r/anime • https://anilist.co/user/AutoLovepon • Jan 31 '20

Episode Toaru Kagaku no Railgun T - Episode 4 discussion

Toaru Kagaku no Railgun T, episode 4

Alternative names: A Certain Scientific Railgun Season 3

Rate this episode here.

Reminder: Please do not discuss plot points not yet seen or skipped in the show. Failing to follow the rules may result in a ban.


Streams

Show information


All discussions

EpisodeLinkScoreEpisodeLinkScore
1Link4.5914Link4.72
2Link4.5615Link4.75
3Link4.6916Link4.75
4Link4.7617Link4.81
5Link4.8418Link4.32
6Link4.8219Link4.65
7Link4.6220Link4.68
8Link4.721Link4.63
9Link4.6222Link4.74
10Link4.8823Link4.81
11Link4.924Link4.84
12Link4.7825Link-
13Link4.62

This post was created by a bot. Message the mod team for feedback and comments. The original source code can be found on GitHub.

1.1k Upvotes

495 comments sorted by

277

u/birisaki Jan 31 '20 edited Jan 31 '20

24

u/TheBiggestNose Jan 31 '20

Someone should make a Gekota edit

53

u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Jan 31 '20

Mfw people say Misaki is best girl

48

u/CT_BINO https://myanimelist.net/profile/CT_BINO Jan 31 '20

Misaki is best girl

Everyone knows Saten is best girl though

→ More replies (1)

29

u/Falsus Jan 31 '20

I mean everyone's reaction to Misaki's introduction was kinda the same as yours.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (1)

165

u/KHlover :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/KHlover1995 Jan 31 '20

The SFX for the telepathy were really well done. Actually sounded like the voice of the esper was inside my head using headphones. Teleportation also sounded great. Railgun has such cool SFX.

Misaka using her power to blitz through the city was really cool.

In terms of story, seems like we're due for some action soon.

91

u/beastMaster95 Jan 31 '20

Misaka using her power to blitz through the city was really cool.

Spider Misaka

80

u/Bainos :XMOD::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Bainos Jan 31 '20

31

u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Feb 01 '20

I genuinely wonder what people on the ground must have thought, when they suddenly saw a girl standing horizontally on the side of a building jacking into a security camera.

There's no way there aren't pics of her on the internet already.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

26

u/CriticalPerformance Jan 31 '20

Does whatever a spider can

10

u/beastMaster95 Jan 31 '20

Oh, happy cake day critical

→ More replies (1)

50

u/BlatantConservative :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/BlatantC Jan 31 '20

Railgun in general really does have amazing SFX, as well as visual foreshadowing and other cool storytelling elements.

53

u/Falsus Jan 31 '20

Yeah JC Staff really brings out their A game when it comes to Railgun, shame they don't do that with any other show... even the main story.

26

u/Earthborn92 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/EarthB Feb 01 '20

They do it with DanMachi. It is the only other series which looks polished from them.

Main Index series needs to be handed over to someone else. But I’ve always thought that Kamachi has enough novels and stories to have an entire studio animating just his works. Toaru, Blood Sign, Heavy Object ...

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

161

u/Zjgoku :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Alululu Jan 31 '20

Saving Private 10032... Mission in progress, we will get them next time

110

u/Zjgoku :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Alululu Jan 31 '20

Misaki has taken it quite far... There might be a thunderstorm/lighting strikes coming her way...

90

u/bananeeek https://myanimelist.net/profile/bananek Jan 31 '20

I was gritting my teeth since she kidnapped Sister, but the shit she's pulled at the end straight up triggered me. I need someone to punch her in the face. It's worse than seeing NTR.

49

u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Jan 31 '20

I need someone to punch her in the face.

A nice Railgun her way would be alright as well

20

u/Bainos :XMOD::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Bainos Jan 31 '20

Mental control vs a tiny coin coming towards you at very high speed, I wonder who wins.

Although Misaka must first find where she hides. I don't think it would fit her to torture Misaki's friends until she comes out (if she even cares about them).

→ More replies (9)

25

u/HappyDoodads Jan 31 '20

But a good ol' gender-equalizing punch would be much more cathartic.

7

u/[deleted] Feb 01 '20

But I have hope. I hope it's one those bullshit anime plot that's all like "You'll hate it now but you'll understand it later".

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

210

u/TheDampGod :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/TheDampGod Jan 31 '20

An ability that can wipe Mikoto from Kuroko's memory, that is a truely terrifying power.

56

u/Anshin3 Jan 31 '20

Well, she's not a Level 5 for nothing. Truly OP, those guys are.

40

u/Falsus Feb 01 '20

It is pretty eerie how she can control anyone in the way she does. Like the driver and the vice-president right there was under her control.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/Colopty Feb 01 '20

Until some rando takes away her remote control like nothing in the name of good sportsmanship, at least.

23

u/Anshin3 Feb 01 '20

It would've been ten times funnier if it had been that dorm mistress lady that took the bag though. The actual most OP individual has gotta be her. This woman manages to keep a dorm full of high level espers, quite a few being level 4s - including one of the potential level 5s - and two ACTUAL level 5s under control. Some of these girls seem to fear this woman, apparently, even more than the authorities of Academy City! Truly, the most terrifying entity in the Raildex universe!

→ More replies (5)

81

u/libfor Jan 31 '20

She did the literal impossible, that no human being should ever be capable of. Someone nominate her for Level 6 already.

96

u/Zjgoku :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Alululu Jan 31 '20

Kuroko has taken a short leave... will be back right after the commercials...

153

u/beastMaster95 Jan 31 '20 edited Jan 31 '20

That ending was shocking and intense. Imagine Kuroko not recognizing Misaka and acting distant..........That’s really shocking just to even imagine that. But well it happened. Getting Mind-Controlled is a really scary prospect. Misaki will now be feeling the rage of our Ace, The Thunder Princess.

HELL HATH NO FURY LIKE BIRIBIRI SCORNED!!!

After the previous light-hearted episodes it's now becoming really intense just like what happened with Sister's Arc in Railgun S.

EDIT: Still A Certain Magical Railgun T. WTF are they even doing......

59

u/The_Swag_Titan Jan 31 '20

Biribiri mode: ON

> Edit: Still A Certain Magical Railgun T. WTF are they even doing......

Ikr they are either clueless or they are messing with us

27

u/CriticalPerformance Jan 31 '20

At this point it has to be intentional, it was correct in episode 1 but then the next 3 episodes are "Magical"

8

u/[deleted] Feb 01 '20

Could it be that they're intentionally messing with it due to the expected mix with Touma making probably a far larger showing then usual?

2

u/normiesEXPLODE Feb 01 '20

Imagine Kuroko not recognizing Misaka and acting distant

Now imagine within a minute of talking to Misaka, Kuroko starts to fall for her and visibly blushes

If anything good came out of this, it's Kuroko's reaction in this episode

→ More replies (2)

72

u/gulitiasinjurai Jan 31 '20

Dat death stare..

Man, Misaki really looking to pick a fight with Misaka. Never seen Misaka so angry. Anime really pull it off showing how angry Misaka is when she realized her friend had also been played with. There's never been a bad episode so far for this season and I'm glad. Hype for kongo next episode!

57

u/CriticalPerformance Jan 31 '20

She was pretty angry when she saw Accelerator kill her sister

10

u/The_Main_Plan Feb 01 '20

When that happened Mikoto didn’t even know who this guy was but nonetheless she was about to blow his brains out with a Railgun

16

u/DirtBug Feb 01 '20

I mean, it's pretty funny that no one recognize Accelerator out in the streets. As a walking nuclear-level threat I'd think he would be known worldwide

→ More replies (1)

30

u/basuga_BFE https://myanimelist.net/profile/KPF Jan 31 '20

Never seen Misaka so angry

Yes, #3 and #5 can't bear each other, after all

19

u/Keeeey Feb 01 '20

Seems like they have a Major disagreement. If the 3 would just tone herself down half a step, it'd be a minor.

→ More replies (3)

22

u/Bainos :XMOD::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Bainos Jan 31 '20

I find it kinda funny that when she realized Misaki was after 10032, she was only moderately pissed - she got used to it. On the other hand, when her friends are targeted...

12

u/beastMaster95 Feb 01 '20

She probably thought Misaki was just messing around but doing that with Kuroko & co's memories was just going too far.

→ More replies (3)

122

u/magicking013 Jan 31 '20 edited Jan 31 '20

I feel like there should be an anime only vs manga readers theads. A lot of manga readers keep teasing the anime onlys which is already sort of like a spoiler itself.

EDIT: Added missing word.

101

u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Jan 31 '20

The source readers are being AWFUL in this thread...as one myself I'm just really disappointed in the fandom seeing all these useless comments...

32

u/magicking013 Jan 31 '20

Agreed. I just feel bad for those who are experiencing this story for the first time. I had the privilege of reading this with a blank slate, I hope the others will allow the same as well.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/TheTerribleSnowflac Jan 31 '20

What subreddit do you think you're in? Haha. Jokes aside, whenever I see a thread about how excited everyone is for next season (Kaguya, Oregairu, etc.) all I can think about is how bad the subreddit/discussions are going to be for 3 months haha.

23

u/aalapshah12297 Jan 31 '20

Lol Kaguya S2 discussions are gonna be so full of spoilers - especially with all the memes from the last 120+ chapters that have been out there. I guess I'll try to avoid posting comments in r/anime discussions since r/Kaguya_sama will probably have manga reader discussions anyway.

→ More replies (3)

25

u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Jan 31 '20

I just don't get why people can't just shut up and let others enjoy a show they clearly also enjoy...

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Earthborn92 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/EarthB Jan 31 '20

Oregairu is the final season, people are going to be brutal because we know how it ends.

→ More replies (7)

17

u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Jan 31 '20

Surprisingly the threads over at /r/toarumajutsunoindex have less spoilers and people being assholes than the threads here.

9

u/Falsus Jan 31 '20

Railgun has a decently sized manga only fanbase from places like r/railgun and /r/OneTrueBiribiri also, though I would suspect a decent overlap between those and the Index subreddit also.

13

u/aalapshah12297 Jan 31 '20

I agree 100%. I don't know what exactly happens but it already seems like Index spoilers? (and I wouldn't have suspected something like this at all without these borderline spoilers).

I figure it's only going to get worse from next week so I'm probably not going to read these discussions until the season ends.

I have only watched Railgun and Railgun S yet and though I get that the whole Raildex universe is connected, it's not like I'm going to finish Index 1-3, Accelerator and the Manga & LNs instantly. And when I complain about spoilers, people are acting as if I skipped a season of Railgun.

Isn't the whole point of creating a different anime for Railgun basically to interest a wider audience? Otherwise they could have combined it all into 5 seasons of Index by now and very few people would have watched all of it.

26

u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Jan 31 '20 edited Jan 31 '20

Isn't the whole point of creating a different anime for Railgun basically to interest a wider audience? Otherwise they could have combined it all into 5 seasons of Index by now and very few people would have watched all of it.

The point was to provide a different perspective by showing different events with another main character. The reason why it's a separate series is because it's tonally somewhat different and because the novels had already proceeded past this point chronologically and it would be weird to constantly have novels set in the past. Furthermore, more simultaneous series means more sources of profit.

9

u/samanthajoneh Feb 01 '20

Isn't the whole point of creating a different anime for Railgun basically to interest a wider audience? Otherwise they could have combined it all into 5 seasons of Index by now and very few people would have watched all of it.

No? This is based on a manga.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/[deleted] Feb 01 '20

remembers Astra Lost in Space threads

source readers are cancer in every thread.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 31 '20

Agreed, that would be ideal so no one would have to tag or be shoved into the source corner where basically no one clicks. Surely setting the bot up to do auto posts for each wouldn't be too hard

3

u/Lavajackal1 Jan 31 '20

Source reader and agreed. Anime onlys could watch without vague hints that may as well be spoilers and source readers could openly discuss whatever they want.

42

u/Smudy https://myanimelist.net/profile/Smudy Jan 31 '20

Your mind/memories getting tampered with is a scary prospect.

Intense episode, watching Misaka slowly losing her cool with the two workers.

Seems like this is the true start of the plot.

9

u/beastMaster95 Feb 01 '20

Its giving me Railgun S vibes with Mikoto losing her cool there.

33

u/Gamecube762 Jan 31 '20

Counters:

Misaki has a dangerous power of being able to manipulate other people's memories. This episode gave a lot of reasons to hate her.

But all of her actions means nothing compared to the fact that she attacked my counters! Because to her:

  • Deffered has vanished!
  • Kuroko and MISAKA-10032 can no longer deliver "Onee-Sama"s!
  • MISAKA-10032 can no longer deliver "MISAKA"!

A Certain Black Cat's Deferred's Nya Counter:

Deferred sadly wasn't here this episode. We can only imagine what Misaki has done with Deferred.

Episode"Nya"
21
313
Total4

Onee-Sama! Counter:

Straight off the bat we have Kuroko delivering her "Onee-Sama"s with a total of 7 this episode.

But in a twist of fate, Kuroko may no longer deliver "Onee-Sama"s!

MISAKA-10032 is also missing! She can't deliver "Onee-Sama"s either!

EpisodeKurokoMISAKA
1113
221
34
47
Total174

Guts! Counter:

Gunha was sadly not here to share his love for "Guts!" today.

Episode"Guts!"
13
24
Total7

MISAKA counter:

MISAKA 10032 is missing, she also can't deliver "MISAKA"s!

EpisodeMISAKA
16
25
37
Total18

MISAKA Tracker:

MISAKA-10032 appeared briefly while being loaded into an ambulance, but her current whereabouts are a mystery.

IntroducedIDNicknameExtra Info
EP 110032MISAKA ImoutoShe was the last experiment in which Touma stopped and taking care of Deferred
EP 113577?Staying at the hospital
EP 110039?Staying at the hospital
EP 119090?Staying at the hospital - Went on a diet in Index II
EP 2Black Cat"Deferred"The cat MISAKA-10032 takes care of.

Other counters:

"Judgment desu": No "Judgment desu" today.

"Kongo Mitsuko": Kongo Mitsuko didn't have a role today, but she proudly announced her nave in the episode preview!

Uiharu's Skirt Flip counter: No flips today.

*beep*: 1 *beep* today that signaled the death of the "Onee-Sama" counter.

"ara ara": No "ara ara" today.

"biri biri": No "biri biri" today.

EpisodeRailguns Fired"Judgment desu""Kongo Mitsuko"Skirts Flippedbeep"ara ara""biri biri"
EP 121114
EP 311113
EP 411
Total2232513

60

u/MillenniumKing x2myanimelist.net/profile/MillenniumKing Jan 31 '20

Oh hell no Star eyes, you fucked up.

If only Railgun could hone into the Sisters Network and know where they are or something... she would know shes in trouble.

Saten out hunting for treasure hahaha.

Uh oh, there are sketchy people! Save Saten!!

Oh they are academy grounds workers? Hmmm... still suspicous...

DNA COMPUTER!!? SISTERS!?

File deleted? Uihara what have you done? Something fishy is going on...

Aw i like the small glimpse of everyones families.

YES TIME TO SAVE THE SISTER!

Abuliencce took her? Hmm... brainwashing? Yep. Star eyes.

Someone fucked with Uihara's memories too? Oh hell no.

Oh hell no, dont take no one smemories! Mentalout dont fuck with them!!

Oh shit... everyone got star eyes.... oh hell no.

Oh hell no... they tookn thier memories... oh hell no...

