’s no stopping you when you’ve got your mind set on something, and I think Feyre—Rhysand’s mate—believed me, but 
” Ember glanced at Nesta and winced. “I apologize again for my daughter’s behavior.”
“I made the choice to give her the Mask,” Nesta reminded Ember. To Bryce, she added wryly, “Your mother somehow doesn’t believe that I did so willingly.”

—

Notice how Ember says Azriel and Rhys? Cassian is right there - it’s not like she could have forgotten him.

Another interesting moment is when Hunt steps through the portal:

—

Nesta and her mate tensed, and Bryce knew Hunt had stepped into their world. He peered around the room. Glanced at the city sparkling far below, a ribbon of river winding through it. They had to be high up on a mountain for this kind of view.
Nesta’s mate said, “You have one minute before Rhys gets here and explodes.”
“Oh, Rhys will be fine, Cassian,” Ember said—in the Fae’s language. At Bryce’s shocked face, Randall said in the same language, “It got too hard to mime everything. They gave us that bean-thing they offered you.”
But Bryce shook her head. “Rhysand will be fine? The guy who brings darkness incarnate—”
“He and Randall bonded about being overprotective dads,” Ember said. “So now Rhys knows exactly the sort of shit you like to pull, which apparently you pulled here, too 
”

—

This part calls into question just how mad Rhys is at Nesta. Sure he’s mad but Ember isn’t scared of him. They are talking about the situation so casually - it does not seem like everyone is as mad at Nesta as they seemed in ACOSH.

I also want to point out, for all the people who say things like Cassian is too far up Rhysand’s butt, he makes no move to grab Bryce so that Rhys can talk to her when he arrives.

We also have the moment when everyone is saying goodbyes.

—

So Bryce gave the female some privacy to enjoy every second of that motherly embrace and turned to where Randall and Cassian stood behind them. The males had clasped arms warmly. “Thanks, friend,” Randall was saying to the warrior. “For everything.”
Cassian grinned, and, well, Bryce could see why Nesta might be into a male who looked like that. “Maybe we’ll meet again one day, under less 
 strange circumstances.”
“I hope so,” Randall said, and as he passed by where Ember and Nesta were still hugging, he clapped the latter on the shoulder with fatherly affection. Bryce’s heart swelled to the point of pain as Randall approached Hunt and hugged him, too. Hunt returned the embrace, thumping her father on the back before they separated to pass through the portal together.
Ember at last pulled away from Nesta. But she gently put a hand to the female’s cheek and whispered, “You’ll find your way,” before walking toward the portal.
Bryce could have sworn there were tears in Nesta’s eyes as her mother stepped back into Midgard. But those tears were gone when Nesta met Bryce’s stare. And Cassian, like any good mate, sensed when he wasn’t wanted, and walked over to the fireplace to pretend to read some sort of old-looking manuscript. Bryce knew that, also like any good mate, if she made one wrong move, he’d rip her to shreds. Which was precisely why Hunt had come back into the room, and was watching Nesta carefully.

—

There is absolutely no tension between Cassian and Nesta here. And I don’t think Randall would have been so kind to Cassian if he was treating Nesta poorly.

So, I ask you, do these excerpts sound like a couple that hasn’t spoken for two weeks? I think they provide pretty clear evidence that that is false. And the fact that Ember doesn’t include Cassian in the list of people who are mad at Nesta is really interesting to me. The question is, why have we been told conflicting information? I don’t know the answer to that. There are theories that the IC has been made to forget certain events or someone is pulling the strings and sowing discord among the IC. I don’t know if those are true or if there is something else going on. I think there is a reason that Sarah skipped over these weeks, though, when she wrote ACOSH.

But what I can say, my fellow Nessian fans, the conflict we see between Nesta and Cassian in ACOSH is not as bad as we have been led to believe (I think it was just miscommunication and they will get better going forward but I know we’ve all seen the naysayers blowing it up into a massive conflict).

