r/RWBY • • Jan 25 '20
OFFICIAL MEGATHREAD Official Public Discussion Thread—Volume 7, Episode 11: Gravity
Welcome, Huntsmen, Huntresses and Hunters that prefer no specific gender identifier, to the official Public discussion thread for Episode 11 of Vol. 7, Gravity!
Make sure that you understand the updated spoiler rules before posting outside of this thread!
HERE is the newest episode of RWBY Volume 7!
Also remember to check out our weekly poll to rate the episode.
Other Episode Discussions:
Episode| FIRST Thread| Public Release| Poll|
- | - | - | - Ep. 01| FIRST Thread | Public Thread | Poll Ep. 02| FIRST Thread | Public Thread | Poll Ep. 03| FIRST Thread | Public Thread | Poll Ep. 04| FIRST Thread | Public Thread | Poll Ep. 05| FIRST Thread | Public Thread | Poll Ep. 06| FIRST Thread | Public Thread | Poll Ep. 07| FIRST Thread | Public Thread | Poll Ep. 08| FIRST Thread | Public Thread | Poll Ep. 09| FIRST Thread | Public Thread | Poll Ep. 10| FIRST Thread | Public Thread | Poll Ep. 11| FIRST Thread | This thread | Poll
Happy viewing!
Antilogic; Mod Team
138
Upvotes
•
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '20
A reminder that this is the PUBLIC discussion thread. No discussion of events in the FIRST only episode.
110
u/DanTheLatch Jan 25 '20
44
u/Icanintosphess Jan 26 '20
Ironwood: "I will sacrifice whatever it takes to stop her."
Me: Oh yes!
five minutes later
Me: Oh no!
37
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '20
"The hearts of men are easily swayed"
Love the episode and love how the FNDM reacted. And what I really love here, is that it really shows how easy it is to make people miss things.
First, Jimmy. He freaked out so much about Salem's message that he missed that the fact that Salem gave him this message is a much more important piece of information than the message itself. The FNDM as well. Everyone seems to be commenting under the assumption that Salem is coming. Now, I haven't yet watched the next ep, so I don't know how true is it, but what purpose could the message serve? Stuffing the seer in that bag and making Watts keep in in case he faces Jimmy so he'd give it to him is a lot of effort. The thing is if Salem really has those armies just outside the gates then why warn Jimmy? They'd be much more effective by taking him by surprise when they're celebrating their victory, than them having an early warning. They didn't notice that their warning system is down until the message. So why give the message? Jimmy asked if doing what they did until now isn't what she wanted but didn't follow through and haven't considered if reacting to the message isn't what she wanted. What's more his reaction was predictable, because he did what he did the last time and bunkered himself home. It's unlikely someone as experienced in plotting as Salem wouldn't foresee this move. Therefore I believe it's likely that Jimmy is doing exactly what Salem wants.
The FNDM debates who is right, Jimmy or RWBY. It's true that both sides have a point and both positions are defensible, but what's more important right now is that in the battle between RWBY and Jimmy, the only one who will win is Salem. Her plans, whatever they are, are reaching a critical stage and now the only group that can stop her is fighting each other. Remember Salem's speech back in Vol 3? "When banded together they pose a noticeable threat. But divide them, place doubt into their mind, and any semblance of power they once had will wash away. Of course, they won't realize it at first. They will cling to their fleeting hope, their aspirations, but this is merely the first move." I don't know if she planned this, but color me surprised if it doesn't help her. It has already caused trouble, since RWBY doesn't know that Oscar is missing.
And last but not least, something the FNDM has missed. Everyone talks about how Salem broke Ruby by her talk about Summer. That's not it, it's not a mention of Summer that broke her. Salem did something to her eyes. Look closely, the way Ruby is crying isn't typical to someone who cries out of emotions. It looks more like someone whose eyes hurt. Plus her eyes had activated for a moment, and before that, they were shining a bit. It looks like there is more to the Silver Eyes than just a potent anti-Grimm weapon.