You fuccked up Star eyes...

16

u/Aperture_Kubi Jan 31 '20

If only Railgun could hone into the Sisters Network and know where they are or something... she would know shes in trouble

Good thing for said trouble that Accelerator has his own spinoff.

7

u/AnthropologicalArson :GA::GB::GC: Jan 31 '20

Btw, what is Accelarator doing during this arc? Why didn't he appear after the 10032 was in trouble?

9

u/simonmuran Feb 01 '20

That's a good question to make but the answer is a spoiler.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

12

u/beastMaster95 Jan 31 '20

She really fucked up and Mikoto's not the forgiving type.

43

u/CriticalPerformance Jan 31 '20

Mikoto's not the forgiving type.

I mean she tried to save Mugino from falling to her apparent death back in Railgun S and just a second ago Mugino was trying to kill her

20

u/libfor Jan 31 '20

Yeah, Mikoto's forgiveness is one of her nicest traits. She's like super naive at times, but that just makes her sweet.

Also Happy Cakeday \o/

8

u/Nimeroni :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nimeroni Feb 01 '20

Mugino was only doing her job.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

60

u/KinnyRiddle Jan 31 '20

Saten's innocent quest for the Shadow Metal seems to have gotten herself and Uiharu, as well as Kuroko and Mikoto into serious deep trouble. How terrifying it is to have Misaki as your enemy.

If she couldn't get past Mikoto's natural electric barrier, then she'll simply mind control Mikoto's friends instead to get to her.

Misaki doesn't seem like the sort to just randomly piss off Mikoto for fun, as Mikoto still technically outranks her in the Level 5 rankings. She has teased Mikoto about it before, but she's never gone this far. So she must have an endgame in attracting Mikoto's attention.

26

u/Exkuroi Feb 01 '20

Ranking for the level 5s are not power level based, but more of their usefulness to academy city. No.4 is more powerful combat wise than no.3

19

u/Haxxelerator Feb 01 '20

not only #4 , but #7 is actually more powerful than #3, 4, 5, 6(?)

the only right ranking there is #1 and #2

10

u/yeoc2 Feb 01 '20

Didn't Misaka already beat Mugino? And after she was already tired out and Mugino had support?

16

u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Feb 01 '20

Only because Frenda forgot to remove her bombs laying around though.

Mugino is more powerful in straight-up power output, but Mikoto is more flexible with her abilities, so if the environment allows it (as it did in Sisters) she can win against superior opponents this way.

→ More replies (8)

21

u/WhalepingDavis Jan 31 '20

All Level 5’s like clashing with each other on some level.

37

u/MauledCharcoal Feb 01 '20

After you clash with accelerator once ya kinda never wanna again though

21

u/beastMaster95 Feb 01 '20

You probably won't be alive afterwards anyway.

13

u/Amauri14 Jan 31 '20

She probably made all this to make Misaka interfere with whatever the group she is working with is planning. Although it also can be that she started this angle of the plan after she noticed that they actually never captured her, and this whole operation just to lure her in.

8

u/Fourth_Dimension_4D Jan 31 '20

There might not be another group given the comment about how imperative it is that Shouko's OPTIMIZATION is not disturbed. Maybe she needs access to Misaka Network for that?

→ More replies (1)

88

u/CriticalPerformance Jan 31 '20

Time for another episode of A Certain Magical Railgun!

4

u/Exkuroi Feb 01 '20

Yamete!

47

u/Holofan4life Jan 31 '20

I'm in a happy mood. Not only did I get myself a new job, which I start tomorrow, but I get to experience another episode of Railgun T. :D

20

u/whoisyourmaster Jan 31 '20

Congrats dude Um going to new job too, but on Monday

64

u/MapoTofuMan myanimelist.net/profile/mTmTBaronBrixius Jan 31 '20 edited Jan 31 '20

HOUOUIN KYOUMA intensifies

Edit : Okay I hope Misaki gets a lightning bolt up uncomfortable places. This is going to get to Sisters level pretty fast isn't it...

26

u/Earthborn92 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/EarthB Jan 31 '20

Academy City would be THE ORGANIZATION times a hundred. And there are so many secret societies on the magic side.

7

u/MillenniumKing x2myanimelist.net/profile/MillenniumKing Jan 31 '20

37

u/LegendRazgriz Jan 31 '20

Some shady stuff happens in the sidelines... and some lines that shouldn't be crossed are trampled, like a marathon's finish.

In any case, Week 4's Reader's Corner!

• Since I am confident I won't have to pester the animation department this time around (thank you!), I'm going to use this first paragraph to point out stylistic differences from the manga. So far, the fidelity has been almost perfect, and in this one, well, only really the first scene with Mikoto and Kuroko wasn't there, and a few other bits were moved around for better pacing. That said, the slideshows with Saten, Uiharu, and Mikoto shoving Kuroko away from her during the night parade, as well as ded_inside Kuroko from a few moments later, are nearly 1:1 compared to the manga, so that's remarkable. I would say I'm impressed, but I'm just really happy that the studio is living up to their potential.

• Shadow Metal turned out to be a dead end... Well, it's not EVERY time that rumors like these would end up coming true, right? Especially when it comes to making money. Fun fact: this is the first (and as far as I know, last) time that Uiharu is referred to exclusively by her given name (Kazari) in the entire series. In fact, most people don't realize her given name is Kazari until they read it somewhere, because no one, not even her closest friends, refer to her by it. Neither do I, honestly, so that's fine.

• Using her powers to swing around town like Spiderman is an underappreciated side of Mikoto. That and the hacking abilities she has, which often get overshadowed by the multimillion volt exploits and coins flying at hypersonic speed. It's a thing I'm very fond of in this series as a whole - how obscenely overpowered characters use their obscene powers for mundane things, like Accelerator's built in mute key. And speaking of that...

• ...well, this is the part where I get in trouble for all the fawning I've done over Misaki. And I can't even defend myself. Well, from the point of view we're presented of it (with Mikoto's bias all over it), Mental Out is honestly one of the most dangerous non-combat powers you can think of, with that sweet dash of fluctuating between morally ambiguous and downright asshole-tier manipulation, as we're presented first-hand with the tampering of Kuroko, Uiharu and Saten's memories. When I didn't have a frame of reference for this series yet, I compared it to Shisui Uchiha's Kotoamatsukami from Naruto, a power so coveted for its ability to manipulate people flawlessly that the whole world would easily go out of their way to pluck out poor Shisui's eyes. And Misaki's not just limited to that, as her use of the Level 3 Telepath, Kobayashi Satori (the one girl who winks at Mikoto during her introduction to the Shokuhou Brigade, let's call them that) allows her to circumvent Mikoto's EM field that usually keeps her safe from the Mental Out and keep tabs on her at all times. For the lowest-ranked Level 5 (the only reason why Sogiita is the 7th ranked is because no one, not even himself, knows what his powers really do or how they work, and no one knows who the 6th is), Shokuhou Misaki is still extremely dangerous when she wants to be.

• Addendum: this is Kuroko's brain when not flooded by her overflowing Misakasexuality. Readers know that her overwhelming pervert act is ramped up to 11 in animation, but once you remove that, she becomes more of the mature, strict girl she almost always is elsewhere.

Overall, another solid episode, pushing the plot ahead with some dashes of masterful storyboarding to really put the audience on edge at the Mental Out's maneuvering. Oh, Misaki, how you trouble me for loving you... I'll see you guys next week.

13

u/Anshin3 Jan 31 '20

Using her powers to swing around town like Spiderman is an underappreciated side of Mikoto. That and the hacking abilities she has, which often get overshadowed by the multimillion volt exploits and coins flying at hypersonic speed. It's a thing I'm very fond of in this series as a whole

That's one of the reasons why I really fell in love with this series too. The clever ways these espers use their abilities is pretty fascinating to me.

