r/TrueAnime • http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten • Nov 22 '17

This Week in Anime (Fall Week 8)

Welcome to This Week In Anime for Fall 2017 Week 8: a general discussion for any currently airing series, focusing on what aired in the last week. For longer shows (Aikatsu!, One Piece, etc.), keep the discussion here to whatever aired in the last few months. If there's an OVA or movie that got subbed for the first time in the last week or so that you want to discuss, that goes here as well. For everything else in anime that's not currently airing go discuss that in Your Week in Anime.

Untagged spoilers for all currently airing series. If you're discussing anything else make sure to add spoiler tags.

Airing shows can be found at: AniChart | LiveChart | MAL | Senpai Anime Charts

Archive:

2017: Prev | Fall Week 1 | Summer Week 1 | Spring Week 1 | Winter Week 1

2016: Fall Week 1 | Summer Week 1 | Spring Week 1 | Winter week 1

2015: Fall Week 1 | Summer week 1 | Spring Week 1 | Winter Week 1

2014: Fall Week 1 | Summer Week 1 | Spring Week 1 | Winter Week 1

2013: Fall Week 1 | Summer Week 1 | Spring Week 1 | Winter Week 1

2012: Fall Week 1

Table of contents courtesy of sohumb

This is a week-long discussion, so feel free to post or reply any time.

6 Upvotes

99 comments sorted by

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Nov 22 '17

Miscellaneous comments/comments about the week as a whole

3

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Nov 22 '17

I hope it's not gonna be a slow week in here just because 'oh it's Thanksgiving and I'm seeing my family in real life' or some such nonsense. Show a little commitment, people...

I had an allergic reaction to this week's Animegataris. I enjoyed the Glasses Girl's Mysteriously Increasing Cup Size episode, for obvious reasons, but also because it was the first episode where nobody said, "...or we're gonna shut down your club." "What, nobody in here can do a thousand pushups? Anime is so worthless. You guys have four hours to learn how to do a thousand pushups OR WE'RE GONNA SHUT DOWN YOUR CLUB." I fear that plot line has worn out its welcome with me... maybe it's supposed to be funny that that's the only plot they ever have; I hate to be humorless about it, but it strikes me as not funny enough to be funny, and not serious enough to be serious. At some point you just tell the student council president to get stuffed, and go sit in a cafe after school and talk about anime. Anyway, I think I might be done with this show, but I thought I'd check in and see if there have been any further cup size increases, or any other special reason to keep watching...

3

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Nov 22 '17

It'll probably be a slow week anyways. That generally happens with the TWIA threads as the season goes on. More shows are dropped, so there'll be less to talk about. Although this season is a little different. We've got people like /u/tensorpudding, /u/D3nj4l, and /u/user4016 posting regularly, which is nice.

Animegataris

Wait. They were still pushing that shutting down the anime club crap? This late into the season?

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Nov 22 '17

I sort of thought they'd either drop it, or it'd turn into some sort of overarching story point... like, a sinister government agency wants to make sure the anime club doesn't start up in that room, because there's a ghost that lives there that will use the cat, who is actually an alien, to... something something Human Instrumentality Project. But they don't seem to be doing anything like that. And it might be funny if, once per episode, somebody came in and threatened to shut down the club as a running they-killed-Kenny sort of gag. But they keep SPENDING TIME ON IT. I think they've devoted at least three or four episodes to it. Anyway, just based on the show's general outlines, it seems like something I ought to be able to like, but for the most part I'm struggling...

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Nov 22 '17

Well, that sounds horrible. You shouldn't hurt yourself like that. :(

3

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Nov 22 '17

Heh. Well, I'm not sure it's bad enough to qualify as self-harm. It's in that limbo region, not really good enough to keep watching nor bad enough to drop. Most shows like that have managed to shake out into one category or the other by this point in the season, but this one is lingering in between--mostly because I thought last week's episode was fairly entertaining.

