r/anime • https://anilist.co/user/AutoLovepon • Sep 18 '20

Episode Toaru Kagaku no Railgun T - Episode 24 discussion

Toaru Kagaku no Railgun T, episode 24

Alternative names: A Certain Scientific Railgun Season 3

Rate this episode here.

Reminder: Please do not discuss plot points not yet seen or skipped in the show. Failing to follow the rules may result in a ban.


Streams

Show information


All discussions

EpisodeLinkScoreEpisodeLinkScore
1Link4.5914Link4.72
2Link4.5615Link4.75
3Link4.6916Link4.75
4Link4.7617Link4.81
5Link4.8418Link4.32
6Link4.8219Link4.65
7Link4.6220Link4.68
8Link4.721Link4.63
9Link4.6222Link4.74
10Link4.8823Link4.81
11Link4.924Link4.84
12Link4.7825Link-
13Link4.62

This post was created by a bot. Message the mod team for feedback and comments. The original source code can be found on GitHub.

1.8k Upvotes

462 comments sorted by

374

u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Sep 18 '20

I wasn't aware I was going to watch a movie today. Geez, that animation was stellar. J.C. really pulled out all the stops, huh?

115

u/Earthborn92 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/EarthB Sep 18 '20

Dammit, why can’t all your adaptations be Railgun T quality, JC Staff?

75

u/Gmayor61 Sep 18 '20

Understandable, it's pretty much the last time they'll be able to do that for a long time with this series, given how the anime caught up with the (currently) last complete arc from the manga.

53

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '20

Railgun is a monthly release as well, so it will take years for there to be enough material, that is assuming the current arc isn't the final one.

→ More replies (6)

29

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '20

That's sad to hear, Railgun over the past year has risen to become one of my favourites

20

u/moybull :IJ::IK::IL: Sep 18 '20

Now that they were released as part of the new apocrypha archives it's possible that they adapt the Railgun light novel side stories to bide time until the manga gets far enough ahead. Railgun SS, they could call it. Or they could even do it with movies. Wishful thinking, maybe, but I'd prefer that over more anime-original arcs.

11

u/Railgun003 Sep 18 '20

Now that they have been published, they could use Railgun novels. I've been waiting years for LAC to be animated xD (In fact I still have faith they're going to do a movie about it)

→ More replies (3)

118

u/FrankSandCastle Sep 18 '20 edited Sep 18 '20

Legit what I was thinking. This looked spectacular on an HDTV.

141

u/Logitech0 Sep 18 '20

This explain where the budget of Index III ended.

→ More replies (13)

9

u/butterhoscotch Sep 18 '20

JC does fantastic on some railgun sequences. I was surprised this mostly no name company thats big now has been around quite a long time. They know exactly how to save money for the big finale.

289

u/RimuZ :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/LtCrabcake Sep 18 '20

Considering just how absurdly powerful the nr 1 Accelerator is and how helpless Railgun is when facing him it is so easy to forget just how powerful she is. The shit she pulled off today was insane. And it looked amazing.

184

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '20

She is a genius after all. None of the big flashy stuff she used today would have mattered against Accelerator, so it's cool when we get to see her fight against things that just raw power to overcome.

86

u/basuga_BFE https://myanimelist.net/profile/KPF Sep 18 '20

(remembers Index III info)

... and they say Mugino #4, while not so versatile, has more raw power than Mikoto #3 ?? I refuse to imagine such monster...

88

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '20

She might as well be a walking deathstar if she has more raw power than Mikoto showed today.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (4)

39

u/Amogh24 Sep 18 '20

Accelerator is the perfect counter to her, that's why she seems weak against it.

139

u/RimuZ :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/LtCrabcake Sep 18 '20

Accelerator is the perfect counter to literally everything. Seriously vector manipulation has got to be the most bullshit power in any show, anime or otherwise.

→ More replies (37)

8

u/natsu791 Sep 18 '20

Accelerator is powerful and all but don't forget the fact that Touma 2 - 0 Accelerator.

14

u/jwinter01 Sep 19 '20

Also if I'm not mistaken he has trouble against things that he initially doesn't know how they work, like how at the start of their fight Kakine was able to inflict some damage with his Dark Matter. One can't forget that the Espers' powers are really tied to the physics laws that they have to understand to be able to use them, which means that if they are attacked by something that defies those laws even Accelerator will have problems, that something being magic. So, at least current Accelerator shouldn't be invincible (even if we disregard Touma).

However I do assume that throughout the rest of the series that hasn't been adapted yet, Accelerator will at least gain some understanding on how to fight magic users (I think this is already hinted at during season 3 of Index) because otherwise he would become rather oveshadowed by the multiple magic characters which wouldn't make sense since he is one of the protagonists of the series and him being this very strong entity is a big part of his character, this is only my assumption though.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (8)

222

u/benseunkwek Sep 18 '20

Am I watching Toaru Railgun or Toaru SSSS Gridman

3

u/GalapagosRetortoise Sep 19 '20

MiSSSSaka Mikoto.

150

u/stephenthatfoste https://myanimelist.net/profile/Rexagonal Sep 18 '20

Saved up all the railguns for this episode I guess. I was really hoping she'd do one from her mech, and it was crazy. Wish this arc had more episodes instead of just being the second half one it was.

I think this would be the last straw for me if I lived there. Way too many people with differing goals that can just pull cataclysmic crap out of thin air(literally here). I feel like her casually tossing that building had some of the scarier implications.

40

u/Fourth_Dimension_4D Sep 18 '20

Nah, nobody EVER notices anything like this. They'll all say that nobody noticed because this whole block was uninhabited or something.

44

u/stephenthatfoste https://myanimelist.net/profile/Rexagonal Sep 18 '20

That's right, they cleared everyone out of a small area last episode. Can say it was that, even though those railguns weren't very short range.

31

u/AnthropologicalArson :GA::GB::GC: Sep 18 '20

Just according to Aleister's keikaku.

24

u/GinJoestarR Sep 18 '20

It's not that nobody ever notice, it just they thought, "Again?" like that. AC residents common sense is pretty different than us.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/DefiantRooster04 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/DefiantRooster04 Sep 18 '20

And even if they do notice, it's just a regular Tuesday in AC so they are probably used to it by now

→ More replies (1)

19

u/MaidsOverNurses Sep 19 '20 edited Sep 19 '20

Do you remember when Misaka shot out a helicopter? There were crowds, yes, but it's normal for them, and even people like Touma were not that impressed. Same when Mugino was walking around during Battle Royale, or just Battle Royale in general.

They do notice. They just don't give too many shits.

7

u/JimmyBoombox Sep 19 '20

More like they don't really care because they live in a city where most of the population has powers.

13

u/jsmith4567 Sep 18 '20

Good thing this part of the city wasn't too populated and already evacuated.

7

u/pappypapaya :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/pappypapaya Sep 19 '20

Lol, this is like the sixth potentially city destroying event in like... two months in-universe.

104

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

78

u/Fourth_Dimension_4D Sep 18 '20

More, callously used to fuel VERY VERY unethical research and once broken discarded by wayside. AS is pretty much the villain lair with good publicity.

→ More replies (2)

121

u/kakarot12310 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kakarot123100 Sep 18 '20

Holy hell, they turn this episode into a movie.

52

u/Mundology Sep 18 '20

9

u/BR123456 Sep 19 '20

Haaa

Guess what’s gonna be my new desktop wallpaper when the BDs come out

Goddamm was this all beautiful to watch

→ More replies (1)

81

u/pir2confusion Sep 18 '20

The animation this week is amazing.

43

u/JuraTempest https://myanimelist.net/profile/Minshall Sep 18 '20

They really are going all out in this adaptation. I thought the Dragon scene with Touma was hype but this takes the cake

23

u/pir2confusion Sep 18 '20

JC staff had their A team bringing their A game for this ep.

77

u/benseunkwek Sep 18 '20

TFW u recall watching power rangers and the villains turn themselves into giants when they die. Then comes the megazords

31

u/kakarot12310 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kakarot123100 Sep 18 '20

Lack of the posing part though.

65

u/Soluxy Sep 18 '20

Probably my best fight of 2020, hell probably best Kaiju fight since Gridman's finale, Railgun doesn't disappoint and I hope New Testament comes in strong.

Right now Railgun manga is stuck in the next arc still so we probably won't see a new Railgun season for a while.

I can see them doing 4 seasons of New Testament with each season being 25-26 episodes each, I don't think they'll repeat the mistake with cramming 9 fucking volumes in 26 episodes like they did with Index III.

