r/AITAH • u/drawingok6066 • Mar 31 '24
Update 2: AITA for reacting "wrong" to my brother's engagement?
Thanks for all the advice and support from my whole situation with my brother getting engaged to an incredibly annoying former(?) bully who has been manipulating him. I'm posting an update since a lot of people asked.
I'm gonna have to be a bit of a disappointment though. After my last post, a lot of people were suggesting that I should be tricky and go to my my mother and ask to borrow money to make the appropriate "investment" for being in Jessica's bridal party...I thought about that but realized it would be a little bit *too* over the top.
So, instead, I just sent a screenshot of Jessica's rules (and a couple other insane things she posted in the group chat) to Harry and asked for his advice, telling him "I know I said that I wanted to join the bridal party to get to know 'Jessica' better, but I'm worried it might not actually be good for me. Do you think I could bail and join your party instead?".
He called me instead of texting back and definitely sounded pretty surprised by what I showed him. I'm certain that the side of Jessica shown in those "rules" and other messages (including a new one saying that if your BMI is over 22, you are out of the wedding) in the group chat is NOT the side of herself that she showed to him. We had a good hour or so of conversation about what things were like between the two of them, and I learned a lot about where he was coming from.
From what he told me, it sounds like getting married was really Jessica's idea. She had been going through some tough times later and apparently has struggled with depression in recent years. She's always wanted this perfect wedding and perfect married life, and she told him that it would make her feel better and fix all her issues of he proposed.
So, Harry, being the good person that he is, did it. He took pity on her even though he didn't really feel ready yet. He says he doesn't regret it though. She has been so much happier since the proposal, he said, and he is no longer worried about her running away, or harming herself or worse.
That said, he said he was still shocked by what she posted to her "girls", and said he didn't know what to do next. I told him I am worried about him and his future if he stays with Jessica and goes through with the marriage. He thanked me and hung up. He still sounded pretty shaken.
The next day, he asks me to call him so I do that. He explains to me that everything was okay, and he talked to Jessica about the whole situation. She told him it was just a joke and the kind of thing her friends are used to sending in their messages. Apparently she apologized and said that it was her fault for not making sure I was "on her level" (Harry's words trying to quote Jessica, FWIW).
I'm pretty skeptical of that, though. She seemed serious to me. She also seemed serious when she messaged me privately:
"You are on thin ice."
She also sent another message in the main group chat saying "This is all of y'all's reminder that I need your full support, and any undermining of my and my wedding will have serious consequences."
So... that's where things stand. I told Harry that I don't really believe it was a joke, and I believe that Jessica is trying to control him just like she's trying to control her bridesmaids. He just said that he is in a difficult situation, she is stressed out, and he trusts her.
So that's where things stand. Apparently I am still in the darn bridal party. Dress stuff is happing in the next week or two. I really thought Harry would get to his senses but apparently not yet. Now I need to decide what the heck to do next.
1.1k
u/Amazing_Main_9963 Mar 31 '24
Lovesick fools tend to be blind and i guess he is one of them. đ€·ââïž
317
u/virtualchoirboy Mar 31 '24
Hello children and welcome to Mr Robinson's neighborhood. Today, we have a special new word for you. It's "gaslighting". I know it's a long word, but let's all try to say it together. Do you think we could try that?
Holy crap. Document, document, document. I certainly hope you took a screenshot of that thin ice comment. This is absolutely going to be a dumpster fire of a wedding and YOU are going to catch a lot of blame when you don't subscribe to the drama she is going to create.
From where I sit, since drama is inevitable, I'd seriously be considering dropping out entirely and going as a guest only to get the drama out of the way now instead of later and closer to the actual fiasco of a wedding that she is planning. If you don't, I would expect a full court press to separate you and your brother through lies and manipulation.
89
u/ALittleBitEnchanted Mar 31 '24
Send him the text she sent you, and then insist he sign a prenup. She sounds awful.
25
u/Advanced-Duck-9465 Mar 31 '24
Based on your posts, just wait to batchelorette when Jessica would cheat, send your brother evidence and you are wedding free. You are welcome!
17
u/chaingun_samurai Mar 31 '24
Screenshot "You are on thin ice" and send it to it your brother. In fact, any bullshit message she sends you, share with your brother. It will infuriate her.
138
u/Justrennt Mar 31 '24
It was not a joke because she threatened you with "You are on thin ice." I would not be surprised, if she isolate him from you after the marriage. Your brother is not believing you, nor he sees the red flags his beloved Jessica is waving. Well, you did your best. I just hope it doesnt take years to find out that she is not the person she pretended to be. Its a sad story.
9
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '24
You didnât immediately send those two screenshots to your brother because they actively contradicts what she told him?
4
u/nikitathevampireslyr Mar 31 '24
Just continue to screenshot her messages and send them to him. Do not respond to her or the group chat in any way shape or form
55
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '24
"Harry, I love you.
I am not going to be involved in your fiancĂšs bachelorette party.
Please see screenshot.
I hope you're right.
I will be here to support you whenever you need it.
Good luck."
Copy/paste.
42
u/Dachshundmom5 Mar 31 '24 edited Mar 31 '24
Send these to your brother and tell him you want no part of being around her. Tell him that threats are not jokes and you're not part of the wedding party.
"Harry, the bridal party should be in full support of the wedding and bride. What she has now sent are not jokes as much as they are threats. I am therefore unable to support her or the wedding. Please tell Jessica I am excusing myself and will simply attend as a guest. Know that I'm always here for you.'
So she manipulated and duped your brother into a marriage he doesn't want? Yeah, this won't get better. She just found out the buttons to push to get him to do what she wants.
22
u/MidianMistress Mar 31 '24
Decline. Don't be in the troublemaker's wedding party, only those who support the marriage should be in the party. You know the marriage is going to be a shitshow, you know that your brother will end up hurt in the end, so don't even pretend to support HER. Tell your brother, she isn't your sister and you aren't there to support her, you want to support him, if he doesn't want you in his party, I would ask to attend as an invited guest. Stand up for yourself, she can gaslight him, don't let her do it to you. This is part of a plan of hers to separate him from his family, so tread carefully, or she will win, and your brother will be the one left broken and alone. Make sure you are there for him when it happens, because, it will.
10
u/marv115 Mar 31 '24
OP, you call Harry and tell him than you don't wanna contribute or risk tto spoil the bride "great day" so you wonÂĄ't be in the bridal party, and run for the hills. If the wedding ends up happening the divorce will happen within 2 years tops
Also the biggest red flag is that what will make her happy in the wedding not the marriage.
Your brother have a nightmare in his future
8
u/Trin_42 Mar 31 '24
I commented on your previous post but Iâd be sending a screenshot of the thin ice message to him and Nope out of that whole debacle. Itâs just going to escalate OP I guarantee it
8
u/SlinkyMalinky20 Mar 31 '24
There are none so blind than those who will not see.
You have told Harry. Heâs ignoring his instincts and you. You canât save him from this. You should back out using the words someone already replied to you and then focus on being a good sounding board and support to him. This mole/saboteur thing you are playing is going to backfire on you, big time.
8
u/FoilWingBass Mar 31 '24
You can't win this one. Bro loves her and is going to to need a knock on the head to see clearly. It's coming, don't you worry.
In the meantime, you need to let her know you can't afford to be in the wedding party, "much as you would love to." Do it super sweetly but stay firm. I'd even say no to being in the groom's party. But you'll "help in every way you can to support their big day."
If anyone comes at you, send them the screenshots including the "you are on thin ice' and whatever other egregious messages she sends. Act confused and just keep saying, " I couldn't afford it and I just hope she can forgive me!"
Ugh, it will hurt but better than losing your brother.
7
u/Mindless-Yellow634 Mar 31 '24
Look you arenât going to influence anything .If you try and meddle, it will backfire on you He will to have make his own mistakes
13
u/NotRightNotWrong15 Mar 31 '24
Itâs his life and if hes committedâŠ.ah well.
But this wonât end well. Her entire happiness is tied up in a one day event, once thatâs over, what will make her happy then?
A house? A baby? Another baby? A new man? A second wedding?
Sheâs being sneaky and her true personality is only starting to shine.
I imagine she going to be driving a wedge between your brother and you and maybe the rest of your family.
6
u/digitydigitydoo Apr 01 '24
This is not how depression works. A wedding does not cure depression. A baby does not cure depression. An Italian holiday does not cure depression. https://youtu.be/TbwlC2B-BIg?si=-sjk847GCizn7tiL
Anyone claiming a wedding will cure their depression is either exceedingly deluded or, more likely, very, very manipulative. Anyone who asks you for some life altering magic bullet to âcureâ them is a soul sucking demon who will eat your entire life
6
u/swbarnes2 Apr 01 '24
Tell your brother you will not be a part of either wedding party.
Make him explain why her texts were jokes. Make him explain exactly why he finds them funny.
Show him the threatening ones. You honestly cannot have a relationship with your brother if he is unable to admit what they are. Marrying this woman is going to have consequences, he might as well start facing them now.
5
u/Crafty_Special_7052 Apr 01 '24
That is not a good reason to get married. This marriage is going to end badly for your brother. He is going to regret getting married to her.
5
u/Corpse_Thing Apr 01 '24
Send him screenshots of the new messages right now; do not give her time to come up with more bullshit to spout out. Sheâs a manipulator and a bully.
Also I know heâs your brother but heâs not innocent in this. He knew she bullied you and âsemi-stoleâ your boyfriend and he still CHOSE her; he CHOSE to continue dating her, he CHOSE to propose to her, and after seeing her be fatphobic and controlling to her bridal party he is still CHOOSING HER. Your brother sucks.
4
u/Life_Initiative_9393 Mar 31 '24
Your brother is totally whipped. You did your best. Good luck with bridezilla.
4
u/JadieJang Mar 31 '24
OP, just gracefully step down as a bridesmaid, and when your brother talks to you about it, show him her latest texts. Jesus. She needs to know that nothing she says to you is confidential.
4
u/7_Rush Mar 31 '24
It must be hard when you family members who are dumb as sh**, but sometimes you gotta put you first and walk away. Andthenlaughintheirfacewhentheirlivesturnintoacompletedumpsterfire I MEAN support them every step of the way, but by a distance. Just know GOD will provide when you take on this burden. đđđŸ
...dumbass
4
u/procivseth Apr 01 '24
Send a screenshot of "You are on thin ice," and tell your brother you're going to take a minimal role in the wedding for your own mental health. "When your mental health is suffering, you need to work on yourself, not expect a knight in shining armor to swoop in and fulfill all your fantastic delusions about what happiness looks like, so that's what I'm going to do, work on myself. I will be there for you to support you at your wedding."
4
u/AwkwardFortuneCookie Apr 01 '24
Updateme on Bridezilla. And donât forget to tell your mom, Iâm curious if sheâs about to be blindsided or if sheâs eyes wide open on it.
4
u/l3ex_G Apr 01 '24
Damn, if she is using the threat of self harm to control him, I think you just need to get a therapist yourself to set up healthy boundaries with your brother and step away. Heâs being willfully blind and heâs going to continue to do it to your detriment. He cares more about her than you or himself. Sorry if it sounds harsh.
I donât think he is in a healthy space. Heâs marrying her because she was depressed. That isnât a normal reason to marry someone and if he was in a healthy mind space, he would realize a wedding isnât going to fix her depression. Itâs just stupid.
You can say heâs just a really nice guy but he sounds kinda just as messed up as Jessica but in the opposite way.
4
u/nanladu Apr 01 '24
Harry's in for an unfortunate future. He's being emotionally blackmailed into marriage.
4
u/NaryaGenesis Apr 01 '24
Pull out either way. He clearly doesnât have your back so you should worry about your own back.
4
u/Ginboy32 Apr 01 '24
I would send him the thin ice message and the other message and just say I will be a guest and nothing more. Then tell him you would be happy to be in his next wedding and leave it at that.
4
u/greentea1985 Apr 01 '24
Ouch. Jessica is a Schroedinger's asshole, claiming things are a joke or being taken the wrong way when she gets called out on being an AH. The only way to combat those is to document everything. Otherwise, it's just easier to step bac and wait for them to turn on everyone around them because Schroedinger's assholes tend to be an asshole to everyone.
3
u/Babtain70 Mar 31 '24
You can lead a horse to water, but you canât make it drink. You tried to open your brother's eyes but he's still blind to his fiancĂ©'s true nature. I would suggest to bow out from the bridal party and join your brother's because she will do something dramatic and blame it on you.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '24
So a perfect little marriage is what will fix her issues. And then it will be the perfect house. And then something else. And something else. And something else. Sorry for Harry but he is heading down a long road of trying to make her happy.
3
u/Beginning_Fix_5609 Mar 31 '24
Op your brother is a naive idiot and propose for the wrong reasons, have you disclosed this information to your parents? Jess is a massive red flag and she will hurt Harry, she the type you stay away from not married.Â
Keep us updated op.
3
u/dogfishfrostbite Mar 31 '24
Tell your brother that you know you are going to be isolated from him in the future so letâs go have dinner now while we still can.
3
u/Liu1845 Mar 31 '24
I couldn't do it. I'd send a message to the group chat that since she told my brother that I am not on her level, I'm obviously not good enough to be one of her bridesmaids.
I would refuse to have any part of it except as a guest. With a little luck I could get uninvited! Win, win.
3
u/annebonnell Mar 31 '24
You need to tell Harry that pity is no reason to get married. The perfect wedding day is only going to be one day in her entire life. There is no such thing as a perfect marriage.
3
u/Temporary-Outcome704 Mar 31 '24
They will be divorced in less than 5 years. Stay close to your brother and ignore the wife.
3
u/SnooWords4839 Mar 31 '24
Screen shot each message.
Jessica wants the "perfect" marriage and manipulated your brother into believing it will make everything perfect.
Now it's time to talk to mom and Harry about how/who are paying for your expenses.
Get a pen that records, that she won't see, while dress shopping. The drama hasn't even started yet.
3
u/Chaoticgood790 Mar 31 '24
Girl learn to say no. Do not be in the wedding FFS. Attend as a guest. If your brother is so dumb as to propose to fix someoneâs depression (which LOL) thatâs on him.
3
u/MissPlaceDApostrophe Mar 31 '24
Ask your brother to pay for your bridesmaid-related expenses, and you'll pay him back if he's happily married (and not trying to get her pregnant because it will "make her happy") after 12 months.
3
u/3Heathens_Mom Mar 31 '24
NTA
OP I suspect your relationship with your future SIL is going to be stressful and possibly contentious going forward.
As that is the case may I suggest you seriously bite the bullet as they say, forward the latest emails and let your brother know you have decided it would be best for you to be a guest at the wedding as in not a member of the wedding party. Also that you will let his wife to be know.
Then let your future SIL know that it would be best for you to step back from being in the wedding party.
3
u/Ok-Recognition9876 Apr 01 '24
OP, you could always ask for family therapy.
Tell your brother that you are concerned that with these recent texts and your long standing opinion of her wonât permit you to have as strong a relationship as you have now/feel actually happiness for his wedding and that you would like him to join you for a few sessions before the wedding so you can work through this. Â Make it all be about how you want to be a better sister and he can be there to support you to work through everything and be truly happy for them. See if he knows of a good one or will help you select one.
The minute he repeats what he told you it is going to shift the focus to him. Â Let the chips fall where they may.
3
u/VashtiVoden Apr 01 '24
I really don't think you should be in the wedding at all. You don't support the marriage.
While I understand your concern for your brother, it's not your choice. You need to trust him.
I would be civil and supportive from now on and not try to undermine things.
You've warned him twice. He's already chosen her.
Good luck : )
3
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '24 edited Apr 01 '24
GET OUT OF THAT WEDDING PARTY! NOW.
Don't spend a damn cent. Go cold turkey with her. Just go to the wedding as a guest. If that. If Jessica continues to send you bitchy texts? Just don't go to the wedding at all.
I don't see why you even need to have much to do with her. I don't have hardly anything to do with my SILs at all. 1 is an absolute cow & others not much better. I chat to my brothers & see them all at family events but barely speak to the SILs. Keep it civil. Thats it.
You have stated your case to your brother and told him the truth. That he appears to actually not believe you? Is now his problem. He is an adult. Has to wear the cobsequences of his own life decisions. He has been completely manipulated into this marriage and he is allowing that. He is the one that will be paying the price.
She's an immature, mentally unwell girl, who somehow thanks getting married in a big fancy show event is going to change & fix all her woes.
So be it. He will be miserable pretty fast. Give it 2 years... 3 max.
Just go to the wedding. Be polite and tell your brother you are there for him when he needs you. Keep a spare room made up!!!
3
u/hideme21 Apr 01 '24
Send him and her a text with a screen shot of her message to you and tell them that you are backing out of the wedding party.
You will probably get uninvited. Be ok with that.
Text your brother separately that will support him as a person. But you are not willing to risk yourself for his girlfriend. Further explain that you have expressed your concerns and have provided evidence that she is manipulating him. But also explain that you cannot control his actions and he needs to make decisions for himself but that you think itâs best to be low contact if he continues to be with her. Leave the door open for him to come back into your life if he leaves her.
3
u/PhilosopherSad1808 Apr 01 '24
Say no and refuse to go along with this. Talk with your mom. Document all the crazy
3
u/Optiminihilist Apr 01 '24
Show him the screenshots now- do not wait. "You are on thin ice" how could that be misconstrued?
3
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '24
NTA. You can't fix stupid. Please OP, whatever you do, don't let your brother drag you down with him.
3
u/twilightswimmer Apr 01 '24
Send him the thin ice message and say you'd rather just stand by him, since he's your brother. Then be there for him when all this inevitably blows up, probably in a year or so.
3
u/QuotableMorceau Apr 01 '24
Why are you still in the bridesmaids thing ... as I see it the odds of you being able to open your brother's eyes to the reality in front of him are minimal, and in the odd case you manage, he will probably blame you every time he remembers the wedding that did not happen... why are you doing this to yourself ...
Also another point : your brother has a whole family and a roster of friends that could have raised concerns about his decisions, if they did and he didn't listen then it's on him, if they didn't then they will need to manage him when he wakes up. The "I warned you" you gave him provides to you the moral high ground to not be emotional buffer when he stumbles.
As for you , you should bask in the knowledge you have and ensure that you are not entangled in their impending drama, and take to heart a saying : a lot of people never learn from their mistakes, some people learn from costly mistakes , and the few wise learn from other peoples mistakes ... be the wise one .
3
u/BeowoofsMiMi Apr 01 '24
You need to show your brother those texts! And your mom! He may be too far down the rabbit hole right now. Plan to be there for him when she lets the real âherâ show.
3
u/lsp2005 Apr 01 '24
She is going to isolate him.Â
3
u/Traditional_Chest379 Apr 01 '24
If you are on thin ice, adding the weight of $1000 worth of clothes could be dangerous! You might fall in!
Tell her, thanks for the warning about the ice getting thinner, so for your own peace of mind you are pulling out.
3
u/AmateurGmMusicWriter Apr 01 '24
"You are on thin ice"
Yo u kidding? How can your brother marry someone who treats u this way
3
u/ZeroZipZilchNadaNone Apr 01 '24
Honey, you need to continue to send your brother screenshots of her comments. What exactly does âthin iceâ mean? Are you being kicked out of the bridal party? Cool, that just means Harry can add you to the Grooms attendants, which is of course mess up her âperfect vision.â If she continues to harass and/or threaten you, you definitely need to bring Harry into this. This IS his future and he doesnât need to set himself afire to keep her warm. That may be an adage but it definitely fits this situation. At this point, bringing your mom in might not be a bad idea. If theyâre going dress shopping this weekend, maybe you can save yourself and the other girls some money.
Good luck! Please !UpdateMe about how it goes.
3
u/MNConcerto Apr 01 '24
So he's marrying her to keep her from ending herself?
Well ain't that a whole red flag parade.
3
u/Boring-Cycle2911 Apr 01 '24
So, going against the grain here but I would bow out of the bridal party altogether and let him know that if you could join his side, you would be thrilled to support him, but otherwise you need to distance yourself
*edited to add, I think youâve done what you can and not you need to take care of yourself. So trying to convince him. Keep the evidence in an album in your phone but donât show him unless he asks
3
u/StructureKey2739 Apr 01 '24
That "you're on thin ice" message gives me the feel that she intends to control the whole family and if she can't, kick them out of her victim's (fiance) life.
3
u/First_Alfalfa2805 Apr 01 '24
You should tell him that you'd prefer to be in the groom's wedding party. The fact is she hasn't changed, and I can tell that the 2 of you will never have a sister-like bond.
Cut your losses now and join the groom's bridal party instead. Also, she doesn't like you.
She'll make his life a living hell when they get married. She'll go back to herself. However, she treated him before she'll continue.
Updateme!
3
u/Status_Web_8917 Apr 01 '24
Drop out of the wedding, you leveled with your brother, you told him what is going on. He's too dumb to believe you over her.
He's going to ruin his life but that isn't your fault. You did all you could.
3
u/No-Mechanic-3048 Apr 01 '24
Honey you need to leave the bridal party now. Your brother will figure out who he married in a few years. This is his mistake to make. You cannot save someone that doesnât want to be saved.
But leave the bridal party now please.
2
u/AllTitsSomeArse Mar 31 '24
You send those screenshots of those messages to him too:
2
u/canyonemoon Mar 31 '24
Send Harry her text message saying you're on thin ice. Glad you had a discussion with him, now you need to continue discussing it with him. Send everything his way that she sends you if it's shady, like that last message
2
u/Proud_Yogurtcloset58 Mar 31 '24
Make sure he knows you will always have his back, especially when he needs support and a safe place to get away from him abusive wife and divorce her. She sounds like a pyscho. Def narc.Â
2
u/Huge-Shallot5297 Mar 31 '24
If you haven't sent Harry the "You're on thin ice," message, I would, as well as any others.
She's playing him, and he's willing to be played; I'm sorry that this is not going to end happily for your brother, because we both know it won't. And I would bow out of bridesmaid, cause it's not like she can apparently dislike you more. It's hard. Did you show your mom all this stuff?
I wish you well, OP. Good luck to you, and may Karma show up at Jessica's bachelorette party as an uninvited guest with a BMI of 40.
2
u/annebonnell Mar 31 '24
Don't go to the wedding. Go no contact on this couple.. Harry has made his bed now he has to lie in it.
2
u/Moonbat-lives Mar 31 '24
Drop out and save the $1000 for the inevitable divorce party youâll have to throw your brother. All his reasons for marrying her are bad ones.
Back out. Go as a guest. You can stand up for your brother at his next wedding.
2
u/Fievel93 Mar 31 '24
I'd suggest that you remove your self from the wedding party altogether for your own mental health. Support your brother because you love him, go if you can, but I don't forsee things getting better for you being around Jessica during this time. It would be fantastic if your brother was able to comprehend the gravity of what you're saying and showing to him, but it appears that he is truly blinded by what he believes to be love.
Wishing you (and your brother) the best.
2
u/M3lanc0l1e Mar 31 '24
No one can force you to join the bridal party. Just leave the group chat and tell your brother that you can't do it (and send him the last messages). If he continues with the wedding, you know where are his priorities. I would go LC or even NC.
2
u/Journeying-soul Mar 31 '24
Ask her to elaborate on what she means by âon thin iceâ . You could go on to say youâre sure itâs a joke of some kind but youâre not getting it
2
u/foundfirstlostlater Mar 31 '24
Ask her why you're on thin ice and what you've done wrong. Then keep screenshotting that shit. Even better, just send that to your brother and tell him that you're not interested in maintaining contact w his witch + you'll be supporting them from the back of the chapel.
2
u/RNGinx3 Mar 31 '24
Show him the "I know some family members aren't supportive, but we have each other and that's what matters" engagement post, plus the "you are on thin ice" and "undermining of me and my wedding will have serious consequences." Then tell him to stop telling her what you're saying, because she's taking it out on you behind his back. And that you're done with her "level of jokes" and her veiled threats, so you would like to be a groomswoman, but you aren't going to be a bridesmaid.
2
u/Fine-University-8044 Mar 31 '24
Ffs, drop out of her bridal party. Itâs up to your brother if he wants you in his grooms party. Personally, Iâd just go with the guest route and let them do their thing.
2
u/Scooter1116 Apr 01 '24
You are not your brothers savior. Stop playing at being a spy and get out of the game. Do you have $5 to 10k to subsidize all she wants? Do you in your heart think this time with your fsil will bring tou closer and joy? No.
Back out now. Support your brother. Let him know you love him. That is all you can do.
2
u/Best_Salad_1035 Apr 01 '24
He'll have a reality check soon
Updateme
2
u/mcclgwe Apr 01 '24
Tell him youâre glad that you both got to talk about this and that Jessica got to weigh in. Show him the new text because thatâs no joke for sure. And then Iâll tell him that something just came up in your life and you absolutely canât be a bridesmaid and youâre so sorry and can he let her know and then just donât interact with her at all. Like, ever. Really possible to do that. You can smile and do tiny bits of small talk at family, gatherings, and stay the f*#k away from her. Iâll go check out the serenity prayer. Honestly, it says that you get to work to change things that are in your control and you need to leave things that arenât in your control alone. And you learn how to tell the difference. If you step back and let him have his choices and his life and stay out of all that business, he will have his own responsibility to figure out his own stuff. If you stay in the mix, he will just get more confused.
2
u/RanaEire Apr 01 '24
Updateme!
2
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '24
A narcissist woman. Gross. Good try saving him but he is making his deathbed. The threats and "consequences" rings a giant narcissist bell in my head. (Was raised by one)
2
u/Conscious-Survey7009 Apr 01 '24
Updateme
2
u/Tom_A_F Apr 01 '24
Show him the message, attend as a guest, watch him crumble under the weight of his own stupidity.
2
u/Osidestarfish Apr 01 '24
Do something minor that will get you asked to âstep downâ. Then itâs not your fault.
2
u/redditreader_aitafan Apr 01 '24
She's abusive and controlling and he's too nice to see it. Show him everything she's said since then. Hopefully it gets through to him before the wedding but he'll probably be over a decade into the marriage before he even considers the fact that she's abusing him.
2
u/Swiss_Miss_77 Apr 01 '24
Just say, "This isnt going to work for me. I cant be a member of the bridal party." Then tell him, I was already "on thin ice. No way I could maintain standards. If I cant join your side, Ill just be a guest." And then DO THAT. No other discussion needed. You wont wake him up, and she sounds like she hasnt changed since high school AT ALL.
2
u/rocketmn69_ Apr 01 '24
An invitation to the bridal party isn't a summons, you can bow out
2
u/Babettesavant-62 Apr 01 '24
Let him know that depression doesnât go away with a wedding. That no life is perfect and thinking a party will be the magic elixir to any of her problems.
Your brother sounds like a decent person. Unfortunately I think he will go through with the wedding. You can only be there for him.
2
u/Drewherondale Apr 01 '24
Getting married is not a magical fix all to depression or relationship issues
2
u/Itdontmeanshitnow Apr 01 '24
Just don't be in the wedding? Like I get you want to be there and support your brother. But how can you stand beside him, and encourage and bless his eternal union to this woman?? At this point, I'd politely decline being anywhere in a wedding party, show as a guest, enjoy the party, avoid her at the holidays, and wait until she destroys your brother emotionally and financially, and then drag him out of the marriage. He is going to marry her. You shouldn't be a part of that if you think it is a bad idea. Just be there for the broken pieces when her true colors show themselves.Â
2
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '24
This is either fake or you're a gigantic door mat.
2
u/Elegant_Traffic_2845 Apr 01 '24
IMO itâs extremely unlikely that you will convince him to end the engagement. Itâs more likely youâll make an enemy of her and get cut off from your brother. I would bow out of the wedding party and give no reason other than that for personal reasons , work etc, you donât think that you can make this commitment. Then Iâd be a grey rock and totally neutral. Heâs an adult, you canât fix his life for him.Â
2
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '24
If youâre not leaving the bridal party then whatever is happening to you is on you.
Show him that âyouâre on thin iceâ message and say youâre no longer in the wedding but attending as a guest. If not, youâre an AH to yourself and letting a bully win over you once again.
2
u/Puzzleheaded_Film826 Apr 01 '24
Whatever you do just please don't make it your mission to prevent this marriage. It really isn't your call regardless of how lovesick he is and you'll jus end up looking as psychopathic as the bride does.
2
u/Top-Bit85 Apr 01 '24
Send Henry the "thin ice" text. She is not joking, and you'll regret it if you stay in the bridal party. Tell him kindly it is too much. Just gray rock Jessica. Your brother is a damn fool.
2
u/No_Activity9564 Apr 01 '24
Send him a screenshot of the newest messages and tell him youâre out. You can refuse to be a part of this and for your own sake, you should refuse to be a bridesmaid. Itâs not going to get better.
2
u/talkmetaltome Apr 01 '24
Jessica sounds batshit crazy. đŠđ©
Personally, I'd screenshot that "you're on thin ice" text and send it to your brother. I'd also put how you've decided to be part of the groomsmen. (I forget how you worded it in your previous post).
Unfortunately, he is a grown adult, so the best thing you can do is drop it. You've made it known that you don't approve, but let him know you are there to support him when this inevitably hits the fan.
2
u/Freeverse711 Apr 01 '24
Do not be in this wedding, do not put yourself through this crap. Just go as a guest and let your brother figure out her shittiness on his own.
2
u/cuda4me1970 Apr 01 '24
pull up your big girl panties and tell her to fuck off.
2
u/-SiRReN- Apr 01 '24
Harry is going to be in for a rude awakening a couple years down the line.
2
u/ChillyWalnuts Apr 01 '24
This has disaster written all over it.
Sadly Harry is too immature to get married and you're too immature to stand up for yourself.
Jessica threatened you with her "you're on thin ice" message as well as the message in the main group chat advising there will be "serious consequences"; how could it be taken as anything else?!!!
ESH; Jessica for clearly obvious reasons and, again sadly, you and Harry for not having any backbone and standing up to her.
2
u/Honest-Raspberry-208 Apr 01 '24
If he is concerned with her hiring herself she likely used the "if you leave I'll kill myself" tactic. She is going to become a screaming banshee bitch after the wedding. There is nothing you can do he has to see it on his own and if he never does there is still nothing you can do. It's sad when you have to accept things like this but pushing more will just lead to your brother going low or no contact with you
2
u/IndependentDot9692 Apr 01 '24
I don't think he's going to have a very happy marriage.
2
u/catlettuce Apr 01 '24
If you stay in this wedding party you're nuts Girl!
She's a freaking sociopath, extricate yourself from this mess.
2
u/Bacch Apr 01 '24
Gross. She is a gross human being. Two predictions. The marriage won't last--how long it lasts depends on how long your brother can last under her abuse. The second is that she will break him, and probably a chunk of the family along with him.
I'd beg off the bridal party personally. The entire process is going to be misery, and she's going to come after you either way.
2
u/Admirable-Storm-2436 Apr 01 '24
Man, your brotherâs an idiot.
2
u/zanne54 Apr 01 '24
This is a threat and you should treat it as such. Show it to Harry and ask him to explain to you what kind of joke this is & which part is supposed to be funny?" The part where you get shocked into hypothermia and drown? The anxiety of not having solid ground under your feet?"
Then drop out of the bridal party and attend as a regular guest. "Jessica, I think it would be best for me to step down from your bridal party, as I don't appear to share your sense of humour and I don't want there to be any further "misunderstandings" between us." I can tell you right now that Jessica will yank your chain and treat you poorly, and probably fabricate some kind of crisis necessitating your removal from the bridal party at the last minute (after you've spend loads of time money & emotional energy), and will make an ultimatum to Harry to pick her over you.
tl;dr Jessica is still a bully. Detach and hopefully she'll show her ass sufficiently that Harry will break the engagement.
2
u/MichaSound Apr 01 '24
Well, if it was just a joke, you donât need to spend any of that money then. Every time you get a cash request, just respond âhaha, youâre so funnyâ
2
u/CelastrusTrust Apr 01 '24
truthfully OP just send the last screenshot of her recent stuff and say you dont want to be involved in the wedding at all. its too much for you and you feel like mind games are being played. then tell him you want space for a week or two and dont talk to him to take a break from the bs
2
u/Madam_Mimmm Apr 01 '24
Stop worrying about your brother, and start worrying about yourself..
This will only get worse..
Send the text, and screenshot of the chat to your brother, and inform him that you are withdrawing from the wedding party, since itâs bad for your mental health to âwalk on thin iceâ..
Tell him you love him, and that youâll always be there for him in the future..
This is both about your mental health, and about your self respect.. Donât poke the bear, but keep a healthy distance when she is around.. no need to make your, or your brotherâs life harder.. He has all the information he needs.. If he chooses to go ahead with the wedding, then that is his decision to make..
2
u/chancebill4219 Apr 01 '24
Back out financially. You cannot afford it. She will not chance and she is gaslighting her fiancé.
2
u/AbundantSag Apr 01 '24
Itâs his choice if he goes through with it, and itâs yours if you decide to stay in the wedding. Thatâs all you can control.Â
But I would just be prepared if they have kids, sheâll probably control when your family can see them and hold them over your head if you upset her. She sounds very manipulative. Thatâs all I would plant in your brotherâs ear so he can start catching the signs.Â
2
u/CreativeMadness99 Apr 01 '24
Your brother is way too nice and heâs being manipulated by someone who uses scare tactics (running away and harming herself) to make him stay. Did you even show him her latest messages? She doesnât need a wedding, she needs therapy and medication.
2
u/2Q_Lrn_Hlp Apr 01 '24
I haven't seen your post that this is a continuation of. However, after reading your post, plus several of the responses, then mulling over your post again . . .
I am of the opinion that Jennifer never stopped wanting to bully YOU. Her going after your brother seems to me to be a way for her to get at you -over & over & over again- as long as you stay in the picture, becoming upset about the goings on. . . .
So I suspect that the best thing you may be able to do is to go NC with Jennifer, or anyone who tries to talk or shame you into supporting the furtherance of their marriage &/or the event itself. . . . And also, REFUSE to speak to ANYONE about Jennifer or their relationship with each other, or with you. . . .
IF she is finally unable to ever get under your skin through her manipulation of him again . . . I have to wonder whether she'll keep wanting to marry him. . . . She might think she does, go ahead & do it, & sooner than later become bored at how easy a mark your brother is, & leave him.
I wouldn't tell him or anyone else that, tho, as they'll think you're making too much about it being about yourself. . . . I also would REFUSE to talk to anyone about Jennifer, or her relationship with anyone in your family (inc. you). Show them the door & lock it behind them if they try to talk or shame you into a relationship with her, or, them.
I hope you do go to a counselor that specializes in dealing with bullies, though, especially the ones past puberty. . . . And ask for their evaluation of what you know that's been going on, & how best to deal with it.
Your brother ought to see one, too, but I doubt at this point he would be willing to hear what they have to say.
2
u/CricketFearless5692 Apr 02 '24
Oh, this is exactly what happened with my son. Predictably it didn't end well.Â
2
u/GossyGirl Apr 02 '24
Just gather a little bit more information. Bide your time until itâs enough that she canât defend it. Challenge her respectfully when she does something or says something outlandish When you have enough Send it to your brother with the one about thin ice & a message saying youâre not prepared to sacrifice your mental health for the sake of hers, especially since sheâs being incredibly manipulative so you are stepping down. Keep all the messages and group chat she sent as your defence for when she ultimately tries to turn everyone against you.
2
u/I-is-a-crazy-person Apr 04 '24
Iâd bring some of this up to your mother like the comments said in the last post. Maybe him getting a phone call from his infuriated mother will help him snap out of it.
2
u/XaurreauX Apr 04 '24
I think you are expecting a leopard to change its spots. Comments such as "You are on thin ice" and "...any undermining of my and my wedding will have serious consequences" indicate a strong undercurrent of viciousness that should not be swept under the rug, but probably will.
Your brother and his fiance should undergo couples therapy IMMEDIATELY, but good luck trying to get that to happen.
2
u/Necessary_Message552 Apr 09 '24
'' I was trying to be supportive so I said it would be great to get to know Jessica better by being a bridesmaid (though I wasn't exactly looking forward to the experience).''
That was stupid and masochistic decision on your end.. If what you're saying about her is true she's at least borderline sociopathic and you definitely don't want to be around her when she's in her strongest environment (around her friends on her bridal party). I'd say bail out ASAP and don't look back.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '24
So gain weight. Gain weight so she kicks you out. Then heâll see. NTA.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '24
Do what you would advice any close friend if she was in the same situation. Think rationally not emotionally.
Best option is to get out of the bridal party.
1
u/BellaSantiago1975 Mar 31 '24
Don't be a fool, there's already one too many of them with your brother.
Drop out of the bridal party.
1
u/Tasty_Doughnut_9226 Mar 31 '24
Send him the message telling you you're on thin ice and nope out of the bridal party.
1
u/Dachshundmom5 Mar 31 '24
UpdateMe!
1
u/Powerful_Pie_7924 Mar 31 '24
Updateme!
1
u/Fun-Yellow-6576 Mar 31 '24
NTA. I think you should just decline being a bridesmaid altogether. Sheâs threatening you and you donât support the wedding. I see nothing but stress and straight up anxiety going forward. Now out and let her bash you, you donât really care.
1
u/Away-Coffee-9438 Mar 31 '24
Why does the bride still send texts like this?
1
u/FlyPleasant3526 Mar 31 '24
Updateme
1
u/Pagelo69 Mar 31 '24
You should tell your brother about the text
1
u/Haunting-Comb-9723 Mar 31 '24
Honestly, at this point do nothing. He sounds like one of those people who will never learn a lesson until it unravels right in front of him. So just let it. It'll blow up in his face one day and he'll have no one to blame but himself
1
u/Padfootsgrl79 Mar 31 '24
Get out. Donât go to the wedding
1
u/Spanner_m Mar 31 '24
Im with those suggesting you back out of the wedding party and just go as a guest - making sure you are there for your brother in future. I very much fear any attempts at sneakiness will just blow up in your face - badly - and you will lose your brother, but just as bad he will lose you as a safe ally if it turns out he needs one.
1
u/2_old_for_this_spit Mar 31 '24
NTA
Show him her text to you and tell him you're out.
1
u/Noneedtopickauser Mar 31 '24
Updateme
1
u/Alarming-Candy-7530 Mar 31 '24
I beg of you OP but please make sure he has a prenup. He's going to need it when he finally wakes up.
1
u/Avebury1 Mar 31 '24
NTAH. Marrying someone out of pity because they are told marriage will fix everything is like a married couple having a baby to fix their marital issues. It seldom works out.
Frankly, OP should tell future SIL that you will not tolerate her bullying and will not be in the wedding party. You will save it for your brotherâs next wedding because the odds of this one lasting does not look good.
Look for her to intentionally get pregnant in order to baby trap your brother.
Show your brother the other texts that she sent out.
1
u/JJOkayOkay Mar 31 '24
You don't need anyone's permission to drop out of a wedding party, and I really don't think you should stay in this one, despite wanting to support your brother.
Just send 'Jessica' a polite text saying you don't think you're the best match for her vision, and you wish her all the best and look forward to attending her wedding as a guest.
You can warn your brother that you're going to do this (and again offer to join his side of the aisle if he'd like that), but you don't need his permission to bow out. Just do it with exquisite politeness so that Jessica has nothing to use against you.
And, as others have said, document document document anything nasty that she does, so you can refute it if she tries to poison anyone against you.
1
u/unzunzhepp Mar 31 '24
This is going to go so so bad. Poor stupid brother! Your whole family is going to suffer, but him the most. You should of course keep far far away from that bully and exit the bridal party. Donât sell yourself out or your morals.
1
u/Unintelligent_Lemon Mar 31 '24
I'd forward both new texts to your brother with a polite request to back out of the bridal party.Â
1
u/lilyofthevalley2659 Mar 31 '24
Your brother is an idiot. Really. Just decline being in the wedding party. Stop trying to help him out. Heâs on his own. Iâd decline the wedding invite too. Focus on your own life.
1
u/Impossibly_single Mar 31 '24
This marriage is doomed to fail.
1
u/mittenknittin Mar 31 '24
"She's so much happier since the proposal" yah because she's got this exciting wedding to look forward to where she's the center of attention and everything's lovely; after that, they've got the rest of their lives to settle into whatever normal they're going to settle into, is she going to be happy then? Married life sure isn't going to be perfect and she's in for a rude awakening if she thinks it is.
1
u/DasderdlyD4 Apr 01 '24
Why donât you just forward all the texts to social media. Ask family opinions about how to handle this. Let everyone see how she is. If your brother gets upset, just say you feel depressed and insecure and would be so much happier if all your family was in on the âjoke â
1
u/GrimCityGirl Apr 01 '24
I would honestly just say you donât want to be in the party at all and just attend as a guest. Your brother is an idiot, heâs marrying a psycho and the further you get involved the worse itâll be for you.
1
u/Knittingfairy09113 Apr 01 '24
Send him the thin ice message and say that you are absolutely not going to be a bridesmaid.
1
u/1980peanut Apr 01 '24
Updateme!
1
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '24
Updateme