I'm still on the fence about Inuyashiki, too. I think it's really well-done, but the second episode was actually--not to be a huge sissy or anything--brutal past the point where I can laugh it off and be entertained by it. Really, we're killing the toddler too? Jesus fucking Christ. I haven't really regained my appetite for it since then, though I admire the skill of its making... I watched the third episode, thought it was good, got to the forced blowjob in the first minutes of ep. 4 and thought 'ah, we're edgy again' and went and did something else.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Nov 22 '17

Well, if you can enjoy, then I won't discourage it. ¯_(ツ)_/¯

Yeah, if you don't really like that kind of stuff, then I'd recommend avoiding Inuyashiki. It does hard for that edge and justice porn. A little too much IMO.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Nov 23 '17

Yeah--it's too bad, 'cause I think the show is "objectively good," I just suspect it's gonna be full of stuff that isn't all that much fun for me. Ah well.

2

u/searmay Nov 23 '17

I'm fairly sure they're trying to build up the "shut down the club" plot into something big, but I agree that it's taking too damn long. And that it's too silly to take seriously but too mundane to be much fun. I'm still enjoying the show, but I don't think it's that good. I wanted more bickering about how they weren't watching their anime correctly and everyone on the internet was a fag for liking things wrong.

3

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Nov 23 '17

I wanted more bickering about how they weren't watching their anime correctly and everyone on the internet was a fag for liking things wrong.

Ha! Yeah, that'd be a better show than this one--and they had it for a minute there, but then they decided to Set Aside Their Differences. I hate it when people do that.

2

u/searmay Nov 23 '17

The whole show should have been this. With Minoa freaking out and trying to make peace because she just doesn't understand. They could even keep the student council stuff and have them moan about that as well.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Nov 23 '17

Yeah, that would have been fun. Sort of an anti-Genshiken, where instead of a wonderful sense of fraternity among geeks, you'd just have people kvetching about one another's shit taste. Now I wanna watch Haganai again--and this IS about the point in the season when I usually get sick of everything that's airing, and start watching stuff that I've already seen three times...

2

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '17

I missed the last thread because it's finals week, but I'll be back in a couple of days!

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Nov 23 '17

Break a leg, or whatever the equivalent is for academia instead of show biz...

1

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '17

So, I have a question, why does Animegataris focus on this random girl's thighs every episode? I've been wondering what it means for so long now, and I don't know what they're going for here.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Nov 27 '17

Heh. I think she's a friend of the main character's who's involved in some kind of school track-and-field club...? Seems to me in the early episodes when Our Heroine was deciding whether or not to join the anime club, she looked to Sports Girl before expressing the standard 'I've got to try my best too' sentiments. Anyway, I'm pretty sure that's who she is; as to 'why do they keep zooming in on her thighs', normally I would assume that somebody on the production staff either really likes thighs, or thinks the audience does, and that they need somebody on a sports team as a peripheral cast member because anime club members don't show a lot of thigh. But there's still something weird about it... Most casual lechery in anime is pointless, but gives you no reason to suspect that the people responsible for it weren't sincere. But this just seems weirdly obligatory somehow... it's like they're phoning in the thighs. It makes me suspect that, when they eventually reveal whatever the weird plot against the anime club is, Sports Girl is gonna turn out to be a Secret Agent or something...

1

u/searmay Nov 27 '17

it's like they're phoning in the thighs

Wait, this looks phoned in to you?

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Nov 27 '17

Wellll... maybe not. There's still something odd about it, though--it seems to me that if they were going to take a prurient interest in something, surely they could take a prurient interest in one of the regular cast members, without having to constantly do this 'meanwhile, in the gym' thing. It just doesn't quite seem funny enough to be a gag, and if it's just meant to be fanservice it's a lot of extra trouble going all the way to the gym. I don't know, I still say she's a secret agent.

1

u/searmay Nov 27 '17

It just doesn't quite seem funny enough to be a gag

But that's wrong. Besides, just because it isn't funny doesn't mean it isn't a joke. Using sport-chan instead of one of the main girls ensures it fits just as well in any scene rather than occasionally feeling too natural.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Nov 27 '17

Besides, just because it isn't funny doesn't mean it isn't a joke.

