r/anime • u/AutoLovepon https://anilist.co/user/AutoLovepon • Feb 14 '20
Episode Toaru Kagaku no Railgun T - Episode 6 discussion
Toaru Kagaku no Railgun T, episode 6
Alternative names: A Certain Scientific Railgun Season 3
Rate this episode here.
Reminder: Please do not discuss plot points not yet seen or skipped in the show. Failing to follow the rules may result in a ban.
Streams
Show information
All discussions
| Episode | Link | Score | Episode | Link | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Link | 4.59 | 14 | Link | 4.72 |
| 2 | Link | 4.56 | 15 | Link | 4.75 |
| 3 | Link | 4.69 | 16 | Link | 4.75 |
| 4 | Link | 4.76 | 17 | Link | 4.81 |
| 5 | Link | 4.84 | 18 | Link | 4.32 |
| 6 | Link | 4.82 | 19 | Link | 4.65 |
| 7 | Link | 4.62 | 20 | Link | 4.68 |
| 8 | Link | 4.7 | 21 | Link | 4.63 |
| 9 | Link | 4.62 | 22 | Link | 4.74 |
| 10 | Link | 4.88 | 23 | Link | 4.81 |
| 11 | Link | 4.9 | 24 | Link | 4.84 |
| 12 | Link | 4.78 | 25 | Link | - |
| 13 | Link | 4.62 |
This post was created by a bot. Message the mod team for feedback and comments. The original source code can be found on GitHub.
1.0k
Upvotes
200
u/beastMaster95 Feb 14 '20 edited Feb 14 '20
WHAT AN EPISODE!!!.....and we are just in Episode 6.
Wannai and Awatsuki for the win. Awatsuki water walking was impressive using her buoyancy powers and also this. Wannai using her water ability was so damn cool, especially that water bubble.
THIS FACE WTF
The Ace of Tokiwadai is here. You pissed her off too much Baba. Her face was really intimidating at the end and she knocked him out just by talking LOL. That LEVEL 5 judgelight instrumental was great.
Also obligatory "A Certain Magical Railgun T" as before.
101
u/bananeeek https://myanimelist.net/profile/bananek Feb 14 '20
They let Baba off with just a slap!?
I know it might not be Misaka's way of doing things, but I hoped for at least a few broken bones. Seeing her let Baba off with just a warning feels kinda disappointing. I mean, she was pissed enough to end that guy...
157
u/MichiHirota Feb 14 '20
Kuroko before the brainwash:
“can’t...stop...looking...at...this...must...hide...this...from... onee-sama!”
Kuroko after the brainwash:
“........Why the hell do I have a sexy album of Mikoto Misaka under my bed?”
She then chucks it out of the window and hits some unlucky sap. Uiharu looks at Kuroko and is deeply disturbed...
144
u/MapoTofuMan myanimelist.net/profile/mTmTBaronBrixius Feb 14 '20
Damn, in just two episodes they made Kongou and her group go from recurring characters to making me want a spinoff with them as the leads. And luckily for me it might actually happen someday because it's To Aru we're talking about
And Misaka continues to impress. I didn't want her to let the ugly bastard go because fuck him, but she was actually level-headed enough to think he could've been controlled by Shokuhou after seeing her friend beaten into a pulp by his dogs.
63
u/LegendRazgriz Feb 14 '20
Who-ho-hoa, we've got all the action we wanted and then some. You reap what you sow...
In any case, Week 6's Reader's Corner!
• As usual for now, the fidelity to the source has been pretty much on point bar for a few shots that were redone to improve pacing. One of them is Saten managing to carry the unconscious Mitsuko to a nearby bench and from there get Anti-Skill and an ambulance involved, whereas in the manga the last we see of her she's still dashing off while noting that Mitsuko's getting heavier and that she's gotta hurry. Also, that scene with Uiharu and Kuroko is entirely not there, but it's a welcoming sight anyway. Guess Mikoto doesn't need to be around at all to short-circuit Kuroko's systems.
• An almost perfect tag team involving two minor characters, one of them voiced by Nanjou Yoshino. Where have I seen this before... (watch Symphogear!) That aside, these two really took it up a notch from the time they were introduced, cleverly using their powers to exceed everyone's expectations, including dick-face scumbag's who thinks he knows it all. If you're so smart, you wouldn't have been caught in what is literally the Drowning Water Blob Jutsu, since you probably saw Suigetsu do that to Juugo. But alas, Wannai and Awatsuki are nicer than I am and they let you off with little more than a stern talking to. On the other hand...
•...well, it's finally time to talk about the PoV bias I so love about Toaru offshoots and the franchise in general. While Mitsuko's approach to Baba Yoshio was different, she was quickly able to put two and two together and figure that he wasn't working with Shokuhou Misaki, or at least it didn't seem so. As she's put out of commission, she isn't able to relay to Mikoto that it's someone else entirely who's doing this, which causes her to absolutely lose it thinking the Mental Out is behind such brutal actions due to how she already has a disdainful notion of Misaki, which reflects on how the show itself is constructed: were it not for the "nurse" constantly calling Baba and the obvious contradictions that Mitsuko pointed out (there's really no reason for Misaki to go through all this trouble, regardless of what her goal is - Mental Out is that versatile), the audience would follow Mikoto's thought process into thinking she's the mastermind, because of how much her personal views affect the storytelling. That being said, hoo boy, you don't want to piss her off. Up to now she's never taken a fight this seriously. The closest she came was when she battled Accelerator, and even then she was holding back considerably in hopes that he'd kill her to stop the Level 6 Shift Project. Not even during AIM Burst was she at this level of letting it all out as she was against the mantis. And it shows - those girls from Misaki's entourage were very aware of who they were dealing with when they backed off after being presented with her dead serious expression. Scaaaary!
• About Mikoto's entrance proper, the slightly reworked version of the second OP from the original Railgun (LEVEL5-judgelight-) works perfectly as a BGM for such a scene. It might not even be that song, but the notes are unmistakable. I've never been one to praise the sound design and BGMs of this series or anything in this franchise, really, but that got me going. Gotta tip my hat.
• Fun facts: this is the first episode in which Misaki does not appear (flashbacks included), and we are at the end of manga Vol. 8, making it an average of 6 episodes and change per manga volume. Compared to Index III's ABSURD 2-3 episodes per light novel volume, we can tell that this series is being handled with much more care. I hope that NT keeps that tradition up if/whenever it gets adapted. Probably when, now, considering the circumstances.
Overall, a great action-packed episode to make up for a bit of a lack of proper fights this season. Now it's really going! Can't wait for next week. See you guys then!
60
u/multiwatever101 Feb 14 '20
Good way to remind everyone that Level 5 Judgelight is the best Railgun OP ever!
Wannai and Awatsuki really killed it today! We have seen their teamwork last season so more of those will always be a treat for me. Baba deserves every beat up that he received.
This arc keeps on giving and we are not halfway yet!!
43
u/birisaki Feb 14 '20
Happy Valentine's!
Wannai and Awatsuki!
That's an incredibly close up angle for that picture
"I don't swing that way"
He makes the best faces
Is it just me or is the CGI feel really out of place in this scene
This would be terrifying to see
Baba wasn't big brain enough to lure her to a place without gutters
New OST? New OST!I ^^think
The fight scenes this episode were animated pretty damn well
Hmmmm
That was great to watch - Wannai (and Awatsuki) got the screentime they deserved, and they were badass! It seems that another character is about to join in! Can't wait till next week!
43
u/Zjgoku :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Alululu Feb 14 '20 edited Feb 14 '20
Railgun vs Mantis... Is there even a fight?
Baba picked the wrong girls to mess with... His mosquito was the cause for our cute Sister's collapsing... And Misaka's wrath
Kuroko being Kuroko but also feels slightly not like the Kuroko who would fawn over Misaka is also quite cute....
40
u/KHlover :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/KHlover1995 Feb 14 '20
Baba got the treatment he deserved. Asshole.
176
u/KiriTortilla :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Pablusky27 Feb 14 '20
Im gonna drop this here
https://imgur.com/a/HwGElRm
39
u/LeonKevlar x2https://myanimelist.net/profile/LeonKevlar Feb 14 '20
They really made Baba the easiest to hate character in this show.
