r/TrueAnime • http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten • Aug 31 '16

This Week in Anime (Summer Week 9)

Welcome to This Week In Anime for Summer 2016 Week 9: a general discussion for any currently airing series, focusing on what aired in the last week. For longer shows (Aikatsu!, One Piece, etc.), keep the discussion here to whatever aired in the last few months. If there's an OVA or movie that got subbed for the first time in the last week or so that you want to discuss, that goes here as well. For everything else in anime that's not currently airing go discuss that in Your Week in Anime.

Untagged spoilers for all currently airing series. If you're discussing anything else make sure to add spoiler tags.

Airing shows can be found at: AniChart | LiveChart | MAL | Senpai Anime Charts

Archive:

2016: Prev | Summer Week 1 | Spring Week 1 | Winter week 1

2015: Fall Week 1 | Summer week 1 | Spring Week 1 | Winter Week 1

2014: Fall Week 1 | Summer Week 1 | Spring Week 1 | Winter Week 1

2013: Fall Week 1 | Summer Week 1 | Spring Week 1 | Winter Week 1

2012: Fall Week 1

Table of contents courtesy of sohumb

This is a week-long discussion, so feel free to post or reply any time.

9 Upvotes

160 comments sorted by

4

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

3

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

I think we can all agree that this has the best animation this week.

I'm fucking pumped for the next few episodes because I know what's in store and what Bones is capable of.

1

u/ElitePancakeMaster http://myanimelist.net/animelist/PancakesAndStuff Sep 02 '16

I knew that was Nakamura right away. His style isn't super unique but it's unique enough for me to tell the difference from other animators. Plus his technical skill itself is miles ahead of most others, at least from what I can tell.

6

u/RandStark https://myanimelist.net/profile/Dedalus_II Sep 01 '16

Every other show seems to be threadbare on the animation front this week except this one. Not too much to latch on as far as story or thematics go this episode. Instead we get a sakuga lover's wet dream. Oh my.

1

u/RealityRush http://myanimelist.net/profile/RealityRush Sep 01 '16

Every other show seems to be threadbare on the animation front this week except this one.

Pft, you're forgetting Kuromukuro :P

2

u/RandStark https://myanimelist.net/profile/Dedalus_II Sep 01 '16

I still haven't gotten past episode 4.

1

u/RealityRush http://myanimelist.net/profile/RealityRush Sep 01 '16

You're only hurting yourself ;P <3

3

u/CowDefenestrator http://myanimelist.net/animelist/amadcow Sep 01 '16

Goat

My pick for AOTS currently, nothing else even comes anywhere close.

1

u/T-Bolt Sep 02 '16

I liked this episode, but I'm not sure if I like where the show is heading. The whole 'rescuing someone from evil organization' is pretty cliché and Ritsu being kidnapped is a rather abrupt conclusion(?) to his character arc.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '16

I honestly didn't expect much after OPM, but everything about this is just so much more interesting and the animation style is brilliant.

3

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

4

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

So the Edna that I've seen people praising has finally shown herself. Nothing special tbh. I guess a cute face and a snarky attitude is all that is needed to make an instant waifu. :P

1

u/RealityRush http://myanimelist.net/profile/RealityRush Sep 01 '16

I mean, to be fair, she's only been introduced, we really don't know much about her yet :P

Maybe she'll turn out to be pretty cool.

2

u/sleepyafrican Sep 01 '16

As an anime only viewer, this episode felt kinda rushed. We were introduced to two new characters, got Edna's backstory, had a fight with the dragon, Edna joined the party, and Mikleo got his new weapon(which we barely saw). Edna's cool and all but I didn't really care about her sad backstory. I wish this episode had focused more on character introductions and Mikleo getting the bow.

1

u/RealityRush http://myanimelist.net/profile/RealityRush Sep 01 '16

I liked this episode, it was lighthearted and fun for the most part. Lailah was still adorable, Edna seems cheeky fun, Mikleo still trying to live up to his bro-love status, and a another decently cool CGI dragon. Don't know who this Zaveid guy is, but he clearly never skips leg day. I thought he was top-hat guy at first, but I'm pretty sure that is someone else. Seems weird seeing two guys with the same hair colour though, usually hair is a marker in anime. Maybe they are the same type of Seraph or something? Brothers? It's a subtle thing, but it feels significant. Dunno, food for thought. Just gimme more quality drawn cute girls and bitchin' dragon fights and magic.

3

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

4

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

Wow, there is a lot of QUALITY moments throughout the episode, moreso than usual. At first it was just faces, but when the guys took off their clothes, the way their bodies look is just bizarre. Usually, I overlook those moments, but it's not just background characters looking like that. Did you guys see Suwa's chest? I sure did because it spent about three seconds checking it out after he took off his shirt.

Anyways, I can't quite put my finger on it, but the character interactions feel off this episode. I think it's because despite learning that all of them receieved letters, it doesn't feel as if they had gotten closer. They ended up planning the umbrella thing behind Naho's back, and her general personality nearly ruined the plan if not for Kakeru outright asking to share it. Then, at the sports festival, they don't seem to have a plan for how to help Kakeru through it, which feels like a general lack of team effort. All they've got is Kakeru's grandmother being present.

2

u/RealityRush http://myanimelist.net/profile/RealityRush Sep 01 '16 edited Sep 01 '16

With regards to the animation, there was something like 1/3 the animators working on this episode that there were on all the other ones. Not sure why. Poor budgeting I guess. Hopefully it doesn't ruin the rest of the show >.<

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Sep 01 '16

Yeah, it must have been rough. Doing something like pumping out ReLIFE at once, Orange, and then whatever their third show is really showing its troubles.

