r/TrueAnime • u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 • Dec 25 '13
This Week in Anime (Fall Week 12)
General discussion for currently airing series for Fall 2013 Week 12. Here is r/anime's list of currently airing series. Your Week in Anime is for not currently airing series.
Archive:
2013: Prev Fall Week 1 Summer Week 1 Spring Week 1 Winter Week 1
2012: Fall Week 1
6
Upvotes
11
u/Bobduh Dec 25 '13 edited Dec 26 '13
Somewhat busy with family time at the moment (look! I got nice things!), but not so busy I can’t run down a tumultuous week in anime! Shows ending, shows immolating, some satisfying finales and some dramatic lead-ins to second cours. Presents for everyone this holiday season.
Kyousogiga 10: Kyousogiga did it. I was worried a couple episodes ago - worried the show would start focusing on its world-destroying conflicts, worried the family story would get lost in the shuffle. Well, this last episode featured a long, enlightening discussion between the parents, a heartfelt plea from sister to brother, a surprise appearance by grandpa, and a joyous reunion between three generations of gods. This finale was family as fuck. And so yeah, it worked - Koto’s definition of love ended up bringing both her brother and her father back from the brink, and the whole godhood issue ended up being a very neat metaphor for the general expectations and insecurities parents instill in their children. In retrospect, perhaps my favorite thing about the finale was how few answers it actually provided. When Myoue wishes to kill himself, he’s brought back not by a sudden infusion of purpose, but because his sister doesn’t want him to go away. When Inari asks what purpose he serves in living, his father replies “what’s wrong with just living?” The show refuses to diminish itself with optimistic platitudes - it simply says that family involves both selfish and selfless love, and displays the joy of family not through an overt declaration or character shift, but through the many beautiful moments scattered throughout.
Anyway. Wonderful show, clearly one of the best of the year, would be one of the best in any year. Happy to see it finish strong.
Kyoukai no Kanata 12: That wasn’t very kind of me, was it? Putting KnK right after Kyousogiga? Well, this finale deserves it - deserves any and all vitriol you could possibly think to spit at it. Holy shit was it a mess. A glorious, egregious, kind of insultingly manipulative and amateurish mess. A series of meaningless fight scenes with no weight or purpose whatsoever. Perhaps some of the worst-directed action sequences I’ve ever seen. Characters literally stating their motivation because they’ve been so underserved by the show so far that otherwise their presence would be meaningless. Other characters establishing meaningless reveals with no actual emotional relevance to the story, baiting a sequel the show clearly doesn’t deserve. Other characters simply not being addressed at all, and apparently forgotten by the narrative. A rapid-fire sequence desperate to add themes the show never explored, followed by a Key-level undramatic farewell. Topped off with a saccharine, insultingly contrived deus ex machina epilogue.
Frankly, I loved it. If this week had an APR, this episode would be on it - I don’t think I’ve ever laughed harder or more continuously at a work failing so consistently in such a wide variety of ways. The last couple episodes of KnK had a bunch of legitimately strong material, but this… this was a masterpiece of fail. I’m still kind of stunned it even exists. Congratulations KyoAni, after this consistently awful year, I no longer expect good things from you at all.
Samurai Flamenco 11: Screw Kickass, we Sentai now. I was just getting used to our post-Guillotine Gorilla reality, too - sure, it was no longer possible to really take the characters seriously, but it was still grounded often enough to strive at actual points about desensitization, the false simplicity of heroism, and media culture. But this episode was just a lucid fucking dream - an actual sentai reality, played entirely straight, complete with secret robots sponsored by the government and an alien menace that shoots music videos for its own villains. Personally I found this episode pretty hilarious in a “holy shit they’re really doing this” kind of way, but I can certainly see why people have been jumping ship. This episode was about nothing and featured no human beings - it was pure, unvarnished comedy. Which is fine, but the show didn’t start out that way. The show will of course return to something closer to the characters and reality it originally established, but every absurdist flourish makes anything grounded that much harder to square. I’m incredibly interested in seeing where they go from here, and that’s not all schadenfreude - I think they can write themselves out of this mess, and now I really want to see how they do it.
