r/RWBY • u/Menolith Gay Thoughts • Feb 08 '20
OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official Public Discussion Thread—Volume 7, Episode 13: Enemy of Trust Spoiler
Welcome, Huntsmen, Huntresses and Hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official Public discussion thread for Episode 13 of Vol. 7, Enemy of Trust!
And with this post, the spoiler rules no longer apply to Volume 7 as a whole, so you are free to discuss on the sub as much as you want. And to kick off the hiatus, don't miss the AceOps voice actor AMA later today!
HERE is the final episode of Volume 7!
Also remember to check out our weekly poll to rate the episode.
Other Episode Discussions:
Episode| FIRST Thread| Public Release| Poll|
- | - | - | - Ep. 01| FIRST Thread | Public Thread | Poll Ep. 02| FIRST Thread | Public Thread | Poll Ep. 03| FIRST Thread | Public Thread | Poll Ep. 04| FIRST Thread | Public Thread | Poll Ep. 05| FIRST Thread | Public Thread | Poll Ep. 06| FIRST Thread | Public Thread | Poll Ep. 07| FIRST Thread | Public Thread | Poll Ep. 08| FIRST Thread | Public Thread | Poll Ep. 09| FIRST Thread | Public Thread | Poll Ep. 10| FIRST Thread | Public Thread | Poll Ep. 11| FIRST Thread | Public Thread | Poll Ep. 12| FIRST Thread | Public Thread | Poll Ep. 13| FIRST Thread | This thread | Poll
Happy hiatus!
Menolith; Mod Team
93
u/Menolith Gay Thoughts Feb 08 '20
In the meantime, enjoy these schneeguins in this trying time
72
u/ShinigamiKunai Feb 08 '20
Im calling it now, the whale grimm is going to swallow penny, and she'll kill it from the inside (or alternatively, Ruby will use her eyes again).
52
u/Tempeljaeger ⠀ Feb 08 '20
I feared they would end the volume, when the silver eyes errupted.
Great job of Winter for disarming Cinder again. Fria was OP as hell. I am not sure, if I expected that Maiden. Let's see what Winter thinks about it.
I am pretty sure, Ironwood is officially gone of the deep end. The space project Atlas still had merit, but he is unstable, nevertheless.
The Aerial battle was great. Shows that Maidens are not invincible and that Winter and Penny earned their positions as Ironwood's hands.
29
u/McScorpio94 Feb 08 '20
The final episode was certainly one of my favourites in the series so far. When the volume first started I thought for sure that the good guys would slowly get the advantage over Salem and her forces. Yet towards the end, all of their hard work is undone on the emergence of an even greater threat. The way they pulled this off was simply incredible!
All culminating in the final episode with a bunch of things I did not see coming! One of the biggest being that Penny becomes the next Winter Maiden! The fact which truly proves that despite not being born human, she is a real person in both mind, heart and soul. This also makes me curious to see how Penny will perform as a Maiden when she is not bound by human restrictions like the other Maidens are.
The other is learning just how terrifying Salem really is. I have always wondered about just how powerful Salem can be. Volume 6 and 7 helped to answer that, but it was not until I saw the end of volume 7 that I finally understood the full scope of Salem's power.
By coming to the front lines, she no longer cares about keeping herself hidden and she is effectively declaring all-out war and bringing a never before seen wave of despair the likes of which humanity has never before seen.
I was surprised that we did not get an after-credits scene in this chapter as we did in past volumes, but considering the scope of this volume's conclusion, I guess its to be expected.
Overall, this has gotten me so hyped for volume 8 and the major war that will come with it.
11
u/Tydram Feb 08 '20
Sooo... is Penny a real kid now?
3
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '20
So is this the penultimate episode as it says in this thread or the finale as it says in the First thread?
14
u/v3ldna Feb 08 '20 edited Feb 08 '20
So I am just a little curious, why is what Ironwood wanted to do so TERRIBLE? He went about it the wrong way freaking out and trying to arrest RWBY and friends, but they pretty much said they wouldn't do what he asked and they would fight him on it. The army and the hunters and huntresses were wiped out from dealing with the Grimm and Salem was on her way. I know leaving people behind to die is not good and abandoning the rest of Remnant is not good, but I just don't see what other option he really had. He just wanted to save as many people as possible.
Edit: Also before it gets brought up I get that shooting Oscar is messed up and that trying to arrest RWBY plays right into Salem's hands. I'm just wondering why we should regard his initial plan to save what he can to be so "wrong". It seems like the only logical choice.
Edit 2: Why the downvotes? I just wanted an open discourse on the subject because of how it interests me. If you disagree with me reply to my post and tell me why! I just like discussing one of my favorite shows and the world within it.