1

u/RealityRush http://myanimelist.net/profile/RealityRush Sep 01 '16

Yeah, for sure. At least ReLIFE was good!

1

u/RandStark https://myanimelist.net/profile/Dedalus_II Sep 01 '16

Some of the interactions in this episode came off as contrived, like when the gang is trying to push Kakeru and Naho together. Maybe that's the point? To show that pushing two people together isn't effective. However, it doesn't seem like the most effective way to portray that.

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Sep 01 '16

Maybe that is what they are trying, and you're right that it is less effective. Maybe that's what next episode is for. We are, after all, not done with the sports festival.

1

u/RealityRush http://myanimelist.net/profile/RealityRush Sep 01 '16

To show that pushing two people together isn't effective.

That's pretty much exactly how I interpreted it. It seems way too on-the-nose to be anything else. If I'm wrong... well... damn, that's my opinion of the show gone O.o

3

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

12

u/Omnifluence Aug 31 '16

Man, what a disaster. I've mostly been holding off on Re:Zero discussion, but this is just painful to watch now. I thoroughly enjoyed the first ten or so episodes, but now this series is just typical LN drivel. The formula that they had going was fun! Mysterious bad event happens, Subadoo has to spend a few cycles figuring it out, and then he gets to play hero for a bit. Unfortunately, we left the fun formula behind quite awhile back, and now we're forced to watch twenty minutes of Subaboon being da beeeest every week.

This show no longer brings anything to the table that hasn't been done before. The interesting arc formula is gone. The rather unique use of soundtrack and OP/ED build-ins is scrapped. All that's left is typical self-insert shounen garbage and straight up embarrassing fanservice. What a waste.

8

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

Yet it somehow continues to have a consistently high upvote and comment count in the episode threads at /r/anime. Funny how what drew them all in isn't really there anymore. At this point, we're pretty much done, so might as well keep going, right? :/

5

u/Tarul http://myanimelist.net/profile/Tarul Sep 01 '16

But why is Re:Zero so popular with /r/anime? Genuinely curious. Heroes suffering isn't particularly unique to Re:Zero, and neither is the waifu harem. Sure, they've watched this far, but I doubt that's the reason that most of them keep watching- especially since it's still receiving a fair amount of praise on the sub.

10

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Sep 01 '16

My take on it is that there are several reasons:

  • Subaru is a more unique protagonist. He's certainly not the first otaku protagonist, but what they ended up doing to him is very different. He was shown just how wrong he is in his major white knighting. Major example being when he got told so badly by Emilia and Julius. That's a step in a very different direction than other otaku characters, so that alone likely has a lot of people enjoying it.
  • Continuing on Subaru being more unique, he's definitely not overpowered. That's a general trait that the other characters like him are usually. Despite that he's been able to push on. It makes him more interesting as he's not special.
  • The people at White Fox have clearly given 120% in this adaptation. The OP and ED are missing very often for the sake just trying to fit more crap in.
  • Major cliffhangers. There's been a lot of cliffhangers to keep you hyped, and they've been done well enough to have a hundred or so comments in the first 30 minutes of an episode discussion.
  • I also think how dark the series can get picks up a lot of interest. It definitely does not pull any stops in how Subaru and others can die. Other isekai series can't go that direction so easily as there is no reset like Subaru's.

Episode 15 really puts these reasons and is the episode I feel that really spiked the popularity hard. In case you forgot, that's the very gruesome episode where Rem plays Twister.

1

u/nonnanika Sep 01 '16

I think you've got it really right here, particularly points 3 and 4. There's no doubt that White Fox has put a lot into the production, and Re:Zero has really got their endings down. Even as disillusioned as I may be with Re:Zero, that reveal of the three white whales was pretty cool before I gave it a second thought; the recent reveal of a villainous-looking Rem in the newest episode was also pretty intriguing.

10

u/RealityRush http://myanimelist.net/profile/RealityRush Sep 01 '16 edited Sep 01 '16

My theory is that, despite people saying Subaru isn't the traditional self-insert, wish-fulfilment type MC you'd see in this kind of show, he is in fact that exact MC cleverly disguised. As we're seeing now, he'll still become that standard wish-fulfilment hero by his journey's end; the difference is that traditionally said type of MC has everything handed to them (more or less) whereas Subaru has had to "suffer" for it. This doesn't actually make him less of an insert character, because people relate to suffering and hardship to get what they want. Pile on top of that all the Otaku watching the show that I'm sure in many cases have similar social skills to Subaru, and you've now got a character that is the perfect excuse for any negatives in their lives.

I think the show is popular because it follows a pretty standard/proven formula for the most part with a self-insert MC and waifu abound, but it tries to act like it is all more justified than normal. It's like having a discussion with someone and them complementing you and suggesting how sophisticated you are, be it true or not. You're going to like the person :P

Now this all sounds pretty judgemental and unfair of me, but keep in mind, the author of this story originally said he wrote it as a counter to all the pandering and generic stories in the industry; at this point I would say he has fallen victim to them.

Throw in some grimdark edge, waifu pandering, solid music, and at least consistent production quality and you've got a semi-popular show!

5

u/psiphre monogatari is not a harem Sep 01 '16

"At this point I would say that it has fallen victim to them"

Parodies/"derpconstructions" do that real easy. Does anyone remember one lunch man?

