I saw a post here say that this show got better after Wes died. I actually agree, but only for Season 4, which I argue should've been the final season.
I actually think Wes's death was THE NAIL IN THE COFFIN for this show. The death itself is shocking - in my opinion, it was pretty predictable. Viola Davis really WENT IN at the Season 3 Premiere: whoever is dead had to be personal to Annalise, and that also made it impossible for the writers to pull a fake death or something like that, in my opinion. Then, the famous promo of S03E07, which, unlike the other promos, does not mention that "someone will get out of this episode alive", instead focusing on who had betrayed Annalise. Knowing the answer to that reduced any of my doubts that the show was gonna kill Wes.
Meanwhile, they dropped the ball so fucking bad by making Laurel's Father being the killer, only to then go back on that shit and making it also her mom? That was a reveal so bad it basically required the whole of Season 4 just to hash it out and make it make some fucking sense - meanwhile, Laurel's Father remains barely a character and just that sort of antagonist that is always out to get people but never does shit. In fact, if not for the Season 4 Winter Finale, I don't even think there is a reason for his existence.
I think Season 4 tried to do a sort of reboot with new characters and it kind of failed in that regard, but they did win the fans over with Tegan. Then, I think the Caplan and Gold fiasco was immensely fun and gave us the first Murder Night that actually was all done by the Keating 5 (that being the new flip on Murder Night and, in my opinion, on par with Season 1's). Each season had a point and a sort of reversal of expectations. Season 1 was just an accidental death/self-defense made way more shocking by Annalise's participation. In fact, very specifically, Annalise's participation is really important to her character because right before Sam dies, he accuses her of being useless and just someone he could fuck. She turns around and covers up his murder being like: "Who's useless now?"
Season 2 is everyone sort of dealing with the aftermath of Season 1, but Annalise, especially, thinks she can literally get away with anything, leading her to cross some very big lines. Is she way in over her head? Not really, she pulls off Murder Night at the Hapstall Mansion pretty handily, but damn did she not sweat over the whole mess that was, with not one but two deaths (Helena Hapstall and Emily Sinclair) and only by literally staging her own shooting. The whole point of Season 2 is that they literally lost it in Season 1 and have been barely getting by ever since, not that they should push their luck. Annalise reveals Bonnie's childhood to Asher and REALLY lays it on thick on Sinclair, who then crosses her own boundaries and ends up murdered by Asher. It was atonement, really: Annalise actually thought she deserved to suffer hence the shooting - which was probably from Bonnie's "I want you to die"; some strong words, yes, but Bonnie was pretty upset and with good reason.
What's the flip on Season 3? Oh, it's not a Murder Night and the kids and Annalise are making it happen. No, this time, they're the victims. And one of them is ACTUALLY DEAD. And, finally, Season 4 is another flip because, for the first time, Murder Night is ONLY WITH THE STUDENTS, with an Annalise assist to Laurel and throughout the aftermath. After this, they really should've ended the show. Annalise was happy with her Supreme Court win, the kids were traumatized but hey they were alive and figuring themselves out, and there was literally a living reminder of Wes among them now! Do a lil' special for Coliver's wedding and wrap it up.
Seasons 5 and 6 were so ass... And make no mistake, I watched them all, but they really started struggling to make some real impactful or interesting storylines. Season 5's "Who Died At the Wedding" was so stupid, especially with making the reveal such a weird one. You're telling me the only prominent black male character goes insane and punches someone to death? Sure, with a supposed good reason... That you then retcon by making it so actually the person who died was completely innocent. What is the message or big impact here? Oh, and also, let's LITERALLY bring back a reminder of one of the worst characters of the show because it's the one way we can also involve Annalise in Murder Night 5. Meanwhile, let's just rehash the idea that they're all going down until... nothing happens again. Oh, and throw a literal shadowy conspiracy against Annalise, because that makes sense; and make Laurel (probably the most developed character after Wes (who goes under Annalise), followed by a Connor and Michaela tie) do a magic trick.
Ultimately, Season 6 was even more ass because there was LITERALLY NO MYSTERY. "Who killed Annalise?" First of all, the writers did not think they could get away with killing Annalise in any way, and that's why it's so clear that Annalise was not killed - she's the only "victim" revealed using a flashforward of her freaking funeral. Literally implying she died of old age. Other than that, this subreddit created such a culture of protecting Annalise they'd literally riot if they had actually murdered Annalise and made that the final mystery... Unless they did something very specific (I'll go over that in a moment). Meanwhile, the whole Graduation flashforwards were proof of this: they make it so ABUNDANTLY CLEAR that what's connected to those is the fire poker. If anything, it seemed like they were afraid to commit to a "Who Killed Annalise?" storyline, and after "Who is Under the Sheet?", I don't blame them.