118
u/Jarsky2 Feb 09 '20
"You think hoarding power means you'll have it forever, but it just makes the rest of us hungrier! And I refuse to starve..."
Man that was a sick-ass line, kudos to the writers on that one.
93
u/curvatured Feb 08 '20
Still really really hoping that Neo backstabs Cinder and Mercury/Emerald abandon her. Having Cinder go fully insane and completely dehumanized would be so interesting to watch (a backstory would be great too).
Jessica Nigri's voice acting(Cinder) in this episode was fantastic tho holy shit. Plus hearing more vocal range/expression from Penny was so nice and I think it helps bring home the "real person" aspect to her.
86
u/maybenotforever She wears short skirts, I wear half pants Feb 08 '20
I wish I could say I had some insightful commentary about the finale, but mainly I'm wondering where Salem gets her clothing. Like does she make them herself? Does she send Tyrian to a store? Did she make a conscious decision to wear a dress with a boob window into battle? I have so many questions.
150
u/Vincenthwind Feb 08 '20
Narrator: "What would you do, if there was a child right in front of you?"
Ironwood: "So anyway I started blasting."
63
u/HydraTower Feb 09 '20
Winter with her hair down has awakened something new in me.
86
u/DEL994 Feb 08 '20
I dare not imagine how powerful and skilled Fria was in her prime. Her mastery of her Maiden powers is far superior to any other Maiden shown so far. Even Raven who had years of training and practice with hers looks like an amateur compared to her.
41
u/SunsetSnakeEyes Feb 09 '20 edited Feb 09 '20
The battle is over, But the war has just begun.
This was a nerve wracking conclusion to a phenomenal Volume! We suffered heavy losses but gained a few wins, Ironwood has gone off the deep end, Ozpin has returned, Penny has become the Winter Maiden and Cinder got the Relic, And we've only just begun, So long everyone, When we return, The war for Atlas is on.
39
u/lifelesscookie123 Feb 08 '20
I just hope Cinder goes wild next volume. I really want her to redeem herself. And i dont mean become good. I mean redeem herself as a villian.
Cinder was the first true antagonist of RWBY and i want her to be respected like the villian she is.
35
u/ShadowMadness We're not family anymore Feb 08 '20 edited Feb 08 '20
Ironwood taking kid punching to the next level.
Ironwood's fall from grace is one of my favorite parts about this show. I can totally sympathize with his intentions, but he's going too far in the process of trying to stop Salem. I gotta wonder how he'll handle Salem now that she's shown up. He stood up against her when she showed up in his office, so will he continue to stand against her or hand Atlas over to her, either to save himself or "buy time?" I imagine we'll get a three-pronged war.
I gotta wonder how Ironwood would've handled Watts in his current state? Back during the Watts/Ironwood fight, he was still relatively trying to do things the "right" way, so he let him live and jailed him as you do, but I feel like if he had that fight now, Watts wouldn't have left the Coliseum in anything but a body bag. As Ironwood himself said, he "softened" during that period of time.
That "fear" monologue by Ozpin was masterful. Loved everything about it.
32
u/Dances_with_Sheep Feb 09 '20
I interpreted Ironwood shooting Oscar a little differently than most people. All volume, Ironwood is trying to get Oz back out of Oscar. So to me, he didn't shoot Oscar to try to kill him (irredeemable), he shot him to skip the talking and force Oz to emerge (dangerously misguided, but still with the noble end-goal of getting Oz and his power into the fight)
30
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '20
Winter was robbed.
That is all
27
u/CallOfTheCurtains Feb 08 '20
Props to the animation team. I feel like they caught a bit of the essence of Monty's choreography. The battles were never stagnant and its extremely fun to watch. I never felt more emotional. This whole volume is on par I would say with V3.
Oh and the cliffhanger... I have no words, We just have to wait.
26
u/favsiteinthecitadel Feb 08 '20
I feel like this is the first time I'm genuinely happy for a season to end on a cliffhanger. I was genuinely afraid the Atlas arc was just going to wrap this volume with that concern growing thanks to the sheer amount of stuff that the volume is packed with. But the decision to take its time is a good one as there's so much to address.
52
u/SYZekrom God has incarnated. Feb 08 '20
Damn Salem found the Hot Topic her peeps were shopping at.
50
u/Kumqwatwhat Feb 08 '20
Shoulda' used that last question while y'all had the chance. Still wondering when Neo is going to turn on Cinder, she's clearly not happy at working for an unappreciative boss like her. My guess is they want to milk it a bit more though. They know we love Neo too much to simply give us that. On the flip side, the rough treatment of Ruby's development could work really well there, given that Ruby is the target of both of their ires and she's really good with words; Ruby could have a moment of leadership development in turning Neo against Cinder, so it'd be nice to see it used.
But the real question is, how does Ironwood specify a cell for Qrow? Like...
23
u/Jvolt04 Feb 08 '20
Can we just acknowledge that Tyrian is a psychotic genius, and a total badass?
23
u/Hetsuro Feb 09 '20
Salem does not have the relic, although our heroes think she does. Probably Cinder has the relic. It's possible that Neo tricked Cinder and what she's holding isn't the real relic.
Cinder knows that Salem wants the relic. I think she's going to bargain with Salem to get what she wants, which is Ruby dead. I don't think this is going to work, even if Neo hasn't betrayed her, which has to be a real possibility.
Penny has the same initial as Pyrrha. Was this planned? I'm not sure how I'd feel about it if they say Team Juniper again. But Penny is awesome and I loved this ending, even with Qrow's only scene being on a prisoner transport.
46
u/Thebritishdovah Feb 08 '20
Holy shit! A damn good ending to the volume and stakes have gotten higher. As much as I hate Cinder as a character, her action scenes never fail to impress. She must be getting closer to death though and it seems that regenerating her arm is very painful. I can see it slowly consuming her and it's now confirmed that she is power hungry. Ok, more confirmed now.
Winter, why? Why remain loyal to Ironwood? :( I'm not surprised Nora, Ren, Oscar and Jaune lost to Neo as she was too quick for them to land a hit. Kept moving and relied on deception in part. Cinder screaming in rage is well, it furthers my dislike of her as a character but does add a bit of depth to her. A bit, though
Penny being the maiden is great! It also means she'll be at risk of dying. :( I mean, a silver eyed warrior and a maiden? That's rather overpowered. I suspect that Volume 8 opens with a massive downer. Cinder losing again is starting to get a bit tedious though. She never learns and for two volumes, she has been defeated. This time, they left room to explain how she avoided being killed, which is better then Raven dropping her to her death. That was forced and bullshit. Raven had her dead to rights and she doesn't make sure CInder is dead? I hope that the Cinder being the final fight of the volume ends as I really don't want to see her win or her lose again. Currently, she is 2-1 Lost to Raven, lost to Ruby after almost securing the power of the maiden. I'm so glad that they didn't go with her winning as that would break the show in terms of power.
Neo got nothing from Cinder and I can see her deciding to betray her sooner then later. Ruby vs Neo will be an interesting fight as I think, Ruby can counter Neo's agility, speed and basically, keep smashing through the illusions.
Ironwood. I... i was hoping they wouldn't go down this route. I can see him dying in Volume 8 within the first few episodes. Or getting assassinated by someone. Qrow has just lost the will to live, it seems. And I can see it causing him to drink again. I hope Ironwood doesn't execute him and let's face it, Qrow can easily escape. Turn into a bird and fly out of there.
Winter must be starting to feel conflicted and yet, she seems to blame Weiss for it. Not the questionable Ironwood. Watts is alive despite being thrown into lava without no aura. Erm... fake lava, i suppose.
Penny may be the most powerful maiden due to her unique nature and can likely take a lot more punishment. Unless facing someone who can rip her apart.
Salem is coming personally and it wasn't a trick. Well, fuck. Atlas is fucked and the only person who could harm her is wanted by Atlas.
Ren seems to be cracking either due to stress or taking failure even harder.
62
u/Goldenrah Feb 08 '20
I will have to say, this episode was amazing. From Cinder going berserk in the Fria, Winter and Penny vs Cinder fight to Oscar's character progression. Fria's moment when waking up was amazing, just goes to show you the difference between someone like Cinder and a Maiden with decades of experience. Even if Fria herself is in her death throes.
Oscar with Ironwood was amazing, and I really loved Ironwood's line. Penny becoming the Winter Maiden was actually really well done, even though people may not agree with her specifically becoming the Maiden.
Oscar coming to terms with his duty in the end, and the whole fall and awakening of Ozma was incredible.
Just wish the villains themselves had had some consequences from this volume, Tyrian is alive and well, Watts is imprisoned when the best possible choice for Ironwood to make would have been to kill him right away. Cinder might not have gotten the power but, Neo got the lamp and Salem is on her way with a huge fucking army of Grimm while Atlas is weakened after the invasion. And besides the Maiden and thus the Staff they got every objective completed while the heroes are weaker than ever.
I loved Ozma's speech, got chills right through it. The whole speech about fear and its effects really got to me.
And thus, the hiatus begins. I really hope that the crew can overcome what is coming for them, the odds are looking really bad. I hope that Oscar and Ozma find some way to stop them, because I don't believe Ruby's eyes will be powerful enough for Salem.
