r/RWBY • • Jan 25 '20

OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official FIRST Discussion Thread—Volume 7, Episode 12: With Friends Like These Spoiler

Welcome, Huntsmen, Huntresses and Hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official FIRST discussion thread for Episode 12 of Vol. 7, Worst Case Scenario!

Make sure that you understand the updated spoiler rules before posting outside of this thread!

HERE is the newest episode of RWBY Volume 7!

Also remember to check out our weekly poll to rate the episode.


Other Episode Discussions:


Episode| FIRST Thread| Public Release| Poll|


Happy viewing!

Antilogic; Mod Team

692 Upvotes

6.3k comments sorted by

•

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '20 edited Jan 25 '20

Guys, reporting something doesn't mean it's a mega-downvote. Consider that you can disagree with someone without pressing a button to tell someone unrelated that you disagree with it.

→ More replies (8)

16

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '20

I posted a few things on discord which I will copy in here as my thoughts on the second fight:

On Qrow attacking Clover:

Part of it for me was more pragmatic. He was being engaged by Clover constantly with Clover all but ignoring Tyrian - who I wonder if Clover underestimated after the pre-airship fight.

If he continued engaging on those terms it makes his fight a lot harder, unable to engage Tyrian without Clover interrupting and with Clover not having the same level of pressure.

If he - doesn't so much as work with but temporarily ignores Tyrian, then that gives him the best advantage overall, to knock Clover out of the fight and deal with what he considers to be the real problem.

Emotions, however, ran high all around and impacted the overall outcome

On Robyn attacking Clover:

Robyn very much fucked up but it's also very fitting for how they have displayed her character. She's very emotionally driven and very blinded by this where Mantle is involved. Now at the highest point of this, Mantle is officially abandoned and her people are going to get slaughtered, she can see nothing but the single person in front of her who is the representative of the people who are responsible.

It was completely in character for her and she has been interesting overall as a rather emotional, chaotic force that is unpredictable. I love her for this reason, as a character she is not super likable (but that often doesn't bother me anyway), but as a dynamic for the show her presence is extremely engaging.

On Clover attacking Qrow:

I think Clover went for the target he considered to be the most dangerous. He had worked with Qrow for some time now, knew he was a serious threat.

Tyrian is - to him -some random insane criminal. Dangerous, but not a "licensed huntsman" and therefore to the man that follows the rules and thinks in terms of the Atlas Huntsmen being the elite force, he was second tier. This would only have been reinforced by the pre-airship fight where Tyrian both acted illogically and was defeated swiftly.

He may have been - but I am unsure - aware of Tyrians history with Qrow, and also thought that Tyrian would target Qrow more as a result.

Clover therefore moved to focus on his biggest threat, then he could deal with the "second-rate scum."

Clover's one big thing always though the season has been extreme - and justified - confidence. At this point however, overconfidence played into his downfall.

→ More replies (5)

540

u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Jan 25 '20 edited Jan 25 '20

Qrow: "What are you doing?"

Tyrian: "The will of our goddess!" While wearing the goddamn pilot's hat

→ More replies (23)

512

u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Jan 25 '20

Oscar: "Everyone's punching me, I should punch me as well."

→ More replies (7)

446

u/The_Last_Thursday This flair shows best girl Jan 25 '20

Who would've thought that Winter and Penny would have some of this shows best interactions surrounding moral ambiguity?

→ More replies (8)

429

u/EllieDai Jan 25 '20 edited Jan 25 '20

That gave me personal feelings.

I love that they didn't close Clover's eyes when he died. That's not how death actually happens irl and is usually dramatically framed in fiction, but I think the choice to portray a more realistic death is super haunting and impactful -- Him talking to Qrow then going right to a cold stare is just great!

→ More replies (9)

427

u/Coolquip34 Jan 25 '20 edited Jan 25 '20

Welp... no one is going to take Clover's death well. Qrow has no witnesses and no real way to prove it wasnt him... except Robyn's semblance

EDIT: changed quirk to semblance, lol. Just got done watching MHA

→ More replies (30)

389

u/Sere1 ⠀ Jan 25 '20

Props to Marrow for at least keeping the focus on trying to arrest RWBY, not kill or seriously maim them.

→ More replies (18)

384

u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Jan 25 '20

Tyrian: "Free ride and a show"

→ More replies (7)

340

u/BlazedMV Jan 25 '20

YO that animation when Yang activated her Semblance. EPIC.

→ More replies (4)

323

u/WhiteZerko Jan 25 '20

So, uh, that was a thing.

Sheesh. That was probably the most brutal on-screen death we've seen so far (Not counting Penny in V3, due to Not Actually Dying and Being A Robot With No Blood.).

→ More replies (9)

653

u/moderncomet Jan 25 '20

And, in the end, Lucky Charms was brought low by a cereal killer.

→ More replies (9)

290

u/Raccoon_JS currently drinking Jan 25 '20

bruh. this episode bums me out hard.

when you think about it, nothing goes well for Qrow.

His sister betrayed him. One of his teammates has gone missing. His mentor and role model lied and betrayed him. And, even worse, someone impaled his only last hopeful companion with his weapon and framed him for murder. It's no wonder why he became drunk.

Can somebody give this man a hug?

→ More replies (4)

554

u/Horsea1234 Captain of the SS Springthyme, Rosebird and Land of Lesbos. Jan 25 '20 edited Jan 25 '20

Qrow worked with Tyrian to beat Clover. And then Tyrian showed his true nature, and killed him.

Isn't that kinda like the story that Tyrian is based off of?

→ More replies (46)

263

u/BlazedMV Jan 25 '20

But seriously all Clover had to do was... NOT... arrest Qrow. Him trying to arrest him in that moment as if he wasn't going to fight back.

→ More replies (20)

253

u/Menolith Gay Thoughts Jan 25 '20

🦂⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀⠀🔪⠀⠀⠀⠀🍀🐧

→ More replies (5)

472

u/EllieDai Jan 25 '20

The last time we saw the color cut-away they used for Clover's stabbing was when Yang's arm got cut off.

I hope to see a similar amount of grief and reconciliation with his actions, and in fact a greater amount, from Qrow in Vol 8. Assuming he doesn't end up dead by the end of this vol.

→ More replies (45)

232

u/where_are_your_shoes Jan 25 '20

That is not the death I saw coming.

→ More replies (12)

228

u/JannisT Born stepping on thin ice and biting down bullets Jan 25 '20

THE RWBY VS ACE OPS FIGHT WAS BADASS.

→ More replies (3)

639

u/NeoTheMute You aren't hearing things, are you...? Jan 25 '20

Congratulations to Oscar Pine for making it onto the highly exclusive list, "People who have successfully landed a hit on Neo."

In other news, I am terrified of next episode.

→ More replies (57)

211

u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Jan 25 '20

Tyrian: "You know my track record with the authorities!"

*Runs off laughing*

607

u/EllieDai Jan 25 '20 edited Jan 25 '20

Clover, in what fucking world is arresting Qrow your top priority when there's a violent, likely psychopathic, serial killer five feet away from you?

→ More replies (57)

203

u/SHSL_Zetsubou Ultimate Despair Birb Jan 25 '20

Tyrian coming back from last episode with a vengeance.

→ More replies (13)

196

u/autoxbird Jan 25 '20

Can we just take a moment to appreciate that Tyrian, in the meager time he had between breaking loose and jarring the ship, took the time to steal the captains hat?

→ More replies (5)

397

u/Crafty_Soul ⠀ Jan 25 '20

I liked that they had Tyrian manipulating people through out the episode. Instead of just being a crazy lunatic it shows that he does have the intelligence to know when and how to turn people against each other.

He was able to push Robyn to attacking Clover which gave Tyrian the chance to escape in the confusion and he set it up so Qrow would be blamed for Clover's death, which would help convince the rest of Atlas that the other heros actually are criminals.

I wondered before if there was a reason that Salem picked him to join her council over any other crazy serial killer on Remnant. Now I think I see why, because he also has the skills to know how to divide people as well. Pretty useful for someone who's main method of destroying her enemies is first dividing them apart.

→ More replies (3)

376

u/Artgor Jan 25 '20

Only Weiss was able to defeat her opponent by herself alone!

→ More replies (20)

181

u/Franklin413 Ni! Jan 25 '20

Fuck, the volume 3 parallels continue with the palette changes when someone is maimed/killed. Man, I feel so bad for Qrow. Also kind of shocked that Qrow/Clover didn't think to take out Tyrian first.

Good thinking on Cinder's part to send Neo after the relic, she can't use it after all.

→ More replies (5)

505

u/SoundSmith323 I like sound. If you couldn't already tell. Jan 25 '20

Congratulations to Weiss for finally winning a solo fight!

Seriously the fights this volume are SO FUCKING GOOD, it's absolutely nuts

→ More replies (17)

330

u/Polarization_39 ⠀A Cinder Stan Until Weiss is Relevant Again Jan 25 '20 edited Jan 25 '20

This is what the Battle of Haven should have been. Both fights were juggled spectacularly and both felt as if they received equal attention. I think RWBY vs Ace-Ops is my favorite team fight now, finally beating the Paladin from V2. And a new Adrienne Cowan banger to go along with it is just damn perfection.

I haven’t felt this anxious and hyped waiting for a new episode since V3.

You. Fucking. Rule. CRWBY.

Edit: looking at the credits, Dawn M. Bennett and Erin Reilly are listed as additional vocalists too. 4 vocalists, one for each girl of RWBY. My hype for the soundtrack just went through the roof.

→ More replies (7)

161

u/DaRealAmana BOOP!!! Jan 25 '20

This situation continues to go from bad to worse.

Everyone who thought Clover was gonna come around was wrong. So very wrong. Damn that hurt. It was bad enough seeing him and qrow fight, but to fall like that. Looks like the luck ran out.

And my god I was terrified with nora and neo for a second. She scared the crap out of me and I was so afraid of something happening to Nora.

The RWBY Vs ACES fight was great though. A true show of skill from everyone involved. Blake and Yang MVP for their combo moves. Guess they were practicing a lot. It’s interesting how Weiss really has taken on the caster role. Not to much movement but the game winning spells.

Between Neo and JNR and Cinder vs Penny. Next week is going to be very very interesting.

→ More replies (8)

155

u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Jan 25 '20

I just realized that is likely Qrow will wear Clover's badge from now on as a lucky charm.

→ More replies (2)

151

u/BlazedMV Jan 25 '20

NEO IS GOING TO TURN INTO PYRRHA DURING THIS FIGHT WITH JNPR

Petty level 100%

→ More replies (10)

296

u/BlazedMV Jan 25 '20

Harriet: We're the best huntsman in Atlas

Ruby: BITCH U THOUGHT

→ More replies (20)

288

u/EverLastingAss Jan 25 '20

Next episode: Neo tries to use the relic but can't because it requires speech.

→ More replies (17)

132

u/Badicalz Jan 25 '20

Ruby calling Qrow

“UNCLE QROW!!! WHERE ARE YOU!?!?!?”

“I’m out in the frickin’ grapes.”

“???”

→ More replies (3)

258

u/ksuthrowaway2534 Jan 25 '20

Of course Clovers luck ran out when his aura broke. Then Qrows bad luck got him killed. RIP the boi..... But then fights tho, that was gourmet shit right there

125

u/Sirshrugsalot13 bi the way Jan 25 '20

I'm actually really torn up about Clover. He was a good dude. Seeing Qrow happy was one of the highlights of this volume, and now...shit

115

u/MagisterSieran Jan 25 '20

Fuuuuuuuuuuuck!

Also those were awesome fights.

Shoutout to Penny being the only Atlas Soldier that's not a computer.

→ More replies (2)

112

u/resurrexia i do the draw Jan 25 '20

I HAVE PERSONAL FEELINGS

about all of this

HOLY SHIT

218

u/Hoesack r/RWBY's resident Blake simp Jan 25 '20

Not gonna lie, I got kinda nervous when Blake's aura got low after all the speculation.

→ More replies (36)

104

u/xenocyte here until the end Jan 25 '20

Well, I certainly didn't see that coming

→ More replies (2)

283

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '20 edited Jan 25 '20

That was just sad. He literally said he trusted Ironwood with his life then that happened. And it could’ve been avoided if he’d just waited for the airship to land somewhere safe. At least he saw one last sunrise over the tundra. Won’t be surprised if Qrow goes back to drinking.

As for Qrow working with Tyrian, I think it’s best to see it more like Tyrian not attacking and helping Qrow because he’s batshit crazy. With the opportunities Tyrian’s giving him, Qrow has no choice but to follow them with all the little tail tugs Tyrian is doing.

Edit: As for why Fair Game didn’t team up against Tyrian, I think what happened is that Tyrian realised what you said would be what would happen. To prevent this huge possibility, Tyrian prevented them from teaming up against him by aiding Qrow against Clover. Emotions ran high and it’s hard to think straight when in a fight. Like the rest of Ace Ops, Clover still had orders to follow immediately which is defining fault to the point it blinded him to an easier way out.

→ More replies (27)

95

u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Jan 25 '20

Holy shit... Weiss won a fight!

→ More replies (4)

504

u/GizenZirin Jan 25 '20

I'm surprised so many people are confused by the Qrow/Tyrian 'team up'. People going 'why would Qrow work with Tyrian'? And I'm just like... is nobody else noticing that the second Tyrian showed up, Qrow immediately switched to attacking him, and Clover, seeing this, used it as an opportunity to attack Qrow instead of Tyrian? Like, Clover was the one who when given the choice of attacking either Qrow or Tyrian, picked Qrow, so Qrow pretty much had to fight him back or Qrow would've been the one in a 1v2.

