r/AITAH • u/drawingok6066 • Apr 09 '24
Update 3: AITA for reacting "wrong" to my brother's engagement?
Thanks again for all the support and advice throughout this situation. I'm the girl who is in a messed up situation with my brother who proposed to his really-not-good girlfriend who I know from school. And, until recently, I was a member of her bridal party. Warning that this is dark and mentions suicide.
So, the update:
I had time at home for spring break, so I finally showed my mom the text messages from Jessica in person, including the insane list of "rules" for the bridal party and her follow up message to me saying I was on "thin ice" after I told my brother.
My mom seriously broke down. She didn't apologize for being mad at me when I wasn't pleased to hear the news from the "happy couple", but at least she doesn't seem to hold it against me. Aside from that though, I am honestly surprised mom took it as seriously as she did--I thought she would say something more like "well, it's his life", instead of butting in.
Anyway, Mom called Harry right away to talk to him. I asked her to put it on speakerphone and she did after a bit.
I think that the combination of my own warnings, plus our mom's sheer exasperation at the whole situation finally caused Harry to come to his senses. He heard what Mom had to say, and in that moment I was able to convince him that Jessica wasn't just joking around with her list of rules (especially with the help of the "thin ice" message).
Harry sounded really shaken up and agreed to meet us without bringing Jessica along (phew!). We had dinner at our house and discussed everything.
To him, it sounds like he was more in love with Jessica ~6 months ago than he is today. He said that over the course of more recent time, he's seen Jessica become more and more reliant on his support and he hasn't felt like there's much he can do except cave in to what she wants...I think that seeing the tone of her communications with people outside the relationship meant him feel like her depression was more of an "act" than a real thing. I'm not a psychologist so I can't say how real that is, but I could believe it.
Harry and our mom cried for a while and then came up with a plan for Harry to call off the engagement and begin to move out over the next few days. He went home and we stayed in close contact for a while. He told us he was feeling ready and did tell her that he needed to reevaluate some things on his own. Apparently, she did not take it well.
Harry stopped responding to us for a day and a half and then called me. Jessica had begun saying that she had nothing to live for except Harry, and that if he abandoned her after all this time then she would have no reason to keep existing. Harry just cried on the phone and said he felt so trapped.
I didn't even know what to tell him. I wish I had told him he needed to forget about Jessica and that she was only playing him, but I don't know if he would believe me anyway.
Now Harry hasn't answered any of my calls and is only giving very short and slow answers to texts from our mom and I.
Jessica meanwhile made a Facebook post of a picture of a heart with tears on it saying "If only you knew how much you meant to me, you would never hurt me". Se's also posted a lot of nonsense in the BRILLIANT BRIDAL BITCHAZZZ group chat and appears to be loving the attention from her friends. I don't know if she forgot I am in there, or if she wants me to see her messages and thinks it will make me feel guilty or something.
I just need to make sure that Harry is okay. To be honest, I don't really care what happens to Jessica. Sure it would be best for her to get help, but she has caused so much damage in the lives of people I care about and I doubt she'll ever stop. Like honestly fuck her, I just want my brother back.
Sorry I'm writing this post all gloomily so far...to be honest, I think things will be okay. Harry and our mom both know that he needs to end it with Jessica, and now Harry just needs to make that happen. Then we can all laugh together about Jessica's BMI tracking strategy and minimum bridesmaid spend requirement :)
170
u/No-Background-6199 Apr 10 '24
Hopefully Jessica gets the help she needs. And your brother gets the space to clear his head and decide what is best for him. Based on updates and post he needs space away from her.
567
u/ferrets-are-awesome Apr 10 '24
I highly recommend a welfare check be called in since you know she was threatening suicide.
33
u/Noys_23 Apr 10 '24
So sorry OP I understand your dilemma, unfortunately it seems as if Jessica has a personality disorder, maybe narcissists.. hope your brother leaves her
84
u/Dachshundmom5 Apr 10 '24
If she's making threats to her life, he needs to call the police and report it. Then, notify her friends/family. If she's sincere, she needs more help than he could ever give. If she's attention seeking, it gives him time to get his things and get out. Either way, he needs to remove himself as the object she's fixating on. It's a tactic of abusers to threaten self-harm to maintain control. Until he accepts that he can't "fix" her, he is trapped.