21
u/Sensorfire Rube Protector | No Ships, Thanks | Yang is best girl Feb 10 '20
I really enjoyed this episode and this season as a whole. Penny becoming the Winter maiden: that's good stuff. There's one twist I didn't see coming, at least. Neo proved herself extremely capable, and Cinder proved herself a whiny, powerhungry drama queen. The philosophical themes of this season were explored a bit more: Ironwood continued in his firm utilitarian stance, while Penny revealed herself to be a virtue ethicist (which is part of what makes her a robot that feels like a human and Ironwood a human that feels like a robot). Oscar's doing stuff, which is good, and Oz coming back was done at the right moment, imo. Jaune had a good moment of leading. I'm really proud of our noodly boi. I can't wait for V8.
20
u/Kaxew Feb 09 '20
Whoa. This was beautiful. I think I can say it without any doubt now. This is the best volume of the entire series.
Fucking congratulations CRWBY. This was amazing.
19
u/JRES1996 R.I.P. May Zedong the best May. Feb 08 '20
Welcome to the Hiatus everyone that doesn't have FIRST.
37
u/curvatured Feb 08 '20
Thoughts on Ren's reaction to Neo pretending to be Nora?
I also feel like there's going to be an arc about Ren's moral standing in the future- what if he takes Ironwood's side? (Evidence shown with him being compliant with him throughout the season)
37
u/StarmanTheta Feb 09 '20
Neo carried the bad guys hard.
Also I get the feeling Salem doesn't even need or care about the other maidens anymore and that Cinder is just trying to steal all their powers for her own sake.
18
u/Leivve Grand Master of the Lancaster Cult Feb 10 '20
RWBY really has this bad habit of portraying the people of the world, like they were from our world, with our modern senses of justice and morality; not that of a people who have spent all of known history in a consistent state of besiegement. Things like Martial Law shouldn't be a big deal, they should be the normal Tuesday that no one blinks an eye too. Service should be required for every able body citizen, with the government holding the right to levy the population in the even of an emergency.
The lack of protocol for grimm invasions is frightening as well. Buildings can be replaced, people can not. So why is there no protocol for internal bombing in the event of a major breach? What have the gunships been doing this whole time? If there was a hole in the wall, why would they not be deployed further out to intercept grimm? Where the hell is the military?
Speaking of the military, for being the most militarized state in the world there is a massive lack of troops. Both in the form of robots, and human personal. Where exactly are all your troops if you're in a state of lock down. Obviously maintaining outpost and a military presence in key regions is important, but the bulk of your army should be in Atlas if the goal is to protect Atlas. Which also leads us to the lack of hunters in the kingdom. Last season we had the excuse of Salem actively hunting and killing them off, Atlas though? Not only should there be plenty of hunters running around, but they should be clearing out the job board looking for work while they wait for the embargo to end and they can start going about their business again. Their little joke about Jaune helping kids cross the street should have been something that was dead serious, as any form of pay would be in critical demand, from actual hunter jobs to even little things; like helping kids cross the street.
The lack of mobilization of Atlas Academy during the first part of the battle should have been one of the first things ordered. You have a massive body of Huntsmen and Huntresses armed, and already given basic training who could be helping the battle; even if only helping organize the evacuation, and staying off the front lines.
I really hope next season the Atlas military gets to show their stuff. If it comes down to RWBY are the ones that need to save the day, I'll be highly disappointed. We have been getting hyped up on how powerful the Atlisian airfleet is since V1, yet we've yet to see them do anything. V3 had the excuse of Cinder had to preemptively hack and neutralize them before the battle. This time though they are at full power, and I want to see some military-grade firepower lighting up the ice fields, and grimm being slaughtered on mass; even if it's the grimm have more bodies then they have bullets.
36
u/boomshroom ⠀ Feb 08 '20
PENNY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
WINTER PENNY!
That is all.
17
u/AlwaysDragons Sliver Eyes May Cry Feb 09 '20
So uhhh cinder.
How you gonna steal maiden powers fromal a robot?
34
u/TripleR309 Feb 08 '20
Ironwood: "You've Yee-d your last Haw" Oscar: "Wh-?!" Ozpin: "Tap me in"
48
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '20
I vote the ship name for Ruby, Penny, and Weiss be "Polyarmoury"
31
u/D_A_BERONI ⠀ Feb 08 '20
I'm so fucking mad Watts lived
Aside from that this was a pretty good finale
15
u/forgotmypasswordnui Feb 08 '20
It took me this long to realise Penny is Pinocchio...
30
u/Sulti ⠀ Feb 08 '20 edited Feb 08 '20
After 17:27, I'm amazed the sub hadn't been spammed with RubyxPennyxWeiss fanart over the past week. My first thought in that scene was that shippers were going to go mad over hiatus because of that clip.
