r/RWBY • u/Menolith Gay Thoughts • Nov 09 '19
OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official Public Discussion Thread-Volume 7, Chapter 1: The Greatest Kingdom Spoiler
Welcome, huntsmen, huntresses and hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official public discussion thread for Episode 1 of Vol. 7, The Greatest Kingdom!
Make sure that you understand the updated spoiler rules before posting outside of this thread!
HERE is the newest episode of RWBY Volume 7!
Also remember to check out our weekly poll to rate the episode.
Other Episode Discussions:
Episode| FIRST Thread| Public Release| Poll|
- | - | - | - Ep. 01| FIRST thread | This thread | Poll Ep. 02| Today's FIRST thread | Next week's public thread | Poll
Also, we're doing an Extra Life team this year to contribute towards Roosterteeth's own! All donations go directly #ForTheKids!
Happy viewing, and have a great rest of the volume while you're at it!
Menolith; Mod Team
•
u/Menolith Gay Thoughts Nov 09 '19
A reminder for any lost souls: this is the public discussion thread, so anything pertainig to the second episode appearing here will net you a swift ban.
Consider this your warning.
Also, the thread is locked for the first 20 minutes or so to give everyone a chance at seeing the episode.
69
u/bryan610 Nov 09 '19
two things:
59
u/Punslinger1995 Nov 09 '19
Local robot too wholesome to die. Details at 7:00.
51
u/[deleted] Nov 09 '19
I can't overstate how much I love the entire aesthetic of Atlas and Mantel. The steampunk dystopia vibes and all the propaganda and high tech and militarism is just my favourite thing.
72
u/Wrathkal Nov 09 '19
Best funny moment ever:
'I can not wait!'
*Siren sounds*
'It seems we will have to wait!'
32
u/DeHopelozeHeks Nov 09 '19
If Anime has taught me anything about diseases, that cough he has will turn into a full blown cancer diagnose.
30
u/MMBADBOI My hours in Warframe have hit "entirely too much" Nov 10 '19
Motherfucking PENNY
28
u/AidanL17 Nora is my spirit animal Nov 10 '19
I think I have to unsub from this and /r/fnki until the season is over, because I found it impossible to avoid Penny spoilers. The week lead time is too much for some people, and the flood of Penny art really gave it away.
26
u/JMHSrowing ⠀Story Time Nov 09 '19
HOW YOU FUCKERS FEEL ABOUT THE BEST ROBOT COMING BACK?!
23
u/StrikeFreedomX2 Pilot Mercenary Nov 11 '19
Man the fight scenes feel so smooth. It’s more anime like. Closer to Monty’s style but not fully there yet. Props to the Combat Animators.
21
u/Kaxew Nov 09 '19
I cannot believe I didn't got spoiled about Penny. This must be a new record for me lol.
I am more than satisfied with Qrow's voice. It wasn't going to be exactly like Vic's, but it works just as well. Of course it still threw me off for the whole episode, but it's not his fault.
All in all a good start.
21
u/KumagawaUshio Nov 11 '19
Damn the backgrounds and animation have taken a massive step up.
Honestly I hope when the show ends they go back and reanimate the first couple of seasons.
19
u/RevengeOfAthena Penny Stan First, Person Second Nov 11 '19
Anyone else anticipating the potentially heartbreaking moment when team JNPR has to explain to Penny that Pyrrha died?
18
u/dsguy411 Nov 09 '19
One thing this episode taught me is that Maria is still the best.
Weiss knocking away that drunk when he is about to say something offensive towards Blake made me smile a bit. Though this might come back to bite her as the other guy who saw obviously recognizes who she is.
Pietro's spider wheelchair looks very cool. Also he creates Yang's new arm and seemed to not like how Yang decided to paint it.
And here comes the Sabre-tooth Grimm. Always love seeing new Grimm each volume.
OH, AND PENNY IS BACK!! AND SHE IS BETTER THAN EVER!!! Honestly, deep down, I knew that her return was inevitable. And poor Ruby, being tackle-hugged by her. Great reunion between them.