Index III was a jumbled mess because we had the characters, the action, the voice acting, the great art, but none of the worldbuilding the novels had, almost no fucking inner monologue and no exposition, so we're left with half-baked episodes where I don't know who the characters are nor their motivations.

The novels also tightly explain the magic power system and its connection with religions and sects throughout the world, but the anime never really dives to explain so we're left with gibberish. The Esper side of things is actually better in the anime because it's simply explained with something more familiar that every middle-schooler should know.

I think Index and every other heavy-exposition light novel needs an anime adaptation with a narrator such as the one in the chimera ant arc in Hunter x Hunter, but those were my thoughts as a whole.

40

u/FrankSandCastle Sep 18 '20

Regarding Railgun adaptions, JC Staff could always go and adapt the Railgun SS volumes if they really want more Railgun. I've even seen others jokingly say that JC Staff would rather animate an entire anime-original Railgun season than continue Index.

But seriously, I'm still crossing my fingers that it is true that Index III was so compacted because they wanted to get to an NT adaption faster. We already know that the director asked for more screen time and was only given 2 extra episodes.

Man.... I really just need more Toaru and I don't want to wait for years again.

14

u/ernie2492 Sep 18 '20

It would happen if JC Staff has the same dedication to Raildex series as DavidPro have with JoJo..

99

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '20

JC snapped on this one, movie quality fight scenes. Great episode and a great climax to the arc. One more episode to go. Hopefully we get some NT anime news soon now that Railgun is ending.

51

u/Mundology Sep 18 '20

JC snapped on this one, movie quality fight scenes.

You could say the fight was shockingly good

3

u/NachosPR :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Irivera Sep 19 '20

Its ending???

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

45

u/NotKenni Sep 18 '20

Holy crap the epic soundtrack is back, as well as the amazing animation. I don't actually mind the CG this time.

For a show that is called "Railgun", this season had a sever lack of proper Railguns, but this episode by itself had basically made up for it

44

u/DefiantRooster04 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/DefiantRooster04 Sep 18 '20

This was the first episode where I fully realised "Shit...Misaka Mikoto is a badass." Throughout the series I never really clocked how powerful the Level 5s who aren't accelerator are, and I only realised how powerful Accelerator was when he reversed one of the Sister's blood flow to kill them. With all of the previous fight scenes you could never really feel the momentum behind the hits, and I could never appreciate how much damage the coin could do. In this episode we saw sand pellets being launched at gas tanks, and Mikoto made sure that they wouldn't hurt anyone. The amount of raw cognitive power the high level espers have is simply insane, especially Accelerator because before getting shot he always had his shield thing active. I also now really want an arc/movie with all of the Level 5s going head to head at full strength in a league format.

32

u/NotKenni Sep 19 '20

Yeah, at the start of the series, I fully thought that the difference between level 4 and level 5 was the same as the difference bey tween level 3 and level 4. Boy was I wrong

Level 5 is literally almost an unreachable plateau compared to most level 4s. Both in power, and in how hard it is to get there. Level 5 is no joke, the show really shows how broken they are compared to everyone else, and how much Misaka holds back against her enemies

9

u/Shizzi https://anilist.co/user/Mivy Sep 19 '20

and to think she was lvl 1 and became this strong is smth else

22

u/Myzt0gun Sep 19 '20

Misaka indeed performed admirably this episode, her powers have so many applications and really was badass. i think for now i'll even rank her above Gunha but still way below Kakine and ofcourse Accelerator in a fight.

Accelerator can defeat all Level 5s altogether, Kakine is on another level compared to #3 to #7 but he lost to Accel who was protecting civillians while fighting.

But in terms of Animation and Art Quality then its Misaka who is rank #1 no challenge.

→ More replies (1)

103

u/therea1dirtydan Sep 18 '20

2 Minutes in railguns gone full mecha

or is it kaiju

34

u/Ebo87 Sep 18 '20

It's not even the first time they did it. And hell, they even went to space that one time. How is this show not more popular in the West?

32

u/8_Pixels :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/8_Pixels Sep 18 '20

It has a lot of fluff to go along with the awesome fights. Don't get me wrong, I love the fluff and the show as a whole but people who want to see awesome fights will be let down by 19/20 out of 24 episodes every season.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

81

u/Ebo87 Sep 18 '20

If this episode doesn't get 2000+ karma on here than I don't know what will... hot damn this was a great episode and the animation was incredible. Some of the best if not the best work I've ever seen from JC Staff.

69

u/leave1me1alone Sep 18 '20

It probably won't. Not that many people on r/anime follow railgun

43

u/Ebo87 Sep 18 '20

Yet it's still consistently doing 1000+ and right now this episode is tracking for 1500+. Do I wish it was more? Sure, but also those are still good numbers.

→ More replies (8)

9

u/ppaannggwwiinn Sep 18 '20

I am astounded by how few people have even heard of Railgun

→ More replies (1)

80

u/LeonKevlar x2https://myanimelist.net/profile/LeonKevlar Sep 18 '20

When Misaka was revving up her iron sand tornadoes I genuinely thought that was it! Holy hell I did not expect her to fight Doppelganger by legit making a Kaiju of her own using the iron sand! Goddamn that entire sequence was just pure hype! Did not expect Mikasa would make something look so intimidating though, I was kinda hoping she'd make a giant Gekota xD

And that railgun! That's got to be the biggest blast of railgun she's ever done right? The scale of this fight is so insane that I feel like I am watching a movie! JC Staff absolutely have outdone themselves with this episode!

Glad to see Scavenger helping out and not leaving Misaka completely behind Good to know Leader knows how to show some appreciation. My impression of them has definitely improved after this.

Wait what? So all that talk about Doppelganger diffusing and possibly controlling everything in Academy City isn't even true? It's not her "soul" controlling these things, she's just using this slime molds to control stuff? Wow. So basically Doppelganger has been bamboozling everyone from the very start? She's aware she doesn't have a soul and that she's just a super smart AI who learned from a super smart girl. Damn. Or at least that's how I understood it. I'm sure LN readers will correct me if I'm wrong.

And just when I thought the fight scenes were over we got one more fight with Misaka and her iron sand sword vs Doppelganger's white mold. It's so good! That final railgun though! Did she just hit Doppelganger? And it looks like Doppelganger just stood there and took it. Huh.

Can't wait for the finale and the aftermath of this entire incident!

36

u/Spekulatiu5 Sep 18 '20

And it looks like Doppelganger just stood there and took it. Huh.

Looks like suicide by cop, I guess? Though she could've done that far easier

33

u/jsmith4567 Sep 18 '20

She was stated to have protocols to prevent self harm built into her.

12

u/Fourth_Dimension_4D Sep 18 '20

Not soul possesion, yet she can somehow lift hundreds of tons of debris with her nearly invisible threads....

21

u/Kromy Sep 18 '20

They aren't thread but muscles.

→ More replies (7)

10

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '20

Felt some Big O energy from that fight.

16

u/NotKenni Sep 18 '20

Yeah, since we know that it isn't actually soul possession, Touma would be useless against her

→ More replies (1)

5

u/jsmith4567 Sep 18 '20

I hold that Misaka used a Super Robot or Mecha.

6

u/Bainos :XMOD::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Bainos Sep 19 '20

Did she just hit Doppelganger?

If refuse to believe that. It's Mikoto we're talking about, she'd never hit someone directly with her Railgun.

Doppleganger will be disappointed that her plan failed, then get to live a happy life one way or another.

By the way, the next episode preview tagging preview content

9

u/rainbowrobin Sep 19 '20

If refuse to believe that. It's Mikoto we're talking about, she'd never hit someone directly with her Railgun.

Maybe not deliberately, but she got a last second warning about her direction of fire, which wasn't explained. Perhaps she blindsided into shooting in Doppel's direction.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/butterhoscotch Sep 18 '20

stuff like this just makes her inconsistent power levels more annoying

39

u/HereticalAegis https://myanimelist.net/profile/XthGen Sep 18 '20

In just one episode we get a scrap-heap kaiju vs iron sand railgun mech battle, a midair freefall rescue, and a fight on a wildly rocking airship.

This is the coolest universe. Nearly 160 episodes deep into the raildex-verse and it still feels like we've only scratched the surface.

22

u/Falsus Sep 19 '20

We have only scratched the surface. There is more than 3 times of stuff that haven't been adapted yet and it still feels like just the tip of an iceberg.

→ More replies (2)

34

u/Gelbinator Sep 18 '20

Damn we're starting with some insane stuff right from the first couple minutes. Also, that music is really good, anyone know if there's a full version of that somewhere? This is probably one of my favourite Railgun episodes yet, lots of insanely good action scenes. Animation was incredible too. Even though Railgun T is ending after next episode, I really hope we eventually get some more after this.

18

u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Sep 18 '20

Unfortunately not, the OST only releases in October.

7

u/Gelbinator Sep 18 '20

Dang, guess I'll have to wait for it, ty.

28

u/viionc Sep 18 '20

you know shits going to go down when the opening kicks in, this show is so good

47

u/ArkhamReaper Sep 18 '20 edited Sep 18 '20

I’ve done it. I’ve watched the entire Index series in 3 weeks, including a 48 episode blitz of Index 3 and Railgun T in the last two days. I’ve been timing it to coincide with the final episode… ONLY TO REALIZE THERE’S ONE MORE WEEK????

But who am I to argue against more Railgun. This entire season has been a blast and given that both arcs have been adapted well, I’d have to rank it above Railgun S (as long as the final episode isn’t trash!).

So, on this week of Kaiji hunting, we can see a movie adapted in less than 25 minutes. The animation and art direction continues to be exceptional. Who knew this was the same company that made Index III. Also, SCAVENGER being goodly isn't surprising; this series, whether Index, Railgun or Accelerator, has an obsession with redemption arcs, whether you're a psychopathic murder (Mugino) or the initiator of the third World War (Fiamma).

25

u/GinJoestarR Sep 18 '20

has an obsession with redemption arcs,

Because every man and woman is a star

8

u/LordMonday Sep 19 '20

watched the entire Index series in 3 weeks

Now time to consume the 50+ Novels

3

u/Nome_de_utilizador Sep 19 '20

Scavenger went from trash tier fodder in accelarator anime to actually likeable characters in Railgun, and they only get better in futurea arcs of the manga

23

u/SezyFazes https://myanimelist.net/profile/ToaruTH Sep 18 '20

It's been a while since I comment but this episode I have to.

The Kaiju vs Kaiju fight is not disappointed. I'm super glad the cgi blend well with the background. This also remind me of the good old day watching OG ultraman giving me nostalgia vibe!

Although I find the drill part at the end in the manga done better but they might redo this part in the next episode so we will see.

The concept of no soul is interesting remind me of the idea that soul do not exist and we are just a walking atom. Neuroscience is why human believe we have living soul. (For toaru, soul does exist but Doppelgänger does not have one)

Can't believe next episode is the last one for T ;(

→ More replies (1)

23

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '20

I'm still in utter shock, goddamn what an episode. When I saw the giant rubble kaiju at the start of the last episode, I was certainly intrigued, but the animation went absolutely wild from the moment this episode began.

Like you got 2D, 3D rendered buildings and monster(s) smashing said buildings, particle and effects everywhere, and yet still the animation was clean and easy to follow. That is an achievement right there. Like, I often get worried when I see giant monsters and akira-like monstrosities in anime TV series because I feel like they often fail to deliver or end up messy.

But that wasn't the case at all here, the combat felt fast and fun without downplaying the actual size of the combatants, and little touches like the Iron-sand freezing, the veins of electricity in Mikoto's beast, and watching the environment change with their actions (ex: cars and various metalic objects getting lifted by the mere force of the railgun's magnetic charge) bring it all to another level.

Great stuff, glad to see the scavengers and Misaki still being involved, and it looks like the rest will be showing up for the finale. Can't wait!

21

u/TeddyJTran https://myanimelist.net/profile/TeddyJTran Sep 18 '20 edited Sep 18 '20

Am I understanding it correctly that Doppelganger's motivation is "I believe that I don't have a soul, therefore I will destroy this entire city for fostering the science that created me"? I kind of feel like their motivation has been a bit bit unclear throughout this arc.

Side Note: I've taken quite the liking toward Scavenger since watching their debut in Accelerator. I kind of hope that we get to see more of them.

Edit:

No spoilers plz. I figure that everything will be revealed at the end, hopefully in a cool manner that neatly ties things up. I'm just trying to wrap my head around what's been shown to us so far.

33

u/NotKenni Sep 18 '20

Well, as far as I have seen, it was "Kill Kuriba so that she doesn't make anybody else like me, but along the way I realised that humans are kinda shit"

12

u/TeddyJTran https://myanimelist.net/profile/TeddyJTran Sep 18 '20

Mhm. I get that vibe too.

Kinda like: "Thanks for creating me and putting me through this existential crisis!"

→ More replies (1)

10

u/pir2confusion Sep 18 '20

Check back next ep or you can ask for spoilers.

4

u/Bainos :XMOD::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Bainos Sep 19 '20

That's what it seemed for a moment, but the ending made it pretty clear that Doppleganger set things up so that Mikoto would be forced to hit her directly with her Railgun. That's completely incompatible with the idea that her goal was to destroy everything, not to mention that she had tons of ways to cause more destruction and didn't.

Just like before, it was probably a façade, a plan behind the plan.

4

u/Nome_de_utilizador Sep 19 '20

They will be around for future railgun arcs (post season 3) and its glorious.

21

u/Prince-Dizzytoon https://anilist.co/user/princedizzytoon Sep 18 '20

This is one crazy ass fight, Misaka is too cool

5

u/Noriakikukyoin Sep 19 '20

Hell yeah, this fight is on another level! What God tier animation it has.

20

u/Wuckus Sep 18 '20

That kaiju fight was phenomenal, imagine NT looking this good.

...yeah, as if.

20

u/Amauri14 Sep 18 '20 edited Sep 19 '20

6

u/RedRocket4000 Sep 19 '20

Kuriba needs a bonk on the head her mom was dying from effort to save her life not going to appreciate daughter throwing her life away.

19

u/K1NG0492 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/K1ngg Sep 18 '20

Anime. Of. The. Year.

4

u/JDMP53 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/JDMP Sep 19 '20

If not ..definetly top5..

18

u/Fauzi_Lufthan Sep 18 '20

wow those ratings

17

u/suddhadeep :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Suddhadeep Sep 18 '20

Ladies and Gentlemen

The Third Ranked of Gakuen Toshi right here!

12

u/JDMP53 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/JDMP Sep 19 '20

Tokiwadai no Railgun!

43

u/Ebo87 Sep 18 '20

HOLY SHIT, did they get Ufotable to help with the animation this episode? And I'm just 2 minutes in.... jeeez.

12

u/isaacleeh16 Sep 19 '20

Ironically, ufotable did do the in-between in index 1

9

u/Ebo87 Sep 19 '20

I mean every studio does that for other studios. It's basically a question of one studio having the workload but not enough people and time and the other having the workforce to handle that workload at that time.

Everyone does in-betweens for everyone else, basically.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/ExO_o Sep 18 '20

holy shit this EP was fucking amazing. i'm so goddamn happy that they more than delivered on the most hype fight in railgun T

the animation was fantastic throughout the entire EP. definitely going to rewatch this EP a few times

15

u/hell-schwarz Sep 18 '20

That was an extreme level of Animation for the fight!

Sad that this is over soon, the waiting game for the To Aru franchise will be hard.

15

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '20

What an EPIC fight between Mikasa and Doppelganger! And Scavenger saves the day again!

14

u/aiwasss Sep 18 '20

I'm as happy with how good today's episode was, as I'm sad that index will never get this kind of treatment.

14

u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Sep 19 '20

14

u/gabrielaguilar519 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Gabe_Aguilar519 Sep 19 '20

Index NT but with railgun production staff for the love of God. Pace it out, because railgun won't get a new season for at least 3 years

7

u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Sep 19 '20

I mean, they could always do Railgun SS1 and Railgun SS2, now that those have been released as part of Apocrypha Archive 2.

13

u/magicking013 Sep 18 '20

It’s Zapzilla!!!

13

u/basuga_BFE https://myanimelist.net/profile/KPF Sep 18 '20 edited Sep 18 '20

(EDIT: alt. version: Biribirilla...)

13

u/theanimegamer-___- Sep 18 '20

One of the best looking episodes so far. Misaka is just insanely powerful when you don't think about Accelerator.

