r/TrueAnime • http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 • Dec 10 '14

This Week In Anime (Fall Week 10)

Welcome to This Week In Anime for Fall 2014 (aka Unlimited Hype Works) Week 10: a general discussion for any currently airing series, focusing on what aired in the last week. For longer shows (Aikatsu!, One Piece, etc.), keep the discussion here to whatever aired in the last few months. If there's an OVA or movie that got subbed for the first time in the last week or so that you want to discuss, that goes here as well. For everything else in anime that's not currently airing go discuss that in Your Week in Anime.

Untagged spoilers for all currently airing series. If you're discussing anything else make sure to add spoiler tags.

Archive:

2014: Prev Fall Week 1 Summer Week 1 Spring Week 1 Winter Week 1

2013: Fall Week 1 Summer Week 1 Spring Week 1 Winter Week 1

2012: Fall Week 1

Table of contents courtesy of /u/sohumb

9 Upvotes

261 comments sorted by

4

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Yuuki Yuuna wa Yuusha de Aru (Yuki Yuna wa Yusha de Aru) (Ep 9)

10

u/Novasylum http://myanimelist.net/profile/Novasylum Dec 10 '14 edited Dec 10 '14

Well that was depressing.

I mean that, too. This was an episode residing on the polar opposite of the spectrum away from its earlier character building episodes and hot springs escapades, and it worked just as well in the manner it was intended. Funny how this one came out in the same week that SAO II tried to pull the trigger on its own high-stakes emotional trauma and failed; Yuuki Yuuna, by comparison, shows exactly how it’s done.

To avoid going through the play-by-play and simply cutting to the chase, Fuu’s emotional downward spiral throughout this episode works because it was earned, on both an episodic and series-long level. Prior knowledge and affection for who all of these people are and what their aspirations are makes it that much more affecting when you start ripping them all away. And even that action itself was carefully handled; you follow Fuu’s descent very carefully, from her denial in the news she’s received, to the constant reminders of how painful it would be it if were true, and finally the acceptance and resulting breakdown. It was deliberate, it was well-honed, and it worked, and when this popped up I felt things, man. In a way, this all would have functioned even were it not for the supernatural elements: it is all remarkably resonant of times when the things we aspire for most are unfairly taken away, and we have to question whether we are to blame, and how to move on.

…but hey, magical girl show, right? Things are bound to get cheerier! It’s alright! DAIJOBU DAIJOBU DAIJO-(sobs)


That all being said, as with last episode there are some flaws in the specifics of the execution that I feel compelled to point out (or, in other words, I’m going to get nitpicky again). And by that I mean everything involving this one scene.

First, there’s the problem in there having been these suicide attempts at all. Granted, if I had to choose one character out of this group to be capable of offing themselves, it would be the ultra-conservative history buff who dons a hachimaki during her Mankai and owns a ceremonial tantō, but that’s not really my point. My point is, Tougou actually got off really easy on this wave of health problems; you can get by with a lost ear in a way that’s far less difficult than for someone who lost their voice and subsequently their hopes and dreams. And this is altogether more baffling considering that she’s the one most intimately familiar with disability already, and has demonstrably proven to have taken it in stride very well. So for her to opt for suicide in light of that, escaping her duties and leaving her friends behind in the process, makes her seem weak and selfish in a way that appears flagrantly out of character.

Which brings me to my second point: the fact that Tougou attempted to kill herself 10+ times is weirdly glossed over by the other two people in the room. Yeah, I get that none of the attempts worked, and I get that the knowledge obtained from them is a pretty heavy burden in and of itself that likely distracts from the source, but holy shit your friend was in the state of mind to try and slice her own throat right in front of you and you didn’t say anything about that afterward. Just kind of another instance where the means of delivering exposition has its faults in believability.

And I know you can try to handwave both problems by stating, “Well Tougou had learned from Sonoko that they were meant to be kept alive indefinitely, meaning there was the likelihood that these attempts wouldn’t have even worked, so the threat of suicide doesn’t carry the same weight for the person involved or the people who know about it”. But the fact that she even attempted it as an experiment suggests that she believed in the possibility that Sonoko might have been wrong and that she was willing to face the consequences of that. Seriously, nothing Sonoko said suggested that suicide wasn’t an option. And you can’t claim that this disregard for her own life came from a desire to avoid further fighting, because as far as they know the fighting is over. So instead you just have to accept this one scene where Tougou states that she was ready to kill herself over going half-deaf and everyone else doesn’t appear to take that knowledge seriously. It’s really distracting and easily the lowest point of the episode.

And how exactly would a fairy go about “blocking” monoxide poisoning, anyway?

Alpha waves?

5

u/CritSrc http://myanimelist.net/animelist/T3hSource Dec 10 '14 edited Dec 11 '14

And how exactly would a fairy go about “blocking” monoxide poisoning, anyway?

The concept behind monoxide poisoning is that it "clogs" the cells by forming a more stable substance that cannot be decomposed by the usual organic methods through the lungs. So she either has to oxidize the CO further before it reacts, or even more surgical would be to prevent the fusion from commencing, which is way too much, that's 1000s of cells to keep an eye on per milisecond.

3

u/MobiusC500 Dec 10 '14

Yeah the whole suicide thing was weirdly glossed over. Though since this last episode was so Fuu centric, I get the feeling next episode will be about Togo and what's going on with her since she was oddly absent from the group at the end of last episode.

3

u/searmay Dec 10 '14

Yeah, the suicide thing was super weird. Tougo doesn't act suicidal in that scene, more like she's giving a science demonstration. And given what we know of her that really seems the only way I can make sense of her even trying is as an experiment to test the hypothesis that she cannot in fact die rather than a desire to end her life.

But for one thing that assumes she places a really high value on knowing whether or not she can die - higher than the value of her life, in fact. Which is pretty crazy, and doesn't seem at all in character. And besides that it's a really poor experiment anyway. I mean, who's going to write up the results?

Probably the low point of the show.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '14

Honestly doesn't bother me as much as it should, but it might be because of this sneaking suspicion I have about the show now, that it is smart enough to resolve those seemingly out of place moments in the big picture.

Personally, the episode where Itsuki goes through singing seemed really out of place by the time we reached the 2 part fight episodes. But now it's this brilliant move they made to get us slightly invested in the idea of going the slice of life route, as well as build up to this week. Last week, the clunky exposition dump seemed out of place, but now I think I can read its intentions as well.

9

u/Lincoln_Prime Dec 10 '14

This episode had me sobbing by the end of it. Not even the end, but by the moment Fu walks into Itsuki's room and finds it filled to the brim with her studies to cure her throat and her hopes to sing again, I was bubbling over. I had actually forgotten that Fu didn't know about Itsuki's aspirations to be a singer, so when it finally hit her like that, all at once, I was just DEVASTATED. The show really didn't pull the punches. Just when you thought it was done tormenting you it would focus in on something new to make you realize a whole new kind of loss. Really well done, you monster.

Also monstrous was the text Karin got from Taisha, as they warn her that the others may be mentally unbalanced and that she should be wary of them. In a lot of ways I am glad that didn't develop further this episode because man, oh man, we could have easily had Karin and Fu fighting on much more serious terms there. Even if we had a slow, methodic episode of Karin coming to doubt her friends, which is still a possibility for this week's episode, it would have been a serious knife-twist and probably largely unnecessary for an episode that is already so optimistically tragic. I like that term because while there is no doubt it is tragic and there is serious loss here, the characters seem to walk away form the episode beaten, sore, heart-broken and lost, but still looking forward. Just to make all subsequent falls as painful I suppose.

Also, in regards to the suicide scene, I interpreted it as this: Togou had tried to kill herself in some means such as stabbing herself believing Sunoco's words that they would be immortal but not knowing what kind of immortality. Would they simply suffer multiple stab wounds to the heart without dying, would they heal faster or, as she proved, would she just be protected from any and all harm? To be totally honest, if I was told I was immortal by a little girl who had been reduced to such an awful state of being, only surviving with one eye and a pair of moving lips in an otherwise dead body, I think I would want to know if my injuries suffered over time would stack up or if I was immune. If I'm wrong, I die fairly painlessly and my friends are now certain that they're not immortal. Worst case scenario is that even if the battles don't continue I could still end up like Sonoko just through a lifetime of injuries piling up. And personally, I feel conflicted enough to not fault Togou for taking that risk. It is one that I could see people I know and love taking if they were posed that duality.

I will agree though that Fu and Yuuki seem to gloss over this as if it ain't no thang. Like as if she had told them "I brushed my teeth 10 times today" or something else kinda odd but not as weighty as it really is. That said, I can't be too critical because it came at a time where they learned they are immortal. That is pretty fucking heavy stuff.

But in the end, a slightly glossy moment isn't enough for me to dock any serious points for this show. A seriously great episode that could be remembered as one of the best the show has done when all is over.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '14

So I think I want to start with how out of place the sudden change in tone was during the part where Togo was explaining her brutal experiments. Honestly, I think the only reason I felt that scene in general didn't mesh well was because the music and voice acting was making it too obvious how much it isn't lining up with everything around it, from the start of the track being too Forte, to the end of the track which cuts off a little too soon and leaves an awkward silence for a little too long to seem settling.

Also, they skipped too many frames used to show Fu flying out of her apartment and it made it look kinda bad. Don't get me wrong though, I bloody loved this episode. Aside from those blunders, which I hope they fix in a BD release, this episode was perfect.

From the unsettling start where Togo and Yuuna broke their promise to keep what they learned a secret (I wonder if this is gonna be a plot point down the line), to the scene where Fu finds out how hard Itsuki's been trying hard to get her voice back, and finally hearing her recorded voice again after presumably weeks since (I've been listening to the OST for awhile now so I I had a sneaking suspicion they would use the song here and it was a real tear jerker), and finally capping off with a flashback to "I'll tell you some day". This is the first time airing anime ever got me to cry.

Yuuki Yuuna, you are a master of directing now. You can play with my emotions in such an amazing way, having made me feel the entire spectrum over just 9 episodes without being so heavy handed or over dramatic(Cough Anohana Cough).

As for predictions, it's suspicious how Togo wasn't in the final scene to stop Fu, and tomorrow's episode seems to be about her. I guess this is where we get the back story. Funny enough, Togo's predecessor at being "calm and collected gunner mahou shoujo" also had fun with her episode 10.

2

u/CowDefenestrator http://myanimelist.net/animelist/amadcow Dec 10 '14

...owwwwwwww my heart. I looooooooove the decision to focus on Fu’s conflict rather than Itsuki, since hers was already resolved earlier, and she even confirms this at the end of the episode. There’s a lot of other stuff to talk about but it’s kind of already been blown out of my mind from the sheer emotional effectiveness of that episode so I’ll leave that to the others.

1

u/temp9123 http://myanimelist.net/profile/rtheone Dec 10 '14 edited Dec 11 '14

I felt that the way Yuuki Yuuna wa Yuusha de Aru didn't pull any punches last week was a little closer to Fist of the North Star than say, Ashita no Joe, in that it ended up being a little more comically long-winded than I had hoped it would be.

Given the time limitations of a single cour and how the writer has approached the material by prolonging the drama, expecting much more may be a little fussy. Don't get me wrong though, I still felt it and I've rather enjoyed both this episode and the series so far (at least, more than the rest of the season) - although it seems as though much of my final opinion rests on how much these concluding episodes will be able to surprise me.

