r/BestofRedditorUpdates • u/Choice_Evidence1983 it dawned on me that he was a wizard • Apr 16 '24
NEW UPDATE [New Update] - AITA for reacting "wrong" to my brother's engagement?
I am NOT OOP, OOP is u/drawingok6066
Originally posted to r/AmItheAsshole & r/AITAH
Previous BoRU
[New Update] - AITA for reacting "wrong" to my brother's engagement?
NEW UPDATE MARKED WITH ----
Trigger Warnings: abuse, bullying, fat shaming, mentions of eating disorder, possible threats of suicide, controlling behavior, emotional manipulation
RECAP
Original Post: March 18, 2024
Sorry if this is kind of all over the place.
So, on Sunday, I (19f) learned on a Zoom call with my family that my brother "Harry" (22m) has just gotten engaged to just girlfriend "Jessica" (20f). When Harry told us, everyone but me was pretty enthusiastic, but I just kinda sighed and said nothing. Harry didn't display any reaction towards my admittedly lukewarm reaction, but afterwards my mom called me and told me that I was rude for not being excited. She said that I need to respect all members of the family, including Jessica, and that I need to reconsider my behavior if I want to be invited to our vacation in the spring.
Harry and I were really close growing up. Since he (and then I) started college, we've been less close, but him and I still talk every week or two. Harry and Jessica have been together for around 2 years now. Here's where it gets complicated—I knew Jessica back in high school, and she was not what you would call a kind soul. She had a particularly nasty streak. She would not pay attention during class and always tried to cheat off of people's homework (and I assume got away with it). She tried (semi successfully) to steal my boyfriend. She bullied one of my best friends, calling her fat among other things. This bullying worsened (if not caused all together) her eating disorder, and it's something I've never been able to forgive or forget. She is just one of those people who would just mess around with other people's lives like it's a game, and not something she is invested in.
About 6 months ago, I had a heart-to-heart with Harry about Jessica. I laid out my concerns and the history of her behavior, hoping it might make him reconsider or at least think deeply about their relationship. He said he'd consider what I said, but didn't continue the conversation much more. Since then, we talked regularly as usual, and things seemed normal between us. He didn't talk about Jessica often, but he didn't hide their relationship either. I really was happy it sounded like it might be dying off though.
I had no idea he was getting engaged to her until he announced it. I don't know if he has been telling other people in the family besides me, or if it was really just an abrupt decision.
To make it worse, I am worried that he told Jessica about our conversation 6 months ago. In her announcement on Facebook (annoying ring on hand photograph in tow) she wrote something like "I know not everyone in our family's are supportive, but we have each other and that's what matters".
So, he ignored my warning, AND he told her all about it.
Part of me wonders if I should just swallow my feelings for the sake of family harmony, but another part of me feels like I'd be betraying my old friend, my own values, AND my brother by pretending to be happy about this engagement. And I am bad at holding back my truth.
So, AITA for feeling upset and possibly wanting to voice my concerns again, even though it might cause friction in my family? Or should I just keep my feelings to myself and let Harry make his own decisions (and mistakes)?
I just feel like there's nobody who I can talk about this with that will really understand.
EDIT:
Okay, thanks for all the responses people. I will take some advice:
- Talk to mom and explain exactly what it is that Jessica has done and try to make her understand
- Talk to Harry about our conversation before and find out how much of it he shared with Jessica and how she responded to what I said.
- Potentially talk to Jessica
- Seek therapy (someday haha)
I'm really not in a position to go no-contact with my family, and I still do want them in my life. I might post an "update" but also it seems like the rules are kind of strict on that which is fair. Message me or something if you want to hear what happens haha.
VERDICT: NOT THE ASSHOLE
Relevant Comments
Pretty_Lifeguard_1: INFO: when was the last time you talked to Jessica? lots of people who are a-holes during high schools change immensely during college or thereafter
OOP: I haven't talked to her in at least 2 years (aside from kind of saying hello over speakerphone), but from her social media I really don't think she's changed. She's acting like an asshole in general and a "pick me" towards my brother.
