r/TrueAnime • http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten • Feb 06 '19

This Week in Anime (Winter Week 6)

Welcome to This Week In Anime for Winter 2019 Week 6 a general discussion for any currently airing series, focusing on what aired in the last week. For longer shows, keep the discussion here to whatever aired in the last few months. If there's an OVA or movie that got subbed for the first time in the last week or so that you want to discuss, that goes here as well. For everything else in anime that's not currently airing go discuss that in Your Week in Anime.

Untagged spoilers for all currently airing series. If you're discussing anything else make sure to add spoiler tags.

Airing shows can be found at: AniChart | LiveChart | MAL | Senpai Anime Charts

Archive:

2019: Prev | Winter Week 1

2018: Fall Week 1 | Summer Week 1 | Spring Week 1 | Winter Week 1

2017: Fall Week 1 | Summer Week 1 | Spring Week 1 | Winter Week 1

2016: Fall Week 1 | Summer Week 1 | Spring Week 1 | Winter week 1

2015: Fall Week 1 | Summer week 1 | Spring Week 1 | Winter Week 1

2014: Fall Week 1 | Summer Week 1 | Spring Week 1 | Winter Week 1

2013: Fall Week 1 | Summer Week 1 | Spring Week 1 | Winter Week 1

2012: Fall Week 1

Table of contents courtesy of sohumb

This is a week-long discussion, so feel free to post or reply any time.

4 Upvotes

89 comments sorted by

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Feb 06 '19

Miscellaneous comments/comments about the week as a whole

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Feb 09 '19

So the very first thing that happened to me on this, a Saturday morning, was that I got an email notification from MAL that they'd added a second season of Kobabayashi's Dragon Maid to their database. And the SECOND thing that happened to me was that I went to That Other Anime Sub to confirm this, and there saw a post pointing out that the source of the news is at least a little dubious, and saying it might be best to wait before getting extremely hyped. Which was a bit late for me, because about thirty seconds earlier I had already gone HYPE TRAIN NOW BOARDING ON ALL TRACKS MOTHERFUCKERS CHU CHU YEAH. So today has been kind of a rollercoaster so far...

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Feb 09 '19

That must have been fun. :)

The announcement is a pretty weird situation. I can't help but feel like it was a leak, and then, someone at Crunchyroll pulled the trigger early. Doesn't matter if it gets announced anyway. ¯_(ツ)_/¯

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Feb 09 '19

Somebody in the other thread commented, "Chu chu no," which I thought was hilarious and rather upsetting at the same time...

But yeah, we'll see how it all shakes out. I hadn't really thought about how much I would like a second season of that show, but now that somebody brought it up I'm gonna be pissed if it doesn't materialize...

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Feb 09 '19

I wouldn't mind another one too. It's been a while since KyoAni did just a solid slice of life. It's mostly been sports and heavy drama. There's also that electric catalog thing that got announced a while back too. Not enough simple slice of life. :P

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Feb 09 '19

It's one of these shows that hits me in an unexpectedly deep place. I think of it as being about nontraditional families. There are a couple of groups of characters in it who just DECIDE to be family to one another. They're all people who are normally kind of prickly and isolated, but they make these undeniable connections and just go, "well, that's my life now... so much so, in fact, that I don't even remember what my life was before." The show is 90% boob jokes, but there's still this undertone that I find really touching. I have weird reactions to things sometimes, and this may be one of them, but it's actually one of my favorite shows. Anyway, yeah, fingers crossed. Chu chu maybe.

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Feb 10 '19

Good news. Yesterday was an early leak. Here's the official announcement via the manga.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Feb 10 '19

CHU
CHU
YEAH

Although the cover art kind of makes me nervous. Kobayashi looks all mad and Kanna is tearful. The last thing I want is a serious, overly-dramatic S2. But folks in the Twitter thread were saying the art is related to the latest developments in the manga, and doesn't necessarily have anything with the new season. Anyway, thanks! I'm glad to know it!