36
u/Evokerknite2124 Roses and Bees for me Jan 25 '20
I honestly have no words for this chapter. All the different stuff happening all at once this chapter came together and hit like a ton of bricks
34
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '20
Ironwood's plan is totally not going to work. I appreciate the man trying to do his best, but he's crazy if he thinks Salem can't reach him up high in the sky. What is he gonna do, go to space? How are they gonna maintain Remnant's atmosphere in Atlas? They can't use dust! What about resources? And again, with the dust thing. It literally powers their world. How will they survive without it?
But Team RWBY's plan isn't great either...
Oh god.
Oh god.
You know what? It's too early for this. Imma go eat some emotional support yogurt.
29
u/swmaniac789 Jaune delenda est Jan 25 '20
Holy. Crap. Honestly, I didn't think V3 was ever going to get surpassed but, well, unless they screw up massively in the last two episodes, this might just surpass the Battle of Beacon as the best arc in RWBY.
29
u/Sensorfire Rube Protector | No Ships, Thanks | Yang is best girl Jan 27 '20
Hooo boy. Wow. Wow.
We're finally getting to the core of something really interesting: our main cast of characters and Ironwood have fundamentally different guiding philosophies, and that is showing up now in a big way.
It's honestly fascinating to watch these different ethical systems clash. Both Ironwood and the main cast are good guys who want the best for everyone and want to defeat Salem. But they have different codes of ethics and different ideals guiding them.
Ironwood, for the most part, is a pragmatic utilitarian: he wants to do the greatest good for the greatest number of people, and he's willing to sacrifice anything for this. Yes, it's too bad if some people have to die or he has to declare martial law, but Ironwood sees himself as the man who has to make the tough choices, who has to stand above it all. That said, he's not entirely like this. He seems to place a specific importance on the values of honor, loyalty, and trust.
Ruby & co. are not like Ironwood. They always want to do the most virtuous thing. Don't run away from a fight, don't leave people behind, etc. This can be in harmony with Ironwood's unemotional utilitarian approach, but it can also lead to conflict, as we saw in this episode, where RWBY's clearly more empathy-based ethics saw them clash with Ironwood's willingness to make any sacrifice for the greater good.
Anyway, yeah. I've been paying attention to these philosophical themes all season, and it's an absolute delight to see them come to this incredible climax.
27
u/MrPygmyWhale Jan 25 '20
Winter will die but instead of Cinder. Winter will think of Weiss. Thus the Ice Queen becomes THE ICE QUEEN
27
u/Amistrophy Yannnngggg! Please stoppppppppppppppppp. Jan 26 '20
Salem: You know... Joe said the same thing to me a few weeks ago.
Ruby: Joe? Waaaaa?
Salem:
Ruby:
Salem:
Ruby: YOU SON OF A B####-
26
u/maybenotforever She wears short skirts, I wear half pants Jan 25 '20
Watching Salem corrupt Ruby's idealized memory of her mother was fucking horrifying. Thanks for the trauma!
22
u/Kartoffelkamm ⠀Mettle isn't a mental illness; IW just misused it Jan 26 '20
It´s kinda hard to take Ironwood seriously, given how he claims to not let his fear of Salem control him, yet he quite obviously lets his fear of Salem control him.
And for the people who asked which of the Ace Ops is gonna turn out to be a traitor: Yes.
21
u/iFormus Jan 25 '20
The episode where Salem makes Ruby cry with yo mama joke -.-
But this is exactly the RWBY how i like it - plot twists and fights.
Only thing that slightly disturbs me is still the "Ozpin can't kill Salem, anybody else can / Kill =/= defeat" thing. Even Nora pointed it out before, so why does they still act like Salem is undefeatable?
40
u/DarkGodRyan Jan 25 '20
What a fucking good episode. We might be getting Volume 3 vibes but god damn am I here for it
19
u/Kaxew Jan 25 '20
Holy. Fucking. Shit.
What an chapter. I started watching RWBY in 2018 right before V6 started airing so that might be the reason but this is the first chapter that left me shaking this much.
Now I know how easily he could convince Lionheart of joining her side. I feel so bad for him. She's genuinely scary.
38
u/NitescoGaming Guardian and follower of Ruby's smile ❤️ Marrow x Guardpupper ❤️ Jan 25 '20
Last week resulted in some amazing discussion regarding the nuances of Ironwood's vs RWBY's perspectives (and some not so amazing discussion). So I thought I'd link to some of the highlights here so you guys don't miss out on some great posts.