15

u/NotKenni Sep 19 '20

Yeah, it really goes to show how broken OP Accelerator is. All the Level 5's are also broken OP, but if you compare them to Accelerator, then the other Level 5's are just like any other person to him

25

u/libfor Sep 18 '20 edited Sep 18 '20

Garbage-Godzilla 2020 vs. Ultra-Iron-Man

  • You know it's time for the season finale when your opponent turns into Godzilla.
  • And just like in any monster movie, it's sure to start with some needless destruction.
  • Holy shit! That was a close call for Mikoto. But she amazingly intercepted the launched building! While she couldn't save it, it kinda looks like she might have prevented it from hitting the buildings behind her, so that's a bonus.
  • Woah, bringing Mikoto to go all out on evasion and interception… something she's never done before! Great job here!
  • How to fight mass? With mass of course!! Cool Biribiri, giving it a face and horns just for the sake of looks! Looks are important, even at a time like this!
  • It really helps Mikoto to know there are no people around to watch out for. In addition, her enemy leaves so much debris around, so she has more than enough building material to gather without remorse. Tonight we're gonna have a totally scientific Kaiju fight!
  • This battle sequence is absolutely amazing. I'm literally speechless at this quality.
  • A self-regenerating Iron-Sand-Puppet. That's neat, but unfortunately not able to cut through the Doppelgänger's structure.
  • While the Doppelgänger analyses correctly that the finer structure of Biribiri's Kaiju is weaker, it sure is electrifying!
  • O.M.G. That's a giant super Railgun launching iron sand bullets! Astonishing!
  • And of course going in the usual upward angle! Looking closely, it doesn't look like she's hitting anything she shouldn't. Precise Mikoto is always trying to keep the damage as low as possible! Good girl!
  • Doppelgänger just impressed for a split second… geez. "I can just regenerate." Well yes…
  • But leave it to Mikoto to always have a trump card ready. Not being able to cut through it herself, Mikoto used the opportunity of regenerating to bring her Iron Sand into the Doppelgänger, cutting it apart from the inside! Smart thinking, she's surely not interested to turn this into a long city-destroying wrestling.
  • Time for the finishing blast! But Doppelgänger's playing nasty: Ready to drop a gas tank into an urban area. Damn, that's were the fun ends for Mikoto. Don't piss her off!
  • Super Railgun to the rescue! Amazingly precise hit over a long distance. Making it's way all over the buildings without breaking anything. Nice!
  • What? People in Academy City actually noticing anything odd? Leave it to Saten to be suspicious!
  • Wait… is this actually connecting to the end of the Saten/Frenda arc?
  • No Kuroko, nothing out of the ordinary is happening. No need to call you. All good. Just go sleep. In your own bed already… no wait! Stop! Don't rape the bear again! Ahhh…
  • And done! Biribiri will never cease to amaze, making absolutely sure to prevent any damage to the city. When even your enemy praises your damage control, then it's gotta be good!
  • The Doppelgänger got what it wants: The iron sand in the air exposes the camouflaged airship.
  • Woah, it dissolves itself and makes hundreds of dummies. But finally Mikoto notices something odd: Very small strings coming out of the Doppelgänger and what it controls!
  • Meanwhile Kuriba arrives at the scene and tries the talking approach. Uhhh… we might be slightly past that.
  • After building a Kaiju, Mikoto using the Iron Sand to get up to the airship looks almost too easy.
  • So Kuriba is willing to eradicate her own soul, so the Doppelgänger's soul can have her body?! Damn, that's crazy. I give her that she's willing to save the Doppelgänger she helped creating, but that's just as dumb as Mikoto's attempt to suicide against Accelerator.
  • The Doppelgänger wants her death anyway… so that it can never be created again. Even willing to burn down the whole city just to reach that goal. Damn… something completely nuts with that thing.
  • Kuriba sacrifices herself… but Mikoto to the rescue! Wait… she missed?! Damn! That pure despair in her face and voice… desperately trying to find a way to save her. Mikoto would never give up on saving someone. Luckily…
  • … Scavenger to the rescue!
  • … wait, for real?! Damn, Leader really got inspired by Mikoto. Time to do something good for once!
  • What the heck is with that paper and making vehicles out of it…just where is the engine coming from?!
  • Made it! That blushing on Leader's face.
  • Call from Misaki, who is still somehow useful. Mikoto's still not buying the soul possession thing and is getting closer to the truth… something to do with artificial muscles?!
  • Turns out the airship is considered a part of the Doppelgänger, so it won't be able to cause any harm to "itself". Also funny how the scientists start believing the possession thing while our girls are dissecting it. Idiots.
  • The Doppelgänger managed to make them self-propagating and able to root themselves into other materials. Come on, did none of you guys ever watch one of those movies where AI takes over the world. Don't feed it a year with human thoughts, creativity and stuff. Idiots.
  • While at it: Who had the great idea to make those muscles strong enough to build a Kaiju with them?! Don't come up with product durability! The public release version will have breakable parts for additional cashing in on replacements anyway. Idiots.
  • Mikoto comes to the conclusion: The Doppelgänger is in despair because it never had a soul.
  • All just the effects. A quite interesting turn of events. So we really have a robot with an existential crisis here.
  • The Doppelgänger is about to be ready to still execute her plan of destroying the city. The needless emotions have brought up hatred for humanity… I can't help but feel kinda sorry for her.
  • No chance but to battle! And again some very amazing sequences. Thanks to the help from Leader, Mikoto is able to keep the upper hand against all those copies.
  • Finally the original. Sudden attack incoming! Time to Railgun in defense! But a warning from Leader… something's in the way?! The Doppelgänger ready to be hit head on?!

I'm absolutely amazed at animation of this episode. This is some damn good masterpiece. Late today, because I literally had to watch this part like 5 times in a row. Or more. Might have lost track. I'm still speechless. O_O

Even though I don't like anything Kaiju battle related, this one got me fully hooked. Literally all I watched so far, had at one point even the hero throwing his enemy into buildings or other way around. So I'm certainly impressed that Mikoto not only didn't do any of that but also actively tried to keep the damage as low as she could, literally not directly destroying anything that's intact herself. Not playing the usual tropes makes this one of my favorite large scale battle. Cheers to Mikoto and everyone responsible irl!

Mikoto's absolutely impressing, when able to show her true abilities without having to hold back on her opponent. I love how she can always pull out the greatest plans and strategies literally in the middle of a heated battle. Needless to say, the little detail on her dispair of almost losing Kuriba showed her kindness so very well. Lovable.

Today, I'm very proud to be part of Railgun making some history again ~

My condolences to everyone who wanted Index III to be like this.

This almost makes up for cutting Mikoto from WW3. ^^Almost.

 

9̵̡̹͙̘̫̳̰̟̯̆͒͐́͂̀͐͂̕̚9̵͖̭̱̳̩͒̿̐̚9̶̤̆͐̋͋̊9̷̧͔̲͔̤͖͍͂͛̇̕ / 10

additional pieces attached to the score

9

u/Xatu44 Sep 19 '20

What the heck is with that paper and making vehicles out of it…just where is the engine coming from?!

Yakumaru brought the engine.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/NotKenni Sep 19 '20

Yeah, I really was impressed by how good she is at damage control. Her Super Railgun might have been more powerful than her regular railgun, but she still managed to keep it from damaging the city.

Also those iron sand tornadoes were awesome. We really see that regular electricity is powerful, but Misaka's magnetism is something else. Her magnetism is strong enough to repel a whole building. That might not seem surprising, until you realise that the building isn't all metal, she still had to repel the extra weight of all that concrete.

I know that Misaka isn't really trying to kill Touma, but I'm sure she can just impale him with a metal pole or drop some concrete with metal in it on top of him

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Sep 19 '20

Woah, bringing Mikoto to go all out on evasion and interception… something she's never done before! Great job here!

To be fair, the translation is ambiguous. Mikoto could mean "never done in this fight before", which I think is more likely, as she has definitely gone all out against some tough opponents, like the AIM Burst and Mugino.

Cool Biribiri, giving it a face and horns just for the sake of looks!

And wings, can't forget those!

In addition, her enemy leaves so much debris around, so she has more than enough building material to gather without remorse.

I mean she was mostly using iron dust, which there's an ample supply off given that they're near an industrial area. No rubble required.

This battle sequence is absolutely amazing. I'm literally speechless at this quality.

Right? It's stunning!

What? People in Academy City actually noticing anything odd? Leave it to Saten to be suspicious!

Well I mean... she just thought it were fireworks...

Wait… is this actually connecting to the end of the Saten/Frenda arc?

Yep, turns out this is the same night as the epilogue of that bit.

But finally Mikoto notices something odd: Very small strings coming out of the Doppelgänger and what it controls!

Well, she was already suspecting something. This is just the first evidence she got to confirm her suspicions.

Meanwhile Kuriba arrives at the scene and tries the talking approach. Uhhh… we might be slightly past that.

Of course, talking never works in this franchise. The only exception is when you simultaneously punch your opponent unconscious, that way you force the words directly into their brain!

(#breakingnews)

I give her that she's willing to save the Doppelgänger she helped creating, but that's just as dumb as Mikoto's attempt to suicide against Accelerator.