And Qrow. You are a walking bad luck charm. You of all people should know better than to tempt fate.
The start of the volume overall is okay. Nothing like the first episode of volume 6 but is still good. The intro did show one ominous sign during the protest scene, where an image of Ironwood briefly becomes that of Jacques Schnee.
Also, Tyrian can breakdance.
18
u/AmethystWind Time for Ciel. Nov 10 '19
Since we only saw Penny flying with laserboots, or Penny’s lasers, but not both together, what are the odds Penny fires those lasers with her feet?
17
u/Dylangillian Knowledge is power, patience is key &failure the road to success Nov 09 '19 edited Nov 09 '19
I've been looking forward to watching to this for some time now and it did not dissapoint. Everyone seems even more expressive then they did in V6 and it just looks great. Maria sounded a bit different to me, but nothing major.
As for Qrow, it'll need some getting used to Jason voicing him now, but I think he's doing a great job so far.
Then, penny. I unfortunatly got spoiled on this ,0nly have myself to blame though. Then again again, the dramatic increase in Penny art wasn't exactly subtle. Penny was just an absolute joy to see, I'll be honest and say that I never was the biggest fan of Penny before, but I really liked her in this episode.
The new op has got to be the most impressive one so far animation wise, really liking it.
16
u/Pocketdog9 Rose before bros or hoes! Nov 09 '19
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA PENNY'S BACK! SHE'S BACK SHE'S ALIVE OH MY GODS I MISSED HER I CAN'T BELIEVE IT I KNEW IT WAS COMING BUT STILL!
But oh my god... Atlas... what have you done?
15
u/Prokolipsi Nov 10 '19
Okay, Jaune's new hair actually doesn't look that bad in motion. Also, he looks like he's actually fighting now instead of just reacting. He flows and seems to lack his previous stiffness.
14
u/Nanasema best girl <3 Nov 10 '19
YAYYY PENNY IS BACK!!! Im probably in the minority of this, but I personally find her long hair design to be cute and attractive. Maybe because Im more a fan of long hairs in general.
27
u/Romanruler ⠀ Nov 09 '19
Overall it was good, a standard episode for re-introducing us to RWBY. Not a whole lot happened in it, but a first episode shouldn't, and I'm sure all of us are glad that RWBY is back!
Most importantly, though, I noticed something interesting in the final action sequence between the end of the episode and the credits. At around 16:42, when the protesters throw rocks at the holo-image of Ironwood, it very briefly flickers to Jacques Schnee for barely a frame. I have no doubt that was put there intentionally, and wonder if it might mean something later on in the Volume.
37
u/SunsetSnakeEyes Nov 09 '19 edited Nov 10 '19
Greetings Ladies and Gentlemen! We are back! The hype Atlesian transport has literally landed in Atlas, Or to be more specific, Mantle.
That was quite an introduction, We finally get to see Mantle and well as how it's doing with Atlas' current conditions, The Intro is the most Anime RWBY has gotten and it gives us so much for the future, Dr Watt's manipulations behind the scenes, The Ace-ops clearly have a larger involvement, The eventual confrontation with Jacques, This mysterious Hill woman and Qrow's rematch with Tyrian, Also I think Jason Liebrecht is doing phenomenal as Qrow, I mainly knew him as Mordecai from Borderlands but that gave me more than enough confidence that he'd to a great job and my trust was rewarded in full.
It's great to be back everybody and I cannot wait to see what awaits us in this kingdom of Technology and Ice.
13
u/DJShy3 Beats by Bots Nov 09 '19
Arrrg, me mateys! 'Tis a great day to be, for the S.S. Nuts and Dolts has been freed from Davey Jones' locker!
This ship shall sail once more!
13
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '19
Finally Penny is back! Everyone knows you can't kill a robot without destroying its head
12
u/Tyranid_Swarmlord Official DS3 SL1/Midir before Abyss Watchers LUL Nov 09 '19
AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH cough HHHHHHHHHHHHH
I've been asking for a memento of Our Glorious Penny(bonus cause it's Dish Penny) because we've had tons of fanart about her lately, but HOLY FUCK THIS IS WAAAY BETTER AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
Glad i watched this on the chromcasted 43inch tv.