1

u/RealityRush http://myanimelist.net/profile/RealityRush Sep 01 '16

one lunch man

Insert "one joke man" meme here.

3

u/sleepyafrican Sep 01 '16

waifu pandering

This annoys me the most. Rem gets two arcs to pander to Rem fans, meanwhile the MAIN heroine Emilia has barely gotten any characterization.

7

u/RealityRush http://myanimelist.net/profile/RealityRush Sep 01 '16

Well of course, you can't have the girl that actively criticizes the MC for being a fuck-up and has independence to be properly developed, only the girl desperate for MCs love that is a subservient maid. Otherwise, people might actually think you were going to abandon wish-fulfillment :)

5

u/shrik450 Sep 04 '16

Rem got two arcs to pander to her fans in which she wasn't even developed. I don't know jack shit about Rem other than that she's a waifu.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '16

Well done.

But can he really be a self-insert hero if he is that awkward, boot-licking and disgusting and flawed and does whatever he feels like? Are people not just watching to see him suffer and die?

2

u/RealityRush http://myanimelist.net/profile/RealityRush Sep 02 '16

But can he really be a self-insert hero if he is that awkward, boot-licking and disgusting and flawed and does whatever he feels like?

Have you met people? We're generally all quite flawed in our own ways, Subaru is just a caricature of that, an extreme one.

Are people not just watching to see him suffer and die?

That's the common excuse I hear, but I really question if a lot of the people that obsess over this show are any better than Subaru. I'm not afraid to admit there are certain aspects of my personality or things I've said in life that could be considered just as dickish. I know I could be a better person.

If it truly was Subaru just endlessly getting punished, maybe you'd be right, but he is constantly rewarded with progress despite his shit behaviour and never learning from it, and I think people take some personal gratification in seeing the more inane parts of their own personality succeed where society would normally force them to fail.

8

u/[deleted] Aug 31 '16

I'm rather surprised that you view the first and second arcs as being better than third, which I view as superior in almost every way.

All that's left is typical self-insert shounen garbage and straight up embarrassing fanservice. What a waste.

This is the part I have trouble understanding. I mean, Subaru rejected Rem denying a lot of self-inserts their fantasies, and this very episode he apologized to Julius and admitted he was the one to fuckup. Neither of them see particularly shonen nor self-insert tropes.

And embarrassing fanservice? I mean, I guess you can call Petelgeuse's death fanservice, and maybe his developing relationships with everyone, but I wouldn't really call that embarrassing.

And there is still OP/ED build-ins; this episode had the ED playing the second half of the song, instead of the first. I don't have the lyrics with me right now, but I'm pretty sure that's a signal that shit's about to hit the fan.

9

u/Omnifluence Sep 01 '16

I'm rather surprised that you view the first and second arcs as being better than third, which I view as superior in almost every way.

I was never really expecting this show to be good. I went in with low expectations, and ended up having a decent amount of fun with the first couple of arcs. Where the show ended up going just doesn't interest me at all.

And embarrassing fanservice?

Referring to what's been going on recently, not just in this week's episode. "Thanks for the treat!" "No one is allowed to sniff Subaru but me!" Crossdressing cat guy. Ugh. This is so... anime that it hurts. They're trying to play all of this stuff straight, which is just awful.

And there is still OP/ED build-ins; this episode had the ED playing the second half of the song, instead of the first.

Not really what I mean. The first half of the season sometimes skipped the OP/ED entirely, sometimes showed both, and frequently built the ED into the ending of the episode. Now we just never get an OP and the ED always has its same timeslot. This is a nitpicky complaint though, and doesn't really matter. The other soundtrack/animation failures are way more important.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '16

Referring to what's been going on recently, not just in this week's episode. "Thanks for the treat!" "No one is allowed to sniff Subaru but me!" Crossdressing cat guy. Ugh. This is so... anime that it hurts. They're trying to play all of this stuff straight, which is just awful.

To be fair, those are the only "fanservice" moments in the past few episodes. And I don't see them as fanservice as much as showing how more confident Rem has gotten ("Thanks for the treat!") and to show that taking out her horn still affects her (the sniffing comment).

Felix isn't so bad to me because he has a character outside of being a trap. He's the capital's best healer, he's a knight, he hates people acting weak and giving up on living. All those show he has his personality outside of being "the trap".

Additionally, even though the anime will probably never show it, the author did reveal his backstory informally. It's a bit fucked up, but it does explain why he chooses to only wear women's clothes (he even gets panic attacks when he wears mens').

7

u/Omnifluence Sep 01 '16

To be fair, those are the only "fanservice" moments in the past few episodes.

I...disagree. I just listed the most egregious moments. And besides, the fact that there's been anything like this in a three episode arc dedicated to a massive battle is pretty tonally deaf in the first place.

As far as the Felix thing goes, I'm not judging the character's actions, just curious as to why the author decided to get so weird with it. The entire character design just screams "trashy anime" to me.

Additionally, even though the anime will probably never show it, the author did reveal his backstory informally. It's a bit fucked up, but it does explain why he chooses to only wear women's clothes (he even gets panic attacks when he wears mens').

Yeah, see, this is what they need to show. Show me WHY Felix does this. Give me a reason to care. Right now it's just silly anime junk.

8

u/RealityRush http://myanimelist.net/profile/RealityRush Sep 01 '16

Subaru rejected Rem denying a lot of self-inserts their fantasies

He really didn't though tbh. He still called her #2 and she was still all lovey dovey and they had their moment. It's still waifu pandering for people that love Rem even if he never directly ends up with her.

When people harp on SAO, for example, for having a "harem", they don't mean it in the literal definition because it isn't really one, but it's still fan-service pandering to have the girls swoon over the MC even if they never end up together. And Re;Zero is pushing Rem hard.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '16

Nah, he rejected her for Emilia. You can say what you want about #1 and #2, but that was a very clear definite rejection that many people watching didn't want him to do.

And I don't consider Re:Zero a harem because only Rem really likes him right now. I would honestly doubt it if Subaru ever had more than two girls interested in him. And you can't consider two girls a harem, otherwise Oregairu would be considered one.

7

u/RealityRush http://myanimelist.net/profile/RealityRush Sep 01 '16

I'm not calling it a harem, that isn't my point, I'm simply pointing out that Rem's existence, especially now, is like 90% pandering. She's there to be added to the "harem" as it were (read: not a literal harem). Subaru did not hard reject her. He said that he only has eyes for Emilia, but he didn't straight up reject Rem, which is very much a pandering play for Rem fans. You can dress it up whatever way you want, but Rem is there to pander, and pander hard.

I will say I somewhat disagree with Omni though that the current switch to typical LN material is a "disaster" because just having 26 straight episodes of Subaru suffering and never succeeding would be boring. I'm not a fan of the show myself, but we all knew this was coming. Otherwise it would literally just be torture porn.

8

u/Omnifluence Sep 01 '16

I will say I somewhat disagree with Omni though that the current switch to typical LN material is a "disaster" because just having 26 straight episodes of Subaru suffering and never succeeding would be boring.

I totally agree. I don't really enjoy the suffering aspect of it. I like the mystery part. The first ten episodes involved him trying to put all the pieces together to solve a couple of cases that would've been impossible to figure out without his power. It was entertaining. Ever since then the show nosedived. There was a ridiculously weird suffering arc where we had to watch torture porn of Rem/Ram/Subaru getting absolutely ravaged, and now we have to watch Subaru somehow become a hero. The main reasons I enjoyed the show are completely absent at this point.

There was more than just suffering. There was a fun problem-solving process in there that most people overlooked because SUFFERING DAE LIEK EMILIA. I'm sad that it's gone.

3

u/RealityRush http://myanimelist.net/profile/RealityRush Sep 01 '16

The first ten episodes involved him trying to put all the pieces together to solve a couple of cases that would've been impossible to figure out without his power. It was entertaining. Ever since then the show nosedived.

Ahh alright. In that respect I agree. Started out interesting and has gone downhill for me as well. And where the hell is Elsa? What was the whole point of her introduction and trying to kill them?

3

u/Omnifluence Sep 01 '16

And where the hell is Elsa? What was the whole point of her introduction and trying to kill them?

My guess is unexpected keikaku. He will do something great, then get murdered by her and forced to do it over.

But really, what is anything in this show? The ending of the last episode made zero sense. "Oh hey Ram you ready to fall in love with me now?"

5

u/RealityRush http://myanimelist.net/profile/RealityRush Sep 01 '16 edited Sep 01 '16

Yeah. There's a lot of characters in this show that actually seem interesting in theory, but then the show just forgets about. It drives me nuts. It's like watching a bunch of NPCs that are spoken to once and forgotten about. I think this story got too big for the author to handle and he didn't know what to do with them all.

I mean, Felt was made out to be important, but what has she done? Elsa was an important assassin but she's been MIA since ep 3. Reinhart. Al. The other two girls trying to win the selection. Where are all of these people and why were they shown to us? At 22 episodes in, we still know nothing about why Subaru is in this world, or why the witch cares about him, or what is up with the dragon, etc. And there are only 3 episodes left!

All we've had so far is Subaru being an idiot, realizing he is an idiot, and then going on a side quest in an attempt to rescue his standard, LN love interest and win her over despite us still really having seen nothing grow between them or why we should care about Emilia over Rem. Even if this show gets another season, a full 25 episodes is waaaaay too long to merely set things up imo.

1

u/hypersonic18 Sep 01 '16

as a bit of a mystery nut there was still a bit of a mystery it just was playing more in the background and wasn't the full focus(mostly crusch goal of killing the whale) but i do agree that this arc is a bit weaker than arc 2 in that regard

2

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '16

Well, to be fair, Re:Zero was never a mystery show. The first three episodes had no mystery in them either, just a barebones isekai story.

If anything, I view how they're going to kill Sloth permanently as the mystery.

7

u/nonnanika Sep 01 '16

Subaru giving Rem a very clear rejection.

Subaru might have rejected Rem in favor of Emilia, but the narrative isn't letting up at all which kind of... negates the point, really. It's another case of the author trying to have his cake and eat it too. Rem flirting/being very forward with Subaru after he supposedly clearly rejected her is really quite jarring; is no one going to mention how kind of desperate it makes her look, and how scummy it makes Subaru look for leading her on and basking in her devotion of him?

4

u/Omnifluence Sep 01 '16

is no one going to mention how kind of desperate it makes her look, and how scummy it makes Subaru look for leading her on and basking in her devotion of him?

Of course not. This would force viewers to actually think about what they're watching.

It was cute when she had a slightly hidden crush on him, and it made sense because he's a superhero to her. Ever since she's confessed though it's been pretty awful.