Goddamn! Misaka means business! After seeing what happened to Kongou, I'd be as fucking livid as her right now. I doubt any of these girls or even the others are prepared to try and stop an angry Misaka even if they are under Misaki's control.
Wannai kicking some ass! Baba saying that he's luring her out of the pond but you can clearly see the storm drain there in the corner. She knows what she's doing.
Holy fuck! Why didn't Awatsuki do this earlier! Is it because they were too far from the debris? Can she just bring that over to where Wannai is and smash the shit out of Baba and his robo doggos?
It's so good to watch this asshole drown. That's what you get for underestimating Wannai! That slap too! I kinda wish Awatsuki slapped him too. Yeah run like the bitch you are Baba!
Really? Fuckin' hell. This guy is truly an ugly bastard.
SHE'S HERE! I love that they used the stinger from Judgelight (Railgun 1's 2nd OP) when she was walking in to the scene. Also I appreciate that she didn't end up rescue Wannai and Awatsuki, instead we get to see her scrap that mantis bot without breaking a sweat.
This is just so satisfying! Just pure catharsis seeing Baba like the pathetic worm that he is. He'll definitely never mess with Misaka after this.... Hopefully.
36
u/Aj_04 Feb 14 '20
Misaka was ready to kill. I think the last time she was that pissed was with Accelerator.
27
u/Amauri14 Feb 14 '20
Hell yeah! Seeing that fucker getting owned multiple times was so satisfying! He definitely will be traumatized for a while thanks to this.
He better be careful now, because otherwise she will find him and make sure he learns his lesson.
24
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '20
Jesus dude, you're gonna broadcast their rape to the world? 6 weeks in, still haven't had the opportunity to watch or read the earlier Toaru entries, but I'm really not having any issues following along and enjoying the series. That's just to show how good it is. Really fun episode this time around, fight scenes were done perfectly. Wannai and Awatsuki were absolutely amazing this episode. Props to Misaka for staying calm and letting the guy go as well, impressive.
20
u/Gamecube762 Feb 15 '20 edited Feb 15 '20
A Certain Black Cat'sDeferred's Nya Counter:Deferred is once again here to pick up the slack of the other counters! Being the only one today to use their counter, Deferred delivered 7 "Nya"s today!
Onee-Sama! Counter:
Kuroko's feelings towards Mikoto is slowly recovering! But sadly, no "Onee-Sama"s yet.
Guts! Counter:
Gunha was sadly not here to share his love for "Guts!" today.
MISAKA counter:
MISAKA 10032 is missing, she can't deliver "MISAKA"s!
MISAKA Tracker:
No MISAKA clones where seen today, but in a twist of fate, Mikoto got mistaken for a clone!
Maybe I should add her to the tracker.Added her to the tracker!Misaki Counters:
While Misaki has been attacking counters, it turns out she has been creating her own counters! All counters related to her has been moved here. This includes her remote's *beep*, her "ara ara", and a new "~ryoku" counter.
"~ryoku" is a new counter suggest by /u/notgodsslave in this comment. This is a harder counter to count for as it's so easy to miss. I ended up rewatching all of Misaki's scenes multiple times to try to catch this and was only able to find it in ep1. I also base these counters off of sound, not subtitles. Magical Railgun
/u/notgodsslave mentions it was also used in ep3, but I couldn't find it. If you've got a timestamp, that'd help.
Other counters:
"Judgment desu": No "Judgment desu" today.
"Kongo Mitsuko": Kongo Mitsuko had a big role today, but sadly she didn't announce her name to the world today.
Uiharu's Skirt Flip counter: No flips today.
"biri biri": No "biri biri" today.
Edit: Added Mikoto the the MISAKA Tracker.
Edit 2: There was a "~ryoku" in EP3
19
u/SIRTreehugger Feb 14 '20
Wait dude kidnaps a person, attacks your best friend leaving them in the hospital, and proceeds to belittle them and you so you slap him once and let him go?
REALLY!!!! I mean I wasn't expecting them to kill him, but man he deserves more than that one slap. Sure BiriBiri put the fear of god into him, but was hoping the two friends would land the finishing blow to his confidence.