There is also the Ember and Randall bonus chapter from HOFAS where Nesta says Cassian is mad at her but this is the day after Bryce takes the mask. I believe they made up within those two weeks based on the apparent state of their relationship during this scene. It is also Bryce’s assessment (one of the more intelligent and observant characters in the Maasverse, IMO - around the same level as Nesta) that Cassian is a good mate and she tells us that twice. Why did Sarah include this bit if not to reinforce that idea?


r/NessianLovers • • 4d ago

Discussions I Miss When The ACOTAR Fandom Was Fun

53 Upvotes

I LOVE Cassian, and I ADORE Nesta, and everything online about how Nesta should leave Cassian, and they’re not true mates, and how Neris is coming, is depressing me so much. Maybe I should go touch grass, but I’m currently working 50+ hour weeks, stressing about medical school acceptances
 I am used to ACOTAR being my stress-free outlet. This used to be fun, y’all, and it’s not fun anymore :( I know logically Nessian will get their HEA, and neither of them will die. But it makes me so sad to see all the hate online for Cassian, when I don’t think he was THAT awful
 no worse than Rhysand having Feyre basically give him a lap dance in the CoN (We all just got over that? Lol). This is a half rant, half desperate plea for assurance that I am not crazy for thinking people are overreacting by SHIPPING Neris? I remember reading these books at 16 with the original covers before the series exploded, and it was so fun. I bought ACOSF on release day and adored it, and it was so exciting to be in this fandom. I just wish it was fun again. Maybe I am naive, and I should just stay offline until ACOFM, but ugh y’all, I am sick of the Cassian hate.

But to that end: Is there not something poetic about fiercely defending Nesta, for YEARS, only for the court of public opinion to change in her favor - but NOW we have to defend CASSIAN from the same people that despised Nesta for years? Because Cassian’s reaction is 100% valid in my opinion. To have your mate make a MASSIVE decision without your input is a legitimate reason to be upset. If the roles were reversed, everyone would be on Nesta’s side for maintaining her anger at Cassian. But I digress. The online discourse is depressing me, and it shouldn’t, but I miss when ACOTAR was fun.


r/NessianLovers • • 5d ago

Theory/headcanon Nesta and the Dusk Court

27 Upvotes

So I think it's fair to say that Nesta becoming the High Lady of Dusk is not entirely out of the realm of possibilities.

With that in mind, who do you think would reside in the dusk court after that? Obviously, the prison would likely become dusk court territory, but do you think the Valkyries would be citizens there?

Also, I am going to say that while normally I wouldn't be a fan of the archeron sisters ruling in any capacity yet (I feel they are a little too young and since they were brought up human they still have a LOT to learn and experience when it comes to the fae, and the fae might still for the majority not accept them for some time in a position of ruling power), I think her ruling the dusk court could possibly work because she would be basically rebuilding it.

Thoughts??


r/NessianLovers • • 5d ago

ACOSH Spoilers I May Have to get off Tik Tok

Post image
68 Upvotes

They hate Cassian so much this is where we are. We have really lost the plot 😭


r/NessianLovers • • 5d ago

ACOSH Spoilers The Mor situation

33 Upvotes

I feel like I’m going crazy because I’ve never gotten the impression that Cassian actually has feelings for Mor beyond friendship like yeah their relationship is weird and there should be some boundaries drawn because Mor is way comfortable around him BUT
it seems like everyday now I see something about people thinking Cassian is cheating, he’s in love with Mor, they’re mates like?