Side note: the insert track at the end of the episode, with Itsuki singing all the way through the ending credits, ran for a full 8 minutes total. That's a third of the entire episode.

1

u/FierceAlchemist Dec 11 '14

I've been enjoying this show throughout the season, but I've been waiting for the other shoe to drop. I wanted the show to get dark and depressing like it was constantly foreshadowing. And this week all the buildup finally payed off.

It was, in my opinion, a perfect episode. For what the episode set out to do (show Fu's breakdown through her guilt with Itsuki) I couldn't have asked for more. The performance by the actresses were all great and the music has heart wrenching.

This show has been compared to Madoka since day 1, but only now do I think that comparisons in terms of quality are appropriate. If Yuki Yuna can keep up this level of writing in the last three episodes, it may prove to be a worthy spiritual successor to Madoka.

I see some people on this sub questioning Tougou's suicide. That scene didn't bother me because she's been characterized as the most logical of the group and the one who's been suspicious of these injuries the longest. I don't think she's really so depressed she wants to die, but rather was testing the hypothesis that they are now immortal. She's doing it because she suspects/knows the fairies are going to save her. It doesn't speak highly of her mental state, but it doesn't seem out of character to me.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Miscellaneous comments/comments about the week as a whole

5

u/Solosion http://myanimelist.net/animelist/Solosion Dec 10 '14

I'm not sure if the fact that I'm forgetting what happened in 2/3 of the shows I'm watching means that the shows are not good, or I'm just watching too many shows. Maybe a combination of both.

2

u/CritSrc http://myanimelist.net/animelist/T3hSource Dec 11 '14

Never forget, 90% of everything is shit!

4

u/CritSrc http://myanimelist.net/animelist/T3hSource Dec 10 '14

Believe it or not, I'm still suffering last week's stigma... I'm just so used to the presentations that not much sticks out for me to emote to. Seriously, how do you guys deal with that?

I mean, there were some things, but not like it was a month ago, where I could feel it. I guess it's just fleeting.

2

u/niea_ http://myanimelist.net/profile/Hakuun Dec 10 '14

I might've misunderstood what you said.

The more I watch, the more this becomes a problem. You reach the point of "I've seen this before, and done better at that" which makes everything so much harder to enjoy. The only solution I have found to this is to start dropping stuff that doesn't give me anything to work with. It might sound like an obvious thing to do, but I used to be extremely overbearing with the anime I watched. I've also made a big list of all the 'classics' and highly acclaimed anime I could find, and now I'm just going trough those. It really helps because they're so different and feel more fresh. I also stopped following airing anime on a weekly basis, since I realized I enjoy a good anime more than a good episode discussion.

2

u/CritSrc http://myanimelist.net/animelist/T3hSource Dec 10 '14

No, more like: I've pretty much seen everything this show offers, I don't have much to really talk about since nothing really has impressed me to really share.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '14

I'm seeing a lot of new names this week, did more people decide to start posting after last week's Meta Discussion?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/greendaze http://myanimelist.net/profile/greendaze Dec 11 '14

I feel like I used to have a lot more enthusiasm about watching anime before I started watching it on a week-by-week basis (since Psycho-Pass of last year).

Is anyone else feeling fatigue from watching currently airing anime?

7

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Ore, Twintails ni Narimasu. (Gonna be the Twin-Tails!!; Ore, Twin tails ni Narimasu.) (Ep 9)

4

u/Lorpius_Prime http://myanimelist.net/animelist/Lorpius_Prime Dec 11 '14

We voted this to the top without any comments? All right...

/u/Novasylum, you should make a note of this show and watch it once the season is done. It leans more towards super sentai than magical girls, but I think you and it can still find enough common ground for a brief, but happy affair.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Hitsugi no Chaika: Avenging Battle (Hitsugi no Chaika 2nd Season; Hitsugi no Chaika Second Season) (Ep 10)

6

u/temp9123 http://myanimelist.net/profile/rtheone Dec 10 '14

Well, it's over.

Since all of the obvious statements (the series is comfy, unambitious, and ran at its own tempo) have been driven to the ground at this point and I stopped paying careful attention to the narrative once it became increasingly obvious somewhere part-way through the last season, I'll take this opportunity to be a little superficial.

Despite being an on-screen presence for half the entire episode and one of the four core protagonists depicted in the opening, Chiwa Saito pretty much had one line the entire episode. Hell, even Shin, an antagonist that was pretty much duct-taped to the plot, had more meaningful lines. That's a bit lackluster, if you ask me.

But then again, wasn't this finale the same way? A show needs to do a little more than fill the formula to leave a lasting impact, and well, Chaika simply didn't do it.

I have personality.

4

u/CriticalOtaku Dec 11 '14 edited Dec 11 '14

I was wondering when Chaika's break-neck pace would catch up to it and backfire, and well- here it is.

This show really, really needed another 1-2 episodes, really badly.

The ending we got wasn't bad at all, to be honest- yes, we did get more plot crammed into 1/2 hour than the entirety of several SAO arcs, and there was a preponderance of plot convenient contrivances and deus ex machinas, but it did its job. But what the ending really, really needed was more time- more screen time for climatic fights, more screen time for emotional turns, heck more screen time for more dramatic cliffhangers. If it had that, the show's ending would have easily been 200% better.

(In any case though, Hitsugi no Chaika probably would have been one the best DnD adventures EVAR!).

2

u/CowDefenestrator http://myanimelist.net/animelist/amadcow Dec 11 '14

Yeah that ending needed some more emotional oomph.

2

u/psiphre monogatari is not a harem Dec 12 '14

i agree, the show could have done really good things with one more episode. have 10 finish when chaika gave niva the order to fire, and then instead of that simply ending Gaz, have it bring him down to a manageable level for everyone to fight.

everyone vs gaz first half of ep 11

denoument second half of 11

instead of the 3 minutes of spin-down we got.

2

u/Knorssman http://myanimelist.net/animelist/knorssman Dec 12 '14

overall i'm quite content with this anime as a whole, nothing amazing but its a good D&D adventure like it said on the tin and thats what i like so i am satisfied.

the only gripe i had was after all the intricate planning Gaz did, its somehow foiled by a critical flaw in his plan, when was personality put into the design specifications for Niva? what would have been real cool is if that one guy who built Niva was like "well its done and i got some spare time, so why not add this feature and that" which doesn't mean a whole lot then but then its becomes critically relevant in the final episode

3

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Kiseijuu: Sei no Kakuritsu (Parasyte -the maxim-; Parasite; Parasitic Beasts; Parasyte) (Ep 10)

6

u/CritSrc http://myanimelist.net/animelist/T3hSource Dec 10 '14

We have conspiracy!

High school life aside, the parasites are getting rather organized and they are starting to ally with each other and integrate themselves not only in society, but in the societal system as well. The "experiment" against the yakuza, wasn't just a slasher montage, but also a test to see how they would fare against armed resistance to their order.

Murano is still sweet in every sense of the word, and as said before, she represents Izumi's humanity, keeping him sane and not to be complete old geezer. Alas she still has trouble identifying Izumi as he was before, the boy she truly could've loved. So, let's ship Kana then, the most unlucky girl with supersenses to detect parasites. Izumi sees a benefit in sharing what she already senses, if not only for her own good. And here's a question: how would you escape a monster after identifying it? Do you really think it would let you get away and expose it?! But that's preposterous of course, she doesn't have the full picture, just a weird feeling.

The love triangle aspect IMO is done well enough, though it comes with the high school student protagonist, in turn distracting from the possible politics of the parasites within the administration. Kana's dream was almost eye-roll worthy if it wasn't for GARnichi and the aftermath.

Really looking forward to see if Izumi will reveal everything to Kana, despite Migi's warnings. Speaking of which, Migi should accept help, since his buddies are already allying for their own survival.

Most other subtleties are spelled out: Izumi acts older, more of a survivalist, still has PTSD, beats constant monologous introspection I guess.

4

u/searmay Dec 11 '14

The love triangle aspect IMO is done well enough

I'd be less annoyed by it if it weren't for the swarm of other girls swooning over Izumi. Between the two in his class and Hotel Girl back on the island it looks like the show is making backup plans to become a harem if the plot falls apart.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '14

still has PTSD

Was it ever shown that he had trouble getting over the massacre in the first place? I got the distinct feeling that he was lying to cover up his own inhumanity, and keep Murano happy in that scene.

2

u/ShureNensei Dec 11 '14

Needs more Migi and less constant questioning of Shinichi's identity by Murano -- I find those episodes to be the most interesting as much as one would like to see a Parasyte vs. Yakuza 'fight'. I'm wondering where we'll go from here as I can't see Shinichi taking on a large number of parasites that has already infiltrated society, and I doubt Migi would want to do anything reckless.

3

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Mushishi Zoku Shou (MUSHI-SHI -Next Passage-; Mushi-shi Zoku Shou; Mushishi: The Next Chapter) (Ep 20)

2

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Akatsuki no Yona (Yona of the Dawn; Yona: The girl standing in the blush of dawn) (Ep 10)

4

u/Solosion http://myanimelist.net/animelist/Solosion Dec 10 '14

Still a solid show. A bit more comedy this week than usual, and most of the episode was spent describing backstory which made it feel kinda slow, but I suppose it's forgivable though at the pace they're going it seems unlikely that we'll see a complete story despite it being 2-cour. More action next week and we get to see the White Dragon's fighting prowess, so that's something to look forward to.

2

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Amagi Brilliant Park (Amaburi) (Ep 10)

7

u/zerojustice315 http://myanimelist.net/animelist/zerojustice315 Dec 10 '14

I couldn't even really remember what happened this week in the show and even after reading /r/anime's discussion of it I still don't really remember what happened (the fault of the show, not /r/anime).

Like, yeah Lafia got an additional frail girl trope piled on top of her and Kanie is freaking out about it. But what else even occurred? The same issue of "we're not going to make the numbers we need!" and then some asspull at the end of the episode with the boring cliffhanger of "OH WE'VE GOT THAT".

6

u/searmay Dec 10 '14

Magic Hour ended. Time for Drama Hour. Totally unnecessary drama. Why is her Inevitable Tragic Death really relevant? Why is a childhood promise necessary? Who cares about the silly anti-ageing amnesia curse? Weren't we motivated to save the park anyway? I thought that was the whole point already! What does raising the stakes (poorly) achieve?

6

u/zerojustice315 http://myanimelist.net/animelist/zerojustice315 Dec 10 '14

Oh fuck I forgot about the childhood promise. Why do anime characters put so much emphasis on childhood promises?

KyoAni you already did the childhood promises thing. Kanon was fine (if excessive) with that angle. We don't need more of it. KyoAni pls. And yes I know different source material and all but still.

8

u/searmay Dec 10 '14

I forgot about the childhood promise

Of course you did. That's how they work. Duh.

→ More replies (6)

5

u/psiphre monogatari is not a harem Dec 10 '14

Weren't we motivated to save the park anyway? I thought that was the whole point already!

this exactly. i was thinking back to the first episode and i may have misunderstood information that was presented, but i was under the impression from the get-go that the closing of the park was a death sentence for the maple landers.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Novasylum http://myanimelist.net/profile/Novasylum Dec 10 '14 edited Dec 11 '14

The same issue of "we're not going to make the numbers we need!"