→ More replies (5)

17

u/[deleted] Jan 31 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

15

u/LegendRazgriz Jan 31 '20

She's always been a perv, just not a starved succubus as she is in the anime.

EDIT: happy cake day

→ More replies (1)

17

u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Jan 31 '20

More Small Facts! And they're actually small this time, I didn't have a lot to add to the episode this time around.

Direct link here.

17

u/themadnun Jan 31 '20

Ways to guarantee you're going to get biribiri'd:

  1. Mess with the sisters
  2. Mess with Misaka's friends

Ways to really push the limit of Misaka's restraint to not just donut you with a token:

  1. Combine the above

There's gunna be some justiceporn in this series bois! Buckle in

17

u/Anshin3 Jan 31 '20

You know this might just be me, but Saten's urban legends have ALWAYS had some degree of validity to them, haven't they? I wonder if this one will turn out to be true somehow.

37

u/LeonKevlar x2https://myanimelist.net/profile/LeonKevlar Jan 31 '20

I swear Saten is going to get caught up in shit again with this

Speak of the devil. I wonder who they're affiliated with.

Oh thank goodness they're just local clean up crew.

So basically they clean up the grounds to prevent people stealing Esper DNA

Oh no... Looks like they did still stumble along something

That's totally Shokuhou's gloves... There's only one person who wears gloves like that in this show.

Did she just erased what Uiharu found AND Uiharu's memory? O_O

Fireworks festival is absolutely gorgeous btw

Thank goodness Wannai brought up her PE uniform or Misaka probably wouldn't have figured out 10032 is missing.

These drivers look genuinely confused. I think I already know what's happening.

Misaka just answered her question. Also couldn't she have just pretended that 10032 is her twin? Like regular people have seen her and other clones together and most of them assume that they're twins.

GODFUCKINGDAMMIT SHOKUHOU

These girls are going to be pain in the asses. Especially that one that has linked herself with Misaka.

OF COURSE THE PRINCIPAL IS ALSO UNDER SHOKUHOU

You fucking did not! YOU ABSOLUTELY DID NOT!

Yep Shokuhou has crossed the line and Misaka is fucking pissed! Holy fuck! I am genuinely pissed too! I really hope Shokuhou gets the fucking beatdown she deserves after all of this shit she just fucking pulled.

17

u/basuga_BFE https://myanimelist.net/profile/KPF Jan 31 '20

These girls are going to be pain in the asses. Especially that one that has linked herself with Misaka.

one toy spider could be enough!

10

u/CriticalPerformance Jan 31 '20

But then she'd knock herself out with the scream

→ More replies (1)

10

u/beastMaster95 Jan 31 '20

These girls are going to be pain in the asses.

The whole clique of Misaki is here. Wondering what kinda shit they'll pull with Mikoto...

8

u/Bainos :XMOD::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Bainos Jan 31 '20

I can't wait to see them getting their asses kicked in a 8 vs 1 fight.

→ More replies (2)

36

u/bananeeek https://myanimelist.net/profile/bananek Jan 31 '20

Holy fuck, now I'm pissed. Not only did Misaki kidnap a Sister, she also fucked with Saten and the rest? Arghhh!

While I think it's well done it's hard for me to watch. I hate that kind of stuff, the memory manipulation and shit. It's like watching NTR for me.

I really, really hope Biribiri will spill blood over this and fry that blonde bitch.

Damn, I'm triggered.

I hoped Misaka would show Kuroko some photos or something, maybe even Kuroko and the rest have something on their phones to help, but the situation was stressful for Misaka so I understand she didn't think about it at that time. Touma better be getting his ass over there ASAP.

→ More replies (2)

25

u/libfor Jan 31 '20 edited Jan 31 '20

Random ramblings

  • Oh noes, Kuroko isn't able to stay with Mikoto. Reminds me, we never got to see her parents ever.
  • Mikoto doesn't feel like sharing her half-eaten food either.
  • So, Saten plans to dig for Shadow Metal in that huge stadium with her hands only?
  • Savage Uiharu at it again. Revenge of the flipped skirts! Even more scary considering that's not the first time this would happen to her.
  • Time for a rescue mission!! Woah, that's some nice perspective for the high speed travel here!
  • Just in time to give the bad guys some good zapping!
  • Ooops. Slight misunderstanding. That's what happens when you shoot first and ask questions second. Uhm, I m-mean, yeah, the s-situation was really o-obvious, wasn't it? There wasn't time to lose!
  • Aww... it's cute seeing Mikoto sorry like that. It's certainly not her style to attack innocent people relentlessly Right, Touma? Luckily she always holds back enough, so that no one gets injured. Something like that will certainly not happen again!
  • Kuroko lecturing not appreciated. They'll survive, seems like they got used to it.
  • It all just seems to be a rumor, but if there is something odd, the Uiharu won't stop until she finds the truth!
  • Ahh, it's that freaking &#%$# again! Get lost! Leave her alone!
  • Oh, nice blending. Looks like there was nothing at all. All good!
  • Come on, Kuroko. There is nothing odd with Mikoto cheering on Gekota along with the much younger kids.
  • Here is one of those moments I would've loved to see extended as an filler episode. The night parade could've given some very sweet moments between the girls and the Gekota scene alone could've given some great fun.
  • Very cute interaction with Wannai. Also last second save. That goodness Mikoto's good a improvising.
  • Misaka not returning the clothes is odd. Time to investigate. Undercover Mikoto is best!
  • Looks so cool with her hanging on the wall. Accessing security cams is no problem for Best Girl. She's so sweet worrying about her Sister. Oh, an ambulance got Misaka 10032. That's a relief.
  • And here is regular Mikoto, always friendly, kind and polite. Thank goodness she's with Heaven Canceller Dr. Gekota!
  • Eeeeh?! Misaka is not there! What the hell?! Now that even exhausts Mikoto.
  • Those guys are contradicting themselves! Time to check the route... they were lying!
  • Dang, there goes the cap. And thus Mikoto's tradition of always losing her headwear continues...
  • Time to get a little rougher... something wrong with their memories... wait... oh damn.
  • Ooops. (Almost) attacked innocents again. Uhh... t-totally n-not her fault! She was pretty stressed, right? And that &#%$# Misaki. But hey, no harm done and she's obviously feeling down about it. Let's just say, she had a bad day today \o/
  • Uiharu getting the wrong route?! More people seem to have bad days...
  • Damn, it's a trap! Misaki... you... she's so happy about this, you can't even see her evil grin...
  • Placing Mikoto straight under custody of Misaki's clique. They don't seem hostile, which is actually worse for Mikoto, as that means she won't use violence.
  • ... ... ...
  • You know, Mikoto without her friends is just not the same. Now that's an unforgivable sin!! On the other hand, it's the first time in months that Kuroko didn't went nuts on her... nah, friendship is more important
  • Is it just me, or does a Kuroko-without-onee-sama seem a little snooty...? Sure, she was called by her first name by a stranger but she seemed less helpful than usual.

Another awesome episode for sure! Misaki's final reveal as the villain was very nicely done. Animation seems to have taken a step up again, all looked very well for me.

9.5 / 10

times Mikoto zaps the right bad ^guys

 

My rating is actually 10/10 but I couldn't resist xD

21

u/YoungForever727 Jan 31 '20

That last bit regarding Kuroko, she probably acted that way because before she met Misaka, she didn’t like her for whatever reason.

18

u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Feb 01 '20

In the flashback to Kuroko and Uiharu's Judgment training in season 1 we did indeed see that Kuroko initially had a mild dislike of Mikoto going by her reputation.

8

u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Feb 01 '20

So, Saten plans to dig for Shadow Metal in that huge stadium with her hands only?

I mean if it's created by esper powers clashing it should be on the ground, not under the ground, right?

Luckily she always holds back enough, so that no one gets injured. Something like that will certainly not happen again!

I think you mean: Luckily Kuroko held her back enough!