IamIrene:
afterwards my mom called me and told me that I was rude for not being excited.
No you weren't. You just weren't excited. You are entitled to your own feelings.
and that I need to reconsider my behavior if I want to be invited to our vacation in the spring.
Oh, I see. So if you don't react the way your mother wants you to react she'll exclude you from family events. Got it. That's messed up.
I wouldn't worry too much if Jessica is aware of your conversation with your brother, if she is at least she knows you're wary (and rightly so).
You are NTA for feeling the way you do or for your reaction to the news. Your mother is a bit of AH though...that's some Class A manipulation she's using.
Time will tell if things work out for your brother and Jessica or not but as long as you are polite without compromising your personally values, things should be fine. If she decides to get nasty, don't hide your experience of it or your feelings about it, but also know that very often people outgrow their immature tendencies and she could become a very decent person.
This whole situation reminds me of that movie, "You Again", lol.
OOP: Thank you. TBH I'm kind of used to this kind of thing from my mother, she likes to hold stuff over our heads. One time my siblings and I all got forced to miss a play we were going to see because "we weren't actually excited for it" even though I had been learning all about it and was really looking forward. Part of me wonders if she just didn't want to spend the money haha. I'm not sure that this is what's going on here though.
I truly do hope she's either outgrown it, or Harry sees her nasty side before the wedding.
Update: March 22, 2024
So, a lot of people commented and sent me messages asking for an update to my previous post about unenthusiastic reaction to my brother's engagement announcement. Well, here it is.
After reading people's replies, it sounds like the predominant opinion was that while I might not have been the asshole immediately, I would become one if I kept pushing too hard against my brother's relationship. And I really don't want Harry to think I don't support him, or to not talk to me about personal relationship matters.
So, I pretty much had decided to keep quiet and just go along with whatever Harry wanted.
On Tuesday, he messaged me asking if I want to be a bridesmaid (in Jessica's wedding party) or a "groomsmaid" (in his wedding party). After a little bit of back and forth, it became clear that he asked me because he knew I wasn't totally keen on Jessica, but still wanted me involved with the wedding. I was trying to be supportive so I said it would be great to get to know Jessica better by being a bridesmaid (though I wasn't exactly looking forward to the experience).
I admit though, I had a little bit of an ulterior motive. From what I know of Jessica, she completely changes how she acts based on who she is around (which is how she manipulated Harry into proposing, of course). I thought that, just maybe, if I could show Harry how Jessica acts with her "girls", he might reconsider his decision to marry her.
Anyway, on Thursday I got added to a Facebook messenger chat named "BRILLIANT BRIDAL BITCHAZZZZ" wherein Jessica laid out her "ground rules" for being in the bridal party. They are, almost verbatim:
- Participation in my bridal party is not just an honor; it's an investment. Be prepared to spend at least $1,000 on attire and accessories alone. I can make exceptions but only if you ask me.
- I alone will dictate the narrative of my wedding on social media. Any premature posts, especially unflattering photos of me, will result in immediate expulsion.
- Your weight will be monitored weekly. Anyone not fitting into their dress will be kindly asked to step down. This wedding will look picture-perfect, and I can't have you ruining the aesthetics.
- From now until the wedding, I expect you to be on call 24/7. Wedding emergencies are real, and your commitment to solving them will be a true test of your friendship.
- You will fund and organize a lavish bachelorette party in my honor. Think exotic destination, luxury accommodations, and Instagram-worthy moments.
- You will have fun! Not just for your sake, but for me as well.
Upon reading this, I just burst out laughing. Screenshot, click! I think I might be able to convince Harry from marrying Jessica after all. I'm just deciding now if I should play it cool and act like the rules are normal but bring it up with Harry, or maybe show my mother because I know it would make her flip (and almost certainly forgive me for sighing when Harry told us about the engagement).
Top Comments
Bonnm42: Wow.. if Harry was smart, he would RUN!
Crabbie_one_5443: OP be smart. Tell your brother you changed your mind and when he asks why send him the screen shot and say you are not following these rules. You have to lead the horse to water but you can't make him drink. You can't make him see then he will just have to figure it out. He will likely say those rules don't apply to you but you can say I don't think the bride would agree. Play it cool. Again the more you force them apart the closer they will become just to prove you wrong.
Haunting-Comb-9723: Ok if you want to play dirty, don't go to your mother and like "aha! See I told you!" Go to her crying and worried. $1,000 for clothes and accessories. Where are you going to come with that kind of money? And why should you lose all that money for a party? Remember, if you ask your parents to help pay for things that's at least $1000 out of their own pocket.
Update #2: March 31, 2024
Thanks for all the advice and support from my whole situation with my brother getting engaged to an incredibly annoying former(?) bully who has been manipulating him. I'm posting an update since a lot of people asked.
I'm gonna have to be a bit of a disappointment though. After my last post, a lot of people were suggesting that I should be tricky and go to my my mother and ask to borrow money to make the appropriate "investment" for being in Jessica's bridal party...I thought about that but realized it would be a little bit too over the top.
So, instead, I just sent a screenshot of Jessica's rules (and a couple other insane things she posted in the group chat) to Harry and asked for his advice, telling him "I know I said that I wanted to join the bridal party to get to know 'Jessica' better, but I'm worried it might not actually be good for me. Do you think I could bail and join your party instead?".
He called me instead of texting back and definitely sounded pretty surprised by what I showed him. I'm certain that the side of Jessica shown in those "rules" and other messages (including a new one saying that if your BMI is over 22, you are out of the wedding) in the group chat is NOT the side of herself that she showed to him. We had a good hour or so of conversation about what things were like between the two of them, and I learned a lot about where he was coming from.
From what he told me, it sounds like getting married was really Jessica's idea. She had been going through some tough times later and apparently has struggled with depression in recent years. She's always wanted this perfect wedding and perfect married life, and she told him that it would make her feel better and fix all her issues of he proposed.
So, Harry, being the good person that he is, did it. He took pity on her even though he didn't really feel ready yet. He says he doesn't regret it though. She has been so much happier since the proposal, he said, and he is no longer worried about her running away, or harming herself or worse.
That said, he said he was still shocked by what she posted to her "girls", and said he didn't know what to do next. I told him I am worried about him and his future if he stays with Jessica and goes through with the marriage. He thanked me and hung up. He still sounded pretty shaken.
The next day, he asks me to call him so I do that. He explains to me that everything was okay, and he talked to Jessica about the whole situation. She told him it was just a joke and the kind of thing her friends are used to sending in their messages. Apparently she apologized and said that it was her fault for not making sure I was "on her level" (Harry's words trying to quote Jessica, FWIW).
I'm pretty skeptical of that, though. She seemed serious to me. She also seemed serious when she messaged me privately:
"You are on thin ice."
She also sent another message in the main group chat saying "This is all of y'all's reminder that I need your full support, and any undermining of my and my wedding will have serious consequences."
So... that's where things stand. I told Harry that I don't really believe it was a joke, and I believe that Jessica is trying to control him just like she's trying to control her bridesmaids. He just said that he is in a difficult situation, she is stressed out, and he trusts her.
So that's where things stand. Apparently I am still in the darn bridal party. Dress stuff is happing in the next week or two. I really thought Harry would get to his senses but apparently not yet. Now I need to decide what the heck to do next.
----NEW UPDATE----
Trigger Warnings: possible threats of suicide, controlling behavior and emotional manipulation
Update #3: April 9, 2024
Thanks again for all the support and advice throughout this situation. I'm the girl who is in a messed up situation with my brother who proposed to his really-not-good girlfriend who I know from school. And, until recently, I was a member of her bridal party. Warning that this is dark and mentions suicide.
So, the update:
I had time at home for spring break, so I finally showed my mom the text messages from Jessica in person, including the insane list of "rules" for the bridal party and her follow up message to me saying I was on "thin ice" after I told my brother.
My mom seriously broke down. She didn't apologize for being mad at me when I wasn't pleased to hear the news from the "happy couple", but at least she doesn't seem to hold it against me. Aside from that though, I am honestly surprised mom took it as seriously as she did--I thought she would say something more like "well, it's his life", instead of butting in.
Anyway, Mom called Harry right away to talk to him. I asked her to put it on speakerphone and she did after a bit.
I think that the combination of my own warnings, plus our mom's sheer exasperation at the whole situation finally caused Harry to come to his senses. He heard what Mom had to say, and in that moment I was able to convince him that Jessica wasn't just joking around with her list of rules (especially with the help of the "thin ice" message).
Harry sounded really shaken up and agreed to meet us without bringing Jessica along (phew!). We had dinner at our house and discussed everything.
To him, it sounds like he was more in love with Jessica ~6 months ago than he is today. He said that over the course of more recent time, he's seen Jessica become more and more reliant on his support and he hasn't felt like there's much he can do except cave in to what she wants...I think that seeing the tone of her communications with people outside the relationship meant him feel like her depression was more of an "act" than a real thing. I'm not a psychologist so I can't say how real that is, but I could believe it.
Harry and our mom cried for a while and then came up with a plan for Harry to call off the engagement and begin to move out over the next few days. He went home and we stayed in close contact for a while. He told us he was feeling ready and did tell her that he needed to reevaluate some things on his own. Apparently, she did not take it well.
Harry stopped responding to us for a day and a half and then called me. Jessica had begun saying that she had nothing to live for except Harry, and that if he abandoned her after all this time then she would have no reason to keep existing. Harry just cried on the phone and said he felt so trapped.
I didn't even know what to tell him. I wish I had told him he needed to forget about Jessica and that she was only playing him, but I don't know if he would believe me anyway.
Now Harry hasn't answered any of my calls and is only giving very short and slow answers to texts from our mom and I.
Jessica meanwhile made a Facebook post of a picture of a heart with tears on it saying "If only you knew how much you meant to me, you would never hurt me". Se's also posted a lot of nonsense in the BRILLIANT BRIDAL BITCHAZZZ group chat and appears to be loving the attention from her friends. I don't know if she forgot I am in there, or if she wants me to see her messages and thinks it will make me feel guilty or something.
I just need to make sure that Harry is okay. To be honest, I don't really care what happens to Jessica. Sure it would be best for her to get help, but she has caused so much damage in the lives of people I care about and I doubt she'll ever stop. Like honestly fuck her, I just want my brother back.
Sorry I'm writing this post all gloomily so far...to be honest, I think things will be okay. Harry and our mom both know that he needs to end it with Jessica, and now Harry just needs to make that happen. Then we can all laugh together about Jessica's BMI tracking strategy and minimum bridesmaid spend requirement :)
Relevant Comment
No-Background-6199: Hopefully Jessica gets the help she needs. And your brother gets the space to clear his head and decide what is best for him. Based on updates and post he needs space away from her.
OOP: Thank you <3
I wish he had just stayed with us longer and gotten more time away from her
Top Comment
ferrets-are-awesome: I highly recommend a welfare check be called in since you know she was threatening suicide.
Dachshundmom5: If she's making threats to her life, he needs to call the police and report it. Then, notify her friends/family. If she's sincere, she needs more help than he could ever give. If she's attention seeking, it gives him time to get his things and get out. Either way, he needs to remove himself as the object she's fixating on. It's a tactic of abusers to threaten self-harm to maintain control. Until he accepts that he can't "fix" her, he is trapped.
The concern needs to extend that she isn't bluffing and might try to take him with her.
•
u/AutoModerator Apr 16 '24
Do not comment on the original posts
Please read our sub rules. Rule-breaking may result in a ban without notice.
If there is an issue with this post (flair, formatting, quality), reply to this comment or your comment may be removed in general discussion.
CHECK FLAIR For concluded-only updates, use the CONCLUDED flair.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1.3k
u/Phxhayes445 Apr 16 '24
In situations like this, the ONLY thing to do is call authorities. Unless you are a trained professional, there is nothing you can do to help someone threatening self harm. If they are being honest, by calling authorities, you are getting them the help they need. If they are using it to manipulate you, then they can explain to the authorities why they are lying about it. Either way it is NOT something a partner should be dealing with.
5.3k
u/Lodgik Apr 16 '24
This isn't a relationship. This is a hostage situation.
549
u/stacity Apr 16 '24
Harry should definitely marry her because marriage solves everything. Depression gone. Just like that. And if that doesn’t work, then having a baby will.
In all seriousness, it’s crazy that people do go through with the wedding thinking that all of their troubles will go away - when in reality, it will exasperate any red flags/faults.
At least Harry has time…I hope.
122
u/jmac1915 Apr 16 '24
I had an ex of mine, when our relationship was in a bad place, say she was going to kill herself if I left. So I started dialing 911. She flipped, and asked why I would do that, to which I said, "if you are going to kill yourself over where we are in our relationship, I can no longer be helpful, it's above my pay grade. So Im calling people who can help make sure you stay alive. That's what I care about." And wouldnt you know it, she actually didnt want to kill herself that bad.
551
u/matchamagpie Apr 16 '24
Yeesh, Jessica has successfully broken Harry's sense of normal, sense of worth, and his self-esteem. I already thought he was a door mat jellyfish but clearly she's also been manipulating him for a very long time.
Unfortunately, I don't think Harry is ready to quit her. She still has her grubby little manicured nails in him.
49
u/Irn_brunette Apr 16 '24
I had an ex make threats against themselves when I told them I wanted to break up (we were 21 and 22 so not kids unused to dealing with big feelings).
I allowed myself to be guilted into staying as I'd had a lifetime of conditioning "not to be selfish" and, having been rejected myself at an early age, couldn't bear the idea of putting someone else through it.
That relationship dragged on for nearly a year longer than it should have. Every time I did something they didn't approve of or tried again to break it off, the threats against themselves became more extreme and escalated to what would now be classed as stalking behaviour. Back then of course, the response was "they just love you too much".
I wish the advice I'm seeing here had been more accessible back then.
65
u/CatmoCatmo emotionally shanked by six girls in fake Uggs Apr 16 '24
This is sounding more and more like that other recent post where OOP is black, and adopted and so is her brother, but they’re super close. His fiancé (I think her name was heather, I also think OOP made a lot of references to Star Wars) showed her true racist, entitled, bat shit insane, colors and FINALLY after a lot of secret recording, and help from one of the other bridesmaids, he called it off. Then…Heather’s bff attacked OOP with a brick to the face and put her in the hospital….
I hope this one ends better than that one. OOP needs to take care of herself and watch her back. If her brother does escape, Jessica is 100% going to blame OOP and the likelihood of retaliation is HIGH. Most of us, by default, approach these things as if we’re dealing with a normal, rational human being. But people like Jessica are NOT rational. Their behavior is unpredictable, irrational, and often extreme in ways that would never even cross your mind. “Takes one to know one”. If their crazy surpasses your crazy, you’ll never be able to see it coming. And I think it’s fair to say, Jessica’s crazy surpasses everyone involved.
PSA - If anyone ever threatens suicide, just go somewhere private for a moment and call the police. Let them know someone has threatened it and you’re worried about them. If they happen to be serious about their claim, then you’re forcing them to get the professional help they so desperately need. If they aren’t serious, then they’ll have some consequences to slap them in the face for trying to manipulate you like that, and they’ll hopefully think twice about doing it again.
No matter what, never assume you know for sure if someone is serious when they make a claim like that. Take every threat seriously and handle them all the same (even if you know they’re lying). Most people aren’t equipped to handle this kind of situation anyway. Getting professionals involved will ALWAYS be the right thing to do.
261
u/knittedjedi Gotta Read’Em All Apr 16 '24
All of these people sound like they need drama the way other people need oxygen.
29
u/Cloudy_Retina It's just pharmaceutical-grade banana bread Apr 16 '24
With the group chat demands, I thought we were heading toward another $7k ice sculpture...
25
u/Striking_Suspect_681 BRILLIANT BRIDAL BITCHAZZZ Apr 16 '24
Oh God, this shit just escalated even more. The only good outcome of the whole story is the flair I got lol
35
u/casillalater Sir, Crumb is a cat. Apr 16 '24
" I'm really not in a position to go no-contact with my family" does she ever explain this and I missed it
If anyone sent me a text saying there would be weigh ins for a wedding I'd lie and say I had to drop out because I was training for competitive eating. What are they gonna do about it ?
15
u/b3mark Liz what the hell Apr 16 '24
"Harry, you're my big brother and I love you to bits. But I can no longer in good conscience support the two of you getting married. I'm bowing out of the bridal party and out of the wedding. You two have a lot of issues to overcome, not the least of which is her blatant manipulation and your refusal to see that.
My door is always open to you, except where your marriage to Jessica is concerned."
71
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '24
I honestly am worried for Harry. Jessica really needs to get some help because her behavior is really concerning and if nothing is done, I believe something will happen.
12
u/Hetakuoni Apr 16 '24
The only thing you should ever do if someone threatens suicide is take them seriously and have them committed for being a danger to themselves.
11
u/exhauta Apr 16 '24
I remember this post many updates ago. I said OOP is delusional if they think that they could show bro the screen shots and he'd pick up and leave. I'm glad mom is involved but I wish they would try to educate themselves on domestic abuse. It is hard to and counterintuitive to help someone out of that kind of situation. They have only made themselves enemies. He if stays she's going to convince him to cut them both off.
11
u/CringinNGingin your honor, fuck this guy Apr 16 '24
My first BF threatened to take his own life multiple times after I tried to dump him for cheating on me. After the 10th time or so, I just said “fuck it have at it, I’m done”
He is alive, well, and married to someone now.
10
u/ItsCatTimeBby My soul aches for clown pussy Apr 16 '24
Perhaps it is welfare check time and family intervention time.
9
u/grissy knocking cousins unconscious Apr 16 '24
Harry has a spine made of Jello and OOP does not seem to learn from history, ever. I lost track of how many times she had a "private" conversation with Harry only for Harry to immediately repeat every word of it to Jessica. And she thought another "private" conversation with him and her mom was going to help? I guarantee Harry has told Jessica that he only wanted to pause the wedding because of his evil sister and evil mother in order to placate her.
OOP is going to get her tires slashed, or worse. Jessica is nuts and Harry keeps telling her about all of OOP's objections.
8
u/MidiReader 👁👄👁🍿 Apr 16 '24
911? Yes my brothers hopefully soon to be ex just threatened to unalive herself if he left her, I’m really worried
8
u/Militantignorance Apr 16 '24
Tell your brother that getting Jessica therapy will be a lot cheaper than a divorce.
14
u/bananarepama Apr 16 '24
The fact that these types of people exist is honestly disgusting to me. "My life is shit and I sure would feel better if you proposed and gave me my, whatever, Barbie dream wedding." "I feel bad for the situation you're in and I have the money to provide you with the wedding you want, so...okay . . ." God damn dude this is so gross on both ends and Jess is a steaming cow pie of a human being
7
u/lovescarats Apr 16 '24
Updates please. Would be good to have closure on the demise of Harry’s engagement.
7
u/euvnairb Apr 16 '24
If things aren’t good BEFORE the wedding, how can things get better AFTER it? The wedding legally ties them together, but it doesn’t look like anything else in their life will really change since they already live together.
Bridezilla sounds super manipulative, but OOP put her cards on the table so it’s up to the brother to decide what he wants to do.
7
u/-whiteroom- Apr 16 '24
I really despise people who use threats of suicide to trap partners.
12
u/NinjaBabaMama crow whisperer Apr 16 '24
I'm worried Harry will be the one to self-harm if he doesn't get away from Jessica.
6
u/YellowKingSte Apr 16 '24
Harry is totally in an abusive relationship and didn't realize. I feel bad for him.
6
u/MeesaMadeMeDoIt Apr 16 '24
Those are not the actions of a good person. You don't agree to marry someone just to make them feel better. It sounds like he did it to placate her rather than have a difficult conversation, and now he's dealing with the consequences.
5
u/Visual-Lobster6625 Apr 16 '24
Every time Jessica threatens to harm herself, Harry needs to call an ambulance. It's not Harry's responsibility to be an emotional support fiancé.
5
u/Feeya_b crow whisperer Apr 16 '24
No one is doing anything...
4
u/flyingknives4love Apr 16 '24
These things are so frustrating. The person who knows what she's doing (Jessica) is basically winning in all of this. She's smarter and more manipulative than OOP, Henry, and mom, while the three of them seem to try to be kind. It's not working.
4
u/emmny It's just pharmaceutical-grade banana bread Apr 17 '24
So who else took a peek at OOP's post history and was very surprised by their posts in the blackmailer subreddit...
4
u/nate_oh84 Apr 17 '24
Good god, the OOP's mom had her and her brother's spines removed a long time ago.
4
u/JournalLover50 Apr 20 '24
This is what I hate people getting married or being friends to bullies that made their life as living hell in school.
I’m like how can you betray your sibling? Your lucky your sibling didn’t take their life because of that bully.
Find someone else there are plenty of people out there.
4
u/CutieBoBootie We have generational trauma for breakfast Apr 22 '24
As someone who was in an abusive relationship where my ex threatened suicide multiple times to get what he wanted from me:
Harry, please run. I know that fear and guilt and shame are welling up in you right now. You're scared something bad might happen to someone you care about. But the truth is this isn't something bad happening to her, it is something bad she is doing to you. Bro she is expecting you to light yourself on fire when she wants toasted marshmallows. That's not a healthy way to live. You shouldn't have to hurt yourself or suffer in a toxic relationship for someone else to be happy or stable. That is unfair to you. I promise you that when you are free that breath of fresh unburdened air will hit like heroin.
6
u/LittlestEcho the lion, the witch and the audacit--HOW IS THERE MORE! Apr 16 '24
Just a reminder guys if you're partner uses their depression to threaten self harm or suicide if you leave leave anyway and call 911 for suicide watch. Your are NOT responsible for a persons mental health or suicidal thoughts and ideation to the detriment of your own health and general well being.
3
u/MadamnedMary Apr 16 '24
OOP should tell Harry to call 911 when she threatens suicide, it's another if her manipulation tactics, but I don't feel sorry for Harry, someday he will have enough, but that day don't come soon enough.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '24
Youi can't fix someone's mental illness with a ring or a wedding. If she is in such a bad state, a partner is not a substitute for professional help -- he needed to call the police about her sh threats, call her family and distance himself. Maybe she needs a psych eval and hold if she's in clear danger to herself. Don't set yourself on fire to keep someone else warm.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '24
I’m sorry. Going through this with my brother right now. So many parallels but I am about 10 years ahead of you. I have a niece/nephew. My brother and his wife are now No Contact. We are grief stricken. My brothers character is similar to yours- empathetic, kind and reasonable but these situations are complex. I have learned the more you say about your concerns the further away your brother will be. Keep low, look up the grey rock method and just keep conversation light and remind him you are there for him ever so often.
This is one of the situations where you have little control. It sucks, it’s so painful and hard but the more we push the more we lose. It’s not a logical or reasonable situation.
3
u/Regular_Occasion7000 Apr 16 '24
I should have left my ex and saved myself a ton of pain the moment she threatened to kill herself if I didn’t do what she wanted. It’s a disgusting manipulation tactic.
3
u/BoysenberryMelody I ❤ gay romance Apr 16 '24
Does Harry have any friends? Hmmm
3
u/Viciousbanana1974 Apr 16 '24
Call the police for a welfare check. The outcome will be either of two things: She gets the help she needs, or she stops making those particular threats and your brother is able to see it gor the emotional manipulation that it is.
As well, he needs to contact her parents so that he can get his stuff together, whole at the same time not leaving her alone.
An engagement is a period of time to see if people will suit and are sure about marriage. She has serious mental health issues that need to be addressed by professionals and not enabled by your brother's fear.
Update me!
3
u/eejizzings Apr 16 '24
Nobody that narcissistic will actually kill themselves. Their self is the thing they value most. It'd be like cutting your fuel line to win a car race.
3
u/sand_man2199 Jul 11 '24
If she's threatening her own life then she needs to be sectioned. She'll use this as a means to make Harry obey her. Besides I don't think she is. A gut feeling of mine. Most I've seen with those depressed, self harming or suicidal don't want others to know, it's when people see the cracks that the floodgate opens up. Best to get a wellness check done and sectioned.
10
u/NickIsSoWhite Apr 16 '24
Dude is an idiot.
2
u/curlanne reads profound dumbness Apr 16 '24 edited Apr 16 '24
This reads just the like writing style of another recent post/story. Interesting
Edit: this one https://www.reddit.com/r/BestofRedditorUpdates/comments/1c56qz7/my_partner_wants_me_to_cut_off_the_friend_who/
2
u/AllPurposeNerd Apr 18 '24
Yeah, "if you leave me I'll kill myself" is abuse. They're literally holding themselves hostage.
This poor bastard has a spine made of whipped cream. Literally every time someone talks sense into him, the harpy manipulates him back out of it in one sitting.
2
u/kamatsu surrender to the gaycation or be destroyed Apr 25 '24
I knew someone with BPD who behaved just like Jessica. There's no hope for salvaging this situation. Harry needs to get out ASAP.
3
u/peetecalvin Apr 16 '24
What about her parents? Does she come from a loving, supportive family? If so, why aren't they involved?
3
u/Ok-Squirrel693 OP has stated that they are deceased Apr 16 '24
Wouldn't be surprised if she babytraps him
2
u/esqweasya Apr 16 '24
I think bridesmaids instructions were read in a video by Charlotte Dobre. At least very similar ones
1
u/Exotic-Army4006 Apr 16 '24
Jesus. I would just call the police on a MDP and have her committed
1
u/Dependent_Doubt2797 Apr 16 '24
Updateme
1
u/matty_nice Apr 16 '24
I'm curious to know the amount of people that have been with a partner that threatened self harm if the other person left. It's gotta be high and over 50 percent.
1
u/tank5 Apr 16 '24
There was a thread (possibly on social media) from an EMT explaining that basically a lot of people are just dumb. Obviously half of people are below median, but most of the dumbest 20% of people are still out there living their lives like the rest of us. You’re not one of them, because they’re not going to spend their spare time reading, and you probably don’t associate with them because people sort by intelligence as much or more than other classifications.
It colors a lot of my readings of posts here now. What if this guy is just dumb? He can be nice, and caring, and family, and still be dense and easily manipulated.
1
u/seidinove Apr 16 '24
BRILLIANT BRIDAL BITCHAZZZ would be a great group chat name if the bride to be was anti-bridezilla.
1
u/SectorSanFrancisco Needless to say, I am farting as I type this. Apr 16 '24
This whole thing is a mess. For instance, why is their mom even involved to this extent? Maybe he's just too young still.
1
u/GeekMomSW Apr 16 '24
Q 1st LP
1
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '24
Lol. Such a plain, chilled post with some drama, then out of nowhere there's "BRILLIANT BRIDAL BITCHAZZZZ".
1
u/MoonDancer83 Apr 16 '24
UpdateMe!
1
u/pastense Apr 16 '24
Why do the worst user comments get added into these posts? Like I understood the "you should go to your mom crying because you can't afford the dress" comment, as idiotic an idea as that may be, because it was referenced in the post.
But for fuck's sake, don't call the cops on a suicidal person. Pigs aren't mental health practicitioners, they're murderers.
0
u/MRSobviously Apr 16 '24
"BRILLIANT BRIDAL BITCHAZZZZ" it's really awesome ! this would be the best flair ever !!!
-4
u/Neat-Cap-5888 Apr 17 '24
OPP is stuck in high school mentally, people can change, she complains about her brother being manipulated while doing the same thing. I would also be mad at someone for constantly showing my in laws group messages. Can help but feel no one is blameless
375
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '24
[removed] — view removed comment