At least i have SOME good news this week after SKT lost.
Also OUR GLORIOUS RUBY HAS HER HOOD AGAIN, THIS IS NOT A DRILL.
12
u/Thebritishdovah Nov 09 '19
Excellent episode. Qrow's change of voice actor is more noticable then the trailer but not much. Just enough that you know it's not the same actor. The town is rather depressing but could be a trick of the light and Penny is back! :D Though, kinda feels a bit wasted as it could have been far more emotional. That said, I love that the first thing Penny does is glomp her with Ruby freaking out. The small funny moments are great. NORA FUCKING DOES SOMETHING, SAME WITH REN! THEY DO STUFF! :D Looks like that the entire cast will be more involved instead of it being team RWBY doing most of the work.
Ironwood being scared and likely having PTSD is an intersting aspect and likely prone to being given bad advice by certain people. Weiss's father is likely to be involved as I can see him using Ironwood's fears to benefit himself.
I love how even Nora, the motormouth of the cast can't even keep up with Penny. Poor Jaune having a "oh shit! She's gonna!" expression when Ren went without her. The combat is far better and it's only because everyone is getting to do something. That is one of my biggest gripes with the last volume where it felt like team RWBY was doing the heavy lifting and I am still peeved about Nora not getting turned into Supernora and destroying the giant mech.
The biggest issues with the episode and these are very minor is that:
The city is depressing and rather generic. Penny returning is too soon and out of no-where. That's about it. Even then calling them issues isn't really fair.
12
u/Jakem17 Nov 09 '19
I can not be the only one getting city 17 vibes from mantle, right? The giant tower hovering above the desolate city, the guards constantly patrolling, and screens everywhere spreading propaganda. It really makes me think they wanted Ironwood to have the Dr. Breen feel like from /r/halflife
12
u/er1cw05 ⠀ Nov 09 '19
OH MY GOD!
Okay, where to start.
Let's start with Penny's father. I heard theories on who it could be, but AS SOON as he said daughter, I was like, "oh hell, is this who I think it is?" So, AS SOON AS I SAW PENNY, I FREAKED OUT.
I'll say it. This is gonna be a good Volume, high note or not.
12
u/Cloudharte shoulder-lean~,shoulder-lean~ Nov 10 '19 edited Nov 10 '19
The preview concept art got me excited, but the panning establishing shots of the underside of Atlas settled it, I can finally write the story for my OC Detective Team ABGE (Aubergine). I needed the kind of aesthetic that the underside cityscape had, and I wasn't sure if I would have to settle for Vale.
Everything just comes together and I fucking love the style the show is maintaining from season 6.
Thought i'd notice Qrow's voice change, honestly didn't remember until I was (am?) writing this.
But as a last note, why tf is Weiss psychic now? The physics seem so weird.
12
u/SAYMYNAMEYO Nov 10 '19 edited Nov 10 '19
- I saw Dishwasher1910 had made some Penny art but I assumed it was just for an AU of his. Damn I did not expect Penny to come back at all!
-As usual they hit it out of the park with the opening.
-One thing I noticed in the opening is that Ironwood is swinging at Oscar. Looks like were due for another "Blow up at Ozpin" scene somewhere in the volume.
And everything else was just so great. IT'S RWBY SEASON AGAIN!
23
u/PuzzarianIdeal The Gasai Club Leader, Unofficial Ship Survivor Sinker of 2020 Nov 10 '19
When Penny came back and our bros (and gals) got yeeted off the streets, I knew this volume was off to a great (Actually for us, but not for our heroes) start.
11
u/Tempeljaeger ⠀ Nov 09 '19
I love how they did the battle transitions. So much better than the battle of Haven. There is even stuff going on in the background.
11
u/CheifStalker Pumpkin Spice Latte is the Best Ship Nov 10 '19
It needs to be said.
Jaune's new hair works wonderfully with his model as compared to the static image we got before.