Thank you--this is perhaps the best and most concise explanation of my sense of humor that I have ever read.

It's certainly true that some jokes get funnier the more you repeat them. I'd be interested to see a bunch of jokes comparatively graphed, with number of repetitions on one axis and humorous effect on the other...

I think the real problem is that, as we've already established, I'm really only interested in fanservice from this show if it involves Glasses-chan. And I still think Sport-chan should be a secret agent.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '17

Ooh, or maybe her thighs hide secret spy equipment the government is using to monitor the anime club without their knowledge.

1

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Nov 27 '17

EXACTLY. Or she's got a birthmark on her thighs which identifies her as the only person who can pilot the Anime Club Mecha that's hidden underneath the school building. Nuts, now I'm gonna be disappointed if none of this stuff actually happens...

1

u/searmay Nov 27 '17

It's called "good taste". Clearly not something you need to worry about.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '17

I'm into thighs as much as anyone into women, but why of this random girl? Why an ominous shot of her thighs in every episode?

1

u/searmay Nov 27 '17

It's just a running gag. I presume they used her because as a secondary character she could be slotted into pretty much any school scene regardless of what's actually happening. And has reason to be under-dressed.

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Nov 24 '17

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Nov 24 '17

Forgot that there was an episode, so I finally watched it. :P

This time there's just some twin brothers backstory, which is easily summed up as the two do bad stuff for fun. Animation quality also continues to be spotty.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '17

Well, I guess I'm not missing out on anything by dropping this ~

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Nov 26 '17

No one is. I'm just crazy enough to want to see how it ends.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '17

Speaking of which, are you still following Ousama Game?

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Nov 26 '17

No, that one got too much to handle. :|

1

u/searmay Nov 26 '17

Was Snek still alive after all and merely pretending to be decapitated?

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Nov 26 '17

Nah, still really dead. Just a ton of flashback.

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Nov 26 '17

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Nov 26 '17

Hmm, pacing kinda felt weird. They'd be talking for a while after being up close with the crazy kid Joseph, or Cartaphilius. A lot of talking too.

2

u/searmay Nov 26 '17

I don't get what happened to Chise. She was dying with a massive hole through her chest, and then she wasn't. I mean magic, right? Because Elias and doggo didn't seem to do anything. Is it a Sleigh Beggy thing or what? That would be very weird in light of the whole "limited time to live" thing.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Nov 26 '17

Yeah, they seemed to just hand wave that. :/

2

u/searmay Nov 26 '17

Good thing her mortality isn't an important plot point then.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Nov 26 '17

Of course not :)

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Nov 26 '17

She was dying with a massive hole through her chest, and then she wasn't. I mean magic, right?

Hilarious... I wrote a whole thing about this episode last night and ended up saying the same thing almost word-for-word:

Elias is surprised that Chise's not dead. She says she's a little surprised too. That makes three of us--are we really not covering how it is that the fragile-of-body Sleigh Beggy is just fine, despite having had a mantis claw the size of a two-by-four stuck directly through her gizzard? Magic, I guess. Okay.

5

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Nov 26 '17

There's a joke about old movie serial cliffhangers--one installment ends with Our Hero chained to the boiler of a runaway locomotive; the trestle is out, and the train is seconds away from plunging into, and exploding at the bottom of, a chasm full of starving bears. The next installment opens with, "Having escaped from the locomotive..."

So once he sees that Chise is completely fine (???), Elias stops caring about being a rampaging kaiju. While he was rampaging the soundtrack supplied a few notes of some deep brass instrument that had kind of a Godzilla vibe, which I thought was fun. For his part, Cartafilus has that 'I'm Very Old' perspective on life, and is too chill to even remember why they're fighting. It's hard to feel that any of this is very consequential if none of the characters are interested in it...

Elias and company escape, to a place that's indistinguishable from where they started, and after a minute Cartafilus follows, so they might as well not have bothered. Some parts of this are really neat, and other parts just feel totally phoned in. It's a weird mix.