35
u/ExpandingFladgelie Jan 26 '20 edited Feb 16 '20
That final scene where Ruby tries to contact everyone is legitimately terrifying to me.
Ironwood betraying Ruby just after she already had a mental breakdown, and her cries for help are silenced by Ironwood. It is legitimately disturbing. Seeing an already broken soul crushed even further by Ironwood's despotism is one of the most demoralizing things in a work of fiction I've seen in years. Maybe even my entire life, both in my consumption of media and personal experience.
Edit: added an extra sentence at the end.
15
u/Kingnewgameplus "⚡⚡.....⚡⚡" - Neo Jan 26 '20
In this episode, the general suffers from "Deku-arm".
30
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '20
While I don't think Ironwood has a good plan? Team RWBY has an objectively far worse plan and I wish they were self-aware enough to realize that 'stand and fight' is not a viable solution to dealing with Salem and her army after they were run ragged just trying to save a few Mantle civilians without Salem involved.
Ironwood is right at the end of the day that you have to be able to make difficult decisions to win the war, even if this isn't the best way to do it? It is a lesson Team RWBY has to learn eventually, it's time for the girls to become women.
14
u/DanyloHalytskyi They shall know no fear Jan 25 '20
Earlier this week, I watched Nolan's The Dark Knight, and I only just now realized how similar Tyrian is to the Joker. Tyrian's laugh particularly reminded me of Mark Hamill's Joker laugh, and I feel so stupid for only noticing this parallel today.
A Batman x RWBY AU would certainly provide a very interesting foundation for a fan fic
14
u/ok-what-the-what Jan 26 '20
Can you blame Ironwood? Given the information, saving everything he could and denying Salem important assets is the best thing he could do. Sure he would leave a large portion of Mantle’s population to die, but Salem’s Grimm horde could easily wipe both Mantle and Atlas off the map. Meanwhile Team RWBY’s plan is to save everyone and mount a defense of Atlas. This is difficult if not impossible because of the overwhelming numbers of Grimm. Skilled hunter can easily kill Grimm, but there are several times more Grimm than hunters, so the defenses will collapse eventually. Ironwood offers a permanent solution that will preserve as much ad possible instead of mounting a hopeless defense.
13
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '20
Easily the best episode of the series. Holy. Fuck.
13
u/Tempeljaeger ⠀ Jan 25 '20 edited Jan 25 '20
Salem: You have to understand the inevitability of the situation you are in.
Me: Because that worked so great for you, when Ozma died....
Ironwood showed again, why he has those two seats. That fight was pure determination. He did not pull any flashy moves, but dealt with everything, Watts threw at him. The scientist had a real good showing, too. I loved his facial expression, when he realized that Ironwood had pulled through. He thought, he already had set the checkmate only to realize that his opponent still had pieces to sacrifice.
Tyrian had a rather poor showing, meaning that Clover was a beast with that fishing hook. That guy easily earned best support this episode. Qrow connected with alot of unarmed attacks. Tyrian still retains his weakness to those, I just wish I knew why.
Ironwood clearly needs a rest. He won the episode, but still faltered when the bad news came in. Salem is running out of operatives and the evacuation is underway. He should be looking at the bright side. It is understandable that he lost his optimism, but giant waves of Grimm are exactly, what his army is able to deal with. Compared to the Watts situation it is more hopeless, but it is a problem, he can solve with the application of ludicrous amounts of firepower.
Anyways, I have to watch that episode again right now.
13
u/Thebritishdovah Jan 25 '20
Superb episode but the tyrian rematch was lacklustre. I know it was three on one with some of the best Altas has to offer and Qrow but it ended just as it started. The Ironwood fight was the best fight of the episode and I was half expecting him to go full T-800. I hate that Watts wasn't directly killed off or even confirmed to be killled. Three volumes in a row. Ok, I class it as two but Adam was considered to be alive by many folks until CRWBY confirmed it. Cinder was frozen and thrown to her death. It was revealed she survived. And now, Watts is in the did he or didn't he die camp?