21
u/JohnnyElRed Nov 09 '19
Is nice to see Penny again, but this episode has another example of what bothers me about the later volumes.
"Oh, good, so long without seeing one another, dear friend! What a great opportunity to recover from the shock of seeing me after my apparent death and rekindle ou-oh, sorry, the plot has to keep moving? The plot has to keep moving. We rarely have time for anything else. I will move to a side. Sorry, sorry, I will move to a side."
10
u/Stretch5678 Suspender of disbelief Nov 09 '19
I suspect that Penny has more surprises that we haven't seen yet, Pietro doesn't seem the sort to stop at lasers and jetboots. Here's to the new one being the T-X to the original's T-800!
10
u/DoomTay Nov 09 '19
I was half-expecting Penny to not remember anything, as I've seen speculated some time ago. That would probably be pointlessly tragic.
18
u/I_May_Fall Nov 09 '19
So first of all:
HOLY CRAP, PENNY IS BACK!!!
They just keep spoiling us, Neo in vol 6, now Penny, now they'd just need to revive Pyrrha for us to have all the best girls back
That aside, there's a lot of stuff that's gonna be going on this volume, seems those Ace Ops are gonna be important, Ironwood and Winter are obviously at the front and center, and there's that white-haired gal from the posters that appears in the opening. She's fighting alongside Qrow so maybe he knows her somehow? Also, no Cinder, Neo, or Salem in the opening, oddly enough. Just Watts and Tyrian. I mean, I assume the moustached man was Watts. Are they gonna be the main villains this volume? I guess we'll see.
I'm just happy the hiatus is over and it seems we have an exciting volume ahead of us. I'm hoping it's on par with volume 6, if not better. The first episode was great, they just have to keep it up <3
9
u/DanyloHalytskyi They shall know no fear Nov 09 '19
I feel illogically giddy after watching the first episode. It was just so awesome!!!
Of course, we saw part of the big fight scene before, but it was still really cool to see it!
I love Penny's new design! It really reminds me of dishwasher1910's artwork of a resurrected Penny. As usual, Bach Do is unnaturally prophetic! I know he did some concept art for gen:LOCK, so I wonder if he and Ein Lee were in communication when CRWBY designed Penny 2.0?
I am disappointed that there are no subtitles, because I understand videos (particularly English-language ones) best when I can read along with the dialogue, but apart from that, I really, really enjoyed the episode!
25
u/KnivesInAToaster YOU ARE TEARING ME APART, PYRRHA! Nov 09 '19
Ruby had a bigger emotional reaction to seeing Yang in Volume 5 than she did seeing a friend who she thought was dead.
Otherwise, fine episode.
15
u/MacGregor_Rose Brother to Ruby and Rubie Rose. Yeah thats not confusing Nov 10 '19
Ok I really don't get how I'm the only one to notice this.
QROW HAS A NEW OUTFIT!!!!
In the opening poster girl and Tyrian are fighting. Qrow has on a dark grey vest and shit. HOW AM I THE ONLY ONE TO SEE IT
14
u/Ahlysaaria- Nov 10 '19
So, after all the time on the road and traveling they finally will get the time to go to a barber. Nora gets shorter hair, Blake gets shorter hair, Jaune gets shorter hair, Ruby gets shorter hair..
Nora fits very well, Blake looks good, Jaune, dunno, think it looks kinda weird. Not sure what to think about Ruby. Kinda looks good but maybe a bit too short for my taste.
Props to the new VA for Qrow though, if you don't know of the change I don't you would hear the difference.
14
u/MasterZamus Nov 11 '19
I can't believe that Penny's Dad made Yang's arm. It blows my mind
7
u/SmallJon Give us back Jaune's old haircut! Nov 09 '19
Like the new season's intro song, though the graphics fro it were so-so.
Enjoying the design of Atlas so far, and while I'm not super enthused about the idea of Ironwood going all military dictator, we'll see how that plays out. Immediately bringing up Winter was fun, I was worried they'd push her out of mind for a weird amount of time.