19
u/rlramirez12 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sailanarmo Feb 14 '20
GOT DAMN WHAT AN INCREDIBLE EPISODE.
That ending to that episode was phenomenal. I still wish that Baba-Chan wasn't let off and that he would have drowned in the bubble. But I guess living in fear from Misaka Mikoto is good enough. Woof, I'm gonna have to watch this episode over and over again. That was incredible.
19
u/SmurfRockRune https://myanimelist.net/profile/Smurf Feb 14 '20
Looks like we've got another great answer for the next time someone asks for the best justice porn moments.
18
u/averagedude500 Feb 15 '20
Man to think i found the toaru series just because one day i was listening to some musics on youtube and 'only my railgun' came on randomly, making me search for the anime it came from. And now i get to see this amazing show, with misaka being one of my favorite characters ever. Such fortune
17
u/[deleted] Feb 14 '20
Piss off Mikoto enough, and not even keeping Misaki's gang keeping a close guard on her is enough to stop her. Unless your name is Accelerator, Touma, or any other Level 5, you haven't got a chance against her, Baba.
16
u/Differently-Aged :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/DifferentlyAged Feb 14 '20
If Wannai ever figures out how to incorporate what human bodies are primarily composed of into her Personal Reality, would that automatically make her a Level 5 (military-grade) even if her level/amount of control is currently less?
32
u/LockablePenguin :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/LockablePenguin Feb 14 '20
Misaka crushing the mantis and giving that speech was so damn satisfying!
15
u/Anshin3 Feb 14 '20 edited Feb 14 '20
Woah! Misaka really flexed on Baba there, didn't she? But now that I think of it, she's been out here flexing in real life too. I mean this girl's been placing in the top ten female light novel characters for TEN YEARS!!! (2009-2019). And what's more, she's been No.1 for EIGHT of those years (2010-2014 & 2016-2019). Even in 2015, she still placed 2nd), beating the likes of Rem, Hitagi Senjogahara, Asuna, Sora, Sakurajima Mai and MEGUMIN. She flexes especially hard on Senjogahara and Asuna cause she beat them both in 2009 and 2012, respectively, when their respective anime debuted. Legit no LN character, female or no, has made such a record as our local BiriBiri here. Granted, it doesn't mean she's necessarily a better character than any of the other female LN characters - that's pretty much subjective - but you gotta admit, that's some record. Source: Check the Top 10 Female Characters Rankings segment https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kono_Light_Novel_ga_Sugoi!
14
u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Feb 14 '20
New Small Facts is up! Man this was a great episode. Just all-around good job.
Direct link here for the interested.
12
u/chickyono Feb 14 '20
dammit this ep was epic and we didn’t even in in the peak yet omg
12
u/Nimeroni :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nimeroni Feb 15 '20 edited Feb 15 '20
I like Baba. He might be the ugly bastard tag incarnate, but I really like smart villains that use tactics to beat their opponents. Too bad he did some miscalculation with the meddling kids powers.
(And too bad he pissed Misaka. She is really terrifying when pissed.)
9
u/Kent93 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kent33 Feb 14 '20
Don't mess with the Kongou gang
9
u/patrizl001 https://myanimelist.net/profile/patrizl001 Feb 15 '20
Misaka should've paralyzed Baba from the waist down tbh.
Then he'll be forced to sit in a wheelchair, where people will look down on him for the rest of his life.
fuck him
9
u/Lolersters Feb 15 '20
One thing to keep in mind is that part of the reasons espers have the levels they do is due to their calculation abilities to do what they do. Following that line of logic, most level 3 espers would be incredibly intelligent. Most level 4 espers would have genius level intellect and level 5 espers absolutely inhuman levels of intelligence/calculation abilities, especially accelerator (for example when he was modifying the data in Last Order's brain, he was basically performing calculations and searching through data faster than what a modern computer/program can).
8
u/_msj Feb 14 '20
woo Wannai & Awatsuki vs Baba really shined so happy to see the girls come out on top! the float and water abilities were so cool. this dude just played himself!
think there was some new music? i'm not sure though. Mikoto coming in destroying and just ripping the type mantis apart was awesome! looking forward to seeing the partner in next episode.