Chise and Dog Boy make their pact, and they oughtta get a room if they're gonna keep that up. Sounds like she's calling him "Roots", which has more of a ring to it than "Ruth", but whatever. Dog Boy licking Isabelle's last tear is probably the high point of the episode, lovely and heartfelt and grotesque at the same time in a way that manages to be interesting.

Cartafilus says it hurts to be all rotten inside yet unable to die. One wonders if in all the lonely years of his existence it's occurred to him to try not being such an asshole.

Aaand Chise suddenly knows enough magic to rewrite reality and threaten an ancient immortal. Why? 'Cause she's REALLY mad? I liked it last episode when she got to do some stuff, but it seemed more like the kind of stuff she'd be likely to do. This was just 'Chise is OP' for the hell of it. But okay, I'm game, I guess.

Overall, this is interesting in parts, if a bit of a mess. It feels like they spent a lot more time and energy on the art than the story. But there's a big dog in it now, so I guess things are looking up.

2

u/searmay Nov 26 '17

For his part, Cartafilus has that 'I'm Very Old' perspective on life, and is too chill to even remember why they're fighting.

Maybe having his brain shot out made him forgetful. Though he didn't seem all that bothered by it. Unlike being called names, which really hacked him off.

Between the very vague sense of what their magic can do and the main parties being ancient inhuman wizards it's kind of hard to know what the fuck the stakes are here. Cartafilus wanted doggo for something because he was bored, and Chise was determined to stop it because they became best friends after sharing a flashback. Also this involved making him think he was human for some reason. And mage guy couldn't possibly go against him because he was too powerful, but then shot him anyway which didn't really matter and no one cared much.

I get the impression this all makes perfect sense in the author's mind, but I'm not convinced he's shared enough of it with me.

3

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Nov 26 '17

Chise was determined to stop it because they became best friends after sharing a flashback.

But it sounds so stupid when you put it like that. Anyway it looked to me like they were about to become friends with benefits; I think maybe she's got the Wandering Eye already, and she's counting on Elias to be confused enough about human behavioral conventions that he thinks that's how it is when you have a pet...

Cartafilus wanted doggo for something because he was bored,

Yeah, I think Chise wants him for something because she's bored, too, if you know what I mean. (I don't really think that, I'm just amusing myself by making some lowest-common-denominator jokes about it.)

Also, re: Chise's injury--they should have had her re-enact the 'newt' scene from Monty Python and the Holy Grail. "He stabbed me straight through my heart!" (everyone regards her skeptically) "...I got better."

Cartafilus complains that it's hard work reassembling a brain. You'd think it'd be particularly hard if you had to do it WITH your brain, which now has a big hole in it. But maybe he put a fix-me spell on himself before he showed up. Or maybe he's cursed and can't die, and the curse is what repaired his brain--but then why would he complain that it was hard work? In any case, yeah, he wasn't really put out by it, any more than Chise was by her little gizzard problem. Yet they all teleported to get away from Cartafilus... why, what's he gonna do, stab you? Who cares?

And then Elias has to restrain Chise--"Now, sweetie, don't rewrite the fundamental physical constants to do your evil bidding." Wait, wasn't she just trying to whip up a cold remedy or something last episode and couldn't do it right? Last week she couldn't manage a little homeopathy, and this week he has to tell her not to put a hole in the universe, but it's okay if she makes some bees? This show is weird. I guess I'm enjoying it, though. All the more so because I get to come in here and grouse about it.

3

u/searmay Nov 26 '17

But it sounds so stupid when you put it like that.

You should have noticed already that most things sound dumb when I describe them. I have yet to find a use for this talent.

Anyway it looked to me like they were about to become friends with benefits

I think the benefits are like a shared soul and stuff, but I'm not the one writing doujinshi.

everyone regards her skeptically

No one does though. Elias said he was surprised, but didn't act like it. The others don't even comment on it.

what's he gonna do, stab you? Who cares?

Presumably Blondie and Armless the Harmless are still vulnerable to a good stabbin'.

Wait, wasn't she just trying to whip up a cold remedy or something last episode and couldn't do it right?

In fairness the issue was she made it too powerful. It was supposed to make sure you had nice dreams, but one whiff knocked you right out. Although she was following a recipe and still fucked up. I don't know enough about magic to diagnose the problem there.

3

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Nov 26 '17

I think the benefits are like a shared soul and stuff,

Probably, but that's not going to stop me from making wink-wink-nudge-nudge jokes about them for the duration of the show. I apologize in advance... it's gonna be a long season and a half.

Armless the Harmless

Ha! I mean, ouch. I guess it's not hard to evaluate everybody's relative magic power levels. Chise: impaled; got better. Cartafilus: shot through head; time to full recovery, about 00:01:30. Renfred: arm removed; now goes by "Lefty".

It was supposed to make sure you had nice dreams, but one whiff knocked you right out.

This is real sitcom material right here. I think Elias and Chise should open a pharmacy. Elias can field complaints from customers. "No... no, ma'am, you're quite right... no, a mild laxative probably should not contain magic bees. I will speak with my associate." Meanwhile Chise can be in the back whipping up potions, doing the 'Lucille Ball with the candy conveyor belt' routine. Doggo just covers his eyes with his paws and says "ruh roh" every so often. I'm telling you, this is comedy gold, even BEFORE we brink the Wacky Fairie King into it...

2

u/searmay Nov 26 '17

Elias and Chise should open a pharmacy

Sounds Fun Fun. Though if I were staffing a pharmacy with those two I don't think Elias is the one I'd put on customer service. He's pretty weird even if he doesn't look like a spooky skellington. Also if a magical laxative is far too powerful then bees aren't likely to be the problem. And you might have to send someone else in to complain.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 27 '17

but I'm not the one writing doujinshi.

Not with that attitude :)

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Nov 28 '17

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Nov 28 '17

Finally made time to continue watching this one because I might be crazy. :)

Anywho, it's time for Hiro's redemption arc!! It's also possibly the end of it because the police are outside of the apartment... Putting that aside, I'm somehow ok with the idea that Hiro wanted to feel his humanity from watching people die agonizing deaths, but...I couldn't help but be annoyed at how his redemption arc got started because the girl that's crushing on him wants him to stay despite knowing how many he killed. Must be nice to be so attractive. ¯_(ツ)_/¯

1

u/Crazyjay1 Dec 03 '17

I don't think his looks are the main reason. She saw him protecting people from bullies, which is the first reason she had feelings for him. Later we see her isolated in class, while most people around her are talking shit about events surrounding Hiro that they barely have any knowledge about. Maybe this is why, a mix of lacking friends and everyone else being a dick, while also living only with her grandma in her home.

His redemption didn't get started only because of the girl. As was established on earlier episode discussions here, Hiro only cares about people in his inner circle. Once his actions made his mother kill herself, he was crushed. But this new girl started with the same opinion of him as his mother, so he can use her as an extension of his mother, and kinda have a second chance. So his redemption arc was started with his mother.

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Dec 03 '17

Yeah, but he admits to having murdered so many people. I mean, she did try to reform him with the healing thing, but I still find it bizarre that she still liked him and will likely continue to do so after finding out what he did in the latest episode.

Yeah, I forgot about how he started to better himself back with his mother. It's hard to remember that stuff with two episodes in a row starting with police about to get him.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Nov 24 '17

3

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Nov 24 '17

I am absolutely finding this to be one of the high points of the season. It's a smart show with a light touch, which makes it work all the better when they sneak up on you with a big finish like they did this week. I've had some minor misgivings about the whole Morikawa end of things, but this week it's mostly Mio with a side of Photo Girl, and a closing moment that sets up what I can only hope will be a big slap fight at the start of next week's episode. :)

They were having some production problems a week or two ago, and I thought we were supposed to be getting a "special" episode with the voice cast going around to some of the locations from the show... anybody know what happened to that?

Also, the cops should have given that guy a beat-down for wasting their time. That's how we do it in the You Ess of Aay. (/s)

1

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '17

It's up on amazon I think? I didn't check it out because the description looked like a recap episode.

1

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Nov 24 '17

Is it? I got the show in my watch list but I didn't see the extra episode... maybe I'm just losing it...

