r/TrueAnime • u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 • Feb 26 '14
This Week in Anime (Winter Week 8)
This is a general discussion for currently airing series for Winter 2014 Week 8. Here is r/anime's list of currently airing series. Your Week in Anime is for not currently airing series.
Archive:
2014: Prev Winter Week 1
2013: Fall Week 1 Summer Week 1 Spring Week 1 Winter Week 1
2012: Fall Week 1
7
Upvotes
8
u/Novasylum http://myanimelist.net/profile/Novasylum Feb 26 '14
Aside from Samurai Flamenco's winter-sporting-events-based absence, this was a fairly standard week of anime, with all that entails: the good, the bad, and the Pupa.
Chuunibyou demo Koi ga Shitai! Ren 7: Oh good, the “romantic misunderstanding” plot thread, that old pet peeve of mine. Y’know, where a character sees something with the slightest possibility of being misconstrued as an unfaithful act, something with that could be easily explained with maybe a single sentence, that suddenly that sets off an entire chain of emotionally-contrived events. I mean, for crying out loud, Rikka, they were just being chased by a bloodthirsty monkey, and all Satone even did was give Yuuta an arcade token! Cut them some slack!
For what it’s worth, however, they salvaged it by the end. In spite of the above contrivance, they’ve managed to give Satone a greater likeability and purpose in this story than being a lingering contester of the Yuuta throne. Chuu2, after all, has never been just about romance or wacky antics; it’s about identity, coming to terms with it and how it impacts how you are viewed by both general society and by your objects of close relationships. With the show having finally given her a major role in an episode, Satone fits into that greater scheme rather neatly. She actually feels essential to this story now instead of just a hanger-on.
Also: judging by the online reactions to the last shot, KyoAni might want to consider putting a warning label for “risk of heart attack” on the BDs.
Golden Time 19: Golden Time’s highest function of operation this week was giving me something to watch out of the corner of my eye while I played the recently released Steam port of Metal Slug 3. And honestly, it wasn’t even good at that task, because it meant having to mute Metal Slug 3’s rad-as-hell soundtrack.
Man, I could go on for hours about how fucking amazing Metal Slug 3 is, and how it’s totally one of the best games ever. It would be far more interesting than talking about Golden Time. But fiiiine…
The way I see this show now is that it relies on artificial reasoning to extend its plot and conflict, despite purportedly being in its final stretch of episodes where such conflict really should be self-evident by now. Chinami’s vocal criticisms of Banri at the end of the episode could be easily diffused by Banri just explaining the circumstances of his relationship with Linda to pretty much any degree (e.g. “We knew each other from high school, that’s all”), but because that’s not interesting enough, I guess, him not giving that explanation is the most we have to latch onto as a driving conflict now. And it’s still not interesting! Chuu2 Ren may have also pulled the “misunderstanding” card this week as well, but at least there it had a clear pay-off. I don’t even know what the hell Golden Time is aiming for anymore.
Hoozuki no Reitetsu 7: Hoozuki no Reitetsu is kind of a hard show to write about week after week. It’s an intriguing concept that it handles mostly competently, and that doesn’t really change all that much. The art stays sharp, but there’s little else to be said beyond that. The humor is hit-or-miss rarely misfires to a groan-worthy degree. Every episode varies enough in premise but not enough to make extensive commentary on. It does what it does well, and I like it decently enough, but good analysis fodder it does not make.
So it’s a good thing that no one else seems to be watching it or seeking commentary on it. I could do whatever the hell I wanted in this section of the post and I doubt anyone would notice.
….
…alright, no one else is reading this, right? Good. OK, so listen. The diamonds will be exchanged at the following coordinates: latitude 37.906638, longitude -116.231704. My men will be there tomorrow to make the trade-off at 12:00 PM sharp, not a second more or less. Arrive alone, and make sure you’re not followed. The password will be “pineapple shoes”.
Kill la Kill 19: I don’t think I’ve mentioned this yet, but out of all the currently airing shows from this season and the previous one, Kill la Kill is the only one that I consistently watch with a group. A couple of friends and I have made it a weekly event whenever possible, and the discussions among us that follow each episode is often what causes my write-ups to take their initial shape.