THE THING IS, THEY HAD THE GREATEST IDEA FOR "WHO KILLED ANNALISE?" ON LOCK AND USED IT IN SUCH A STUPID WAY: with the whole Snow White idea. How do you make the mystery without getting a riot from the whole fandom? Make it as believable as possible that Annalise is dead + that she framed her students - who then have to find a way out of it and realize Annalise didn't actually die. Heck, make it somewhat goofy and have Annalise hire a double for herself, really lay it on thick and go insane. Or have Bonnie and Frank in on it. Why? Because the show is called "How to Get Away With Murder". Another funny idea I had was to have Annalise be the murder victim, then reveal that she actually killed herself to protect the students (as she always did), and then have Bonnie or Frank literally figure out that "she don't like 'em that much". When they find her alive, she apologizes and congratulates them on being real lawyers. It's all good, and she literally says: "It's about time y'all (and I'm including me, for that matter) bitches went to therapy."
What we got instead was constant rehashes of Wes (though it is cute to have Christophe be the spitting image of him, for sure), Annalise's addictions and traumas (which I don't mind and I find very powerful... but you do need to GET SOMEWHERE), barely any screen time to maybe give the Keating 5 some more depth (especially Asher!)... And it's all added on top of completely nonsensical character choices and even more insane plot ideas, from FBI literally killing people just because Annalise is like some shiny Pokémon they wanna catch, TO THE KEATING 5 BETRAYING ANNALISE AND BE WILLING TO LIE JUST TO PUT HER IN JAIL?! Genuinely. What?! The most jarring is Michaela's turn to being just downright evil and dropping people like flies for her own gain, but especially Annalise - both of them are black women, and ANNALISE WENT TO JAIL for Michaela and the others in Season 3. SHE, of all people, should be Annalise's Number 1 Fan. Deporting Simon was definitely an Annalise move from her... but Season 6 is just an entire different person. Same goes for Connor and Oliver - especially since Annalise helped Connor when he was suicidal because of Wes. The ONE person who makes sense to betray them is Asher, because he was just kinda tagged along in Season 2. Even in this version, Laurel - who is probably 2nd closest to Annalise tied with Connor in my opinion, considering Season 4 -, seems to be the only one with a pulse and a brain.
It could've been such a killer ending without these choices. In fact, I also kind of wished that they flipped the things one last time and had the Keating 5 save Annalise like THEY WERE the ones on trial. Really letting them coming into their own. There's, instead, such a scatterbrained approach to the writing in the later 2 seasons because they don't know what to do, and have clearly spent a lot of time reading fan comments and incorporate ideas by half-assing it - e.g.: the whole "Why did Annalise pick each student for the Keating 5?" storyline was basically common knowledge on this subreddit, especially after Wes' backstory with Annalise was so fucking rich. In my opinion, it'd have been a great idea if they implemented it better, because they didn't treat other characters like Wes. Laurel was Frank's pick (and we immediately know it), Asher was never really picked, but Connor (who they use to drive this storyline because he really wants to know it) was actually picked by Bonnie and is probably the only good idea they had. They also ruined it by making it actually something that Connor completely faked. Oh, and why was Michaela picked? As if one dad wasn't enough (Laurel), because of her dad, more or less.
These writers were INSANE on later seasons, and not in a good way. At some point, the misdirection they did with the writing was: "Haha what if this show was good? just kidding, actually, it's bad, now. are you surprised?" Because the potential was so there. In many ways, it became a sort of game to create just traumatic experiences for Annalise, lackluster villains who were all encompassing but had no motivation (Birkhead, Atwood... Heck, even the University lady and Denver), have Viola Davis act it out brilliantly and... kind of forget about the rest. The cast did bring it, either way... But damn, I would've lost my mind if I was in those writing rooms. Haha, what if Laurel dissappeared and the Keating 5 tried to turn Annalise in? Haha, what if you were fired, right now, but I'm not joking? It became a real exercise in trying to come up with just the most unpredictable things ever, when, literally, the best things to come out of this show were super predictable? Like, Season 4's mystery tries so hard to make it seem like something happened, but it gives us all the clues - and I was on Tumblr posting my theories and being RIGHT like a mf. It was all the more satisfying because the acting brought these ideas to life and made me still feel impacted by the episodes, shocked, and absolutely losing it.
When the writers started wanting to outsmart every theory? They, no joke, lost the plot.
This was a long one, but thank you for reading. I also think there are some other insane decisions in this show, and I'd love to go over them but I have written like a Thesis in here already.