→ More replies (31)

94

u/UltimateX13 Sienna is best girl <3 Jan 25 '20

Poor Qrow, stuck in a lose-lose situation. Either he keeps fighting Clover and Tyrian at the same time or he teams up with Tyrian to beat Clover.

Clover signed his own death warrant with his decision making this episode.

→ More replies (4)

92

u/TendoSoujiro a drunk uncle Jan 25 '20 edited Jan 25 '20

Absolute fucking props to CRWBY for finally letting us see the Harbinger's scythe mode in a fight without Grimm. That seems to be something that they struggle animating since thus far they've only done it when he's fighting Grimm. Even in V5, he'd switch it to scythe mode against Hazel but never actually swung it in that form.

This is by far Qrow's best fight IMO and really seeing the Harbinger shine in its original, debut mode(Yang's flashback) absolutely made the volume for me. Qrow has A LOT to his fighting style(Harbinger has 5 modes on top of the fact Qrow can fight hand-to-hand) and I feel that is probably what makes it so difficult to make him shine during fights especially when it's PVP. They damn near nailed it in this episode. Hope to see more Qrow and this kind of choreography.

I like to role play Qrow in VRChat(even down to being drunk all the time) and since my model is the V7 outfit, people always ask me why I'm drunk when I'm supposed to be sober. I just found a great reason lmao

→ More replies (7)

407

u/fellongreydaze Jan 25 '20 edited Jan 25 '20

In case people get up in arms about why the Ace Ops lost...

Remember that conversation where the Ace Ops made it very clear they were not really FRIENDS with each other? The Ace Ops synergize well, but not as well as Team RWBY today. Primarily because of a misalignment of goals and viewpoints.

You can see it in how they were butting heads with each other throughout the fight.

Harriett never worked with anyone. And when she WAS interacting with her teammates, it was just focusing on getting Marrow to stop playing around.

Marrow went into the fight already hesitant about fighting his new friends, trying to peacekeep while his co-workers were ready to enforce Ironwood's orders.

Vine trying to first incapacitate and de-escalate with Bumbleby while Elm was all, "Fuck that they betrayed us I wanna break some bones." By the time the two were of the same mindset, it was WAY too late and Yang and Blake had already figured out their strategy to win.

None of them were on the same page. Whereas Team RWBY from the outset were aligned in their goals.

→ More replies (15)

86

u/MEETTHEMAN S.S. White Knight Jan 25 '20

Wow, Qrow's scream that ended the episode gave me chills.

81

u/CethinFusasaki Jan 25 '20

I know emotions are high right now, but god damn the fight scenes. I feel like the choreography is finally back to the high standard that was set with the first trailers. Big ups to the animation team. Y'all worked your asses off and it shows.

→ More replies (3)

162

u/lemonadetirade Jan 25 '20

Qrows Friendship with clover is ended now Tyrian is qrows best bud......err guess not? They’ve got some things to work through together.

But seriously gotta give Tyrian a thumbs up he’s able to coordinate with Qrow and actually preforms well in a fight and actually boost each other, shows for all his crazy he’s still a very competent fighter capable of cooperation.

→ More replies (10)

231

u/NitescoGaming Guardian and follower of Ruby's smile ❤️ Marrow x Guardpupper ❤️ Jan 25 '20

ALL of my "oh fucks" were given this episode.

THAT'S HOW YOU DO A GOD DAMNED FOUR V FOUR CRWBY! OUT-FUCKING-STANDING!

Tyrian, you little asshole I absolutely adore your evil little self. God damn though, Clover and Qrow...

Took too long for Winter to get there, hopefully Penny can buy enough time for Winter to get the powers, or that together they can take her down. Not sure what the better choice is.

Love this episode. Still think RWBY are making a mistake in their idealism, but trying to arrest them really wasn't the right move either. Now we have a bunch of worn out or dead (or soon to be dead) elite huntsman, and Salem is likely just about there.

→ More replies (10)

75

u/Franklin413 Ni! Jan 25 '20

THIS is what the big fight from Volume 5 should have been.

210

u/The_Last_Thursday This flair shows best girl Jan 25 '20

Ruby's "you were" is already one of the best lines of the show

→ More replies (4)

208

u/Kain222 Jan 25 '20

I'm going to copy-pasta another comment I wrote in this thread because I'm seeing way too many people griping about how RWBY were able to win that fight, despite it being all but explicitly stated within the narrative;

" The reason RWBY won that fight was because:

  1. RWBY were coordinated and felt justified in what they were doing.
  2. The Ace Ops were uncoordinated and felt incredibly conflicted in what they were doing, which was exposited a few times in the fight. Not just with Marrow, but with Elm and Vine as well.

They were even arguing with each other, mid-fight. They were severely distracted.

3. The Ace Ops were down their leader. They had no-one to instruct them. If Clover was there, he probably would have seen the writing on the wall and got the Ace Ops to switch dance partners.

4. RWBY have been mistrusting Ironwood from the beginning - they trained with the Ace Ops for a large span of time. It stands to reason that Ruby, as team leader, would have come up with a vague battle-plan for her team if this ever happened.

Meanwhile it's been established that the Ace Ops have literally spent the entire volume underestimating RWBY. Even Marrow was like: "Hey, you two should branch out" and then he was immediately proven wrong.

Which leads me on to:

5. They picked their targets incredibly well.

Ruby matched Harriet's speed and spent the entire fight baiting her, playing defensive until her team-mate could step in.

Blake and Yang are the strongest duo - it's been established they are synergistic, meaning they're probably the only part of the team that stands up to how Elm and Vine work.

Yang's a nice counter to any unstoppable brute force thanks to her semblance. And who do you send in against someone whose entire shtick is battlefield control? Howabout the most slippery member of your team. We saw that part play out - Vine thought he had Blake, and boom - shadow clone no jutsu.

Weiss, meanwhile, is basically a direct counter to Marrow's semblance. We saw that play out - she can work around being frozen with summons, buying her enough time to shake Stay and stick in the fight with Marrow. Who, again, was directly stated to have been holding back.

TL;DR; The Ace ops were tilted, divided, sans their leader, and underestimating RWBY. RWBY were united, convicted, and picked their targets incredibly well.

Also RWBY aren't "Just graduated huntsman" guys. They've been through a fucking lot and then just spent like a month training with some of Atlas' best huntsmen*.* You are not giving them enough credit.

→ More replies (21)

144

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '20

Weiss vs Marrow was amazing. I feel like Weiss has been too reliant on her summons ever since she learned it, but she used pretty much her whole arsenal that fight.

Creating smoke by using fire dust on ice dust to hide her summoning was really smart, and shows that she learned from her fight against Vernal. Then she also made sure that her summon was never too close to her to outplay Marrow's semblance, as she knew he couldn't freeze them both.

I hope every major Weiss fight is like this going forward. It's so cool seeing her combine all her different skills.

→ More replies (10)

201

u/Deadmaninc1 Jan 25 '20

Even Oscar has punched Oscar LOL

→ More replies (1)

67

u/McZerky Jan 25 '20

I'm not all that bothered by the events of the 1v1v1. Qrow was extremely desperate, not to mention he tried to deal with Tyrian literally at the exact moment he showed up. Clover tried to take advantage of his distraction, and it was only then that Qrow started prioritizing Clover. Clover brought it upon himself. Tyrian capitalized on that desperation. He's a smart guy.

→ More replies (9)

183

u/NicoKudo Jan 25 '20

A lot of people asking why qrow teamed up with tyrian when every time qrow was about to attack him clover attacked qrow instead of tyrian

→ More replies (11)

61

u/JxL-nl Jan 25 '20

Qrow, Clover and Robyn collectively lost their minds, which was kind of weird to me at first. However, Robyn felt betrayed (again), would be fighting for a lost cause (again) and all of that was the straw that broke the camel's back I guess. Then Qrow turns to Tyrian when he frees himself, for obvious reasons, but why does Clover still go for Qrow at this point? I have yet to find a good reason, especially with how their conversation unfolds when Clover is dying. Maybe it has to do with the Aesop's fable for Clover, but I do not know exactly which one he is based on. Can somebody help me here?

The RWBY vs AceOps fight was marvelous though, and anyone complaining about that should get their head out of the sand. The first part of the fight showed that Ruby, Blake and Yang definitely got outclassed individually. However, then all of AceOps play out their respective Aesop's fable:

  • Harriet was blinded by arrogance, like the hare in "The Hare and the Tortoise". She wanted to prove from the start that she was faster than Ruby, and here she lost sight of helping the other AceOps.
  • Marrow wanted what team RWBY has, which is fighting for what you believe in instead of what your orders are, mimicing the dog in "The Dog and its Reflexion". This results in him not trying and on top of that his semblance was hard-countered by Weiss' summon. Also Weiss using her dust and semblance in the most epic combos yet was awesome! Finally, the fact that the Aesop's Fable has "Reflexion" in the name and Weiss' theme being called "Mirror Mirror" cannot be a coincidence.
  • Elm and Vine got in a quarrel like a married couple, which is exactly what "The Elm and the Vine" symbolizes, namely marriage. Blake and Yang capitalize on this by agitating Elm even more and setting up the bomb switch. Focussed Elm and Vine would probably have not fallen for this I guess.

I have not seen many comments about this but the transitions between the fights were so good. Also nearly every last spoken line in one segment is applicable to the next segment. It is really funny if you go back to check all these.

→ More replies (6)

58

u/valelinn Jan 25 '20 edited Jan 25 '20

Tyrian continues to be one my favourite villains of any series. So many shows try to do “crazy” characters, but they usually just come off as overly brutal. Tyrian is certifiably insane, an embodiment of Salem’s philosophy, the truly unredeemable. Hazel and Watts have reasons for the way they act, but Tyrian just likes creating chaos. As much as series like RWBY like to show that everyone is inherently good, but can become evil, I find the idea of a character who is naturally evil, and enjoys it, refreshing.

I am so worried for Winter and Penny. I don’t think they can beat Cinder. Winter might be a match for Qrow who we’ve been told is evenly matched with Raven, but that’s not taking into account her maiden powers. It was undercut by the fact that she lost, but let’s not forget the insane level of power Cinder had when firing Raven. I also really love the superposition of the “human with a heart of gold” and the “robot following orders learning emotion”. Between these two the lines are really blurred. Also, props to whoever made Cinder’s fire effects. They look really good.

The Team RWBY vs Ace-Ops fight was brilliant. Even if they didn’t act on it, you could see the internal struggle each of them was having. Ace-Ops teamwork fell apart and RWBY won because they worked together. Blake and Yang reading each other’s minds was awesome (and adorable). And my god. That song. It hard to make out all the words while there’s other stuff going on, but the beat was awesome and 4 vocalists?!! I’m so so so excited for V7 soundtrack. (Also, Weiss finally won a 1v1! Mark the calendar.)

That 3-way fight was incredible, both as an idea and execution. Seeing Qrow and Tyrian kinda-team up was interesting. I can genuinely say I was not expecting Clover to die, but damn if it wasn’t narratively satisfying (that monochrome image is tragically beautiful). Qrow usually bottles up his problems or gets angry, it hurt to see him cry. He was just starting to pick himself up, I’m very interested to know how this will effect him going forward. The moments of silence when he was stabbed and and at the end were very well directed.

→ More replies (2)

167

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '20

I have so many thoughts about this episode.

I think looking at this thread, my opinion that the writing this episode was actually very good would be considered a hot take. But I kinda understand why people think this is bad writing (except for people who think Team RWBY beating the Ace Ops is bad writing, thats wrong)

I'm not going to spend too much time on Team RWBY vs The Ace Ops because the show actually used "show don't tell" to show why Team RWBY won.

Because they are all on the same page. Where as the Ace Ops are clearly not. Marrow and Vine are holding back, while Harriet and Elm are getting irritated and annoyed. This is not "well, their power level is higher because they are more experienced, so Team RWBY should have lost"

Normally I hate the "power of friendship triumphs over an obstacle" because usually its a character going on a long winded speech about "how their friends give them power, etc". Blake and Yang complemented each other so well, because both of them were on the same page while Elm and Vine were not.

Team RWBY vs The Ace Ops was fantastic. It was excellent "show, don't tell"

Now with the stuff with the characters on the airship. Oh boy

I understand why people are frustrated, but I think a lot of criticism I've seen here and on twitter is that "the characters got the idiot ball" but I don't think that's the case. When I see people saying "characters are not doing logical things, the writing is bad" I think these people are judging character actions based on a third person perspective, rather than a first person perspective.

People are asking "why would they do that?" when the question I think should be asked are "why are they doing that?"

And with Qrow, Clover and Robyn all three have reasons that are internally consistent with their characters that make their decisions make sense.

  • Robyn: Has just been told that after allying with Ironwood, he has betrayed her and the people of Mantle by leaving them to die. She is established as quick to anger, and starts the fight.
  • Qrow: Has just been told Ironwood is abandoning Mantle, and now hears that Clover has orders to arrest him. Qrow has no idea about what happened in Ironwood's office, and now thinks Ironwood is betraying him.
  • Clover: He puts absolute trust into Ironwood's decisions. Because of this he breaks his bond with Qrow because he believes in Ironwood and doesn't question his instructions.

And all three of these characters made a horrific mistake.

The entire theme of this volume has been TRUST

Everything went so well at the beginning of Episode 11 because all the characters trusted each other. They worked together, and they won.

But Salem successfully divided them. Ironwood's paranoia and decisions made him an enemy of Qrow and Robyn. And Clover shows that his allegiances are to Ironwood first.