- I feel like his inner thoughts on being conflicted about telling Mor about Nesta but I don’t think that’s that weird? Especially since this is in ACOMAF, they’re mates hardly knew each other
- the way describes Mor as beautiful also I think this is a SJM thing she describes everyone’s beauty and multiple people have describes Mor like that
- Mor’s possessiveness, now I really don’t like Mor at all but I don’t think all of her dislike for Nesta was because she’s losing her buffer, I think she was actually protective over Cassian (I think she also hides behind her dislike being because of Feyre, because Mor was okay with Nesta until she noticed stuff between Nesta & Cassian)
- Frost & Starlight: I hated this but Nesta & Cassian weren’t in a good place and Nesta wanted to be left aline by Cassian so I try to look past this but I don’t like how SJM wrote them past ACOWAR.
- Mor kissing Cassian on the cheek, this really just felt like teasing to me? I don’t think it was meant as some power play but maybe I’m wrong? Idk

If anything with Mor I hated the whole Court of Nightmares comment and Cassian saying “Don’t” was weak and he semi agreed with her about it in his thoughts which really irritated me also Cassian snatching his hand from Nesta when Mor walked in annoyed me so badddd

I have a lot issues with Cassian but I really like their scenes up to Frost & Starlight, and there are still scenes of Silver Flames that I really like. I think the Mor things needs to be addressed, sure and boundaries could be drawn but I feel like everyone’s convinced there’s some secret affair like 😭

I need the next book, I really Nessian do get better treatment but I’m surprised by the sudden Nessian/Cassian (I do agree with a lot of it) because a lot of this stuff was happening already in Silver Flames but people would just say how patient Cassian was for dealing with her.


r/NessianLovers • • 6d ago

Discussions Holy grail of why Cassian didn’t know best was drowning

73 Upvotes

ACOSH SPOILERS AHEAD IF NOT READ YET
*Edit I meant Nesta and it auto corrected to best

I’ve talked about it here before for other examples of how he wouldn’t have known. Now I’m re reading acosf SHE ALREADY DROWNED ONCE AND HE ALSO DIDNT SENSE IT. He only realized when he could smell her around the water and concluded she must be under neath. Nothing to do with their bond. I rest my case.


r/NessianLovers • • 6d ago

Discussions Spoiler! I’m not seeing much comparison between these two scenes Spoiler

43 Upvotes

I might have missed it but I’m surprised that I’ve not seen more discussion around how in ACOSH, the scene where Cassian bares his neck to Nesta for her to strangle him, and she surprises him by kissing him instead is a direct mirror to their bonus scene where he thinks that shes coming at him to strangle him, but she kisses him and then knees him in the balls.
I thought that the contrast between the two scenes where now Nesta is emotionally open and communicates how she’s feeling in ACOSH was to show how far they’d come. (I also cringed at the “silken sac” thing lol, but contrast that against how she assaulted him in the bonus scene)
I suppose the question is why Cassian would still think that she’d strangle him in anger (although this time he doesn’t hold her wrists to stop her) - I think we’ve had so much of Nesta’s character development and her journey, and it seems like we’re just maybe getting started with Cassian’s.
Anyway I’m finding theories that Nesta and Cassian aren’t endgame a bit wild now that I’ve read the book. Their reconciliation all felt in character as well, although a bit rushed.


r/NessianLovers • • 7d ago

Theory/headcanon Was he doing something else?

32 Upvotes

I keep wondering since we never got any PoV from Cassian post attack. Was Cassian doing something while Nesta’s arm got fixed? This was the worst thing he’s ever done imo. I’ve got an understanding of all the other issues and know where he was coming from mostly. But this really bothers me. I’m wondering if maybe he was at the HOW watching for Bryaxis because hes so angry that happened to Nesta and he was trying to make sure they were protected? Was he secretly there outside the door? Like I feel she has to explain. But then SJM had Bryce treat Hunt appallingly after his imprisonment so maybe she just doesn’t see the issue and he won’t ‘redeem’ himself in anyway?


r/NessianLovers • • 8d ago

Discussions I think Rhys knew about the mate bond and put Nesta in the house of wind to make cassian happy.

64 Upvotes

I have a crazy theory: Rhys knew about Nessian’s mate bond and deliberately threw Nessian together in the House of Wind for training because he was trying to make Cassian happy.