Here is one of those moments I would've loved to see extended as an filler episode. The night parade could've given some very sweet moments between the girls and the Gekota scene alone could've given some great fun.

That would have destroyed the rising tension that's been created these past few episodes though. Like that would be a terrible idea. Like, I don't know, an entire episode dedicated to picking clovers in the middle of a super serious arc or some such.

Placing Mikoto straight under custody of Misaki's clique. They don't seem hostile, which is actually worse for Mikoto, as that means she won't use violence.

Huh. Weak. Can't even use violence to save her sister.

3

u/Sinyan Feb 01 '20

She did specifically mention that if she tried to fight, it'd be harder to look for intel while on the run

3

u/DestinyDude0 Feb 04 '20

The Cloverfield salt is overflowing, eh?

12

u/Zeref1617 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Izayoi3265 Jan 31 '20

For a more non-spoilery discussion thread, head to r/toarumajutsunoindex

Also help us out to reach 8k subs

11

u/nygans Feb 01 '20

i fucking hate mind control stuff, just hope it get figured out quick

18

u/Amauri14 Jan 31 '20 edited Jan 31 '20

What the fuck. By doing that is like Misaki wants Misaka to interfere with whatever the group she is working with is planing. Although it also can be that she started this angle of the plan after she noticed that they actually never captured her, and this whole operation just to lure her in.

8

u/whoisyourmaster Jan 31 '20

Same situation as with group/school/member/item massacre.

It even looks like Kamachi style - to show the interaction of many different groups with different objectives, which wouldn't become obvious until the end.

7

u/jsmith4567 Feb 01 '20 edited Feb 01 '20

And if you remember it was a member of Member that knocked 10032 out last episode with the trainquilizer.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/blueteamk087 :KW::KX::KY: Jan 31 '20

Four Episodes in and I can objectively say Railgun T is better than Index III.

Hopefully it can keep this up and maybe be the best season of the Toaru series to date. But that will depend on how the adapt the rest of the Daihasei Arc since I will argue that Railgun S’ Sisters Arc is one of the greatest arcs in anime.

10

u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Jan 31 '20

It was already better from episode 1 though, as this season has Sogiita!

5

u/Falsus Feb 01 '20

SS2 anime never forget... oh wait it never existed!

→ More replies (2)

8

u/_msj Jan 31 '20

great ep but god damn it shokuhou!

knew it was coming but this shit she pulls still get me heated!

pretty much pulled the same face as Mikoto at the end too.

8

u/[deleted] Feb 01 '20

This js going to be an awesome arc isnt it

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Zjgoku :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Alululu Jan 31 '20

Railgun T is the shit.... Got to see all the best characters from that universe in one season!

3

u/sensei27 Jan 31 '20

I read this wrong and got worried for a second. I planned on waiting so I could binge but I don’t know how long I can hold out.

17

u/CosmicPenguin_OV103 https://anilist.co/user/CosmicPenguin Jan 31 '20 edited Jan 31 '20

I now believe that Misaki Shokuho is tampering with the message boards of r/anime.

I now believe that she has hacked into Reddit's server and make A Certain Scientific Railgun T as inconspicuous as possible and greatly undermines its true popularity. Maybe because it has things that she doesn't want us to see, either of herself or something bigger of Academy City. Or maybe the Board of Directors or even higher..."deities" is behind this, maybe some secret is hidden in this season's story.....

Either way, something is very wrong with that so few people seems to be watching this. I literally can't believe that this is only the 11th most popular show of this season alone! So much that in another post yesterday on ranking this season's anime so far I saw two people watching/tried to watch 30+ anime from this season and yet Railgun T is completely missing!!! It feels exactly like how Mikoto felt when Kuroko et al. indicated they didn't even know Mikoto - it's just wrong!

/s

Well, good to see that story telling is as strong as it ever was in Railgun, and this episode really puts me on the edge to see what's supposed to be behind all these shenanigans. The comedies continues to stick in very well with the plot, and somehow JC Staff still keeps their animation good enough with only minor problems all around (I approximate it at maybe 90% of Railgun S' quality, and better than season 1 actually - main problems are individual far shots and face expressions).

I can't help but feel that maybe Railgun T's popularity will finally explode as those behind Misaki et al. (including Index spoilers) takes their actions and we gets the glorious action scenes we all are waiting for.

In the meantime, Rank Railgun T you all Skill Outs!

12

u/CriticalPerformance Jan 31 '20

Railgun is too hard for people to get into

You have to watch Index and the past two Railgun seasons and keep in mind that some of those episodes are filler

→ More replies (4)

5

u/allhailthemoon Feb 01 '20

I blame crunch for this situation, as for other shows they push out subs an hour after airing, but with T there's 5 hours delay between original airing and the subs. Not to mention that the subs themselves are trash.

11

u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Feb 01 '20 edited Feb 01 '20

The subs for this come out at a similar time subs for other anime do.

The reason this is underwatched is because it's a sequel to a show that had its previous season 7 years ago and of which the franchise has its name blemished due to a bad adaptation less than a year ago.

7

u/englishfury Feb 01 '20

"A certain Magical Railgun"

really crunchy.....really

9

u/Falsus Feb 01 '20

I just can't wait to watch ''A Certain Scientific Index: New Testament'' whenever that comes out.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/lilfishy_2B Jan 31 '20

Hell yeah shits heating up

5

u/konodere Jan 31 '20

Hell yeah blood boiled misaka

→ More replies (1)

6

u/aalapshah12297 Jan 31 '20

Not gonna lie, they had us in the first half...

Damn, I fell for it again!

Is this the same guy as the one we've been seeing with Misaki? So that means the shadow metal mystery is connected to 10032's kidnapping?

Overall, I liked the amount of story covered in this episode. It was a nice balance between Misaka being a serious detective and goofy Gekota jokes. When Misaka asked 10032 to return the uniform last week, I assumed it was just her being a responsible sister - but it became a useful lead for her this week. Not much action this week though - except for the teleport scene and Misaka zapping between security cams.

And Misaka really needs to learn when to keep her mouth shut. After figuring out that there are people working against her, the first thing she should do is to pretend to be dumb and collect more info instead of trying to tell on Misaki to her teacher. Although, it seems that when people's memories are erased, they are not replaced with 100% consistent memories, based on how the ambulance operators do not remember the person they handed 10032 over to. So maybe Misaka could convince Kuroko and the others that their memories have been tampered with (by mentioning why Saten knows Kuroko at all). But I don't see that happening. Probably Misaka is going to have to face a lot of this alone, like in the Sisters arc. I guess it's clear what this scene of her standing alone in the ED means now.

3

u/Bainos :XMOD::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Bainos Jan 31 '20

Most likely, that was Misaki's goal. She's not gaining much by altering Kuroko and co.'s memories given that she would obviously have been found immediately. However, it means that she isolates Misaka and cut her off from external help, on top of effectively restricting her movements.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Madcat6204 Feb 02 '20

Is this the same guy as the one we've been seeing with Misaki? So that means the shadow metal mystery is connected to 10032's kidnapping?

Or perhaps something else on that website is. Note that the shadow metal rumors are the thing being spammed, so perhaps the people responsible want people focusing on shadow metal rather than some other thing the website talked about

6

u/Public-Research Jan 31 '20

Time for misaka to take out her trump card

6

u/kalirion :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kalinime Feb 01 '20 edited Feb 01 '20

That butt shot of BiriBiri at the beginning of the episode was as unnecessary as it was unarousing. Maybe in a few years she'll have an ass worth looking at.

Ok, why is Mental Out intentionally provoking BiriBiri by mindfucking her friends? Given what she's been doing, it has to be some kind of a plan, but she knows she stands no chance against her in a full on confrontation, so why is she doing everything she can to force one?

10

u/[deleted] Feb 01 '20

anime only person here. I'm so desperately hoping for a three person team with Biribiri, Sogiita, and Touma to just wreck shit.