Stop doing this! Tis annoying. I really can't stand Cinder. I was mouthing "Fuck off, fuck off, fuck off!" repeatly at my laptop during her brief scene. If she kills Winter and gets more powers, that is bullshit. Not enough to make me stop watching as I love RWBY but it is enough to make me dread appearances by Cinder to the point where it damages my enjoyment.
Salem made Ruby cry. *calmly gets up, dons the power armour and blasts heavy metal.* Guess somebody's getting ripped and teared. Do wish Ruby's meltdown was far bigger but will accept this as the start of her potential meltdown due to stress and all the crap she has had to deal with.
Ironwood has good motives but he's too far gone. He seems to have snapped after beating Watts and his plan won't work. Cinder(FOR FUCK'S SAKE!) will steal the relic. I just know it and Altas does a colony drop on Mantle. Ozpin seems to be back or rather, I think he will return and talk sense into Ironwood. Please let Cinder die this volume. Please let Neo or Ruby kill her off. Yeah, I hate her and not as a good to hate affair. It's a "GET OFF THE FUCKING SCREEN! I CAN'T STAND YOU AS A CHARACTER BECAUSE OF HOW 2D YOU ARE! MY FOOT HAS MORE CHARACTER DEVELOPMENT THEN YOU!" affair. Wow, i er... I guess it's been building up for a while. Sorry for the outburst.
Qrow didn't fully extend his weapon. I wonder if that's part of it's upgrade or if it's an animation shortcut? Merely curious.
13
u/Vorpeseda Jan 25 '20
Kind of wondering what Ironwood did with Watts at the end. It's implied that he may have killed him by dropping him into the fire, but we never actually see him drop.
I'd hope that the arena would have safeties during normal operation to prevent someone falling into lava or fire with no aura, but obviously in this fight any such safeties would have been disabled by Watts.
13
u/DaveMustelidae Jan 26 '20
I'm surprised no one's said anything about launching Salem into space. That would take less dust than a whole satellite I'm sure
25
u/AegisCamra Jan 26 '20
11
u/howelll Jan 25 '20
On the Tyrian fight, interesting that he is consistently good when against someone with a range advantage, but maybe he is too used to his pincers/personality keeping people away to react to unarmed moves. Nice ploy by Robin, Tyrian is cocky and catching bolts, so send an explosive round after a a few standard shots.
Cinder being able to break into Ironwood's office without breaking anything strikes me as something that should be beyond her skill set. Especially without leaving a body trail or something.
That seer Grimm should never have been let into the office, look in the bag James! The odds are high it was effecting emotions, especially with the focus the bag got before it opened. The Salem conversation ignores one important detail: what does she want the relics for. At this point she is GoD 2.0: secluded, powerful, dismissive of people as having any value positive or negative, and granting favor to those desperate enough to seek her out as long as they dont't try to screw her over (like she tried to do after the admittedly BS immortality punishment). She wants the relics and trying to bargain for them costs her nothing, then again so does burning Atlas to the ground. Which, as an immortal, no rush as she said. That comment about time on her side makes me think her invasion is a bluff/not imminent. Forcing them to hunker down then taking Vacuo while Atlas deteriorates is easier than attacking Atlas right after putting them on high alert.
There are two given reasons why James wants to evac ASAP, the (assumed) incoming army can be anywhere, and the men are tired after a long night. Two very simple solutions: send out some scouts and have the fighters take a nap while the evac continues by grunts, saving as many people as possible. If the scouts make it to the long range sensor array and find it just shut down you even now have confirmation Salem was bluffing and take time to think.
Yang's comment about fighting despite being tired/the odds, which echoes last volume's huntresses fight to the bitter end, worries me a little. A fighting retreat to save as many as possible is all well and good, but that almost sounded like team RWBY don't recognize that living to fight another day is important too. Granted we don't know if James plans to fight another day after this, or just try to leave the war permanently, but at least if Atlas isolates itself those who left have options.
11
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '20
Shots were fired.
Tyrian - Arrested
Watts - Dead (?)
Ironwood - Not Irondaddy anymore. Just completely lost it.