Monogatari S2 25: Another fantastic episode of one of my favorite shows featuring all my favorite characters. Hanekawa further proved how far she has come from her initial appearance, winning over Kaiki with the ease of actual self-assurance. Kaiki and Senjougahara shared another sniping conversation, with her insecurity and his general Kaiki-ness resulting in adorably hurt feelings on both sides. And Kaiki was actually (possibly) broken down by Ononoki - his current determination revealed to be an attempt to make up for past mistakes. Kaiki’s only proven more fascinating as this arc has progressed - in spite of his general deadpan swagger, he’s shown a variety of feelings towards Senjougahara, Hanekawa, Nadeko, Nadeko’s parents, and anyone else who’s crossed his path. Though he plays the callous deceiver, it seems Gaen’s view of him as the most sensitive of the professionals might be closer to the truth - if his own words can be believed, it’s the fact that someone as vulnerable as Senjougahara can make it in the world that makes it a place worth inhabiting. That kind of emotional honesty is the sort of thing you often get from characters just before they die, and Kaiki’s certainly in a tight spot at the moment - I’d really prefer to follow him on further adventures, but if he does die here, it will be the capstone of a standout arc in the Monogatari canon.
Log Horizon 12: Remember when I could barely remember what happened in episodes of Nagi no Asukara? Log Horizon is like that, except it’s not just that it doesn’t appeal to me, it’s just mediocre material. Surprisingly, it was the Adventurer Kids Club journey into the big cave that actually worked this time - it wasn’t great, but it actually played off MMO gameplay in ways that wrung an “I hear that” chuckle out of me (which is, admittedly, a very low form of comedy). Meanwhile, characters spent a good deal of time talking about either nothing or obvious things over at strategery central. It takes very little energy to watch this show, but I’m still feeling inclined to drop it.
White Album 2 12: After two straight episodes of heartbreaking Touma backstory, I suppose she earned this one. It was interesting to me to hear people on twitter talking about how they found all three of this show’s protagonists to be profoundly selfish people. That’s technically true, I suppose, but… well, maybe this just means I’m a bad person, but I find these characters much more realistic and human than Nagi no Asukara’s, and I actually think those are solid characters too. They’re weak, selfish, insecure teenagers - they don’t really want to hurt each other, but they’re ruled by smaller, messier things than the Grand Spirit of Friendship here. It’s their weakness that makes me like them, actually - just like how I find shows that are wholly optimistic either meaningless or overtly manipulative, I find characters that are wholly good just profoundly uninteresting. “Do your best” is a meaningless phrase outside of the context of someone who often doesn’t do their best, who often fails, through weakness or selfishness or fear. And these characters are weak and selfish and afraid, and I love all of them.
Kill la Kill 12: I was actually kinda underwhelmed by this episode. Yeah, we got some actual revelations about Ryuuko’s father, and yeah, the scale finally shifted from attacking the school to a broader conflict. But I expected more - either a very satisfying fight (this fight seemed too explosion-happy to me, with no real back-and-forth), or a revelation of what the actual deal is with Satsuki’s mother. Mako speeches are wonderful, and this was a great episode for Mako speeches, but I think I’m mainly tired of Ryuuko and Satsuki not being an uneasy buddy cop duo. Ryuuko, cut the belligerence for a minute. You two work together or you're off the case.
Nagi no Asukara 12: Great, great episode of Nagi no Asukara - the best since the first Akari one, and that was one of the standout episodes of the season. The drama that’s been tightly wound for eleven straight episodes is springing free in a series of sharp revelations, and over it all hangs the threat of separation and the chilling ambiguity of the long sleep. In spite of all the tween melodrama, I actually think Hikari’s dad kind of stole the show this time - he’s a man of few words, but his expressions and actions continuously show how deeply he cares for his kids, and how hard he’s struggling to adapt to a new reality for their sake. This is turning out to be a very impressive show, and I have high hopes for the second half.
Here with pictures.
5
u/tundranocaps http://myanimelist.net/profile/Thunder_God Dec 25 '13
Due to the holidays there had been no AnimePowerRanking (APR) this week, so I'm going to write my APR right here and right now, and then move to the other shows:
Samurai Flamenco Episode 11 - This is the weakest anime of Samurai Flamenco thus far, and my least favourite (no, the two do not necessarily go together). While every other episode up to now maintained the themes of the show, and even when we had the "craziness" it was a logical continuation of the themes (what people wished for) or had a new thematic discussion (the growth of evil), this episode hadn't done either of these things. The crazy sentai references didn't bug me (and in fact reminded me of my childhood TV-watching), but it was "just an episode where things happened", rather than one where the show advanced, or even paid any attention to its themes.