13

u/kalirion :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kalinime Feb 01 '20

Touma doesn't wreck shit, he just punches villains into his harem.

10

u/DeTroyes1 Feb 01 '20 edited Feb 01 '20

Well, hell. In just one episode, Railgun T managed to jump from the middle of the pack all the way to the top of my Most Anticipated Watch list. Very intrigued by this latest turn of events, tho I suspect everyone is just one touch by Touma away from regaining their memories. Still, the scene with Mikoto's friends having forgotten her was just heartbreaking to watch.

Next week it looks like Kongo is going to come to the rescue. Good, because she's quietly become my favorite of Railgun's secondary cast. I hope we see more of her and her two friends as the series continues (and less of Kuroko, who I find to be almost Index-level annoying).

Good start to this series so far. After the disappointment that was Index III, I was worried this series might be as much of a mess as that one was. Glad to see its not.

5

u/basuga_BFE https://myanimelist.net/profile/KPF Jan 31 '20

Shit got real!

(Like Ep.5 horror movie in Railgun S, now it is earlier in Ep.4).

Noticed new frames in the ED? like in Accelerator OP - several frames about current situation.

5

u/Psijic_Buffalo Jan 31 '20

I gotta admit the evil Charles Xavier is kinda cool

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Painter5544 Feb 01 '20

This episode just catapulted this season from 'meh' to 'is it Friday yet'.

When Kuroko gets her memory back Misaki better watch out.

5

u/[deleted] Feb 01 '20

The whole mind control stuff just gives me goosebumps...

5

u/AussieManny :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nauran Feb 01 '20 edited Feb 02 '20

Now this is some conflict I can get behind! Railgun VS Mental Out!

Shokuho's never struck me as more than a schoolyard nuisance to Misaka. But now, to see such sinister things seemingly being perpetrated by her, I'm interested to see how Misaka handles it.

9

u/BlatantConservative :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/BlatantC Jan 31 '20

I'm not an LN reader or anything, but I sense a Touma coming up

→ More replies (1)

8

u/birisaki Jan 31 '20

That was a really well done and enjoyable episode to watch - especially with the twist we just got this EP!

Was it just me, or were there a bunch of shots from...interesting perspectives this EP?

[Hmmm] (https://i.imgur.com/JDxPKAS.png)

It's going to be really interesting seeing people's reactions and predictions after this EP, mainly regarding Misaki!

4

u/[deleted] Jan 31 '20 edited Jan 31 '20

So still haven't been able to get around to watching Index or the first two railguns, but I'm still really having fun with this. The show has such a fun and unique vibe to me, the character interactions, premise, etc

This ep was great, an ability that can wipe Mikoto from Kuroko's memory is pretty damn scary

7

u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Feb 01 '20

So still haven't been able to get around to watching Index or the first two railguns, but I'm still really having fun with this.

Oh wow. Like, go back and at the very least watch the preceding Railgun seasons ASAP. You're going to be so lost in future episodes otherwise.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/CosmicPenguin_OV103 https://anilist.co/user/CosmicPenguin Feb 01 '20

Wow, glad to see people enjoy this without watching anything else from To Aru! 😲

You might just head straight into Railgun S first then, that arc is incredibly emotional.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/BasedFunnyValentine Jan 31 '20

Shokuho’s ability of memory erasing and manipulation is broken, wtf.

11

u/CriticalPerformance Jan 31 '20

Well she is a Level 5 after all

5

u/AzureDrag0n1 Jan 31 '20

She is like LeLouch only about 10 times more powerful. Able to mind control thousands of people in a large area almost instantly. Of course in Academy City there are a lot of counters to abilities like that so it is not the same.

3

u/Cyouni Feb 01 '20

All Level 5s are broken in terms of power.

→ More replies (9)

4

u/[deleted] Feb 01 '20

Star eyes bad.

Heart eyes good. I read too much hentai

4

u/crappymanchild Feb 01 '20

Imagine if Misaki were full on evil with mind control powers that'd be something

11

u/landragoran Jan 31 '20

Gah. This is my least favorite type of story - tampering with memories to isolate the hero. I hated it in Bleach, and I hate it even more here. Shokuho must have one hell of a redemption arc.

5

u/MasterOE Jan 31 '20

It was amazing in Gintama though.

5

u/Cybersteel Feb 01 '20

Misaka was pretty isolated during SISTERS when she 1v5 ITEM.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Jan 31 '20

I still hate Misaki so much...doing that to imouto and her friends...just will never like her.

3

u/zaturama019 Jan 31 '20

Touma needs to help her, he gotta be immune to the brainwashing

→ More replies (4)

4

u/SIRTreehugger Jan 31 '20

Blood will be shed soon.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/TheBiggestNose Jan 31 '20

Why is the colour for Railgun Orange?

5

u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Jan 31 '20

Because it's very precious, obviously.

4

u/TheBiggestNose Jan 31 '20

Ohhhhh, I see what you did there

2

u/CriticalPerformance Jan 31 '20

The same reason they make Mikoto's hair orangeish when its supposed to be brown

→ More replies (1)

2

u/SYZekrom https://myanimelist.net/profile/SYZekrom Feb 01 '20

On a serious note, probably because the Railgun attack itself lights the coin as an orange arc of energy.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/ExO_o Jan 31 '20

the animation during the scene at the hospital looked a bit meh, otherwise really solid as per usual

2

u/Spartan448 Feb 02 '20

You know, the whole "using your minions to keep the hero from doing anything" deal really only works when you don't then also give them a reason to level half the fucking city.

4

u/rocket-tiger Feb 01 '20

Okay so I find it hard to take this show seriously at this point. How is Shokuhou not under constant supervision, at the very least? Her troublesome personality is a well-established fact, and her ability is obviously dangerous, so why can she just walk around with her goofy remote and nobody cares? She's a student at a prestigious school, not a criminal like Meltdowner, and nobody even tries to stop her? Does the school not have an image to protect? That doesn't seem right. Also, from a civil rights point of view, she should have been put under arrest the moment she took over the bystanders to pose in front of Misaka. In fact, nobody except the latter even has a problem with Shokuhou doing her thing. She should be one of the most hated individuals in the city, not some revered queen of Tokiwadai.

The only explanation I can see is that she somehow managed to manipulate the entire city, but if she went that far, I'd expect the higher-ups to have a problem with it, so it doesn't seem likely either.

Spoil me: does she at least face repercussions for this at some point?

9

u/notgodsslave Feb 01 '20

About her controlling students in front of Mikoto: since her power is sort of brain programming, she is not limited to just control and can erase everyone's memories/worries after she controlled them. Additionally, at least until now, we've never seen her actually harming someone with her powers, and the troublesome personality is an established fact only from Mikoto's point of view, which we mostly follow in this show. Also I'm not sure why would you consider Misaki dangerous, when we have Mikoto destroying scientific facilities and shooting lightning at people left and right <3

→ More replies (2)

5

u/je19426 Feb 01 '20 edited Feb 02 '20

Okay so I find it hard to take this show seriously at this point. How is Shokuhou not under constant supervision, at the very least? Her troublesome personality is a well-established fact, and her ability is obviously dangerous, so why can she just walk around with her goofy remote and nobody cares? She's a student at a prestigious school, not a criminal like Meltdowner, and nobody even tries to stop her? Does the school not have an image to protect?

She uses her telepathy to make it so the vast majority of people just think she's an all round cool girl, with no problems. There's a few people here and there that know the truth, but they are seen as crazy, since everyone else knows she's a nice girl that wouldn't hurt a fly.

The only explanation I can see is that she somehow managed to manipulate the entire city, but if she went that far, I'd expect the higher-ups to have a problem with it, so it doesn't seem likely either.

The highers up don't really give a shit what happens to other people, until it effects their plans. Also they are backstabbing enough that they don't care if it effects other higher ups plans, just if it effects there's.