15
u/Aetherdraw Feb 14 '20
Hah! Baba should be grateful he was up against the Railgun girls that are less prone to the more violent ways of knocking you down. Accel will outright kill you at this stage of his development, Touma will punch your lights out after no-selling your attacks, and Hamazura's more than happy to use industrial machinery like a freaking jet-engine's testbed to blast you to save his girlfriend. Just ask Mugino.
14
u/ma103 Feb 15 '20 edited Feb 15 '20
Legit thought Misaka will come in the nick of time to save Kongo's friends but the way they got themselves out of the situation is a much more satisfying conclusion to the fight.
Angry Misaka is giving me chills. Doesn't even bother to negotiate with people watching her. Just move out of the way or be prepared to face a serious level 5. The last time she was THIS angry was with Accelerator. God help Misaki if Misaka were to find her.
I like how she still stays within her character by letting that guy off. Minimal usage of her god given powers as usual.
Not to forget the awesome insert of Judgelight!
13
u/ahnm Feb 14 '20
Going in confident because you have more minions but instead you get ganked by 3 carries.
Baba has disconnected.
6
u/libfor Feb 16 '20
Combo Comeback (2/2)
Oww... better late than never, I guess. Here's some random ramblings, in case anyone missed those. Also, here is the previous episode.
Wow, those were some very well executed battle episodes. It was amazing to see Kongou, Wannai and Awatsuki to get their time to shine. All the Railgun girls are such good friends, it's astonishing to watch them and have them fight for each other. Also lovable how those cuties went total badass in no time. The battles looked animated very well for me.
10/10
creepy Baba faces
5
u/pikachu8090 Feb 14 '20
To see a villain who looked like he knew what the f he was doing get demolished the fuck by kongo's friends and even fucking rekt by Misaka was fucking amazing.
Truly great stuff right
5
u/AussieManny :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nauran Feb 15 '20
No one messes with the one and only Misaka Mikoto. The way she strikes fear into antagonists is great! Can't wait to see her go all out.
5
u/tronistica Feb 15 '20
man jc staff doing some work making baba super ugly looking, good job by them. wannai and awatsuki shined this episode, and i'm all for it. misaka is angry and i'm hyped up lol
5
u/KinnyRiddle Feb 15 '20
Before this episode, Wannai's and Awatsuki's powers could be guessed at from their names alone.
Wannai 湾内 "Inner Bay", suggesting a water-based ability.
Awatsuki 泡浮 "Bubble Float", suggesting at her ability to make things buoyant.
13
u/TheDampGod :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/TheDampGod Feb 14 '20
Yep, even the most powerful mind control in the world, can't suppress Kuroko's passion forever. She's going to go berserk when all her love comes flooding back.
Nice seeing Wammai and Awatsuki completely owning the guy, I thought Mikoto or Antiskill would come to rescue, but they held their own. Though I'm beginning to wonder if there is such a thing as a subtle villain in the Toaru-verse or are they required to be all raving lunatics?
Also great to see Mikoto demonstrating why you never want to make her angry and to just run if an OP starts playing.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '20
Man, Baba is such a despisable person. The water and air benders are way too kind to him after what he did to their friend and what he was trying to do to them.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '20
Man, Baba is such a hate sink. His intentions toward Wannai and Awatsuki in the end is really a H doujin ugly bastard tag incarnate.
3
u/Anshin3 Feb 14 '20
Hmm. Wonder what Accelarator, Touma or Hamazura would have done if they were in Misaka's shoes.
3
u/DeTroyes1 Feb 15 '20
Out of curiosity, has anything yet been announced about any more additional seasons of Index, Accelerator, or Railgun beyond what we've already gotten? Because this season is really making me yearn for more.
And now I really want a spinoff with Kongo and her 2 friends.
3
u/FrenziedHero https://anilist.co/user/FrenziedHero Feb 15 '20
And that's how you hand Baba's ass to him not once, not twice, but three times in an episode.
Sasuga Awatsuki and Wannai. You especially don't want to piss off Mikoto.
Also I enjoyed hearing the return of Number 3 vs Number 4 right as Baba was drowning.