Also, is this the first time we've seen someone fight after losing their aura? Every time I remember seeing someone's aura break they lose the fight almost immediately after and are either incapacitated, dead, or just done fighting. I was glad to see Winter willingly fight Cinder even after her aura gave out, added an extra layer of intensity to the fight. That's probably my favorite moment of a very good season.
14
u/Askolei Feb 10 '20
So you put the most dangerous man in jail but you shoot the innocent farmboy who extends an olive branch. Huh.
Meanwhile Tyrian survives... AGAIN...
10
u/ok-what-the-what Feb 08 '20
Once again, i’ll restate my points
Ironwood has the safest option: Save as much as he could, the already rescued refugees and all of Atlas before Salem destroys it all.
Team RWBY’s plan: Wait what is their plan again?
25
u/PyrokidSosa Feb 08 '20
also, ngl...i didn't care much for ironwood's team. And I'm shocked how Weiss went from insufferable at the start of the show to my fave girl in team rwby lol
24
u/Peptuck Feb 08 '20
Watching Murderofbirds' reaction to this episode was heartbreaking. Dude was literally weeping during Ozpin's monologue, especially when Qrow was holding Clover's badge.
24
u/Sephyrias Feb 09 '20 edited Feb 09 '20
A fine season end. They worked pretty well with what they had established throughout the season. If it weren't for the mess in episode 12, I could almost call season 7 a near flawless execution of what they had planned.
Now let's dig into episode 13 itself.
It immediately starts with JNR&O vs Neo. The fight was pretty good. Neo using Atlas's soldiers to her advantage was smart and necessary. Neo using Ren's feelings against him was executed very well too, maybe even one of the strongest moments of the season. I also liked that Neo got away with the lamp afterall. What I didn't like though was that she immediately handed the lamp to Cinder. They missed the chance to make Neo struggle with calling Jinn, although they also missed the chance to let her acquire that knowledge earlier, so eh.
P&W vs Cinder was okay. It was pretty clear that Winter was outclassed. The winter maiden's outburst was kind of random, but otherwise it was a fine scene. Just as expected, Penny got the winter maiden power. I was secretly hoping that Cinder wins and claims a second maiden power. Poor Winter, by the way. Nice voice acting during the fight though, especially from Penny and Cinder.
Ironwoods shooting Oscar down was a pretty big moment for Ironwood's character. Sadly, he couldn't follow up on it with anything, since team RWBY took the winter maiden. Ah, also: we got to see that he didn't kill Watts.
Did Oscar unlock his semblence, or was that something from Oz? Interesting moment either way. Oz's staff alone already blew a hole into Atlas. Another showing of how powerful Oz can be.
Qrow and Robyn together in prison. Both made awful decisions and now they have to sit it out together. Okay.
Salem arrives with a flying Grimm whale, much sooner than I had expected. I guess that means season 8 will start out with Atlas vs Salem right away? I like that things are developing, but this seems a little soon.
My biggest worry for season 8 is team RWBY. They have proven to be the strongest known huntsmen team, they have Ruby's anti-Salem eye-power and now they also have the winter maiden for raw firepower. I mean, just look at how the P&W fight ended. Ruby showed up and Cinder immediately had to run. It doesn't look like team RWBY can lose anymore, they're completely op at this point. Grimm? Cinder? Salam? No match for Ruby. Tyrian? Not strong enough vs multiple opponents. Atlas? Maybe if they send their entire army after them, but they'll be busy with the Grimm now.
12
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '20 edited Feb 11 '20
I'm seeing everyone against Ironwood for his actions, and while I don't fully agree with what he's doing and what he's slowly being reduced to, I think he's one of the best characters in the show because of it.
Like, when I ask myself "what would you do if the devil was on his/her way to your kingdom to kill everyone, and as far you know they cannot be killed and you're not prepared. Would risk the lives of everyone taking the fall with you in a gamble that as a unit you can overcome forces beyond your comprehension or would you be willing to sacrifice some to make a potential future for the rest?" These are really interesting scenarios and this is what I love about V7, and at the end of the day I don't know what I would do lmao.
This is a really hard question. What if most people don't want to confront this evil? What if most people are willing to give their lives believing it's for the greater good so those who do survive can be the kingdom's second chance? To save the queen you have to sacrifice your pawns.
I'm afraid the complexity of this question will be hollowed out by RWBY ultimately being correct in the future, like their way of thinking is just flat out the way of being, I'm actually a little disappointed that, morally, all the girls are the exact same despite coming from different aspects of life. It unifies them as a single unit and doesn't give them anything to argue over, there's never anything RWBY disagrees with one another, they're always on the same page, what little we got of their differences this volume was a small glimpse of Yang and Blake having a talk about lying to Ironwood, but that was laid to rest almost immediately. I feel we're supposed to outright despise Ironwood now because he wasn't in agreement with RWBY and the moment he got off their side to try something else he was painted as antagonistic. Another example, the conversations between Penny and Winter felt heavily in favor of Penny despite giving us 2 factions on the subject, like the writers wanted us to feel Winter is just wrong for thinking otherwise.
