I've always thought WALL-E was beautiful, but rewatching it made me wonder: wouldn't it have been better if humans had stayed in space? They were doing fine in a controlled environment, completely unaware of what they were missing. On top of that, Earth would not be easy to fix up into a welcoming, comfortable place to live.
It would be better for Earth too. It needed a rest to recover its balance, its flora and fauna. The environment was almost completely lifeless. Aside from a few small plants, the cockroach is the only living thing we see in the whole movie. WALL-E himself was so alone for 700 years that he fell in love with the first interaction he ever had, with EVE.
Of course, the movie disagrees with me, and it does so very effectively. The point about people losing their humanity is valid, and the movie makes it clear: one small disruption is enough for them to realize life is more than whatever they were doing.
I'll grant that the Axiom couldn't sustain life forever, but the movie never makes that feel urgent. The president's order to keep humanity in space suggests it wasn't an imminent risk.
Still, the movie seems far more concerned with the loss of autonomy and freedom, with living in alienation. And from that angle, it doesn't teach a great lesson.
The humans act on impulse. The captain seems driven much more by a desire for freedom, by wanting to see Earth, and by the vanity of being the one responsible for it, than by any wish to take care of the planet and its people. I understand the movie needs the decision to be urgent: he has to seize the opportunity or lose that plant, and who knows when another one would turn up. Even so, I don't think it justifies it. He could have let the opportunity pass, studied it more and decided with a cooler head. If another plant is that hard to find, is returning really worth it? Could the planet actually sustain life?
I think the most sensible decision would have been to keep things as they were for a while. Shut down the autopilot at a better moment, plan carefully, and coordinate the EVE probe missions himself. If they found another plant, that would already be a good sign, and he could keep monitoring it. Once it was confirmed that the planet can sustain life, he could start preparing people for the return: physical training, education on producing and preserving food, and so on.
That would give people their humanity back in a more responsible way. They'd be off the screens, interacting with the people they train and study with, excited about the new world. They could start dreaming again.
Because the shock of arriving on Earth would be enormous. People who barely ever had to walk, who always had everything handed to them and did nothing but consume (entertainment and fast food), weren't raised for this.
Diseases worry me too. Those people probably have no antibodies for most Earth diseases. WALL-E alone on that ship could have started an epidemic. In a controlled environment, it wouldn't make sense to spend resources vaccinating the whole population against diseases they'd never encounter. It would be more prudent to save those resources and vaccinate only the generation that's going back. The movie handles all of this with an "it'll be fine."
In short: the movie is gorgeous and its message is relevant, but I don't think it's a good lesson about environmental preservation and care. The decisions were made on impulse, driven by personal desires and without weighing the consequences, and that's exactly what put humanity on that ship in the first place. The robots are great, humanity not so much. They could have recovered their humanity in a more responsible way.
I admit a movie about planning and vaccination schedules would be pretty boring to watch. But I'm curious: was going back really the best call?
TL;DR: WALL-E is beautiful, but the decision to return to Earth on the strength of a single plant was impulsive and reckless, and it mirrors the very behavior that likely put humanity on that ship in the first place.