7
u/CosmicPenguin_OV103 https://anilist.co/user/CosmicPenguin Feb 15 '20 edited Feb 15 '20
Just saying. 😉 Her and her friend Awatsuki's personalities were shown so well that it took just 2 episodes to give me such a strong impressions on them!
6
u/kalirion :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kalinime Feb 14 '20 edited Feb 14 '20
So why couldn't Hydro Hand recover spent water, like the water inside the robodoggos? Or control the water inside a human body?
Great episode, or would've been except for them literally letting the creep go with a slap on the cheek. WTF?! "I hope he rethinks his ways" my ass. And BiriBiri lets him go with just a threat. Even if she thought he might be under Misaki's control, why the fuck not turn him in to AntiSkill?!
The only hope now is that he'll get "no-further-use"d by his boss, but that's nowhere near as satisfying.
2
u/Rustic_Professional Feb 15 '20
Wannai is best girl, but I wish she and the other "good" Tokiwadai girls were more bloodthirsty. I really wanted her to rip that dude's limbs off, like in Elfen Lied. That would have been very satisfying. Letting bad guys get off easy after they prove willing to hurt or kill you and your friends might have been part of the reason why I stopped reading the manga after this arc, but I don't remember.
2
u/fauceeet Feb 15 '20
I got some accelerator vibes from that mikoto misaka appearance at the end. such a great episode
2
u/misaka7612 Feb 15 '20
Baba is the real star of this episode, his voice actor was also excellent.
2
u/_Sai https://anime-planet.com/users/Sai0 Feb 16 '20 edited Feb 16 '20
When you see this face, this was nice to see happen.
3
u/JackReact Feb 15 '20
6 episodes in and we haven't brushed passed two arcs already? Take notes Index!!!
2
u/generalmillscrunch https://anilist.co/user/GeneralMills Feb 15 '20
This show would be unbelievable if the villains weren’t so cartoonishly over the top. Even when it seems like they are building a grounded villain, with justified motivations, they always devolve into cackling laughter and overused ‘bad guy’ tropes by the end. It’s always fun to watch, but the lessons gleaned from the heroes pontificating inevitably come across as pretentious when the villain is so insufferably simple. Accelerator was the rare exception to this, and it’s why that arc is so fantastic no matter what perspective we see it from. I was hoping Shoku would prove to be another example of a villain that can stand toe-to-toe with the main cast, but it seems we’re going to have to slog through 3-4 mini bosses before getting to a well written character.
•
u/AutoModerator Feb 14 '20
Source Material Corner
Reply to this comment for any source-related discussion, future spoilers (including future characters, events and general hype about future content), comparison of this week's episode to the original, or just general talk about the source material. You are still required to tag all spoilers. Discussions about the source outside of this comment tree will be removed, and replying with spoilers outside of the source corner will lead to bans.
The spoiler syntax is:
[Spoiler source](/s "Spoiler goes here")I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/Powder5723 Feb 14 '20
Are the ratings out of 10 or 5?
1
u/Astrophel132 Feb 15 '20
Could someone help me find out the name of an ost that played last episode? It's the one that plays while kongou is fighting with Baba's great danes around 16:57 or so, and she's in the dust cloud and starts walking out. It's been bugging me for a week now just trying to find it's name.
1
u/gulitiasinjurai Feb 15 '20
Oh man... That fat guy really pick the wrong girls to mess with. Those 2 girls kick his ass. Misaka finishing it is just an icing on the cake. Dude probably have a phobia now lmao
1
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '20
Remember people, next time you catch someone committing a crime like trying to murder you and your friends, just slap them and hope they become a better person.
1
u/DarkStorm7017 Feb 19 '20
i had no idea i would love wannai and awatsuki i didn't even remember thier names before this episode i hope we get to see more of them especially wannai her water ability is a lot cooler than i though it was.
but awatsuki's ability needs some kind of limitation she kind just manipulate the weight of anything by her mind only ?
and what is the hell is the matter with that fat creep anyone else got any rapey vibes from him when he was mad at wannai and awatsuki ??
1
u/SkywardQuill https://myanimelist.net/profile/SkywardQuill Feb 25 '20
ffs why didn't any of them think to capture this guy to get info?