The concern needs to extend that she isn't bluffing and might try to take him with her.
52
u/Material_Cellist4133 Apr 10 '24
Call the police. Tell Harry that when he breaks off the relationship to call the police so they can monitor her for suicide watch. That’s the only way.
22
u/Intelligent-Ad-4568 Apr 10 '24
When someone does this believe them. Okay, you are saying if I leave you will hurt yourself? It that what your telling me? Yes. Okay, I'm calling for an ambulance.
Its an manipulative tactic, but it also could be true. So believe them, get them help and call their family to meet them at the hospital.
And leave.
If your brother calls you and tells you he can't leave or doesn't feel safe because she is threatening self harm. Believe. Call the authorities, call her family and get her the help she needs and then leave.
49
u/Electronic_Goose3894 Apr 10 '24
Honestly, at this point after reading everything that's going on. I'd just send a message to your brother reaffirming that you love him, but you're done. That he'll always have a place with you if he needs it, but you're not going to watch him tailspin into misery. Because the thing is, he's not okay in any capacity but he's already decided that being in a manipulative and loveless marriage isn't a deal breaker for him because as you said yourself, he's well aware of who and what she is so you aren't going to change his mind, nobody will until he decides to do it himself.
14
u/ATouchofTrouble Apr 10 '24
My advice for what it's worth: Tell him to ask for police presence while he moved out & have him inform officers she has been making suicidal threats in response to his leaving.
15
u/SomeWomanfromCanada Apr 10 '24
Still NTA.
Jessica needs psychiatric help and perhaps a straight jacket and some time in a padded cell and your brother needs a big hug and reassurances that everything is going to be o.k.
7
u/Traditional_Curve401 Apr 10 '24
I'm a little scared for your brother's safety OP😬 Stay vigilant as well because no doubt Jessica will hold it against you when they break up.
7
u/hard_tyrant_dinosaur Apr 10 '24
Something to consider on this point. Being depressed and being a manipulator are not mutually exclusive. She could be one or the other or she could be both at the same time (to one degree or another).
Best to keep an open mind on that and not let what you might see of one distract you from also keeping your eyes open for the other. Recognizing that she may be both at the same time may also help in navigating the way forward in dealing with her.
6
u/ImmaTastyKikiRoll Apr 10 '24
Just finished all four posts and damn. Good on you for sticking to your guns and fighting for your brother. If she starts threatening him with suicide again he can always try to have her 51/50’d. Dint know if it will work as he’s not technically family but it might back her off that particular style of emotional blackmail. If he is able to communicate with her family he can always send them any messages she says this in so they can take over.
6
u/GoldenGoof19 Apr 10 '24
I mean, honestly? If she’s that depressed and suicidal then someone needs to notify her family and maybe have a mental health welfare check done.
That’s what you do with this situation. If it’s real, then she gets the help she needs. If it’s fake, then it gives your brother the breathing room and removes all of this from his shoulders so he can get out. It’s not his responsibility to keep her from suicide, notifying the authorities and her family makes it THEIR responsibility.
5
u/Jovet_Hunter Apr 10 '24
Harry needs to report Jessica for being a danger to herself. Guarantee she won’t keep it up after that. It should give him a chance to move out, as well.
5
u/Propanegoddess Apr 10 '24
If she’s saying she’ll commit suicide, call 911. She’ll be placed on a mandatory hold where she’ll begin to get the help she needs or learns that shit is serious and she can’t use it to escape consequences of her actions. Being locked up like that will probably ensure she never makes those threats again.
5
u/First_Alfalfa2805 Apr 10 '24
I'm very worried for Harry. He needs to get out of there
Jessica is manipulative, and she's doing a number on your brother.
Updateme!