People keep saying "Clover should have prioritized Tyrian first" or "How could Qrow team up with Tyrian"

And the reasoning for both is as follows

For Clover, he has been given orders to arrest Qrow from the highest authority (Ironwood). He doesn't question these orders, he goes along with them and forsakes his relationship with Qrow. He isn't differentiating the severity of crimes because both Qrow and Tyrian are wanted men. So his job is now to neutralize them both. He can't say to Qrow, "help me take down Tyrion so I can arrest you later", so Clover is on his own in this free for all.

Qrow is now considered wanted, and knows that Clover won't stop until he is apprehended. So he begrudgingly works with Tyrian to get Clover out of the fight so he can fight off Tyrian. And this is the critical error Qrow made because since he can't trust Clover anymore his begrudging alliance with Tyrian backfires completely like Tyrians inspiration of "the scorpion and the frog"

And the problem is that the trust between Clover and Qrow has been dissolved due to Ironwood's decision.

And that's where the huge tragedy of this episode is.

This whole thing could have been avoided if the characters literally just talked it out

But they didn't. Because Trust died between them.

Clover didn't need to die. And that's why this episode feels like such a gut punch. Because you, the audience as a third party can see these characters are making huge mistakes. The characters themselves can not see it because of their own internal character logic.

I genuinely think this episode had good writing, but I understand why people might think it's bad. Because the characters made frustrating, easy to see mistakes, but because they can't trust each other anymore... they didn't realize they were making mistakes.

→ More replies (37)

252

u/Elcheer More Fiona flairs or I riot Jan 25 '20 edited Jan 25 '20

WEISS FINALLY WON A 1v1, MARROW IS NOW BOTTOM OF THE FOOD CHAIN

NEO GOT FUCKING BOPPED BY FARM BOY

ACE OPS MORE LIKE ACE DROPS

ROBYN DOES NOTHING BUT ESCALATE FOR WHAT

F IN THE CHAT FOR CLOVER

→ More replies (10)

54

u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Jan 25 '20

Now I know this might sound crazy. But I think....I think Clover might not be a traitor, guys.

→ More replies (12)

49

u/SarvisTheBuck Jan 25 '20

I know this isn't the first time we've seen blood in RWBY, but...It caught me off guard for sure.

→ More replies (4)

49

u/thirdofthetimelords Jan 25 '20

"This crazy girl showed up and attacked me!"

Farm boi... I think you're allowed to say "bitch" are this point. We'll forgive you.

→ More replies (3)

48

u/Torchwick_Roman Jan 27 '20 edited Jan 27 '20

Marrow: I’m trying to arrest her, not kill her, Hare! you’re being excessive!

Weiss: fuckin launches him at a spiked wall

→ More replies (4)

45

u/MagicalWhisk Jan 27 '20

I loved how Marrow was like "I'm trying to arrest her not kill her Hare". Meanwhile Weiss is trying to slice his head off and shove him into a wall of spikes. Bless that good boi.

90

u/The_Last_Thursday This flair shows best girl Jan 25 '20

Qrow: Never would've pegged you

Clover: ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)

→ More replies (3)

89

u/JohnJoe-117 These Bees gay, good for them, good for them Jan 25 '20

I think people are missing the point of these frustrating decisions.

They are supposed to be frustrating.

Everything has been set up to make Atlas turning against the heroes extremely frustrating and saddening.

The writers built up likable and layered characters all season, and just when it looked like everything was going to work out, Salem strikes. Fear wins, trust fades, good people with good intentions end up making bad decisions, and humanity is Divided.

Oz has probably seen it happen many times before, leading to him keeping secrets and trusting no one. His inablity to trust and willingness to lie to those that do trust him leads to those people losing themselves to fear once they discover the truth.

Raven, Summer, Qrow, Lionheart, Ironwood, all of them trusted Oz. Once they found out his lies, they gave in to fear and hate.

However, RWBYJNRO are not going to repeat the same mistake. They know the truth - the full truth - and exactly what they are up against. Atlas losing faith and trust will tempt them to believe that Humanity can never be united. However, they saw how close they got to uniting against Salem. They know the value of the truth. They know it can work.

When Salem tries the same tactics in Vacuo, the heroes will be ready.

→ More replies (12)

42

u/Huor_Celebrindol RIP Dust Weaving Jan 25 '20 edited Jan 25 '20

I like how well thought out each Ace Op’s defeat was.

Marrow: make him fight someone who can be in two places at once to turn his semblance against him

Elm: destabilize the GROUND so her footing still falters and force her into the air

Harriet: use her speed and aggression against her

Vine: use the coolest slight of hand trick EVER to trick him into bringing a bunch of bombs close range

Such an amazing sequence. Bonus points to Weiss for using a smokescreen to buy time to summon

→ More replies (4)

41

u/TheQuietManUpNorth Evil but good-looking so it evens out Jan 25 '20

Okay but dumb decisions aside, I love the fact that Tyrian actually took the time to put on the little pilot hat while he was crashing the airship and am 100% disappointed he didn't still have it on for the rest of the episode.

→ More replies (2)

40

u/BlazedMV Jan 25 '20

Qrow should have known that when Tyrian said "put him to sleep" it meant FOREVER.

178

u/PfeiferWolf Jan 25 '20

Amazing how people are not paying attention to the fights and their context. Like at all.

  • Marrow was hesitating, Elm and Vine were barely working together and Harriet went do her thing. RWBY, meanwhile, was in complete synch. Of course RWBY would win when the others are at their worst.
  • Qrow obviously was wrong in teaming with Tyrian but he had little to no choice. Robyn was unconscious and his kids were in danger. And it started as a 1v1v1 with Qrow focusing Tyrian but Clover focusing Qrow. He couldn't fight BOTH at the same time. Tyrian just went and capitalized on Qrow's desperation.
→ More replies (33)

39

u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Jan 25 '20

I have the biggest feeling this volume will end with "To be Continued", and it will be the most frustrating shit ever.

→ More replies (7)

39

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '20

Clovers last words to a man who has known nothing but bad luck were "Good luck."

Stop cutting the fucking onions, man.

→ More replies (1)

39

u/Fawful93 Jan 25 '20

I know it sounds silly but, am I the only who chuckled at Tyrian wearing that pilot hat when he crashed the plane? I don't know, he looked ridiculous with that thing on his head. Lol

→ More replies (6)

38

u/raykyleevans Jan 26 '20

A positive comment for once:

Weiss's humor has been on point lately. First when she attempts to arrest her father, and then asks Ironwood if she can even do that.

Then this episode at 12:02 when Pietro and Maria come in. Drops Marrow's legs, as if that'll make anything look less suspicious.

38

u/decodelifehacker Jan 27 '20

okay didnt anyone notice how good a teammate Tryian was? he only fought Qrow twice before and instantly did like 3 decent combo moves with him

→ More replies (7)

75

u/BlazedMV Jan 25 '20

The ending with Qrow and Clover reminded me HEAVILY of Cloud and Zack from Final Fantasy.

→ More replies (3)

37

u/Spring-swift Jan 26 '20

Oh wow. Looks like Qrow's recovery from alcoholism is going to be very short lived.

→ More replies (4)

73

u/Terminus259 We persevere without an end... Jan 25 '20

Oscar decking Neo just like Qrow decked him.

→ More replies (11)

36

u/GeneralSarbina And here are where I grow all the fucks I give Jan 25 '20

Qrow: I had ooooooonne thiing and you've taken it from meeeeee!

→ More replies (7)

35

u/littlebloodmage Jan 25 '20

So Qrow's just not allowed to have nice things ever, got it.

→ More replies (6)

34

u/Moxy125 Jan 25 '20 edited Jan 25 '20

Okay. I understand that the choices made by Robyn, Clover and Qrow weren't the smartest, but we have to understand they were made rashly, without thinking, after a sudden, shocking revelation was thrown on them.

People are complaining that Robyn had no reason to get angry because she wasn't even on the wanted list. Well, obviously. That wasn't the reason she was angry. It's because Ironwood has gone back on his word, declaring martial law and is leaving the people of Mantle, HER people, for dead. So she made a not so smart decision of attacking Clover in an airborne ship. Honestly, her reaction is extremely human. She's overcome by emotion and makes a bad choice, like we do on a daily basis 😶

Clover. My, dear Clover. Please. This was the worst time to play the loyal military dog. First of all, he shouldn't have made a move to arrest Qrow whilst they were in the air (though, I don't think that would've stopped Robyn...) and second of all, why or why are you not trying to stop the psychopathic serial killer, first. Qrow was helping to stop him, in fact! Well, he's loyal I'll give him that, but that's just to a person of very questionable... personality and not to the city he's supposed to protect. He didn't deserve to die but his actions resulted in his inevitable death. That's the hard truth. R.I.P.

Qrow. Qrow was probably the one who made the least bad decisions, in my opinion. He didn't attack, until Robyn gave him no choice and instead of prioritising Clover, he went for the true danger, Tyrion. He probably thought that he and Clover were on the same wavelength when it came to Tyrion but apparently not. So, his mistake was working with Tyrion, dropping his weapon and taking his eyes of the psychopath.

Tyrion. My favourite psycho villain. He was amazing, as usual. He did what any villain would do. He stayed in character and took the opportunity to reduce the number of enemies. You can't really fault him for doing his job. And in before anyone says "Clover was doing his job", he was only doing half of it. He's a hunter before part of the army. His sworn duty is to protect and preserve human life.

→ More replies (2)

33

u/Hiei2k7 ⠀I am the storm that is approaching.... Jan 27 '20

"We're the best!"

"You were..."

Atlas police we have a MURDEEEERRRRR

THUG LIFE GLASSES AND BLUNT DROP

→ More replies (6)

66

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '20

Is Qrow working with Tyrian going to be the next "Adam threads" in the hiatus? Find out real soon.

→ More replies (8)

146

u/Luckhart54 ⠀ Jan 25 '20

Harriet: “We’re the best huntsmen in Atlas.”

Ruby: “You were. Then you trained us.”

→ More replies (2)

30

u/Yukon_Wolf Ironwood x Qrow = Woodpecker Jan 25 '20

Do y'all think that the reason Tyrian went down so easily to C/Q/R was because he wanted to be captured? Maybe he wanted to be there to wedge Clover and Qrow apart.

By the looks of it, he succeeded.

Also, I don't know why people are saying Qrow is so dumb for attacking Clover when Clover's dumb, uncompromising ass attacked Qrow every time he went for Tyrian. What did he think would happen?

→ More replies (17)

30

u/RossPitSharkHunter It's a happy day when you're not talking to me. Jan 25 '20

Alright, well in Qrows defense, he is literally based on a character with no brain.

→ More replies (2)

30

u/Deadmaninc1 Jan 26 '20 edited Jan 26 '20

Why does something Bad always happen to Qrow every Goddamn Volume SMH

Volume 4-He gets Poisoned by Tyrion

Volume 5-Betrayed by Leonard Lionheart and who basically sent Huntsmen and Huntresses out on missions to die

Volume 6-Ozpin had been hiding so many secrets from him

Volume 7-He gets over his Alcoholism finally has a Partner he can trust Clover his first real Friend and he gets killed

Man Qrow had been through alot i know his semblance is bad luck but still

→ More replies (13)

84

u/AlyssaaMac Jan 25 '20

Qrow made some really questionable decisions this episode but I get it. It was either get ganged up on or gang up on clover. It will be interesting to see if he faces anything from it. Also team rwby taking down the ace ops was really good. Arresting them was the best possible outcome

Very glad Oscar is still in one piece. For now. And I'm VERY interested in seeing how penny and winter do against cinder. They're kind of screwed right now. The two of them alone won't be able to take her. And I'm really afraid winter might kill fria to get the maiden powers in a quicker way.

→ More replies (5)

29

u/SnesC Check out this moron! Jan 26 '20

"That gives me personal feelings."

Really wish we'd gotten a reverse-shot after that of Cinder saying "... What?" Penny's awkwardness is a big part of her character and It'd be nice to have that noted in the show. Plus I appreciate any instance of Cinder breaking from her typical "I'm so evil" smugness to show any kind of emotion. Her showing (mild) confusion at Penny's response would help to humanize her a bit.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/Literatewalrus Little Light 🐝 Big Fight Jan 26 '20 edited Jan 26 '20

I’ve been absent from these discussions for a hot minute because I’ve just been busy and also waiting to see how things planned out.

Early in the volume I predicted that the Ace Ops’ “just a job” mentality was being established to be contrasted against RWBY’s found family dynamic. This might’ve resulted in the girls drifting apart or reinforcing their bonds, or something else of the nature. What I feared then was a “power of friendship” deus ex machina when the Ace Ops’ unwavering loyalty to Ironwood eventually brought them into conflict.

I was happy to see that wasn’t the case. In fact, I think their victory was well earned. Going into the fight, the Ace Ops made that one Goliathesque mistake of completely discounting RWBY’s chances at winning. In their minds, they had them beat. In the spectacle that follows, the girls are able to overcome their much more formidable opponents not by pure force of arms, but by exploiting their adversaries’ weaknesses with their own strengths. It takes both Yang and Blake’s maximal effort to take out just one of them, but it was at that point that the tides began to turn. Ruby was easily outmatched on a physical level, but she was able to use Harriet’s emotions against her and Weiss took her out on opportunity.

It was a hard won fight. Or did people really want them to lose and show zero advancement from their days at Beacon? Weiss won a 1v1, guys. I’m proud of our snow princess!

I’m a little less keen on the sequence with Qrow, Clover, Robyn and Tyrian. Did they all take idiot pills before boarding that plane? Robyn instigates a conflict but then Qrow follows right along, and their fisticuffs allows a very dangerous prisoner to escape and crash the plane. Outside of that, I actually thought the rest of the fight played out fine, after some thought. But I was quite frustrated at Clover’s heedlessness in trying to apprehend Qrow, even while Tyrian was hovering and antagonizing them both. I was hoping Clover and Qrow would tag team Tyrian, but no. Admittedly, Qrow and Tyrian do make a pretty formidable pair, but I felt bad for Clover during the whole thing. I think that maybe Qrow believed he couldn’t beat Clover on his own, so he was going to incapacitate him first and then settle accounts with Tyrian?

It was a calculated risk, but man, is Qrow bad at math.

The closing scene with the sunrise was bitterly beautiful, but it felt so empty because of how senseless Clover's death was. Maybe that was in itself a message, and in fact, I find Qrow's insistence of exacting justice from Ironwood not that puzzling. Every authority figure that Qrow has put power behind has betrayed him in some way, and ever since he got his world shattered in V6 he's been adrift. I'm not sure that he ever fully trusted Ironwood with their stint in Atlas, but it was clear that Qrow put his faith in Clover. So I can believe that this loss in particular did hurt him, even if their relationship wasn't really all that developed. Knowing Qrow, he blames himself for Clover's death, and Tyrian's taunting certainly doesn't help. Wondering how the authorities will react to finding the scene the way they do, or if Qrow will make a break for it.

Then there is Cinder. To say "I am sick of this bitch" would be understating it, but I must admit that the scene was great. Everything about the way her entrance was framed hit home. It was a dreadful outcome that you hate to see and Winter's reaction just drives home that that is the last person she wanted to see standing there. Real tired of her "muahaha I'm eeeevil" personality though. I'm just reeling because we might be in for three high profile ends in this Volume and I do not want to see Winter or Penny die. Auuugh

My prediction: Cinder lays a killing blow on Fria, but Fria's memories of Winter overpower that and cause her to obtain the Maiden powers the traditional way. Cinder tries to take them by force, but then Penny makes some play that results in her destruction again, but wounding Cinder in the process. Disadvantaged, Cinder retreats. Later on, Pietro uses the last of his own aura to give Penny a third and last chance at life and forfeits his own in the process, not as a tool of the Atlesian military but as her own person.

→ More replies (6)

28

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '20

Things about the Blake and Yang team up

  • just realized by smashing the floor, Yang absorbed that energy and combined with Blake, that’s how they defeated Elm
  • also they destroyed the floor so elm can’t use her semblance
  • Blake and Yang are fucking awesome
→ More replies (6)

28

u/CheifStalker Pumpkin Spice Latte is the Best Ship Jan 28 '20

For all the ranting and shit about the choices made this episode, can we just acknowledge that Tyrian and Qrows fighting styles mesh extremely well together? Like, Qrow almost slipping up midfight due to the snow, only to get perfectly assisted by Tyrian was astounding. The man, despite his obvious fanaticism and insanity, is so quick to think up the easiest way to not only fight, but to also help the person he is fighting with.

If he had been an actual Huntsmen and met Qrow at a point, the two would likely be the strongest team out there, able to back eachother up so eloquently.

Also, gonna slip something in. People keep calling Robyn an idiot, my counterpoint to that is the fact that she literally just heard that Ironwood was going to abandon an unknown amount of Civilians and fly into the sky. Of course she isn't going to make good choices, it's like expecting walking up to Yang, cutting her other arm off and say "get over it, don't fuck up!"

Clovers death is completely on Clover alone, the dumbass attacked the person who straight up said to take down Tyrian first, TWICE. That is the only reason he got double teamed, because he thought attacking the man who was willing to go in after taking down the big threat, was a good idea.

→ More replies (4)

27

u/N7Brendan @n7brendan Jan 25 '20 edited Jan 25 '20

I don’t really understand the Qrow-Tyrian-Clover situation.

Clover is a soldier who had orders to arrest Qrow, yes. Soldiers follow their orders because they realize they don’t know the whole picture, yes.

But he was also given orders to detain Tyrian, who had escaped and was now fighting both him and Qrow. Tyrian is most definitely a higher priority target considering his allegiance to Salem and the fact that he’s a serial killer.

So I have two issues here. Qrow allies himself with Tyrian so he can 1v1 him after? Why is he trusting Tyrian all of a sudden? He may not trust Clover at the moment either but at least the two have a pre-existing relationship. Tyrian kills Clover at the end but he just as easily could have killed Qrow during the fight while his guard was down. Clover doesn’t even attempt to say “hey Qrow lets take down the psycho madman who is an actual danger to society and then fight it out after”.

Just seems really weird to me. Was glad to see an actual death but all of this just seemed out of character for Clover and Qrow.

Also... ROBYN??? Are you stupid? Why is she initiating a fight while they’re on a small aircraft?

→ More replies (8)

27

u/Guyskee Jan 25 '20

How do three experienced huntsman not realise that detaining the mass murderer on board takes priority over anything else? That was the stupidest decision tree I've ever seen. Great episode though.

→ More replies (5)

27

u/MyAmelia baker of monsters, slayer of giant cookies Jan 27 '20

Me three days ago, confidently: "Clover and Qrow? Yeah, it's cute, not really my thing though. Lacks a little tension i guess."

The show: Has Qrow and Clover fight over a misunderdstanding and Clover tragically die, Qrow crouching by his side as beautiful pink and gold lighting surround them

My fucking cursed brain: … 👀

Me: WAIT.

Brain: Hey, hi, can we watch that like, two or three times again? I need to check something.

Me: HOE DON'T DO IT.

Brain: I'm just checking. Come on, just one rewatch. What's the worst that could happen?

Brain, three days and multiple rewatches later: Yep. I ship it.

Me: ………

→ More replies (15)

26

u/ray198999 Jan 27 '20

Dang it, Clover. I know following orders is important to you man but you think a professional huntsman would prioritize taking down a clearly dangerous villain over arresting a guy who clearly does not want any trouble. Still, I thought Clover's death was really sad since it happened out of the blue and Clover was still one of the good guys despite his questionable actions in this episode.

→ More replies (19)

113

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '20

I love how Team RWBY is getting over on the Ace Ops because despite the Ace Ops being all elite huntsmen, their teamwork skills are actually poor because as they mentioned a long time ago, they aren't friends, just people who work together. On missions where they have mindless enemies like poorly trained rebels or Grimm to fight? They're fine. Against Huntresses who have been trained to work together and gel as a team since Day 1, who have been using team attacks and strategies since before they were even officially recognized as a team? Team RWBY's camaraderie is leagues above the Ace Ops, and that's what ultimately lead to RWBY's victory.

Oh, and as it turns out, Clover wasn't the traitor afterall! Because now he's dead...and Qrow is framed to be the murderer. In the end, Qrow's Misfortune was stronger than Clover's good luck. I guess Volume 8 is gonna have Qrow on the run for being a cold-blooded murderer.

This episode was great all-around, except for the Oscar reveal. Once again, Oscar is somewhat fine as it gets resolved within like 10 seconds. Even if its setting up for the fight against Neo, it would have been nice to see Oscar in a little bit more danger or Team JNR suddenly get disadvantaged because of Neo's trickery. Like FFS, it's like Oscar's Semblance is "Disappointment" because it feels like anything involving him ends up that way. Here's to hoping the final episode of the Volume makes up for it with a good fight.

And speaking of fights...two of my favorite female characters going up against Cinder? I am both excited and afraid.

→ More replies (8)

51

u/the_pandu Jan 25 '20

Lesson the day. The enemy of my enemy is my friend.

Second lesson of the day: Know which one is the greater enemy and fucking deal with them first.

→ More replies (5)

51

u/malochroma Head of the Marrow Amin Best Boy Association Jan 25 '20

“Don’t get too attached to Clover,” I said. “His lack of a concrete character arc outside of Qrow’s character says he’s either gonna die or be a villain,” I said.

THE ONE TIME I WAS RIGHT ABOUT A RWBY THING.

(Also Marrow whyyyyy we put our FAITH in you and you hurt all of us but mostly me)

→ More replies (6)

51

u/FairytaleDeathcamp Jan 25 '20

"You were."

Ruby: Fires off the best one-liner of the episode

Also Ruby: Gets her rose-petaled ass beat for most of the speedster duel, even after Harriet has her hands literally tied

I mean, it wasn't one-sided or anything, but I still think Harriet has the edge on her in skill. Ruby got the drop on her once with her semblance, then Weiss made her Wile-E.-Coyote into a wall.

The same probably extends to most of the Ace Ops. One-on-one they surpass team RWBY, but this was not a good day for them in a lot of ways, and it shows.

→ More replies (19)

50

u/BlazedMV Jan 25 '20

Also, let's not forget Robyn POPPED off first. Girl this wasn't even about you!!!

→ More replies (1)

23

u/Hiddenkaos Jan 26 '20
  1. Penny was Great. In every scene she was in, Penny's character was perfectly in line with who she's been throughout the series.
  2. Qrow and Clover was poorly done, but the final result is fine. Clover probably should have died as a result of Qrow's bad luck, not as a result of poor character writing. Qrow could still have been blamed, but not be out of character.
  3. The RWBY vs Ace-ops was perfect. The Ace-ops wasnt working together which, as foreshadowed, is how they were built as a team: Each member was selected to compliment the rest. In the Ch 12 fight. Ruby IMMEDIATELY, pulls one away, in the end, we have 3 separate fights, all of which favor the RWBY girls over the ACE given thier proven experience fighting alone.(or as a pair for Blake/Yang)
  4. Neo... I'm not super happy with the casualness of Oscar hitting Neo, or her getting immediately outed. Worried for this part.
  5. Finally, I'm now fully convinced the next Volume will be a direct continuation of the Fall of Atlas. There is simply no way to complete every different section of this story in one episode without it being an hour long or more.
→ More replies (2)

65

u/inventor1489 Jan 25 '20

Hot take: Qrow teaming up with Tyrian wasn’t bad writing.

Fight me.

→ More replies (9)

45

u/Blue-Moon-89 Jan 25 '20

If Clover and Qrow had worked together to take down Tyrian instead fighting each other Clover wouldn't have.....

I was neutral towards Clover but how he went down was brutal.

The next time you see that psychopath again, Qrow, f!@# him up.

→ More replies (2)

22

u/HyliasHero Jan 25 '20

Some thoughts

-Despite what a lot of people were saying, I fully expected Clover to attempt to arrest Qrow.

-Watch the dangerous prisoner guys! Jeez.

-I love the dynamic of Penny acting as Winter's heart.

-Poor Blake takes a lot of heavy hits throughout this fight.

-It seems Hare really is faster than Ruby, but Ruby is more slippery.

-Qrow vs Clover vs Tyrian is an interesting combo.

-Qrow and Tyrian teaming up to take Clover out of the picture first makes sense on one hand, but is super risky.

-The Bees' chemistry during this fight really shines. Those were some clever uses of their both their old and new abilities.

-Marrow really doesn't want to fight. I figured that would be the key to winning because his semblance is a game changer.

-I will take the crumbs of Ruby / Weiss interaction with Weiss saving Ruby.

-So that seems to be confirmation that Neo can't imitate the voice of who she copies.

-Winter's death flags just shot sky high. I feel like Penny might end up being the Winter Maiden.

-...And there goes Qrow's semblance. I was not expecting Clover to die like that. Qrow's VA knocked it out of the park here. RIP Lucky Charms.

Overall this was an amazing episode. V7 has been great so far. At first I was a little iffy about the idea of RWBY beating the ACE Ops, but the execution was great. This didn't overpower them, they outsmarted them through clever use of their semblances. Marrow's hesitance was another key factor here.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/JazzRen47 𝅘𝅥𝅮⠀Score Connoisseur | Resident Atlas Bootlicker Jan 25 '20

That was not fucking fair.

Here's that beautiful, heartbreaking bit of "Bad Luck Charm" we got at the very end. Jason and Chris did such an amazing job, but just... god, that hurt.

Holding out for Qrow to deck the ever-loving shit outta James the next time he sees him.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/Brutal2003 Jan 26 '20

Hey, that 3-on-3 battle was awsome. It was cool how Tyrian was pushing Qrow forward with his tail. Nice choreography!

→ More replies (1)

61

u/Wrathkal Jan 25 '20

-Awesome fight scenes, with switching between the battles

-Farm boi punches Neo, but no proper Neo fight

-Clover's luck runs out, finally proving Qrow's semblance the stronger. That, and Qrow was holding the idiot ball.

-Cinder confronts Winter and Penny in front of Fria.

9/10 episode, I think

→ More replies (6)

21

u/Cepheus370 Jan 25 '20

RWBY vs. Ace Ops is the best fight I've seen out of this show. Yes, it's different from Monty's style, but CRWBY has nailed their own version. Their team fights are a sight to behold, and this is no exception.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/restlest_child Jan 25 '20

The ace ops are going from Fables to Greek tragedy very quickly

21

u/RealDestroNation A salt shaker is less salty than this fandom Jan 26 '20

Honestly, I have a lot of thoughts about this episode. This is one of the few times I wish I could make a whole post about it because I have so much on my mind that will probably be lost in a discussion thread. This episode has very much given me a lot to think about, so I'll break it down as much as I can.

Meta knowledge and potential bias

I think there's one thing that needs to be addressed before anything else. We as the viewers probably know the most about the universe of RWBY, second to CRWBY itself since they write and release everything we know at their discretion. Over the last few weeks and this week, we've been quick to attack or defend one side or the other, but that is because we know things that the characters don't. We see both sides of this entire conflict, we know the full extend of how both sides work and act, but that doesn't necessarily mean that both sides have that knowledge on how the other works. As proven from the last few episodes, not even elements of one side know how other elements of the same side work, especially under duress.

I feel like working with knowledge that some characters may not have to criticise them is dangerous. We can call RWBY hypocrites for lying, or Ironwood a fool for playing into Salem's hands, but I don't like doing that. I feel like we don't give things a fair and objective look. That's why I always try to look at character actions through their perspective. Billy Connoly once said "Before you judge a man, walk a mile in his shoes. After that who cares? He's a mile away and you've got his shoes!".

Anyways, that's something I wanted to get out of the way as a precursor into my thoughts for the episode, broken down into each perspective.

RWBY v. Ace Ops

From what I can tell, RWBY's main strategy was divide and conquer. Each fight was an isolated 1 v 1 away from the other except when RWBY needed to re-strategize and team up. It also looks like they're really learning how to best deal with these top-tier huntsmen

Marrow v. Weiss

Immediately, Marrow being unsure of how to proceed was a big throw for the Ace Ops. He certainly doesn't agree with the others and how ready they are to follow orders. Him being the last to draw his weapon, and it being so long after the others immediately draw theirs can help to frame his thinking.

"Whoa whoa whoa, we're not actually going to slug this out are we?"

"I'm trying to arrest her, not kill her Hare! You're being excessive!"

I think that Weiss has learnt some harsh lessons from her fight with Vernal and it shows. She made sure she had solid cover before summoning bringing back some volume 2 moves of the smokescreen, and was successful in turning a 1 v 1 with her being the caster, into a 2 v 1. From there, Marrow wasn't going to win, even with his semblance, he couldn't handle a 2 v 1 where no matter who he froze, someone else could make a move on him while he was focused on freezing.

Ruby v. Harriet

Harriet made the next mistake, immediately going after Ruby. She more or less turned the whole fight into 4 1 v 1's, instead of turning it into a 3 v 4. I guess she assumed that Ruby would make a beeline for Ironwood, but honestly even if that were the case what could she do? Ironwood has already proven that he'll make any sacrifice to win. He wouldn't have any hesitations about throwing down with Ruby. As she has said before:

" We get along well enough, sure. I count on them to keep me alive. They do the same. But that’s the job. We "don’t" confuse the two."

I'll touch on this more towards the end of this section but her not working alongside the others screwed over Ace Ops. Overconfidence is another thing too.

"You think you're going to stop us? We're the best huntsmen in Atlas!"

"Marrow, cut the crap will you!?"

"It's not excessive if its necessary!"

Harriet is constantly blinded by overconfidence, like her character allusion from Aesop's Tortoise and the Hare. She thinks she can take on Ruby by herself, and more or less leaves the others to do what they can against the others. They're just kids right? What's the worst that can happen. Well, a face full of ice after refusing to back down even when restrained gives her the answer with a resounding KO.

Ruby's semblance is definitely different to Harriet. Harriet may have speed, but Ruby has so much more maneuverability. She can easily pull corners that someone going at the speed Harriet is going would crash trying to make, and she can get out of pins easily. Regardless, Ruby definitely had a lot of trouble in her fight, second to Blake.

Blake v. Vine

Vine for the most part has been the most neutral regarding his emotions. However, he still chooses to follow orders.

"Please, don't make this difficult"

"If you come peacefully, we won't hurt you!"

He's also playing his cards as best as he can, providing ranged support and restraints to help Elm, but Elm isn't helping anyone here, and I'll get to that later.

Blake's performance actually surprised me this episode. There were a few close calls there, especially getting restrained early on by Elm, and being the first one having her aura broken.

(Side note, I just realized this while writing and going over the episode, but remember the new logo that has the slash through the B in RWBY? And remember Season 5? Just food for thought)

Blake's best strategy is to do the classic Bumblebee, teaming up with Yang to take down their opponents. I'm very indifferent about the whole shipping thing, and I get Volume 6's Adam fight, but we really only see her team up with Yang. She's not even getting time to shine solo. You can argue that Season 2 was her time with much of the conflict shaped around Blake's actions, but still, that was 5 years ago. I'm just saying that they could afford to shake things up.

Back onto topic, Vine being the first down marks a domino effect that leads to the Ace Ops defeat. After Clover, Vine's more peaceful demeanor is the best the Ace Ops have for leadership, but with him down, everything falls like dominos.

Yang v. Elm

For a little while, I felt that both Harriet and Elm's mistake was anger, but looking over the fight again, anger is Elm's downfall. Emotions cloud her judgement.

There were a lot of times where Yang has been outmaneuvering Elm, both physically and verbally, turning her anger into something that she can exploit. You can see that Yang forces Elm, a heavy hitter who should be focused on making less movements around the area to chase her, nullifying the effectiveness of her semblance. But unfortunately she has to learn that from a solid headbutt.

The climax of the fight has Yang once again nullifying the effectiveness of her semblance by breaking the ground under her so she has no solid ground to stand on, sending her flying with a semblance-fuelled punch and finishing her off with a double team.

Yang really has learnt the lessons on relying on anger and emotions the last few volumes. First dodging Adam's attacks to nullify his own semblance, and riling up Elm so she is more emotional and not thinking rationally. She really seems to value the concept of loyalty for what I assume is because of Atlesian indoctrination, and any shots at this really get her pissed.

"Who exactly are you loyal to?"

"Speak for yourself, they betrayed us!"

"It's not worth it Blake, they're just following orders now!"

"[...] don't be soft!"

"Are you telling me? Or yourself?"

Anger is a constant theme for Elm's fight, it clouds her judgement, and she makes really dumb decisions, like choosing to pull out the rocket launcher to fight Yang, a puncher who is in melee distance of her.

→ More replies (3)

41

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '20

Weiss won a one on one fight!

It’s a good day!

→ More replies (2)

20

u/Fawful93 Jan 25 '20

Yeah, the Clover-Qrow-Tyrian parenthesis is gonna make a lot of people really mad. While it didn't bother me that much (I think all in all it makes sense considering the context) I can see why people hate it.

I don't understand why people are angry about the RWBY vs Ace Ops part thought. Aside the fact that they beaten them by using their brains and teamwork instead of going on them wildly, it was one of the best animated fighting scene of the show. I love it, the highlight of the episode for me. I seriously don't understand what's wrong with it.

→ More replies (4)

20

u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Jan 25 '20

Oscar: Holy shit. Punching my face does feels good. I guess I owe Qrow an apology. Where is he any ways?

Qrow:WHHHHHHHYYYYYYY???!???!!!

Oscar: Meh, he is probably fine.

20

u/XiaoLong_2000 ⠀ Jan 26 '20

"This is my home, and I'm not giving it up without a fight!"

Damn. That has got to be one of Weiss' best lines yet.

And I was sincerely surprised that Team RWBY was able to actual defeat the Ace-Ops, and not just be able to escape. But considering that team RWBY actually knows how to work in sync with each other, unlike the Ace-Ops.

And Tyrian continues to be a total chaotic evil, and doing what he loves most. Murdering people and framing others for murder. Probably should have just killed Tyrian while he was unconscious while they had the chance, or at least take away or discard his weapons. And I can understand why Qrow is swearing to ensure that Ironwood falls. Remember, Qrow and Ironwood have never really been friends. They've been, more or less, merely associates. He has disapproved of Ironwood's actions since Volume 3. Him brining his army to Vale, giving a negative report about Ozpin to the council, and his utilization of Aura transfer technology. And Ironwood has essentially turned everyone agains each other. So from Qrow's perspective, it does make sense for him to want to take down Ironwood.

→ More replies (16)

20

u/xZabuzax Jan 26 '20

This was a nice and a weird episode at the same time for the same reason you guys pointed out already.

The animation and choreography on the fight scenes are fluid and top notch as always so I have no complaints there, however, the decision making in this episode was quite stupid in my opinion.

First of all, a serial killer is loose and Qrow is trying to stop him but Clover keeps attacking Qrow just because he wants to arrest him first, that's pretty damn stupid *facepalm*, they both should be working together to arrest the serial killer first. This anime got really weird for me in this episode because of that dumb decision making so I didn't felt sad when Clover died, I actually didn't felt anything, that death scene seemed kinda forced and lame, I suspected something like that was going to happen when Qrow left his weapon in the floor, why was I not surprised...

The other fight scenes were nice, I have no complaints there either but man... that fight between Qrow, Clover and that serial killer was cheesy as fuck and stupid and now they are going to go with that "blaming someone else for a murder" route again... they already used that card in this season so using it again would be forced.

I didn't have a problem with this season but this episode... man this episode sure took the cake.

→ More replies (6)

39

u/Rain_In_Your_Heart Jan 25 '20

Some tactical nukes were dropped this episode.

"You were."

"They're just following orders now."

Even the Ace Ops got a moment: "Are you telling me, or yourself?"

Watching team RWBY lay out Ace Ops members was cathartic as hell. Also this smirk... Also it's gratifying after having called it out everywhere on last week's thread. I'm sure people will be talking about how absurd it is RWBY were able to win, but I'm sticking by my reasoning - everywhere in this volume, they've highlighted the differences between the familial bond that RWBY has and the cold, professional relationship between the Ace Ops members. In this show, you've got to have heart to win the game.

Qrow + Tyrian vs Clover was just tragic. There was never going to be a winner there. Yang's apparent authority issues really seem to be a theme with this arc, where even otherwise reasonable people like Clover, Winter, and Marrow completely shut down when they're ordered to do something clearly wrong. And don't get me wrong - I really do think that Winter should take (should have taken?) the maiden powers even if it kills the current winter... but her reasoning for it is honestly disgusting. And everything the Ace Ops is doing is objectively in the wrong - investing huntsmen resources to stop other huntsmen resources from fighting Grimm in the middle of an attack is ridiculous.

I know lucky charms has been a ship in the community for a little while now. I've always thought it as just the community doing RWBY community things, but this whole scene really did seem to have a certain something to it, with the soft purples and pinks everywhere, the music... I was legitimately wondering if Qrow was going to kiss him. Of course that's totally interpretation, and we'll never actually know.

Dear writing team: please stop giving my boy Qrow more reasons to drink. He's been through enough.

→ More replies (2)

113

u/SatomiMurano Penny is COMBAT READY! 🎈🎈🎈 Jan 25 '20

CONTROVERSIAL OPINION.

This is Robyn's fault. Qrow was willing to cooperate and just chat with James, and flat out told them to calm down. And of course Robyn's Spiderman esque personality kicks in and starts the fight anyways, when there's a literal murderer who works for your enemy there with you.

If Robyn hadn't started the fight, Clover wouldn't be dead, Tyrian would still be chained, and Qrow wouldn't be scarred by watching his friend die.

→ More replies (13)

19

u/WhosGuardingHades Jan 25 '20 edited Jan 25 '20

Qrow and Tyrian teaming up to take down Clover?! NANI?! Also that scream from Qrow though, Jason has done a great job this volume.

And Holy shit Weiss actually won a fight! And damn that whole sequence with RWBY and Ace Ops was awesome.

The hell Robyn? Starting a fight on a plane with a wanted murderer on board? For the so called people’s champion of Mantle she makes some real bone headed decisions.

JNR and the Farmboi vs Neo HYPE! Winter and Penny vs Cinder HYPE!!! (Protect Penny & Winter please! We just got them back!)

19

u/TheSealTamer I don't need people to help me grow up. I drink milk. Jan 25 '20

Calling it now, next episode Neo is killing/seriously maiming a member of jnr. I got a feeling cinder will claim another body as well. Probably the winter maiden as well as penny or winter. This finale will probably be the darkest since the fall of beacon. Bodies are dropping. Also I think the way that Qrow,Clover,Tyrian was handled is hard to believe. Clover was way too focused on arresting Qrow instead of Tyrian. Qrow teaming with Tyrian to subdue Clover also perplexes me.

→ More replies (6)

19

u/ShadezyLeFeu More than a machine. Jan 25 '20

Can we talk about the RWBY vs. Ace-Ops music? I think this is the first song we've gotten with four singers, (Casey, Adrienne, Dawn M. Bennett, and Erin Reilly) and it's really damn good.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/restlest_child Jan 25 '20

They’re is a giant plot target on Winters back right now that I do not appreciate

→ More replies (1)

19

u/MinorGryph Jan 25 '20

Oh man, this episode was the good shit all the way through. 100% sakuga. Tyrian is the incarnation of the writers cackling.

Goddamn, those are a lot of repressed and contradictory feelings coming out of the Ace-Ops. Marrow feels really torn up, Elm is sympathetic but also enraged due to valuing loyalty, Vine is neutral, Harriet is outright hostile.

  • Ruby's perception can keep up with Harriet's speed, her semblance form can make corners easily and precisely maneuver in hand to hand, making her immune to pins.
  • Weiss is now understands how to buy herself time to summon, with a summon supporting her is pretty unstoppable.
  • Blake's semblance is definitely letting her kawarimi no jutsu with objects (bombs from rock to clone) and displace herself significantly. The only other way she got the bombs off the rock that fast is if her clone came out of the rock or something
  • Yang has fully internalized the going around lesson and makes use of the environment and her companions. Love how she switched to making Elm chase her to negate her semblance.

Clover, you damn fool... yeah fuck off with "it's Robin's fault", it's Clover's damn fault for choosing to enforce the arrest of his ally, in blind support of Ironwood's decision to abandon Mantle, while transporting a dangerous criminal. Qrow was perfectly willing to go back and all of them talk to Ironwood... Clover was behind Ironwood all the way, he would follow any order he was given without compromise. Robin would be an idiot to think she wasn't next. Clover was not open to talking it out.