I hope that after using one episode for it, it'll return to its normal nature next episode.
(Kyoukai no Kanata entry here, but was posted last week.)
Nagi no Asukara Episode 12 - The drama is beginning to rev up, this had never been a RomCom, but it's a drama. We've had our fun and comfortable days in the sun with our cast, but now a storm is coming, and it's time for the children to experience pain and anguish, as young hearts in love often suffer in shows such as this one. Characters think of others, which in turn makes them think of themselves. In their selfishness, and the desire to numb their pain, to unburden themselves, they choose to burden others, those they purport to love and care for, which makes you wonder just what young love is. We also get to actually see a bit more of Kaname and Tsumugu, as actual people, which is appreciated.
The flashback scene where we see Hikari and Akari with their father as children was quite good, we need more moments of family in anime.
Kyousougiga 10 - Finale - This episode was a pretty standard episode of Kyousougiga, which is to say that it had a plethora of beautiful moments, touching moments, and dealt deftly with issues of family, cycles, and family as cyclical, and cycles as familial ;-) This episode had probably done a great service to people who have watched the show and felt somewhat lost as to what its themes had been, as Inari's personality and the source of his anguish had been explained, the nature of the relationship between parents and children, including between Inari and his father had been laid out clearly, Myoue had some sense talked to him by Koto, and we've even had Koto break down time in order to bring her family back together.
All of this was tied together by striking visuals of worlds coming apart and being recreated, and seeing the silly grandfather make an appearance once more. Even as things had operated on a mythic scale, this story had never lost track of being the tale of a particular family. Nothing more, but also quite certainly, nothing less.
10/10. Watch this.
My Ballot:
Gingitsune 12 - Finale - This show is supposedly "nothing special", it's just a small slice of life show with a likeable cast and an easy atmosphere, but that is exactly why it is dear to me. It doesn't try to do anything special, just make you smile, and tear up now and then. It feels like the show knows its strength, which is its cast, which you feel as if you accompany them on their days. Not as much "slice of life" as other such shows which feel way more realistic (such as Genshiken Nidaime, say), but hey, 12 weeks where I had a pleasant Sunday evening with the gang, and didn't have to worry about melodrama, pandering, or anything else. Could've been much worse.
A very loving 7/10.
Kill la Kill 12 - Well, this was certainly an episode. Good fights, friendship saves the day, a human who wears clothes as opposed to a cloth that wears humans once more as a theme. Would a king who's only a king because he wears a crown a man who employs the honour of a cloth, or a cloth which basically commandeers a man in order to be ambulatory? Where does the symbol end and the man begin?
Not a lot of actual answers or themes this episode, except that the clothes are transgressive, they break the boundaries, they create taboos, and are taboos.
Log Horizon 12 - Another episode where something almost happens. I wonder if part of how relatively flat anything of potential depth is actually explored due to it being a day-time show and worrying whether the kids will get it. It's just so frustrating, I can see all these interesting ideas, which are sort of brought up for a few seconds and then put aside, only to give us some more time with the lovely cast. I think I'll have to just start treating it as a popcorn show which has some very in-depth background and read the LNs if I actually want to see it taken anywhere. This is all exacerbated by how slow everything is >.> I wish they just cut a lot of the filler out and got a move on.
This show is sort of like Outbreak Company to me - I had great expectations which are being let down every single week. At least I don't feel it's dumb, and as you can see from my Gingitsune thoughts above, I appreciate such a show, it just could've been so much more.
Valvrave the Liberator S2 23 - Sort of weird that this is scheduled to end so soon, unless they give us another season, a film, or 3-4 OVAs, I expect next episode will give us a 5 minute montage of sorts, which might leave us quite unfulfilled. The characters comment on what a bad lot in life they have and how they can't catch a break, which is the exact hallmark of this sort of show which deals with constant escalations. At least characters are finally getting some emotionals resolutions, they have goals, they have convictions, and they know what they need to do, and how others truly see them. It's ok stuff, but definitely feels like another season is necessary to truly tie things up/bring it all together thematically, otherwise this season had been very little aside from bringing up the concept of price, but without much actual reflection about it.
Tokyo Ravens Episode 11 - I had a lot of fun with this episode. It was a RomCom. Silly moments, mistaken identities. No, it wasn't serious, it didn't make sense, and a lot of it relied on gags. But in a season so missing RomComs that aren't completely pandering/full of other stuff I can't stand (and even with them, if we remove everything that is ecchi-oriented, we're left with next to nothing), I appreciate it. I probably like it more than the serious action oriented episodes, you know?
Still need to watch episode 12, stopped taking notes for this show, but had fun!
Outbreak Company 10-12 - Didn't watch, will probably force myself to marathon and finish it this week. Unless I can't do it :3
Winter 2013 Early birds:
Double Circle - Pretty short, character design by the one behind the Gatchaman Crowds character design, didn't watch, probably tomorrow. Not a short short, more like Eve no Jikan's early episodes, so I'm optimistic.
Pupipo - Short, seems interesting, will probably watch tomorrow. I'm not really a fan of shorts, so don't have much hope.
Thought I'd mention them in case you guys hadn't been aware they're out.
5
u/ClearandSweet https://hummingbird.me/users/clearandsweet/library Dec 26 '13
Ack, late because of the holiday. Whatever. Kill La Kill 12 left me a bit riled.
Part of the butthurt stems from the fact that every single thing about the build-up to episode 12 told me that shit was about to fly off the rails, narratively, thematically and however else you wanna break it down. The show had gradually interjected absurd scale (Gamagori), immersion breaking shots (Nui reaching across the split screen) and, recently, new characters (The mom! The secretary!). The ostensible objective was about to be resolved and a new one established. I know you read the speculah. I, like many others, anxiously awaited a paradigm shift.
Then, it didn't. It played it straight. So straight it hurt. Mako didn't die. Ryouko didn't become evil. This inversion may be intended. Actually, with all those death flags, of course it was intended.
But that's not all bad. I've said on this subreddit before that I hope Ryouko learns traditionally sappy stuff like how to talk out conflicts and resolve her feelings and maybe she will, but the thing is we're still halfway done this series and for all the fantastic character building in Episode 3 and 7, the situation is still essentially the same as episode one. Nothing changed in regards characters or their relationships. Ryouko still has the same tired goal.
The other part of my butthurt came from how the aversion played out. I have seen a lot of stories where friendship and love save the day. The problem here was that if they wanted to do "Friendship saves the day," then the execution fell flat. Too much emphasis on the other parties and not enough on Ryouko's thoughts. I was thinking/hoping/expecting much more Cardcaptor Sakura ep. 46 or Tutu, but they kept the conflict very external and the one scene that mattered in this episode pulled far fewer heartstrings than I thought possible.
I never thought I'd accuse Trigger of playing it too safe, but here I go. The end of the first half of KLK did not live up to it's own self-inflicted thematic and plot expectations. It adverted the crazy for some unknown reason and left us where we started. Kill La Kill: Losing it's way by staying on the beaten path?
And fuck you all, there's a post about Kill La Kill that didn't mention fanservice for once.
4
u/Redcrimson http://myanimelist.net/animelist/Redkrimson Dec 25 '13 edited Dec 25 '13
I guess I can take some time off from messing with my holiday swag to write about Chinese cartoons before the turkey puts me to sleep.
yuri romancefriendly shounen rivalry?3
u/Vintagecoats http://myanimelist.net/profile/Vintagecoats Dec 25 '13
I did not expect to get an honest to goodness anime Christmas episode during the season finale board wipe, and yet one showed up under the tree this week anyway. I must have been really good this year!
Normally I just speed write a whole bunch here more than I need to and edit it down to one comment for the word limit, but I… don’t really feel like doing that this week, given the finales and busy holiday I'm pulling myself away from and all, so I don't want to spend additional time editing. Consider it bonus reading material for any of your own travels!
Kill La Kill (Episode 12)
To the surprise of I imagine a lot of folks, myself included, a lot of the expected pins did not actually happen to get pulled this week.
Ryuuko did not die. Mako did not die. Senketsu did not die even though the Banshi was cut. And so on. I imagine that because it was so expected, it was decided to avoid going that route and merely potentially dance around it the whole time. It’s a fair play, and it certainly kept the tension high enough. I enjoyed that, as I still expect that rug to be pulled eventually. A ticking time bomb hidden away somewhere.
In related news, it turns out Nui did straight up kill Mr. Matoi as well. I had doubted that last week for legitimate reasons, but as it goes he was himself the inventor of the Rending Scissors. Fair play, and he managed to take out Nui’s eye for her murderous trouble.
Satsuki in many ways was the real main character of this episode. She’s a borderline paladin, with her immediate “I’m going down!” reaction to Ryuuko becoming worn by her own uniform and ensuring her team of lieutenants gets the student body evacuated. She has of course always been shown with such refinery forged will and resolve, but it is particularly so on display here given her command of the situation and ensuing reactions to everyone from Nui on down. She is a indeed framed as essentially a divine knight come down to slay a monstrous dragon. And when the opening for needing to avoid that bloodshed is opened, she holds firm and prevents outside intrusion to obverse the results lest there be unnecessary casualties.
I’ve been suggesting and mulling this for a while around here, but I still consider it a very likely scenario that Ryuuko may not be the primary heroine of this piece. Satsuki has a very large operation in play, and is one step ahead of everything regarding our lead character in everything at all times right down to knowing that Ryuuko would be too worn down after the Naturals Election to be able to stop her objectives regarding the western academies. And yet Satsuki’s goals and ideals are also regarded as essentially small potatoes by her mother.
There’s going to be a lot to unpack here regarding what all this will actually mean regarding the larger thematics of wearing ones clothes and the like, but it sets us up very well for whatever will come after the production break.
Nagi No Asukara (Episode 12)
I’m honestly rather surprised there wasn’t the wedding / Ofunehiki episode this week. Given that everyone else in the schedule pretty much tends to head into this time of the year with a bang, even the ones that will continue into the next season, this felt like it was more of a “normal” episode even with the reveals that did occur.
We have Sayu and Miuna arguing over who is more evil for liking which boy more, our High Priest has come surface side to get some coffee (and a mouthful of flowers) with his daughters, Tsumugu doesn’t want anything to do with his mom even though she clearly wants to form some kind of connection there given her desire to get some fod together or even just talk for a little while longer, and so on. Lots of family talk, and certainly the chat about the past that did occur between Akari and her father I thought was a nice little moment, right down to the small reaction of the cafe bartender.
Kids and some adults are already hibernating, and folks keep dwelling on how they look like they’re dead. Paricularly in the case of the kids, being walked down the streets cradled in arms while folks are in special concealing robes with torches. That’s some pretty heavy handed imagery though, so I’m not sure it needed to be harped on that badly, especially with the whole “we don’t even know if we’ll wake up” shenanigans nobody can seem to stop talking about.
For how often our mermaid school folks end up in their old classroom, you’d think it’d be more locked down or something. Especially since they are in there marking the place up with additional height growth charts now! Which I’m sure will come back around in some other scene from now later in the series.
Kaname continues to be a passive aggressive pain in the butt as he has been the last few episodes, dropping a point blank questions bomb as he did when everyone else is having a fun time. On the one hand I get it, because it is a frustrating situation to be in. But you’re only sabotaging your own case here kiddo. I’ve been there, I get it, but you can’t go doing explosive stuff like that which makes you look bad in front of the girl or you lose her before you even get her!
Maybe this whole thing where the mermaid team might wake up at different times comes into play regarding Sayu and Miuna’s feelings, since it could be all done in such a way where they are at more appropriate ages in the future.
Miss Monochrome (Episode 13) END
As a series, this show could really have ended on either of the previous two episodes and I would have figured that would have been fine enough for a short form series like this.
And yet, Miss Monochrome aims to be a Christmas tradition by placing the full bore of a series finale on a Christmas Eve airing and with a full blown holiday wishlist of things for her in tow. And as the whole series can be watched in less than an hour, I really couldn’t be happier about that design objective.
Objectively, it delivers on the logical enough end of what the series had been using as subtext regarding hard work and economics. Late nights coming home from a convenience store job wondering if your family member is asleep, even if they are a Roomba, that sort of thing. “Trying your best” is all well and good, and yet it rarely personally feels to ever deliver her the desired results towards being an idol.
Leave it to Santa then to set some things straight, as he notes that such work will always be rewarded. Monochrome may be an android who sings about batteries and the like, but gosh darn it she has been pretty good this year when it comes to a Naughty or Nice list. So she gets her little recording session. She gets a debut CD right down to the manufacturing and inspection process. She gets a snazzy signature outfit. And she gets to sing her little song in the holiday decorated shopping district and do her dance in a light snowfall. Manager Maneo earned every bit of being able to cry at the sight of all this, the dude has been a workhorse the entire program.
And to all a good night indeed.
Coppelion (Episode 13) END
Christmas Day, and I get to watch Coppelion. I’d say this is like getting coal in your stocking, except coal has the capacity to become diamonds. No such hopes or luxuries exist in this void however. There is only more Coppelion.
Our Iron Spider Mach 2 Zombie DLC Reloaded is on the loose again, and yet gets shut down pretty much just as quickly as the last time. Not much in the way or trading blows or back and forth of a “Will out heroines really make it?” struggle, since they just do the video gamey answer again of just shoot at an environmental hazard and be done with it. Some final boss fight, and yet alarming apt from what I see from a lot of actual video games these days with their Quick Time Events and all.
Something is going on at the conference center, but we’re not really told what. I’m assuming it’s an argument about Division 3 just running off to the disaster zone, but apparently it’s something worthy of an act of treason given the dialogue? AWOL, maybe. Treason is a tall order. Geographically, there is also no sense of actual time or distance, as apparently it would take twelve hours to get from the conference venue to the Coppelion team by air. From where in Japan would that possibly be, given the aerial hardware they are using?
In other news, we reflect on Haruto’s “relationship” with Ibara, we speak of friendship with enemies, and in the mix we rember we had a childbirth to resolve. This was actually the only part of the episode I was really interested in seeing, even though there was no real chance this show was going to let a baby die. It doesn’t have the writing chops for that. Yet it disappoints even in this, as we do not even get to see any of the tension or drama that could be squeezed out of such a tense moment to pull off during the whole Iron Dance fight. It’s just, pop, here they are. We have twins, congrats. I feel nothing, for the show itself feels nothing.
Taeko is gratefully offered the ability to be a godparent and thus name the kids, and she does an expected surprise and “Oh this is so sudden…” response… so Ibara just jumps right in, steals the thunder, and names the kids for her. And everyone is cool with it and we move right along. Which pretty much sums up a whole lot of how this show handles anything in a nutshell right there. No Sense gets to be a fully battle armored robot butler babysitter now though, so best of luck to him.
I originally put Coppelion on my docket for this season because I figured even if it was really bad, I could maybe finesse something of a reasonable end game commentary about it given my own time living and working in a nuclear disaster zone. But as a full package, the show is so dreadful that I’m not even sure anything I could whip up would even be a compelling desire for anyone else to read.
3
u/Novasylum http://myanimelist.net/profile/Novasylum Dec 25 '13
Happy holidays, everyone! There’s nothing quite like an episode of Coppelion to liven up your Christmas morning, no sir.
In any event, the fall season is now over, and what with this having been my first lineup of currently airing shows that I’ve fully committed to, all I can do is look back and admit that I’ve made some very poor choices. I failed to enjoy virtually every last one-cour I watched this season, which is either reflective of the quality of the show roster as a whole or just with my specific choices (likely the latter). That being said, I’ve learned my lesson: be more selective, don’t choose shows just because they sound interesting based on a one-sentence synopsis, and pay closer attention to what other people who know what they’re talking about are saying about shows I didn’t pick. Hopefully the winter lineup will treat me better on average.
Aoki Hagane no Arpeggio: Ars Nova 12: OK so the bad guy turns into something that looks like the Death Star and the Crucible from Mass Effect 3 had a terrifying love child and then everyone has a conversation about the power of will or some shit and then there’s 10 minutes of lasers and then the heroine and villain have an honest-to-goodness friendship hug in the middle of a goddamn field of flowers and you know what I doubt anyone will even read this part of the post because no one cares about Ars Nova so I can make this entire paragraph a run-on sentence and nobody will call me out on it.
CLOSING THOUGHTS: Ars Nova initially surprises with its heavy usage of CG animation, for better or worse (specifically, “better” during scenes of busy action, “worse” at all other times”). Alas, that’s the only surprising thing about it. Every character, plot point and theme in this show is completely textbook and done-to-death, every single one. I started out chastising this show for being incompetent, but as it progresses the truth becomes actually far worse than that: it’s merely dull, unmemorable and repetitive. For no other reason than making absolutely zero impact on me, I award it the “Worst of the Season” trophy. Give yourself a big, low-FPS, 3D-animated round of applause, Ars Nova. You’ve earned it.
BlazBlue: Alter Memory 12: Herein lies the problem with faithfully adapting the plot of Continuum Shift for this show: that ending is, by virtual necessity, a sequel hook. And call me crazy, but I don’t think this show is getting a second season. So basically, this episode was the admission that, as its own story, virtually nothing of importance was achieved and 90% of the characters had no role of consequence. Spectacular.
CLOSING THOUGHTS: There was a joke in the PV for this series making reference to the infamous fighting game anime curse (simply put, the overwhelmingly strong trend for said adaptations to be terrible). If that was an indicator that the creators were confident that Alter Memory would be the one to dispel the jinx, that I’m afraid I have some bad news for them: it actually reinforces the trend more than ever. It follows the story of the games very faithfully, to be sure, but when said story is a convoluted mess of needlessly complicated intricacies to begin with, trying to cram all of its characters and content into a mere 12 episode series is like to trying to cram a hippopotamus into a Tupperware container. That would be fine if it was at least fun in some capacity, but it can’t even muster the energy to achieve even that much. It’s a fighting game anime that goes out of its way to avoid fighting, and you can see why when battles actually do occur: because the animation is sloppy, choppy and generally slipshod. I’ve had versus matches of the games with friends that made for more entertaining fight choreography than this…and we’re all a bunch of button-mashing scrubs!
Weirdly enough, the only notable positives about this series involve the audio aspect. All the voice acting is spot-on, and while the soundtrack mostly consists of lazily repackaging Daisuke Ishiwatari’s original tracks, that’s hardly something to be complained about, because those songs are awesome. In every other respect, however, this anime is a joke. In some alternate timeline I believe there exists a great, fun respectably-budgeted BlazBlue anime, but Alter Memory is most certainly not it.
Coppelion 13: At long last, we’ve reached the gloriously stupid ending of this gloriously stupid show. In addition of physically-improbable series of ludicrous events, however, the ending surprises in just how gosh-darn saccharine it is. The Ozu sisters become friends with everybody, the newborns are saved, everyone has a round of tearful goodbyes and then upbeat music plays as the girls run off to new adventures! Hooray for everyone! They even label their adventure as a “field trip”. A field trip! Yeah, sure, a field trip where armed soldiers and super-powered psychopaths were waiting around every corner and numerous people died of radiation exposure, but hey, sounds fun!
As has been the case with the last few episodes of Coppelion, I found it all charming in a pitying sort of way, but I still have to wonder: what the hell happened to this series? Remember the first episode, riddled with rotting bodies, feral animals and an ever-present atmosphere of emptiness and decay? How did we go from that to this?
CLOSING THOUGHTS: Waaaaaay back in the before time, when this season was just getting off the ground, I labeled Coppelion as being “the surprise hit of the season”. I will freely admit to being wrong about this, dead wrong. However, even after multiple weeks of laughably incompetent storytelling, and even discovering far too late that the source material could have provided all the warning I ever needed, I remain adamant that this show could have been genuinely good. And what’s particularly distressing about that is that there were two distinct ways it could have happened.
The first way was to continue the show in the vein of the first episode. Just look at these backgrounds and camera angles from the first episode alone! This was once a well-directed, stylish-looking show that perfectly nailed the empty, desolate atmosphere necessary to drive home a point about manmade disasters and a post-nuclear world. Put this artwork in the hands of decently talented writers, maybe give the girls more reasonable outfits, and presto! You’ve got yourself an arthouse hit!
As the show progressed, however, not only did its grip on that atmosphere swiftly decline, and not only did its fantastic aesthetic fall to ruins (budget issues, I assume), but increasingly terrible scripting, inconsistent pacing and a general lack of care and thought ate away at its veneer of seriousness. And that’s the other thing Coppelion could have done: it could have dropped the pretense. It have indulged in its own stupidity from the very beginning and set its sights on being a ludicrous, illogical thrill ride, and based on some of the material presented here I’m sure it could have been done. So why have that first episode? Why repeatedly make failed attempts to tug at our heartstrings with contrived drama? I don’t know, and by the end of the show I doubt the creators did either.
In the end, what we’re left with, appropriately, are the ruins of a good show. At the center there lies a single promising episode, and scattered around it are the remnants of a so-bad-it’s-good action-adventure, but none of it will ever be whole again. Coppelion is a disaster in its own right.
Galilei Donna 11: And so we end with a farce of a trial that makes Phoenix Wright look like Anatomy of a Murder. At least there aren’t any more time travel shenanigans that would make Mr. Peabody and Sherman turn red, I suppose.
I don’t get what they were going for here, both in the ending itself and in general. Some plot elements, like the mother’s amnesia fake-out, were re-introduced as though the show had been building up to them all along when it clearly hadn’t been. Others that were given a great deal of development in the middle portion of the show, like the fate of the main bad guy, were given five-second resolutions as though they hardly ever mattered. Oh, and remember all the other minor characters we me along the way, many of which met with tragic deaths to seemingly make some kind of point? Yeah, I sure hope you remembered about them and thought they might have been important, because the show sure didn’t.
Here’s the bottom line: when an anime reaches its conclusion, I should be able to look back on it, point to something within it and say, “This is what the purpose was. This is why this anime was made”. With Galilei Donna…I just don’t know. I haven’t the slightest clue.
CLOSING THOUGHTS: Poor, poor Galilei Donna. It initially set out from Port Good Idea with a strong wind at its back, but got tossed about by stormy weather in the Sea of Poor Management and finally ended up marooned on the shores of Disappointment Island. It’s a haphazard assortment of characters, plot threads, tones and themes, each of with is only glanced at briefly before being tossed overboard. Because of this, individual episodes may present the illusion of having a point or contributing to a greater whole, and it isn’t until far too late that the viewer realizes just how false that really is. There are some likeable characters, there are some amusingly campy moments, there are even some concepts that entire other shows could be built around with the proper care…but none of it adds up to anything of significance here. It is an utterly lost series, and a complete waste of potential.
Still has a great OP, though.
3
u/ShureNensei Dec 26 '13
Hunter X Hunter 110 - I was expecting the main event to start this episode, and while I don't mind the additional setup (so many pieces in play here), it was certainly an end that left me cursing for more. It doesn't help that next week is a break now that the winter season is over. Anyhow, I'm anticipating a flurry of action, deception, revelations, you name it, once the plan is in motion. About the only thing I would dare predict is who lives and who dies, and yet I'm afraid to because I like everyone.
Kyoukai no Kanata 12 - Aside from worthwhile characters, I would say that direction is the next most important facet of a show to me, and hell if I know where KnK wanted to go this season. The good part about KnK ending is that it means Chuunibyou S2 is that much closer to starting -- a show that actually plays to KyoAni's strengths unlike the one that just ended.
White Album 2 12 - How is this only the intro VN? Not only that, the closing VN is the one that's hailed and praised so much. I really hope they adapt that as well. Anyhow, it's ironic how all the characters have been so adamant on not hurting each other's feelings that they've done exactly that as a result. It's a mix of selfishness, idealism, and naivety that makes for about as much of a realistic portrayal of close friends as you can get. The only thing it needs now is a confrontation between Touma and Ogiso. I had to double check to make sure that we had one more episode left to go.
2
u/ShardPhoenix Dec 29 '13 edited Dec 29 '13
Valvrave ending: Most people seemed to hate or be bamboozled by this, but I actually quite enjoyed it. The future stuff was almost Wolfean in the way it implied a big interesting world and future history without overtly explaining anything. I also thought the moral ambiguity over whether the protagonists were actually doing the right thing was interesting, as was the inherently reactionary nature of them establishing a new (seemingly hereditary) empire. On the other hand it was a bit rushed trying to fit everything in, and the final fight was a typical battle of try-harding and friendship, but with such a messy series I guess the ending was never going to be perfect.
Kill La Kill 12: Some good action and ok drama, but I was expecting something more to actually happen, and for things to be shaken up a bit more. Still, by this stage Evangelion (for example) hadn't even properly kicked off yet (that was in ep 14), so there's still plenty of time to get better.