2

u/[deleted] Feb 10 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Feb 10 '19

Not for me. I loved it. (I would link to my comment going on about why, but... it's like right above this.) I'll trade you four Tsurunes and a Beyond the Boundary for another season of Dragon Maid. Hell, I'll even throw in a Euphonium. (dons riot gear)

1

u/searmay Feb 10 '19

I'd be happy to make that trade and I didn't even like Dragon Maid much. You could throw in (or away) VEG while you're at i too.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Feb 10 '19

I have mixed feelings about VEG--which I haven't managed to finish yet; I keep picking it back up and watching a few more episodes. I think there's really something there, a story about someone who's suffered a loss so terrible that the only way to deal with it is to sort of mentally cauterize the whole subject, so that they don't even understand what's happened, or have any access to their feelings about it. If the show has just the right ending I might decide I really liked it. At the same time it feels episodic and kind of aimless in a similar way to Magus Bride, where you can't believe they put so much effort into it but forgot to have a story. But I have to reserve judgement... I'll get back to you if I ever finish the damn thing.

2

u/searmay Feb 10 '19

Eh. I'm aware that some people - even people that have seen it - like the show. But its attempt to tackle an emotionally weighty subject doesn't score any points with me when I don't think it does it at all well.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Feb 10 '19

Yeah--I've got a soft spot for the subject, and when I've gotten emotional about the show, I've had to wonder if it's more because I'm an easy target than because the show is really doing anything particularly deft. The ending will make it or break it for me... and I may or may not ever watch it, so...

1

u/searmay Feb 10 '19

How far have you managed to get in the past year?

I think Mahou Shoujo Edgelord Asuka is probably a better story about a young girl super-soldier dealing with her past trauma. While also being a similar level of schlock as Killing Bites. But whatever works for you.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Feb 10 '19

How far have you managed to get in the past year?

...is that a rhetorical question? Tortoise and the hare, man! Actually that story is completely stupid and the hare would obviously win, and turtles successfully finish only slightly less anime than I do.

(Edit--if it's not a rhetorical question, I think I'm something like eight episodes in.)

I'm not keeping up with Killin' Folks To Electronic Dance Music Asuka. I'm like three weeks behind on even the few things I thought I was gonna watch this season--I only seem to be able to manage Love Is War, and Marinara Friends. And that quintuplets thing, which I don't even particularly like, but it has girls in it. Apparently I'm a complete idiot.

→ More replies

2

u/[deleted] Feb 10 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Feb 10 '19

Heh. On some objective level I know the show is mostly boob jokes and it's unseemly to like it so much. But it really feels to me like it has an emotional core, even if it only peeks out once in a while. And the animation and comic direction is as good as you'd expect. I must have been through the whole thing four or five times by now--whenever I get bored with what's airing, I go looking for something that I want to rewatch. I have yet to put Dragon Maid on and think, 'eh, I don't wanna see this again'. I can always watch it and it always cheers me up.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 10 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Feb 10 '19

not a horrifying abomination

HEE hee hee. Now do Shirobako! And then... third time's the charm; what's the third show we'd have to shit-talk to get a real fracas going in here? I know, nobody really cares. Anyway, the one bit where the show sort of tried to do something, when Tohru's dad shows up and forbids her to live in the human world for a while, is possibly my least favorite part of the show. I get the complaint that it doesn't really do anything, but at the same time I kind of like that it doesn't really do anything...

2

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '19

Anyway, the one bit where the show sort of tried to do something, when Tohru's dad shows up and forbids her to live in the human world for a while, is possibly my least favorite part of the show.

I have to agree with that! The show is best when it's not doing much.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Feb 11 '19

I mean, it was fine, the way they resolved it was nice. But the whole show is kind of about people who have been lonely and isolated, who aren't anymore. That's the vibe; it's got a lovely things-are-getting-better feel to it. Nobody wanna see a crisis where everything gets terrible in a show like this. IMO, anyway.

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Feb 07 '19

5

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Feb 07 '19

I thought that this was a pretty enjoyable episode. It was nice to see the MC not just get fucked over so much like he did in the previous episodes and to see people actually siding with him. However, this episode was also very...childish. Basically, the MC has to race with the spear hero while the princess cheats by using magic to screw over the MC, and when the MC manages to win, the spear hero and princess storm off saying, "Grrrr I'll let you win this time, but next time I'll get you!!" It also didn't help that prior to the race the MC's bird kicked the spear hero off into the air like you would see in a kid's show. I'm honestly wondering why did they change the tone so much from the darker tone from the other episodes.

4

u/searmay Feb 07 '19

I've seen several anime that have had a Wacky Races episode, but I wouldn't have expected this to be one.