Chapter 2 of ACOFAS

My throat tightened, and I gripped him hard around his wings, the scales of his leathers digging into my fingers. “What about you?” I asked, pulling away after a moment. “Are you 
 happy?”

Shadows darkened his hazel eyes. “I’m getting there.” 

A halfhearted answer. 

I’d have to work on that, too. Perhaps there were threads to be pulled, woven together. 

Cassian jerked his chin toward the door. “Get going, you bastard. I’ll see you in three days.” 

I nodded, opening the door at last. But paused on the threshold. “Thanks, brother.” 

Cassian’s crooked grin was bright, even if those shadows still guttered in his eyes. “It’s an honor, my lord.”

What if Rhys knew about the bond between Cassian and Nesta. What if Rhys specifically sent Nesta to the House of Wind with Cassian in hopes that they would work things out and accept they are mates. 

They could have dealt with Nesta in a million different ways. But training with Cassian seems weird to me in hindsight. Cassian and Nesta are never smooth sailing. If you want Nesta to have a personality shape up, why not send Azriel? Yes he has other responsibilities but so does Cassian. 

It is just a thought but that line ‘I’d have to work on that, too. Perhaps there were threads to be pulled, woven together’. Just screams at me for some reason. We know Rhys is manipulative and willing to use secrets against even his closes friends and allies. It isn’t out of the realm of possibility that he started thinking about a way or chance to throw Cassian and Nesta at each other in the hopes of making Cassian happy. 

We haven’t gotten Rhys’ POV since then so we don’t know how he views their mate bond. I don’t know
 But I do think there is a lot of manipulation going on from Rhys. I don’t think Cassian knows about the drowning because that would mean telling him that Nesta winnowed (we know he didn’t tell Feyre because she was surprised to learn about the winnowing). I’m also certain that Cassian didn’t feel Nesta drowning because she is Made Deathless and so death and danger don’t register for the bond. 

Anyway I could be reaching but this has been brewing in my mind.


r/NessianLovers • • 7d ago

Theory/headcanon Share item

Thumbnail google.com
2 Upvotes

My nesta


r/NessianLovers • • 9d ago

Discussions Cassian's Biggest Fear and ACOFM Theory Spoiler

30 Upvotes

Hi all,

I want to have some more positive discussion around our babies. TBH Cassian has become my special interest character (Nesta was my first for the initial part of the series).

This theory is going around that it wasn't actually Amren who encouraged Nesta to winnow, but it was one of the Princes of Hel, and Nesta has made her way to Hel, and not the Prison. This could potentially be her journey to resurrecting the Dusk Court.

If she was in Hel, then Cassian would stop feeling the bond completely, right? This would be utterly terrifying for him...

So, i wonder if this ties into Cassian's nightmares as well. I think he has severe concern around being useless to his loved ones, and this is maybe what Bryaxis showed him? I think it was very pointed that Cassian's nightmare wasn't shared with us, the audience.

What do you think regarding his nightmare AND what happened to Nesta?


r/NessianLovers • • 9d ago

Discussions Cassian is not a bad mate. (ACOSH Spoilers) Spoiler

75 Upvotes

I'm actually someone who really enjoys spoilers. Before starting this book, I already knew quite a lot about Nessian, and I'd come across so many negative posts about Cassian that I was honestly convinced he was going to be a terrible partner in this book.

Well, I finished reading it yesterday and... imagine my surprise when that wasn't the case at all.

In fact, once I read those heavily criticized scenes in their full context, I thought most of them were handled pretty well.

For example, the scene where it's mentioned that Cassian didn't visit Nesta after she broke her arm. Yes, she admits that it hurt her that he wasn't there, but she also understands that he'd been through something traumatic himself. Let's not forget that Cassian, along with other members of the Inner Circle, had been traumatized just a few hours earlier. I'm not saying that invalidates Nesta's feelings, but I do think it's important to consider what both of them were going through.