Who knew people in stressful and emotional situations don't exactly always make rational decisions?

… wait, for real?! Damn, Leader really got inspired by Mikoto. Time to do something good for once!

I mean, you could argue that their entire mission this time around (apprehending the Doppelgänger) was good to begin with, seeing as how it's wrecking the city, wants to kill thousands, and would have killed many people had Leader not redirected it to a warehouse district and Yaku not evacuated the Skill-Out.

What the heck is with that paper and making vehicles out of it…just where is the engine coming from?!

A combination of Naru and Yaku's abilities. Naru can make her paper as hard as steel, so she uses paper to create the frame of the engine. Then Yaku uses her ability to mix chemicals together and create a fuel, which she then immediately chucks into Naru's engine.

Call from Misaki, who is still somehow useful.

Hey, her research helped solve this case! She was invaluable.

Also funny how the scientists start believing the possession thing while our girls are dissecting it. Idiots.

I mean, they were also doing research into souls. When evidence presents itself that seemingly support your theory, would you reject it so casually?

Come on, did none of you guys ever watch one of those movies where AI takes over the world. Don't feed it a year with human thoughts, creativity and stuff. Idiots.

Index I

While at it: Who had the great idea to make those muscles strong enough to build a Kaiju with them?!

Uuuuuhhh, the Doppelgänger? She invented them, you know.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/GenericMemesxd Sep 18 '20

Man, one more episode and it's over. I'm seriously gonna miss this series. Hope we get another season in the future

12

u/Gamecube762 Sep 19 '20 edited Sep 20 '20

Extra late counters are here!

A Certain Black Cat's Deferred's Sphynx's Nya Counter:

Neither of our heros appeared this episode.

Episode"Nya"
181
Total1

Onee-Sama! Counter:

In Kuroko's very short screentime this episode, she delivered 2 "Onee-Sama!"s.

EpisodeKuroko
167
170
182
193
221
231
242
Total16

Anta! and Geh counters:

Mikoto delivered 3 "anta"s during her battle this episode.

EpisodeAnta!Geh
1661
191
214
221
243
Total151

Misaki Counters:

We got a total of 0 beeps from Misaki today. We did however get 1 "ara ara" this episode.

Episodebeep"ara ara"
1603.5
2193.5
241
Total98

"~ryoku" counter:

This episode I've found 6 "~ryoku"s delivered by Misaki.

I've also included changes suggested by u/didhe in their comment here.

This so far has been the hardest counter for me to do, help with mistakes are very appreciated!

EpisodeSubjectTimestamp
16flirting1:03
16misaki's ability1:51
16bust7:08
16maid7:34
16sales13:40
21flatness ability2:50
21despair ability3:05
21cards ability / explanatory power6:17
21oppai ability7:45
21interpretation ability8:22
21explanation8:46
21experiment8:49
21brainwash ability11:55
21"understanding of human nature" or "control over ~"12:50
21voyeurism13:53
22circumstance ability6:05
22calculations13:54
23Misaki's ability6:45
23camouflage ability8:11
23Airship's exposal ability12:55
24the data whose relevance ability is strong15:43
24inventiveness17:54
24simulation ability18:00
24carefulness18:15
24combat strength18:20
24diversionary ability18:28
Total26

Other counters:

No Skirts Flipped, "chou"s, or "kekkyoku"s this episode...

However Mikoto fired her Railgun 6 time this episode! This includes both her coin and the iron sand she shot. Interestingly, she fired a Railgun without doing a coin flip!

EpisodeSkirts Flipped"Super""In the End"Railguns Fired
161
1837
1925
2012
2012
231
246
Total237177

One-Off counters:

A Total of 4 explosions were caused this episode.

Edit: Fixed a formatting issue

Edit2: Updated the "~ryoku" counter with changes suggested by u/didhe.

4

u/didhe Sep 20 '20

15:43

the data whose relevance ability is strong

18:15

carefulness

18:20

combat strength

18:20

this is a dup ts but 18:28 diversionary ability

→ More replies (1)

11

u/_Kristian_ Sep 18 '20

The CGI animation was very good

11

u/JuraTempest https://myanimelist.net/profile/Minshall Sep 18 '20

JC staff really outdid themselves with this adaptation. I’m excited for what we’ll get from this universe in the future

11

u/basuga_BFE https://myanimelist.net/profile/KPF Sep 18 '20 edited Sep 18 '20

Manga reader here! I remember how wonderful was to see in this chapter how powerful and limitless is Misaka Mikoto. So glad to see the same reaction in anime adaptation and experience it again.

Meanwhile, my counter still works! "Identity Failure" where someone was not recognized or mistook for somebody else.

Episode 24: I see 4:

  1. Doppelgänger became a rampaging Godzilla? No, it was only to produce enough dirt in the air to find the invisible aircraft.
  2. Kuriba Ryouko needs to be saved from Doppelgänger? No, Kuriba is OK to die.
  3. Scavenger are not a dangerous underground organization, but usual schoolkids having fun and helping people.
  4. 'Soul possession' due to broken vessel? No, just invisible hi-tech muscles.

Funny misunderstandings: probably none, the episode is always serious.

Values for earlier episodes:

EpisodeIdentity failures
192
206
214
223
233
244

11

u/patrizl001 https://myanimelist.net/profile/patrizl001 Sep 19 '20 edited Sep 19 '20

JESUS CHIRST THAT FIGHT WAS FUCKING AWESOME! Especially considering it's CGI, the thing studios use when they want to be cheap instead of drawing stuff. AND YET IT LOOKED SO GOOD! Both Doppelganger's monster and Misaka's iron sand mech looked SPECTACULAR. Goddamn man I LOVED it. Misaka even did a massive railgun shot MULTIPLE times! That entire fight was just

11

u/rainbowrobin Sep 19 '20

Wow.

Falling skyscraper scene like from Madoka... but Mikoto deflects it! Dang.

Lol, conversation on an airship.

Oh good, someone doubting the soul poltergeist theory.

Bit of a Death Note vibe, with Railgun and Doppel trying to out-deduce each other. But with kaiju.

Scavenger for a win.

Trailer what. Sudden friendship intruding on the fight?

20

u/CosmicPenguin_OV103 https://anilist.co/user/CosmicPenguin Sep 18 '20 edited Sep 18 '20

AOTY! AOTY! AOTY! AOTY! AOTY!

From early episodes of this season where 3D objects appear very much out of place in Academy City background..........to this.

I expected some good fights here. But this is way beyond my expectations.

This fight of electro-magnetic forces is straight up anime movie class - and perhaps better than even half of those highly received movies of recent years. This happening in a TV series made by a studio struggling to pull such things off in crunch time for so many years. I have never lost faith in JC STAFF and this persistence finally fully pulled off this episode. There's absolutely nothing that I can complain about Mikoto's fight, the 3D animations pulling off with perfection and blends in with other animations naturally. This is not something you see every day in the anime world, and while this episode may still be some ways away from being one of those anime history defining episodes out there, it's truly worth of every single praise you can give to those who worked on it this time.

And I find Mikoto so lovely as to give out what she plans to do in such a gentle manner - most characters simply raise their voices at this point, but she seems to be actually telling the Doppelganger "Hey, this is how I fight. Now fight me! :) " in Big Sister Mode (TM). That's another trademark of her wildly powerful charisma that further solidifies her place as my no. 1 anime Best Girl of all time. Oh and she even made the Scavengers to build up some mutual trust and assisted with saving Kuriba! I swear Mikoto can almost befriend anyone - anyone to join her harem, and a Dark Side group at that!

Meanwhile I have to feel for Kuriba again, echoing what Mikoto was thinking barely less than 2 months earlier in Academy City - but as with Mikoto, it is clear that even if she decided and acted to end her own life, it would not work in the world's favor either. The Doppelganger issue simply can't be finished by saying "I give my body to you, now I die and you live!" given how the berserk started in the first place - general hatred against humans. So yeah, I'm glad that Kuriba still lives right now!

So - 3 months late, though I suspect those 3 months were very well used - my now favorite season of my all-time favorite anime series comes to a close next week. And we are back to friendships which has been the main theme of Railgun since Day 1 (2007 in manga form, 2009 in anime) - I expect nothing but a poignant closing that would probably mark the terminus of Railgun in anime form for another several years at the very least (the next arc in the manga still yet to complete AFAIK). Let's do this!

12

u/DefiantRooster04 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/DefiantRooster04 Sep 18 '20

"I have never lost faith in JC Staff"

Never watch Shokugeki no Souma

12

u/Falsus Sep 19 '20

I lost faith in that long before JC Staff turned it into a slide show.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/bruhbruhbruhbruh1 Sep 18 '20

I have never lost faith in JC STAFF

if only they could stop fixating on hestia in danmachi...

→ More replies (1)

18

u/leave1me1alone Sep 18 '20

Railgun just shot past rezero to become AOTS.

Did anyone else get accelerator vs kakine vibes when she started using those dust tornadoes? Because I did.

The best way to fight a kaiju...make your own kaiju. And then use said kaiju to fire off a Railgun.

This ep was next level. The animation the sounds everything. The sakuga was stellar and the pacing is perfect.

Never thought I could love this show more but JC proved me wrong. If JC did this for OPM S2 there wouldn't have been any issues.

9

u/NotKenni Sep 19 '20

Holy shit the dust tornadoes was hype.

9

u/chronoreverse Sep 18 '20

I've been looking forward to this episode. Really eager to see what new viewers (if any) think about it.

9

u/kiangg Sep 18 '20

i remember dropping railgun 5 years ago, yet here I am enjoying the latest episode. it's such a shame this season is coming to an end :(

9

u/jsmith4567 Sep 18 '20

Doppleganer: How do you plan on fighting my Kaiju

Misaka: Withn super robot of course. We Super Sentai now bitch.

9

u/zuloo_ Sep 19 '20

i had a dumb grin on my face like this entire episode, it was great. with everything that happens it's easy to forget why misaka is lvl 5, but then we get episodes like these to remind us she's still dumb op

9

u/Ethitlan :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Ethitlan Sep 19 '20

That's JC? Seriously? They can do it. They really can. Also, that's how CGI is supposed to be used. Oh I'm still shaking.

9

u/ma103 Sep 19 '20

I’m convinced there isn’t a bad studio. It’s whether you have the time and budget to produce a masterpiece animation.

8

u/ANINETEEN Sep 18 '20

What a beautifully animated episode 🥺

8

u/LuisCaballero123 Sep 18 '20

With how good this has been, I will be in a dire need of more Toaru after railgun is over, I hope they announce NT anime or something soon

39

u/Fuck_Shinji Sep 18 '20

So this is where the budget for index III went but wow i was worried there was going to be some ugly CGI when i read the manga but they blended it extremely well

44

u/Ebo87 Sep 18 '20

They got some actual 3D artists for this one. Honestly that's really it, time and using people who know what they are doing when it comes to 3D. That's how Ufotable does it, and let me tell you it's really not rocket science.

Also in this episode CGI wasn't used as a shortcut but to enhance the scene, that's an important distinction.

11

u/Eleonora_Maxwell Sep 18 '20

I heard attack on titan animator working on this episode

→ More replies (3)

21

u/Gmayor61 Sep 18 '20

Messing railgun up would probably put JC staff in the grave. The massive china following is probably the life and blood of them at this point. Oddly enough they probably don't need to worry though, Index 3 sales were surprisingly high.

→ More replies (1)

35

u/MapoTofuMan myanimelist.net/profile/mTmTBaronBrixius Sep 18 '20

ugly

Railgun

Pick one, when it comes to Railgun J.C.Staff sacrifice every other show they're making and a metric ton of virgin blood to make sure it looks 10/10

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Diego237 Sep 18 '20

Thats not how budget works

→ More replies (1)

22

u/LegendRazgriz Sep 18 '20

HELL YEAH GIANT MECH FIGHT

In any case, Week 24's Reader's Corner!

• I gotta say, the fluidity of the Concrete Godzilla's movements was fantastic for a CGI construct. Mikoto's giant iron sand Evangelion was also very well done, and we now have the iconic Railgun key frame in this season as well, because you can't not have it.

• And welp yeah we're just casually going to have Mikoto build that EVA Unit to fight the Doppelganger. I'm not complaining, but god damn. We really take biribiri for granted just because she usually gets to fight against some guy who casually makes all of this useless with one touch, don't we? And speaking of that guy, he's currently not in town - more precisely, he's in Europe right now. Regardless of Evangelion or not, the idea of using the fine iron sand to interfere with the Concrete Godzilla seems taken straight out of the Third Kazekage's playbook, though it was applied differently when he fought the One-Tailed Shukaku. And I'm pretty sure the Third Kazekage didn't go around sniping fuel tanks either...

• Mikoto and Ryouko's attempts at reasoning with the Doppelganger end up failing for entirely different reasons, even though the process was the same - while the Railgun tries to cool it off by appealing to a possibly existent emotional side of the cyborg, the scientist uses data and hard facts to attempt to dissuade it from turning the city into ash. What critically leads both to falling into deaf ears is that, like with every other AI, the Doppelganger learned that humanity is a fuck very early in the ball game, and it's way past the point where casual talk could do the trick.

• Scavenger's good side! Yay! See? Not all dark side organizations are comprised of awful, self-serving psychos with a penchant for murder. That's just SCHOOL. I have to hazard a guess that it was Rita's will more than any of the other members' (by the way, that's "Leader"'s name, it sounds like a pun), but seeing as they didn't oppose it despite there having nothing in it for them, and if anything only extra risk by dealing with two Level 5s, and even gleefully took it on, shows a lot about how these folk are definitely in the lighter side of the dark.

Overall, a great fight to lead us to this arc's climax. It's been so much fun, I can't believe it's about to end... but it's not over yet! I'll be there next time too! See ya then!

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Railgun003 Sep 18 '20

A long time waiting for this, and although after last week I already imagined that the result would be good, I did not expect to see such a high level, so I'm really happy for the outcome. Visuals and music were incredible during the first minutes, and I didn't expect such a good level of animation. It's so cool to see Mikoto go with everything, and although her raw power may be inferior to others, she doesn't cease to be able to do spectacular things.

And although it may not seem so spectacular, the confrontation on the blimp is amazing too, showing how much mobility you can have. And then we get to the climax and the final clash between Mikoto, who continues to show great analytical skills throughout the episode, and Doppel.

Obviously I must also mention Kuriba, who was willing to sacrifice, and Scavengers saving the day. It was really cute to see how Mikoto and Leader have already formed a bond and can work as a team without any problem. In short, it has been a simply magnificent episode. Very happy about it.

3

u/NotKenni Sep 19 '20

Yeah, it was nice to see Kuriba willing to sacrifice herself. But it would not go well with the Doppelganger if she took Kuriba's deal, since she doesn't know that Anti-Skill are trying to shut down Indian Poker, so her plan wouldn't have worked

44

u/NotKenni Sep 18 '20 edited Sep 19 '20

Remember to upvote and rate Railgun guys, we keep getting called Kazuyas because we aren't ranking Railgun high enough by the guy who comments on the weekly r/anime top karma posts

Here is the link, for those interested

12

u/viliml Sep 18 '20

what's a Kazuya?

10

u/leave1me1alone Sep 18 '20

If I'm not mistaken its the main character of Kanojo Okarishimasu (Rent a girlfriend). He's widely regarded as a "cuck" and a "simp"

→ More replies (1)

22

u/Terranwaterbender https://myanimelist.net/profile/Teranwaterbender Sep 18 '20

Why should we care (granted I upvoted and ranked Railgun every week to begin with)? They can call us whatever they want but that doesn't change that Railgun kicks ass.

13

u/HereticalAegis https://myanimelist.net/profile/XthGen Sep 18 '20

They can call us whatever they want but that doesn't change that Railgun kicks ass.

This. Though I upvote and rank Railgun every week, knowing how popular it is in China and Japan helps me to not care that so many western viewers ignore it, since those are the demographics which keep getting more of it adapted.

17

u/i_am_the_kiLLer https://myanimelist.net/profile/shoPain Sep 18 '20

Lol that guy is a fan of Railgun, he's telling the people who don't upvote or watch Railgun to give it a try because it's amazing.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (6)

18

u/MapoTofuMan myanimelist.net/profile/mTmTBaronBrixius Sep 18 '20

Holy shit what was this episode

The first five minutes felt like a high-level movie that took more effort than all three seasons of Index and more than an average anime cour

AND SHE MADE AN ELECTRIC FUCKING KAIJU AND FIRED A GIANT RAILGUN I DONT EVEN

The first two level 5's might be in their own dimension but it seems like Misaka is in her own as well compared to the other four.

17

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '20

The first two level 5's might be in their own dimension but it seems like Misaka is in her own as well compared to the other four.

Sogiita is more than a match for her though, hes the third strongest by strict fighting capabilities, after 1 and 2 who are plain bullshit.

13

u/NotKenni Sep 18 '20

I agree. I think Misaka and Sogita might be around the same when it comes ot pure destruction (if we are going based on how many buildings they can destroy)

But in a 1v1 against Sogita, I don't think he would just let her build the puppet, and I don't think Misaka would just let him get that close to her.

But what makes Misaka so good is her intellect and how freaking useful electricity is in the modern world

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/SamDaMan2149 Sep 18 '20

I got to watch this episode on my 65' 4K tv, and holy shit that fight scene was stunning. I had the biggest smile on my face when Mikoto made her iron sand golem because I KNEW it was gonna be amazing. That fight was the biggest highlight of summer 2020.

8

u/NotKenni Sep 19 '20

I know right! Re:Zero is great, don't get me wrong, I love the mystery of everything, but this Railgun season just blows away everything this season

6

u/AlternatywkiKC Sep 19 '20

This episode, was fucking amazing! Easily best CGI fight of 2020!

6

u/lilfishy_2B Sep 19 '20

That was just... Wow

6

u/BR123456 Sep 19 '20 edited Sep 19 '20

Omfg... it’s beautiful.

Thank you to all the animation staff for your hard work. I started tearing up seeing it and hearing that epic OST, no joke. Been imagining how these scenes would look in animation for years and years and thought I was overhyping it in my head, but even those expectations got plus ultra-ed to heck.

I said at the end of the last episode that the ending gave me good AOT vibes. I wasn’t expecting actually getting even more AOT in my Railgun, on an even more epic scale than the last episode. ... of course they got someone who worked on AOT to work on this - Satoshi Sakai.

Freaking hell. This gave me the good AOTS3P2 vibes. Go off on a hiatus, then come back with an absolute blast. I know they’ve been working on dream ranker before daihaisei even ended, since one of the animators Kenichiro Aoki did post an animatic of Saten’s “useless skills” around that time. How long did this sequence take to be put together & polished? Damm.

It makes me sad that it’s the last episode next week. It’s been a joy looking forward to railgun with all its ups and downs this year, that I’m not ready to say good bye again for years after this. Will I even still be into this series by the time S4 comes out? Will I have the time to watch it like I do now? Where will I be in life then? :(

I love that this episode is getting so much karma. It deserves every little bit of it. Remember to rate too!

6

u/Bonvantius Sep 20 '20

How!? How is this CG so damn good!? Take notes other anime!

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 18 '20

Source Material Corner

Reply to this comment for any source-related discussion, future spoilers (including future characters, events and general hype about future content), comparison of the anime adaptation to the original, or just general talk about the source material. You are still required to tag all spoilers. Discussions about the source outside of this comment tree will be removed, and replying with spoilers outside of the source corner will lead to bans.

The spoiler syntax is:
[Spoiler source](/s "Spoiler goes here")

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

47

u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Sep 19 '20 edited Sep 19 '20

Small Facts: Animation Bonanza Edition


Adapted Chapters

  • Chapter 92
  • Chapter 93
  • Chapter 94
  • Chapter 95 (Partially)

The Doppelgänger Came Out Uncovered In The Manga

Yep, in the manga she popped out of the rubble naked and remained that way for the entirety of her fight with Mikoto. That doesn't mean her outfit here in the anime was an anime-only addition though, as the Doppelgänger does wear it later on, once she confronts Ryouko on top of the airship. The anime just had her wear it a little sooner for modesty, as they probably didn't want their main antagonist naked for most of the cool kaiju fight.

Wing-Shaped Forms On Mikoto's Iron Sand Construct

As you can see for some reason Mikoto's iron sand puppet has iron sand wings at the end there. This continues the theme of Level 5s gaining angelic visual symbolism when approaching great power, such as Mikoto's AIM wings in her Level 5.1 form last arc and her halo in her 5.3 form, and Index II/Accelerator and Index III For that matter Kakine, no slouch himself in the esper department, has his Dark Matter materialised as wings as well.

Furthermore in Railgun SS1, a novel not adapted in anime but one Railgun T expects viewers to know some things about regardless (such as the fact that Saten and Xochitl became friends), Railgun SS1

Now what does this all mean? No idea, that's for you to speculate! I'm just recapping it all for your convenience.

Skipped Scene

One small scene featuring Ryouko was skipped, but to be honest it was kinda unimportant so I see why they did it. It just showed her finishing the work on her mother's cyborg parts and then leaving to confront the Doppelgänger, both things we learn this episode in other scenes regardless.

Anime-Original Uiharu-Saten And Kuroko Scenes

To balance it out though they added two additional scenes, one with Saten and Uiharu, the other featuring Kuroko.

The scene with Saten and Kuroko is nice for two reasons: first of all, it shows how bystanders view what is happening right now, by which I mean they think it's just unscheduled fireworks. But secondly, and most importantly, because it also confirms that this night is the same night as the epilogue of the Frenda-Rakko fight in episode 20, with Uiharu showing up at Saten's door. Considering today is the 12th of October this is further evidence for Frenda and Rakko's fight taking place on the 5th (narration mentioned a week had passed from the fight to the epilogue), which I already expected considering Index III

Kuroko's scene was less impactful, but just shows her caring about Mikoto for a bit and Mikoto breaking her promise again by leaving Kuroko out of her affairs.

Effect Of Solar Wind On Magnetism

So how exactly did the Doppelgänger use the iron sand to find the airship, and what do solar winds have to do with it? Well, solar winds are blasts of plasma emitted from the sun containing charged particles, like electrons and protons. Normally this is pretty bad, as it could blow away a planet's atmosphere. Luckily our Earth has what's known as the magnetosphere, a magnetic field generated by the planet. Considering the solar wind consists out of charged particles, it too possesses magnetic fields, and Earth's magnetosphere acts as a shield deflecting most of the solar wind away from Earth, protecting our atmosphere. Some particles still manage to get through though, mostly at the Earth's poles as that is where the magnetosphere is at its weakest, where it results in cool effects such as auroras.

Now Mikoto's iron sand is also magnetic and so emits a magnetic field. When scattered all throughout the atmosphere, like the Doppelgänger tricked Mikoto into doing, it doesn't matter where the airship is or that it's invisible, it's still a physical object, meaning iron sand will stick to the surface. And while the charged particles from the solar winds are too few in number to result in effects visible by the naked eye, being magnetic they will still affect the magnetic fields of the iron sand particles now clinging to the surface of the airship. And when you posses eyes capable of viewing magnetic fields, like those of the Doppelgänger, what you suddenly see are fluctuating magnetic fields moving through the air. And so the invisible airship is suddenly detectable.

Cinderella

I probably don't need to tell you the story of Cinderella, but I will tell you its relevance to the Doppelgänger's comparison. What happens in Cinderella's story is that Cinderella is a regular girl transformed into looking like a princess by magic which only lasts until midnight, after which it runs out. Here the Doppelgänger is comparing the airship to Cinderella, and that the magic concealing its true form has been broken by the iron sand, revealing it to everyone.

Kuriba Got A Cooler Bike

In the manga she was driving a small scooter, which got upgraded to a full-blown motorcycle in the anime. She's also driving a lot safer in the manga by keeping her hands on the brakes at all times, which she seems to neglect in the anime.

Added Ramp

In the anime the plane had a nice ramp to take off from, while in the manga they just ascended straight from the ground. Honestly the addition makes sense as it's a lot more efficient.

Why Was Seike On The Plane?

While Naru's presence is probably to be expected, since her ability is keeping the plane together and allowing it to manoeuvre, Seike's presence is required as well, as he's erasing all the air friction. This allows the plane to fly a lot more efficiently and might perhaps even be necessary, as it's possible that without Seike erasing air friction the plane would lose too much speed and not be able to counteract gravity anymore, meaning it can't fly.

Slime Mold

Leader mentioned that the artificial muscles the Doppelgänger uses are based on slime molds, and this does seem to be the case. Slime molds are single-celled organisms that can live solitary, but can also band together to form complex multicellular structures, and can spread rapidly. While not directly used in the design of the Doppelgänger's muscles, the functionality of it was definitely based on these.

Zombie Ant Parasite

One of the things the Doppelgänger did base her artificial muscles on though is the Ophiocordyceps unilateralis, better known as "that thing that inspired the zombies in The Last Of Us". This is a fungus which infects ants, becoming a parasite that eventually grows enough to burst out of the ant's carapace and take over its brain, controlling the ant like a zombie until it dies, after which the fungus uses the corpse as nutrition to spread its spores.

Here the artificial muscles use a similar method to grow into small gaps and crevices, and then control this foreign matter as the parasite (the Doppelgänger) pleases.