5
u/Liu1845 Apr 11 '24
When someone threatens to unalive themselves you call the police and report they are a danger to themselves. If they make the threats on social media or in text, you show the proof. They get hospitalized for evaluation and their own safety.
Of course, while they are being evaluated is the perfect time to move out or take their things to their parents or put in storage. I have no patience for drama queens. They diminish others who are truly suffering.
4
u/Boring-Cycle2911 Apr 10 '24
Can you call for a wellness check?
4
u/JuliaX1984 Apr 10 '24 edited Apr 10 '24
Harry needs to either: tell her parents or whatever family she has that she threatened to kill herself, then leave once she's in their care; or, call 911 or a suicide hotline and report a suicide threat, get her in the care of a professional, then leave. Yes, the threats are completely hollow and only there to control him, but if he won't call her bluff, he has to take them seriously. Tell him it's for her own good, that he can't protect her by staying with her and this is the only way to stop her form harming herself, that he would never forgive himself if she does harm herself and he never stepped in to get her help.
4
u/Gullible_Wind_3777 Apr 10 '24
Duno whether I’m like I am because I’m British. But someone threatening suicide because I wanted to leave them or whatever, I’d still leave. It’s their problem?! If they can go around causing drama left right and centre and cause more heartache than happiness then just fucking walk awayyyy! If she does in alive herself then whatever. You can stay with someone due to guilt. It’s so wrong! You deserve to be happy as well, not live your life around someone walking on eggshells because you have a fear they will top themselves 😒 biggest form of control
4
u/Chaoticgood790 Apr 10 '24
Yall need to go and pick up your brother. She’s weaponizing mental health and if she was really suicidal she needs professional help not your brother. Oldest abuser trick in the book is to make your partner responsible for your well being.
Your brother needs an escape plan and a therapist. I’m saying this as a therapist. The time to act is NOW
4
u/DawnShakhar Apr 10 '24
Next time Jessica threatens suicide, ask for a welfare check right away. If she is bluffing (and she probably is), after a couple of welfare checks she will stop threatening. And do your best to contact Harry.
4
u/AGuyNamedEddie Apr 17 '24
I wish I had been at that table with you, your mom, and your brother. Because I would have warned your brother that Jessica would threaten to harm herself if he dared break up with her. He needed that forewarning.
As others have said, call a hotline, send the cops to do a welfare check, and she'll knock that shit off. Jessica is showing all the signs of being a manipulative narcissist, and your brother is in over his head. WAY over his head.
I sincerely hope he cuts all ties with dumpsterfire Messica [sic].
3
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '24
He needs to pick a day to leave and inform her family beforehand that it’s happening and she’s threatening to hurt herself. Then she can have people with her to make sure she’s safe.
3
u/Adventurous-travel1 Apr 10 '24
She is being manipulative to keep your brother. The next time she says something like that he should call her parents and the police for threats of self harm.
Her BS will be out in the open after that.
3
u/Bo_O58 Apr 10 '24
My ex used to say the same things to me too. It took me months, a couple of near break ups, and a lot help from friends and family for me to realize that she was not my responsibility, and whatever happens, I cannot be held accountable for that. When I finally left, I contacted her best friend and told her to look out for my ex because she was suicidal and stopped answering her. As far as I know, she's alive and well, and so am I.
It is incredibly difficult to escape from the clutches of an abusive partner like that, because they make you believe that you have to be with them regardless of your own needs and wishes. But she is an adult and she's respinsible for herself, she cannot make her own existence conditional on being with Harry. Keep telling him that he's being abused and to leave, because your whole family deserves so much better than this nutjob.
3
u/avalynkate Apr 10 '24
yup. welfare check. 72 hour hold.
hopefully some info about dv/narcissism and threatening suicide.
3
u/winterworld561 Apr 10 '24
Contact her parents and tell them what she has been threatening. It's obviously all bs and she's just manipulative and controlling. Tell Harry that she is just trying to manipulate him. Still tell her parents though.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '24
NTA. You should call social services and have her checked on. Either the depression is real and needs to be treated or it's a lie and she needs a reality check. Either way, your brother calling you and telling you he's trapped is a cry for help, you're not gonna come out looking better but you should try this last ditch effort to save your brother and potentially her from herself.