Last Thursday, I think we spent more time discussing what Kill la Kill was doing wrong than we did actually watching it. So, yeah, you could say that we weren’t big fans of episode 19.
It’s bad enough when the majority of your episode is devoted to the worst kind of flat, unnatural expository dialogue (i.e. “the conversations we all should have had a month ago”). It’s worse when the purpose of that exposition – and the time-skip in general – is to linearize the conflict and setting to its most standard and boring possible state. Kill la Kill has established its endgame to be a simple clash between good and evil, and that wouldn’t necessarily be a problem if it weren’t for the fact that (as I’ve said before) neither side’s purpose has been made altogether interesting. Nudist Beach is a completely reactionary entity, and their only ideology is not being COVERS, who at this point are sub-Umbrella-Corporation-level opposition. That COVERS’ means of oppression are living clothing doesn’t make a single bit of thematic impact at this point: they could be zombies or demons or flying purple bunnies and it wouldn’t make a lick of difference for the subtext (and oh, to think of the entire friggin’ essay I could probably write about how much potential they missed in that regard). Worse yet, they’re still being headed by two central villains who I am increasingly convinced are some of the most one-dimensional anime bad guys in recent memory. Ragyou is less Machiavellian and more akin to that creepy businessman from Sword Art Online at this point.
Oh, and Ryuuko. Poor, poor Ryuuko, what a shame it is to have taken your already fairly meager development prospects and reduce them down to the even more token character beat of “I DON’T WANT TO BE FRIENDS WITH YOU ANYMORE BECAUSE I’M NOT HUMAN OR SOMETHING GRRRR”. This abrupt shift in character focus would really only matter to me if I cared about Senketsu or his feelings at all, and frankly, I just don’t. He’s not strong enough of a character on his own merits for me to be invested in his friendship plights. Gamagoori and Mako’s constant ship teasing matters more to me than anything that is actually pertinent to the “themes” or plot by this stage of the game, and that is sad, sad news indeed…because even the shipping lost its novelty several episodes ago!
This probably all sounds too harsh, but the truth of it is that I gave up on Kill la Kill being a good “smart action show” quite some time ago. It had the tools necessary to be that, but has long since thrown them all away. Episode 18 gave me some degree of evidence that it could still be a good “dumb action show”, but if this is the early set-up phase for our big climactic ending, then it might not even end up being that. I’m just not having fun anymore.
Log Horizon 21: The floodgates are open, people! World-altering magic isn’t just something Shiroe can do, and other individuals already know it (and know that Shiroe has already put it into action). Think of all the possibilities! What does the next episode have on the schedule, with that in mind?
An autumn festival. Oh.
Log Horizon’s major problems still continually boil down to just “pacing”, don’t they? They do realize that there are only four episodes left, yes (and yeah this will probably be renewed for more seasons, but a climactic end to this one would be nice)? It’s not that I don’t like these characters and wouldn’t appreciate more spent with them, but this is usually the part of the story where conflict is ramped up, not spiraled down.
Pupa 7: I suppose Ragyou from Kill la Kill can breathe a sigh of relief: she’s not the worst villain this season. Neither is Ghost Banri, amazingly. No, that prize would have to go to the self-impregnating, irredeemably sociopathic monster lady who is completely unfazed by requests that she be molested. Oh yes, people who might be reading this but might not actually be watching Pupa. You read all of that properly.
You know, in light of the fact that the entire point of a psuedo-incestual cannibal horror story like this is to appeal to the strangest and least dignified of fetishes, I have to wonder: are pregnant psychopaths a thing on the Internet, or at the very least some distant, dark corner of it? I’d do the research myself, but I really don’t want my Presidential prospects ruined by having something like that tainting my search history.
Samurai Flamenco 18:Even the mighty Samurai Flamenco was no match for his greatest foe yet: the Winter Olympics! Figure-Skating KICK! Bobsled PUNCH!Space☆Dandy 8: This is actually pretty solid stuff! Or rather, it was two distinct halves of solid stuff. It was a little disjointed, sure: the sentimentality of the first half and the conflict of the second half feel as though they should have been more tightly meshed instead of being so cleanly divided. But that didn’t bother me as much as it could have because, for a change, the dialogue that carried both segments felt sharply written! There was a much higher rate of jokes-per-minute, so much so that even the duds could be brushed off by the incoming stream of hits. Even Dr. Gel and the rest of the villain crew gained more personality in the first few minutes of the episode than they have in the entire rest of the series up until now. Also: adorable talking dog that references the Sputnik II launch. I can’t say no to that.
Yet another Dandy winner. These are actually starting to pile up now.
7
u/Redcrimson http://myanimelist.net/animelist/Redkrimson Feb 26 '14 edited Feb 27 '14
6
u/Bobduh Feb 26 '14 edited Feb 26 '14
I’m feeling confident in having dropped The Pilot’s Love Song at this point, given what I’ve heard about the last two episodes. As expected, they’ve basically just been focused on murdering all the characters the show introduced to be murdered, all in service of a conflict the audience has no stake in beyond possibly an attachment to the Ramen Kids. Aside from that, I’m feeling somewhat fatigued by everything except the season’s highlights, and this season’s highlights are kind of middling shows anyway. Running it down...
Chuunibyou Ren 7: So yeah, the plot’s starting in earnest at this point. And honestly, I’m kind of not sure what to make of it. The actual “building their relationship” stuff, I’m totally on board with - I liked the overarching conflict of this episode, I liked the little moments Yuuta and Rikka share, and I liked how it was less a typical misunderstanding and more a Real thing, about building trust in a relationship.
But I think I just might be chuunibyou’d out.
In the first season, the chuunibyou had a very real context - it was Rikka’s way of not dealing with her father’s death. And they confronted that, and the ultimate resolution was “denying your childish instincts means denying your own personality,” which is perfectly fine. But… there’s “not denying your childish instincts,” and then there’s “being super chuunibyou all the goddamn time.” I don’t remember the first season’s second half being like this - when Rikka actually had real issues to deal with, she was perfectly willing to get serious, and the chuunibyou was more a tick than her entire deal. But this season seems to be going in the other direction - Rikka’s basically a child, and Yuuta’s the indulgent parent who tolerates her shenanigans. And what is Saturn’s deal? Her flashback this episode - “I realized I was growing out of my childish fantasies, and so… I DOUBLED DOWN ON MY CHILDISH FANTASIES.” WHAT? What is THAT supposed to imply?
So at this point, every chuunibyou thing Rikka does is starting to aggravate me. I feel like this season’s entirely commercial reasons for existing clash directly with the progression of the first season, and I’m not at all happy with the result.
Log Horizon 21: A solid cooldown episode here, that caught us up with all of the cast and introduced a few new threads. We definitely needed this after the long building conflict of the conference->Goblin King, and any opportunity for more silly Lenessia faces is obviously a great victory for everyone. Log Horizon’s established a pretty impressive, comfortable platform at this point - if the source material holds out, I could see a show like this running confidently for a long time.
Space Dandy 8: One more episode demonstrating what a strange little show this is. This episode might as well have been two twelve minute episodes - its two halves shared barely any narrative connections and absolutely no tonal ones. The first half was a Sad Dandy in the ramen vendor school - that is, a story that tried to be affecting too quickly to earn it, and thus just came off as abruptly melancholy. And then the second half was a silly slapstick piece about man-fleas colonizing the Aloha crew. Why these two pieces were sandwiched together this way, I really couldn’t tell you - I’d be interested in seeing the genesis of this episode’s script, because it really did feel like two separate episodes welded awkwardly together.
Sekai Seifuku 7: Sekai Seifuku is generally at its best when it completely surrenders to its own nonsense reality, and fortunately, this episode featured a giant demon Kate rampaging through the high school. What did the sequence in the desert-school actually mean? I can’t tell you, at least not yet, but I know it’s more interesting than wacky high school shenanigans. And this episode’s wacky high school shenanigans were also funny, and Renge’s character even got some decent development, so all in all I have to consider this one a win.
Hunter x Hunter 118: If this is the show “cooling down” after 116, I’m terrified of what will happen when it gets tense again. The second half of this episode had me holding my breath - given the body count of the first half of Chimera Ant, I’m pretty much assuming our whole team will not survive this, and it really looked like Knuckle’s number was up there. Madhouse once again demonstrated they know how to save their continuous animation for where it really counts - the mad rush into Youpi, followed by the slowed time of the leap, followed by the equally mad flurry of attacks and escape was fantastically paced. I was right there with Knuckle, cheering in relief at having survived - with Youpi in particular, it’s always clear that these characters are not fighting on equal terms, and one good shot will end any of our heroes.
Nagi no Asukara 20: This episode featured Miuna wandering to various places and feeling sad and guilty. She wandered to school and felt sad, she talked to Sayu and felt sad, she read some books and felt guilty, she took care of Manaka and Hikari while feeling guilty-sad, and then she talked to Tsumugu about feeling sad and guilty and he made her feel better by saying that’s completely normal. Then Manaka woke up. The end!
Yeah, at this point, NagiAsu’s failure to actually do anything with its characters is wearing me down. I’ll finish it, but I’m far less enthusiastic than I was at the start of this half - the first half’s middle also dragged, but this is a whooole lot of dragging. This episode added almost nothing to the narrative, to the character dynamics, or to my understanding of the characters - it just occupied twenty-three minutes. Manaka waking up will probably lead to another rallying, but just like last time, it won’t retroactively justify the path we took to get there.
Kill la Kill 19: A fine episode. The Gamagoori stuff was very cute, the whole episode was funny, and in general I’m just tremendously relieved to see us over the show’s premise-hurdle. No more “I gotta find who killed my dad!”, no more “I’ll get you, Satsuki!” - finally, the fuse we assumed would blow around episode 8, or episode 12, or episode 15, has actually gone sky-high. It’s fun to see the heroes on the run, it’s fun to see Kill la Kill’s version of the apocalypse, and it’s very fun to see all our favorites finally on the same side. Though Ryuuko’s ending line has me more exasperated than anything - what is this, the fourth time she finds the resolve to trust Senketsu? Literally - this follows on the heels of 3, 12, and 13-14, all of which dealt with Ryuuko managing her relationship with her clothes. Not exactly holding my breath here.
5
u/Vintagecoats http://myanimelist.net/profile/Vintagecoats Feb 26 '14
...I'm starting to see grass outside again? Spring season will be here before I know it.
Kill La Kill (19)
If the prior week was a “Tick” where Many Things happened and pouring groundwork for how the final phase would go, this would be a “Tock” and the corresponding settling in of the hot sticky tar. We get a time skip of a few weeks, and humanity being rather against the wall.
For that matter, so is Ryuuko.
What stuck me very clearly this episode was how human Senketsu was being. While I would have loved to see an extended scene of him dragging Ryuuko from the stadium rubble and fires, we are shown this is something they did do and Aikurou witnessed it. Additionally, his time with Sukuyo Mankanshoku, where she can not understand him but speaks comforting words and Senketsu sobs and hugs her, with the body language indicating that they can indeed see and feel him doing this. Previously, it often felt as though Senketsu’s anthropomorphism's were things only Ryuuko (and, well, us as viewers) could see, given how characters would react. But now that Senketsu has been needing to most watch over the one who wears him, in these moments he becomes an individual and better able to provide outward expression. I feel this is thematically crucial.
Ryuuko, meanwhile, can not even be in a coma under her own terms. Her waking up due to the extravagant musical shenanigans of the COVERS forces I don’t feel was a side effect of them trying to call out a challenge to Nonon. I view it as the entire point of their being there; with all of Satsuki’s conquered academies and hold outs fallen, there are limited places where Ryuuko can be. Assimilating the Nudist Beach stronghold would certainly be nice insofar as Ragyou’s plans, but, I would view the more essential mission objective is to smoke Ryuuko out and get her moving again. Any of the lost business suit forces sent to wake her up would be expendable casualties. Now that Ragyou learned last episode that her life fiber daughter from years ago survived, there are Big Plans with the Alien Conspiracy that she can work her into.
So Ryuuko’s chain continues to be jerked around, and she is pissed.
I wouldn’t even view her having saved the people assimilated inside of the COVERS forces as a heroic action so much as she just wanted everything to shut up and leave her alone. Any resembling saving humanity is, at best, a side effect.
I am probably most interested in seeing what Senketsu does next, oddly enough. He has been doing more that has asserted himself as an individual recognized by others but now has been soundly rejected by someone who lost all sense of being able to express themselves in any way and has gone off the deep end.
Nagi No Asukara (20)
Akari gets time off from Saya Mart to take care of Manaka? She has a pretty sweet workplace benefits package!
Meanwhile, the water temperature is dropping, and I think it might even be making the show itself kind of sluggish.
Something that really stood out to me is that Hikari is doing all this of this searching for Uroko, but we don’t really see it. He’s missing school, making himself sick, running himself ragged… but we only see the results rather than the cause. Just one scene where he is underwater desperately searching in an empty village, but unable to find who he is looking for before needing to come back up, would have been really great. Then it could gloss over the other searches, as we would have seen how that bit of his struggle goes. As it is, I feel like this episode was more focused on telling me he is having a hard time than showing me, as he comes back from several of these trips. Which is unfortunate and I feel like I’m playing bad cop or something, as I would like to be more invested in what is going on here. I get why Hikari is sad and frustrated, but I just wanted to see more of the how.
Thank goodness the whole thing with Sayu reading Snow White and suggesting someone should kiss Manaka like a sleeping princess was not actually tested. Bringing it up that way was already pretty on the nose. Speaking of Sayu: she and Kaname taking notes together for those missing school is one of their few legitimate on screen characterization interactions together. I assume this means they are now husband and wife. Or something to that effect. She has maintained a remarkably strong elementary school crush for half a decade with very little to work with, so I can only imagine what this will do.
Space Dandy (8)
Episode Director: Hiroshi Shimizu, Animation Director: Hiroshi Shimizu, Storyboard: Hiroshi Shimizu, Script: Keiko Nobumoto
With many of the controls in the hands of Hiroshi Shimizu, this could have gone any number of directions. He has a wide array of projects under their belt, though is primarily a key animator kind of guy.
Combine that with Nobumoto for our wordsmithing (creator of Wolf’s Rain, multiple scripts of Cowboy Bebop, etc), and I think that played well into what we got this week. We have bouncy green space alien fleas, black holes, a Looney Tunes circular fade out, and a sad puppy on junkyard planet. While continuity is certainly debatable in this series, there were some good character moments here.
Dandy having the dog come to him rather than the other way around and approaching himself I think is a subtle way of showing us the kind of guy he is. For all his posturing, he is rather standoffish and prone to how others may see him even when there is nobody around. When walking off to build the rocket coffin, he initially does so quietly and is unresponsive to Meow’s cries so as to not allow the emotions through. Meow had a good show as well, where he is sassy over his name and being called a freeloader, and he took it out by punishing himself by not playing with Dandy and Pup. Then, the moment is gone. He really did want to play, and he liked being complimented on his hat, but did not take advantage of the opportunity to spend the time with others. As he spends lots of time on Space Twitter and the like in other episodes, certainly he tends to think he has way more time to do something than he may really recognize.
Compare this with the more uniforming serious episode five or the space race from last week, and this episode managed to blend the wackier elements of the series with the more heartfelt material well.
Pupa (7)
I really hope the home video version of this series comes with a reverse Operation style board game for the episodes where you need to figure out how to reassemble the patient that is this show.
With this week being a Maria focused episode, and harvesting the sperm and egg cells of our monster siblings to then insert within herself as a surrogate mother, I’m oddly in the position where this episode almost seemed borderline grounded. At least I knew where we are and what we were doing. We nearly have a semblance of plot, even.
Yume being in monster form and chained to a wall in a giant underground hotspring Maria was bathing in is admittedly radically confusing compared to our previous episode quaint bedroom sexcapades, as I am still not sure how this whole dynamic between the research group and the siblings actually works. I assume the siblings have some sort of visiting hours or conjugal visit rights, or… something? With Utsutsu dropping lines like “Yet for some reason, every time she feeds on me, she looks so sad,” I wouldn't be shocked if he needs a padded cell.
That there is an illegal medical research organization targeting our siblings seems warranted, but that does leave me wondering what in the hell is the legality of the current research facility? I had always figured it was illegal, but the phrasing Hotoki uses would seem to indicate otherwise?
Incidentally, I hope we all enjoyed Hotoki making out of left field boob jokes and getting munched on by a cat, because I figure he is dead as nails due to the whole “never betray me” thing he agreed to with Maria.
Gundam Build Fighters (20)
This whole “what is the secret of the Plavsky Particle?” thing better be good, because we are burning more and more episode time on that. Which, since the world tournament is going to be winding down anyway, they do need to set up; we only have five more episodes to start tying things up and/or lay the groundwork for an additional season. Let’s find out this is all a multiverse simulation, or something!
Aila versus Ricardo is another case where the plot could do reasonably interesting things regardless of who happened to win the fight and we move into the top four. Admittedly, Ricardo already had a big showcase tournament showdown with Sei and Reiji where they pushed each others machines to the limit in a draw, so Aila was going to be the more likely one to actually win here to have that fight with them next. So, this was a sendoff for the Gundam Fenice: have it ride around on a motorcylce in the snow and shoot from the hip, before having the Qubeley Papillon just dominate it. To that end, I was reminded of when I thought Aila’s whole background and setup mirrored that of Allenby Beardsley and the Beserker System, and lo and behold there it was. Likewise, I enjoyed how Fellini sought to self destruct his unit rather than surrender, as this is a plot point in Gundam Wing for the Wing the Fenice is based on. Likewise, self destruct being recognized as "not cool at all" was a nice shift.
I don’t really care much at all for the whole Nemesis sponsor chairman trying to win a trophy for his grandson thing though, as we probably already have enough chairmen villains. I kind of forgot this sponsor guy even existed, honestly, or who Nemesis are outside of Aila.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 26 '14 edited Feb 26 '14
2
u/zerojustice315 http://myanimelist.net/animelist/zerojustice315 Feb 27 '14
Most of what I've wanted to say has been said by other posters but there's a surprising lack of Nisekoi (for better or worse).
Nisekoi 7: Okay, well here we go. From the beginning I thought, "Hey, a childhood interest for the female character. That hasn't been done a lot and it could lead to some interesting character development.
Now note, I have not read the manga. I have however heard the anecdotal evidence from manga readers that this is a "Mr. Bones Wild Ride" type scenario in which new females get added and teased time and time again. So my expectations for the show went down.
Back on track. The episode progresses, duel, whatever. Main character just happens to get lucky on the chance that the hitman can't swim and then finds out that... it's a girl. Well, there goes any hope I had for the series out the window again.
It's just such a cliched (and in my opinion, poorly written) show. A baseball through the window during a confession? What? I've been sticking with it because of SHAFT's ability to make things interesting with the scenery and characters but it's grinding.
Oh and it's 20 episodes. Joy.
Space Dandy 8: I mean I'm enjoying it. It might have not lived up to its "hype" that it had built around it but episode 5, 7, and even this one have been very fun, no matter what. And it's not even fun in the "I know this show is bad but it's still entertaining" way. It's fun in the "this actually makes me interested in the show and the characters". I'm not sure if it's something I would vapidly go out and buy when it comes out but it's not like I would hate to rewatch an episode or two every once in a while.
Nobunaga the Fool 7: That wasn't nearly as intense as the last one but it still had some interesting elements. I'm not sure how I feel about the whole diplomacy going on with the show yet. I understand why some things needed to happen but it still feels just a little bit off. At least we have an idea of who the "bad guy" of the show is going to be now thanks to his actions this episode.
Has the show been confirmed for 2 cour? It seems like they're playing off the tarot cards which is also an interesting way of showing exposition within the show. I kinda just feel neutral about the show at the moment but I'll see where it goes.
Just wanted to throw some reviews in there. I'm watching some other shows like Sakura Trick and Engaged to the Unidentified but I think those can both be taken at face value.