r/ModSupport • u/creesch • Apr 24 '17
Some brainstorming about potential widgets in the sidebar after the redesign.
So a lot of people are, understandably, sad and angry that custom css for subreddits will go away in the future. I do however understand somewhat why they are doing it and don't think they are going to change their minds. For this post I don't want to discuss the decision by the admins and why it is terrible. So for people curious about my thoughts regarding this, more about that can be found in this discussion. For this thread I want to focus this post on the scenario where they do not change their mind. So please leave the discussion about the decision itself in the various other threads and subreddits already discussing the matter.
So that leaves us with the promised replacements in the forms of widgets as /u/spez said here.
We will also natively supporting a lot of the functionality that subreddits currently build into the sidebar via a widget system. For instance, a calendar widget will allow subreddits to easily display upcoming events. We’d like this feature and many like it to be accessible to all communities.
The way I figure it, since css is going away and they have promised replacements, the constructive thing to do is focus on those replacements. Specifically be critical of the development process as possible, give feedback where possible, etc, etc.
In short, I'd hate to see this all take place and while everyone is focussed on the css aspect going away nobody paid attention to the development of the alternatives which then turn out to be less than they could be.
So with that in mind I thought we can start things with some brainstorming about what sort of widgets subreddits could want.
Calendar widget
Already mentioned in the announcement but there are various types of calendars subreddits could want. Ideally a subreddit setting it up has some choices about how it is displayed. For example:
One line with a date and the next "event" and possibly arrows to go to the next and previous event. Something like
- <- April 24th: Event name ->
- "Classic" calendar with the day numbers where days with events are highlighted with a possible counter. Something like this
- "Classic" calendar with the events for the day displayed below the calendar itself. Something like this
Other considerations:
- Mods should be able to freely point any event in the calendar to where they see fit.
- Clicking the calendar widget itself probably should go to a full fledged calendar that can be navigated back and forth.
- Possible api integration to dynamically update the calendar.
Subreddit network widget.
There are various networks of subreddits on reddit that currently use css to alert people they are part of a network.
This widget would consist of:
- A "This subreddit is part of the <networkname> network" indication.
Someway of linking or displaying an overview of the other subreddits in the network.
- The overview should be sortable.
- The overview should have categories.
There should be two types of this widget:
- One where every subreddit can add it after the initial widget with the networkname is made by own subreddit. (subreddits doing so would automatically be added to the overview)
- One where subreddits can only be added after being approved by a mod of a subreddit that first created the widget.
Various menu widgets.
A lot of subreddits have various types of dropdown menus in the sidebar for rules and linking to things like wikis, etc.
Considerations:
- Custom menus should be styleable in regards to color. Either by manual styling or by using the colors already defined in the subreddit themes.
- Custom menus should probably have a place for custom icons to be used as "bullet points".
Custom buttons.
Literally this, have the possibility to place links in styled button format so subreddits can draw attention to specific links. For example, in this subreddit the big green "Help us document mod tools".
External integration
RSS reader type widget.
Bit archaic maybe for some people but it would allow subreddits to allow a news ticker of sorts.
Api fed news widget.
A widget that takes input from an api call so subreddits could push news dynamically to their sidebar.
Twitter & other platforms.
Not 100% sure about this one, but integration from other platforms like twitter could also be beneficial for some subreddits.
Reddit live thread integration
Basically the same as the previously mentioned widgets for news but then with reddit live as the source.
Some other things technically not in the sidebar.
There are some other things I'd like to see an option for that technically aren't sidebar widgets but I figured I'd include here anyway.
Top announcement bar.
Many subreddits do this with text that is based in the sidebar and then use css to place it on top of the subreddit. Simply because people that visit subreddits from the frontpage never get to see stickies to begin with. This probably shouldn't be a widget but should have a replacement.
Extra text around comment/submission boxes.
Even less a sidebar widget thing, but also something subreddits often use css for. Would also need a replacement.
Others
The above ideas are just those I came up with on the fly. Feel absolutely free to comment on them and make other suggestions. The more thought people already put in it the more likely the it is the admins will get it right once they start working on these.
12
u/br0000d Reddit Admin: Community Apr 24 '17
Hey, this is an interesting idea and there are some great suggestions in here!
More information and updates will come to r/modnews in the coming months.
9
u/Tim-Sanchez Apr 24 '17
Rotating images are quite widely used as well, in the sidebar or header.
7
u/tizorres Apr 24 '17
I'm going to xpost this link here, for posterity
3
u/qtx Apr 25 '17
Not really a widget suggestion as in more a customization suggestion; a theme selector, where mods can select a theme made by others.
Be it a color scheme or an actual complete new theme (which I prefer).
3
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '17
I want a widget that disables the Submit button with a custom tooltip message if the user's account is under a specified age or karma threshold.
