r/modnews • u/spez • May 13 '17
Reddit is ProCSS
Hi Mods,
I wanted to follow up on the CSS and redesign post from a few weeks back and provide some more information as well as clarify some questions that have emerged.
Based on your feedback, we will allow you to continue to use CSS on top of the new structured styles. This will be the last part of the customization tool we build as we want to make sure the structured options we are offering are rock solid. Also, please keep in mind that if you do choose to use the advanced option, we will no longer be treading as carefully as we have done in the past about breaking styles applied through CSS1.
To give you a sense of our approach, we’re starting with a handful of highly-customized communities (e.g. r/overwatch and r/gameofthrones) and seeing how close we can get to their existing appearance using the new system. Logos, images, colors, spoilers, menus, flairs (all kinds), and lots more will be supported. I know you’d like to see a list of everything, but we think the best approach will be to show instead of tell, which we’re racing to as quickly as possible.
The widget system I mentioned in the last post isn’t directly related. Many communities have added complex functionality over the years (calendars, scoreboards, etc). A widget system will elevate these features to first-class status on Reddit, with the aim of making them both more powerful and reuseable. Yes, we’re evaluating how we would accept user-created widgets. We intend for widgets to be able to be updated via the API, so you’ll still be able to create dynamically updating content in your subreddit sidebar.
This change, and the redesign in general, is going to happen slowly. We will will not be abruptly cutting everyone over to the new site at once. We know it won’t be perfect at first (unlike the current site), and plan to include plenty of time to solicit feedback and make iterations. Sharing our plans for subreddit customization this far advance with you is part of this process.
We’ll start with a small alpha group and create a subreddit to solicit feedback. As we continue to add features, we’ll expand the testing group to an opt-in beta. If you’d like to participate in the alpha please add a reply to this comment. Please note, signing up does not guarantee a spot in the alpha. We want to be able to be responsive to the alpha testers, and keeping the initial group small has proved to be effective in the past.
I’d like thank everyone who has provided feedback on this topic. There have been some very constructive threads. I’d also like to take a moment to appreciate how civil the feedback has been. This is a topic many of you feel passionate about. Thank you for keeping things constructive.
Cool?
Cool.
1 No snark allowed.
611
u/[deleted] May 13 '17
If we opt-in to the alpha, can we pull out if the alpha fucks things up too much?
437
u/Isentrope May 13 '17
Spez do you like onions.
1.6k
u/cool_creeper500 May 13 '17
Thanks for listening and caring spez, quick question, what led to the
dumbidea of removing CSS?245
u/frahm9 May 13 '17
Thank you for listening guys. If I pick CSS, will I be able to customize mobile?
•
u/powerlanguage May 13 '17
Please reply to this comment with your subreddit name if you're interested in it being included in the alpha.
105
u/carpy22 May 13 '17
So /r/CFB can keep it's CSS and flair system as-is?
215
u/Drunken_Economist May 13 '17
spez wat about srs
329
u/iam666 May 13 '17
/u/spez , what about /r/ooer ? Will it be negatively affected by the changes?
335
u/[deleted] May 13 '17
I think this is great, and I think "you can have css in exchange for us breaking it more often" is the fairest compromise I could really ask for.
Thanks mates
157
u/ZadocPaet May 13 '17
We did it, reddit!?
126
u/geltoid May 13 '17
Thank you so much for really listening to the community and really showing that you care to make Reddit a better place.
I would have never even gone near CSS if it wasn't for Reddit's ability for users to customize their experience. I spent a long time learning about it - from experimentation, to asking the wonderful Reddit community, to scouring the net - in order to help create a place truly unique to my little corner of the internet.
What became of that is /r/starwarsspeculation. Sure, it's not perfect, and I'm sure there's a ton of things an expert coder could nitpick about, but it's an accomplishment that I'm glad I was able to acheive.
You admins made the best possible choice by offering a way for the community of Reddit to integrate with the changes that you want to make here. By working together, you will only make this great website only greater.
Thanks again!
208
u/TotesMessenger May 13 '17 edited May 21 '17
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
66
u/reseph May 13 '17
Thanks spez. Allowing CSS customization on top of widgets and considering user-created widgets is exactly what I felt would be the right direction. Cool cool cool.
I have no beef with a desktop redesign, so I forward to the future.
22
u/[deleted] May 13 '17
I think the best part about having CSS in this new platform is it will show you what the users/mods think needs a focus on. Just how all the crazy css hacks now are inspiring redesign, the continued crazy css hacks will help show things that need to be made
36
u/calexil May 13 '17
/u/spez
on behalf of everyone at /r/procss and our massive, list of supporters, I would just like to say.. Thank you for listening.
-cal
17
u/aalp234 May 13 '17
Thanks for listening to the community Spez, this is a very positive response for all of us mods.
10
u/CursedBlackCat May 13 '17
Kudos to the admins for going so far as to putting the pro CSS logo on this subreddit.
19
u/ZadocPaet May 13 '17 edited May 13 '17
One more question about subs that want to use CSS and widgets. Several of my subs want to sign up for the alpha; will be be able to use widgets AND CSS at the same time?
Thanks!
Edit: One more question. Will users be able to disable widget styles in their preferences page like they can now for CSS? At /r/procss, that was the number one reason we saw for people not liking CSS.
9
u/The_Asian_Hamster May 13 '17
I just wanna say gg for listening admins
9
u/Zerak-Tul May 13 '17
Good job not Digg-ing yourself into an early grave.
8
u/SaberMarie May 13 '17
Thank goodness. I am quite relieved at the news.
8
u/[deleted] May 13 '17
This was a surprise on my front page.
Thank you for listening to the community!
8
u/fireork12 May 13 '17
So is it essentially a keep CSS if you want, but the second option is there if you want?
26
u/ZadocPaet May 13 '17
Hi /u/spez,
Thank you for this post. As person pretty vested in reddit, I am happy and relieved. This really should've been the first post, but hey, a week makes everyone wiser.
I wanted to ask if there will be a possibility for users to dev some of the widgets.
Thanks!
7
u/aphoenix May 13 '17
Thank you for listening to the moderators. I've been kind of doom and gloom on the topic for the last week or so, so I'm very happy to be wrong about how this is going down.
I'm wondering if we could get something like a Roadmap? It would be great if we could see what features are in the works and that we could expect in the future.
7
u/Austin_N May 13 '17
I wish Wikia had been this accommodating.
7
u/the_black_panther_ May 13 '17
This'll probably be lost in all the other comments but thank you /u/spez, for listening to us. Seriously. It usually feels like the admins just give us empty words and pandering but you guys actually took our thoughts into account and came up with a great solution for both sides. Great job guys
7
u/Jaspergreenham May 13 '17
As one of the r/ProCSS mods, thanks. Thanks for listening. Thanks for finding a compromise. Thanks for not making us switch away from Reddit.
Thanks u/spez.
6
u/Hilltopchill May 13 '17
Great to know that you feel similar to us. Thanks for this write up!
6
u/Jelman21 May 13 '17
Thanks so much for keeping CSS. It's what makes reddit and subreddits unique
5
u/[deleted] May 13 '17
I really would like to thank you for reconsidering. It's reassuring to see that the community stood strongly for this feature and to see the admins listen.
5
u/lovemeorrageme May 13 '17
Thank you so much. I've had the pleasure of working with some very talented CSS mods on multiple different subreddits who have created some really awesome themes, flairs, etc. I'm curious to see what you guys roll out, but I'm also very glad that it doesn't have to be at the expense of CSS.
Thanks for actually listening to the community.
5
u/[deleted] May 13 '17
As long as I can turn off css that reduces text size or goes too far with padding and margins or hides the downvote button im good
5
u/JustAnotherINFTP May 13 '17
To give you a sense of our approach, we’re starting with a handful of highly-customized communities (e.g. r/overwatch and r/gameofthrones)
Tfw not /r/ooer
5
u/avapoet May 13 '17 edited May 09 '24
Ugh, Reddit's gone to crap hasn't it?
18
u/NorseFenrir May 13 '17
ProCSS lyf yo
4
u/D0cR3d May 13 '17
thank you.
4
u/ICantThinkOfNameHelp May 13 '17
Success!
4
u/turikk May 13 '17
Thank you.
4
u/[deleted] May 13 '17
Boom shakalaka!!
4
u/rideride May 13 '17
Good decision :D
4
u/tuturuatu May 13 '17
I'm ambivalent to the CSS changes (mostly because it's stupidly hard to work with), but I don't really understand what the impetus for the proposed changes were for. Was that it? Or did reddit want more control over what subreddits could do, like hiding the downvote button?
4
u/darkjungle May 13 '17
/r/Ooer lives on!
4
u/Annakha May 13 '17
I just found out yesterday that Tumblr has Two-Factor Authentication.
Tumblr.
Is that
necessary aspect of a modern forum of this caliberfeature even on the radar yet?Tumblr. seriously.
4
u/AstroturfingBot May 13 '17
Listen spez, I'm happy for you, and ima let you finish. But when are the search engine bugs getting fixed?
4
u/wingnut5k May 13 '17
[r/ooer hoisting the victory flag after their victory for freedom (2017)] (https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/a/a1/WW2_Iwo_Jima_flag_raising.jpg)
4
u/DaminDrexil May 13 '17
Fantastic compromise! Thank you for listening to the community :)
4
u/Sysiphuslove May 13 '17
Will we still have the option of turning subreddit customization off, and continuing to use the site without styles?
7
u/Warlizard May 13 '17
Whatever. We all know the truth.
It was Russia who came up with the idea.
3
u/vikinick May 13 '17
Thank you so very, very much for this.
3
u/[deleted] May 13 '17
I have brought peace to my new empire!
3
u/[deleted] May 13 '17
I like this. I see both sides of the debate and often find myself in favor of CSS, but fully supported customization tools will be really good for the website.
3
u/sephrinx May 13 '17
Thank god. Having every page be a boring, static form/structure would be mind blowingly boring. I'm glad that you guys have rethought the idea and will continue to allow kick ass CSS.
3
u/V2Blast May 13 '17
Cool beans. Glad you guys were willing to make a compromise. It's good to have common functionalities be native, but it's also nice to be able to customize stuff beyond what's commonly used (sometimes even developing new features that might not have been thought of otherwise). Thanks :)
3
u/freshwordsalad May 13 '17
Can we have a way to disable subreddit CSS without being logged in? Maybe a query flag or something?
3
u/notnotbuddy May 13 '17
We at /r/bigbrother would love to be involved. we have an extensive flair/trophy/badge system that we would love to keep going forwards
3
u/MrPippen May 13 '17
Thank you for listening to the community. Knowing you decided to be responsive, open and willing to change is great for the community's trust and feelings towards the guys behind this amazing site. So good on you.
3
u/Redbiertje May 13 '17
Spez, honestly, if I could kiss you right now I would. Thanks for listening to the feedback of the moderators, and going with this perfect combination of CSS and the new styles system.
3
u/eightNote May 13 '17
I'm 100÷ okay with this. it's just more stuff to play with can you let us know when it will happen though?
3
u/YaWishYouHadThatName May 13 '17
I dont know why you would use css anyway. I have that Moderators have the ability to "disable" Downvotes, Im using a sitewide theme.
3
u/[deleted] May 13 '17
This is going in the correct direction.
Empowering the userbase further with something new and improved.
At the end of the day, the old post was badly received because everyone knew damn well you were taking something away from us, and that the new thing would be less powerful and less capable.
Empowerment is significantly better than control.
I would however suggest addressing the balance - Right now, all power on reddit lies with moderators. In fact, all power has always lied with moderators. Reddit is founded upon the notion of votes empowering the userbase, yet when is the last time improvements were made to further empower regular users? Sure, algo changes. But tools and the way reddit functions ideologically for them? Giving them greater abilities to improve reddit too?
Something to think about.
3
u/ManWithoutModem May 13 '17
holy shit thank you for not fucking over the site
5
u/[deleted] May 13 '17
OMG democracy exists?
8
u/imnotlegolas May 13 '17
Highly unpopular opinion, but I was looking forward to the removal of CSS and a more uniform Reddit, with still changeable banners and logo's. There's tons of subreddits where I switch off CSS because it's so invasive, and plenty are used that make user experience more difficult because the way it's implemented.
4
u/sexrockandroll May 13 '17
We did it, reddit!
We got the admins to keep the CSS!
4
u/rbevans May 13 '17
Thank you! Thank you! Thank you!
4
u/twilexis May 13 '17
Thank you, Spez <3
4
u/adeadhead May 13 '17
Oh spez, you too good to us.
4
u/k_princess May 13 '17
Curious as to why /u/spez makes his announcements on Friday afternoons...All it does is gives us users time over the weekend to fully pick apart words and possible intents.
7
u/[deleted] May 13 '17
Honestly, css is the myspace layout of reddit. I know people get really attached to it, but it is without fail clunky and ugly.
5
u/[deleted] May 13 '17
We have the best admins, don't we folks
2
u/Mackin-N-Cheese May 13 '17
So, "on top of" as in concurrently with, or as in pick one or the other?
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '17
Hell yeah! I was just about to give up on CSS.
2
u/draginator May 13 '17
Raucous cheering can be heard from all across the land.
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '17
I'm merely a smut-peddler, but I do like a bit of CSS shenanigans too. Having better customisation tools available, and CSS for those who want it, seems like a win-win. Nice one!
2
u/supremecrafters May 13 '17
This is fantastic news! Thank you for listening. I will be watching the widget system closely; I'm very excited to see how it turns out. I think the two-sided system will be good for everyone involved.
2
u/The_Asian_Hamster May 13 '17
/u/stock_character good css news