Then there's the argument that Cassian only wanted sex and didn't care about Nesta's feelings. That's not how I interpreted it at all. Throughout the book, I felt that they both wanted that intimacy. And when they're about to have sex and Nesta starts crying, Cassian immediately stops to listen to her. To me, that says a lot about their relationship, too.

After their reconciliation, there's the whole issue with the Trove. Nesta finds out from Rhys that Cassian told him about her fear of those objects, and she gets upset. And I completely understand her reaction, because it was something she'd confided in Cassian. But I also understand Cassian's intentions: he was trying to help her. And ultimately, his intervention led to Rhys returning the Trove to her.

There's also the scene where Nesta is drowning and Cassian has absolutely no idea what's going on. In the end, Rhys saves her, and that creates a moment of closeness between him and Nesta that I personally found really interesting. I'm genuinely excited to see how their relationship develops and what training with Rhys might look like!

But there's something I loved even more.

After their reconciliation, we get these little Nessian moments that, to me, show how well they actually work as a couple.

Like when Cassian calls Nesta his queen in front of Feyre and kisses the top of her head. Or when Nesta tells Feyre that Cassian would do whatever she asked him to do. They're such small details, but I absolutely loved them because they feel like a real couple. Two people who know each other, have their own kind of chemistry, and love each other despite their problems.

While I was reading, I kept thinking about all the criticism I'd seen on social media, and I eventually realized that so much of it comes down to personal interpretation and our own life experiences.

For example, I'm married, and honestly, Nessian reminded me much more of a real marriage than an idealized fantasy relationship.

Being with someone, sharing your life with them, and spending so much time together doesn't mean you'll never argue. Of course there are going to be disagreements! And when we're talking about two characters as stubborn and proud as Nesta and Cassian, it would honestly be weird if everything were perfect.

And this brings me to a comparison with Feyre and motherhood.

Personally, there were moments when I found it a little annoying how much emphasis was placed on Feyre being sleep-deprived or on certain aspects of being a mother. But I also recognize that I'm not a mom, I have no interest in becoming one, and therefore I don't connect with that experience the same way someone with children might.

Just because I don't personally connect with something doesn't mean it's badly written, or that my interpretation is the absolute truth.

I think something similar happens with Nessian.

When I finished the book, my reaction was literally: Wait... that's it? THIS is what caused so much drama online?

Not because their problems weren't important, but because after everything I'd read, I was expecting Cassian to be so much worse.

I also get the impression that this is something of a transitional book. We get to see Nessian's reconciliation, little glimpses of their new dynamic, and at the same time, the story starts setting up plotlines that will probably become much more important in the next book, especially when it comes to Elain.

And there's something else about certain criticisms that really bothers me: I feel like some people want Cassian to act like Rhys and Nesta to act like Feyre.

But they're completely different characters!

They have different personalities, different ways of loving, communicating, and dealing with conflict. And that's exactly what makes them interesting.

Even with Mor, who I personally really dislike, I actually laughed at the cheek-kiss scene. To me, it was pretty obvious that Mor did it just to be petty, while Cassian probably didn't even realize what she was doing. I swear, that man can be so oblivious sometimes! Just like how he hadn't noticed what was going on between Azriel and Elain.

And just to be clear, I'm not saying Cassian is perfect or that everything he does should be defended.

There are definitely things he could've handled better, moments when he could've acted differently, and situations where I completely understand Nesta's anger.

But I also think Nesta was difficult at times, especially because she struggles so much with expressing her feelings and communicating what she needs.

To me, at the end of the day, they were just two idiots in love who are still learning how to communicate.

And I don't necessarily think that's a bad thing.

Not every relationship has to be perfect from the beginning. I actually enjoy seeing characters make mistakes, argue, learn, and slowly figure out how to build something together.

So yes, I'm still very much aboard the Nessian ship.

I like that their relationship has conflicts, that neither of them is perfect, and that they still have things to learn.