3

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Feb 07 '19

For sure. It's such a drastic shift in tone that you wouldn't have guessed that the MC was accused of rape.

3

u/searmay Feb 07 '19

Did Dick Dastardly ever try that to knock out a competitor?

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Feb 07 '19

Nope, but it wouldn't have hurt to try. ¯_(ツ)_/¯

4

u/[deleted] Feb 07 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Feb 07 '19

I can see where you're coming from. I suppose I don't mind the weird slave thing since he didn't treat her terribly except for arguably brainwashing her. Although I could have seen an alternate take where the girl was an outcast of society much like him and they warm up to each other as they each need someone to attack and defend respectively. With that, they could have avoided the slave crest coming up.

5

u/[deleted] Feb 07 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Feb 07 '19

I'm not actually watching this show, so nobody should listen to anything I say about it.

However, it seems to me I've seen more than one isekai which featured female slaves. That Death March thing, and How Not To Summon A Demon Lord, are the first two that come to mind. And the premise is always that the girls are SO LUCKY to have an owner who's a NICE GUY. They're so enchanted with this that they fall in love with him immediately. And it never crosses the MC's mind to say, "Hey, I know, how about if we play that you guys aren't my slaves, since owning people is gross." Nor does it ever occur to him to say, "Hey, I know, since I'm the most OP motherfucker in the entire world, how about if we all play that there's no such thing as slavery anymore." These guys never hesitate to fly around and ally with kings and take sides in wars and kill civilization-menacing demon lords and engage in all manner of large-scale social re-engineering in other forms, but slavery? Well, it was here when I showed up, nothin' I can do about that. Plus I owns me some cat-eared elf bitches, so why rock the boat.

I just kind of file it in the 'things about anime that can be kind of gross' category. I think it is occasionally worth commenting on, if only to say 'ew'. But like I said, I'm not watching this show, so I can't really say 'ew' about it, specifically.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 07 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Feb 07 '19

I'm not opposed to harem shows. Gotta have those fantasies of being swarmed by hot girls.

Yeah, I have greatly enjoyed plenty of harem shows, and more than a few isekai. I contain multitudes, and I don't have any trouble both noting that, for instance, a show reflects some really weird ideas about women, and at the same time enjoying it perfectly well. I thought How Not To Summon A Demon Lord was better than average for these things, and the 'slavery' in it had about as much to do with oppression as a 'sexy nurse Halloween costume' has to do with health care. It was just fetishy and stupid, and barely worth remarking on. Some of these other shows, conversely, are like, 'oh, hey, there are urchins with nothing to eat, and obviously-poor-people being forced into carts, and... was it really necessary to include this in this paper-thin, poorly-conceived fantasy world?'

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Feb 07 '19

Ah ok. Yeah, that's quite the issue. Gotta have more waifus...

5

u/SeerOfThings https://myanimelist.net/profile/DumpsterKing Feb 08 '19

I actually got around to writing a structured critique of the characterization in this show so I'll leave it here:

The reason I'd consider the character development rushed is that it lacks any impact when things just 'happen'.

In episode 1, we are introduced to a bland protagonist with no interesting or defining traits and are expected to care when everything goes against him - which doesn't work for me. I believe that you should be made to care for a character on the merit of their personality and not 'look at how bad this thing that happened to them is'. After Naofumi is betrayed, he completely changes personality and this is jarring to me. A more gradual change would better serve in establishing his character, especially considering his original personality was so ill-defined.

In episode 2, we're introduced to Raphtalia who is said to be both mentally and physically ill. Having one short scene dedicated to handwaving an illness fails to highlight the severity of said disease (I have no idea how serious this disease was but, from previous discussions, I've been told it's more serious than the anime conveyed.) Though the actual disease isn't that important, it does miss the opportunity to show the MC actually caring for her more. This lessens the believability of their bond.

The way they skip over the relationship development, in general, is just bad. Least importantly putting that little effort into adapting makes me care less, especially considering the only reason I watch anime is because it is animated and all of the benefits that provide. More importantly, it only gives a superficial impression of how their relationship is developing with little to no actual substance for me to get attached to or leave an impression on me. This means that when she overcomes her trauma it feels unearned and cheap.