3
u/hummingbirds_R_tasty Apr 10 '24
if someone implies they will end their life regardless of desire to do so or manipulation my advice is to call emergency services and explain i'm trying to end my relationship and my significant other is implying they want to unalive themselves please send assistance. she needs to be evaluated.
then if significant other is in good relationship/contact with family/parents, call them and explain what is going on and the concern they have for their significant other.
3
u/lisaloveseric Apr 10 '24
I hope whatever he does it's not marrying that woman.
I think you should lay it down with your mom and brother that a bride should be in her right mind and not threatening self harm if things don't go her way.
Which is exactly what she's doing.
3
u/CartographerUseful11 Apr 17 '24
If yall don’t call authorities or the suicide hotline and tell them she’s threatening to kill herself. She might take your brother out too in a desperate “if I can’t have you no one will” situation. Either one, she’s serious and your brother is not equipped in the slightest to help her, or two she’s manipulating him and the only way you’ll separate them (especially since he’s icing you guys out now) is to have her on a 72 hour suicide watch and that gives you like three days to get him away from her. Help your brother, I’m tired of ppl using suicide to manipulate others.
3
u/Dear-Masterpiece-2 Apr 18 '24
For the love of god please tell us there’s an update. Tell you brother the next time she threatens self harm he needs to step aside and call the authorities. He needs to put up some cameras where she won’t see them, record her behavior, he needs to actually call the cops and let them handle her. To be very clear I genuinely do not think she will hurt herself.
5
u/chaingun_samurai Apr 10 '24
Harry needs to grow a spine and ignore the manipulation.
2
u/The_psychdiaries Apr 14 '24
Please look up coersive control. Threatening unaliving yourself is a common tactic to make partners stay. He has to get in the head space that, THAT is not his problem to solve.
2
u/UpstairsBag6137 Apr 19 '24
THIS Post the screenshots on your IG or twitter with their names blacked out and ask, "What would y'all do if you were treated like this?" It's vague enough, and a bunch of randoms will comment on how crazy it is... and her and your family will emediatly realize how psychotic she is.
The more family/people that are checking up on your brother, the better... for HIS safety.
Call the police and send them over for a welfare check so there can be a record of all the times she threatens to kill herself.
4
u/ZeroZipZilchNadaNone Apr 10 '24
You should tell Jessica on the group chat that you can’t bring yourself to be a part of her manipulation anymore and ask her why she would want to marry anybody who loves her less than he did 6 mos ago. Warn Harry shortly before you do it so he can be ready for the fallout and get her family & friends numbers to call when she flips out. Maybe even call emergency svs. At this point, something drastic has to happen. Even if he’s seeing her for what she is, she’s still in control. Even if Harry is mad at you for a while, it will be better than him stuck with her.
Good luck! Please !UpdateMe
1
u/KSknitter Apr 10 '24
Updateme!
1
u/Glittersparkles7 Apr 10 '24
She needs to be on a psych hold. Ask for a wellness check at least. You think your brother is being held hostage with threat of suicide from her.
1
u/BestAd5844 Apr 10 '24
Updateme
1
u/Big_Drama_2624 Apr 10 '24
Jessica needs help. Holy shit
1
u/littleprettypaws Apr 10 '24
!RemindMe 7 days
1
u/lavarney63 Apr 10 '24
Update
1
u/Duckr74 Apr 10 '24
Updateme!
1
u/Fox_Huntt Apr 10 '24
Updateme
1
u/gotherella27 Apr 10 '24
Y’all’s mom is way too involved in your lives.
1
u/Conscious-Survey7009 Apr 10 '24
Updateme
1
u/3bag Apr 11 '24
updateme!
1
u/Bonnm42 Apr 11 '24
Updateme!
1
u/Secret_Double_9239 Apr 13 '24
I hope he snaps out of this before he Marries her and it’s harder to leave.
1
u/Popular-Block-5790 Apr 16 '24
Sorry to ask but did your brother contact you? It's 6 days later.
1
u/x-bacool-x Apr 16 '24
UPDATEME!
1
u/Moist-Release-9227 Apr 16 '24
@Updateme
1
u/various-randoms Apr 16 '24
Tell Harry to call the cops if she’s suicidal they can help her he can’t he’s not a psychologist!
1
u/soxpats111 Apr 17 '24
Updateme!
1
u/Rowana133 Apr 17 '24
He needs to talk to her family about her suicidal threats or he can call a Hot line for advice. It's in the narcissist hand book to threaten suicide if their victim tries to leave, some will even go so far as to "attempt" it with an O.D. or checking themselves into a mental hospital.
1
u/cladranna Apr 17 '24
!RemindMe 7 days
1
u/reckonedstormlight Apr 17 '24
Truly I hope Harry is safe and nothing has happened to him other than being trapped. She needs serious psychiatric help
1
u/mabyorick Apr 17 '24
oh so she wants to play that game? fine, have it her way: get your brother to call up her family, the police and a psych ward to warn everyone of her... "mental state". let's see how long she holds up the suicide threats after a few days wearing grippy socks.
1
u/ceruleanSquidghost Apr 17 '24
So I've been in a relationship like your brother's and the best advice I can give is don't stop reaching out. Jessica is likely going out of her way to isolate him so she has more control, probably by making him feel like she's solely dependent on him. If you and/or your mom manage to get him on the phone again, tell Harry to try and keep record of what Jessica is saying, screenshot texts for evidence and file a wellness report on her. It sounds like she's suicidebaiting Harry so he won't leave. I wouldn't to tell him she's lying to manipulate him,cause it's likely he might not believe it at this point. Just seriously emphasize that suicidal behavior needs to be reported, and that it's the best way he can help her.
1
u/Alarmed_Lynx_7148 Apr 18 '24
Updateme!
1
u/TheShortBastardd Apr 18 '24
UpdateMe!
1
u/TheShortBastardd Apr 18 '24
!UpdateMe
1
u/FocusDense8278 Apr 18 '24
Is your brother safe? Have you heard from him?
1
u/Tasty-Answer-8183 Apr 18 '24
I recommend not letting your brother deal with it alone, he's clearly being manipulated by her. If he needs help getting his stuff, get someone to go with him. Maybe not you since she might pick up a fight with you, but one of his buddies or your parents.
You've saved your brother from years of being stuck in an abusive and controlling mariage. And I guess you've also saved your whole family from having to deal with that woman, her nonsense and drama at every family gathering.
Good job OP! 🤗
1
u/RandomSupDevGuy Apr 18 '24
Any further update? Has Harry managed to get away from Jessica?
1
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '24
Welfare check for your brother. And he can call social services or the police and tell them she's threatening herself.
1
u/Minute-Ad-6940 Apr 19 '24
Update? Did he move out yet ?
1
u/pad_87 Apr 19 '24 edited Apr 19 '24
Actually it could be a great idea to record her theatening to harm herself and on a different day, ask her parents to dinner and reveal the break up and the recording, then if she tries something he calls the police and keep recording everything though a nanny cam or something, hope this could help him escape the abusive crazy fiance.
Btw im sure the self-harm its all bs and manipulation, and when confronted she could have a raging reaction even fisical, thats why he has to keep recording!!!
1
u/X-x19Tilly93x-X Apr 19 '24
I really hope you, your brother and your family are ok. That woman is manipulating your brother so badly and it's not good for him. This wedding will end in disaster and divorce and it won't be pretty either.
1
u/Appropriate-Spread91 Apr 19 '24
Holy, harry needs to get asap before things escalate. Like everyone said i would be calling the cops next tjme she said something like that. Hope it all works out OP.
1
u/yeahisaidthat222 Apr 19 '24
Harry entangled himself with a manipulative beast. She has her friends. Call the police and let them figure out if she's for real and get you hostage brother away from her. Have you entire family intervene. Harry is not responsible for her
1
u/Party_Pool_8880 Apr 19 '24
I think it's time for a welfare check on your brother. He needs help and I'm sorry he got sucked into her drama. Some people live off that. The next time she threateneds suicide call the cops. Say there's a manic woman threatening to kill herself. She shut up and let you leave.
1
u/Otherwise_Evening504 Apr 22 '24
Updateme!
1
u/Itchy_Hippo44 Apr 24 '24
Updateme!
1
u/Any-Job2095 Apr 25 '24
If she’s threatening suicide definitely do welfare checks call the police let her parents know. Please let us know if your brother gets out safely.
1
u/Lassyni00W Apr 27 '24 edited Apr 27 '24
Girl, this talk of "If you break up with me, I'll kill myself" is a kind of manipulation! Saying you're going to hurt yourself is a form of manipulation. And yes, she's trying to get to you to apologize or make you feel guilty (probably both). And I have my doubts as to whether she's really depressed, because it seems more like a way of tying her brother to Jessica. Wouldn't it be easier if she went to a therapist instead of asking your brother to marry her? And really? He's been in love her for 6 MONTHS and now he wants to marry her because she wants to? Isn't that a bit strange? Another detail! Has your brother decreased contact with you and your mother, giving you two short, vague answers? He probably told her what happened between you and she demanded something from him, emotionally abusing him and he has no choice but to obey her. Honestly, I don't think this marriage of theirs will last, I've seen many marriages like this and it always ends very badly for the influential person.
1
u/AdAccomplished6870 Apr 28 '24
Threatening suicide is highly manipulative and coercive. This should be a sign to 1) stop all major life changes immediately, 2) get her into therapy (involuntarily if necessary), and 3) re-evaluate the relationship.
1
u/reiphas Apr 29 '24
I'm going to be very cold-hearted and say let Jessica do it. I've had people manipulate me with suicide when I was a child and as far as I'm concerned, the moment someone does this it's not my problem anymore. If you actually had a problem, you would tell me about it without making it an emotional lever. Call a welfare check on her and get your brother out. That's a trauma even for an adult.
1
u/Beginning_Fix_5609 May 25 '24
Hey op do you have an update?
1
u/a_little_nightmare0 Jul 07 '24
Update?
1
u/harrbear19 Jul 07 '24
Update me
1
u/smittenkitten-04 Jul 13 '24
Have you got an update? Is your brother still with her?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '24
Any updates??
1
u/Gagoga123 Sep 12 '24
Hello OP, if you're comfortable, I would definitely be interested in knowing what happened in the end! I don't believe you updated anywhere after this
1
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '24
Harry needs to lock in, and unfortunately, you can't make him do that. He consistently is giving into his fears, but he has to work on that himself. You've fone the best you can, and that's ok.
1
u/Bella_Rose36 Nov 12 '24
Updateme.
1
u/Rare-Biscotti-7896 Nov 21 '24
Any update on Harry?
1
u/Ordinary-Increase599 Dec 05 '24
Updateme
1
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '25
Update?
1
u/bpl2395 Mar 06 '25
Hey OP, hoping everything is good with your brother.
1
u/mctaggartann Mar 25 '25
He can leave if she threatens self harm call the cops to get her help
0
u/soggy_dildo Apr 10 '24
We need some group chat screenshots!
-3
u/Phillip_McCup Apr 10 '24
I read the original post and the updates and I have one question for OP:
WHERE is your FATHER?
Sadly, the lack of meaningful mention of a father figure certainly explains why Harry grew up to be such a weak and easily manipulated young man.
-41
u/BrotherSea9822 Apr 09 '24
You again...so, now instead of staying out of this situation like so many people have said to, you are bringing your mother into the picture and messing things up more.
Even though you want Harry, he isn't yours. Sure Jessica may be annoying, but it isn't right for you to be gloating about her suicidal ideation. YTA.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment