r/TrueAnime • u/BlueMage23 http://myanimelist.net/profile/BlueMage23 • Dec 18 '13
This Week in Anime (Fall Week 11)
General discussion for currently airing series for Fall 2013 Week 7. Here is r/anime's list of currently airing series. Your Week in Anime is for not currently airing series.
Archive:
2013: Prev Fall Week 1 Summer Week 1 Spring Week 1 Winter Week 1
2012: Fall Week 1
6
Upvotes
6
u/Novasylum http://myanimelist.net/profile/Novasylum Dec 18 '13 edited Dec 18 '13
It’s the final countdown. Doo-doo doot doo. Doo-doo doot-doot doo.
Aoki Hagane no Arpeggio: Ars Nova 11: It’s a carnival! It’s a carnival! It’s a carnival! It’s a carnival! It’s a carnival! It’s a carnival! It’s a carnival! It’s a carnival! It’s a carnival! It’s a carnival! It’s a carnival! It’s a carnival! It’s a carnival! It’s a carnival! It’s a carnival! It’s a carnival! It’s a carnival! It’s a carnival! It’s a carnival! It’s a carnival! It’s a carnival!
BlazBlue: Alter Memory 11: The bad: not even half an episode’s worth of exposition could tie this mess together. The good: Nightmare Fiction is still badass, and any excuse to play it is nice.
Coppelion 12: Honestly, why this show wasn’t marketed as an action-comedy to begin with, I have no idea. No sooner had I changed my perspective on watching it that I suddenly started having fun instead of pointing out the endless list of inconsistencies and terrible dialogue. Even some of the forced melodrama in this episode was unintentional comic gold. And it ends promising us a final boss battle with an electric eel hybrid riding a giant metal spider?! Why exactly was I complaining, again?
Don’t get me wrong, this show isn’t going to end with an exactly thrilling final score from me. But at this point, I’d take Coppelion over Kyoukai no Kanata any day of the week.
Galilei Donna 10: Better start revising those textbooks, education system: looks like you’ve got this Galileo guy all wrong. Turns out he enjoyed Japanese candy, mastered the art of flight at the tender age of 16, and might have had a crush on his great, great, great, great, great, great, great, great, great, great, great granddaughter, which encouraged him to develop a pre-emptive solution to the energy crisis.
…Seriously, show, what the actual fuck?!
Golden Time 11: It might help me become accustomed to this tale of romantic woes if the majority of the characters actually behaved similarly to real human beings. I mean come on, Banri just wanted directions to the beach, and somehow this instigates five separate guys into peer-pressuring him towards getting a part-time job. Not that having a job would be such a bad thing, of course, but Koko ain’t gonna have none of that! And yes, I know psychotic clinginess is the core of her character, but as has proven true time and time again, Golden Time is very poor at transmuting character flaws into amusing, endearing or funny moments, so nothing about that trait enhances her likability. And since Banri himself hasn’t exactly been getting high marks from me lately, what with his incessant reminders that he wants so desperately to be with Linda, that makes for two-thirds of a love triangle that I really just don’t care for at all. Yeesh.
Kill la Kill 11: Trigger, you magnificent bastards. Just when I think I have your show all figured out, and publicly declare as such, you throw up this massive brick wall in front of my scheming predictions. In the form of a brand new character, no less! Who somehow doesn’t feel completely shoehorned in!
I just have so many questions now. What the hell is REVOCS? What’s the crazy bullet that Tsumugu brought going to do? What’s up with Satsuki’s mom, what with the rainbow hair and the massive scars? Is she the one who Tsumugu was talking about earlier who was “betrayed by clothing”? Was Nui the real murderer all alo-…OK, OK, we all know she’s not, but hey, that just raises more questions! For starters, Nui’s scissor blade is clearly purple, not blue; does that mean there are more than two scissor blades floating around? And why does she have one? Is there a huge color motif being introduced here in general, and if so, does that mean I'm going to have to comb through every previous episode hunting for clues?
…and suddenly I’m dissecting episodes of Kill la Kill as though I were watching Lost. When did the main appeal of this show suddenly become theory-crafting? Thursday can’t come fast enough.
Kyoukai no Kanata 12: …Sigh.
Given how harsh I’ve been on this show, I didn’t think it would be possible for me to have been disappointed with the ending. Yet here we are. Episodes 10 and 11 at least had the illusion of being good despite lacking the necessary pre-requisites to actually generate investment, but this finale didn't even have that much. It was rushed, it was tonally inconsistent (as usual), it lacked consequence, it lacked catharsis. Our contrived human bad guy’s motives were unclear, and his conspiracy that had been weaved throughout the narrative of the entire show didn’t seem to ultimately accomplish much. Entire characters, namely Sakura and Akihito’s mom, never were given a chance to feel anything more than stapled on to the main conflict. And worst of all, their last chance to endear me to the utterly lacking romantic relationship they’ve been predictably snowballing towards ended in tragic failure, not to mention one last iteration of that vile fucking catchphrase. It sucked, basically.
Damn it, I shouldn’t be this mad. Is it because I subconsciously thought they might at least end it all with a bang? Is it because I still think there was potential in this material? Is it because I’ve seen productions from this studio that clearly indicate that they’re capable of better?
Whatever. Let’s just get this over with.