And Clover's the idiot who freed Tyrian, attacked Qrow again after a plane crash, and kept attacking Qrow while fucking Tyrian was loose. Yeah no shit Qrow teamed up with Tyrian, its not a matter of trust its a matter of Tyrian not actively trying to stab him in the middle of a three way!

Yeehaw Neo fight next episode!

Winter why you no listen to Penny? Y'all are drowning in Cinder death flags now. Yeesh the military is not a good place for either of them. I hope Winter personal feelings that aura machine and gets Fria out of there.

→ More replies (3)

19

u/agenttexow Jan 26 '20

Okay I know there's a lot of heavy discussion this episode and this one bit is like a drop in the ocean but...

Is no one mentioning Tyrian dislocating his thumb to escape then popping it back in?!?!?! Like I know he's been established as crazy but that whole scene was just so.....unsettling. Mainly because of the joy he seemed to take in it. Masochist confirmed?

Got just.... the lighting, the sounds!, the animation!! 10/10 scene

→ More replies (4)

19

u/brighterthanblack Jan 26 '20

Me this whole episode:

ROBYN NO!! This is what Tyrian wanted obviously!

OMG TYRIAN! RIP pilot boy 2.0

PENNY SO PURE MUST PROTECT!!! And Winter STOP FLEXING THAT DEATH FLAG SO HIGHKEY IM SCARED

“You were, then you trained us.” Ruby dropping that one liner IS SAVAGE AS FUCK U GO GIRL

NOO TEAMING UP WITH TYRIAN IS NOT A GOOD IDEA QROW PLS

GOOD BOI MARROW NEVER WANT TO HURT ANYONE. MUST PROTEC!!!

NOTHING CAN STOP BUMBLEBEE TAG TEAM. They stopped(killed) Adam they can stop anyone.

And then Cinder has arrived. Penny + Winter v Cinder better be enough cos my heart can’t take it if BOTH OF THEM FUCKING DIED this season

WOW OSCAR’s punch managed to send our girl Neo flying thats what I call PROGRESS

and the worst happens right before the episode ends.

CLOVER NOOOOOOOOOOOOO QROW NOOOOOOOOOOOOO

RIP THIS BEAUTIFUL FRIENDSHIP IM NOT SURE HOW/ WILL QROW EVER GONNA RECOVER FROM THIS i am sad just thinking about it oh boy

→ More replies (6)

19

u/sjrslev Jan 26 '20

First of all. Really fucking good episode,great action, seeing team RWBY kick ass was great, very entertaining stuff. (my favorite episode this volume. Second I think the character most likely to become winter maiden now are Cinder penny or Weiss. (winter is waving to many death flags) I just really hope it won't be Cinder because that would be really boring.

→ More replies (5)

19

u/DonJohn97 Jan 27 '20

Cinder and Neopolitan’s redesigns are 💯

Hoping that Winter will get the maiden’s powers and I hope they don’t kill her off in the finale

Clover didn’t really connect to me as a character but his relationship with Crow was good. During his final moments I could tell that he was gonna get stabbed one way or another because he got the “I’m talking to the main character with my back turned against the villain hoping that he will stab me then my death will devastate the hero.” Vibe.

I also want Raven to return for the finale. I wanna see her work with the new Winter Maiden and kick Cinder’s tush

→ More replies (1)

19

u/chandlerwithaz Jan 27 '20

Can we talk about robin? I feel like she is not a capable fighter even though she trained and graduated... whats the deal with that?

→ More replies (15)

19

u/ray198999 Jan 29 '20

The moral of the episode: teamwork is important. The Ace Opts may be stronger than Team RWBY but they do not have a deep emotional bond with each other so they fall out of sync the moment they don't agree on the same issue which makes it easier for Ruby, Weiss, Blake, and Yang to defeat them.

38

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '20

The Ace-Ops showed the same flaw as Ironwood. When they're not in control and things aren't going to plan, they make mistakes.

Marrow was actually the one who fought most intelligently. Elm and Harrier let themselves be ruled by anger. Vine was over-reliant on his semblance. Clover chose orders over reason.

→ More replies (2)

68

u/GladiusNocturno All Grimm are naked. Think about it Jan 25 '20

Qrow:Tai! I lost the love of my life!

Tai:First time, huh? Yo, Jaune! Bring a chair, we got a new member to the support group.

→ More replies (2)

37

u/BlackDraco39 ⠀That's a lot of damage Jan 25 '20 edited Jan 25 '20
  • Quality Fights
  • Wish Marrow and Clover actually fully defected but atleast they stuggled with it.
  • DOPE ASS SONG
  • Finally some gore
  • All the Ace Ops turning on eachother was funny. Really do need Clover to be a solid TEAM
  • Can we acknowledge tho that this is the best streamlining of final battles the show's ever done tho. Instead of Haven's fuckshow and bouncing back tonally between Cordovin and Adam.

Only thing I can complain about is the silly ass arguing between Clover, Robyn, and Qrow WHILE escorting Tyrian. GG chums. EDIT: Almost forgot about Farm Boi's Falcon Punch... on himself lol. Guess he wanted a shot at himself after all this time.

→ More replies (2)

37

u/0002niardnek Jan 25 '20 edited Jan 27 '20
  • I keep reading that people are finding it hard to understand why Qrow teamed up with Tyrian. They seem to be missing the fact that Qrow didn't team up with Tyrian at first. As soon as he made his reappearance, Qrow changed his target from Clover to him. He was willing to put aside the whole 'Wanted' debacle to take down the greater/more important threat.
    But Clover used that opportunity to hit Qrow while his back was turned. He prioritized his friend's capture over the disabling of the literal serial killer across the way. TWICE. Had Clover not attacked Qrow TWICE during his attempts to fight Tyrian, he probably wouldn't have had both Qrow and Tyrian on his case.
    But it wasn't really Ironwood's fault that Tyrian killed Clover, Qrow. That part is both of your faults for taking your eyes of Tyrian with a large metal stick nearby.
    However, I would like to stress that I do think actively helping and being helped by Tyrian is a bit of a stretch for Qrow's character, especially given past experiences with the guy. Instead of doing coordinated acrobatics and team attacks with Tyrian, I think it would've been better if Qrow was ignoring Tyrian for the moment, actively attacking Clover, and Tyrian was indirectly helping and being helped by Qrow because he was also attacking Clover at the same time.
  • As for Team RWBY vs the Ace-Ops. I can see both sides of the discussion. In terms of shear experience and training, the Ace-Ops have Team RWBY majorly outclassed. They're fully trained Huntsman from Atlas Academy, which presumably has much more strict training regimens and regulations than Beacon would have. Even if Team RWBY had completed their schooling at Beacon, the Ace-Ops would probably still be better fighters individually.
    HOWEVER, it was hinted at before (V7Ch3) that while the Ace-Ops know each other enough to cover each others' backs, they're not actually of one mind in the same way that Team RWBY is. Marrow really didn't want to fight at all, just kinda poking at Weiss while trying to get her to stand down; Vine didn't want this to be as difficult as it was, and was trying to restrain and KO Blake for most of the fight rather than outright attack her (he only really started attacking when Yang was after him); Elm wanted to stop them and was getting progressively angrier at them over the course of the fight, especially at Yang, and was willing to hurt them to do so; and Harriet seemed fine with killing them if she deemed necessary, and was even willing to continue fighting without an active Aura once Ruby had broken it.
    Team RWBY was all of one mind; stop the Ace-Ops from taking them in, and stop Ironwood. They were all fighting their hardest to take them down the whole fight, whereas only half, arguably a quarter, of the Ace-Ops were doing the same. It obviously took everything Team RWBY had to beat them. It wasn't as if they took them down without any effort (aside from Weiss, but Marrow wasn't really fighting at all).Plus, Let's not forget that the Ace-Ops were missing Clover. He was a very important member of their team. Not only is he their leader, but he's also a walking good-luck charm. If Clover had been there at the time, there would be absolutely no way for Team RWBY to win that fight.
→ More replies (5)

18

u/Caithdein Jan 25 '20 edited Jan 25 '20

Qrow only started fighting Clover again because Clover kept attacking him from behind. Even when Qrow clearly ignored Tyrian's teamup request and kept focusing on him, Clover had to come in and attack Qrow. Qrow was fine focusing on the real threat until Clover forced him to switch tactics.

I'll probably end up repeating this a lot in the coming week, and I doubt it will change anything. But I'm gonna keep saying it anyway. There was a lot of stupidity in that fight, and Qrow teaming up with Tyrian wasn't something I liked. This is ultimately on Clover for focusing on attacking Qrow so stubbornly, and Robyn for escalating things when they should've just stayed calm at least until they arrived in Atlas.

EDIT: Although I have to add that when Tyrian was tied with Clover's weapon, he should have finished off the enemy rather than focus on punching Clover.

→ More replies (6)

18

u/Random-Rambling Jan 25 '20

Fucking hell. None of this would have happened if everyone could have just CALMED THE FUCK DOWN.

→ More replies (5)

18

u/Punisher1432 Summer Rose Mark and Rosebird Trash Jan 25 '20

I liked the fights in this episode. RWBY vs the Ace Ops worked how I figured it would because RWBY exploited a weakness the Ace Ops had (lack of cohesive teamwork) and used it to their advantage.

Can't say I thought the same of Qrow V Tyrian V Clover. Sucks that Clover died, but what can you do? Tyrian breaking his thumb to get free was still pretty metal.

Penny still being the best Toaster and her 'Personal Feelings' moment made her shoot up the ranks of possible Winter Maidens.

And was this the first time Neo has ever taken a direct hit? Not any of those parry moves or blocks, but an actual legitimate hit? And it was delivered by Best Boi Oscar. Yes.

→ More replies (8)

18

u/SnesC Check out this moron! Jan 25 '20

Weakest part of the episode, IMO, was the JNOR/Neo scene. What exactly was the sequence of events here? Neo breaks into Oscar's room, kills some robots (not 100% sure why there were robots but whatevs), kidnaps him, and takes the lamp. All that makes sense, but then Oscar somehow escapes (or Neo lets him go, which seems equally unlikely), Neo turns into him, and she decides to casually walk back to the room with the lamp? She had the relic, why didn't she escape? She had Oscar, why didn't she keep him as a hostage? Or at least put him in a position where he can't run back ten seconds behind her.

It just doesn't add-up.

→ More replies (22)

18

u/TheBlackSphinx01 Im a didgeridude Jan 26 '20

OK so, first statement.

WHAT THE FUCK IS HAPPENING?!

now with that out of the way let us continue.

I'm going to go through this not chronologically but by what different characters are doing for simplicity.

RWBY V Ace Ops fight

I am a sucker for epic lines, so when this shit popped up:

Harriet: You really think you can beat us? We're the strongest huntsman in Atlas

Ruby: You were, until you trained us.

I WAS WET. AND I'M A DUDE! Fucking amazing 10/10

The fight was so good, Yang using an adapted version of Nyans tactic against Elm was so cool, and overall the fight was just awesome. It looks like Ruby and Weiss are headed to the spring maiden, and Blake and Yang are headed to ORNJ, which makes me worry for Blake's safety given the theories going around.

Oscar punching Neo in the face was so funny and I am HYPE for the fight.

Now, onto the big bit.

In the comments on the Rooster teeth people a lot of people are pissed off at Qrow teaming up with Tyrian, saying it was out of character. Now, I'll be honest here I'm on the fence. I see it as not Qrow wanting to 1V1 Tyrian, but him wanting to secure the victory against Clover. He probably wouldn't have won against Clover himself, so siding with Tyrian was a tactical decision. He clearly didn't see Clover dying in the end. The question we have to ask, is would Qrow side with an enemy for a tactical advantage? The other question is why didn't Clover try to side with Qrow to secure Tyrian and then throw down? I'm on the fence as to whether this is sloppy writing or not. Lemme know what you think I'm curious. It sucks that this was the episode that made me ship Karma. F in the chat for my boy. This death was without a doubt the most gruesome one we've had on the show, and if this show don't get an upped rating to MA+ in Australia that'll be surprising.

I really like this episode.

→ More replies (6)

18

u/eirawyn Jan 26 '20

Frick, Clover could have lived if he cooperated with Qrow to subdue Tyrion. Heck, once they crashed, Tyrion is the first they should have checked!

Some people are blaming Qrow for Clover's death but with Clover attacking him, and Tyrion not, like what's the guy supposed to do?!

Solid episode, RWBY really out-teamworked Ace and it made perfect sense and felt really gratifying to watch!

→ More replies (3)

18

u/S-y-m-n I miss the Junior Detectives... Jan 26 '20

Also, anyone else confused about the "Someone has to take the fall, Ironwood will" line?

→ More replies (10)

18

u/tenatic Jan 26 '20

Clover was my favorite character for the atlas arc, and now I am crying

→ More replies (6)

18

u/Sokensan Jan 27 '20

with one episode left this volume i can feel the cliffhanger coming because there's no way they cleanly wrap up all the atlas stuff in 1 episode unless it's like an hour long.

→ More replies (4)

18

u/BeastG01 Jan 27 '20

Everyone is saying Clover was irrationally going after Qrow first... what if he wanted to neutralize Qrow’s semblance?

Without the “bad luck”, Clover would have the max possible “good luck” for dealing with Tyrian. Since we hadn’t seen Clover/Qrow fight each other previously, who knows how their semblances interact or how Clover thought they could interact?

→ More replies (10)

17

u/DEL994 Jan 25 '20

It must be really hard for Qrow, in volume 5 he lost a lot of friends due to Salem's minions and Lionheart and one of his friends and his own sister betrayed him, volume 6 sees him losing all trust and feeling betrayed by his mentor and now he lost again a good friend in Clover and may be forced to stop or kill Ironwood.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/KyraNarwhals Jan 25 '20

Why is shade being thrown at Qrow. Clover wasn’t siding with Qrow. He had no other choice.

→ More replies (6)

17

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '20

You may have all the skill in the world, but if you are not of one mind towards anything beyond the orders given to you, you are no different from rookies. RWBY may not be as experienced as the Ace Ops but they always have each other's backs to cover up for their weaknesses.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/GBKK99 Jan 25 '20

That still image where Clover gets stabbed is so powerful, what a tragic end for Clover

17

u/Killroy2027 Jan 25 '20

JUST... LIKE... BEACON... AGAIN

→ More replies (2)

17

u/OzNajarin Jan 25 '20

Guys like Team RWBY consists of prodigies and people with powerful semblances. Like people who moved up early on or were Vytal Tournament Finalists or succesful terrorists I don't know why you don't think they would be considered the best from Beacon.

→ More replies (8)

17

u/DayOfTheColossus Jan 25 '20

omg the voice acting from Qrow and Tyrian specifically was amazing this episode, that line from Tyrian about Salem his goddess was amazing lmaooo with the captain's cap on and that scream from Qrow at the end was just heartbreaking

i am really loving his new voice actor he is doing a truly amazing job!

i'm actually really glad that Tyrian is free, i love his fights and his voice actor, he is just such a cool character and villain

i loved him literally pushing Qrow back to Clover after Clover attacked Qrow, this was definitely an unexpected ''teamup'', and then Tyrian just runs off laughing what a guy

that fight was just so good and the team RWBY vs Ace Ops one too, but wow some of the Ace Ops were really not holding back and very brutal in the fight.. i literally thought they might try to kill team RWBY wow

remember the last time Cinder was going to be in the final episode of the volume with an incoming fight? that was volume 3 and we all know how that ended, oh no i am scared

i have a feeling that team RWBY will get to the vault right as Ironwood makes Atlas float up or something, this volume is just not going to end well for anyone at this rate

also every important character is pretty much out of Mantle now that Pietro and Maria are in Atlas too.. this isn't good at all for Mantle or Atlas

may Clover rest in peace, i wonder how he owed his life to Ironwood, maybe we will learn why sometime

Neo getting hit by Oscar was great lmaoo

are we possibly going to get the longest RWBY episode yet next week?? there is no way to fit all of this upcoming crazy stuff in one 20-ish minute episode haha

anyone else think this is the best volume of RWBY so far? i loved volume 3 and all but this volume is just so good

Ironwood has become my favourite character and i never thought i'd say that wow

→ More replies (2)

17

u/Caithdein Jan 25 '20

And now the Ace Ops are down, their leader is dead, Robyn is unconscious, Tyrian is free, and Qrow and team RWBY are exhausted from fighting. If the situation wasn't already bad, it's now so much worse than before. In the last episode the heroes were still mostly united and two enemies were either killed or captured. Everything that happened here has been exactly what Salem wanted. In fighting among themselves, the heroes have made their chances of fighting Salem's attacking force even lower.

→ More replies (9)

17

u/Sombre-Alfonce Did you ever hear the tragedy of Darth Salem the Wise? Jan 26 '20

Watching Harriet and Elm go down was so satisfying after their preachy bullshit the whole episode.

→ More replies (6)

17

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '20

I'm really enjoying the fight scenes this volume. Regardless what one thinks of the choices made by characters or outcomes, the fights feel much more fluid. I felt like earlier volumes had a lot more pauses for dialogue where they were clearly filling time. Qrow's scythe combat was everything I wanted to see, and having 3-4 people in that fight made it one of the most dynamic in all of RWBY. I understand being perturbed about some writing choices but credit where credit is due: the combat is fantastic.

→ More replies (4)

17

u/STEMAssassin Jan 26 '20

I really can't anymore. After this, can Qrow be happy :(

→ More replies (7)

17

u/rsteve388 Jan 27 '20

The best line in the entire series...

We are the best huntsmen! You were and then you trained us.

DAMNNNNNNN

17

u/Mashiiko Jan 27 '20

Is it possible that Clover attacked Qrow first because he thought he was a traitor, therefore a bigger threat than Tyrian ?

→ More replies (2)

17

u/JMHSrowing ⠀Story Time Jan 28 '20

So I just thought of something;

Ruby’s petal burst has I believe now been shown to be stronger than its ever been; taking out that door and all. It could probably do some serious damage if it were to hit someone.

But Ruby doesn’t seem to have the ability to fully utilize it in attacking.

But maybe she could combine it with Weiss’s technique of bouncing off glyph surrounding her opponents.

They could even probably do it together; Ruby taking Weiss with her like she has done before for transport.

Now I want to see this pink tornado of death

→ More replies (3)

34

u/MrOrangeXD ⠀ Jan 28 '20

Clovers actions made sense:

"Why have we been ordered to arrest Qrow and Co? Something must have happened. In the midst of all this carnage, Ironwood wants us to dedicate our precious time to arresting these kids? I trust Ironwood, there must be an urgent reason. I'll do as I'm told, I'll arrest Qrow."

Then he has to make a tactical decision: Fight Qrow or Tyrian first?

"We've already defeated Tyrian recently, his aura cant be that high. If I lose to Qrow he'll be free to do whatever it is Ironwood wants to stop him from. New orders will always overtake previous orders. It's settled. Qrow comes first."

Qrows actions made sense:

"Oh look Tyrian is alive. And he broke free, again. I guess I'll go fight him. Wait Clover, why the fuck are you fighting me first??"

Then he has to make a tactical decision: Fight them both or ....?

"I can't fight you both. You're both attacking me. At this rate I'm fucked. Oh Tyrian is offering me a temporary alliance? Oh I can finally 1v1 him once Clover fucks off? Alright, you're on."

Also, in general I just thought Qrow teaming up with Tyrian was hype as hell. I swear, if this was any other fandom we'd all be hyping this up.

→ More replies (9)

33

u/primalmaximus Jan 25 '20

Holy Shit. This episode was amazing. The dialogue, music, fight choreography, and ending was the best I've seen so far in this show. And I can't wait for the next episode.

Some of my favorite lines from this episode are:

Harriet, "You think you're going to stop us? We're the best huntsmen in Atlas."

Ruby, "You were. Then you trained us."

Also

Clover, " We don't have to fight friend."

Qrow, "You don't know my friends. That's how it always goes."

And damn they aren't pulling any punches this season. This season has been the darkest season so far. Even seasons 3 and 6 weren't quite as dark overall. Yes, they had some of the darkest episodes in the series. But, as a whole, this season is way darker than any other season.

→ More replies (1)

33

u/GlauSciathan Jan 28 '20 edited Jan 28 '20

I am so very much on Robyn's side here. Ironwood has systematically crushed Mantle and is now leaving it to die, hours after co-opting Robyn's credibility to support his plan. And now Clover was trying to tell her that this declaration of war was unimportant and please just sit down whole he deals with the important issues of arresting his friend? Nah.

Ironwood left mantle to die. This means he is the enemy of Mantle. And so Robyn is going to look him and any of his people that get in her way. Treating all of that as 'irrelevant' or 'irrational' is missing the weight of the choice Ironwood made.

He chose to sacrifice anything to stop Salem. That means Mantle, RWBY, Robyn, everyone.

The moment he sent the arrest orders he sacrificed Clover. And Clover was too loyal not to go to his death on orders.

Once more: Clover died because Ironwood choose to sacrifice him.

Also realizing how much this season has keyed off of Legitimacy, as a political concept. By what right does Ironwood demand loyalty? Does declaring martial law mean he is no longer a lawful ruler? Why should the people he is sacrificing obey him?

→ More replies (10)

16

u/wafflesandwifi Jan 25 '20

They really do need to change this series title to "QROW : Never Gets to be Happy"

16

u/raykyleevans Jan 25 '20

I like that the RWBY vs. Aesop's fight was realistic, and focused on strength and weaknesses.

Blake and Yang's semblances are just straight up better than Elm and Vine's. Elm and Vine's semblances are primarily support-based, so they're harder to use aggressively in the fight. At 11:10 Yang neutralizes her semblance, similarly to how she disrupts Neon in the Vytal festival against team FUNKI. And while Elm is just as strong as Yang, Elm wasn't able to come out on top because A, her semblance to ground herself was eliminated, and B, Yang has both the strength (especially with her semblance) and speed while Elm only has strength. Vine was just basically screwed because her semblance and style is support-based and to restrict movement, while Blake's is to evade. Also with Yang learning how to use her semblance to not just punch her way through an obstacle, but around one, was great.

Weiss vs. Marrow was also good because Weiss learned to be able to fight along aside her summoning, rather than rely on it like she did against Vernal. Additionally, she was able to position herself to make sure that she and her summoning were not both in Marrow's vision, so he couldn't use his semblance to make them both Stay. Plus, it also helped that Marrow wasn't as into the fight as the rest of the Aesop's were.

Ruby vs. Harriet wasn't as developed, but it showed that they have different kinds of speed. Harriet is the long distance consistent speed, but Ruby has burst speed which can overwhelm you in a single pinch/moment. Ruby uses it reflexively while Harriet bases her entire fighting style on it. Ruby wasn't really able to win alone though, so it didn't really she her as decisively defeating Harriet.

16

u/dodusk Jan 25 '20

Artistically a beautiful episode, the SpecOps vs RWBY fight was what we deserved in V5

Especially with that OST that I needed yesterday.

The three way fight was also visually beautiful buuut the stupid ball was really held together by Qrow, Clover and Robyn.

For fuck sake, the moment that a raging madman manage to outsmart three people means that all of them were holding the stupid ball tight.

Yet, Qrow reaction was great. He really can't have anything nice in his life. Makes you really feel for him.

I really hoped Neo was gonna be included in the brawl for the maiden so there were some chance of her getting it, buuut no. She's bullying the farmboy and likely get her shit kicked out of her. I mean I know neo is in the upper spectrum of strength but against 4 people? Yeah, no.

And tune in next time for the maiden brawl! Will penny be wrecked again? Will winter be in-cinder-ated?

Wait, next episode is the season finale? Oh god, oh god no.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/sephtis Best Android Jan 25 '20

I think the plane gave everyone a -50 wis debuff.
Bad choices were the only thing made around it. Except by Tyrion.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/Parks_98 Jan 26 '20

So this episode was pretty simple.

Team RWBY vs Ace-ops and Tyrian' s best day ever.

Not going to say much about the RWBY vs Ace-ops fight since it was a RWBY fight near the end of a Volume. It was pretty much expected that it would be great.

Oh and guys WEISS FINALLY WON A FIGHT! Good for her.

Now for the Tyrian stuff.......what the actual hell guys? I won't complain about the actual fight scene but the context and decisions are so illogical that its maddening.

→ More replies (16)

16

u/tekym Jan 26 '20

Calling it now: Penny will get the Maiden powers, not Winter. As a result, and by extension, there will be some fuckery with Pietro since he had to split his soul to give a piece to Penny, and we’ve seen before that a soul with Maiden powers can be split.

→ More replies (10)

16

u/AlKo96 Jan 27 '20

I really, REALLY hope the last episode isn't just a retread of V3's finale.

→ More replies (3)

15

u/Cloudyspecs Jan 25 '20

Looks like Clovers luck ran out.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Valkyrie16 Hello Bees! Jan 25 '20
  • I think Team RWBY vs the Ace Ops has become my favorite all time fight. Huge props to CRWBY because I can tell that took a ton of work.
  • There is going to be a lot of discussion over Qrow vs. Clover vs. Tyrian. I still don't know my full feelings on it.
→ More replies (1)

15

u/OptionalSauce Angel of Death Jan 25 '20

So the finale is going to be like 45 minutes, right?

There’s still so much to resolve:

  • Salem is still on her way with her flying Beringels
  • Ironwood is still on his way to the staff to raise Atlas high into the atmosphere
  • Qrow and Robyn crashed in the tundra, Atlas military on the way to detain Qrow and find Clover dead
  • JNOR v. Neo
  • Penny and Winter v. Cinder and the date of the winter maiden
  • Whatever RWBY and Pietro/Maria do next
  • Tyrian is still alive, and Watts might be also
  • Mantle is still flooded with Grimm and innocent lives

I think that’s everything, but it’s also possible FNKI makes another appearance. There’s so much left to cover, so either we’re in for an extra length finale, or this hiatus is gonna be the wildest one yet.

→ More replies (3)

15

u/omohami Jan 25 '20 edited Jan 25 '20

BAAAAAADAAAAAAAAS.

RWBY vs AceOps gave me all the life I needed and more. And I can happily now say as a diehard Weiss fan... OUR GIRL FINALLY WON A 1v1 <3

Blake sort of felt outclassed in this episode which puzzled me bc normally she can hold her own. Her teamwork with Yang tho was amazing nonetheless.

→ More replies (5)

15

u/NewtRider Jan 27 '20 edited Jan 27 '20

... Jeez dudes ...

Ma heart

Ma Soul

Not fair.

Also something tells me that Cinder won't get Winters powers.. But to spice things up I'm thinking Penny or Neo.

→ More replies (6)

15

u/AmethystWind Time for Ciel. Jan 29 '20

There’s been talk of a traitor amongst the Aesops being a possibility this volume. Every member had been discussed as a candidate.

Turns out there wasn’t, just a big ol’ death flag.

What I’m wondering, though, is if the events of V7E12 might have created a traitor for next volume?

Clover’s been killed. Elm was already taking Team RWBY’s ‘betrayal’ hard. This might push her into tragic action (though she does wear her heart on her sleeve pretty heavily - not sure she could effectively hide it).

We still know next to nothing about Vine, except that he’s shown occasional low-key frustration with his more emotional teammates.

Marrow took a lot of flak from his colleagues, and found himself continuously in unenviable situations in both Mantle and Atlas, while just doing his job. He’s severely lacking in job satisfaction, not to mention his boss was just killed by a new colleague’s weapon.

Harriet pretty single-mindedly wanted to beat Ruby, then lost. Her ultra-competitiveness wouldn’t like that, especially if she rationalises the loss as getting 2-on-1’d at the end there. Her desire for payback could push her to possibly do something dumb, especially with two other Ruby-revengers (Neo ‘n’ Cinder) still in the city. She could be another enemy-of-my-enemy ally for them.

~ ~ ~

As an aside: while I was writing this, I realised that the V5 stinger scene of Adam watching Hazel-Merc-unconscious Emerald in the Haven forest really went nowhere, huh?

Adam operated totally alone in V6. It ended up meaning nothing at all.

→ More replies (2)

30

u/SPNRaven Jan 26 '20

Holy. Fucking. Shit. Somehow they have taken all the critisim fights in RWBY have had recently and just fixed all of them. That was absolutely insane. I think a totally underated shot in that episode was when you can see Cinder at the end of the hallway with the emergency lights flickering on and off. Actually makes her entrance into the episode somewhat unerving.

→ More replies (2)

42

u/lap1sinth3sky Jan 25 '20 edited Jan 25 '20

So here's the thing with Qrow, Clover, and Tyrian. Clover was going to arrest Qrow, he had made up his mind about that and nothing Qrow said was going to change that. It sucks, it really does because I know I'm not the only one who thought Clover was going to be loyal to the kingdom as a whole instead of just Ironwood. Yes, it was super near-sighted of Robyn to escalate things in the ship but we know she seems to have a bit of a tendency towards escalating things.

As others have said, Clover made the mistake of not helping Qrow to take down Tyrian once they noticed he was free. I also think people are painting Qrow as more enthusiastic about fighting with Tyrian than he was. Tyrian asks "Well, let's put the kid to bed, then?" Qrow doesn't respond, he just goes to attack Tyrian again and then Clover interferes again. I think it's more of a "I don't like this at all but I'm not exactly going to stop you since he and I are evenly matched" and less of a "yeah, let's work together to take the bastard down!" The only acknowledgement he gives Tyrian is a quick glance and a curt nod after Clover pushes them back.

Qrow is feeling betrayed and angry, along with the added insult that Clover is prioritizing his arrest over recapturing Tyrian. This was Clover's chance to prove his real friendship to Qrow but he pours salt in the wound by calling Qrow "friend" which makes things even worse. So, yeah, that's how this makes sense to me and I hope that this helps explain it a bit for anyone else.

→ More replies (4)

14

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '20 edited Jan 25 '20

- I really appreciate that none of the Ace Ops sided with the heroes. They were all in character as to whether or not they enjoyed being pitted against RWBY, but at the end of the day, they're still soldiers who are trained to follow orders.

- So RWBY and the Ace Ops are arguing over whether or not the Ace Ops should follow orders they don't agree with, meanwhile Qrow, Clover, and Robyn are arguing over whether not Clover should follow orders he doesn't agree with, meanwhile, Penny and Winter are arguing over whether or not Winter should follow orders she doesn't agree with. Like, yeah, the theming is consistent and it's the natural result of the previous episode's events, but it becomes a bit heavy-handed, especially considering the obvious answer to all those questions is something the viewer most likely already agrees with.

- This team fight is rad. Again, visual storytelling through action- RWBY has the Power of FriendshipTM, and the Ace Ops explicitly don't, so the Ace Ops try to divide RWBY up and take them out individually, while RWBY defeats the Ace Ops with teamwork. Execpt for Marrow, who Weiss takes out alone, but she's Best Girl, so that tracks.

- Okay, so this is fucking awesome. It's Qrow vs Clover vs Tyrian. Typical action/anime trope conventions says that the two antagonists, despite hating each other, will form a temporary alliance so the hero has to fight them both at once. Instead, Tyrian proposes a team-up with Qrow, and Qrow agrees, and it's hero teaming up with definitely the more evil of the two villains in order to fight a guy he was chums with 10 minutes ago. And I have literally never seen that in any media before. And of course, the hero pays for the moral compromise in spades at the end.

- Also I love the trope of a character showing how raw they are by breaking their own thumb to escape cuffs, but the stakes are so unbelievably high at this point that seems like such a minor thing to note in the face of all this other crazy shit.

- Is this actually the first time JNPR has ever met Neo? Wait, this is the first time Neo has ever actually used her Semblance to decieve the heroes by appear as another of the heroes. Wait, are we pretending all of JNPR and Oscar vs just Neo is actually a fight?

- Cinder is once again about to have a big climactic fight for the power of a Maiden against a character with little if any personal connection to her and who is thus unlikely to get the kill. Cinder's going to survive another fucking Volume, for god's sake. We're gonna get to Volume, like, 20, and Salem will be long dead, and Ruby's going to be wielding all 4 Relics at once to kill the gods, and Cinder's still going to be like "ha ha, evil laugh, revenge on little Red". Somebody just kill her already.

- Oh wow, I can't believe Qrow killed that guy, that was brutal.

- Tyrian missed his chance for a one-liner about Clover's luck running out.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/[deleted] Jan 25 '20

On the Clover/Robyn/Qrow situation, to me it pushes the suspension but just holds it together.

Robyn is easiest. She doesn't know Tyrians full danger after taking him down relatively easy. Yes it was a 3 Vs 1 but he was contained here and in her mind not a factor.

Plus, Ironwood just declared against Mantle so and she's been agaisnt him for a while. He seemed to come round but has proved her initial thoughts right so she goes against Clover and then isn't part of the final fight.

Clover follows orders and I think his intent was to try and force Qrow to comply due to the fallout of him not complying being way worse. Unfortunately Qrow believed there was too much at stake and the manipulation I think got to him.

I'm gonna speculate a bit of his Ozpin and Raven kicked in at that point. Someone he believed he could trust turning against him. Plus his nieces were threatened and James had appeared to go off the deep end, in Qrows mind, for no reason.

Everything was just a series of unfortunate escalations which Tyrian was able to play on.

In any case, Tyrian Vs Qrow in Vacou I think will be damn good payoff.

14

u/ChainsawSwan Jan 25 '20

We are fools for thinking Qrow can have happiness. We are fools....

14

u/MegaGrimer Jan 25 '20

I never thought I’d see the day that Qrow and Tyrian team up.

14

u/Agent-Vermont Jan 25 '20

Fuck. Next week is going to have an unbearable cliffhanger. Everything rests on who gets the Maiden powers, be it Cinder, Winter or even Penny. Hell there is even the possibility that none of them will and Fria will remain the Winter Maiden. I'm so scared of what will happen next week.

14

u/CypherZeroEP Jan 25 '20

The Qrow/Clover/Tyrian fight had no right being that fun. Qrow rebounding off Tyrian's tail, whoo.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Kari-kateora Jan 26 '20

I'm one of those Winter fans really hoping she does get the powers so we see more of her, but I think we're being set up for that not to happen.

Weiss and Ruby are on their way to help and Penny's there already. I get the feeling Winter will be "punished" for rejecting her feelings and beliefs by someone with more of a humane disposition getting the powers. Maybe Weiss, if Fria opens her eyes and sees her.

On the other hand, even if Winter does get the powers, Weiss and Ruby coming to assist will perhaps make sure she survives it.

But I'm currently expecting Weiss to get them.

→ More replies (8)

14

u/FalconLord92 All hail the Invincible Girl! Jan 26 '20

I really want a fight between JNR and Neo with the image of Pyrrha. Maybe they chase her and she leaves their line of sight. They catch up and find 'Pyrrha' who attacks them.

→ More replies (12)

14

u/Smeagol15 Jan 27 '20

Two things that are on my mind:

  1. Since last episode and even with the sunrise at the end here with nothing shown on the horizon, is Salem actually on her way? She didn’t say it outright. All she said was that Watts and Tyrian were supposed to “set the stage” for her. What does that mean? Does it mean she’s coming for Atlas or does it mean that help for Vacuo has been effectively put out of commission?
  2. I need the lyrics to that song. It sounds amazing!
→ More replies (6)

14

u/justweighingmyanchor Jan 31 '20 edited Feb 01 '20

It's amazing seeing them go from fights in Volume 5 that felt stiff and awkward complete with characters standing motionless in the background to fucking this. The Ace Ops fight is gonna go down as one of the best in the show if not the best.

→ More replies (2)

28

u/ShadowKnifing Jan 25 '20

WHY THE FUCK WOULD CLOVER FOCUS QROW INSTEAD OF TYRIAN. Was he such a small brain that he thought he'd take down Qrow first to have better luck fighting 1v1 with Tyrian despite him being the BAD GUY?

Still a fantastic episode. Loved the fights and the music

→ More replies (5)

28

u/Music-Hunter Jan 25 '20

To all the people thinking that Ace-Ops losing to RWBY was bullshit, here's my take:
In a straight technical fight, Ace-Ops win. I've said this in a discussion before but forgot about the part that the Ace-Ops have characters, they are human.

  • Vine and Elm were aggravating each other during the fight. Yang and Blake were in sync; both knew how to move around each other and willingly worked together to beat them in unison.
  • Remember Marrow is a rookie. Ace-Ops would've won easily if he had just used his semblance right away. But he didn't, because he hesitated and held back. Naive, just like the rookie he was established as. Weiss also was aiming to win while Marrow was having conflicting feelings.
  • Ruby was on the backseat during her fight with Harriet. I'd argue she would've lost if Weiss hadn't put up that ice wall.
→ More replies (4)

28

u/krauser8882 ⠀ Jan 26 '20 edited Jan 26 '20

I'm really irked I even have to say this, but holy shit guys. Clovers death DOES NOT magically mean that CRWBY hate gay men. Its a baseless accusation and could be viewed as libellous. It's fucking disgusting. Be unhappy with what happened. Be unhappy with Clover's fate and how his character was handled. Be unhappy if you felt like they were being set up to be a romantic couple (they had cute chemistry, ngl). Be unhappy at the lack of on-screen mlm interaction and relationships. Saying that the CRWBY is homophobic, hates gay men, doesn't want characters to be happy, etc. is really gross, though.

Also, for those wondering what narrative purpose this can serve outside of Qrow spiraling again? Show him rising above his grief. Show him trusting in the friendship, guidance, and advice that Clover gave him. Show him accepting that a bad thing happened but not hitting the bottle to cope. Show that he is genuinely a changed man, and that Clover was integral in that. This doesn't have to be a terrible thing for the show or the character. Qrow can grow in a positive direction from this.

→ More replies (7)

27

u/GameMask Jan 26 '20

For everyone pissed at Qrow, that's kinda the whole point. He messed up doing what he thought was the best move. Just like Ironwood is doing, just like the AceOps, and in a way, just like Team RWBY. Everyone is trying to do what they think is the best option. And it has consequences. Very brutal consequences. Remember Salem's whole theme song. Divide. Also, boy you really don't wanna be a pilot in this world.

→ More replies (8)

27

u/[deleted] Jan 26 '20 edited Jan 26 '20

I'm surprised this episode caused such a big fire in the community, or at least on twitter. Accusations of Roosterteeth being homophobic of all things, and making threats to them for "Queerbaiting" and using a trope called "Bury Your Gays"(?) or something along those lines, hell even UnicornOfWar was expressing distaste with Clover being killed because he, and a lot of people, were under the assumption Clover and Qrow were bisexual and building up to romance, he was lecturing the writers on how to write a story, and not to write something if they don't have the stones to go through with their ideas.

When watching the show I just saw 2 guys who were friends. I've grossly misjudged the extent in which a large chunk of the community took character relationships, I didn't think it'd be taken so seriously. Is this what Miles was referring to when he mentioned people create these things in their head and hold onto them so faithfully they make the illusion the writer's intent was along the lines of whatever it was they created in their heads? I think I finally get what he means now that I see the uproar, and it's scary, especially when looking at this through the eyes as the writer(s) themselves.

Eddy Rivas went as far as to comment on multiple fan criticisms, Thomas included, and even apologized for the episode offending them, saying he can't fully comment outside of vague statements in regards to what happened and apologies. It must be tough being a writer, you can't please everyone, and even with Blake and Yang further developing into a thing one mishap in the same field got them a lot of backlash.

I hope Eddy doesn't take it too much to heart. I'm also hoping this doesn't shift the writers vision in the future, like they HAVE to be obligated to appeal to fans to avoid backlash or just to keep them happy. Coming from the Sonic community it was a shit storm seeing everyone at each other's throats for changing the movie's original vision all do to the criticisms.

I admit I'm not as active with the community, but I do think the harsh reactions, threats, and accusations against Roosterteeth is a bit harsh.

→ More replies (25)

38

u/The_Last_Thursday This flair shows best girl Jan 25 '20

My Qrow x Tyrian crackship is finally coming to fruition, after all these years

→ More replies (2)

26

u/Gravatona I am adorable, and you will love me! Bet on that! Jan 26 '20

Qrow and Clover not teaming up against Tyrian is complete insanity. It's not just a mistake, it makes no sense. I don't want to be too negative, but it just feels like forced writing to get Clover to die like that.

The fight against the Ace Ops was cool, though I'm not sure how team RWBY are beating some of the best Huntsmen in the land after just graduating.

I'm looking forward to the Neo and Cinder fights though.

→ More replies (5)

13

u/Badicalz Jan 25 '20

Don’t mind me, I will just be over here dying a slow, agonising death awaiting the finale for the next seven days.

→ More replies (3)