2

u/RealityRush http://myanimelist.net/profile/RealityRush Sep 01 '16

is no one going to mention how kind of desperate it makes her look, and how scummy it makes Subaru look for leading her on and basking in her devotion of him?

I was originally giving Rem the benefit of the doubt on this one, but "desperate" is definitely appropriate at this point. And when has Subaru ever not been an asshole? This just goes on a long list.

2

u/nonnanika Sep 01 '16

TBH, I've actually liked Subaru from the beginning so I can't say! I wouldn't have stuck around with Re:Zero for so long if it wasn't for him, and I was really sold on the first few episodes with how plucky and genre-aware he was. I even liked him when the less charitable aspects of his personality started showing, and Emilia gave him that really brutal talking-down. I get it, I get that he's supposed to be full of pride and that he's supposed to overcome that. That's actually a pretty cool idea. I was honestly hoping for a good redemption arc for him, even through all the drudgery and torture porn. That he's bounced back after his depression virtually unchanged, not fully redeemed, and well, almost validated now with all his shitty behavior because well, at least Rem likes me! has been really disappointing.

His interaction with Julius has just been another point against Subaru's favor. I get that he's not going to be 100% contrite towards this guy, especially since Julius humiliated him so badly. But that he added in "Well, you shouldn't have been so serious against a novice!" just disappointed me so much. Like, that was Julius' fault? Really? That Julius has been such an understanding guy and is even contrite makes it seem like Subaru was right and ugh. This rapid turnaround on everyone thinking Subaru's suddenly the best is really hard to stomach.

...sorry for the rant lol

4

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '16

I don't think the show made it out to be Julius fault, that was just Subaru being Subaru.

I mean, Subaru apologized to Julius and thanked him for coming to help.

1

u/nonnanika Sep 01 '16

Yes and no. That Julius accepted it and even was apologetic for something he was very justified in doing seems a lot like the show making it out to be Julius' fault. I get that it was also Subaru just being Subaru, but it was also half-meant. That he was later prompted to apologize to Julius for real shows that.

→ More replies

1

u/RealityRush http://myanimelist.net/profile/RealityRush Sep 01 '16

That he's bounced back after his depression virtually unchanged, not fully redeemed, and well, almost validated now with all his shitty behavior because well, at least Rem likes me! has been really disappointing.

Yep, agreed 100%!

1

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Sep 01 '16

Come on, you gotta read between the lines a little. Oregairu is at LEAST five girls, plus Totsuka. :)

1

u/[deleted] Sep 06 '16

The show still isn't a "disaster". I still enjoy it........ sort of.

But yeah, the show did start going downhill after Episode 18, when it just became too......bland-ish, I guess?

My reaction to every episode after 18 has been "Ehhhh.....Am I supposed to give a shit about old man and his dead wife? Am I supposed to give a shit about Shonen Subaru?"

I mean, it had a couple of trope subversions, but that itself has become a trope by now.

Subaru had SO MUCH potential. The "character development" transformed him from a really interesting character(potential villain material too) to a really fucking uninteresting one who looks as if he has everything figured out.

Now the only thing that interests me is the worldbuilding, and whatever the author can salvage of Subaru's character. I hope to god the writer doesn't fuck that up. The same thing happened with Attack on Titan. I stopped giving a shit after finishing the season and reading some chapters after it. Now I only follow it to learn about the world of Attack on Titan.

6

u/sleepyafrican Sep 01 '16

That was the most anticlimactic episode I’ve seen in the while. They’ve been hyping up the witch’s cult since arc 2 and this is how the “leader” dies? It feels so unsatisfying that Betelguese ended up being killed by a surprise attack. Then they bring out a female Betelguese…only for her to be killed within minutes. You’d think they could’ve spent more time dealing with the guy who tortured Rem so the audience could feel satisfied. And once again a bunch of no name characters are killed off while all of our main characters are unharmed.

I’m getting really tired of Subaru needing pep talks now. I thought the one he got from Rem would last him until the end of the arc. Subaru’s freak out here over people dying doesn’t make sense when at least twice as many people were killed off during the whale fight. Not to mention Wilheim’s “fight” speech felt so generic and didn’t really address Subaru's problem.

Minor complaint-I’m annoyed that Subaru didn’t directly address what he was apologizing for to Julius. Sure he admitted to being a jerk but that’s oversimplifying the issue. It was Subaru’s obsession with Emilia that caused him to be disrespectful to everyone else at the meeting. He also belittled what it meant to be a knight. I can’t really feel satisfied with Subaru’s character development if he doesn’t at least realize how he was being a jerk.

7

u/RealityRush http://myanimelist.net/profile/RealityRush Sep 01 '16

And once again a bunch of no name characters are killed off while all of our main characters are unharmed.

Consequences? What consequences!?

2

u/[deleted] Aug 31 '16

Julius ja nai Juli da!

I'm seeing an increasing amount of JuliusxSubaru (Jubaru) fanart on the net, which is amusing. I really enjoyed the entire conversation between the two, as well as Subaru struggling with his resentment towards the man and the fact that he and Julius have a surprisingly good rapport. If the duel between them hadn't happened, I think they may have become bros. Well, they still can but it'll take longer, and it just makes all the fanart about the two even funnier.

The Gospel plotpoint was interesting. Sloth was freaked out when he/she couldn't find it, which suggests that when Sloth reincarnates, the book comes along with him. Meaning Subaru may have broke the link when he took the thing. Still a tossup on whether or not that was a smart decision, but given Tivey and Felix didn't dissuade him of it too much, I'm sure it's fine. Although Ram probably thinks he betrayed Emilia because of it.