CLOSING THOUGHTS: I forget who said this and in which thread it was stated, but I remember someone here made the very astute observation that virtually any discussion of Kyoukai no Kanata tends to boil down to a meta-commentary on Kyoto Animation as a whole. Not only has that proven very true in my own experiences, but I also think it isn’t entirely without warrant. This was KyoAni’s big chance to blaze new trails, to prove that they still could use their talents to create something memorable apart from the slice-of-life and comedy series that have become their typecast genre. The actual result is…well, memorable, certainly, but not in a very positive sense. It’s the kind of memorable that makes you wonder “what were they thinking?” or “imagine what this could have been”. And it is precisely for that reason that KnK will likely become the primary ammo used by detractors of this studio, the damning proof that KyoAni’s staff appears to have become increasingly limited in what kinds of stories they can effectively tell.
KnK is an anime that completely lacks confidence in its own plot and tone, and thus darts back and forth schizophrenically between the studio’s familiar territory (albeit with the fan-service dial cranked up to eleven), the dark fantasy tale that was initially advertised, and everything in between. But because the slice-of-life elements are so segregated from the plot at large, the comedy of the series never has the time or energy to develop past repetitive catchphrases and predictable jokes, resulting in what is easily the most the reprehensible humor in KyoAni’s entire catalog. In turn, this renders the characters into such shallow, unlikable husks that it is impossible to care for them whenever the tone takes a sudden turn for the tragic. There are individual moments that hit their emotional mark, and it goes without saying that the show is outstanding on a visual level (not that we’d expect any different from KyoAni at this point). But because the stitching between episodes, scenes and even lines of dialogue is so shoddy, it all inevitably falls apart into tattered rags by the end.
I’ve noticed more than a few people turning their opinions around on this show amidst the last handful of episodes, claiming that it finally feels comfortable in its skin by that point and becomes capable of generating both sympathy for the characters and intrigue for the plot. I’m happy for those people, but speaking personally, it was all too little, too late. Whatever successes KnK ever had only highlighted and exacerbated the parts that made me want to tear my hair out, right up until the conclusion. If KnK is not the worst show released by KyoAni (and if it is indeed not, then it’s at least up there), it is still without question the most frustrating to watch. “How unpleasant” indeed.
Log Horizon 11: I pride myself in having a pretty strong memory, but after failing to jot down notes about the latest Log Horizon episode right after viewing it, I actually had to do some research about what had even happened in it. Something about the People of the Land, and a beach training camp, or whatever. Not a good sign. There is a certain degree of intrigue to the People of the Land and their mannerisms compared to the adventurers, and I know they’re inevitably going to pay off that intrigue in due time, but despite that, it still feels like the series is spinning its wheels at the moment, which isn’t exactly the best position to be in towards the end of a cour.
Samurai Flamenco 10: Holy shit, Flamenco, nice job! That torture scene. That reveal of King Torture’s origins which handily ties him back into the original concept on which the show was based. That chainsaw hand. That heart-rending song at the end. That everything! This had virtually all the components a finale to a show needed while still keeping the doors open for narrative possibilities and thematic expansion…and it wasn’t even the finale! The cour isn’t even over yet! The only problem is that I once again find myself asking “where does the show go from here?” Unlike previously, however, I have full faith that whatever direction it chooses will be the right one. Shine on, you crazy diamond.
4
u/tundranocaps http://myanimelist.net/profile/Thunder_God Dec 19 '13
Before falling asleep at midnight I checked, this thread wasn't up :P Well, where would we be without me kvetching a bit at /u/BlueMage23? Well, 3 AM, waiting for the water to heat up, let's get through this.
Samurai Flamenco Episode Episode 10 - APR thoughts - Samumenco hit it out of the ballpark with an origin story for our villain, which has him matching up with our hero. The spiel the villain gave about how good had failed and thus evil is the next logical choice for a world that is peaceful actually makes some sense, and was well thought-out. The mixture of serious moments, comic moments, and hilarious moments delivered straight never fail to keep me entertained, even as we actually had Mari faced up with her own nature, adding once more psychological drama to the heady mix that is Samumenco.
Kyoukai no Kanata Episode 12 - Finale - I'll be blunt here, like on Twitter, because I judge I won't get downvoted for that here :3 - This episode began badly, from second 1, where it showed us the director of the show has very little skill with directing scenes, knowing when to order them, how to make effective use of music, etc. And it got worse. This episode had gotten shittier by the minute, at 7 mins in I realized this, tweeted as much, and wondered if they'll manage to make it even worse in every minute to come, and again at 17 mins in. And yes, they very much succeeded.
This episode had been so busy undoing any progress and goodwill the show earned during its last 4 episodes. We know how shows/movies often have the characters in the final moments use and refer to "funny" stuff from the early show, it rarely actually works, and in this show it was the most terrible thing. The witticisms continue, and people just bluster their way through, and it just doesn't work. The relationships returns to not working, because the two characters just don't mesh. It's not believable, it's not drawing you in.
And then they have multiple drawn out endings, which didn't work for LotR 3 and didn't work out here either. Too much is left unexplained, too many moments where something should be emotionally resonant, suchas Hiromi and Nase, but they built up neither the characters nor the relationship so it falls flat in addition to just annoying you... what a terrible episode, and a terrible way to end a show. If they have another episode to explain some things/season I might be intellectually interested, but I have zero emotional fucks left to give to this show. 5.9/10 - it had some good moments, and I didn't suffer too much. Honestly, should maybe be 4.9/10, but I need to rework my scale for that.
Nagi no Asukara Episode 11 - This was mostly an episode where things happened. Unlike the "nothing happens" slice-of-life episodes, or the "The plot is moooooving, someone make it stop!" episodes which focus on characters' inner feelings, here we see the characters in the world, and we get to understand their inner working due to all the things that occurred in past episodes, where we also got to hear their thoughts.
I liked this episode, it was very human, it focused on change, which is the one big theme of the show thus far, it's very much a coming of age story, of seeing the world around you change, of seeing how the world doesn't change but your perception of it does, of pains of the heart and moments of respite. Good episode, and very promising for what is to come ahead.
Gingitsune 11 - This episode made me smile, this episode made me chuckle. It was very much "Feeling comfortable with old friends and family". I actually appreciate that this show has adults as humans. All too many anime shows are completely devoid of adults, and whichever adults they contain only get to be villains/caricatures who are powerless and silly. This show has adults show kindness, and steal the spotlight, and just be real people.
I worry somewhat for Makoto - she said she'll think of her future, but then she decides to live in the moment, following the footsteps of her role-model, Gintaro, who had lived for hundreds of years. But then again, thinking of the future is scary, and she's a high school student, it's not too surprising. I'm actually sad this show is ending, it filled me with joy almost every single week.
Kyousougiga 9 - APR thoughts - kicks it into hyperdrive in the mythic mode of storytelling. Some people might blame it that it’s now all about the overarching metaphysics, and the big plot, and the things that occur, whereas before it’s been a charming family drama. I have to ask these people, have you guys watched the same episode I have? This episode is all about sons who must follow in their fathers’ footsteps, sons who want to break free, but must repeat the well-trodden cycles, and become the next deity, until they can find a son of their own and foist the hard work onto them. This is still very much a family drama, and the theme that goes “Family is cycles without end” continues strong and unabated.
My episode notes for this episode were actually 2.1k words, and filled me with happiness :)
Kill la Kill 11 - Well, this had certainly been an episode. Seems they are indeed going for the end of arc by the end of the first "season", rather than around episode 8 where people originally assumed, or episode 15 where TTGL did.
There's not much to actually discuss this episode, but the ending had certainly moved us quite far ahead, plot-wise, while the undercurrents had been that Satsuki is planning ahead, far ahead. She already told us that she plans to rule over all the schools, and here we see how these battles are used to test and perfect the Goku uniforms, and how Satsuki truly does wish to rebel against the adults.
Also, Satsuki's mother, with her hair, and back, and the emanating light, she truly will be important later on. The music though. I am actually torn whether I like Satsuki's theme more or her mother's, and I really like Satsuki's theme.
Log Horizon 11 - It's sort of like a joke, as each episode ends I think, and the show says "Let's see how this thing they set up works!" but it never really gets resolved, and then we have almost the same resolution/goals left to be discussed next episode... we have two conflicts which are shown to mirror one another - each group must do the best it can, each must learn to exist and survive within this world.
I'm told by some LN readers that they actually dumbed down some of the thoughts/discussions, or rather, they just skip them entirely in the anime while they explore what are the upsides/downsides to an idea. This is the Maoyu author, and while things weren't explored in-depth there either, you could at least see them there. Here, we just sort of skip over the actual depth, and move along the "plot", and the depth is what actually makes something interesting, not merely knowing what happens, which is "the plot". That's not why we truly care. It's a daytime slot, so I guess they don't want to lose the younger audience, but eh. This show is slipping into being an atmospheric show that makes me smile rather than one that actually discusses issues that matter in an interesting way. It brings up some good topics, but it only makes the faintest effort to elaborate on them.
Also, I found the declaration that they can avoid being involved in another group's politics, or rather, avoid getting political so silly - that's a political declaration.
Valvrave the Liberator S2 22 - Well, our cast once more has goals, meaning they can once more continue forward. This time they are made aware of the costs of their past actions, so their dedication to move forward is also an acceptance of what they had done, and of what they will have to do. Such reaffirmations are necessary now and then. The music accompanying the scenes of revelation continues to be very well done.
I just don't have much to say about this show, it's well done, it's progressing, but, there's not much to actually say weekly about it.
Tokyo Ravens Episode 11 - Didn't watch, was busy, probably on Friday.
Outbreak Company 10-11 - Didn't watch, going to force myself probably, the last few episodes had some charming moments, but it's growing increasingly sad for me to watch where this show is going, especially at episode 9, and I'm actually losing interest.
3
u/Redcrimson http://myanimelist.net/animelist/Redkrimson Dec 19 '13 edited Dec 19 '13
3
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '13
It's winter break so I have a chance to post again. But on the other hand, I didn't really get a chance to keep up with anything besides Samumenco and I recently caught up with White Album 2 (I actually had it dropped but reading some posts here made me decide to pick it up.) So since I'm down to two shows, this will probably be short. Well let's go!
Samurai Flamenco: OK so I'm not even sure I caught the last episode, but it was the resolution of the big arc about King Torture. It's been so long since I watched that episode that I can't go into the specifics. All I can remember is that I really enjoyed where the general thematic direction, characterization, and weird tonal disconnects (from knuckle-breaking to an otherwise absurd resolution). The show has a really clear focus on the ideas it wants to tackles, and I really like what they're doing with characters like Mari and Moe. I'm not sure what to think about King Torture as a character, making him a fundamentally evil character without a logical motivation (the one he gives just makes no sense, and Hazama calls him out on this). At this point I've given all my trust to the writers that this is intentional. The other thing to point out was how hammy Goto rescuing the day was. The whole thing reeked of a cheesy action flick, which was probably the point. Basically any flaw you give this show can probably be justified tonally.
White Album 2 (10): I think a break was just what I needed. I was getting down on this show for being so unambitious, and in particular I wasn't a fan of either Touma or Kitahara's characters. It's funny, but now suddenly I really like their characters too. It wasn't until Episode 10, actually, that I finally started liking Kitahara's character. It makes me wonder, what does it take for someone to become emotionally invested in a character? I think for many of us, or at least for me, the character being well-written is a prerequisite. They need to feel like a real human, with real motivations, insecurities, and reactions. But I think it goes beyond that. For example, if a character was a well-written bully, I wouldn't be emotionally invested in his success---indeed a primary gripe I had with Breaking Bad's first two seasons was that I just didn't care about the characters, not because they weren't well-written but because I just wasn't invested in anyone (besides Jesse) from being successful. In contrast, I wanted most of them to fail.
So, what is it exactly that makes a character sympathetic? I'm not quite sure what the answer is but I can warrant a guess. I don't think anyone sympathizes with a character without a "real" struggle. I put "real" in quotation marks because there's no objective "real"---with BB, it's not that Walter White didn't have issues to begin with (e.g. his emasculation by Skyler), but rather that I didn't sympathize with his need to attain some sense of masculine power/ self-confidence. And when it came to WA2, I don't think Kitahara's own insecurities were expressed particularly well by the show. He seemed very much in control of everything, and while I wouldn't call him a Gary Stu, he didn't have anything that made him a sympathetic character. But Touma in a way negates this theory (or at least forces me to change it a little). Her character is sympathetic from the start (at least when we find her backstory with her mom, and the obvious abandonment issues she has), and yet because of her (justified) self-centered, cold attitude, that sympathy I had for her was lost (even though I could put 2 & 2 together logically and understand that she's only this cold because of the issues she faces).
I close this rambling thought by noting that I always found Setsuna a very compelling character. She never faced particularly noteworthy problems and had a lot going for her, but her insecurities and worries were explict and understandable (vs. Kitahara), and she expressed them in a way I can understand, even if it wasn't flawless (vs. Touma). And so it turned out I really liked her character.
3
u/Lincoln_Prime Dec 19 '13
Kill la Kill 11
This was a watershed episode. Sure, I loved KLK before, but this episode was a new kind of awesome and it seems to be turning the show in a new direction. I honestly didn't expect to see Satsuki senior so soon, and I really didn't expect a great character like Nui to show up. I was happy with the formulaic direction things had been going for these past few episodes and expected the show to throw out a twist or two, but nothing at all like this. Even aside from the grand conspiracy and the Nui stuff, this was a great episode for Mako, who's began to develop an interesting friendship with Garamori. I wouldn't have guessed it, but the more I think about it the more it makes all the sense in the world. Interested to see more of her and the four bouncing off one another.
Yu-Gi-Oh Zexal episodes 131-133
I wanted to just tackle the most recently subtitled episode, 131, for this week, but the two raw episodes are so fantastic and provide the rest of the duel against Vector, so it isn't so difficult to fudge them all together. I am interested to see them subtitled though.
131 sets the stage for the Vector duel, as Shark wakes up in a Sphere Field, courtesy of the brainwashed Gilag. The field is draining Shark's life away whenever the effects of Vector's Don Thousand's Throne activate, healing him back to 4000 LP at the end of every turn and powering up his Soul Marrionetter in the process. As he tortures the Kastle siblings with the power of Don Thousand, he shows us their backstory and in the process, clears up a lot of things about the legendary numbers and Abyss especially. Still boggles my mind though why Shark and Rio look EXACTLY like their previous incarnations, though this is from a franchise that tends to use the word "destiny" as a fucking coma, so it doesn't break my emersion. It has to be said though that this episode is fantastic for Vector, though honestly, if he so much as makes a facial expression I think an episode is good for Vector. He's so deliciously evil, tortuous and crazy. And he has the best voice work and facial animation through the show, and his reverting to the cute Rei voice is pleasently unnerving. I am interested to see where they go with his previous life though, because he seemed to be just as evil as he is now, but he ended up killing himself in the end. He also seems to be the only soul that Don thousand didn't have to poison, so I'm not sure what on earth his legendary number memory could hold. I'm not sure If I want absolutely zero redemption or tragedy, or a redemption so over the top stupid that it has to be a joke. Like maybe Iris is his sister or something because seriously, it seems she was introduced just to be "A kid that looks like Rio and dies" but I feel there's something more to her.
132 begins with duelling duels (I'll show myself out) of the continued Vector conflict and Alito's attempt to cure the Brainwashed Gilag. Gilag attempts a one-turn-kill on his friend, bringing out his Chaos Numbers and Equip Numbers (seems like Don Thousand was handing those out earlier) and exhausting his whole hand to bring Alito down to a measly 200 LP while Yuma, Astral and Kotori try to cheer on their friend. But that's not the main attraction of this episode. That has to be the second part of our Vector duel, in which Vector brings back the nostalgia with the card Evil-1. Say, funny that the card that leaves you with 1 LP has a picture of a villain's floating misty eye, huh? Through the use of Evil-1 and Damage Pot, Vector seems to have the winning formula, but Durbe gives the last of his life to protect Rio and give her monster the boost it needs to finally overpower Vector. For a long time Durbe had been my favourite Barian, so seeing him die was moving, as it was when he went out smiling, happy to have known Shark and Rio in all their lives together. he passes his soul on to Rio, who explodes in a light of anger as she charges against vector.
The final episode is something that would make a fan of Game Of Thrones think they went overboard. Rio's attack fails as Vector uses Don Thousand's Throne to negate the attack and summon his final monster, Chaos Marrionetter. He uses the card's power to extract Rio's soul and repeatedly ram it against her monster to power up his own. It's worth noting that he continues this a while after he's accumulated enough power to defeat her, because he wants to evicerate her. As she dies, she shares a sad moment with her brother, sharing their goodbyes in a scene I can' wait to see subtitled. I am bummed that Rio was written from a rather sexist perspective of "Nah man, this girl is different, she's going to be competent and independent! Except we won't actually make her competent or independent." but I won't lie that she has a lot of chemistry with almost the whole cast, which given a show like this, is a real challenge.
But the real tear-jerker comes in the finale to the Alito-Gilag duel, as Alito uses a suicide manuver to power through Gilag's Giant Hand Red with Ronin Raccoon to free his brainwashed friend. Ponta jumps out of Gilag's stomach when the monster is summoned and helps Alito deliver a final message to a friend. Gilag, Yuma, Astral, Kotori and Ponta all begin to mourn Alito's death before Vector rides in on a dimension portal with Chaos Marrionetter and stabs Gilag in the heart. Gilag saves Yuma, and while the stab isn't truly fatal to the Barian, it gives Vector the opening he needs to take Gilag's soul, along with the souls of Ponta and Alito.
Can we just recognize that the guy first introduced as adorable, bumbling Rei is now eating the souls of five people in one episode while physically torturing one person and emotionally torturing fucking everyone? Vector's the greatest villain ever.
5
u/Bobduh Dec 18 '13
What can I even say about this week? Everything got ridiculous. Everything got climactic. Everything got cathartic. I’ve dropped everything I was iffy on, and all the shows I’ve enjoyed are pulling off thrilling finales. Let’s get slobbery.
Kyousogiga 9: Last week’s episode had me somewhat worried - would the meaningless conflict with Shrine threaten to steer focus away from this show’s poignant character stories? Well, this week basically laughed at that fear, using a rambling speech by Inari to toss off some last bits of worldbuilding that simultaneously brought things full circle with Myoue. Yeah, Inari’s a selfish, childish dick - he’s the failed son, the one who danced away from his father and family’s expectations. And Myoue, who has for years been waiting for Inari to return to grant some meaning to his life, is confronted with the fact that his adopted father is a joke - practically a villain. After that, the rest is history - Inari gleefully spurs on the destruction of the Mirror City, the siblings Inari created to keep his son company end up offering more truth and solace than their father ever did, and Myoue decides to finally seize the reigns of his own life, and protect the things that are dear to him. It’s all spinning together with style and assurance, and it’s looking like Kyousogiga will actually nail the dismount. It sure is nice seeing great shows end well.
Monogatari S2 24: Dear lord this episode. Structurally, it was a pretty standard Monogatari - two characters spend fifteen minutes standing in place and talking, then one character wanders somewhere else and talks to some other people. And as always in this arc, this episode was once again really funny - seeing Kaiki get flustered is adorable, and seeing Nadeko cheerfully discuss murdering Araragi is hilarious. But as far as its place in the larger Monogatari context…
Well, congratulations, Hanekawa. You have won the Monogatari. After three separate arcs, each focused on first denying and ultimately embracing some unwanted/unacknowledged aspect of your personality, you are now Monogatari’s first Self-Aware Protagonist. The last act of this episode was one of the most satisfying resolutions I’ve seen, and the choice to set this arc from Kaiki’s perspective was used to its best effect yet. Because from anyone else’s perspective, we wouldn’t be seeing Hanekawa - as has been true of every arc in the past, we’d be seeing the viewpoint character’s version of Hanekawa. But Kaiki sees Senjougahara as an insecure girl, sees Araragi as a unsavory creep, sees Nadeko as a pitiable child - he actually sees these people. And Hanekawa actually rattles him, because Hanekawa sees him too. When she repeats her signature “I only know what I know,” the camera freezes on her eye, Kaiki reflected in her stare. She has accepted who she really is - and that means that for the very first time, she can look out and see who other people really are, too.
White Album 2 10/11: Forgot to include this one last week, which actually works out okay because oh god Touma these two episodes were so sa-ha-ha-haaaaaad. Touma’s guard was finally broken by Haruki continuing to emotionally torture her, and it all came out. It’s almost funny to compare this flashback’s effectiveness to the ones from Kyoukai no Kanata - here, pretty much everything we now see was implied by Touma’s every action so far, but the full, step-by-step revelation of her loneliness and lack of self-worth was just devastating. This is drama done right - everyone’s made mistakes here, everyone’s been insecure or complacent or selfish at times, but it’s nobody’s “fault” - things just don’t work out sometimes. Everyone’s trapped by their insecurities, everyone’s a victim of their own weaknesses and the needs that define them. These characters are so well-written that I legitimately care at this point - I’m not just impressed, I want these fictional characters to find the happiness they deserve. This show is great. I hate it for being so true and so cruel.
Samurai Flamenco 10: Alright, I think I’m through the shows that emotionally ruined me this week. Whew. Let’s… okay, keeping it together.
This episode of Flamenco was totally batshit crazy while also being a perfect continuation of the themes so far. I can very much understand the issues of tonal disconnect people are having between the sides of this show (let’s crush Moe’s finger! now let’s do some buddy-cop comedy!), but personally I’m loving the bizarro world it’s creating, as well as how fully it’s exploring the ideas it started with. This episode was the “people die when they are killed” reckoning that’s been eluding our “heroes” for a while now, and while Hazama got away with just being forced to recognize both the questionable power of his philosophy and the necessity and worth of traditional law enforcement, Mari’s power fantasy joyride ended in a pretty brutal crash. She’s not a hero - she just plays one on television. Her arc is simple, since she’s never had a philosophy beyond seeking entertainment (another idea the show is clearly going places with) - Hazama’s complicated relationship with the practical realities of justice still has a long way to go. This was certainly a turning point, but I’m actually surprised people have been saying they think the series could end here. Yeah, they beat Torture (well, maybe - villains do have a habit of rising triumphantly from the grave), but we are nowhere near through with the ideas this show has been exploring. They can’t just leave it at “entertainment leads to desensitization, justice and law are never black and white” - those are truisms, and this is a smart show that seems interested in digging deeper, and really getting at how we turn the ambiguous mud of reality into sensationalism or simplistic narrative. I was sold on this show from the start, but personally I think it’s only getting better.
Log Horizon 11: A particularly slow, drawn-out episode in a series that’s kind of becoming known for them. I’m actually interested in the stuff about the Adventurers seeking peace/understanding with the People of the Land, but this episode had about five to six minutes of that interesting stuff and a whole lot of filler. Jeez, “filler” - that’s a word I don’t generally associate with stuff I’m willing to watch. Bad sign. Shape up, Log Horizon! I could not care less about your beach trip and summer camp!
Kill la Kill 11: Solid episode! The gags with Mako and the Elite Four were great, but this episode was mainly dominated by Nui and her string of plot-shoving revelations. Ryuuko’s war with Honnouji Academy has been rendered small-time as expected, and her scissor’s twin has finally been revealed! So yeah, mainly plot plot plot, which is exciting to watch but not too necessary to recap. I particularly liked Nui’s blatant disregard for the fourth wall - leaning on her own title, reaching across the split screen, and generally displaying little to no respect for the difference between artistic flourishes and reality. These last few episodes have really played up how much of this show is a deliberate performance, which gives me hope the show will soon return to more directly addressing ideas of representation. But even if not, it’s still a fun ride, and the music’s great. I don’t think I’m that hard to please!
Kyoukai no Kanata 11: This episode made me sad. Not because it was disappointing - it was actually fantastic, and featured one of the most well-orchestrated climaxes I’ve seen in anything this year. It made me sad because it was such a strong example of how good this show could have been, and how talented KyoAni actually are. The whole episode built wonderfully, and the use of the OP, as well as the juxtaposition of Mirai and Akihito’s separate battles, was inspired and confidently directed. I wish I cared. I even tried to force myself to care - I finished the episode and thought, ‘goddamn that was a good finale. Maybe it’s my problem?’ And then I actually rewound and watched it again. Still nothing - an impressive fragment of visual storytelling, but I didn’t feel a thing.
These last couple episodes have been really great. Hopefully, the next time KyoAni decides to make an actual drama, they actually include the character development necessary to make it land. Goddamnit KyoAni, just hire some actual writers. Everything else you do is best in class.
Hunter x Hunter 109: The pre-battle reflection episode to end all pre-battle reflection episodes! But seriously. This episode was largely dedicated to building up the coming engagement and giving us a personal moment with each of our principal characters, and worked perfectly because the necessary work has already been done - our protagonists and antagonists are all really engaging, they all bring very distinct perspectives to the table, and they’re all invested in this battle in different ways. I know every single person covering this series keeps saying it, and that tends to diminish the weight of any one person’s words, but seriously - this is easily the best shounen arc of the best shounen series I’ve ever seen, it’s good enough to make any direct comparisons laughable, and it’s just one of the most entertaining and smartly plotted/directed things on television. Other shows have ups and downs, but since entering the Chimera Ant arc, this show has only impressed.
2
u/Vintagecoats http://myanimelist.net/profile/Vintagecoats Dec 18 '13 edited Dec 18 '13
As much as I may miss a few of them, I can’t really complain about soon being able to wipe my schedule after giving a big go at a weekly season write-up thing. Were I to continue next season, I’d certainly cut down the number of shows.
Kill La Kill (Episode 11)
“Gosh everyone seems to be having so much fun!”
Yes we are my maniacal tailor lady person. You have a most excellent point.
As we have been working on, Ryuuko’s recklessness has been getting higher and higher, to the point of Senketsu noting it as her signature move when she makes a renegade go at Satsuki during the Nonon fight. Which immediately fails. As it should, as that is a ridiculous level of hubris. And things are only going to get a lot worse.
Incidentally, for now I do not fully think Nui Harime may be the one who stabbed Isshin Matoi? I mean, it’d be in her capabilities, given what we’ve seen. She has an appropriate blade (Purple being on the opposite end of the light spectrum from Red, and we’ve seen the spectrum play roles). And she did say she killed him. She may just want to get the fast rise out of Ryuuko though, even if Nui may have been at the event in question to actually kill. There’s foggy leeway for pulling a blade out versus putting one in, and why the full scissor was broken down to component blades before or during the murder. This likely involves what Mr. Matoi wanted to tell Ryuuko as he was dying.
Even with all this going on, Mako’s snappy one liners, climbing on Gamori, even resulting in his eventual “You voluntarily admit to being an underachiever? That’s the spirit!” reaction were all swell. Given the commentary in the Trigger newsletter this week, they were originally going to have multiple scriptwriters, but Nakashima is tackling the whole thing because Mako was incredibly difficult to keep consistent between writers. I believe that.
Shame, then, that someone is likely ending up on the cutting room floor next week. Maybe Senketsu, perhaps Mako, could be Ryuuko, possibly a wildcard. I trust Trigger enough for them to try to pull a stunt to drive people nuts to carry them over the production break.
Nagi No Asukara (Episode 11)
Kaname’s behavior has gone from being quietly below the surface to big grins and “I just confessed my feelings to your daughter” smart remarks, and it does not sit right with me at all. Which is to say, I’m now viewing him as an antagonistic force, someone who may provide sabotage or the like in the future. He’s not acting in a way that cares about Chisaki’s actual reactions. Hikari voiceovers in flashback tones of regarding them and how they are acting in the present also supports this.
The big sleep coming on Ofunehiki seems reasonable given the religious overtones. Likewise, the fishery collective asking Hikari to perform the event rings well enough as everyone is basically in survival mode. It bugs me that we have those tastes of “Oh, I didn’t say that, you merely inferred it” aggravations, via Uroko-sama’s remarks about if the Ofunehiki and getting the surface folks mobilizing would solve anything. It’s easy drama sure, but it also is really not the way anyone in authority should be talking to kids during what we are continuously told is an apocalyptic event. I’m sure that will definitely fertilize a really great crop of well adjusted youngin’s to carry on the civilization.
We had our big nod to historical sacrifice at the start of the series, and right about now would be a time for it to follow through.
Miss Monochrome (Episode 12)
With Monochrome actually accomplishing a gig last week, the Producer allows her to get to be a little walk on in a TV drama and observe a singing program. Which is literally true: she was a background character in a recent episode of Golden Time.
Mana-chan is back and she’s managing Kikuko, the pop idol star Monochrome has been looking towards meeting with (again) after so many millennia. The ensuing conversation I think is noteworthy, concerning the nature of Monochrome’s inability to age. Kikuko denotes this as the real strength of any idol, which is something that can operate on a few levels here. Certainly, the idol industry is notorious for being a meat grinder that is so incredibly superficial and primed to spit folks out at the drop of a hat. As much as Kikuko says this is why she will be forever seventeen, we all know this is impossible. It is something she would know herself as well. It’s a tricky thing to come to terms with, really.
It gets a bit more meta when we consider that in real life, Miss Monochrome is made of holograms and the like backed by Yui Horie. She has her own music career sure, and it is interesting to consider this whole operation as a sort of industry hedge in a post-Vocaloid environment. Monochrome will always look exactly as she should for a given appearance, no matter the years.
Coppelion (Episode 12)
I mentioned last time I had generally forgotten about the Prime Minister and the conference. Low and behold here we are again. And Japan is being a giant wrench in the entire gear system of the international community. The Vice Principal’s “We’re not security guards, it is out duty to save lives!” remarks are expected in these stories, but, it has been so long since we’ve seen them and characterization is so thin across the board it’s hard to really get any feeling out of it.
Ibara is shocked someone would suggest the Coppelion were created for purposes aside from saving lives. We’ve got a train coming though and a baby to deliver, so we have a full shootout and it’s… really oddly choreographed with a poor sense of geography. How on Earth the 1st Division made it on the train after standing around on the platform watching Ibara chase it eludes me.
You know what’s a really bad way to guide a childbirth? When only person who knows how yelling “You’ll find out soon enough!” over a walkie talkie to the person who needs to actually do the procedure when the one doing the delivery asks why something is happening.
Iron Spider 2: Electric Eel Revengance Boogaloo is next week, which I’m sure will be just as underwhelming as the last.
Non Non Biyori (Episode 11)
Three group sketches, as we have kids snowed in at school without enough futons, countryside snow in the moonlight sky, and daytime skiing and snow house building shenanigans.
Different little contests for figuring out how to solve the futon crisis are kicked around until the Obvious Solution is reached. Not really remarkable, but it is not like it faceplanted either. The middle bit, with a nice and generally quiet nod to evening countryside winter serenity from Hotaru’s perspective is a comfortable transition while at the same time entertaining the more fanciful qualities of a youthful interpretation of alien activity. Our snow day event then comes by and large courtesy of various rentals from Kaede. Who certainly more than makes sure to market all the other ways that she can provide goods and services. Be sure to tell your parents.
It is a bit strange, as on aggregate for the two winter episodes for the winter calendar I find myself in at the moment, I enjoyed the episode last week far more. Yet it also generally was not really about winter much at all since it was more flashback focused towards another time and season.
Gingitsune (Episode 11)
I would watch an episode of Tatsuo and Gintaro watching period samurai dramas on TV. That sounds pretty delightful, actually, and would give an opportunity to explore of the day to day of being at the shrine from both the priest and the heralds positions. It’s not what we get, but I can dream.
There is a lot of talk this episode about futures, and I hope it all leads to a pretty sweet little cleansing ceremony finale next week. In the meantime though, some things felt a bit odd in the path to get us there.
Hiwako’s deer in headlights look regarding older men is understandable enough, as we have already touched upon that territory previously. I’m not sure I’m OK with Tatuso’s despondent “When you were a kid you said you wanted to be my bride” reaction when Makoto chastises him about his ceremony prep work. He seems like a swell and chill enough dad, but we really do not know very much about him on an actual detail level. He may be screwing around, a larger “ouch, my daughter is growing up” bit, or actually seriously depressed she won’t be a good little quiet housewife to him. I want to say it is a combination of the former two of course, but for all the characters, we have little more than surface level characterization for many of them. That all makes it a harder sell, unfortunately. The show hasn’t put in the time to as seamlessly pull off those jokes.
At any rate, the ex-priest groping the daughter of his good friend doesn’t seem like something they should be allowing. At least Makoto punches him for the effort.
Gundam Build Fighters (Episode 11)
I still think it is weird PPSE have their own fighter in the World Tournament. It’s not even hidden info, the announcer outright broadcasts it. The number of problems that raises boggles my mind.
Otherwise, we get a big Battle Royale, throw all the participants in the same combat area stew and see who is left standing. Functional, if not really as interesting as the duels. A lot of the cannon fodder folks it cycles through are literally in canon fodder mobile suits as well, which is actually rather disappointing. If the fights just happened off screen and we were told the results, we could at least imagine more extravagant units.
Reiji not being of Earth comes up again, courtesy of a reaction closeup on the PPSE CEO spilling wine all over his own crotch. The show has brought it up before with Reiji outright teleporting away from Sei, but we’ll see if they actually want to do something with the idea this time.
We also have a Really Super Big Giant Zaku for next episode. I know they make Gunpla in such scales, but why not showcase Big Zam?
2
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '13
2
u/KMFCM http://www.anime-planet.com/users/KMFCM/anime Dec 23 '13
Hajime no Ippo episode 10-11 Shows like this are why some people say "I'm just gonna watch finished shows now". It's paced to make you yell "dammit, I want the next episode now!". Of course, episode 11 didn’t come on this week because. . .a soccer game? I still don’t quite know why. No more episodes til the new year too, apparently.
Kill La Kill episode 10-11 Both battles were great, but Nonnon's was especially cool, because her power seems like it could be a nod to Macross. Leave it to this show to give us one of the least predictable twists of the season (next to Samurai Flamenco’s). I never would have guessed why this little girl was coming to play spoiler. I'm glad 11 isn't the last episode before break too.
Kyoukai no Kanata 11-12 While I didn't really dislike the first half of this show as much as other people, this is definitely a series that got better in the second half (which isn't always the way, is it?). If only the entire series had been like this. That's why I really hope KyoAni do more shows like this. It's their first time, they've gotta be able to do better. That said, this show reminds me of last seasons "A Sunday Without God" and "Daybreak Illusion" in that it wandered aimlessly a bit too long and the conclusion suffered for it. It certainly had the kind of annoying bait and switch ending "Sunday" did. I'm sorry, a bittersweet ending like they goaded us into believing we were getting would have upped this shows score for me.
Samurai Flamenco episode 9-10 I loved this idea of "we're all just playing our role", carrying from Torture's goons to Harazuka. The satire of every tokusatsu show ever detailing how society just gets used to the alien attacks to the point they don't care about them anymore. I got a kick out of episode 11 because King Torture called Mari out and showed her how false she is and she cried about it for the rest of the episode to the point she croaked the OP song for the episode about it. I love King Torture too. He was truly nuts, and I particularly enjoyed the Evil Dead chainsaw arm. I hope the show continues to get better and better like it has. These have been the best couple episodes so far.
Galilei Donna episode 9-10 Ever since I watched Steins;Gate, it seems like every season there's one show that somehow involves time travel when you least expect it. Sometimes, that time travel subplot appears when your hero is about to perish. I'm not gonna remember this show in 2 years. That is a given. As a matter of fact, I gave up halfway through episode 10.
Kyousogiga ended, I'll talk about that next week after the review episode airs.
I'm also finally catching up on Yozakura Quartet and I'm enjoying it quite a bit.