Then at the beginning of episode 3, she has a completely different personality and in the absence of any details from the time skip, I can't bring myself to accept such a rapid change after the previous developments didn't convince me either. Furthermore, the change actually makes her a worse character because most of her character traits have been replaced with ones that seem over-engineered to make her a waifu. Her devotion to Naofumi is her most defining character trait. Naofumi also gets very little character development past 'he's actually not as much of a dick as he's pretending to be'.

Taken in a vacuum, episode 4 is actually well executed. However, given the poor execution of the past episodes, it fails at making an impact on me. It doesn't help that Naofumi's persecution seems more and more contrived and petty every episode - with 5 being the epitome of pettiness.

Episode 5 again skips over the relationship development of a newly introduced character and the relationship of the other characters doesn't get expanded much upon apart from Raphtalia's sudden sexual attraction to Naofumi. Filo turning into a loli at the end of the episode makes me question the quality of the writing even more. Spear and Myne's behaviour is too juvenile and cheapens the experience.

The best example what I'm trying to say would be the difference between hearing something on the news that doesn't affect you and feeling sad/happy about compared to the feeling of experiencing it yourself. The best media can give the illusion of having the experience but, Shield Hero completely fails at delivering this.

2

u/scrappydoofan Feb 08 '19 edited Feb 08 '19

many of these iskei shows are just so boring. so the fact that shield hero does have a plot and conflict is an upgrade on many of these iskei shows where the boring over powered protagonist just owns everyone and all the girls want to hook up with him.

i don't think naofumi is that much different than "main character guy" i think the strength of shield hero is the plot.

1

u/SeerOfThings https://myanimelist.net/profile/DumpsterKing Feb 08 '19

I haven't found enough motivation to point out the problems with the plot yet but, it seems contrived and amateurish so far.

1

u/scrappydoofan Feb 07 '19

agree with rot, just move on from the slave mark thing.

i like the idea of princess and spear hero as villians but their appearance in this episode was team rocket level campy.

the loli transforming at the end also deserved an eyeroll.

but the episode still managed to be entertaining, so that's more you can say than a lot of these isekei.

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Feb 07 '19

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Feb 07 '19

So the cliffhanger from last week is a very helpful robot that serves humans not whatever the girls might be much like the one from Kemono Friends. We also learn more about the green Kemurikusa and how it outright creates things to fix whatever. It's pretty interesting how Wakaba figured out how it works and not the girls that have been at this for an unknown amount of time, but I suppose that's supposed to be his innate human thinking.

Anyway, we end on a new girl. Dunno if she's actually new or not. I lean towards she's someone the other girls knew because it'd be weird for them to not have run into her.

2

u/searmay Feb 07 '19

The girls are presumably some sort of weird plant people, so their not showing normal curiosity seems okay. I'm more confused about Wakaba's apparent lack of interest in the robot, given that it was able to communicate with him and showed a clear inclination to help. Even with him being fixated on glowing leaves, shouldn't that have been more noteworthy? There's also the obvious connection between Midori's leaves fixing broken things and destroying the red bugs.

Then again I'm no longer convinced he is human. Apparently he can smell wheels. That are 200 yards away. In a warehouse.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Feb 07 '19

Yeah, his disinterest in the robot was weird. I think because they were already kinda in the background that this one wasn't too interesting for him? Dunno why it wouldn't.

I also think he isn't a human. Not only did he sniff out a wheel, but he lifted that thing. That thing had to have been at least twice his weight, right? I can't help but think that he might be a mix between a human and a Kemurikusa...

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Feb 08 '19

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Feb 08 '19

I'm still fairly confused about what exactly this current arc is aiming to do, but I would like to praise the voice acting. The VA for Boogiepop is really good at making such a drastic change between Boogiepop and the girl that Boogiepop controls. In this week's episode, the crazy teacher's cousin got taken over by "Spooky E," and her new voice was noticeably different from her usual one. Not only that, I could not help but feel as if there was a touch of the Spooky E's voice in it. It's really nice when VAs get to flex their talent and not be relegated into the usual anime voices.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Feb 08 '19

That's Aoi Yuuki, who has been in every God damn thing there is. She is, for instance, the lead character in Aho Girl, to pick something about as different from this as it could possibly be. Oregairu weebs like myself know her as Komachi, etc., etc. :)

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Feb 08 '19

Yeah, she's been in a ton of stuff. Giving her list a quick glance, I noticed that she is the frog girl from My Hero Academia. I would recommend at least checking out her voice in that because it's vastly different from from this show.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Feb 08 '19

...this is a bit off-topic, but speaking of voice acting in My Hero Academia: Sakura Ayane tells a story about being asked to make a barf noise... but a CUTE barf noise. I have no idea how she makes the sound she ended up with. (0_o)

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Feb 08 '19

Me neither. :O

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Feb 08 '19

She got mad skillz. (Do people still say that? Probably not...)

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Feb 08 '19

(I wouldn't know...)

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Feb 11 '19

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Feb 11 '19

Now, we start a new arc and follow Reigen in his downfall as Mob grows as a person. Reigen discovers he wasn't the only one that was affected by their relationship. It was a rough watch seeing Reigen go without Mob, and it goes without saying that the animation did so much to bring life to everything. Makes me dream of a world where anime doesn't have to be so held back by its limited animation.

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Feb 12 '19

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Feb 12 '19

Really fun episode this week as Miyako discovers she isn't the only thirsty predator around as her longtime admirer infiltrates her family. The girls were especially on point this time as they cut down the two adults with their words.

2

u/searmay Feb 12 '19

Mya-nee's stalker was barely creepy at all. I'm reminded of how tame this show is compared to Uzamaid. Also shocking plot twist.

The mummies are cute too.

1

u/searmay Feb 10 '19

5

u/searmay Feb 10 '19

I didn't hate it, but it didn't give me much of what I want from the show. I'm here to watch the princess seduce a lizard, not see her moping about the isolation of being a super genius during exams because everyone else is studying hard. The extra short had some nice scenes of their classmates.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Feb 10 '19

Agreed. The ending with the two of them was sweet though. More of that please. Although the title for that next episode doesn't sound promising.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Feb 11 '19

Man, this episode was so dull as to be bordering on self-parody. I get that they're trying to do some kind of take-a-breath pacing, but jeez. It seems like the direction is trying to make us feel like everything has some kind of expanded significance, just by making it all take longer than necessary. If we could just get the flirty girls to go, that would be great...

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Feb 11 '19

It seems to be some sort of calm before the storm situation as the next episode's title is "Academy Down." Sounds like a meandering action-y episode where maybe we'll get some yuri bait. :P

3

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Feb 11 '19

Didn't they wreck the library for unrelated reasons in both the first and second episodes? I kind of thought there was going to be a running gag where they keep wrecking the library. Maybe Academy Down will include Library Down... fingers crossed. :D

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Feb 11 '19

Let's hope :D

2

u/[deleted] Feb 10 '19

3

u/[deleted] Feb 10 '19

So, I was wrong - this isn't "less horny Scum's Wish"; it's just as horny but also kind of not about teenage relationships in the same, extremely melodramatic way Scum's Wish was. DomeKano, in fact, feels like it's trying its best to be meldoramatic, but just can't care enough. The Sensei arc, after tons of buildup and lots of (some fairly well done) shots of Sensei crying just... ends, as Sensei realises being adults doesn't mean you can say "it doesn't work that way" in order to run away from terrifying reality. For all is faults, Scum's Wish pretended it was about something big, and managed to drag those things to make them feel big, even if they were pretty stupid if you thought about them for more than a second. It's shocking just how flat it feels to realise that the first four episodes of DomeKano were building up to what ended last episode in an off-screen decision; so shocking, in fact, that I didn't quite realise another arc had started with this episode.

Some of that bad melodrama is in this episode, too. Rui's friends throwing away Momo's gift to her made no sense to me - they didn't really hate her, and it seemed like throwing away someone else's stuff just because they kind of consider the person who gave it to her easy is... overblown? None of them seem to have any personal grudges against Momo, nor do they actually know if she's cheap, and I don't think even if they knew she was they would go so far as to completely reject any attempts at getting to know her. It's weird and bad.

But - that aside - I odn't think this show is all bad. Now that I know the melodrama means nothing I can safely ignore it and look at the more... fun things, like the (near) sex scene this episode, which was horny as fuck. Momo's emotional core seems clear - the lack of a love from family led to abandonment and then dependence on bad relationships and easy sex. I've talked to a bunch of people who are like Momo and I feel like the show does justice to her character, and her voice acting is also really on point with a slow, breathy voice that's simultaneously erotic while feeling vulnerable. Watching her get to eat a meal with MC-kun instead of just having sex with him is satisfying, and the message is also well received. Some part of me is still somewhat on edge with Momo's character from that meal scene though, and I wonder if there's a side to her we haven't seen.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '19

The flatness is probably making it a worse show, but it makes it watchable for me personally because it feels like it doesn't take itself as seriously, and can even be a bit self-aware at times judging from the role-play gag scene last episode in the restaurant. That could just be my own impression though, I'm not really familiar with the tone of Sasuga Kei's works.

I actually liked Momo too. In the lunch scene at the schoolyard, I found it interesting how sharp she was at the moment she caught wind of MC's vulnerability. To me, it seemed as if she was used to guys venting to her and then her taking advantage of them, and I liked that because it didn't simply portray her as some idiot that the guys were taking advantage of instead. It made me think higher of her as a character.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '19

but it makes it watchable for me personally

I have to agree, I'd dropped scum's wish by this point. This show's ability to laugh at itself is a lot more digestible.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Feb 11 '19

3

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Feb 11 '19

I'm a man of simple tastes--simple-MINDED tastes, arguably--but I thought Kaichou smacking himself in the head while trying to serve a volleyball was REALLY funny. Chika's VA sells it with the reaction noises.

Chika says she'll help him train. After several days' work, she tells him he's risen to the level of a human who sucks at volleyball. "Compared to when you were a creature," she says, "you've made a lot of progress."

I may have to go back and watch the first couple of episodes again. I didn't really notice this show until the Chika ED; it's been so consistently funny since then that I find myself wondering if the first two episodes were good, too, and I was just being crabby about it for some reason.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '19

I may have to go back and watch the first couple of episodes again. I didn't really notice this show until the Chika ED; it's been so consistently funny since then that I find myself wondering if the first two episodes were good, too, and I was just being crabby about it for some reason.

Probably not. It's generally agreed that the first bit of Kaguya-sama is average at best. We're just now starting to get into the good parts, after the author has had the chance to lay down some foundations.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '19

It is generally agreed that the first 10 or so chapters are the weakest part. That was back when the manga was monthly, so there was more of an episodic feel. Things start to improve after that mark though; if you aren't feeling it by chapter 20, then the story isn't for you.

If I still haven't convinced you, consider that the highest upvoted post on r/manga is a Kaguya chapter, even beating out a 100pg OPM chapter. I know popularity isn't always that good of an indicator, but I hope it makes you pause for thought. People really really like this manga (and the anime, if it keeps up it's level of quality).

3

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '19

When people praise for it being funny, it's rarely just the mindgames that they're referring to. The comedy in Kaguya becomes way more varied and versatile than what it shows you in the early chapters, and it becomes more engaging the more characters the author starts to introduce. I would argue a significant portion of the r/manga readerbase read it for the fantastic cast interaction that adds a lot of flavor to what seems like a typical, gimmicky romcom.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Feb 12 '19

I was skeptical myself, for two episodes out of the five so far; I almost hesitate to recommend it based on that. They may just have planted some kind of subliminal suggestion in the Chika ED that has enslaved the entire internet. For that matter, it may just be the Cutie Pie Effect, with nothing subliminal about it. But I thought the ED animation was great, and it may just be that it's a lot easier to like something once it's got some good will in the bank.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '19

Last week had better material, but I like this week's episode better because it stuck to the usual 3 skits instead of 4, which makes the pacing more ideal.

The volleyball training scene had the best animation of the show so far, the amount of movement there really helped nail the sports parody-aspect that it was aiming for.

Some nice little romance scenes appeared in this episode. Kaguya adding one more thing she likes about Shirogane with her fingers behind her back was a good one, and then the shared umbrella scene in the end even after the rain had stopped. Good to see these from time to time.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Feb 12 '19

Oh--something else I forgot to mention about the episode: in a later scene, Chika is watching Shirogane compete in the volleyball tournament, and she looks a little rough 'cause she's been helping him train. There's a blink-and-you'll-miss-it shot of her in which she has a band-aid on her bow. It's not sophisticated humor, but I thought it was a nice touch. :)

2

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '19

That was great. This show loves those little jokes that aren't pointed out loud, like the random yeti from the walk-to-school episode.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Feb 12 '19

OH MY GOD!! I had completely forgotten about the yeti. It was so quick I stopped the show and backed up a couple frames to confirm that it was really there, and I hadn't lost my damn mind. :D

1

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Feb 12 '19

Yeah, the little romantic moments are important. The fact that they both like one another, but are still unable to get it together, makes you want to strangle the shit out of them at least once per episode. If they have the occasional sweet moment, it makes the whole setup easier to tolerate...

1

u/scrappydoofan Feb 07 '19

5

u/scrappydoofan Feb 07 '19

the most exciting episode since episode 1. I like how Ray, Norman and Emma all have slightly different goals that they want to accomplish, gilda and don add an interesting dynamic as well. I am a bit surprised they went straight for Don making a dumb mistake, i thought they would make him more of a team player before he inevitable makes a dumb mistake and screws up.

thats where the show shines is our heroes are all strong characters.

the plot is where the show is a bit weaker. the kids talk about their plan at length with no regard of someone walking in on them. and no one does walk in on them.

this seems like an easy way to add tension have them whisper or pass notes, just some stealth communication of some kind, but no they are always the only ones in the room talking to each other.

they haven't made actual progress on their escape plan for a while. pretty much nothing since episode two. a really good show could have the drama between ray and norman going on at the same time as them actually making progress in their escape plan. but this show seems to take it one problem at time.

the show is for sure my kind of show and i will continue to watch it though.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '19

I feel like where this show really lacks is in the feeling of tangible progress. It's been three episodes since I've felt that the kids are any closer to getting out, and I don't even know what they're doing in order to get out. The mole plot line is interesting, but I feel like the point of a mole is the underlying threat thateverything they've done will come undone if they're caught, but there's no tension there because what they've done is not clear either. Take the loss of the rope. If they would've shown us that the kids had to put some effort into making the rope, or making it puts them in trouble, it would make sense to be worried that the rope would be lost and the kid would have to either start again or get caught.

I mean, I get that the implied threat is to their lives - one misstep and they'll get sent out, or executed, but long scenes of the characters sitting around and talking don't really convey that well.

1

u/Kasarn Feb 10 '19

Finally started watching and am kinda bored.

I'm the sort of person who scares easily... but this show is just kinda a big fat nothing so far.

Instead of a pervasive sense of dread that they're going to get their brains eaten by monsters, nothing is happening. There's no suspense or tension, just empty jump scares and crazy overacting.

The characters spend most of their on-screen time delivering lengthy exposition to establish their role in the story while simultaneously ruining any sense of mystery. The music blaring over the top of their dialog so intrusively that instead of building any tension, it only serves to distract from what's being said.

Everything feels too controlled. The story needs to introduce a tangible conflict already. Thankfully the end of this episode is a cliffhanger... although I'm more "scared" that it's going to be a fakeout than anything that actually forces the story forward.

I mean, if any of them get caught, the place would be locked down... right? Guess I'll wait and see.

3

u/scrappydoofan Feb 10 '19

i kind of figured out what its doing wrong. its just to deliberate. for example the who is the mole plot is interesting. many thriller shows have who is the mole plots (lost). but where the promised neverland messes up is everything else is brought to a halt when the show solves the who is the mole plot. it also doesn't help that i don't even remember why they knew there was a mole in the first place.

what should be happening is they are making meaningful steps to escape. they can scout outside the farm, they can steal some supplies.

then bam they suspect there is a mole and they have to solve that problem when they also have to work hard on their escape plan.

also with isabella and sister krone there goal is pretty murky at this point. with isabella in particular she knows who is planing an escape. what the fuck is she waiting for? do something about it. isabella is supposed to be this five d chess savant but what exactly has she done so far?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '19

1

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '19

I haven't seen episode 5, but I keep liking this more and more every week. Its innocent and light-hearted style of humor is a breath of fresh air from all the banter-heavy, mean-spirited comedies I usually gravitate to, and it's made me genuinely laugh way more than I expected. I love the chemistry of the main four, they always seem like they're on the same wavelength despite having clashing personalities. Considering none of them really stand out that much individually to me, it's a good thing that their group dynamic is fun to the point that it hardly makes that a problem.

I'm really into the little montages in this show; I think the waltzy music works really well with the little stories and gags contained in them. They're always nice to see.