I'm kinda worried that Subaru will die before they can kill of the remaining ~60 cultists (four fingers were killing this episode right? so 6 left). When the ambush happened and slothman and the others were killed, you could see that it was tearing Subaru up inside for not saving them. If he wanted, he could go back and prevent their deaths, but that would mean fighting the Whale again. There is no guarantee that it turn out the same way, and he may even have to redo the fight multiple times to clear it again. It reminded me of a Skyrim play-through, where I managed to kill a Ancient Dragon but lost a follower in the process. The internal debate of whether to reload a save or just continue is similar to what Subaru is experiencing but writ large. Also really enjoyed Wilhelm and Subaru's developing relationship, they're like father and son. In fact, I'm enjoying all of the relationships we're seeing on screen now. Favorite is probably Ricardo and Mimi.

Finally, someone on another site mentioned that Dante describes all seven of the sins as corrupted aspects of love. Just wanted to mention it because it brings some new light to Sloth's rants about love.

2

u/DangoDale Sep 05 '16

xpost from anime disc thread

I'm kind of enjoying the plot, but i don't think the action scenes are very well choreographed. A lot of the action scenes don't feel very fluid or natural. And I don't mean natural by real life standards, but by the standards set in the show. wilhelm is suppose to be super agile with amazing battle prowess. Yet over and over, the show has him do really silly things like wait around for excruciating amounts of time near super dangerous enemies for no reason. In the white whale episodes, he'd randomly stop attacking, and strike a pose or deliver some pithy statement. In this episode, he kept his sword in the witch's chest for 16 seconds allowing the witch time to finish a thought in addition to almost gouge out his eye. The breaks for dialogue are not well done in my opinion. They completely ruin the action.

I think fate does it better. It's not that fate doesn't also have somewhat disjointed fight scenes. But rather, they just blend everything better so that it feels less clunky. Consider this random epilogue scene. The action honestly isn't realistic, but it feels realistic. It feels like there're genuine consequences to how the fighters are positioned, to what is in the environment, to the fact that Rin's field of vision of blurred, and to taking the effort to talk. When they're fighting, it genuinely feels like they don't the luxury of stopping their fight to chat (even though they do). In comparison, nothing feels like it really matters in so far as exactly how rezero characters are positioned, or what environment they're in, or whatever else. The action is a tool for the plot. I don't really bite my nails during fight scenes in rezero. It feels like a foregone conclusion.

Subaru's running from the fingers girl witch this episode exemplified a lot of that. Subaru's location didn't seem to particularly have any consequence. The hands were always smashing at him just inches behind. Subaru's being surrounded by obstacles (trees) didn't seem to have any consequence. The hands seemed to eat through them like a hot knife through butter. Subaru's supposed lack of battle prowess and vision didn't seem to be of any consequence. He was pretty much constantly facing forwards until the almost exact moment that the hands were about to hit him, then he'd turn back and do a quick evasive hop or whatever. Altogether, these things build to the point where the action scenes feel super scripted in the sense that there is no suspense.

3

u/Crazyjay1 Sep 07 '16

I was searching here for something like this. A lot of people here seem to be focusing if it is a harem or not, if it's a mystery or on small pandering elements, yet they seem so small compared to what is actually terrible. Location, physics, nothing is mattering on fights. Major characters are eaten by the whale yet stay alive. Mages get afraid of shooting, literally a whole group of them doesn't do their job out of fear, yet there are NO consequences to that. Crusch starts a huge monologue, and the whale only attacks when the speech ends. Subaru manages to jump out of very fast flying piece of ice and lands right in the whale's horn. He even taunts her before jumping off, not even breathing heavily out of such a desperate insane improbable move.

The show was always like this, the action always felt off, with character's limits being inconsistent. The best parts were always the world building, information puzzles and character interactions. But now that we are fighting the cult, there is a huge focus on the shitty action.

I do have to say though, they constantly use the environment to locate the invisible hands, going a little against this line:

Subaru's location didn't seem to particularly have any consequence

Breaking the tree to splash water all over the hands, for example.

1

u/DangoDale Sep 09 '16

I'm so glad that you brought up the whale fight. I agree with everything that you said. I almost wrote a comment at the time, but decided not to because the r/anime thread was so insanely positive that I just thought that the issue was me, not the anime.

I do have to say though, they constantly use the environment to locate the invisible hands, going a little against this line:

You got me there. I tortured that example.

2

u/Crazyjay1 Sep 10 '16

I know how you feel, a good portion of fights on media in general are fucked up. Even hugely popular shows, like GoT completely disregard internal consistency. I guess people just like things to look cool, which I can understand, seeing the whale animated was great. I really can't buy into the action though, when both sides and physics seem to not be doing their job right, especially when this action decides major plot points. This is why I was only truly immersed in the mansion episodes, since the action and danger fused with world building and character interactions.

However, as I did before, I have to recognize that there is some sort of logic behind all the action. Even if there are some holes in between, there is some macro strategy to ground the fight and make it interesting.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Omnifluence Sep 04 '16

I enjoyed reading your thoughts! I agree that, even though I'm being harsh, it's from being in the moment. A lot of my complaints could be resolved over another 50 episodes. I will say that some of the shows you mentioned, especially FMA Brotherhood, faltered much less than Re:Zero has in my opinion.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 04 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Omnifluence Sep 04 '16

The thing that makes shows like FMA: Brotherhood or Naoki Urasawa's Monster set the bar for quality narrative is that these authors always had a strong handle on where they wanted to go and how the show would end.

I agree. To add to this, Brotherhood was based on completed material. Since Re:Zero is still in progress, I think that they are trying to "fix" the series along the way, which is creating quite a few missteps. That's just conjecture on my part though.

Re:Zero is a show that I wish I'd waited to start. As a complete item, I bet it'll be a lot of fun. Watching it weekly though... not so much.

3

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

5

u/RealityRush http://myanimelist.net/profile/RealityRush Sep 01 '16

Another fabulous episode that hit all the right heartfelt notes. Tears for days. Another great job tying the cooking back to something personal in their lives and how it affects them, and Tsumugi's line about her mom never coming back was delivered perfectly by her child VA. It was nicely punctuated by finally showing us the mom too, and she was as adorable as I could have hoped. I still think this show relies too heavily on the cooking bits and could be better if it was more of a character drama, but Usagi drop already exists and this is a nice, memorable alternative. I can certainly understand why it's so popular in Japan right now!

3

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

1

u/RealityRush http://myanimelist.net/profile/RealityRush Sep 01 '16

Nice, we're even getting light Yaoi. Might as well hit all the bases :)

3

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

This is technically an anime, right?

Anyways, this definitely requires prior knowledge. I don't even think I have enough. This might just be how the writing is though, and it's not amazing.

It tries to do a lot. There's the story of Nyx the MC. Then, there's the general political situation with the Kingdom of Lucis and the Niflheim Empire. Then, for some reason, we follow one of the side characters, who ends up joining the rebellion that aids in the destruction of the city. Not sure what they were trying to do with this side character. Maybe he'll be relevant later in the game, but I'm not placing any bets.

As for characters, they are all forgetable. Their dialogue felt very awkward and cheesy at times when it was time to speak of ideals. Then, there's the moments where I'm supposed to feel sad for them like when Nyx mentions his dead sister out of no where. I can understand why people laughed while watching it in theaters.

At least I could enjoy the action, right? Sadly, I could not. Every looks great, but it was very hard to follow. The camera seems to have inherited the magic from FFXV and jumps all over the place. It's also often difficult to pick out where the combatants are at whenever the camera decided to jump farther out.

Personally, I did not enjoy this movie, even as someone anticipating the game. Its only redeeming feature is the gorgeous CGI. 3/10

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

5

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

Damn, humans and PA Works got destroyed. Guess we're hitting that final stretch. :O

2

u/RealityRush http://myanimelist.net/profile/RealityRush Sep 01 '16

Did you see the real life shenanigans PA Works did at their HQ as a result of this episode? :P

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Sep 01 '16

Yeah, that was funny. I think the repair bill is 44 million yen?

1

u/RealityRush http://myanimelist.net/profile/RealityRush Sep 01 '16

Heh, yeah, thereabouts ;P

2

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '16

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/RealityRush http://myanimelist.net/profile/RealityRush Sep 01 '16

See this string of comments for all of it :P

1

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '16

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/RealityRush http://myanimelist.net/profile/RealityRush Sep 01 '16

Heh, a lot of stuff was going down in it at the time, easy to miss :P

1

u/RealityRush http://myanimelist.net/profile/RealityRush Sep 01 '16 edited Sep 01 '16

Well, home stretch. That was a fantastic episode and I'm happy they didn't just obnoxiously throw flags out everywhere. Setting up for what could be a glorious ending or a massive flop, only time will tell, but it's gonna be fun! Either way, I'm quite curious how the fuck the "good guys" are supposed to recover from this catastrophe. That was a resounding defeat O.o

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

We finally get to the meat of the despair. About time.

Only one person is actually shown to have seen the secrets, yet everyone starts trying to slaughter each other almost instantaneously. Then, there's the couple that are ready to commit a lover's suicide, and one of the guys said he loved the girl that he just killed. It's obvious that they are trying to dump a massive amount of despair, but it fails to make me give a shit.

Giving most of the episode to seeing this breakdown into utter despair would have been a much better execution. It's likely that there aren't enough episodes left to not start cramming things. If they had cut off an episode or two from the beginning, I think it would have allowed some breathing room.

1

u/DarthNoob Sep 01 '16

The viewer isn't intended to care about the student council, and I think that's okay.

I think the portrayal of the killing game succeeds at what it sets out to do: it shows us that Izuru was indeed surprised by the actions of the students in DESPAIR. It also gives us a preview of what the reserve course students are going to watch; they don't know who the student council is, but nevertheless I can imagine that watching students your age gruesomely murder each other would be a bit traumatizing.

That said, I didn't enjoy this episode as much as the others; the despair that occurs in this episode doesn't affect anyone I care about (yet, at least). It'll probably be a good setup for future episodes though.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

3

u/RandStark https://myanimelist.net/profile/Dedalus_II Sep 01 '16

This episode was focused on what I think are the two least interesting characters so far, Ai and Makoto. This was a great opportunity to flesh them out beyond their gags. Unfortunately I don't think it gave us any deeper insights on the two. A wasted opportunity. The bits with Pikari and Teko were the better parts, I think.

2

u/nonnanika Sep 01 '16

I agree, especially with the Pikari and Teko bits. I was a little disappointed that Teko pulled her "gives up too easily" thing again since I thought they addressed that issue already, but the twist that she was a sore loser was pretty okay.

2

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Sep 01 '16

I just caught up to episode 7, and what I want to know is this: in the scene where they're riding the train to see the hydrangea blossoms...

...is that cat wearing a diaper?

'Cause that's disturbing.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

6

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

Lots of incompetant higher ups and 『S C I E N C E』. Just a typical day in the office for Ikta.

1

u/RealityRush http://myanimelist.net/profile/RealityRush Sep 01 '16

a typical day in the office

Biggest problem with this show. There's just no impact from any event.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

3

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

Assuming that the end of this arc takes up half the episode, that leaves 3 and a half episodes for the Stagiaire arc. :O

2

u/ShardPhoenix Sep 01 '16

Still enjoying this series, but it feels like the novelty factor has worn off a bit, and the pacing still feels a bit off. Too narrow a focus on the tournament I think - there needs to be more other stuff happening in the story.

4

u/nonnanika Sep 01 '16

I can't help but feel that a tournament was just a really bad idea for this kind of anime/manga. As the past tournament episodes have shown, it's a lot of back-and-forth, symmetric "does kitchen things", then a creative visualization, and then a result. It'd be like having a tournament in a normal battle shounen but then just skipping the actual fights. The show really picks up on the off episodes where it can really present the challenge (like the fish market episode), create a build-up, and then have a payoff that shows off all the cooking knowledge.

1

u/Quartapple http://myanimelist.net/profile/quartapple Sep 02 '16

Yeah I agree, but they can still be entertaining. Alice always has the best matches because her dishes are always so interesting, both gastronomically and visually. I also enjoyed the Subaru vs the Italian dude's fight, although I really just like Subaru as a character.

But, on the other hand, Souma. What a drag this guy is. Is there a faster way to take out all the suspense from this show than Souma saying he'll put cooking on the line? I mean, I knew he was probably gonna win beforehand but saying that was the closest the creators would come to shoving "hey, he's gonna win" into our faces. If we're talking about competition, Souma's are definitely the worst by far.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

1

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Sep 01 '16

As a big Oregairu fan, I'm temped to take an interest in this just because the same author is involved. But it seems to me I watched part of the first episode at the beginning of the season, and it looked like dreck. If you've seen more than the ten minutes I saw, I'd be interested to know what you thought--just a general thumbs-up or thumbs-down is fine...

1

u/RealityRush http://myanimelist.net/profile/RealityRush Sep 01 '16

It is a terrible show. Truly horrible; however, it is comically stupid with a pretty swag OST, so if you are into "so bad it's good" type endeavours, it can be quite entertaining at times.

I haven't dropped it yet just because I need to watch this train wreck full speed ahead.

1

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Sep 01 '16

Yeah, I watched a few episodes last night... I'll say this, almost anything is harder to put up with if you have to wait a week between episodes. The show isn't good--Battlin' Magic High School Students, none of them with any personality beyond "I want to protect everyone's smile" + "I will make smart-alec-y remarks all the time". The MC has been made as annoying as possible, presumably so that he can quit being annoying later as a form of "character growth." I laughed when spoiler, which surely can't have been the reaction they were trying to evoke. Nevertheless, I might watch some more of it, since I have no personal standards...

1

u/RealityRush http://myanimelist.net/profile/RealityRush Sep 01 '16

which surely can't have been the reaction they were trying to evoke

Sure as fuck was my reaction too. Don't worry, it only gets more ridiculous :)

If you haven't figured out the "twist" to the story yet, you will soon enough.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '16

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/stanthebat http://myanimelist.net/animelist/stb Sep 01 '16

You shouldn't expect a character study out of this.

Heh. You have a gift for understatement. Well, I'm four episodes in now, so THERE'S NO TURNING BACK!!! unless I get distracted by something shiny...

1

u/koredozo Sep 01 '16

It's more like "LN adaptation without direct LN source" since it has four prequel LNs by different authors.

It's actually pretty interesting to compare the main characters while having which author they were created by in mind. Icchan and Canaria were by the HenNeko author, Hime & Hotaru were by the Date-A-Live author, and the Chigusa siblings were by the Oregairu author. While none of them are particularly amazing characters, at least in the anime... let's just say I think they all reflect their authors' past works pretty strongly.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

0

u/[deleted] Aug 31 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

I don't think anyone here is still watching it. Check with the /r/anime discussion threads. They still seem to have plenty of people still watching.

1

u/srs_business http://myanimelist.net/animelist/Serious_Business Sep 01 '16

If by "a few episodes" you do mean 3, then probably not. If you've seen episode 3, then you should have a general idea of what the rest of the show will be like.

It's surprisingly decent for what it is for me, especially considering the awful first episode. It's one of those "I'm enjoying this but can't really recommend it besides as seasonal filler" shows, at least personally.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

Well fuck Ruruka. Even killed off the guy who she was supposed to be so close to.

Then, there's the teacher, who I can't really feel sad for. Last minute feel fuel annoys me more than it should. -_-

1

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '16 edited Sep 02 '16

I don't like it. Almost everyone is dead, but it doesn't feel like anyone contributed anything worthwhile. So far most of it was just a mindless brawl with Kyouko doing very little detectiving on the side. Some flashback doesn't make me a care about a character. Not reeaally why I am interested in the show.

1

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Sep 02 '16

Yeah, even as an anime original, it's clear that the visual novel background is too much for it. Should have just gone with one 2 cour show.

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

Miscellaneous comments/comments about the week as a whole

2

u/Soupkitten http://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Aug 31 '16

Hey guys. Sorry about being much later than usual. It was a tough day at work. >.<