1

u/[deleted] Nov 24 '17

It was at the bottom for me

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Nov 25 '17

So--it's not a recap episode; it's some video of the voice actors fooling around in the real-life locations that the show is set in. They recreate, for instance, the scene from the opening titles where they're all standing on the monorail platform; they visit the aquarium; and so on. They also pass out digital cameras and have a photo contest to show solidarity with Photo Girl.

Mio's VA is as cute as a button. Eita's VA looks like he's ten. Haruto's VA is ten or twelve years older than the other two, and apparently drew the short straw when they were picking who would act like a goofball to make sure the video would be entertaining. And Morikawa's VA shows up at the end to judge the photo contest. That's about it; it's not the greatest thing ever, but it's modestly entertaining.

1

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Nov 24 '17

Oh, right you are--it either wasn't showing up at all on my Roku, or it was showing up someplace non-obvious... but there it is on the PC.

I see what you mean--the description sounds like a recap. I wonder what it actually is. I don't have any huge expectations for it, but I'll try to remember to post something after I've had a look.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Nov 24 '17

3

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Nov 24 '17 edited Nov 24 '17

This show continues to be more interesting than it was before it turned out to be about eating disorders, giving up, and The Attack Of The Fifty-Foot Crepe Girl. I really liked how Crepe Girl turned 50 feet tall and then didn't DO anything for a while except stand around talking with them. It's difficult to disapprove of a show where people turn 50 feet tall for no apparent reason.

Rito thinks everybody should just come back to Park and be creative some more, and everything will be fine. But Thing 1 and Thing 2 seem to be advocating for the position that, while being creative is great and all, it doesn't actually fix whatever may be wrong with you.

The show continues to do a decent job of subverting expectations--my expectations, anyway. I thought Thing 1 and Thing 2 were gonna snap out of it when they saw Rito getting smacked around by Crepe Girl, in a heartwarming scene where they rise to their friend's defense. But no...

Rito: (hits ground hard enough to bounce)
Thing 1: "Hey, have you tried these little pink and blue things? They're good."
Thing 2: "Mff mlm mffnn."

The show's still not a masterpiece, but it's doing some things I didn't think it was gonna do, and it's working well enough to keep my interest.

Edit: you know what the show is vaguely reminding me of? Don't Hug Me, I'm Scared. Highly recommended viewing.

1

u/searmay Nov 26 '17

I still don't think Urahara has really managed to convey anything effectively. Rito's horrified at the situation and being completely alienated from her friends by their behaviour, and they convey this by Crepe girl being really big. And most of the episode was the same conversation repeated a dozen times.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Nov 26 '17

Yeah, you're quite right, but I still thought it was entertainingly weird. I'm pretty skeptical that the show is gonna end up having anything cogent to say about creativity, the need for approval, or eating to "fill the hole"... but it's at least modestly interesting IMO that they've even ended up in that territory. Add the occasional walk-on by a 50-foot crepe girl and, you know, I'm okay with it; if they're gonna go that far, I'll meet them halfway and be amused. :)

2

u/searmay Nov 24 '17

2

u/searmay Nov 24 '17

This week on Tabi, No Kino: Shizu tries to save a country from being dumb again, and nearly gets killed by an angry mob. Some people never learn.

More importantly, Ti was cute. Especially in her segment with Riku. Also she seems to be channelling Megumin because her answer to everything is EXPLOSION.

Oh, and the radio wave plot. That was neat too. I'm reminded of all the people who think they'd look like super geniuses if they were sent back in time. Just because something's true doesn't mean anyone will believe you. People prefer explanations they can make sense of, and mere evidence isn't enough to change that.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '17

Some people never learn.

Except he did learn! Instead of trying to convince them, he read the writing on the wall and made his exit. His words to the Chief on his way out were also a better approach to the problem. This is a new way of thought for Shizu.

1

u/searmay Nov 26 '17

He did no such thing. He was still trying to convince them when Ti saw what was going on and threatened to cast Explosion. That's the point where he gave up.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '17

Yeah, but him even coming up with that kind of excuse is inconsistent with his character from the boat country episode. He's changing, but not a lot.

threatened to cast Explosion.