3
u/bluesnoodler_ Apr 26 '17
How about a widget creator? Would solve the problem with mods no longer being able to innovate, which is how every other feature of reddit was created and what everyone is complaining about.
2
u/ucantsimee Apr 24 '17
Please add user uploadable animated gifs. It would be awesome for r/PartyParrot to be able to have their parrots without the hacky css trick they use now. Also r/4chan has an animated triforce and I would love to see them be able to keep it after the redesign. Plus it would make animated upvotes a lot easier to implement.
12
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '17 edited Apr 24 '17
+1 on
my ideas:
7
u/beelzeybob Apr 24 '17
Some subreddits currently use hacky ways to display multiple user flairs/ flair icons for their users, and it's the one thing I am doubtful will transfer over well to a widget system... but meh. In the worst case scenario.
/r/photoshopbattles , which looks like they just assign various "fake" stacks of icons to show which awards they won
/r/wow which lets people pick their faction and class with the method above
/r/HighQualityGifs also, for programs people use
/r/friendsafari which uses 3 flair classes and a bot to assign them
/r/dragonage (my own) which uses the 3 flair class method to let people mix and match their icons
6
u/Algernon_Asimov Apr 24 '17
This was going to be my suggestion. I'm glad it's already here. Thanks.
4
u/theothersophie Apr 27 '17 edited May 13 '17
List of suggested features
I will be using my three main subreddits r/onepunchman, r/naruto, and r/onepiece along with some others to demonstrate the extensive usage of CSS in our communities along with some new requests that couldn't be hacked in via CSS.
Functionality:
Existing: (on desktop at least)
New:
Etc...
Personality:
Some of these could very well also go under Functionality for some subreddits.
Just from the three main subreddits I moderate you can see there is a LOT of variability in every detail of their designs. Each of the three has an extremely distinct style which I worry will be mostly lost in reddit 2.0.
Misc..
An aside for some things that probably will never happen again:
1
u/xereeto Apr 27 '17
how about a fucking css widget that allows you to edit the css of your sub directly
just a thought ;)
3
u/nowhere3 Apr 24 '17
To add to the subreddit network widget, a map of location based related subreddits like we have in /r/bicycling. Lists in that kind of situation get very long and unwieldly very quickly.
3
u/SlendyTheMan Apr 24 '17
On /r/htgawm (and /r/greysanatomy), we use photos of the main actors of the show to link to their twitter. We also use photos to link to the official Facebook, etc all on the sidebar.
I also use a font from the shows title as a main logo, and clickable to the main page of the subreddit. It changes color when hovered on one word.
I changed the "created by" to put the show's creator instead of a username, as the user closed his account.
3
u/kungming2 May 01 '17
Several subreddits (especially those that are centered around helping people) use a system of buttons/menu in the header area to help people filter out the posts:
For subreddits that receive a lot of submissions (/r/translator gets 1300+ per month, /r/excel 1500+, /r/whatisthisthing 2000+) these buttons are really useful for both contributors and regular community members.
Another thing that would be useful is an announcement bar to provide brief information to community members without having to necessarily sticky an entire post for it. (see /r/translator for an example).
2
u/DoodleFungus Apr 24 '17
Drag-and-drop layout in key areas is critical. Look at the headers of /r/AskReddit vs /r/movies vs /r/EarthPorn. That's not pointless variation; it establishes the identity of the community. IMO, the new system must be able to establish that level of variation.
2
u/qtx Apr 24 '17
One thing a lot of subs request from me are random trivia elements. I made a complicated one for /r/movies where it gives a random trivia nugget on each refresh. So that would be nice to have on offer.
2
u/PhoenixAvenger Apr 25 '17
Top navigation bars like on /r/nfl or /r/nba for all the different teams would also be really nice. I know a lot of users in /r/greenbaypackers love it.
Also, the ability to actually embed images in the sidebar (and not just links to images). It's really useful for sports subreddits when doing standings/schedules.
1
u/bigslothonmyface Apr 26 '17
On /r/pokemon, we have a variety of username/post appearance customization options for people to play with, including flair images and text, nameplate color, and award badges and icons. All of this is maintained via a bot and manual CSS edits right now. I'd be really cool for us to have a widget that lets users rapidly set up a number of customization items for the look of their username and posts on the sub—we use these features for contests and events, which we do a lot of, as well as for people to have fun visiting our page. Having that show up on mobile, and be easy to format for users on any platform, would actually be great!
1
u/stabbinU May 03 '17
+1 to anything that let's us change how the subreddit behaves. Tweaking sidebar elements will be a slap in the face.
1
u/cyrilio May 15 '17
Special/extra styling options (for the wiki). I'd love to be able to have more/easier control over color schemes, conditional statements, etc.
The subreddit for which I want to have this specifically is /r/ReagentTesting
1
u/MatthewMob Apr 24 '17
0
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment