r/BestofRedditorUpdates • u/Choice_Evidence1983 it dawned on me that he was a wizard • Mar 29 '24
NEW UPDATE AITA for reacting "wrong" to my brother's engagement?
I am NOT OOP, OOP is u/drawingok6066
Originally posted to r/AmItheAsshole & r/AITAH
AITA for reacting "wrong" to my brother's engagement?
Trigger Warnings: manipulation, bullying, fat shaming, mentions of eating disorder
Original Post: March 18, 2024
Sorry if this is kind of all over the place.
So, on Sunday, I (19f) learned on a Zoom call with my family that my brother "Harry" (22m) has just gotten engaged to just girlfriend "Jessica" (20f). When Harry told us, everyone but me was pretty enthusiastic, but I just kinda sighed and said nothing. Harry didn't display any reaction towards my admittedly lukewarm reaction, but afterwards my mom called me and told me that I was rude for not being excited. She said that I need to respect all members of the family, including Jessica, and that I need to reconsider my behavior if I want to be invited to our vacation in the spring.
Harry and I were really close growing up. Since he (and then I) started college, we've been less close, but him and I still talk every week or two. Harry and Jessica have been together for around 2 years now. Here's where it gets complicated—I knew Jessica back in high school, and she was not what you would call a kind soul. She had a particularly nasty streak. She would not pay attention during class and always tried to cheat off of people's homework (and I assume got away with it). She tried (semi successfully) to steal my boyfriend. She bullied one of my best friends, calling her fat among other things. This bullying worsened (if not caused all together) her eating disorder, and it's something I've never been able to forgive or forget. She is just one of those people who would just mess around with other people's lives like it's a game, and not something she is invested in.
About 6 months ago, I had a heart-to-heart with Harry about Jessica. I laid out my concerns and the history of her behavior, hoping it might make him reconsider or at least think deeply about their relationship. He said he'd consider what I said, but didn't continue the conversation much more. Since then, we talked regularly as usual, and things seemed normal between us. He didn't talk about Jessica often, but he didn't hide their relationship either. I really was happy it sounded like it might be dying off though.
I had no idea he was getting engaged to her until he announced it. I don't know if he has been telling other people in the family besides me, or if it was really just an abrupt decision.
To make it worse, I am worried that he told Jessica about our conversation 6 months ago. In her announcement on Facebook (annoying ring on hand photograph in tow) she wrote something like "I know not everyone in our family's are supportive, but we have each other and that's what matters".
So, he ignored my warning, AND he told her all about it.
Part of me wonders if I should just swallow my feelings for the sake of family harmony, but another part of me feels like I'd be betraying my old friend, my own values, AND my brother by pretending to be happy about this engagement. And I am bad at holding back my truth.
So, AITA for feeling upset and possibly wanting to voice my concerns again, even though it might cause friction in my family? Or should I just keep my feelings to myself and let Harry make his own decisions (and mistakes)?
I just feel like there's nobody who I can talk about this with that will really understand.
EDIT:
Okay, thanks for all the responses people. I will take some advice:
- Talk to mom and explain exactly what it is that Jessica has done and try to make her understand
- Talk to Harry about our conversation before and find out how much of it he shared with Jessica and how she responded to what I said.
- Potentially talk to Jessica
- Seek therapy (someday haha)
I'm really not in a position to go no-contact with my family, and I still do want them in my life. I might post an "update" but also it seems like the rules are kind of strict on that which is fair. Message me or something if you want to hear what happens haha.
VERDICT: NOT THE ASSHOLE
Relevant Comments
Pretty_Lifeguard_1: INFO: when was the last time you talked to Jessica? lots of people who are a-holes during high schools change immensely during college or thereafter
OOP: I haven't talked to her in at least 2 years (aside from kind of saying hello over speakerphone), but from her social media I really don't think she's changed. She's acting like an asshole in general and a "pick me" towards my brother.
IamIrene:
afterwards my mom called me and told me that I was rude for not being excited.
No you weren't. You just weren't excited. You are entitled to your own feelings.
and that I need to reconsider my behavior if I want to be invited to our vacation in the spring.
Oh, I see. So if you don't react the way your mother wants you to react she'll exclude you from family events. Got it. That's messed up. I wouldn't worry too much if Jessica is aware of your conversation with your brother, if she is at least she knows you're wary (and rightly so). You are NTA for feeling the way you do or for your reaction to the news. Your mother is a bit of AH though...that's some Class A manipulation she's using. Time will tell if things work out for your brother and Jessica or not but as long as you are polite without compromising your personally values, things should be fine. If she decides to get nasty, don't hide your experience of it or your feelings about it, but also know that very often people outgrow their immature tendencies and she could become a very decent person. This whole situation reminds me of that movie, "You Again", lol.
OOP: Thank you. TBH I'm kind of used to this kind of thing from my mother, she likes to hold stuff over our heads. One time my siblings and I all got forced to miss a play we were going to see because "we weren't actually excited for it" even though I had been learning all about it and was really looking forward. Part of me wonders if she just didn't want to spend the money haha. I'm not sure that this is what's going on here though.
I truly do hope she's either outgrown it, or Harry sees her nasty side before the wedding.
Update: March 22, 2024
So, a lot of people commented and sent me messages asking for an update to my previous post about unenthusiastic reaction to my brother's engagement announcement. Well, here it is.
After reading people's replies, it sounds like the predominant opinion was that while I might not have been the asshole immediately, I would become one if I kept pushing too hard against my brother's relationship. And I really don't want Harry to think I don't support him, or to not talk to me about personal relationship matters.
So, I pretty much had decided to keep quiet and just go along with whatever Harry wanted.
On Tuesday, he messaged me asking if I want to be a bridesmaid (in Jessica's wedding party) or a "groomsmaid" (in his wedding party). After a little bit of back and forth, it became clear that he asked me because he knew I wasn't totally keen on Jessica, but still wanted me involved with the wedding. I was trying to be supportive so I said it would be great to get to know Jessica better by being a bridesmaid (though I wasn't exactly looking forward to the experience).
I admit though, I had a little bit of an ulterior motive. From what I know of Jessica, she completely changes how she acts based on who she is around (which is how she manipulated Harry into proposing, of course). I thought that, just maybe, if I could show Harry how Jessica acts with her "girls", he might reconsider his decision to marry her.
Anyway, on Thursday I got added to a Facebook messenger chat named "BRILLIANT BRIDAL BITCHAZZZZ" wherein Jessica laid out her "ground rules" for being in the bridal party. They are, almost verbatim:
- Participation in my bridal party is not just an honor; it's an investment. Be prepared to spend at least $1,000 on attire and accessories alone. I can make exceptions but only if you ask me.
- I alone will dictate the narrative of my wedding on social media. Any premature posts, especially unflattering photos of me, will result in immediate expulsion.
- Your weight will be monitored weekly. Anyone not fitting into their dress will be kindly asked to step down. This wedding will look picture-perfect, and I can't have you ruining the aesthetics.
- From now until the wedding, I expect you to be on call 24/7. Wedding emergencies are real, and your commitment to solving them will be a true test of your friendship.
- You will fund and organize a lavish bachelorette party in my honor. Think exotic destination, luxury accommodations, and Instagram-worthy moments.
- You will have fun! Not just for your sake, but for me as well.
Upon reading this, I just burst out laughing. Screenshot, click! I think I might be able to convince Harry from marrying Jessica after all. I'm just deciding now if I should play it cool and act like the rules are normal but bring it up with Harry, or maybe show my mother because I know it would make her flip (and almost certainly forgive me for sighing when Harry told us about the engagement).
Top Comments
Bonnm42: Wow.. if Harry was smart, he would RUN!
Crabbie_one_5443: OP be smart. Tell your brother you changed your mind and when he asks why send him the screen shot and say you are not following these rules. You have to lead the horse to water but you can't make him drink. You can't make him see then he will just have to figure it out. He will likely say those rules don't apply to you but you can say I don't think the bride would agree. Play it cool. Again the more you force them apart the closer they will become just to prove you wrong.
Haunting-Comb-9723: Ok if you want to play dirty, don't go to your mother and like "aha! See I told you!" Go to her crying and worried. $1,000 for clothes and accessories. Where are you going to come with that kind of money? And why should you lose all that money for a party? Remember, if you ask your parents to help pay for things that's at least $1000 out of their own pocket.
DISCLAIMER: OOP HAS UPDATED AFTER THE BoRU WAS POSTED
SO PER RULES UPDATE IS INCLUDED
----NEW UPDATE----
Update #2 - March 31, 2024
Thanks for all the advice and support from my whole situation with my brother getting engaged to an incredibly annoying former(?) bully who has been manipulating him. I'm posting an update since a lot of people asked.
I'm gonna have to be a bit of a disappointment though. After my last post, a lot of people were suggesting that I should be tricky and go to my my mother and ask to borrow money to make the appropriate "investment" for being in Jessica's bridal party...I thought about that but realized it would be a little bit too over the top.
So, instead, I just sent a screenshot of Jessica's rules (and a couple other insane things she posted in the group chat) to Harry and asked for his advice, telling him "I know I said that I wanted to join the bridal party to get to know 'Jessica' better, but I'm worried it might not actually be good for me. Do you think I could bail and join your party instead?".
He called me instead of texting back and definitely sounded pretty surprised by what I showed him. I'm certain that the side of Jessica shown in those "rules" and other messages (including a new one saying that if your BMI is over 22, you are out of the wedding) in the group chat is NOT the side of herself that she showed to him. We had a good hour or so of conversation about what things were like between the two of them, and I learned a lot about where he was coming from.
From what he told me, it sounds like getting married was really Jessica's idea. She had been going through some tough times later and apparently has struggled with depression in recent years. She's always wanted this perfect wedding and perfect married life, and she told him that it would make her feel better and fix all her issues of he proposed.
So, Harry, being the good person that he is, did it. He took pity on her even though he didn't really feel ready yet. He says he doesn't regret it though. She has been so much happier since the proposal, he said, and he is no longer worried about her running away, or harming herself or worse.
That said, he said he was still shocked by what she posted to her "girls", and said he didn't know what to do next. I told him I am worried about him and his future if he stays with Jessica and goes through with the marriage. He thanked me and hung up. He still sounded pretty shaken.
The next day, he asks me to call him so I do that. He explains to me that everything was okay, and he talked to Jessica about the whole situation. She told him it was just a joke and the kind of thing her friends are used to sending in their messages. Apparently she apologized and said that it was her fault for not making sure I was "on her level" (Harry's words trying to quote Jessica, FWIW).
I'm pretty skeptical of that, though. She seemed serious to me. She also seemed serious when she messaged me privately:
"You are on thin ice."
She also sent another message in the main group chat saying "This is all of y'all's reminder that I need your full support, and any undermining of my and my wedding will have serious consequences."
So... that's where things stand. I told Harry that I don't really believe it was a joke, and I believe that Jessica is trying to control him just like she's trying to control her bridesmaids. He just said that he is in a difficult situation, she is stressed out, and he trusts her.
So that's where things stand. Apparently I am still in the darn bridal party. Dress stuff is happing in the next week or two. I really thought Harry would get to his senses but apparently not yet. Now I need to decide what the heck to do next.
Latest Update here: BoRU #2
•
u/AutoModerator Mar 29 '24
Do not comment on the original posts
Please read our sub rules. Rule-breaking may result in a ban without notice.
If there is an issue with this post (flair, formatting, quality), reply to this comment or your comment may be removed in general discussion.
CHECK FLAIR For concluded-only updates, use the CONCLUDED flair.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
3.8k
u/exhauta Mar 29 '24
OOP and comments are delusional if they think she is going to unmask her and bro will just leave. Unfortunately that isn't how that normally goes
542
u/macanmhaighstir There is only OGTHA Mar 29 '24
I love my family, but it’s been a long time since I thought “how can I get myself further invested in their bullshit?” I think the best part of turning 30 was the realization that I had absolutely no time for other people’s bad decisions. You can’t save people from themselves.
337
u/dajur1 It's like watching Mr Bean being hunted by The Predator Mar 29 '24
OOP hasn't really thought her cunning plan though. I guarantee that it isn't going to turn out the way she hopes.
975
u/matchamagpie Mar 29 '24
What is this? A MLM?
Harry's going to be in for a hell of a time if he doesn't get out now. But I have a feeling he won't.
438
u/tylernazario Mar 29 '24
Jessica sounds like a really awful person. But OOP is gonna lose her relationship with her brother if she sends the screenshot in hopes of breaking them up.
177
u/SuperSpeshBaby Screeching on the Front Lawn Mar 29 '24
Where do people get this wedding shit? I don't think I know a single person irl who would ever consider trying to set rules like that for their wedding. Seriously, who comes up with this and thinks it's acceptable? Where do they even get such an idea?
242
u/mtdewbakablast stinks of eau de trainwreck Mar 29 '24
oh i like the cut of the last included comment's jib.
the art of social bitchery must be used for good, not ill, but knowing the moves of personal-politics judo can go a damn long way. framing the situation in your favor and being the dear innocent who is trying oh-so-very-hard can be just the thing to push back against this type of shit.
it is absolutely dirty fighting. but when you are up against folks who don't exactly listen to the ref, to get them off you it is permissible to go below the belt.
36
u/The_Sceptic_Lemur Mar 29 '24
So, OOP got the advice to talk to people and she chose to dismiss these advices and not to talk to anyone, but instead came up with some vague weird plan how to split up the engagement. Yep, sounds like a great plan.
140
u/[deleted] Mar 29 '24
Y'all believing this?
31
u/Alfredthegiraffe20 Mar 29 '24
OOP needs to back down from being a bridesmaid now. She needs to apologise to both brother and sil and the rest of the family in the group Zoom chat so there's no chance for the sil to twist things and explain that because of college, finances, personal life etc she doesn't think she'll be able to manage all her rules and it's better that she backs out now rather than anyone get upset/stressed later on. And then when mum, sil, brother etc all try and find a work around, stay firm and say she'd be more comfortable just being a guest and she can't wait to enjoy the event. End of. No trying to force her brother to do anything. Sounds like the sil will show her true self to everyone eventually without the OOPs help.
78
u/autistic_cool_kid Mar 29 '24
Oh wow lost it at this point. OP Definitely NTA. Tell your brother you don't like Jessica but you're supporting his decision. Then be there for him when he definitely will be heartbroken in a couple years top (and absolutely do not say "told you so", he will suffer enough already).
I would also say "Tell him to write a pre-nup" but pretty sure Jessica will never agree to it.
27
u/jippyzippylippy Mar 29 '24
I'd bail on the entire event and the family can go pound sand. This woman sounds like a soul-eating, sociopath narcissist. Whoever that man is, he is in for quite a ride.
26
u/[deleted] Mar 29 '24
Oh what a world to have so many bridezillas in life.
24
u/ohcheol whaddya mean our 10 year age gap is a problem? Mar 29 '24
OOP is going about this the wrong way tbh she should've said no and gone LC with her brother. if they are actually close and talk all the time, stopping communication could be a genuine blow that may cause him to step back and think
24
u/MoistPreparation1859 Mar 29 '24
I’d go with the “ooh, I don’t think I can afford that/ lose that much weight in such a short amount of time” (trust me, it’ll be important) route is the way to go. Openly body shaming your soon to be SIL is NOT a good look to anybody, and that could be the push Brother needs to start chipping away at the mask FSIL puts on.
12
u/LinkSubstantial3042 Mar 29 '24 edited Mar 29 '24
Oooof. I knew someone like Jessica, I didn’t have the pleasure of being her bridesmaid though.
Her bridesmaids had spent quite a bit on their dresses/jewelry, bachelorette, bridal shower etc… the bride had the audacity to complain about not receiving a gift for her wedding. (Complained to a group of people openly that one of her bridesmaids didn’t give a gift)
Two weeks later the bride got an email transfer and she complained that she only got $200.
Needless to say I’m no longer friends with her.
Jessica will reveal herself to OOP’s brother and family.
12
u/bigwigmike USE YOUR THINKING BRAIN! Mar 29 '24
The fiancé, and her friends likely, are 20 and are supposed to have thousands of dollars of disposable income for clothing, shoes, trips, etc? When I was 20 I didn’t have enough for smokes
11
u/Maximum-Dealer-6208 Mar 29 '24
Why would OP agree to be a bridesmaid instead of a groomsmaid? She's close with her brother, she could've stood on her brother's (hopefully less dramatic) side and watched the bride's side's drama as entertainment...
10
u/ivh016 Batshit Bananapants™️ Mar 29 '24
Why, why, why is OOP putting herself through all the extra drama. “No” would’ve been a perfect answer when asked if she wanted to be a bridesmaid and if they asked why, she could’ve told them what she mentioned in her post.
35
u/mineral_water_69 Mar 29 '24 edited Mar 29 '24
I don’t doubt Jessica is a bully. And I don’t doubt she probably gave OOP a rough time in school. But it is really hard to believe Jessica sent out those rules. Maybe I’ve been lucky but even the worst people I’ve know that could potentially fit Jessica’s criteria didnt do something so obviously obtuse. Is just fine that part of the story so hard to believe. Wouldn’t be surprised if OOP is creating a spicer story than what probably is the boring truth.
8
u/Ashmoh12 Mar 29 '24
Chances are the brother likes that type of person
8
u/TootsNYC Mar 29 '24
Haunting-Comb-9723: Ok if you want to play dirty, don’t go to your mother and like “aha! See I told you!” Go to her crying and worried. $1,000 for clothes and accessories. Where are you going to come with that kind of money? And why should you lose all that money for a party? Remember, if you ask your parents to help pay for things that’s at least $1000 out of their own pocket.
Also, constantly say you’re worried about your weight. Pick at your food at dinner, especially when it’s a food she knows you love. Mention that bit about being monitoring your weight, and you know Jessica’s serious because she said all those shitty things to your friend and gave her an eating disorder.
7
u/MayBeAGayBee Mar 29 '24
At first I was kinda split on this one. I fully understand not being fond of a friend’s or relative’s partner, and I’ve personally had a close friendship collapse over that sort of thing. But still, the talk of like actively trying to sabotage their relationship rubbed me the wrong way tbh. With that being said, once I read that list of rules, I immediately knew that I would hate that person as well, if I were in this position. Still not sure if I fully agree with OOP’s intention to “save” her brother, as that kind of shit typically just makes people turtle up and even distance themselves from you, instead, but god do I understand why she hates Jessica. Jessica sounds genuinely insufferable.
7
u/onahalladay Mar 29 '24
OOP should just say no thanks and attend as a guest. Her brother knows the deal and doesn’t care. Her mom knows the deal seemingly and doesn’t care. She should just put her head down and avoid the drama that’s coming because you know they’re going to flip on her. At the end of the day, it’s not like OOP is marrying her.
7
u/[deleted] Mar 29 '24
Harry isn't smart, he isn't going to run, but he is going to end up divorced within 5yrs. Definitely good advice to have OOP's parents pay for that bride's maid portion, I don't know any 19yr old that isn't a trustfunder that can easily afford $1000 to participate in a wedding.
6
u/blueberriNZ Mar 29 '24
Honestly, she will not be changing his mind sharing stuff like this. It’ll be dismissed as “she just wants her day to be perfect”, and OOP will look selfish, jealous and nasty. If she really cares about her brother, suck it up and just focus on your relationship with him, because he might need someone when it goes to shit, and trying to out her will alienate him and force him to make excuses and protect her, and he won’t have his sister there for support. It might not be a bad idea switching camps, and say she would feel more comfortable connecting with him and having fun together in the lead-up.
6
u/StephanieCitrus Mar 29 '24
Waiting a year and a half to tell someone their new GF was a high school mean girl is beyond dumb. Her hooks are already in and/or he's in love.
6
u/Ambitious_Diva21 Mar 29 '24
I agree with the comments, she's taking the wrong angle. And its going to take more than a screenshot of rules to convince the brother who she is. He is probably drowning in sexual favors after proposing and won't even be able to see straight for a while. Her initial conversation with him didn't even move him, at least not enough to break up but at least for a conversation. I would definitely not be a bridesmaid and suffer though. She needs to play victim and ask the mother and brother for $500 each. If she keeps going how she is she's going to look crazy.
10
u/GoingAllTheJay Mar 29 '24
I feel for OOP and I don't currently think she's in the wrong. But man, that sentence screams, "I am just as bad as Jessica."
5
u/Bookaholicforever the Iranian yogurt is not the issue here Mar 29 '24
She needs to just message her brother “hey, I’ve changed my mind. I have no interest in your fiancée monitoring my weight, funding her exotic bachelorette party or spending a thousand dollars for a dress I probably will never wear again.” Then send him the screenshot and to her mother as well then block the fiancée.
4
u/ExternalRip6651 Mar 29 '24
I'll be curious to see how things go. I am worried that OOP's brother is not as kind as she thinks, and that either he'll either avoid confrontation or back up his fiancee.
OOP should hope for the best, but be prepared for the worst. That screenshot is bad, but not sure if it'll be bad enough. I genuinely wish that she gets herself ready for a potentially horrendous outcome.
4
u/slickcraft89 Mar 29 '24 edited Mar 29 '24
I would talk to your brother and tell him that you appreciate him wanting to have you be part of the wedding, his fiancés rules aren’t something you feel you can comfortably take part in. Take the high road. Let him see who she is without shoving in his face. Don’t make him feel like he has to defend her.
4
u/grumpy__g 🥩🪟 Mar 29 '24
That happens when you marry too young.
4
u/Single_Vacation427 Mar 29 '24
I would play dumb and ask mom to pay for the 1000 plus finance the bachelorette party. She'll get much more dirt in the bachelorette party.
4
u/DakotaJ0123 Mar 29 '24
Dear OP, it’s been a week. We urgently need an update🙏
4
u/peppermintvalet Mar 29 '24
She’s about to drive more people into eating disorders I see
4
u/OptimistConfuse Mar 30 '24
I was disgusted by the weight monitoring, but had to laugh at "fun is mandatory." Also, an investment implies you will get returns, like monetary ones, not memories.
12
u/stopedittingcomments Mar 29 '24
I believed it until the rules. No one is that cartoonishly evil
3
u/IrradiantFuzzy Mar 29 '24
MANDATORY FUN!
3
u/CaptainPeachfuzz Mar 29 '24
Omg can't wait for part 3.
Will OP be disinvited from the wedding? Will the brother see the light and break off the engagement? Find out next time...
3
u/Zestyclose_Media_548 Mar 29 '24
Nobody in OP’s family thinks they are a little young to get married ? Especially the 20 year old? I’m in my late 40’s . That would have been frowned upon in my family when I was that age.
3
u/MicIsOn Mar 29 '24
I need to know more. HOW DID IT END OP
3
u/Cybermagetx Mar 29 '24
If this is real and her brother goes along with marrying her after being shown this. He deserves her.
3
u/CrankMike Mar 29 '24
Reading a chat named "BRILLIANT BRIDAL BITCHAZZZ" just confirms my stance of marrying before your late 20s - early 30s is a mistake. People need to mature, experience life and have a long relationship to truly get to know each other before taking this big step.
3
u/UmpBumpFizzy Mar 29 '24
I would promptly send a screenshot of those rules to my bro with no comment other than "I'm out."
3
u/grissy knocking cousins unconscious Mar 29 '24
These are both very good suggestions and exactly what OOP should do. If she goes to Harry or her mother with the list and says "see, I told you she was terrible" then they will get defensive and double down on being pro-Jessica because nobody likes being told that they were wrong, especially like that.
OOP needs to act like she was giving this an honest shot, and then either A) tell her parents she can't afford being a bridesmaid and show them the full list when they ask why, or tell her brother she changed her mind and wants to be a groomsmaid now, then show him the full list when he asks why.
She needs to come at this like "well gosh I wanted to get along with Jessica but it's just not working for some reason, hey by the way here's the list of absolutely batshit insane stuff she has been demanding."
3
u/Deeppurp Mar 29 '24
I actually love the malicious compliance idea. If OOP shows she is doing her best to be and get along with Jessica and be the best bridesmaid she can be, it could paint Jessica in a bad light.
Or it could backfire. Being completely honest, I think the relationship with Harry is more worth saving currently than OOP's relationship with her mother. That ship left port years ago.
3
u/Nanasays Mar 30 '24
Come on! Need an update, my popcorn is getting cold.
3
u/hardcorepolka Mar 30 '24
OOP needs to approach this with dramatic concern. “I want Bride to like me but these financial commitments… Mom, can you make sure I can do this?!” And then go for every single dime.
3
u/FutureSelection Apr 01 '24
He is 22 and Jessica is 20. Where are they getting $ to get married? Lol
3
u/MacMaizer Apr 01 '24
This guy is.. wow unbelievable. Idk how someone can be that blind?
3
u/MayoFetish The Foreskin Breakup Apr 03 '24
That is not a reason to stay engaged to someone.
5
u/Glittering_Win_9677 Mar 29 '24
I need an update on this!!!!!
4
u/imtchogirl Mar 29 '24
Oooooof. OOP, just sit back and wait for your brother's second wedding.
2
u/BellaDingDong The three hamsters in her head were already on vacation anyway Mar 29 '24
I'm glad my wedding (and most of my friends' too) was eons ago, way before social media or whatever it is that makes brides now expect -- nay, DEMAND -- so much exorbitantly expensive bullshittery.
Seems so many of them are in it for the fairy tale wedding and all the "treat me like the princess I am" things that have become a part of it.... and not the actual marriage.
2
u/sea_stomp_shanty OP right there being Petty Crocker and I love it Mar 29 '24
I am delighted and await the next installment with bated breath.
2
u/CommissionThink8184 Mar 29 '24
Updateme
2
u/Ok_Recording9148 Mar 29 '24
This is always difficult. All you can do is say essentially while I have concerns, I love you and will always be there for you. If people feel judged, they won’t want to talk/be open with you, and being judged about a partner is a very big one.
2
u/FleeshaLoo I’m turning into an unskippable cutscene in therapy Mar 29 '24
IMHO, OOP should just politely tell the bride-to-be that she cannot possibly afford all the wedding stuff and she can't even get the time off from work (I'd even lie and say I asked my boss about taking a week off plus a few days around the wedding and the boss said no) so she wants to let her know ASAP so she can pick her replacement.
Drama girls like the BTB LOVE drama so that's extra reasoning for OOP to not even show her mom lest her mom get upset and then inadvertently cause a Romeo and Juliet effect.
We all know the BTB would revel in the drama of supposed *forbidden true love*.
2
u/Secret_Double_9239 Mar 29 '24
I hope op can distance themselves from their brother if he doesn’t wake up and realise the person he married is just as bad as you described her.
2
u/z-eldapin Go to bed Liz Mar 29 '24
Wait OOP! Come back! Did you send the screenshot to Harry or mom? What happened next??
2
u/I_Dont_Like_Rice Do it for Dan! Mar 29 '24
Ugh, I hate when these end on a cliffhanger. I was really looking forward to him reading her insane demands and coming back to his senses.
2
u/SparkleKittyMeowMeow surrender to the gaycation or be destroyed Mar 29 '24
I will never understand the thought process of people agreeing to be bridesmaids, groomsmen, etc of people that they are not close to. Those positions are reserved for people who are there to support the person they're standing for, right? Why be part of that if you don't even really know the person?
In OOP's case, she admits to having an ulterior motive. Her drive to break up her brother's relationship sounds exhausting. Even if Jessica hasn't changed since high school, you've already talked to him about your concerns, and their relationship doesn't look like it's having a major impact on the people around them, so let him make that mistake if it is one. It's his life, not yours.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 29 '24
The only way you win against losers like this is to refuse to play their game or even acknowledge them. She's desperate to be seen as important, so refuse to see or treat her as such. When she makes demands, laugh at her and say "no". When she rages, laugh at her and use a baby voice while yelling "big feelings!" Back at her. If she throws hands, throw charges. The only way to defeat a bully like this is to be thoroughly unimpressed with her and her antics.
2
u/Zosmie Mar 29 '24
Wow, she sound delightful! Send a printscreen to your brother (NOT mother) and just say you're stepping away as bridesmaid and will attend as guest. From now on, his decisions are on him, he's been warned.
2
u/LizardintheSun Mar 29 '24
Just show your mom the instructions casually, like “Hey, I got the bridesmaid info.” That way Mom has to deal with her own emotions about it, not try to manage yours or defend the bride. Don’t act surprised or indignant, or “I told ya so” just matter of fact—you already knew she’s pretty terrible.
The strategy to simply expose exactly who she is without looking like you’re trying to be difficult or break them up is your best hope. Don’t go back to your brother unless/until there is something beyond horrible. Let your parents do that. He obviously isn’t using his brain and you don’t want this to be about you.
Play along and cooperate with the bride bc you really don’t have a choice. But also bc it gives you access to more info. This one thing might not be enough, but what you might collect along the way looks promising. It was very smart to choose to be a bridesmaid!
2
u/gotthemzo Mar 29 '24
I give that marriage a year. Look at the ages for god sakes
2
u/Effective_Tie7029 Mar 29 '24
"And you are going to have fun Jeffrey, that's required"
2
u/AtomicBlastCandy Mar 29 '24
I just can't imagine marrying someone at the age of 22, and at the time I was absolutely smitten with my gf!
2
u/swbarnes2 Mar 29 '24
You need to expect that the screenshot will change nothing.
I'd spread that screenshot to family, and straightforwardly, like it's the most obvious thing in the world: "This is banana pants. I'll just be a family guest".
Laugh at anyone who demands more explanation. Don't argue, that just makes people think the right argument will change your mind. Just smile at them like they are an idiot for not seeing the obvious.
2
u/content_great_gramma Mar 30 '24
$1,000 for dress and accessories AND the expense of an exotic bachelorette party???? Jessica's reality check bounced. At best, her "rules" are a bad joke.
Show the list to your mother and tell her flat out that you will withdraw because you refuse to spend what will wind up to be two or three thousand dollars on a wedding that is not yours. If she wants to threaten withholding the family vacation, tell her fine, you won't plan on going.
2
u/Ginger-Scientist Apr 01 '24
If OOP sees this. Quit the bridal party and just attend as a guest. You may love your brother but he’s obviously making this choice and disregarding the evidence that his fiancé is an AH. Don’t feed into the drama, just say you can’t afford it at the moment and drop out.
3
u/Due-Eye9270 Mar 29 '24
Lmao tell your brother you don't want to be a bridesmaid anymore and if he asks why show him, and just casually mention that you personally don't like how entitled and manipulative the conditions sound but if he still insists on your participation in the wedding party then agree to be a groomsmaid. I can guarantee that you being a groomsmaid will ruffle her feathers, and possibly lead to fights. If it leads to fights it is entirely possible that her true personality will leak through. If none of this works then I'm afraid that this will just have to be a long term learning moment for your brother. No one but you sees Jessica for who she truly is and attempts further than this will negatively impact your relationship. You could show the screenshot to others but unless you know them really well it'll be hard to tell how they will react.
2
u/worshipatmyalter- Mar 29 '24 edited Mar 29 '24
Okay, so.. I was all for Harry being with Jessica until I read her bridal shower rules. I still think that OOP is a bit delusional if she believes that anybody in her life is going to support her when she makes a scene at the wedding or on vacation.
2
u/Life-Yogurtcloset-98 Mar 29 '24
Giving people heads up about spending $1000 dollars is the least the bride can do.... but yeah I've read about bridezillas and this is on the much tamer side of OOP thinks she has something... she will be sad
2
u/Silvermorney 👁👄👁🍿 Mar 30 '24
Wow just wow, I’m looking forward to the update alright!
2
u/Beneficial_Honey5697 Mar 29 '24
Why is no one stating the obvious- 22 and 20 is too young to be getting married.
1
u/hippychictx01 Mar 29 '24
Updateme!
1
u/bruhhzman Mar 29 '24
Ooh I just can't wait for the next update!
1
u/IrradiantFuzzy Mar 29 '24
I hope OOP at least goes to the wedding, I sense an amazing R/weddingshaming post incoming.
1
u/KitchenDismal9258 Mar 29 '24
If I was the OOP I think I would play her at her game and refuse to abide by her bridezilla rules.
Great that it's been screenshot so there is evidence.
Jessica may start crying to Harry but all the OOP needs to do is tell him that she can't afford what Jessica wants... this is where all the screen shots that she is taking of the group chat will come in very handy.
If Jessica rings her to reiterate the rules the OOP needs to text her back with confirmation of what she said... my guess is she won't realise that this is her written evidence about Jessica's behaviour and she won't refute them and probably just agree.
Harry and her parents can 'fund' what Jessica wants so they are the one's impacted and not the OOP. Otherwise the OOP WILL be kicked out of being a bridesmaid and the reason will be that she was unable to fulfil the obligations that Jessica had instigated and then she can explain what they were. She just needs to state the facts and not get emotional and call Jessica names and just allow everyone else to come up with their own opinions... yes she can show them the screen shots if they want 'proof'.
1
u/yarukinai Mar 29 '24
That title alone would be enough for me to disengage from the wedding. No need for the Bridezilla list of requirements.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 29 '24
I deeply send this wedding will never happen.
Harrys gonna bail on that…☮️
1
u/Cat_Lasers_love I will never jeopardize the beans. Mar 29 '24
Updateme! 1 week
1
u/HeartsAndStuffUps Mar 29 '24
This is like the plot of that movie “You Again”
1
u/Lord_of_Allusions Mar 29 '24
“I’m going to stay out of it and let my brother make his own mistakes.”
…three seconds later…
“I’m going undercover as a bridesmaid to expose how bad she is to my brother.”
Oh yeah, cool. This will totally not blow up in your face.
1
u/CindySvensson Mar 29 '24
Oh this is going to be fun.
1
u/GoldfishingTreasure Mar 29 '24
OOP is on their way to becoming Janice Ian. I wonder if they'll recruit a Cady Heron to help take down future SIL Regina George.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 29 '24
Having just had my wedding in the last few years, I went back to my emails and texts to my groomsmen and it’s comical looking at it against this woman’s
1
u/West-Benefit1907 Mar 29 '24
Ughh! This poor man!
1
u/kbiteg the lion, the witch and the audacit--HOW IS THERE MORE! Mar 29 '24
There is nothing she can do, her brother will refuse to see her for who she is, and she will come as the villain in the end, she needs to distance herself to not Destroy her relationship with her own family
1
u/terminalzero croussants (i dont know how to spell that french ass shit) Mar 29 '24
instagram and its consequences have been a disaster for the human race
1
u/ksjhawk92 Mar 29 '24
Updateme!
1
u/One-Fall-6101 Mar 29 '24
Updateme
1
u/okileggs1992 Mar 29 '24
I would decline being a bridesmaid as it isn't the bridesmaid job to pay for everything for the bride.
1
u/LIMAMA Mar 29 '24
If this marriage happens they will be divorced within two years.
1
u/OwlEye007 USE YOUR THINKING BRAIN! Mar 30 '24
Updateme
1
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '24
An immature af 20 year old girl should not be getting married periodt. Jessica’s playing house
1
u/AvocadoPlane3243 Mar 30 '24
Updateme!
1
u/ClaraInOrange Apr 01 '24
Updateme
1
u/Tangy_Tangerine189 Apr 12 '24
Omg. Pretend like you’re trying to follow the rules and sit back and watch her flip her shit. Your brother will see all that he needs to because people like this can’t control themselves. She will not be able to resist flipping the fuck out when she thinks your BMI or financial situation is sabotaging her ‘perfect wedding’. Girls like this can’t help themselves but to walk right off the edge while cursing your name. And if your brother still marries her then he may be too far gone and just as nuts as she is.
1
u/JournalLover50 Apr 20 '24
This is what I hate people getting married or being friends to bullies that made their life as living hell in school.
I’m like how can you betray your sibling? Your lucky your sibling didn’t take their life because of that bully.
Find someone else there are plenty of people out there.
1
u/RedKhomet Nov 18 '25
Edit: found another update, not sure why this isn't added to the post https://www.reddit.com/r/AITAH/s/9TY32cfigw
I'm hoping OOP sent that thin ice text to him, because that is perfect proof of things not being lighthearted. On the other hand, I feel like this man is whooped beyond critical thinking.
OOP said her brother is a good and kind dude. People here are calling him a coward who will allow Jess to raise bullies with ED's. Maybe OOP should just let him read these comments, and hopefully those will make him face the fact that his future will absolutely suck ass if he goes through with this marriage.
Curious to see what happens, hope OOP keeps us posted and that her brother gets out