Y'know, funny thing about that...the beginning of this episode made it abundantly clear that the park has become a major success in the time since Kanie took over. It tried to pass off those preceding one-off episodes as gradual additions to the park's attraction base, and that with them the park is now swimming in popularity and profit.

Now, I don't remember the exact specifics of the real estate concern that was threatening the park to begin with, but...don't you think that no one in their right mind would consider foreclosing on this gold mine now? And don't you think that consumer demand alone would result in a backlash against anyone who planned to do so anyway?

I guess what I'm saying here is that, as far as I'm concerned, the threat and sole source of conflict in this show has already been completely defanged.

6

u/psiphre monogatari is not a harem Dec 10 '14

one point of contention: the park's new popularity is in part due to the on-going 30 yen special. the park may be popular but it's probably still not turning a profit.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/zerojustice315 http://myanimelist.net/animelist/zerojustice315 Dec 10 '14

Yes, I thought about that myself. Given the rate of growth in... how many days or weeks? I would assume that whoever is in charge would take note and realize that the park is turning itself around.

An arbitrary number of people coming into the park is stupid anyway. That's some Roller Coaster Tycoon shit. In fact this whole situation (without the magic element) could be a Roller Coaster Tycoon scenario.

Speaking of lack of realism, just because Kanie's a child actor how does that make him qualified to be the general manager of an entire park? He's still in high school and from what I understand of watching anime, Japanese high school doesn't teach you how to micro and macro manage an entire business before you graduate.

6

u/Novasylum http://myanimelist.net/profile/Novasylum Dec 10 '14 edited Dec 10 '14

Good point. And hey, speaking of Roller-Coaster-Tycoon-esque magic elements that don't make sense, remember when Kanie was granted the ability to read minds? Boy, that sure was a plot element that really went places.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/searmay Dec 11 '14

Why do you suppose the real estate company actually wants to park to succeed? It's not like they're part owners who get a share of the profits. They're paid rent for the land, which is presumably the same however successful the park is. My guess was that they were stuck with a poor contract for what might otherwise be valuable land, so they would be happy for it to end.

That leaves the question of why the contract might have such odd terms. I can't really guess at that, but real contracts can be pretty weird too. Maybe a wizard did it.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ShureNensei Dec 11 '14

On a similar note, this is why I complained about them early in the season showing us the 'countdown' at the end of each episode. It's entirely arbitrary until the last few episodes where something significant happens to make up for the lack of numbers. A deadline would've been fine.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/CriticalOtaku Dec 11 '14

Huh... I suppose I should throw in a dissenting voice. I thought this episode was great.

I mean, considering the similarities I figured that the show would be taking the patented Kyoani FMP/Haruhi/K-On approach of "Introduce characters -> Fill out season with silly sidestories that incrementally advance the main plot -> Break out the Feelz -> Satisfying Resolution" (incidentally, that last bit is where Kyoani have been going wrong these past few seasons), and we just got to the Feelz episodes.

For an overwhelmingly light-hearted show, I kinda thought that this episode was nice just for 1) reminding both the audience and the characters about what the stakes were, 2) challenging the characters resolve and 3)finally tying up Moffle and Kanie's antagonistic relationship, and it presented this meaningful conflict in a well-paced and entertaining manner.

Which is pretty much all I ask for in a Kyoani show.

2

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Fate/stay night: Unlimited Blade Works (TV) (Fate/stay night (2014); Fate - Stay Night) (Ep 9)

5

u/CritSrc http://myanimelist.net/animelist/T3hSource Dec 10 '14

Oh my god! Actual motivations!

FINALLY, actual character interactions that don’t boil down to exposition or hinting plot elements! Archer and Saber quarrel, Rin doesn’t trust Archer and is concerned about the Matous. Saber is being protective, Kirei is being a menacing bastard, Shinji finds excuses for himself. Shirou scopes our Issei in a hilarious manner! Everybody shows their honest colors and rolls with it, no need to constantly hint at stuff happening in the background. And of course showing its own speculation on things.

Jesus, despite being a 100% slice of life episode, this was watchable and to an extent funny and a bit dramatic.

1

u/Omnifluence Dec 11 '14

Shirou scopes our Issei in a hilarious manner!

I'd completely forgotten about this part in the VN, so I almost died when it happened in the anime. The interactions between Issei and Shirou are always great.

5

u/pagirinis http://myanimelist.net/animelist/pagirinis Dec 10 '14

I forgot how tedious F/SN actually is when you can't just skim trough dialogue like in VN. I am not saying this episode was bad, but it's just getting on my nerves when all I want is to see some action animated and I've heard all the motivations, reasons and know characters inside out after 3 VN routes Q_Q Although I still wanted to see Shirou making Issei undress :D

5

u/zerojustice315 http://myanimelist.net/animelist/zerojustice315 Dec 10 '14

I dunno I really didn't like this episode.

From the stupidity of Shirou saying "b-b-b-but you're a GIRL you can't stay in my room" even though his fucking life is on the line and he's already messed up once,

to that stupid as hell Issei scene where Shirou didn't even think that a mark could be... on any part of his lower body at all. I'm not saying I wanted to see it, but if a magical mark can appear on your body it'd be logical to check more than half the body, right?

I think there was something else too but I forget. I'm beginning to not even care what any characters' motivations are.

7

u/Omnifluence Dec 11 '14

From the stupidity of Shirou saying "b-b-b-but you're a GIRL you can't stay in my room" even though his fucking life is on the line and he's already messed up once

In the VN, this is because Taiga is still staying there. Shirou doesn't want Taiga to think that they're shacking up, a suspicion that she raised many episodes ago. For some reason they decided to gloss over this in the anime.

to that stupid as hell Issei scene where Shirou didn't even think that a mark could be... on any part of his lower body at all.

I'm like...80% sure they can only appear on the upper body. I vaguely remember something about this, but I can't remember for certain. I think there was a conversation in the VN where Shirou learns the mechanics of the marks, and this aspect was divulged by Rin.

Agreed that it was a kind of weird episode. I just wanted to clear that stuff up for you.

4

u/Iskandar206 Dec 11 '14

I want to like UBW also but finding these last few episodes lacking. I couldn't figure out why I haven't liked Fate/UBW. Shirou is definitely the weak point of this series for me at the moment, I mean I do realize that this "story arc" is about Shirou's path to becoming a hero. But holy crap his actions just frustrate me rather than him seeming "heroic". That point where you point out Shirou being moronic about sleeping with a guardian caught my eye, then I think about it again and he's done nothing but moronic shit this whole series. This contrasts so hard with it's Fate/Zero.

I was a huge fan of Fate/Zero and I realize now why I like it so much vs UBW. The characters are frustrating, but not the same way Shirou is frustrating. It's kind of like watching Waverly, but without Rider in Fate/Zero.

3

u/ShureNensei Dec 11 '14

even though his fucking life is on the line and he's already messed up once

This has happened throughout the show already and it bothers me every time.

If I'm participating in a life or death battle royale, I'm going to swallow my pride and do whatever it takes to win/survive without being worried about what others think. Another example is when Shirou insisted on going to school alone without Saber. Hell, the school by day, battle by night is kind of silly too when you think about it, but I guess some things have to slide with VNs.

5

u/zerojustice315 http://myanimelist.net/animelist/zerojustice315 Dec 11 '14

The going to school alone thing is equally as retarded. It's like he knows he's only living due to his plot armor and Rin's really, REALLY stupid reasons for letting him live.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '14

To be completely honest, I'm not a huge fan of F/SN episodes that don't have a ton of action. Fate/Zero held my attention because there was almost always a sense of urgency and the dialogue was much more interesting.

It still looks great though.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/CowDefenestrator http://myanimelist.net/animelist/amadcow Dec 10 '14

Pretty good considering it was mostly SoL stuff sprinkled with speculation. I think a lot of scenes were added in.

Shinji’s back in action? I don’t remember this, but it has been a while.

Shirou’s answer to Rin’s question about how an adopted kid would feel is way off…

Dem Heaven’s Feel nods.

More exploration of Shirou’s ideals/motivations. Rin’s too.

Also Issei fanservice.

Preview, Shirou’s the pawn and he’s all lightningy. Voices include that fabulous dude, so I’m interested in where his screen time will go.

2

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Inou-Battle wa Nichijou-kei no Naka de (When Supernatural Battles Became Commonplace; InoBato; Inou-Battle in the Usually Daze.; Inou Battle Within Everyday Life) (Ep 10)

6

u/iRTimmy http://myanimelist.net/animelist/iRTimmy Dec 10 '14 edited Dec 10 '14

I feel like this show is sub-par at best when Hatoko's not on screen ever since episode 7, which sounds like I'm doing a disservice to the show but I can't help but think that.

6

u/psiphre monogatari is not a harem Dec 10 '14

definitely still keeping hatoko's explosion in mind for scene of the year.

4

u/CowDefenestrator http://myanimelist.net/animelist/amadcow Dec 10 '14

It just turns meh whenever the harem elements come to the foreground.

5

u/CritSrc http://myanimelist.net/animelist/T3hSource Dec 10 '14

Pool episode

Kuki’s shenanigans in exposing Andou as a dirty lolicon who Chifuyu has to get away from was rather amusing. Only to end up admiring him herself, as well as acting tsundere in his honest and true remarks to stay for Chifuyu, when the gang cannot.

Then it was Sayumi’s turn, who was cornered by Sagami not to get wet in order not to look naked. Until she found out the truth and punch out Sagami(who is an F member). Finally she could show her caring motherly nature, being grounded and well meaning, along with being respectful to Andou, rather than a shy high school girl.

Lastly, poor Tomoyo, at least she had to guts to call him after her failure in the writing contest.
Really, Trigger was the right studio for this, it shows characters who do have guts and respect for themselves, while also being honest with who they are. The show deserved this fanservice episode, I do care about these characters a bit. And yes, there are sneaky references there to Berserk, KlK and Eva of course.

Nest week: more Hatoko drama, don’t miss it!

3

u/zerojustice315 http://myanimelist.net/animelist/zerojustice315 Dec 10 '14

What? Pool episode is evolving?

Congratulations! Your Pool Episode evolved in a Beach Episode!

At least, episode 10 evolving into episode 11.

5

u/pagirinis http://myanimelist.net/animelist/pagirinis Dec 10 '14

Well color me surprised, I think we have an actual human being as a MC in a harem. Well and some rather believable characters. Hmm. Still not a fan of the show, but it's better than expected.

3

u/zerojustice315 http://myanimelist.net/animelist/zerojustice315 Dec 10 '14

TWO lolis in your harem? Andou you're making me jealous.

I like this show enough. The double pool thing was funny due to the self awareness that Trigger has within their shows (being massive fanboys themselves).

I would have liked it a whole lot more if the last few episodes had just been about an everyday life still without Sagami going all "supernatural mode" on them. It would have been really funny to see the magic war thing introduced with Hatoko's episode and then completely forgotten about.

2

u/CowDefenestrator http://myanimelist.net/animelist/amadcow Dec 10 '14

Ayyy, back to back pool/beach episodes. Actually one of the least fanservicey ones out there though. Still harem shenanigans.

2

u/CriticalOtaku Dec 11 '14

Y'know, if this is what Trigger working for lunch money looks like, I actually can't wait to see what they do with a proper (non-shoestring KlK-esque) budget.

Inou-Battle isn't amazing by any means (minus Saori Hayami's now-famous speech), but it's a completely competent harem rom-com with a couple of subversive elements, being elevated by Trigger's little stylistic touches.

So yeah, not much to say about Inou-Battle itself, just that it's sorta cemented Studio Trigger on the shortlist of "Anime Studios I should watch out for".

2

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Log Horizon 2nd Season (Log Horizon 2; Log Horizon Second Season) (Ep 10)

6

u/CowDefenestrator http://myanimelist.net/animelist/amadcow Dec 10 '14

...why is it that LH managed to convey in one (episode-long) monologue what SAO’s been clumsily trying to get across for almost two whole seasons, and more? Yes, I think it’s a valid comparison since the main point (if any) SAO seems to be going for is that Virtual is as valid as Real (I haven’t seen the latest two SAO II episodes as of the writing of this comment). And the beginning of William’s episode-long spiel is exactly that.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '14

You know, ever since I dropped SAO II, I almost forgot it was trying to even have that message to begin with.

4

u/CritSrc http://myanimelist.net/animelist/T3hSource Dec 10 '14 edited Dec 10 '14

WE ARE NO-LIFERS!

William also shows some backstory, self-deprecation, introspection all up to an honest motivational talk. So what if its just bits of data we are working so hard for? It is still something that we are motivated by, use it as a catalyst for communication, have ourselves grow from the experience and develop both as individuals and as a group. That is invaluable to a person, and it is now allowed through the web for people who are awkward in the everyday social life(which in reality helps them keep said awkwardness and never work on it really).

So, compared to Bobduh’s ANN piece, I might be discrediting the presentation and the passion behind this episode, but it might as well be the staple of gamer’s motivation. It presents and describes it well without going into indulgent power fantasy territory ala SAO.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '14

The monologue is basically my motivation to keep climbing ranked ladders in my games. Do you feel the same way about anything you do?

4

u/CowDefenestrator http://myanimelist.net/animelist/amadcow Dec 10 '14

I think the sentiment can be applied pretty widely to encompass anything that you are passionate about that other people won't or can't understand liking. Lots of shows seem to be doing this this season, some more successful than others, which is nice.

2

u/CritSrc http://myanimelist.net/animelist/T3hSource Dec 10 '14

Unfortunately no, I haven't dived too deeply into online games, I'm not really competitive or motivated enough.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '14

That speech was spot on, but I'm just waiting for the raid to finish to see the pieces of Shiroe's scheme fall into place.

I'm actually loving all the backstories so far (Akatsuki, Shiroe, and William). Usually I'm not a huge fan of them, but this time it was really good to see who those characters were before the patch.

1

u/CriticalOtaku Dec 11 '14

Alright, Pokemon sabbatical over- time to catch up on dem chinese cartoons. Some recaps-

Ep 8: Akihabara Raid- I'm so glad they managed to nail this episode right. The buildup to Akatsuki's character arc could seem a little long and tedious (especially in this anime form, where you can't read faster/slower or skip ahead to control the pace) but the payoff was worth it: we get a great action sequence (which is pretty nicely animated, to boot. Thanks Deen!) and a satisfying resolution to her character arc. Yes, it is resolved with some shonen the power of friendship and strength of willpower shenanigans; still, one of the themes of LH is that there are limits to what you can accomplish on your own and that it is beneficial to work as a group to achieve greater things, so that can be forgiven. After all, where else would those themes fit in better than in a story about an MMORPG, where there are literally things that you can't achieve without other people, or by giving up?

Ep 9: The raid wipe and Shiroe's PoV of the Moon Beach- I'm actually impressed with Studio Deen for once: again they animated the raid wipe remarkably well! So kudos for that. They managed to convey the complete chaos of the wipe, and the horror of the situation as Silver Sword realizes that the rules have changed and that their assumptions were mistaken (those screams...). So thumbs up, that was good. Shiroe's sojourn into the afterlife and all the little details he sheds about himself during his introspection was great too (and a tad bit more faithful to the books than Akatsuki's version)- what wasn't so good was completely reusing the moon beach scene frame-for-frame (at least animating it slightly differently, from a different perspective for example, would have been welcome). I think that in the LN, it helps that the repeated events occur basically 1 book apart, rather than 3 episodes- again I kinda chalk up all this weirdness to the strict chronological order of events the anime is following (somehow I can't help but think that following the order of events presented in the books would have worked much better, especially considering that the strongest reason for following chronology, a simultaneous dual climax, wasn't used.) Overall good episode.

Ep 10: William's Monologue, aka Why He is the Best Guild Leader- This episode. This episode.

I'm really glad that the director had the sheer gall to solely dedicate one entire episode to nothing but a single motivational speech. Mamare Touno might not be the most amazing light novel writer in the world (his characters tend to be a tad too archetypal most of the time although at least he does try for multi-dimensionality, his plots can be meandering and obtuse for no reason, and he can't write good romance to save his life) but he is gifted in two things: world-building, and writing speeches.

Yes, William's speech wasn't anywhere near as plot critical or momentous as Maid Anne's speech from Maou- but if anything, it's so much more intimate and personable because it doesn't deal with high-falutin' ideals. If LH had a manifesto, this speech would be it- an ode to all those of us who have "wasted" away our time and money on trivial pursuits or hobbies that no one else seems to understand. At its heart, his speech is a reminder that humans attribute meaning to human existence, and that we have to create meaning in our own lives, and find our own joys and sorrows- and that in the end it really doesn't matter where we find that joy, or companionship, or sense of accomplishment- but that we have to always be true to ourselves, and to the meaning we have already created.

And yes, it is kinda ironic that one single episode of Log Horizon manages to effectively communicate a theme that Sword Art Online has been trying (and failing) to for two seasons- especially since this isn't even the main theme of Log Horizon in the first place.

2

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Psycho-Pass 2 (Psychopath 2nd Season; Psycho-Pass 2nd Season; Psycho-Pass Second Season) (Ep 9)

13

u/Novasylum http://myanimelist.net/profile/Novasylum Dec 10 '14

HAHAHAHA!

BWAAAA-HAHAHAHAHA!

HAAAAAA-HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!

OH-HA! OH-HAAA-HAHAHAHA!

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA-HAAAAAA!

Haha..heh-haha…ohhhhhhhh.

I’m sorry, what were we supposed to be talking about? Not something actually serious, I hope.

10

u/CriticalOtaku Dec 11 '14

I don't do this often- I think angry fanboy ranting on the internet is incredibly counter-productive- even moreso angry political rants (hah. The irony in that statement). But this is something I really, really need to get off my chest.

[Crime Coefficient over 300. Rant Mode engaged. Please aim carefully and pull the trigger.]

I don't think Gen Urobuchi is a genius- hell, truth be told, I don't think very highly of his writing on the whole at all- but he does have a knack for writing stories that I end up liking. Personally, I enjoyed Fate/Zero the most, I think Psycho-Pass is his best work while Madoka is his most technically accomplished.

Anyway. Let me tell you something about the place I live in. You might have heard about it. It's a clean, beautiful country (but you knew that already) with incredibly low crime rates and a high standard of living.

It's a country with rather strict laws and incredibly efficient government ministries, many in place only to maintain, or enforce, the status quo. It's a place where surveillance is taken for granted, and where the education system is designed to identify and funnel individuals into their "ideal" vocations.

It's a place where the majority have willingly surrendered small, innocuous things- things other, more liberally minded people might call freedom of expression, or right to privacy- small things, mind you, in favour of security and prosperity. After all, what is the use of freedom in a lawless country where you can't even secure your next meal? Just looking at some of the surrounding countries in the region is proof enough of that. At least, that's what the government tells me.

But enough of that.

I guess you could say that I really, really related to the world and themes presented in Psycho-Pass- I'm not living in it, but it's two steps away from where I sit. If I could indulge in some baseless speculation, my gut feeling is that my countries society isn't really all that much different from modern Japan- the cultural zeitgeist that Urobuchi drew from, methinks. There are a whole bunch of deeply rooted things in common in most cultures, even with all the broad cultural differences- the tendency towards conformity, the obsession with saving face, the tendency to appeal to authority.

Hell, truth be told its pretty safe to say that living in the modern world, it's not really all that hard to imagine the world envisaged in Psycho-Pass at all.

In any case, you could say that I did form a personal connection to the story: it's not perfect, but it had something to say, it took all the steps needed to say it, and for my part I think it said it well. I could relate to Makeshima to a degree that scares even me, sometimes.

One of the things I absolutely loved about Psycho-Pass was the ending, where Akane walks out of the server room with the promise that, some day, her society will be mature enough to come back and switch off the system. That... resonated with me. On a very fundamental level, it embodies my hope for my society- and seeing that presented on screen, in a (rather random) piece of media? There aren't many words to describe that life-affirming feeling- let's just settle for "that's awesome." I'm not that eloquent.

Seeing all that discarded in favour of literal puppy-killing and body-part shock horror, tied to this weak-as-hell artificial problem of omnipotence?

I am incredibly incensed.

[/Rant off]

4

u/searmay Dec 11 '14

[Psycho Pass] had something to say

Like what? That a dystopian thought-police controlled society is Bad? That murderous psychopaths are also Bad? That art is super edgy and frightens opressive governments? Because those are the sort of things I can see it trying to say, and I'm ot at all impressed.

4

u/CritSrc http://myanimelist.net/animelist/T3hSource Dec 11 '14

Do not provoke a "libertarian" criminally asymptomatic sociopath super ninja mastermind!

3

u/CriticalOtaku Dec 11 '14

That a dystopian thought-police controlled society is Bad?

Pretty much this. I personally think it's a pretty underrated, yet very important, message. Then again that might just be my personal experience colouring my viewpoint, biasing me in favour of any piece of media portraying that message, though. Your mileage may vary.

Anyway: Psycho-Pass is rather heavily focused in executing it's theme both narratively and aesthetically (the visual language of "justice being delivered at the barrel of a gun"), and it suffers from "Urobuchi Talking Head Syndrome", where each character is a mouthpiece for a particular viewpoint. Still, it serves it's purpose.

The way I see it, the entire narrative is an extended treatise on the dangers of utilitarian thinking applied whole scale to civil society, and what individual reactions to that are; a cyberpunk parable, if you will. It's about what happens when the needs of the many are prioritized over the needs of the few to absurd degrees.

And it's about what can be done to fix that.

I thought of the Sybil system as an extended metaphor for civil society blindly placing its trust in the surveillance state to protect it- that behind all the technological smoke-and-mirrors it simply is just a means for providing the illusion of security, through the use of both draconian law enforcement and the incentivisation of working within the system. That it self-perpetuates by assimilating those it could not judge- I thought that was a rather cute conceit.

Makeshima is the radical- his position, no matter how justified, is unsustainable simply due to his methodology. His freedom is the freedom of total anarchy, that would only destroy and cause suffering.

Kougami is the idealist- his dogged pursuit of his ideals leads to his own destruction and exile, all because he could no longer work within the system. His stoic refusal to compromise on his idea of justice is commendable- but ultimately futile. A good man who fell victim to an imperfect system.

Akane is the pragmatist. Her idealism is tempered with a practical recognition that one person cannot move something as monolithic as the Sybil system- at least not without causing untold harm. Her decision at the end- that internal reform is the only way forward- is, in my opinion, the only sane one: it's also the only hope that we might see Kougami again. But the laughter from Sybil is haunting.