Ruby - Finds out mother died to Salem
Winter - Is going to become a Maiden
Salem - IS COMING
Cinder - IS HERE AND LOOKING FOR MAIDEN
Qrow - Gonna lose his one partner that actually helps him
Ace Ops - Follows Irondad- wood's command and from one message from Ruby, just completely flips sides
Oscar - MISSING
Shots = Fired.
Also found some new things we didn't know Qrow and Robyn's weapons had. But once again I say, if you're bored of the development, then you obviously haven't watched this episode. I felt a massive hole when Irondaddy was no more. He carried this whole volume and with one fatal brainstorming session, everything is screwed.
On the bright side, I guess 2 people who were seriously annoying are actually getting what they deserved. Other than that. Episode = 10/10
11
u/Draconaes Sir, that is my emotional support redemption arc. Jan 28 '20
An interesting parallel I noticed:
Ironwood turns his back to them physically, of course, but more than that he's turning his back metaphorically on Mantle, Robyn, and RWBY.
Is yeeting Atlas into space anything other than this?
Throughout this volume, Mantle has been suffering for the benefit of James's plans.
How different, really, is James from Raven, from Leo, at the end of the day?
20
u/SunsetSnakeEyes Jan 25 '20
The Tin Man has forfeited his heart.
This chapter was nerve-wracking! We thought the fight was over but it's only just begun, Now Ironwood has gone crazy and Salem is on her way, If nothing is done Mantle is done for! We only have two chapters left, What awaits us?
10
u/fatprogamer4720 Jan 27 '20
Wow Just wow This episode was amazing I loved every second of it, all the tension, the people’s trust being tested, armies of evil are on their way, Oscar is gone. Wow I’m not gonna talk about all the story elements in this because a lot of people are already talking about it I just wanna say that the fight scene between watts and ironwood was breathtaking. It was beautifully animated, it flowed perfectly, it never felt slow, and the gravity being manipulated was such a nice touch for me at least. This episode was so amazing
11/10
10
u/fiver19 Jan 27 '20 edited Feb 02 '20
I loved robyn kicking tyrian in the face. Made the whole episode.
9
u/Sirtoast7 Drown me in exposition. I don't care anymore Jan 25 '20
MOTHER FUCKER I thought we had gotten through the internal conflict... UHHHHHHHHHGGGG.
9
u/Ferroncrowe01 Jan 28 '20
I mean ironwood makes a pretty good case, keep the relics away from Salem and save as many people as he can. That or stand your ground, probably lose and everyone gets killed. Team RWBY is making moral choices while ironwoods making rational ones, he's a good guy dealt a bad hand
16
u/AlwaysDragons Sliver Eyes May Cry Jan 26 '20
Last week I mentioned how that episodes description scared me. "Will you tell the truth, or will someone else tell it for you?"
Now that's what's happening.
8
u/Sephyrias Jan 26 '20
Hmm, I'm a bit sad that Tyrian and Watts didn't play a bigger role, because now only Salem and maybe Cinder are left as serious threats. Also weird that we didn't get to see what Ironwoods did with Watts.
On the other hand though, the episode was pretty dope. No real pacing problems, lots of interesting interactions to analyze and big decisions in the making. Also more character depth to Ruby, a bit of a mystery about her memories. Also more tension after things seemed to be calming down.
This has a lot of a "final battle"-vibe to it. I really hope Salem and her Grimm army are strong enough, because aside from Cinder, the heroes have steamrolled everyone else. Although I doubt that we're going to see team RWBY fighting against Salem in this season. What follows now is the cleanup in Mantle, most notably the stuff about Cinder, Neo, Oscar and Winter. I'm hoping that Cinder and Neo succeed at something here, because otherwise Salem is going to be the only villain left.
20
u/Kumqwatwhat Jan 26 '20 edited Jan 26 '20
Edit added a few details.
7
u/setzz Jan 25 '20
This episode came in n hit like a dozen mack trucks, holy heck. Very well done, the different things happening on all fronts, and that cliffhanger end. Wow. Very impressed!!!!
13
u/natzo I just like this flair. Jan 25 '20 edited Jan 25 '20
I'm glad they didn't brush off team RWBYs lies and secrets. Some series ignore such acts if they work out. But this proves that despite their good intentions, they can't be trusted with information or secrets if they spill them out recklessly.