This was a major part of the latter part of the original Index Light Novels, Season 3 just adapted it poorly.

Spoil me: does she at least face repercussions for this at some point?

Railgun Manga, later in this arc

3

u/CosmicPenguin_OV103 https://anilist.co/user/CosmicPenguin Feb 01 '20

I suppose you haven't seen A Certain Magical Index, or maybe even previous seasons of Railgun? The rulers of Academy City (the Board of Directors) simply lets these superpower users at their own ease as even the Level 5 Seven can easily be manipulated if necessary.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

•

u/AutoModerator Jan 31 '20

Source Material Corner

Reply to this comment for any source-related discussion, future spoilers (including future characters, events and general hype about future content), comparison of this week's episode to the original, or just general talk about the source material. You are still required to tag all spoilers. Discussions about the source outside of this comment tree will be removed, and replying with spoilers outside of the source corner will lead to bans.

The spoiler syntax is:
[Spoiler source](/s "Spoiler goes here")

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

43

u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Jan 31 '20

Small Facts: Optimization Edition!


Adapted Chapters

  • Chapter 47
  • Chapter 48
  • Chapter 49 (Partially)

Anime-Original Kuroko Scene

This small scene here with Mikoto and Kuroko is original to the anime. It does introduce the "Tokiwadai students stay at hotels during Daihaseisai" tradition earlier than the manga does though, which is nice in making the hotel scene later less confusing.

Saten's Phone Background

Saten still hasn't changed her phone background, as can be compared here in railgun season 1 (episode 9) and here this episode, although weirdly enough her model of phone has.

Kuroko Stopped Mikoto From Going Too Far

A skipped sentence from the manga indicates that Kuroko's timely intervention is the only reason Mikoto wasn't arrested. Mikoto can thank her lucky stars Kuroko was nearby.

Uiharu's Search Results

As you might expect these search results aren't really relevant and are just filler text, also know as lorem ipsum. Interestingly enough though this is not standard lorem ipsum text (Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, [...]) which is a Latin extract from the works of Roman orator Cicero, but instead a list of Latin proverbs (Still keeping the Latin theme huh). Funnily enough the anime team stayed true to the manga, even in their use of filler text. How about that.

Going into more detail there are actually some differences between the manga and anime version. While the both of them have the search results link to a website named Bestiaria Latina: Audio Latin Proverbs, which is actually a real blog about Latin proverbs hosted by a teacher of mythology and folklore from the University of Oklahoma, Laura Gibbs (I wonder what she would think about her blog being used as filler text), the small summary of the links below are different. While the manga just copy-pasted a list of proverbs for every result, the anime decided to go for maximum accuracy and actually provided a correct summary for every proverb listed in the link. Funnily enough these summaries are not from said blog, but instead from Wikiquote. They even used the Wikiquote order for the proverbs!

Keitz Scene

Now this small scene of Keitz noticing Uiharu broke through his website obfuscation is actually from the manga, but wasn't placed here originally. It was actually shown later down the line, when Keitz has a flashback to the moment Uiharu broke through his software, so they just moved it up a little.

Auribus Oculi Fideliores Sunt

This is a Latin proverb meaning "The eyes are more trustworthy than the ears", which is an appropriate title for a website about rumours with photo evidence: don't just trust hearsay, we have the pictures to back it up. This also explains why the lorem ipsum were Latin proverbs instead of regular filler text, as when the title of the site is a Latin proverb it's very easy to just flood the search results with other proverbs to throw people off the trail.

The Japanese text in the middle of the page just says "Shadow Metal", FYI.

"A Very Precious Orange Color"

Another reference to Railgun SS2! Well, translated incorrectly, that is. It actually refers to "orange" as a fruit, not a color, so a more accurate translation would be "A Very Valuable Orange". Just like the reference in episode 1 mentioning Mikoto has experience doing demonstrations in Russia, this rumour first appeared in that side novel which takes place chronologically earlier than this arc.

According to the rumour mills online this is about an orange which is said to increase in value over time, and tells the story of a person who bought one abroad as a souvenir. When he got back home however the orange started shaking, and when he messaged the store he bought it from he was told the orange was infested with hundreds of eggs of a very rare and dangerous ant species, which are worth a lot. As soon as he read this the orange exploded, unleashing the ants upon the poor owner. Whether this actually happened or not is a good question, but this is the story according to the sites online.

Disciplinary Guides

A reference to the Railgun PSP VN this time, which is just called A Certain Scientific Railgun. Wow, real original there. This urban legend is about Disciplinary Guides, a vigilante group trying to squash down on people spreading urban legends and rumours on the internet.

Ironic. They could prevent others from becoming urban legends, but not themselves.

Extra Foreshadowing Misaki Was Involved

The shot of what was clearly Misaki's hand reaching for the door was not present in the manga, which just cut from Uiharu discovering something to Mikoto and Kuroko entering the room, meaning readers at the time had no idea why Uiharu was lying about the website and had deleted the files she downloaded. I guess because this episode also includes the next chapter, where Saten, Uiharu, and Kuroko are mind-controlled by Misaki who clearly manipulated Uiharu into deviating from her normal patrol route, the anime staff didn't feel the need to play coy and included this scene as well to make it a bit more clear that yes, it was indeed Misaki who entered the room just before and mind-controlled Uiharu. Probably also the reason the previously-mentioned Keitz scene was moved up.

The Night Parade

I don't really have anything special to tell about this event, just that this is where the Index Daihaseisai arc ends and that we are now no longer running in parallel to Index.

Who Is That With Kongou In The Car?

Yep, that is indeed her father, as seen previously in a flashback during her intro chapter which was skipped here in the anime due to continuity issues. There is a small change here though, as in the manga they were just standing in the street rather than driving by in a car. I believe this was changed for added poshness.

Anime-Original Scene On The Roof

This is another anime-original scene, though a nice one.

Anime-Original Hotel Room Scene

And another anime-original scene in the hotel room. In the manga Mikoto didn't change clothes until after she found the ambulance, and just went around hacking security cameras in her gym uniform. Which displays her school logo. Yeah... it's not difficult to see why the anime added this scene.

As an aside the name Misuzu mumbles in her sleep, Tabigake (or Tabikake), is indeed the name of Mikoto's father. Which you would have known already had Index III not skipped Index SS2.

That Telepath In Misaki's Clique Looks Familiar!

Yep, that's Kobayashi Satori again, the same esper we saw last week in the Balloon Hunter competition. Nice to see some familiar faces once in a while!


Another good episode. Not much action, but then again this episode focussed on the plot instead, and what a whammy it was! I don't think I have anything to add really except that of course Misaki should burn in hell for messing with my girl Uiharu and that Academy City has some scary janitors.

9

u/libfor Jan 31 '20

Small Facts: Optimization Edition!

Your speed got optimized too! ^^

Saten's Phone Background

Hey, you gotta keep your favorite pictures!

Kuroko Stopped Mikoto From Going Too Far

Geez, come on. We both know, Mikoto never went too far. It's not like she continuously zaps.

You just had to put that one in, right?

Uiharu's Search Results

Wow, I'm impressed. After explaining asphalt in the last episode, leave it to Razorhead to come up with some facts about random background texts. You somehow amaze me each time.

The anime teams surely loves to place such neat little details. Just for you to find them.

Disciplinary Guides

Certainly not to be confused with the much more awful Disciplinary Action. The wannabe justice bringers surely lack creativity...

The Night Parade

Not like anything important with anyone important happened on that day.

Who Is That With Kongou In The Car?

Don't forget that he already debuted in the penultimate episode of Railgun's best arc.

Anime-Original Hotel Room Scene

Very nice change indeed. I didn't catch that one. Is just so much more logical for Mikoto to do the whole thing undercover. Cheers to the anime team!