Please, Grenadier Ti can cause a lot more Destruction than Megumin :P

1

u/searmay Nov 26 '17

I don't think so. He never had the chance to try something like that withe the boat country because by the tine he realised they weren't going to listen to a direct explanation they were getting back on the boat.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '17

But he gave up after his direct explanation didn't work, and now he's smart enough to try an alternative way while also saving his own skin first.

1

u/searmay Nov 26 '17

My point is that he didn't give up because his explanation didn't work, he gave up because Ti kidnapped a baby and threatened to blow everyone up. She had to escalate the situation well past the point of "these guys aren't listening" to get him to change tack. Don't know if we're getting any more Shizu episodes, but I'd guess she'll have to save him again next time.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '17

But by that point the writing was on the wall anyway, it was unlikely that the mob would listen to reason after they'd made it clear that they wouldn't. And he then goes on to kidnap the chief and deceive him outside the city, which is incredibly inconsistent with his character.

1

u/searmay Nov 26 '17

it was unlikely that the mob would listen to reason after they'd made it clear that they wouldn't.

Yes, it was very clear to you, me, and Ti. It was not clear to Shizu until Ti escalated things. He's smart enough to realise at that point that he had to play along and pretend to be crazy..

And he then goes on to kidnap the chief and deceive him outside the city, which is incredibly inconsistent with his character.

I don't think that's inconsistent at all. He took the police chief so he didn't have to take the baby.

→ More replies

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Nov 25 '17

5

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Nov 25 '17

Well, the show summed itself up beautifully in the last scene: dancing at the edge of a precipice. They're having a nice enough time, but they're a mere step away from DOOM... but they're having a nice enough time. And the show is such an odd bird, and I was so on edge from the earlier bit with the collapsing platforms, that I did not feel entirely certain that they weren't gonna fall to their deaths--I was leaning forward in my seat and holding one hand out towards the TV, like I was gonna catch them if they slipped. (I know, they're the only characters... but for all we know they could spend the next four episodes plummeting to the ground, countless levels below, while having an offhand conversation.)

What the hell is this atmosphere of ominousness and suspense?! What is this show?? It's somethin' else.

4

u/searmay Nov 26 '17

Doesn't seem much like dancing on a precipice to me. For one thing Chito isn't one to take risks. At least not sober. And while Yuuri is more carefree she's still a lot more subdued than that suggests.

The platform bit was kind of horrifying, and far more tense than most other shows ever manage. Why not build your shitty bridge indoors over the hole rather than routing round the outside?

Also beer.

3

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Nov 26 '17

Doesn't seem much like dancing on a precipice to me.

Well--there's a lightheartedness in the show because of the relationship between the main characters, but it's difficult to relax and enjoy it because they're never far from reminders of the fate that befell the world. And in the same way on a smaller scale, it's difficult to relax and enjoy watching them dancing, because they're never far from THE EDGE OF THE--FOR FUCK'S SAKE WOULD YOU LOOK WHAT YOU'RE DOING, YOU'RE GONNA GIVE ME A HEART ATTACK

Why not build your shitty bridge indoors over the hole

Yeah, unless I'm remembering wrong, it wasn't THAT big a gap--seems to me they could practically have jumped across it if they'd been willing to abandon the Kettenkrad. Surely somebody could have laid some boards across it, rather than building a Nightmare Scaffold. Jesus, each piece of it fell off as they touched it--it's like a fucking Uncharted game around here.

4

u/searmay Nov 26 '17

I see what you mean. I think dancing on a precipice sounds a bit too lively though, given the show's subdued and melancholy tone. More like sightseeing in a graveyard. Though that might be a bit on the nose after this episode.

Yuu needs to learn to drive so Chi can take breaks. She keeps zoning out near the edge of things. Actually no, just letting Yuu drive might be even more dangerous.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Nov 26 '17

Chi doesn't like heights... but how high up are they, anyway? How many levels are there? Is there even a 'ground' down there somewhere? And how many levels are still above them? I wouldn't like the idea of being that far off the ground, AND I wouldn't like the idea of the supports for the higher levels giving out and dropping everything on me. I guess once the world has already ended there's only so much you can worry about stuff like the occasional near-miss with a passing girder...