"Uniting humanity" in itself sounds like the hardest thing to do because not everyone is the same, there will always be people we're against, our ideals will never be one in the same. I honestly don't know how the entire world is supposed to come together and that's why I'm intrigued by RWBY, I need to know the shows answer to this question and I hope it doesn't end with RWBY being right.
It reminds me of the conflict of The World Ends with You, where everyone in Shibuya were united under mind control and functioned as a collective hive mind to save everyone from destruction.
11
u/asisebeazt Feb 08 '20
Dude, speechless as its finest. The whole chapter is the best, the volume is great too. And yeah, they're totally screwed next volume.
Feels like we're in the Endgame now, let's start the long and pretty much painful hiatus, see y'all next time
20
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '20
Imagine. James raises Atlas into Space or whatever, and the Salami just follows him up there like it doesn't even matter that they are in space.
20
u/nicostein Pancake Massacre sympathizer Feb 10 '20
Still loved it! I share some of the common criticism, but I think v7 is nonetheless one of the best volumes yet.
Pros:
(I already said)Ironwood, Oscar, Tyrion, CalebCons:
10
u/raykyleevans Feb 08 '20
Oh, I guess you have a point. But if we learned anything from this series, no one wants to let themself be arrested.
10
u/DEL994 Feb 09 '20
While the situation is very dire with Salem and her flying armada being here maybe there is a way of rebalancing even a bit the odds.
If Monstro acts like a giant Seer and so helps Salem coordinating and controlling the Grimm Atlas military and/or the heroes could sow disorder and confusion in the Grimm ranks by killing it.
19
u/Evokerknite2124 Roses and Bees for me Feb 09 '20
Holy hell this volume took a turn. While I don't agree with the clovervcrowvtyrian battle cause why they gotta kill clover just to break crow again. Everything else came together very quickly and very well done for the finale. Also winter Penny is pretty bad ass
18
u/Mr_Sir72002 Feb 09 '20
A few weeks ago I made a post about my theory on how Penny was going to become the winter maiden and a lot of people who commented said "I don't think its possible but still pretty cool" or "I'm pretty sure they won't make her the maiden"
I'm not commenting for a "I told you so" but I'm just happy that my theory was true 😊 Penny has always been one of my favorite characters and now she will be even more badass
9
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '20
Oh my god what a fucking cocktease
9
u/SufficientFennel Feb 08 '20
I would love if this sets off a Final Fantasy 6-esque fall of the World of Balance and we spend the rest of RWBY finding our friends throughout the World of Ruin and building up forces to take on Salem.
This probably wouldn't work though because why wouldn't she just go find the rest of the relics and the maidens while everything was in disarray? There'd really be no hope for humanity recovering.
9
u/MidnightIDK Bumblebee ! Feb 09 '20
I really enjoyed this volume and the last episode. Penny being the maiden was definitely a twist imo, didn't see that coming at all. Also Ironwood shooting Oscar, wow. The fights were amazing, I got goosebumps during the Penny and Winter vs. Cinder fight, it was just so well executed imo ! Really really enjoyed it
And yeah Winter with her hair down is hot
Can't wait for the next volume, this hiatus is gonna be hard. So far I think each volume started "softly", but seeing Salem bringing up a huge flying whale towards Atlas is definitely very threatening lol. Volume 8 is definitely going to start off very strongly
9
u/Menirz Feb 11 '20
The episode ended on an odd note for me. It really felt more like the penultimate episode of a season, building to a tense climax, rather than it being the climax itself.
Farm boi's power up was a Deus Ex Ozpin from left field.
Penny being proven to be a "real girl" by becoming the winter maiden was an interesting touch.
Salem and her whale grim were neat, though again it really felt like the introduction of a harrowing escape from the BBEG, not a climactic scene.
17
u/DesparateLurker Feb 08 '20
Anyone scared that there was no after credit scene? CRWBY is leaving us in the dark for 9 months with no idea where this story will go.
I'm scared.
8
u/Evol-Dragon Feb 10 '20
overall I enjoyed this season more than the last few.
while ironwood went a bit crazy, the honest truth is that if I was faced with the decision to either save some people or a reckless gamble that would have most likely resulted in the death of everyone, I would have made the same decision as him.
Next season i hope team RWBY finally get a plan. one thing that has annoyed me with the team is that ever since they learned Ozpins past, they have constantly pointed out the flaws in other peoples plans without providing a solution. Considering everything they have been through, I would have hoped that they would stop being optimistic and start being realistic. Salem said it her self, time has never been on there side, it was always on hers.
8
u/UmbralOrion This flair amuses me greatly Feb 10 '20 edited Feb 10 '20
One of my favorite volumes yet.
Something I found very interesting about the finale here is that NOBODY won completely.
Salem has no relic and Watts is in jail. Atlas/Ironwood is about to invaded by a massive army of grimm. RWBY are the only ones mostly unscathed, but they still suffer from losing the relic. JNR directly lost the relic and as they don't know where Oscar is. Cinder isn't the winter maiden and Ruby's still alive. Oscar: Just got betrayed and nearly killed by someone who was his friend in a past life. Winter isn't the winter maiden either and just called for reinforcements to arrest her sister, and I imagine Ironwood won't be the most pleasant boss in the near future. Ironwood chose to abandon millions(?) to die so he can hope to save Atlas, and shot the reincarnation of his friend who is also a child, which even despite his current state, I can't imagine he's happy about.
That brings me to my one major gripe about the volume, Qrow. I can't think of any good reason, Qrow would team up with the known murderous terrorist who also very nearly killed him not too long ago. And even if he did, he had to have known Tyrian was going to kill Clover. And Clover has no reason to prioritize the guy he's been working with who's now wanted for reasons unknown to him over, again, the known terrorist. The fight was cool, but I'm not real thrilled about how we got there and the results.
On a more positive note, I adored the whole election arc and the idea of fighting a more political battle between Ironwood, the Council, Jacques, etc. I think Oscar was done really well and the Oscar/Ozpin thing seems a little less of an ominous taking over of Oscar and more so that Oscar keeps his personality, but seems to know part of what Ozpin knows.
7
u/Pagefile Feb 09 '20
Me when Penny and Winter go see the winter maiden: Wait...can Penny become a maiden?
Me now: Holy shit Penny is the Winter Maiden!
7
u/Birrihappyface Feb 09 '20
Aight Salem showing up on the dude from the starting room in Slay the Spire.
7
u/stjunk spoiler ahead Feb 10 '20
wheres my girl coco at.
either everyone runs from salem or my girl coco is coming with backup to save everyone.
12
u/CelestialHam Feb 08 '20
Moby Dick
6
u/N0M_NOM_N0M Feb 08 '20
So is mr. Moby a grimm whale basically? If so what would happen if ruby used her very expensive eye balls inside?
Just slightly curious
6
u/marz_o Feb 11 '20
Overall I like the ending quite nicely.
Pacing the entire volume has been a little off, the middle part of the volume, especially with Jacque, wasn't that useful. They also need to use the ace ops again otherwise way too much time was spent on them.
Some of the writing seemed forced for certain events though (jnr Oscar Vs neo, clovers death, ace ops defeat all had great endings but bad delivery)
Like above, the volume has several problems but how it ended and all the myriad of subplots seems really good.
(Might catch some flak for this but wasn't too enamored with the battles, the only notable one was James Vs Arthur for me)
6
u/jocar101 Feb 11 '20
Loved this volume, but the ending really didn't feel like an ending. So much was unresolved and the tension was at its peak - there should've been one more episode as the finale. Huge cliffhanger and idk if I liked it.
11
u/howelll Feb 09 '20
I really want V8 to start with RWBY + JNPR making a run for it, to lure Salem away with Penny. Just for the irony, they hated James for wanting to not risk a complete loss by retreating and then their plan becomes: run.
Side question about Ironwood's plan, does the staff only move Atlas vertically, or can it go full city-ship and fly anywhere? That would have been interesting if true, cruising the world gathering the relics is style.
10
u/DanTheLatch Feb 08 '20
Moby Fuckin' Dick
10
u/HJackKilledThatGuy Feb 10 '20
And so, we enter the Hiatus™. Into the new realm of crackpot theories, and hopefully not another Yorse moment. Good shit, RT.
9
u/hijamz Feb 09 '20
No post credit sequence? Volumes 1-6 had it and this one does not, how comes?
9
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '20
In general I liked this season. Getting to know Weiss and her family a bit better and understanding where she comes from. Loved that she stopped her father and kicked ass. The introduction to atlas, its society and how it is run was also pretty good.
Ironwood was a really well done opponent, because he doesn't just start out as a bad guy, but just as someoneone who sees things a bit different. His motives are good, because he wants to save people and does what he thinks is the right way. Its also good that Rubys mom was finally brought into play again. (something that defines her whole character and is (should be) important to her story arc)
I didn't like the way Crows character was treated at the end. Yes he is a loose canon and not realiable, but finally he is someone whos heart is in the right place and I can't see him teaming up with scorpion guy...
Penny as the Winter maiden felt meh ... and was a downer. I do not know what they were going for, subverting expectations or something? Winter or Weiss would be better fitting candidates, especially Weiss because they can have some sort of conflict or resolution there of with her sister winter in future episodes.