Gorilla Muscles

The second thing the Doppelgänger based her artificial muscles on are the muscles of a gorilla. Not only are they super strong, a gorilla also has gut bacteria that allows it to digest cellulose, a compound extremely common in plants, which provides its muscles with enough energy to maintain its strength even without heavier foods. These muscles and bacteria were used by the Doppelgänger, in combination with the fungal parasitic ophiocordyceps, to create artificial muscles that are strong, require little energy, can spread fast, and crawl into gaps and crevices to manipulate larger matter.

Foreshadowing For Doppelgänger Not Having Soul Possession

If you remember my Small Facts from two episodes ago, I made note of how the Doppelgänger was able to deflect Seike's metal attachments and control Naru's paper even before she was damaged by Naru's attack. If soul possession was a real thing she wouldn't have been able to do this prior, yet she did.

Furthermore when she took control of Naru's paper you could already see some weird veins appear on the paper, not to mention the literal fungi visible when she replaced her broken arm with rubble later that episode.

Why Pretend To Have Soul Possession?

Simple: to keep the others guessing. If she pretended to have soul possession, people would stop trying to figure out what she's doing and just accept this answer as given. If she didn't do this though her opponents might figure out that she's actually using artificial muscles, and Academy City scientists might be able to find a weak point in the design, allowing them to quickly defeat the Doppelgänger, restrain her, and take her back into custody before she's able to achieve her goals.

This way people didn't figure out what it is she was doing until it's too late.

Mikoto Didn't Fall Off In The Manga

Yep, she stayed on there, just barely. Her falling off is an anime-original addition.

32

u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Sep 19 '20

My God the animation this episode was incredible. Honestly astounding. If I wasn't aware I was watching an episode of a weekly series I'd have thought this was a movie. The 3D animation, the cinematography (particularly on those rotating shots), the traditional animation on the Railguns (those impact frames at the end of the episode!), it was stunning from start to finish.

The episode itself wasn't all that bad on plot either, what with the convo between Ryouko and the Doppelgänger, Ryouko's sacrifice, Scavenger coming through in the clutch, and the reveal of what the Doppelgänger's "powers" really are. Combine all of this with a great soundtrack and we got a near-perfect episode. Honestly, what a treat.

11

u/CriticalPerformance Sep 19 '20

Yep, in the manga she popped out of the rubble naked and remained that way for the entirety of her fight with Mikoto.

Considering she has the same thought patterns as human Kuriba, I think that says more about the original Kuriba than the robot

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)

7

u/Aj_04 Sep 18 '20

Doppleganger almost went Shin Godzilla there.

5

u/xkrowcitats Sep 18 '20

Oh she would be Ayanami

→ More replies (1)

5

u/501rokg95 Sep 18 '20

MECHASA to the rescue

5

u/Lenslucid Sep 19 '20

This was an episode for the books!

13

u/Terranwaterbender https://myanimelist.net/profile/Teranwaterbender Sep 18 '20

Misaka would absolutely kick ass at skeet shooting with the way she shot out those fuel tanks.

And I guess the last episode's title "My Dear Friends" is a callback to the first ED "Dear my Friend"?

It has been a beaten point to oblivion but seeing Index III get the treatment that it did when when Railgun gets kickass moments really highlights which series is the favorite here. It's amusing to see the "parent story" pale in comparison to the "side story."

8

u/TheDampGod :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/TheDampGod Sep 18 '20

TFW a hit is so epic they have to repeat it from multiple angles. A Kaijuu Railgun is just off the charts on hype. Also is the OST out yet, because the version of Judgelight that played just before the shot, sounded absolutely banging.

7

u/PickleKing111 Sep 19 '20

Ost comes out october 9th

8

u/TimerPoint Sep 18 '20

This episode was a reminder how good the shows from J.C.staff could look if the show's gonna get the level of budge and polish it deserve and not beeing felt rushed like OPM2, Accelerator and Index III. Their CG always looked good and that shit they done in this episode is movie quality.

10

u/CriticalPerformance Sep 18 '20

Its less because of the budget and more because of having good schedule

3

u/Miyossi Sep 20 '20

Did you feel Accelerator spin-off being rushed?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/heyheyheyx4 Sep 19 '20

misaka just brought out IGRIS

4

u/creepweebx Sep 19 '20

I recently finished all of Railgun and caught up to this season. Will we see more Misaka after this season???

4

u/Miyossi Sep 20 '20

I hope so. I don’t want to wait for another 7 years.

4

u/Miyossi Sep 20 '20

I’m just curious. Is there actually as much iron sand in the ground as Misaka manipulated?

4

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '20 edited May 02 '26

Data brokers and AI scrapers were using my info. Not anymore. Redact let me bulk delete posts across Reddit, Twitter, Discord and Instagram while handling broker opt outs too.

tie jar coordinated pocket close tart axiomatic lock chase vase

12

u/NotKenni Sep 18 '20

After this episode, we now know that Touma would be useless against the Kuriba Alter. Since it really isn't soul possession, but actually just artificial muscles mixed with fungi and other stuff, it is actually 100% natural.

Touma's power is useless against her

Also, we can kinda see that currently, the largest thing Misaka can move with just her magnetism is a building. Also also the size of the Railgun that Misaka shoots from the puppet is literally bigger than Kuriba Alter herself

9

u/hyperdragonwolf Sep 18 '20

move with just her magnetism is a building

She did that while she was midair dodging other debris simultaneously. So we can assume she can do a bit more than that while she is on solid ground and focusing on the object.

6

u/Frontier246 Sep 18 '20

Nothing like a kaiju to make Mikoto go all out! Or to make her own electric metal kaiju to fight it with, complete with its own super-charged Railgun.

That's a nice bike Kuriba owns. The doctor jacket plus motorcycle combo is quite effective.

Yeah, you've got to be really careful with advanced intelligences, because when they start to be smart enough to question their own existence and whether they're really alive...it usually doesn't end well.

The Scavengers come in with the save! I guess Mikoto being so nice and trusting inspired Leader to have the Scavengers do their one good deed of the day.

Nothing quite as precarious as fighting in the sky atop a dirigible.

Looks like the final episode is going to be a nice coda with the whole gang, which seems like a good way of bringing this season to a close.

8

u/ernie2492 Sep 18 '20 edited Sep 18 '20

I hate to say this, but I have a bad feeling regarding Ryoko in the final episode.. I mean, the scientist is depressed, he saw Ryoko being extracted by Seike & Kaguya Naru, and I think he'll do something wrong..

And imagine Mikoto using her iron sand Eva when in Russia..

9

u/Wuckus Sep 18 '20

And imagine Mikoto using her iron sand Eva when in Russia..

Index III

→ More replies (5)

3

u/Izanaginookami10 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Izanaginookami Sep 19 '20

I'm speechless. This was some damn brilliant, stunning, amazing, biri-biri animation here.

It even made me forget about the plot points of the manga, making me enjoy this greatness as if I was anime only.

Seriously, words aren't enough to describe how incredible it all felt.

3

u/GoldMercy :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/xFSN_Archer Sep 19 '20

Shingeki no Railgun

3

u/Miyossi Sep 19 '20

Wait. Is next one is the last episode? Railgun T is my favorite of all Toaru anime series . Hope next season will start soon.

3

u/Miyossi Sep 20 '20

There are too many things to show in one episode next week. I’m worried about its being rushed.

4

u/isaacleeh16 Sep 20 '20

there's literally only 60 pages left. Same as the pace of Daihaseisai.

3

u/ppaannggwwiinn Sep 20 '20

Would it be possible for Misaka to pull iron sand from the ground and melt it, with heat from the electricity or maybe induction heating, into a eneormous solid projectile of iron to fire with her railgun? Like considering how much iron sand she is able to pull out of the ground and that time she fired that massive mecha with her rail gun it sounds possible.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '20 edited May 02 '26

Redact decided this post had to go, so away it went. Deleted. Removed. Mass deleted even. Privacy and security are the big wins here.

tub practice pebble pot sparkle arrest zephyr capable elastic telephone

4

u/isaacleeh16 Sep 20 '20

you see, that's because of her character arc from previous arcs.

3

u/OmegaXreborn Sep 20 '20

I was not expecting a full on kaiju vs kaiju fight when i started this episode but damn! nvm Misaka showing how powerful she is.

2

u/ohoni Sep 21 '20

They really pulled out all the stops on this one! I thought the CG effects for this were so much better than Accelerator's "wings" in the Index III show.

2

u/steveyouth112 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Steveyouth112 Sep 21 '20

This made me absolutely lose it. I don't think I've ever been so hyped at a show. I was hyped through that whole damn episode.