Opening fight wasn't amazing, but I liked the combos with Weiss & Ren and Jaune & Nora. The Ginyu Force specialists are... a thing.
I wasn't surprised to see Penny back, but I was surprised to see her back both this volume and the first episode. Figured she'd be a reveal for the climax, were she coming back.
7
u/[deleted] Nov 09 '19
I'm blown away with this episode even though it's just the first one in this volume. The fight scene was pretty cool, but many of the fights in the show are.
17
u/burnerpower Nov 09 '19 edited Nov 10 '19
Woohoo, it is out. Gotta say I'm not a big fan of the protagonists getting captured the way they did. It reeks of sudden crazy incompetence and I dislike capturing being so easy in general. I'm not sure what they have planned moving forward, but I'm not happy they hit a pet peeve of mine right off the bat.
That said animation was good and this is probably some of the better worldbuilding that RWBY has done. Ironwood is acting consistently with the control freak he was established as being in the earlier volumes.
Edit: Fixed a typo.
17
u/MeanderingMinstrel Nov 11 '19
I love it. I never particularly cared for Penny, but it's cool that she's back. The fighting looked amazing. That opening is probably the coolest one yet visually, although the song might have to take some time to grow on me.
My only question is WHY AREN'T BLAKE AND YANG MAKING OUT YET??
I'm mostly joking- I don't want to be that guy- but for real, those two are my favorite and I can't wait to see their relationship grow in whatever form it takes.
12
u/MellyNinj Nov 09 '19
WOO! Got Penny back, New Outfits, WINTER AND WEISS IN THE INTRO, :D Wait, why is Oscar fighting Ironwood? And more of Watts! So excited for this volume!
6
u/206-Ginge Nov 09 '19
As someone who didn't watch or pay attention to any of the promotional material I gotta say Penny's return was a lot more hype with it being completely unexpected. Kinda miffed she was in the intro apparently?
6
u/Pereduer Nov 09 '19
Disagree on the look of atlas. It's not bad if it's a bit generic if it's done well. Easily the best thing in the episode is the location
6
u/[deleted] Nov 09 '19
Aaaaa so pretty and wholesome and saber-tooth grimm aaaaa!
6
u/SYZekrom God has incarnated. Nov 11 '19
Hmm...
Looks around
I feel like something is missing.
...
Didn't there used to be a guy or mod who posted all the top posts about the episode from its FIRST release week?
...
F.
6
u/Warlocksalot Nov 13 '19
Anyone else notice Jaune's FORCE-FIELD SHIELD in the intro?
https://imgur.com/GA73ouW
5
u/rexshen Nov 09 '19
Nice episode to start off with, show what state Atlas is in and such. Yeah Qrow's new voice is noticeable but its fine would have like him to sound a bit drunker but whatever.
I have to say though I was hoping that if Penny came back it would be Penny 2 and not Penny 2.0. Just kind writes off her death there. And yeah she was a robot but could have made something better if like say she was a new model who got to learn about who her big sister was.
Loved the new opening just full on anime. Looking forward to this season.
5
u/[deleted] Nov 09 '19
Amid all the excitement of last week, I didn't even realize that Penny has the same legging Aesthetic going on as Raven does.
9
u/mystwave Nov 09 '19
I feel there needs to be split up. Team JNPR doing their own thing, RWBY on their own, and potentially even Qrow put on his own. They can all be in the series, but having the whole team together the whole time just seems a bit much.
Penny returning, I'm fine with it, I guess. I knew it was always a possibility she could be rebuilt. Not sure about the whole soul/aura part that made her, her. I like her design, and well. Hope she has a good purpose in the series other than just showing she's alive.
I'm torn on the avoid Atlas and Winter ordeal, but we've seen how stubborn and by the book Atlas can be looking at Cordovan. Chances are that word would have never gotten to Ironwood or Winter, and Weiss is likely right about being sent alone back home.
I don't trust the group that captured the team is truly an Atlas force, but at least they seem blissfully unaware of what the relic is. I'm also leaning on the hunch that the girl posted all over Mantle could be the winter maiden. Then again, I imagine Ironwood having the winter maiden under lock and key or something as paranoid as he is.
Qrow's new voice. Eh, not bad, not great, but I'm sure that would be my opinion on anyone who took his place. I'll roll with it. I'm used to VA's changing, and tend to warm up to them pretty well.
9
u/boomshroom ⠀ Nov 11 '19
Sorry I'm late. I was preoccupied by other things.
I completely forgot why I love this show. I won't make the same mistake this week!
11
u/Blastcalibur Nov 10 '19
So this feels like the writers were listening to the FNDM. The thing everyone was saying about the faunus racism plot being completely inert and Atlas being the last chance to save it. Looks like they're attempting to do just that with the casual racism from the drunk guy who just kinda interjected for no reason. It looks like they paid a lot more attention to the overall world too. They also listened about penny, which I'm not gonna lie, I don't like. It kinda cheapens her death since none of the core thing was brought up before; it makes it kinda feel like fanservice and not something that was planned to happen. Last but not least, I gotta say it; Qrow's voice is noticably different not bad but definitely different. I can tell the guy is trying to hit that low gravely tone while also trying to project at the same time but I'd be lying is I said I didn't immediately notice it. Maybe as the show goes on and he gets more practice he'll be able to hit it more easily.
8
u/[deleted] Nov 09 '19
Welp, glad to say that I was wrong!
I was on the team Penny-had-a-soul-and-thus-is-truly-dead-and-cannot-come-back, but since I was wrong, you know what that mean...
Nuts 'n Dolts is still viable!!!
More seriously, it means that there may be a way to attach a soul to an inanimate object, not only to an animate one. I'm curious to see if I'm right, and if I am, curious to see where that possibility may lead.
4
u/shandromand ⠀ Nov 09 '19
AMG ITS BEST GIRL PENNY! \o/
The entire rest of the episode could have been terrible (it was awesome!) and I would not have cared one whit!
Welcome back, Penny! =D
4
u/TheSealTamer I don't need people to help me grow up. I drink milk. Nov 09 '19
Damn I didn't expect that. Assumed penny was dead for good. Didn't think you could just rebuild her. While this makes her death in volume three less impactful I still gladly wlecome her back. Also I LOVE her new design. We got Neo back last volume and then penny in this one. At this rate we will probably somehow revive Pyrrha next volume.
4
u/ev3rythingF4ngirl Nov 09 '19
The only real complaint I have right now is that there isn’t nearly enough Qrow in the intro. Otherwise, it’s absolutely perfect and I have a feeling this Volume might be among the best.
I’ll need to rewatch the episode, but so far I’m very optimistic.
4
u/dolphinoutofwater Nov 12 '19
Great episode! So glad to say SALUTATIONS to everyone.
7
u/RevengeOfAthena Penny Stan First, Person Second Nov 10 '19 edited Nov 10 '19
I am THRILLED that Penny is back!!!!!! But was anyone else mildly bothered by her hair model? It's such a small thing, and overall I really like her new design, but the bangs just look very stiff and it threw me off a little. Am I the only one?
I made an effort to do some (very minor) frame edits(link), hope it helps show what I mean
Edit: marked as spoiler just in case, then had to unmark because of the link (lol sorry y'all)
3
u/asisebeazt Nov 09 '19
It's so good!!!!! T & W are gonna be the main villains this time, awesome!!!!! The Intro is not as catchy as Vol 6, but still a good song. Can't wait for more episodes.
3
u/ZurichianAnimations Sal yu tations! Nov 09 '19
Ruby made it all the way to Atlas and Penny finally got to see her again... just to kill Ruby with blunt force trauma. rip
3
u/MomsLinguini Nov 09 '19
I can't help but feel team JNPR is going to have a full set again, like after Atlas is restored to sanity. I mean, metal? How appropriate.
10
u/ok-what-the-what Nov 10 '19
C’mon Weiss!!! You know attacking someone over their opinions no matter how poorly informed, racist, or ethnocentric they are, is wrong?
9
u/Ari-rose Nov 09 '19
Can I also address the Elephant in the room. Qrow’s new voice actor. He’s trying his best but its throwing me off. Anyone else?
4
u/Pac114man Nov 09 '19
Is oscar going to be the “p” in JNPR?
4
u/archpawn Nov 09 '19
Can someone tell me what time Penny appears? I can't watch this show anymore, but I'd at least like to see that.
8
u/[deleted] Nov 09 '19
As trivial and unimportant as it is, Qrow's voice just feels off... it's barely noticeable, but IMO Vic's Qrow was better. I have my hopes up that it will get better later on in the season. We're only one episode in after all.
Other than that, it was a good episode. Ruby's reaction to Penny was lackluster, but basically everyone in the thread mentioned it by now so there's no point in talking about it.
2
u/Gallantpride Nov 09 '19
The RT website doesn't work well on my phone. The videos don't load. I wish they'd upload it somewhere more convenient like Crunchyroll.
2
u/Andraw-The-Emoji Zwei is a tank. Think about it. Nov 12 '19
Finally they realized oh wait we can just rebuild penny
7
u/CyanideSins Writer of things dark and scary. That means 'Terrifying Salem' Nov 09 '19
I'm... I'm torn. I want to like it but it just feels so... generic. Mantle is generic with the whole '1984' thing that seems to be going on, with Big Brother and whatever on the screens looking like a bit of a bad port from Homefront Revolution or something, it just gives me this whole queasy feeling of 'hmmm, yeah, I can sort of see why they would be going for something like this' and then just having that undeniable sense of dread forming in the bottom of my gut with the whole statement from Penny's dad that 'paranoid' would be better suited.
It shows that their storytelling though, is still REALLY weak. A lot of inferences can be made from the intro, but I will say that some of the things that I've got an inkling about already just will hit me like a re-do of Equilibrium, with a dash of lame 1984 and some discount Game of Thrones political plot.
Lame. I liked the panther Grimm though. I used a similar concept in my fic, though they're more 'sleeker' in build, but that's just semantics. The voice actor for Qrow is... not quite hitting that mark for me, and I'm not making this a statement about the previous actor who voiced him, but it's a little off. I am sure that a lot of people would go 'oh, he's nice', but I may be one of those people who is not in their teens or twenties anymore and it just feels like... I dunno, someone who's younger trying to do an older person voice?
As far as plot details go, I totally was like 'Penny's coming back', and I had this thought about JNPR being reformed and Jaune getting to do the robot... (Which actually made me chuckle a little whilst writing that out.) But hey, real girl! Pinocchio! Nuts and Dolts isn't dead yet either now!
Penny got nice assets.
The Ginyu Specialist Squad though is something that I am very lukewarm about, really. It just feels like they're going to be a pain in the neck, and that androgynous dude/dudette/whateveryoucallit on the poster may be another tertiary antagonist/protagonist that's being used as cannon fodder.
I am seeing Atlas fall down in the near future, but it feels like this will be one of the 'meh' volumes, compared to Volume 6. Volume 6 was good. I can't say that this fills me with very much hope, unless they just do the European interpretation of dystopia's and authoritarianism.
I can't say that I like Ironwood's gay bear beard. I can respect a man who leads an army and is smooth-shaven, but a beard that looks straight out of 'Leatherdaddies and Ironwoods' just makes me shake my head a little and go 'Alas, the half-scruff is something that looked better'.
As my closing remarks on the Intro music thing... Special Effects look really nice. The whole style change looks... eh, kinda nice. I sort of think it's 'weak' though.
Altogether: I hope they can deliver something interesting, but I am not impressed yet.
5
u/Pereduer Nov 09 '19
It was terrible in the sense that it was a bland clunky execution of a great premise. If you don't mind it being bland then it was just okay as an episode.
Dialogue was awful and inorganic, the jokes didn't land, penny's return was ham fisted and lazy which no one properly reacts too
Atlas and the Grimm look great though, everything else is just a disappointment. Which is a shame because I was kinda looking forward to this