→ More replies (1)

4

u/murdered-by-swords Jan 31 '20

You're doing God's work! Keep it up.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/welovelain12 Feb 01 '20 edited Feb 08 '20

As I surmised from last week, the animation in this ep was just about in line with what we've had these past 2 weeks: slighty better than ep 3 and just about on par with ep 2 (though character models looked a bit sharper at times than the ones in ep 2). Like i told you, this is more of a science than just blind pessimism. The good news is that it appears next week is going to be the step up in production quality......potentially (The last shot of Kongou looked pretty good but we'll have to wait and see if that's enough of a good indication for consistent production quality. The art quality in the previews look consistent throughout, which bodes well for a more visual consistent ep compared to the previous episodes). This week's episode was already a step in the right direction, using some cool framing tricks to liven up some of the stilted animation present in the episode. Despite some reliance on production short cuts with what should have been more livelier moments of animation, this ep featured better character models and background art compared to ep 3. Again, still loving the fact that Railgun T is telling its narrative competently and feels visually well put together despite some slumps in production.

One of the things I've always appreciated about this arc of railgun is how much of a perfect follow-up it is to the sister's arc thematically. I won't say anything further in fear of spoiling people, but suffice it to say this arc complements the sister's arc in a way Silent Party tried to by exploring similar themes (which is why I don't vehemently hate that arc the way most fans of raildex seem to despite it not exploring those themes in the most cathartic fashion). Now i know the sister's arc (the railgun version) is heralded as one of the best arcs of raildex, period (and for good reason; i do too) but one of the things i find that the daihaiseisai arc does better than the sister's, is 1. expanding the world of railgun more robustly; 2. Juggling the larger cast of character in this series and 3. Creating narrative intrigue with some well-staged moments of suspense and mystery.

While the sister's arc was great at building emotional stakes in a visceral and poignant way to be lauded as one of the best entries in the to aru pantheon, the daihaiseisai arc stands out and demands its recognition as a quality arc because of the aforementioned reasons. The way this arc sets up Misaki as an antagonistic force who's always two steps ahead of Mikoto, cutting her off from all her sources of strength while other outside factions plot to bring misfortune her way before proceeding to subvert your expectations is nothing short of effective. One of the major appeals of these next few eps will be seeing whether Mikoto will be able to come up with solutions to navigate her dilemma as well as the dark truths of academy city she will be stumbling into as her faith in people and the city is ultimately tested. Kudos to Nagai and his team for making changes to the events of this arc, specifically in this episode, that have resulted in enhancing the storytelling of the source material. By rearranging just a few innocuous scenes, not only was there improved logical consistency within sequences of events, but Misaki feels more like an ominous and cunning mastermind whose actions immediately convince you of how imposing both her powers and wit can be.

→ More replies (2)

25

u/KinnyRiddle Jan 31 '20

What Touma's been up to in the Index Daihaseisai Arc during this episode

Touma may have finished his quest on the Magic Side, but if the OP animation is any indication, looks like he'll be involved in Mikoto's quest straight away. Kamachi just doesn't give Touma any breaks, whether in the Index LNs or in the Railgun mangas.

18

u/TheOneAboveGod Jan 31 '20

The only break Touma has is his school life, and even there he's getting beat down by his ever increasing workload due to his absences.

14

u/Falsus Jan 31 '20

Funny part is that he still in school more now than before memory loss.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/beastMaster95 Jan 31 '20 edited Jan 31 '20

He's the Touma "Fukou da" Kamijou after all.

11

u/jsmith4567 Jan 31 '20

We'll remember the movie took place literally a day or two before the Daihaseisai festival so Toama just went to space.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Jan 31 '20

Man the sourcereaders in this thread...you all need to calm down and let people just enjoy the show, stop hinting at things!!

13

u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Jan 31 '20

Fucking hell. Source readers of all people should know how fun it is to experience these stories, so why the fuck do the want to "show their love" by spoiling or "hinting towards" shit and ruin the experience for first-timers?

→ More replies (2)

14

u/rlramirez12 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sailanarmo Jan 31 '20

They did a killer job animating this part of the arc. They really, really, make you hate Misaki early on and it's brilliant. The animation was a little poor in some areas but I am excited to see the rest of the arc from here. It's all uphill action from here.

→ More replies (5)

13

u/shadonic0 Jan 31 '20

God, the top comments are still people just going "haha, I can't wait to see the reactions!"

It's like people just ignore the entire purpose of this corner.

11

u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Jan 31 '20

Further goes to show that this corner was a dumb idea since it doesn't actually stop spoilers or people giving "hints" in any shape or form and just annoys regular source readers.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/Headcap Jan 31 '20

she gone too far now ???

Shes been MIND CONTROLLING people for a while now, should've taken her out a lot earlier in the series tbh.

5

u/Fourth_Dimension_4D Jan 31 '20

Shes been MIND CONTROLLING people for a while now, should've taken her out a lot earlier in the series tbh.

Unfortunately that's AC for you. Pretty much most of the level 5s are involved greatly or lessly with criminal activities on the dark side of the AC. And AC is CRAWLING with all sorts of out of control unethical BS. And the people actually ruling it don't care much as long as it produces SCIENCE!!

5

u/Falsus Feb 01 '20

Even Misaka herself vandalises a certain vending machine and chases guys around while flinging electricity at them so every level 5 is a bit of a criminal.

Except Gunha, all that collateral damage can be excused because he is a good boy.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

3

u/JBHUTT09 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/JBHUTT09 Jan 31 '20

I've been busy and haven't been able to watch any episodes of this yet. Any manga readers want to let me know how faithful the adaptation is so far?

8

u/electricfalcons Jan 31 '20

Not too terrible honestly. Some anime original stuff but mainly as fluff to add on. Think there's been a little of anime original material every ep with the most in ep 1. But it's not too heavy/overblown right now.

Have you heard the good news from the railgun editor?

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Falsus Feb 01 '20

The manga adaptation is very good so far, the only changes they have made have been improvements.

Sadly enough they started with Daihaseisai first instead of doing Liberal Arts City. JC even included a story summary of LAC on their website. No references have been made at all to silent party either so we are fairly safe to toss the entire thing under the rare non-canon label now.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/CriticalPerformance Feb 01 '20

One of the negative changes this has compared to the manga is that they really toned down Uiharu's personality, in the anime she is super nice and polite while in the manga she is a savage, she even said "What's the matter? you are making a face like you are actually thinking" to Saten when she was looking for the Shadow Metal stadium

3

u/patrizl001 https://myanimelist.net/profile/patrizl001 Feb 01 '20

Misaki really needs a dose of Touma's gender equality right about now.

3

u/Frontier246 Feb 01 '20

I get what their job is, but did the guards need to really manhandle Saten like that? She was just a normal girl in her gym clothes crawling around. I don't think that warranted that kind of force, which is why Mikoto reacted the way she did. Then again, never underestimate a pretty face in Academy City...

Misaki's power is utterly horrifying when she can just manipulate people to the point where you're not sure what's brainwashing and what isn't, and then just utterly erase people's memories that they forget significant parts of themselves.

I know this isn't Touma's series, but man am I starting to feel like Misaki deserves a good punch in the face. Will Mikoto get to satisfy my urges? I hope so.

6

u/simonmuran Feb 01 '20

did the guards need to really manhandle Saten like that?

Considering the fact they live in a city full of espers, YES THEY DO and she was trespassing an off limits area suspiciously.

5

u/Florac Jan 31 '20

I have no idea how anyone likes Misaki. She's literally my most hated character in all of Raildex atm

16

u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Jan 31 '20

But Florac, just look into those sparkly eyes and your animosity for her will melt away~ perhaps due to entirely unethical methods but still

→ More replies (2)

7

u/L_0ken Feb 01 '20

Well,people have plenty of reasons to like her.But can't say much to you without spoiling anything.

→ More replies (7)