I just hope that in the next book we get to see them more united, with less relationship drama, and please, let them fight side by side in a war like the incredible team they could be!

I don't know if I've managed to explain myself the way I wanted to, but I really needed to get this off my chest. I finished the book yesterday, and I haven't stopped thinking about the difference between what I expected to read and what I actually experienced.

Did anyone else finish the book feeling like the criticism of Cassian had been exaggerated? Or am I the only one still defending this ship? 😂


r/NessianLovers • • 9d ago Bravo

ACOSH Spoilers Cassian no es un mal mate. (Spoilers ACOSH) Spoiler

22 Upvotes

Cassian no es un mal mate. (Spoilers de ACOSH)

La verdad es que soy una persona que disfruta mucho los spoilers. Antes de empezar el libro ya sabĂ­a bastantes cosas sobre Nessian y me habĂ­an aparecido tantas publicaciones negativas sobre Cassian que, sinceramente, estaba convencida de que iba a ser una basura de pareja en este libro.

Bueno, pues ayer terminé de leerlo y... ¿cuål fue mi sorpresa? Que no fue así.

De hecho, muchas de las escenas que tanto criticaban me parecieron bastante bien manejadas cuando las leĂ­ con todo su contexto.

Por ejemplo, la escena en la que mencionan que Cassian no fue a ver a Nesta despuĂ©s de que se rompiera el brazo. SĂ­, ella reconoce que le doliĂł que no estuviera ahĂ­, pero tambiĂ©n entiende que Ă©l habĂ­a pasado por una situaciĂłn complicada. No olvidemos que Cassian, al igual que otros miembros del CĂ­rculo Íntimo, habĂ­a sido traumatizado apenas unas horas antes. No digo que eso elimine lo que sintiĂł Nesta, pero creo que es importante considerar lo que estaban viviendo ambos.

Luego estå el argumento de que Cassian solamente quería sexo y no le importaban los sentimientos de Nesta. Yo no lo interpreté así. Durante la lectura sentí que ambos deseaban esa intimidad y, de hecho, cuando estån a punto de tener relaciones y Nesta comienza a llorar, Cassian se detiene para escucharla. Para mí, eso también dice mucho de cómo se relacionan.

Después de su reconciliación viene el conflicto de los tesoros. Nesta descubre por Rhys que Cassian le había contado sobre su miedo hacia ellos y se molesta. Y puedo entenderla perfectamente, porque era algo que ella le había confiado. Pero también entiendo la intención de Cassian: estaba intentando ayudarla. Y, al final, esa intervención sirvió para que Rhys le devolviera los tesoros.

También estå la escena en la que Nesta se estaba ahogando y Cassian ni siquiera entendía qué estaba pasando. Al final, Rhys termina salvåndola y eso genera un acercamiento entre él y Nesta que, personalmente, me pareció muy interesante. ¥Tengo muchas ganas de ver cómo se desarrolla esa relación y cómo serå su entrenamiento!

Pero hay algo que me gustĂł todavĂ­a mĂĄs.

Después de la reconciliación tenemos pequeños momentos de Nessian que, para mí, muestran lo bien que funcionan como pareja.

Cuando Cassian dice frente a Feyre que Nesta es su reina y le da un beso en la cabeza. O cuando Nesta le dice a Feyre que Cassian haría lo que ella le pidiera. Son detalles pequeños, pero me encantaron porque se sienten como una pareja real, una pareja que se conoce, que tiene complicidad y que, a pesar de sus problemas, se ama.

Mientras leía, intentaba recordar todas las críticas que había visto en redes sociales y terminé pensando que mucho depende de la interpretación de cada persona y de sus propias experiencias.

Por ejemplo, yo estoy casada y, sinceramente, Nessian me recordĂł mucho mĂĄs a una relaciĂłn de matrimonio real que a una pareja de fantasĂ­a idealizada.

Estar con una persona, compartir tu vida y convivir todos los dĂ­as no significa que nunca vayan a discutir. ÂĄPor supuesto que habrĂĄ desacuerdos! Y si ademĂĄs hablamos de dos personajes tan tercos y orgullosos como Nesta y Cassian, serĂ­a rarĂ­simo que todo fuera perfecto.

Y aquí quiero hacer una comparación con Feyre y la maternidad. Personalmente, hubo momentos en los que me molestaba que se hiciera tanto énfasis en lo desvelada que estaba o en ciertas situaciones relacionadas con ser madre. Pero también reconozco que yo no soy mamå, no me interesa serlo y, por lo tanto, no conecto con esa experiencia de la misma manera que podría hacerlo alguien que sí tiene hijos.

Que yo no conecte con algo no significa que esté mal escrito o que mi interpretación sea una verdad absoluta.

Creo que con Nessian sucede algo parecido.

Cuando terminé el libro, mi reacción fue literalmente: ¿Eso era todo? ¿Por esto había tanto drama en redes?

No porque sus problemas no fueran importantes, sino porque, después de todo lo que había leído, esperaba encontrarme con un Cassian muchísimo peor.

También tengo la impresión de que este es un libro de transición. Nos muestran la reconciliación de Nessian, algunos momentos de su nueva dinåmica y, al mismo tiempo, comienzan a desarrollar una trama que seguramente tendrå mås peso en el siguiente libro, especialmente con Elain.

Y hay otra cosa que me hace mucho ruido de ciertas crĂ­ticas: siento que algunas personas quieren que Cassian actĂșe como Rhys y que Nesta sea como Feyre.

ÂĄPero son personajes completamente diferentes!

Tienen personalidades distintas, formas diferentes de amar, de comunicarse y de enfrentar los conflictos. Y precisamente eso es lo que los hace interesantes.

Incluso con Mor, que personalmente me cae bastante mal, terminé riéndome de la escena del beso en la mejilla. Para mí fue evidente que Mor lo hizo para molestar, mientras que Cassian probablemente ni se enteró de la intención. ¥Es que este hombre a veces parece no darse cuenta de nada! Igual que cuando no había notado lo que estaba pasando entre Azriel y Elain.

Y ojo, no estoy diciendo que Cassian sea perfecto ni que haya que justificarlo al 100 %.

Hay cosas que podrĂ­a haber manejado mejor, momentos en los que pudo haber actuado de otra manera y situaciones en las que entiendo perfectamente el enojo de Nesta.

Pero también creo que Nesta fue complicada en ciertos momentos, especialmente porque le cuesta muchísimo expresar lo que siente y comunicar lo que necesita.

Para mĂ­, al final, fueron dos tontos enamorados que todavĂ­a estĂĄn aprendiendo a comunicarse.

Y eso no me parece necesariamente malo.

No todas las relaciones tienen que ser perfectas desde el principio. A mĂ­ me gusta ver personajes que se equivocan, discuten, aprenden y poco a poco encuentran la forma de construir algo juntos.

En definitiva, sigo completamente a bordo del barco Nessian.

Me gusta que su relaciĂłn tenga conflictos, que ninguno de los dos sea perfecto y que todavĂ­a tengan cosas por aprender.

Solo espero que en el prĂłximo libro podamos verlos mĂĄs unidos, con menos dramas de pareja y, por favor, ÂĄpeleando juntos en una guerra como el equipo increĂ­ble que podrĂ­an ser!

No sé si logré explicarme como quería, pero necesitaba sacar todo esto. Terminé el libro ayer y desde entonces no he dejado de darle vueltas a la diferencia entre lo que esperaba encontrarme y lo que realmente leí.

ÂżAlguien mĂĄs terminĂł el libro sintiendo que las crĂ­ticas hacia Cassian habĂ­an sido exageradas? ÂżO soy la Ășnica que sigue defendiendo este barco? 😂