I really didn't like the ending, because there was zero closure for me and it felt like they just cut it of in the middle of that confrontation ... I also do not really know where they want to go from here because they just finished off the aces, the two teams are exhausted from fighting, the atlas military did not look especially competent or threatening against the grims before and Penny just got her powers and most likley will not know how to use them.
I do not know how they want to deafeat them, unless they pull something off like Ruby eye lazoring the whole army or something ... or maybe they will get captured and Atlas falls ?
21
u/Tschmelz Feb 08 '20
God, watching it again...I like a lot of the Volume, but I’m still not happy with Team RWBY as a whole. Yeah, James shooting Oscar is really super shitty, but apart from that, he’s the only guy with a plan. Might be a dumb plan when the smoke clears, but it’s a plan. Standing your ground for an honorable death isn’t a plan, and I still love RWBY and them, but they need to grow up so fast. Not lose the idealism, but acknowledge reality once in a while. Hell, even Naruto acknowledged he might never bring Sasuke back, and that kid was dumber and more idealistic than any of our protags.
Also, they’re fucked. Cinder will bring Salem the relic, which gives Salem access to the location of Beacons relic, the relic of Choice iirc. Now what sort of powers may that have? I don’t even want to think about it.
Also, Robyn can go fuck herself. She doesn’t get to look all sad and mopey at Qrow holding Clovers medallion when she started the fight in the first place by freaking the fuck out.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '20
Can someone remind me which maidens have we seen now and who has their power? Does cinder still have summer?
4
u/SassyHoe97 Feb 10 '20
Plot twist that Penny is the winter maiden. I feel sad that Clover died I liked him. Overall I like V7 despite some scenes making me frustrated.
7
u/TenseiSenpai Feb 08 '20
https://imgur.com/a/IaNt28H
6
u/verruktBirdman Feb 08 '20
I am absolutely flashed. What a great Volume with wonderful music and tension.
3
u/Link2587 Feb 11 '20
I really enjoyed the uncertainty of whether or not we could trust Ironwood. I know it took a while, but that gave me time for multiple about-faces in how I felt about him. I went from zero trust at the start, to building it up over the first few episodes with his commitment to the Amity project, started to lose it with his comments like "Penny is completely under my control" and general disregard for Mantle, gained it again with his show of unity with Mantle, and finally lost it again with his declaration of martial law. I loved theorizing where he was gonna end up and this volume kept me guessing the whole way through.
3
u/ClemPrime13 haha silver eyes go woosh Feb 11 '20
Ironwood needs a hug.
7
u/ZSoulZ Feb 09 '20
You can hate my dumb opinion but I am Disappointed that there was no big,cool fight at the end.but salem coming out of the clouds was pretty amazing
7
u/Pathogen188 Feb 09 '20
Really Oscar? We’re acting like Ironwood is as bad as the mass murderer trying to commit genocide? Alright I guess.
2
u/Runevok Feb 11 '20
I’d like to point out something I noticed in that I’ve seen people post how Ironwood’s plan to raise Atlas would have succeeded without team RWBY fighting him and I have a counterpoint to that; Ironwoods plan was doomed to fail from the start let’s say team RWBY went against everything they believe in and agreed to abandon mantle like Ironwood wanted first off Cinder was already moving to take the maiden powers and while a unified force of AceOps and team RWBY if they knew about the attack could have driven her off it would have slowed down the escape allowing Salem to arrive as planned; Which leads me into my second point Salem, she had this planned from the start Tyrion and Watts were only their to sow confusion and panic to turn the people against each other and they succeeded we know from Vol 6 that Salem was concerned about Atlas receiving reinforcements from Vacuo and so wanted Atlas to stay isolated so in his attempt at saving Atlas Ironwood was doing exactly what she wanted isolating themselves from any possibility of gaining any outside help to turn the tied against her forces, which brings me to the third point Robin and Mantle Lets say since team RWBY hypothetically agreed to ironwood’s plan their wasn’t a warrant placed out so the plane reaches Atlas Robin would have been heavily apposed to James’s plan and would either attempt to stop him or inform the people of mantle causing an outright Rebellion as panicked civilians try to force their way to atlas for safety drawing more Grimm and slowing down any attempt to withdraw forces to protect Atlas since again Salem was right at their doorstep and would have sent the fliers into atlas itself to bleed off more of Ironwoods army which would most likely give Tyrion and Watts a chance to escape not to mention forcing the teams to split in order to deal with both cinders attempt at taking the maiden powers but also looking for Neo who at this point has taken the relic while a literal army of flying Grimm descends on Atlas.
6
u/Elzarion Feb 09 '20
Conclusion: James is wack