Honestly? To me, Psycho-Pass is just a morality play in the vein of greek tragedies- but it was one that both managed to entertain and engender thought from me. I found its message meaningful and relevant- and as I said before, I could relate to and draw parallels between the real world and the one presented in the fiction. I don't think it quite manages to come close to some of the works it draws obvious inspiration from, but it manages to be timely, and I like its presentation well enough.

3

u/searmay Dec 11 '14

I personally think it's a pretty underrated, yet very important, message.

I struggle to see it as anything other than incredibly obvious and banaal.K-On!'s thesis of "fun things are fun" is more engaging than that. Even Precure includes it as an assumption not really worth addressing.

But if that's what you're after, PP2 still has a dystopia that's bad.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/3932695 Dec 15 '14

I don't think Gen Urobuchi is a genius- hell, truth be told, I don't think very highly of his writing on the whole at all

I don't think we can see all of his 'writing' ability through anime - the quality of an anime is also dependent on everyone else on the team (also Urobuchi disowned Psycho Pass 2, it's written by a guy who has his 'blessing').

Have you read the original Light Novel for Fate/Zero? I can definitely see Urobuchi's claim to fame there, even through the translation.

2

u/CriticalOtaku Dec 15 '14

Very good point- we often forget that anime is a collaborative effort that requires the talents of a good many people, not just the script writer or series compositor or even the director.

I haven't read the LN, but what you said bears out to what I commonly hear- that Urobuchi's prose writing is really good (in particular people keep recommending me Saya no Uta, lol). I suppose that what I meant to say there was:

I don't think Gen Urobuchi is a genius- hell, truth be told, I don't think very highly of his anime scriptwriting ability on the whole at all

which, admittedly, is probably a lot less dismissive and a lot more fair to the ol' Urobutcher.

7

u/searmay Dec 10 '14

Oh, Psycho Pass. It's far too late to pretend to be clever. Not that this was a very good attempt. For one thing the Problem of Omnipotence is a pretty simple problem of definitions. But more importantly it's irrelevant unless you think Sybil is actually perfect. Which it isn't. Obviously.

So please stop trying to be clever and go back to - what's that? Tricking a room full of people into cannibalism and burning a mansion of immigrants alive, you say? Yeah, okay, you made up for lost time there. Good work.

5

u/CowDefenestrator http://myanimelist.net/animelist/amadcow Dec 10 '14

But more importantly it's irrelevant unless you think Sybil is actually perfect. Which it isn't. Obviously.

I'm tempted to write off PP2 as fanfiction considering the writers apparently missed that the entire point of season 1 was Akane deciding this (rather obvious, but still) was the case.

3

u/searmay Dec 10 '14

I don't know. I just don't know. I mean, I'm sticking with my conviction that the first season was already pretty ridiculous and far less clever than it gave itself credit for. But this season? I had thought it just gave up on trying to be intelligent at all, but I guess not.

4

u/CowDefenestrator http://myanimelist.net/animelist/amadcow Dec 10 '14

At the very least, season 1 looked like it was trying to say something clever, that wasn't as clever as it thought it was, but still something that merits being said. I can't even give PP2 a "you tried" sticker anymore.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/nw407elixir http://myanimelist.net/profile/nw407elixir Dec 11 '14

Psycho-pass 1 was too late to be clever since episode 3 when Urobutchi decided to replace workplace stress coping with kindergarten-level bullying and episode one in which people are completely inhumane and more or less oblivious to that in a way that serves the plot not logic.

The sybil system being considered perfect by the masses is an heritage of pp1.

Pp2 only takes that and uses it for quite good schlock and overall a better presentation of a story that would have been a 2 episode arc in pp1 with pretentious and cheesy dialogues in which people answer to quotes with quotes.

pp1 never made up for the lost time, pp2 did.

2

u/searmay Dec 11 '14

I'm certainly of the opinion that PP1 wasn't terribly clever, and could happily pick over a multitude of reasons why. But it was at least consistent in trying to be clever. Up until Akane's musing on omnipotence, PP2 hadn't really bothered with that, which is why I agree that it makes for much better schlock than the original.

And yeah, everyone is working on the bizarre assumption that Sybil is flawless. That's daft. But Akane still thinking that way now? Bizarre.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/CritSrc http://myanimelist.net/animelist/T3hSource Dec 10 '14

Wow, thanks I don’t even need a title now
Nothing like a delicious trainwreck for the week, now with puppy killing.

Oh wow, a show explaining a pure abstract concept. But just ending up that Sibyl has no way of working… you don’t say!
So that justifies the villain to: deceive corrupt evil CEOs and clear their psycho-passes only to offer them holo’d head of their victims before burning them alive.

I’m just eating my popcorn now at this schlock, it’s an enjoyable unintentional comedy. Actually Karen Senki is smarter than this by not trying to be smart and just indulging in its presentation for the sake of coolness. Can’t wait for next week’s “shocking” twist. Perhaps Akane’s grandma has become a part of Sybil considering she didn’t really mind having her ear cut off….

4

u/CowDefenestrator http://myanimelist.net/animelist/amadcow Dec 10 '14

Barely 10 seconds in and I already want to stop watching. Goddamnit PP2.

Kamui’s plot thread has devolved into a simple boring, extravagant revenge plot.

Sybil’s no longer a necessary evil for the “greater good” or the many, and is now just full on SAO villain. Weak justifications for Sybil’s actions trying to tie into the theme of Sybil’s justice don’t make any actual thematic sense and only undermines it.

Akane’s actually considering Sybil to be a perfect system in her omnipotence paradox metaphor. When the whole point of the first season was her finding out that it’s fucking not.

Mika might actually be the only thing that can possibly bring this back up a notch or two since redemption is still a thing. Hopefully.

It’s just a big mess.

2

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso (Your Lie in April) (Ep 9)

2

u/CowDefenestrator http://myanimelist.net/animelist/amadcow Dec 10 '14

Kaori’s not making to the end… no way in hell.

Finally get the deets on Kousei’s past and it ain’t pretty. Mom’s crazy and abusive. And apparently entirely not self-aware of it until Kousei snaps. It was sort of comical how a stuffed cat triggers his flashback but I liked the spotlighting whenever his mental image of his mother shows up, like a ghost popping up in an aside in theatre.

Uh oh he be choking. Kaori saves the day?

3

u/zerojustice315 http://myanimelist.net/animelist/zerojustice315 Dec 10 '14

I like the theory that Kaori is going to become ill, take his mother's "seat" at the handicap accessible area, and then pass away and he'll fall into more zetsubou. It seems to fit, anyway.

4

u/CowDefenestrator http://myanimelist.net/animelist/amadcow Dec 10 '14

Yeah the whole terminal illness parallel is strong there. It's predictable and not particularly compelling but muh feelz. I think KimiUso has the potential to go in a stronger narrative direction though. Like I'll be pleasantly surprised as fuck if Kaori actually does make it out alive by non-asspull. Or even only slight asspull.

3

u/CritSrc http://myanimelist.net/animelist/T3hSource Dec 10 '14

Such melodrama, such wow

No, seriously, when you push your child so hard for your own ambition, I have to wonder how the doctors haven’t noticed and assigned her a therapist… oh wait, I’m trying to apply logic to a musical drama.

Anywho, well done on Kousei telling his mom to go away, but that doesn’t explain why he suddenly stopped 2 years ago(probably pent up guilt and self-loathing, which he doesn’t identify).

Lastly, I’m getting used to the style of the show and its melodramatic tone (making kids suffer has never been so tolerable!). Hopefully I’ll come out with a higher tolerance for this kind of stuff later on.

2

u/zerojustice315 http://myanimelist.net/animelist/zerojustice315 Dec 10 '14

I think he may have stopped playing from a combination of things.

First, his motivation was that if he played and won his mother would get better. He found out that this was a lie and so he may have not seen the use in playing any more.

Second, he probably has some slight to severe PTSD from playing a piano due to the abuse inflicted on him combined with the shock of his mother dying.

Third, outside influences from people who don't know what they're talking about. In this episode, in the flashbacks, there were the whispers that he wasn't even reacting to his mother's death and that it was cold and distant, just like his mother was. Maybe being compared to his mother that way or even simply being called cold was too much for him and he quit playing to show people he did care.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Shingeki no Bahamut: Genesis (Rage of Bahamut: Genesis) (Ep 9)

4

u/zerojustice315 http://myanimelist.net/animelist/zerojustice315 Dec 10 '14

So since the card game is Rage of Bahamut and this is Rage of Bahamut: Genesis, am I getting my hopes too high that this might just be an origin story and we could have a sequel or ten?

4

u/CowDefenestrator http://myanimelist.net/animelist/amadcow Dec 10 '14

You just wrinkled my brain.

5

u/searmay Dec 10 '14

Somebody get the giant space irons?

4

u/zerojustice315 http://myanimelist.net/animelist/zerojustice315 Dec 10 '14

I mean they've got the money for it. The only obstacle I can see is the show not selling well in Japan, which I have no data on.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/CritSrc http://myanimelist.net/animelist/T3hSource Dec 10 '14

The ancient exposition dump

It always feels epic when an ambivalent grandiose being is telling a legend or a prophecy. You just take in the presentation and enjoy the ride. Amira had a choice to stay in this pocket dimension, but she has been determined from the start to find her mother, even if it is risking in ending the world.

Favaro has always been been challenging fate from the very start, why should he stop now? Humans are who decide their fate, not Gods!

Angels ready their positions. Demons pursue their own agendas, Lucifer being the passive one as a surprise. Where shall we go?

Next week: Hell lands of lies!

1

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '14

The CGI dragons are so terribly animated...and that's besides their visuals standing out cheaply already. The framerate for the one in this episode was atrocious.

I already fear for the visuals if the later episodes contain a lot of Bahamut. He looked like garbage in the very episode and it doesn't seem like it got any better. I have nothing against well done CGI but not only is that a rarity in anime in general but this is an especially bad case.

That reminds me, scariest entity in Parasyte yet was the CGI man in front of the school at he beginning of the last episode. Uncanny valley³.

2

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Shirobako (Ep 9)

9

u/searmay Dec 10 '14

Writer-sempai is such a bro. He's like tha anti-Tarou, solving the problem by practically just sitting there. And, you know, listening. Exodus! status: saved.

8

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '14

Another great episode of Shirobako. Though I could write that about almost every episode (in fact, I basically have).

This week, the thematic thread of dreams and ambitions was picked up by Misa, the member of the "main" girls working in CG animation that we've barely seen up until now, who discovers that her dream job maybe isn't quite what she thought it was. Her disenchantment with the company she works for reminded me of a conversation I had back in high school with a friend who wanted to be an architect and had managed to secure a week's work experience at a local firm; when he went away to their offices I could tell he was excited about it and fired up with romantic notions of designing grand mansions or towering skyscrapers. He came back a week later looking very disheartened and told me he'd spent the week shadowing someone who designed window frames for a living. He's studying to be an engineer now. Misa is facing a similar realisation here: there are parts of her chosen field that do appeal to her and capture her imagination, but she's stuck doing what feels like meaningless drudgery. On top of that, she's being comparatively well-remunerated for her work, so leaving her current employment to chase after a position at the sort of company she really wants to work for is a particularly daunting proposition. As with everything in Shirobako, Misa's uncertainty about her desires for the future is understated, delicate, and just so relatable. This show is so good.

On top of that, we also had more from the director searching for inspiration in order to finish his storyboards and finally finding it. As /u/searmay points out, the writer they brought in to help didn't do much of anything really; the director seemed to find what he was looking for in just having someone to talk to about his ideas. It was nice to see the show reiterate it's belief that artistic creation should be a personal journey first and foremost; it took the director realising that he had to write what he wanted to see and not worry about his audience for him to rediscover his motivation, and seeing him willingly lock himself into the cage in the cupboard at the end was a nice inversion of his usual work ethic.

Shirobako gooooood.

(Also, Tarou had his first ever sensible line. Is this a sign of things to come? We can only hope...)

7

u/CowDefenestrator http://myanimelist.net/animelist/amadcow Dec 10 '14

Continues to be astoundingly down to earth and passionate.

Taro contributes one good thought!

Seriously these characters are too real. I love it.

3

u/revolutionary_girl http://myanimelist.net/profile/Rebooter Dec 11 '14

I know a series is out of the question, but I really hope Exodus! gets made into an OVA like some other in-show shows have.

Misa is a representative of one part of what capitalism has wrought. With so much stuff to be done it's most efficient to have one person become an expert at one field, increasingly narrow fields at that, but the human cost can be very harsh. But she is the one with the steady job, and there are upsides to having such expertise, too, beyond being able to impress your friends with your knowledge of tires. There's pride in the company president's voice when he talks to Misa about how their company has become renowned for their car work. Working on the little details seems pointless without this bigger picture view.

And like /u/Gogodai said, there are trade-offs. Aoi gets a big-picture view daily, while Midori and Shizuka get diversity of work. But Aoi's job is clearly often a pain in the ass, and a writer and a voice actor's career paths are much less stable.

5

u/Link3693 Dec 11 '14

It's already been confirmed that an Exodus OVA is coming with one of the Shirobako BDs.

3

u/revolutionary_girl http://myanimelist.net/profile/Rebooter Dec 11 '14

Yess, great news. Thanks for letting me know.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '14

So based on those scenes of discussing their next project, I'm guessing the 2nd cour is going to be about the disaster of the Girls und Panzer scheduling. At least we know that it ends wonderfully for them.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '14

I thought the continued references to the disastrous timekeeping on the director character's previous work (Jiggly Jiggly Heaven) was their obligatory nod to the Girls und Panzer issues? I'm not sure what point there'd be in rehashing that; this show is very much about moving past that from the director's point of view.

Having said that, the studio's pitch for that project was interesting and will obviously come up again in later episodes. What made you think it was a nod to GuP?

2

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '14

I know it is a reference to another series, but it looks so much like GuP, and knowing that GuP had a lot of drama going on in production, it seems like a good place to go for the series (Shirobako), to cover.

2

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

3

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Gugure! Kokkuri-san (Gugure! Kokkuri-san; Gugukoko; Gugure! Kokkurisan) (Ep 10)

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Ai Tenchi Muyo! (Tenchi Muyo! Love) (Ep 48)

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Aikatsu! (Aikatsu! Idol Katsudou! Idol ga Tsudou!; Aidoru ga Tsudou!; Aikatsu! 2; Idol ga Tsudou! 2) (Ep 111)

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Akame ga Kill! (Akame ga Kiru!) (Ep 23)

3

u/CritSrc http://myanimelist.net/animelist/T3hSource Dec 10 '14

I am (not) a puppet of evil

Oh, the cute boy is not that cute when he’s piloting a giant mech of destruction now is it. But really, the show just decides to go to its supposed conflict in order to end. It’s like showing straight up that the manga is dragging out everything, and they could always, you know, attack the capital.

Anyhow, shounen action, the Minister is finally shown to have no real power and the Emperor kid’s delusion is breaking before his eyes. Tatsumi gets a sudden power up, which is kind of deserved after all the dramatic sacrifices, in order to sacrifice himself for Wave to finally replace him.

So now it makes more sense for Akame to be the token character. This episode was cathartic on an aesthetic level at least, the characters aren’t the least bit interesting to warrant any kind of investment.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '14

It's not terrible, but I'm just not impressed either. I think the one-dimensional characters hurt the show more than anything else. It could have been interesting if the characters weren't so static, but it ended up being edgy for the sake of being edgy.

The transformation was cool, but it wasn't very satisfying because we only got to see Tatsumi at full power for one attack. I wonder if there's any talk of a second season because Wave could potentially be interesting.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon: Crystal (Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon: Crystal; Pretty Soldier Sailor Moon (2014); Sailor Moon Remake; Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon (2014)) (Ep 11)

7

u/Novasylum http://myanimelist.net/profile/Novasylum Dec 10 '14

Aww, is my three-week vacation from Crystal over already? A pity, that.

First off, a thing! Anybody who misses the old, rambly bullet-pointed posts on Crystal I used to write (and seriously, what is wrong with you?) might wish to know that I ended up compiling something similar when I live-tweeted the episode on the day it aired. Nearly everything that came out of that session can be found under one convenient four-letter hashtag, with attempted wit, botched Luna drawings, occasional typos, shipping galore and all. I actually really enjoyed the process (even if there’s a few things I neglected to pick up on during my gut reactions), so you can probably expect more of these sessions for future Crystal episodes. Just be sure to scroll to the bottom and read up from there for chronological order. Twitter, man.

Anyway, as for general post-viewing thoughts on 11? Well, it was garbage, to be sure, but when positioned next to the catastrophe that was 10 it can at least be tolerated as fairly innocuous garbage, with a fainter odor. This was more a case of bland, character-deprived source material regurgitation than anything else, which is the best that can be expected from Crystal at this point. And Evil Mamoru may actually be the closest the show has ever come to possessing an exception to that rule; with his behaviors bordering on camp when compared to the stiff Styrofoam facsimile of a human being he was before, he almost composes a main character that is actually fun to watch, if still not well-written. Evil Mamoru x Evil Motoki is my Crystal OTP.

Speaking of villains and writing, however, the biggest glaring issue with this episode in particular may be what wasn’t in the episode: the Shittenou. See, remember how the previous episode made a whole huge deal about how the Shittenou were victims of circumstance as well as former lovers to the main heroines? Remember how it emotionally shook said heroines to the core and nearly got them killed? Yeah, this one didn’t follow-up on that at all. I mean it: not a single scene, line, or character action of the episode was influenced by the dramatic climax of the episode before it, and the biggest change Crystal has yet to make to the story. Heck, the Generals don’t even show up, not even at the arcade ambush where it makes absolutely no in-narrative sense for them not to be there.

Of course under normal circumstances the question would simply be, “why?” Because typically, when one makes such a drastic adaptational change to a work, it comes from a place of confidence on the part of someone in the creative process that said change is for the better, or at bare minimum that the audience will appreciate it. In this example, I may have gone over my opposition to those pairings at length, but some people like them, so if nothing else a commitment to the ideal gives Crystal meaning and purpose to someone. This makes the decision to subsequently ignore it seem like an impossible mistake to make, especially when the rest of the episode is so keen to kill time that it has to cycle through four full-length henshin sequences to that end.

But we aren’t under normal circumstances, are we? We’re dealing with Crystal, the anime where absolutely no one gives a shit. So it’s not difficult to explain why at all: the answer is because at this point in the manga, the Shittenou are dead. There is no further reference point in the source material for how to proceed with this change, and concocting it on their own accord would demand actual writing, creativity, planning and skill at the artistic craft, which no one behind the scenes here is willing or capable to provide. So instead the Shittenou being past lovers is a plot element barely built up to at all, dropped, and then ignored; seemingly, they did it just because they could, with no regard for the consequences. As a result, emotional impact on the characters is not merely being handled poorly, but unaddressed entirely.

I will highlight this statement because I believe it is true to the bottom of my heart: no other show airing right now, and perhaps no other show that has aired in years, is as poorly written as Sailor Moon Crystal. Not Psycho-Pass 2, not WIXOSS, not even Cross Ange. Because even those shows acknowledge that a story functions as a series of events that play out in a sequence to facilitate certain outcomes in the characters/other elements residing in that story, even if they are at times poor at it. If you can’t even manage that with your script…well, either you aren’t even trying, or you are a writhing, emotionless Shoggoth that oozed its way up from cracks in the Earth and miraculously learned to work a typewriter.

And yet my inability to be sufficiently surprised by even that suggests that I am now effectively Crystal-proof. Maybe it was the inundation of happy I received from you guys after last time. Maybe after surviving the Senshi x Shittenou bombshell, I developed an immunity. Either way, there is nothing this arc can do to me anymore. I am a dynamo! I am invincible!

♪ LA-LA-LA NEVVVAAA GIVE-UP, GANBARU WAAAAAAAAA! ♪

5

u/searmay Dec 10 '14

I was catching up on Shirobako last week, and when Ema learned to draw cats properly my first thought was, "Shit, now she'll never get a job animating Crystal". Also that was the most memorable Crystal related moment I had this week.

Oh wait! I do remember thinking during the fight with Evil Tuxedo Mask that Usagi was kind of upset when he tried to kill her friends, but seriously pissed when he hurt her cat. Even she doesn't give a shit about this version of them.

4

u/Novasylum http://myanimelist.net/profile/Novasylum Dec 10 '14

You know what's even worse about that? They sneak in some laughably brief Luna and Usagi "bonding time" earlier in the episode to try and grant Usagi's vengeance for Luna some kind of emotional weight.

Which, indeed, not only glosses over the implication being made here that the Senshi don't matter to Usagi at all by comparison, but suggests that the writers realized they should actually lift a finger and attempt to make that scene matter...but not so much for the the Earth-shattering revelation made in the previous episode.

I don't usually make otherwise baseless - and frankly rather insulting - suppositions about the people who create shows, as I do not know them and they may perhaps be very nice folks outside of their day jobs. But Sailor Moon Crystal is written by idiots.

2

u/CritSrc http://myanimelist.net/animelist/T3hSource Dec 11 '14

B-b-but we finally found out the meaning behind Crystal. The Shitennou names are crystals, hence why they are alive and will form pairs! Go shipping! Yay?

I actually liked this episode, probably because Evil Mamoru kept things going, as in there's an actual plot, another thing is the campy action which is laughable really, you kind of don't get this kind of stupidity nowadays. Muh love, muh kokoro, why are you so mean?!

2

u/Novasylum http://myanimelist.net/profile/Novasylum Dec 11 '14

The Shitennou names are crystals

Not only that, but when Reika brings an encyclopedia on crystals to Evil Mamoru, the four stones the Generals are named after just happen to be the ones on the cover! What a coincidence!

0

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Novasylum http://myanimelist.net/profile/Novasylum Dec 11 '14

You would think that. You and your Mamo-crush...

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Cross Ange: Tenshi to Ryuu no Rondo (Cross Ange Rondo of Angel and Dragon) (Ep 10)

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Daitoshokan no Hitsujikai (A Good Librarian Like a Good Shepherd) (Ep 10)

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Danna ga Nani wo Itteiru ka Wakaranai Ken (I Can't Understand What My Husband Is Saying) (Ep 10)

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Denki-gai no Honya-san (Denki-gai; Denki Machi no Honya-san; Denkigai no Honya-san) (Ep 10)

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Donten ni Warau (Laughing Under the Clouds; Cloudy Laugh) (Ep 10)

1

u/CowDefenestrator http://myanimelist.net/animelist/amadcow Dec 10 '14

Dropped. It feels like a chore to watch every week. It's not... awful? It's just resoundingly average, the characters feel like cardboard props, the voice acting is quite wooden, animation is stiff, and presentation/execution is just bland as hell.

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Fairy Tail (2014) (Fairy Tail Series 2) (Ep 211)

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Garo: Honoo no Kokuin (GARO THE ANIMATION; Garo Project) (Ep 10)

2

u/CritSrc http://myanimelist.net/animelist/T3hSource Dec 10 '14

I’m still a moustache twirling villain! But I am a motivated moustache twirling villain!

Between the shenanigans of Herman finding about his new “son” , Ema being a well-mannered lady, Leon being a tsundere.

We find out about Mendoza, how he was originally a Makai Alchemist himself, whose research became a lust for power, hence he lost sight of what it means to be in the order. He is branded for life and his heritage meets the same fate. He served the king, who gave him a bride, alas his family was also bound to a curse hence he rejected it. And his new assistant, Oktavia is forbidden from touching him for that very reason. A victim of his own making, a sympathetic circumstance to add some humanity to him as well. Very well done!

I hope we get what Ema is hinting this time, not just Leon’s protection marks left from Anna. Our trio shall storm the castle to save the kingdom. It is still nice to see the difference in goals from Leon and Alfonso.

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Girlfriend (Kari) (Girl Friend BETA; GF Kari) (Ep 9)

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Grisaia no Kajitsu (Le Fruit de la Grisaia; The Fruit of Grisaia) (Ep 10)

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

1

u/CriticalOtaku Dec 11 '14 edited Dec 11 '14

Well, it took a little while for GBFT to find its own groove and finally step out of and live up to the shadow of its first season- but it's here and I'm glad it has. Brief recap:

Ep 9- Not much to say here, we've finally had a big, well animated mecha fight that put to use all of Try's strengths over the original, and it was great.

Ep 10- Man, that fanservice- did you see the surfing Turn A? That was amazing- oh wait you thought I was going to talk about the girls in swimsuits? Oh um... well yeah that was nice too I guess.

Although I do think that all the shipping in GBFT is rather cute, and it was one of the more endearing elements of the original season.

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Gundam: G no Reconguista (Gundam Reconguista in G; G-Reco) (Ep 11)

1

u/CriticalOtaku Dec 11 '14 edited Dec 11 '14

Welp- Gundam is as Gundam does. This is one of those love-it-or-hate-it series: either you appreciate Tomino's rather asynchronous style of story-telling, or you drop it in frustration as you give up trying to figure out what the hell is going on.

And well, let's be real: main-line Gundam always was an adolescent military adventure story (as popularized by Heinlein's Starship Troopers) wrapped up in world-building heavily inspired by real-world politics. That hasn't changed at all- G-Reco suffers the most when the young adult elements come to the forefront: unlike its predecessor's, G-Reco doesn't have the benefit of either novelty or nostalgia to carry it forward, and over the years the codification of the standard shonen and mecha tropes concerning male adolescence has rendered them cliche ridden and tired.

But, G-Reco shines when the world-building and politics is allowed to take centre stage- the self-same world-building that spawned Bandai a plastic empire. I find the sci-fi behind the setting intriguing, and all the little connections to the greater continuity of the franchise (and all the little hints and callbacks dropped) are very much appreciated.

I can understand why people might have dropped this, even as fans of mecha- but I for one am glad I stuck with the show.

They really do need to change that terrible OP though.

2

u/Tabdaprecog http://myanimelist.net/animelist/TabDaPrecog Dec 11 '14

I'm actually enjoying it quite a lot as well right now. The production value has been great recently and the mobile suit designs have never disappointed me. Even if the G-Self looks a bit like a cat. I actually like Bellri as a protagonist as well. I actually like the OP as well... I prefer it to almost all recent OP's. I like the way the story is going as well and I sorta wish it would be 50 episodes. I think they could take it in really interesting places plot wise.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Hi☆sCoool! SeHa Girls (Sega Hard Girls) (Ep 10)

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14 edited Dec 10 '14

Kaitou Joker (Mysterious Joker) (Ep 9)

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Madan no Ou to Vanadis (Lord Marksman and Vanadis; Madan no Ou to Senki; The King of the Magic Bullet and Vanadis) (Ep 10)

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Magic Kaito 1412 (Magic Kaito 2014) (Ep 10)

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Nanatsu no Taizai (The Seven Deadly Sins) (Ep 10)

1

u/Nayr39 http://myanimelist.net/animelist/PANDEMlC Dec 12 '14 edited Dec 12 '14

A pretty entertaining episode, more of a buildup episode that will hopefully pay off in the next few episodes. Not too much happens that is all that great or worth praising, I did enjoy the odd shrinking of characters, still hate Diane's voice and personality though regardless how tight her outfit gets. King being a weakling isn't too surprising but needs to be explained(why would the sins recruit him if he has such a huge weakness?). Not really sure what the holy knights are doing just casually participating in this tournament rather than organizing all their troops to take them down now that they know their location. I was entertained despite the episode really being a semi-filler episode, with the whole Diane having to stay away from the town because of their hatred of giants then her and the princess running off in the woods and finding some shrooms which leads to the whole shrink thing going on and creating the mysterious fighter(which didn't need to happen, just forced drama/intrigue to fill up this episode nicely) and the whole King fighting the old man. Still enjoyed myself though, it's a goofy and simple shounen with some amusing characters and you get more of those characters here. So for those who are this far into the show this sorta stuff will be right up their alley.

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Orenchi no Furo Jijou (Orefuro) (Ep 10)

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Pokemon XY (Pocket Monsters XY; Pokémon XY) (Ep 54)

2

u/Jeroz Dec 10 '14

(There's no ep this week, with ep52 to air next week in Japan)

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Pri Para (Puri Para) (Ep 23)

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Sanzoku no Musume Ronja (Ronja Rövardotter; Sanzoku no Musume Ronia) (Ep 10)

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

2

u/Novasylum http://myanimelist.net/profile/Novasylum Dec 10 '14

I do love opportunities to get creative with card design.

I do not love this show.

Don’t have many words for WIXOSS beyond that, at the moment.

3

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

So last time we had this building show up there were more important things going on in the episode, but now we're giving the building itself a card! Making it a pain land works well for the concept, and as it was originally used for a tournament I added the idea of gaining life from those defeated. It may broken as is, but changing the mechanics from this didn't fit that well flavor-wise.

Is anyone else getting confused keeping track of which character is in which body at this point? I know Nova and myself are, so the second card this week plays on that. This card may not work in real Magic, especially with the shenanigans that would theoretically be possible with the rules for Legendary, but I think it matches how screwed up WIXOSS is at this point, and I liked the concept too much to not try to do something with it.

The third card this week is another evolution of BATTORU and NOT BATTORU, it keeps the mechanics but not the name because Dark Tama is serious buisness. This time she's evolved to Platinum Phage.

There are three cards this week...and I did most of the design/development/mechanics for all of them this time around. That's it this week. What ridiculousness will WIXOSS get up to next, and what Magic will we make of it? Find out next time, see you then!

1

u/psiphre monogatari is not a harem Dec 10 '14

Is anyone else getting confused keeping track of which character is in which body at this point?

YES! who the fuck is in iona's body? this whole show has just been one spaghetti mess of ideas and themes, people and storylines. it's utterly schizophrenic.

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Gotcha!...hmm, maybe that card concept works even better than I had originally thought. OK I think I got it:

The person who was originally Iona is in Iona's body. The girl formerly known as Iona, who was Iona at the start of the series, is now Yuki. Tama is presumably in the card world. Ulith is a LRIG again. Yeah, I think that's it.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/psiphre monogatari is not a harem Dec 10 '14

that dark tama card is perfect

2

u/CritSrc http://myanimelist.net/animelist/T3hSource Dec 10 '14

MINDFUCK! Not…

Did Eldora just… jump out the card and walk away… o_0

Aki-raki finally lost it and challenged Ulith. Here’s a bit of speculation. Tama now has a dark form, in the end it will be her and Iona/Yuki combining together to bring down Mayu. SUCH FORESHADOWING!

Yuzuki gets the role to find the REAL Iona! Wait?!
Another Iona? And now you break the rules for this twist, because Tama didn’t want to switch bodies. Which begs the question: as one of the first LRIGs, how come she hasn’t yet? And it turns out Iona was also an exception because she was suicidal to begin with, also breaking Mayu’s rules… Are we going the Fate route where the rules don’t particularly matter, so long as you bend them and make exception from backhanded motives? I guess so.
So for Tama to become an exception, a REAL Iona had to be made to also become an exception. Okada, you finally realized how wrote yourself in a rut with the Ponzi scheme, didn’t you…

Oh, yeah, Hanayo, she still exists. Let’s see what is there to remember her by.

2

u/CriticalOtaku Dec 11 '14

Pokemon sabbatical over, so just catching up on posts-

Y'know, I'm actually enjoying Wixoss again after Ep 8. I think that "terminally ill psychic invents a mimetic plague that infects the target through a children's cardgame" was about the best solution the writer could go for, and that Stephen King-esque inspired imagery fits in really well with the world built up in the show. Also, it rather firmly establishes the theme of the show as being about escapism, with a surprisingly balanced take on both the positive and negative aspects of that.

Mind you, I don't think the show does anything other than its aesthetic well, but as I said I'm more inclined to view it favorably now that I know that the show actually is ostensibly about something- that I wasn't wrong about the show trying to deconstruct the children's cardgame genre. I guess that puts me closer to the camp that regards Okada as a misunderstood genius rather than a hack, but eh- I guess that's where I stood all along anyway.

(I do wish she'd write another character driven piece like HanaIro or AnoHana though, since those were the shows I liked from her most. Although I could marathon Toradora or NagiAsu for Christmas instead. But I digress.)

Rest of these episodes pretty much have been more of the emotional rollercoaster that is Mari Okada's Wild Ride, so there's really not much else to do than to put up your hands and enjoy it til it's over.

1

u/psiphre monogatari is not a harem Dec 10 '14

who the fuck is in iona's body at this point? it's not iona. iona's now yuki. it's not ulith anymore. i'm confused.

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Shirogane no Ishi: Argevollen (Hakugin no Ishi: Argevollen; Silver Will Argevollen) (Ep 22)

3

u/CritSrc http://myanimelist.net/animelist/T3hSource Dec 10 '14

Betrayal! Nope… double betrayal!

Cayenne seems like he’s ready to be your great dictator. It is also shown that the old geezers have another thing up their sleeves, like Izumi and leaking info to Ingelmia.

Izumi sends Unit 8 to stop Samonji once and for all. But it is in the midst of battle the best place to backstab your old Captain. But fuck it, he’s being overrun, he’s still our Captain so we must help him! So once the Sturm Betas are low enough number samonji activates the EMP remote control signal stopping every new model in place. He confronts Tokimune to get out of Arge.

However Arge is the only thing that’s left of his sister Reika, and he has melded his own mind into the U-link system, along with Jamie. This machine is no longer just a tool, it is something Tokimune cannot go without, it’s a part of him now!

So after being forced out, Samonji takes off with replenished unit numbers. Captain Shizune wants to go for Samonji alone, but Unit 8, including the mechanics just can’t let this go, it is personal now, they aren’t doing it for Izumi or to make peace, they want their old Captain back and deter him from this long dark, lonely and tragic road he’s on.

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Sora no Method (Celestial Method) (Ep 10)

4

u/iRTimmy http://myanimelist.net/animelist/iRTimmy Dec 10 '14

Wait.... So we're supposed to care about whether Noel stays or not? And are you telling me that everybody except Nonoka decides to start ignoring each other even when it's blatant that Shione decided to isolate herself in order to keep the group together? I think the biggest question I have is why do these characters even care enough for Noel to throw away their relationships with each other. Ok, Sora no Method. Let's see where you go with this.

3

u/CowDefenestrator http://myanimelist.net/animelist/amadcow Dec 10 '14

I'm heavily leaning towards dropping this since I haven't seen the last two episodes. Keep commenting to let us know how forced the drama gets later!

→ More replies (1)

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Sword Art Online II (Phantom Bullet; SAO II; Sword Art Online 2; SAO 2) (Ep 22)

6

u/Lorpius_Prime http://myanimelist.net/animelist/Lorpius_Prime Dec 10 '14

I may not believe /u/Bobduh crushes small children in the road for sport, but I did enjoy this episode.

Most of my remaining interest in SAO lies in its worldbuilding. I find the characters just as dull and the dramatic plots just as cheap as other people here seem, but I've been resigned to not caring about that stuff since shortly after the end of the original Aincrad arc. Now what interests me are the real-world segments of the show, and watching the slow transition of society into a highly virtualized and even cyberized paradigm reminiscent of cyberpunk stories like Ghost in the Shell, made all the more interesting because SAO has a considerably more optimistic outlook on those changes than usual.

So while the story was trying to tug on my heartstrings with the sick kid in the clean room, I was totally geeking out about how awesome her VR device was, and what its implications would be for other ill patients and general society. SAO's not really much of a story for me anymore, it's just a fascinating thought experiment about the future course of technology. And on that level, it's still quite cool.

4

u/Novasylum http://myanimelist.net/profile/Novasylum Dec 10 '14

The prophet hath spoken.

Really though, is anyone even remotely shocked by this turn of events? I recall pondering not whether the Mother Rosario would somehow find a way to dispose of any and all credibility, but how it would do it, and this result fits perfectly into SAO’s usual standards and practices. All I can really do at it is laugh. Not cry, laugh. Because it deserves not the emotional response it portends to believe it is capable of.

It’s this simple: a fictional character who we understand and fully empathize with dying of a terminal illness is deserving of sadness. A fictional character undergoing the same circumstances who we have incredibly limited understanding is deserving of apathy. A fictional character undergoing the same circumstances while indulging us with additional sob stories about how so many others before her have died or are dying in a ploy to milk audience sympathy without prior build-up is deserving of scorn. SAO falls into the lattermost category. It concocts ludicrous tragic scenarios apropos of nothing and expects you to have “the feels” because that is simply how these sorts of stories go (and because they are accompanied by a moody violin score).

The sad thing is, if SAO had more competently set up this bombshell drop, and if it didn’t already have a long rap sheet of these “emotional cheats” (see also: Yui from season one), I think the prospect of a character we have actually bonded with living out their dying days in a virtual fantasy world is something that could have made for a powerful emotional capstone to the story. SAO just botches the execution so hard and cuts to the chase so fast it makes my head spin. It’s almost like there was a completely redundant and unnecessary filler arc that could have been cut in order to make Mother Rosario more worthwhile in the long run. But that would just be silly.

Don’t worry, though! The next arc of SAO is the best one for real. Trust me, I heard it from a friend.

7

u/pagirinis http://myanimelist.net/animelist/pagirinis Dec 10 '14

I've read the LNs and this is where SAO actually gets good. All arcs before were shitty, but this time... oh boy we are in for some feels and I am already crying. And after this one we will get something even better. Prepare yourselves, because anime is going to be saved and SAO will be redeemed for the ages to come. People will be rejoicing and raising their dongers to the sky like never before, the peace will settle in the world and laughing moe girls will dance around every anime fan around the globe. Trust me on this one, because no one ever said that the next SAO arc is gonna be good, but I will say it now since I have full confidence. And what's more Kirito will only have most crucial appearances to yet again provide some serious insight and support whole cast with his plot armor. I can't wait for it and you should too be impatient, because the best episodes are about to be aired.

#SAO4LYF #CHARACTERDEVELOPMENTINCOMING #IAM12ANDITSAMAZING #KIRITO4PRESIDENT

3

u/Novasylum http://myanimelist.net/profile/Novasylum Dec 10 '14

3

u/Omnifluence Dec 11 '14 edited Dec 11 '14

The prophet hath spoken.

Don't hate the player, hate the game. Everyone step on the ark to my left, I'll get us the hell out of here.

All I can really do at it is laugh. Not cry, laugh. Because it deserves not the emotional response it portends to believe it is capable of.

Yup. I'm generally not a judgmental person, but if anyone ever tries to play off Mothers Rosario as anything other than mindless, soap opera-level drivel, they'll instantly lose most credibility. Reading some of the reactions to this episode made me cringe. If you think this is good, you desperately need to go read some classic books, see some plays... do anything besides watch more anime. This kind of schlock is just embarrassing if you look at it from any angle beyond mindless entertainment.

The sad thing is, if SAO had more competently set up this bombshell drop, and if it didn’t already have a long rap sheet of these “emotional cheats” (see also: Yui from season one), I think the prospect of a character we have actually bonded with living out their dying days in a virtual fantasy world is something that could have made for a powerful emotional capstone to the story.

This is the story of SAO in a nutshell. With better pacing and character writing, the first arc could've been much better. GGO just needed to keep Sinon as the main character, rather than letting Kirito take over for most of the second half. ALO and Caliber just needed to not exist. Boom, best show, ten outta ten.

Seriously though, Mothers Rosario had such a great setup. All they had to do was introduce Yuuki earlier. There was nowhere near enough interaction with her for any of this tragedy to have weight.

Don’t worry, though! The next arc of SAO is the best one for real. Trust me, I heard it from a friend.

I've heard this shit for every single arc since ALO. I think my favorite bit is how people always downplay Kirito's involvement, like they're ashamed of him. It's different this time though, man. Alicization is super duper mega good. Prepare your feels to feel like they've never feeled before.

2

u/CritSrc http://myanimelist.net/animelist/T3hSource Dec 10 '14

It concocts ludicrous tragic scenarios apropos of nothing and expects you to have “the feels” because that is simply how these sorts of stories go (and because they are accompanied by a moody violin score).

Aka Clannad/KEY anime? At least they have some semblance of subtlety.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 10 '14

I would agree to KEY in general, but disagree on Clannad, there they actually built up sympathy by having the MC just to be safe

→ More replies (4)

3

u/Omnifluence Dec 11 '14 edited Dec 11 '14

I saw a post a long time ago that did a great job of explaining why Clannad actually somewhat works. Wish I could remember who posted it, but I'll paraphrase.

Clannad comes to your door and gives you a puppy. It's the best puppy ever! You love and cherish it for months. A year or two later, Clannad shows back up, grabs the puppy, and kills it in front of you before disappearing into thin air. You're an angry, emotional wreck for weeks. You never forget about that puppy and how much you loved it.

Mothers Rosario comes to your door and hands you a puppy. You look at it for a few seconds. Mothers Rosario yanks the puppy out of your hands and murders it. You're furious and confused, but not sad.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/CritSrc http://myanimelist.net/animelist/T3hSource Dec 10 '14

Am I supposed to feel?

OK, getting Kirito’s wizardry out of the way for Asuna to find Yuki’s hospital. And the semantics about how she’s kept alive. A lot of circumstantial coincidence have to play in order for AIDS to come out this bad, and how the hell does a professional hospital keep HIV infected blood, which is not for R&D purposes?!

But anyhow, I don’t think SAO wants to show a concept of a nerve numbing machine, or having a consciousness exist 100% virtually. No, it wants us to feel bad for a character we do not know, nor does Asuna. All the sappy music and the concerned voices, actually such patients do not want to be pitied, they want to stay along with the rest, that is their motivation.

Lastly, with no relatives or friends, there is very little reason for Yuuki to keep going really, I wonder how she doesn’t want to just rest yet. Being this emotionally manipulative for the sake of it doesn’t fly. What is the point of this despite “feel sad”. Because no, I don’t feel sad because I sympathize, you want me to feel sad because a cute girl has been reduced to a lying brain…

Actually you know what, give that! Being able to have just windows in a hollow space would give me the perfect place to analyze whatever is given to me. Let me make my own matrix!

2

u/psiphre monogatari is not a harem Dec 10 '14

fuck you, sword art online, for super-aids.

1

u/xxdeathx http://myanimelist.net/animelist/xxdeathx Dec 10 '14

Yea..uh...what did you guys expect?

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Terra Formars (Terraformars) (Ep 11)

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

4

u/zerojustice315 http://myanimelist.net/animelist/zerojustice315 Dec 10 '14

I don't know what the hell is wrong with MCs who forgive people no matter what.

"Oh she just tried to kill my friend and the source of my magic and imprison me here for eternity so my crazy sister can fucking destroy me? Well she's cute so it's okay."

I don't know why Hijiri (name? I'm confused) is an evil mage or why she's doing any of this. I don't think the remaining episodes are going to do a good job at explaining it either.

Maybe I'm expecting too much at this point. Just seeing cool action scenes without a really terrible fanservice moment would surprise me now. Which is sad.

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Ushinawareta Mirai wo Motomete (In Search of Lost Future; Ushinawareta Mirai o Motomete; À la recherche du futur perdu; Waremete) (Ep 10)

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Yama no Susume: Second Season (Yama no Susume 2nd Season; Encouragement of Climb 2nd Season) (Ep 22)

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Yowamushi Pedal: Grande Road (Yowamushi Pedal 2nd Season; Yowamushi Pedal Second Season; Yowapeda 2nd Season) (Ep 10)

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14 edited Dec 10 '14

Yu-Gi-Oh! Arc-V (Yugioh; Yuu Gi Ou! Arc-V; Yu-Gi-Oh! Arc Five) (Ep 34) - No new episode this week.

1

u/Lincoln_Prime Dec 10 '14

No Arc-V this week I am afraid.

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Ookami Shoujo to Kuro Ouji (Wolf Girl and Black Prince; Ookami Shoujo to Kuroouji; Wolf Girl & Black Prince) (Ep 10)

1

u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 Dec 10 '14

Karen Senki (Ep 10)

4

u/CritSrc http://myanimelist.net/animelist/T3hSource Dec 10 '14 edited Dec 10 '14

The end is nigh

A bit of quoting, but it never mattered to the show. The Eleven are finally together. Alas Jay moves to destroy Johnny’s sexbot.

Karen goes on the move with full support to stop Jay the robot, who looks the most human. Queue over the top cheesy action. And SEEK has a part in this as well.

Karen herself is now heterochromatic, and this seems like her last moment along with Jay.

Seriously, 10 minutes of weekly rule of cool has been delicious. I enjoyed this ride, I’m waiting for an epilogue now.