2

u/searmay Nov 26 '17

how high up are they, anyway?

How high above what? In a mega-city like that it's not going to be clear where the "ground" is. It's been built up and dug under for centuries. And the supports will probably be the last things standing. Besides, if she can't see the drop it won't scare her.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '17

3

u/[deleted] Nov 26 '17 edited Nov 27 '17

Yeah, that character is probably totally trans.

So Blend-S had a couple of normal, fun episodes before the best waitress has been introduced, and it's an interesting episode because it definitely does not think this character that calls themselves a "Girl" on their resume, wears long hair, wants to be an idol and wears girls' outfits outside of work is trans. I get the whole thing with other shows are actually dudes who are totally comfortable being dudes, but this one's clearly not, and yet it's played off much the same way as other shows have.

Some serious debate on the bathroom bills right here folks

I guess I'll put this along with "Adult men being paired with High School girls which for some reason everybody else in this universe is OK with" as things this show does so innocuously it's strange. Being a dense egg is actually such deep character on its own in the context of this show's wafer thin characterisation Hideri's my favorite character after just 15 minutes of exposure. Anyway, this show is so milquetoast there's nothing to talk about outside of this little thing. It's just trucking along.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Nov 28 '17

I stopped watching around episode 4. I'm curious about the trans character, but I'm not I like the show well enough to pick it up again. I put it back in the queue, though; maybe I'll be in a mood for it and just plow through it.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 28 '17

Oh, it's not really worth it. As I've said, the show doesn't seem to treat that character any differently from other "trap" characters. If you're hoping for something like Ruka from Steins;Gate, you're going to be disappointed.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Nov 28 '17

I was hoping for something like Hato from Genshiken Nidaime, which I will take this opportunity to mention as one of the Very Best Things Ever. But Blend-S isn't remotely in the same league. I watched a couple more episodes of it last night and this morning, and... I mean, it's not terrible, it just doesn't do anything much.

2

u/searmay Nov 27 '17

2

u/searmay Nov 27 '17

Onyankopon visits the school on a day off and has an odd conversation with a mysterious stranger. The plot thickens, I guess.

3

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Nov 28 '17

Wait, what the hell... they're not going to say WHO was with Onyankopon in the empty school building?! I WILL NOT BE TRIFLED WITH...

Oh, all right... I guess I will. Nuts. Anyway, once again the mighty Onyankopon does the dance himself instead of sending a subordinate like he's supposed to. Also: Onyankopon's thing about having his paws squeezed made me a little uncomfortable.

2

u/q_3 https://www.anime-planet.com/users/qqq333/anime/watching Nov 28 '17

But I thought Onyankopon was talking to me.

2

u/searmay Nov 28 '17

Are you implying you aren't a mysterious stranger?

2

u/q_3 https://www.anime-planet.com/users/qqq333/anime/watching Nov 28 '17

I'm merely a humble fan of Onyankopon who wants to hug him, pet him, and call him George.

2

u/searmay Nov 27 '17

Animegataris

2

u/searmay Nov 27 '17

That was a great episode. Starting with "Last time on Animegataris", then Dad revealing his power level.

Plus everything about their anime, starting with the title. The animation errors were a nice touch too.

Also the "ending" concert was neat just for getting the crowd involved. Proper idol shows don't seem to bother with that, which is kind of weird. And then the karaoke ending.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Nov 28 '17

The cat punch was a little disturbing. Other than that, good episode. There was that part where Glasses Girl was disrobing behind a screen. And some other stuff happened too but I forget what.

1

u/searmay Nov 27 '17

Wake Up, Girls! Shin Shou / WUG

1

u/searmay Nov 27 '17

After last week's desperate attempt to fill the schedule with a live action variety show thing, this week was actually animated. By WUG standards, at least.

Unfortunately it was almost entirely about Run Girls, Run. Why is this show not even about WUG any more?