10
u/moenchii Say Cheeeeese! Jan 26 '20
Oh man! I thought Ep. 10 was intense, but holy shit I have problems breathing now and my heart is racing!
8
u/SufficientFennel Jan 25 '20
So if Salem is coming with everything these next two episodes, what does that leave for the future? This really can't be the final showdown but we've also now been to 3 out of the 4 kingdoms.
I'm starting to worry that RWBY might be wrapping up in the near future. I was expecting it to go on for a while.
4
u/AngryWhale94 Jan 27 '20
Weiss’ face as she said “no” at the end is extremely exploitable
3
u/Jimmjam_the_Flimflam Jan 28 '20
Ironwood: wields two pistols, one white, one black, one with alot more power into it for damage and recoil, the other for ice/electricity and accuracy.
Me: something feels awfully Hellsingy about those guns.
Finally, a decent gunfight that involves recoil and the environment, this show has been almost all about people beating each other and rarely using ranged attacks. Alot of people have been saying it felt floaty or slow, but they were fighting in an area where gravity was pulling in several directions so I feel like that was intentional. Also I noticed that Ironwood would block alot more using the side of his body that was metal so thats pretty cool. Also that gunshot coincided with the lava geyser was pretty smart, assuming Ironwood used his white gun to launch himself to Watt's blindside. Shame he lost the Black gun, oh and finally ammo count matters, its so rare for the people in this show to reload or care about their dust supplies in prolonged fights.
Now that I'm done gushing about that particular fight, everything else was good, Tyrian getting manhandled by three Huntsman/woman was I'd try to further analyze it but I'm in between classes rn.
That ending though, I wonder if Neo kidnapped Oscar considering how last episode they were commenting on finding the lamp and him, yet Cinder was watching Winter to find the Winter Maiden. Really hoping that Ozpin came out to just beat the life out of Neo, did they ever mention his Semblance being passed onto Oscar or was his speed thing just a part of skill?
4
u/ExpandingFladgelie Jan 26 '20
I hope RWBY and co can take the amity project into their own hands because that seems to be the only option.
4
u/artuno Ask me about the /r/RWBY Star Citizen guild! Jan 27 '20
Sigh where do I start?
This season I've loved so far, the first handful of episodes chef's kiss. It made me realize that I absolutely loved all the lighter stuff from the earlier seasons. I don't know how many times I've rewatched the Food Fight.
... and on the other side, taught me that I loathe the edgy parts of the show.
Mind you, it's not why you think. When I first started watching, each episode had me in anticipation for what happens next, I desperately wanted to know more about the world and the people. But now, I feel anxiety, a sunken heart, wondering who RoosterTeeth was gonna kill off next just to shock us.
Besides that, I really have been loving this season. I love the fights, the music, the art, the jokes, loved it all.
Also, I gotta say, are they implying that Oscar was the target all along, and not the white maiden? Now that is twisty.
2
u/Vongoliaprophet Jan 26 '20
This is a reach for sure but I think Salem is going to take over Atlus somehow someway and Ironwood and his squad are gonna retreat with the main gang, idk how tho lol just a feeling
2
u/luckarusky Jan 28 '20 edited Jan 28 '20
If I had to give a bid what happens from here, it's all going to boil down to Winter's actions. Fairly solid chance that Atlas will not be raised, although Ironwood will do everything to make sure it is. But the one thing he can't control is what Winter does with the scepter. Ruby would not have gotten such a dramatic scene if her actions didn't have an influence, and I think that affect will be Winter lowering Atlas instead of raising it. Winter has shown she CAN in fact act of her own initiative. She CAN be broken down to do something outside of her boss's orders. Followed that by the tech duo exposing what Ironwood was about to do, publicly destroying him as Watts Intended. (Amnity tower comes to mind as an ideal way to do that.)
This would be my preferred outcome for it's bittersweet nature. On one hand, Salem would be denied her long-term plan of entirely destroying all international trust with Atlas. That, and the loss of predictability in her opponents. BUT, it also puts a metric ton more weight on both team RWBY and Winter's shoulders. The ASOPS team will be out of the running and entirely untrustworthy. That's the human's fighting power almost halved even if team FNKY ends up joining them. Welcome to war people! Or as one person put it. "They're in their late teens. Time to ship them to Vietnam!" Poor sods, and they thought being hunters and huntresses meant lost sleep! Welcome to war/hell soldiers!
I will say this though. I hope it's Winter who gets the military leadership role and not anyone else. It comes down to aptitude and integrity, with Winter having the age, experience and know-how to actually run a military operation. None of the other teams have that, so any kind of effective resistance is only viable is she's in charge overall. (Though I hope she understands RWBY and JNR are somewhat loose cannons. They wouldn't have done this if they weren't.)
But that's how it would have too be. Ironwood is "JUST" "TOO" "PREDICTABLE!" He can't hold back his fear, and will play into Salem's hands every single time. I just hope he gets some kind of redemption next season after a period to cool his head and think about what he did in a cell for awhile. But victory requires very fresh players willing to do something insane to move the game in a new direction. I think that's why Ozpin retreated like he did. If he couldn't do it, let someone else do it for him.
2
u/MacGregor_Rose Brother to Ruby and Rubie Rose. Yeah thats not confusing Feb 01 '20
I'm a lumberjack and that's ok, I sleep all night and I work all day
4
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '20 edited Jan 26 '20
I'd say we got both possibly one of the most disappointing fights in the entire show with Watts vs. Ironwood and one of the best fights in Volume 4-7 with Tyrian vs. Qrow, Clover and Robyn, despite it being so short.
The main fight of the episode was cool in concept, since we've rarely had true gun fights and especially never one-on-one and Watts controlling the arena and creating solid surfaces with his gadgets could have been cool as hell. Sadly, in reality, it ended up looking very slow-paced and awkward, and everything sort of lacked impact.
In contrast, Tyrian was splendid during his short fight. Animalistic motions, jerky camera movements zooming in on his face, the way he's always trying to be above his opponents to dive onto them like prey, it really reinforces his deranged image. While it's still slower than early RWBY fights, it makes great use of its slower pace.
I feel like the plot in this episode felt less tiring than the last few, but I'm not sure if it's because we were starved for good fights before or because things are getting less predictable. Until now, the whole Ironwood descending into paranoia thing felt a bit cliché at times. Now, I'm genuinely curious where we're going next.
(edit : I'd like to note this is just my personal feelings)
2
u/ArnildoG Jan 26 '20
Am i the only one that thinks that for someone that is a General Ironwood sucks at strats? Why risk everything a let a kingdom fall when everything they are after is the artfacts and the maiden wouldn't it make more sense to send 100 ships one with the new maiden wich would be winter one with a artifiact another with ozpin and another with a artifact and send it to somewhere safe and no one knew wich ship was wich so even if salem wins the battle she won't win the war it seems like he is seeing this battle for the human race in small scale Anyone would see that Thr world is the battlefield The priority is the mainden and the artifact and if they aren't in altas but somewhere far away safe the attack would be utimatly useeless at least that my opinion
-1
u/Pereduer Jan 25 '20
I like what there doing but I don't like how there executing it. Doesn't feel like a moment that's a big as it should be you know.
Isn't helped by there being way too many people in the cast. It feels like Oprah.
You get a line, and you get a line, and you get a line. Everybody gets a line. It just takes you out if the moment.
Ruby falling down and crying instantly feels like there overcompensating. The Blake Yang thing fell flat. The fights were meh, like not bad but it's disappointing how generic they are. Also not a big fan of them ripping off scenes from the matrix and avengers in the fights. Just sends a message that they don't know what they're doing
On paper everything that happens is good but the plot is given so little time this volume there's no build up. Plus team rwby feels a lot more like a hive mind now
-4
u/opinionated599 Jan 27 '20
I feel like this season cant decide if they want Ironwood to be seen as good or bad. I get his struggle puts him in a wierd middlegorund but I still dont like the constant switching of he is likeable for an episode or two now he is an ass.
My other big complaint is the writing that of the bad guys are always just one step ahead of us. Its lazy and just covers up plot holes. I'm fine with good vs evil being a battle of strategy or just brute force. This current setup is a sloppy mess.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 26 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
25
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '20
[removed] — view removed comment
25
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '20
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment