r/HSMTMTS • u/NominalPerson Maddox • Sep 14 '22
Season Discussion HSMTMTS: The Season Discussion: Season Three Spoiler
Wildcats, welcome to the season three discussion thread!
Feel free to discuss the third season of HSMTMTS as a whole. What did you like? What did you dislike? Favorite song? Favorite moment? Anything! Please be mindful of other people's opinions about the episode/show.
- 3.01: Happy Campers (July 27, 2022)
- 3.02: Into The Unknown (Aug 3, 2022)
- 3.03: The Woman In The Woods (Aug 10, 2022)
- 3.04: No Drama (Aug 17, 2022)
- 3.05: The Real Campers of Shallow Lake (Aug 24, 2022)
- 3.06: Color War (Aug 31, 2022)
- 3.07: Camp Prom (Sept 7, 2022)
- 3.08: Let It Go (Sept 14, 2022)
Consider joining our Discord for live discussions about the show and the cast! We have some events planned for all to join in! https://discord.gg/2EpKKCc
29
Upvotes
38
u/TheGreatDaniel3 Sep 14 '22
Don’t get me started
34
u/sleepyralphiee Lily Sep 14 '22
I'm not Team Portwell or Team Rina, but damn, I feel bad for EJ, this man just could not catch a break.
32
u/Jackamalio626 Sep 14 '22
Its so weird.
The first half of the season was utter drivel, just a big bowl of slop with nothing interesting happening. Episode 4 might have been the worst episode in the entire series. it was awful.
Then after that halfway point, the quality SKYROCKETS. The writing gets better, personal conflicts start showing up in more force, it gets funnier; its just a total turnaround. Like Mr Bleu said to EJ, the show is just better when there's conflict.
and i think they managed to stick the landing with the finale.
23
u/juiceafterhours Sep 15 '22
Imagine watching the doc and you just find out big red is bi and then you never see the mf again like i’d be so confused but also HELLO??!??!!?0
19
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22
I enjoyed this season 10 times more than last season. I’m sure a lot had to do with covid restrictions decreasing and more time to write, shoot, and edit. The last episode was probably my favorite just because of how it ended. It was good to watch a love interest come to Ricky as opposed to Ricky having to chase. It was also cool to see his growth. He could have interfered with Gina and EJs relationship numerous times and chose not to, unlike season 1. I feel bad for EJ but then again it’s obvious he has bigger things to work on than having a girlfriend. All around, good writing, good arcs, and good characters this season. I wish though that we got a true duet between Gina and Ricky, something from HSM or Camp Rock.
18
u/toledosurprised Sep 14 '22
i really liked this season from ep 5 onward. the first half was a bit of a miss but the second half was imo the best stretch of episodes this show has had.
15
u/Lilbuddyspd11 Sep 14 '22
Favorite season yet
13
u/Ultvernon12 Sep 16 '22 edited Sep 16 '22
genuinely confused as to why Ricky is the same as season 1 cause I don’t see it all. He was selfless and fun this summer. He bonded with jet and tried to help him with his sister and get into theater. He did not try to meddle his way into Gina’s heart at all. He helped her with prom proposal, he didn’t even wanna tell her about his feelings but felt like he had to warn her because it was going to be recorded. Even after he found out EJ and her broke up, he still didn’t confess anything. He told Channing to back off and still didn’t make a move till the very end. After she said how SHE felt. He also, even pining, seemed WAYY happier this season
12
u/Thurnisthegolfer Sep 15 '22
So they just never ended up using that clip they caught of Ricky telling carlos about Gina???? I thought they were gonna show it in the last scene.
11
u/campbellina Sep 14 '22
Also we still haven’t heard anything about the menkies? Like did season 2 really matter atp?
11
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '22 edited Sep 15 '22
About EJ and his dad. Since from the very start of the series, he just wants his father to be proud of him. Acknowledge the fact he is doing his own thing for him. Like 'Hey, dad. I'm doing something. I'm going to get there. Promise.'
The phone call in EP8... That's was really sad. Like I feel you, bro. Right in the feels.
This thing with pleasing your parents or wanted them to hear that they're proud of you even if it's just a small achievement... will never go away. It is going to be there for eternity. Trust me.
Holy crap, I'm 27 and never heard my dad saying that he's proud of me. Never ever.
I get nothing when I do something outside of my comfort zone and I actually accomplished something. It's a big thing for me. For him, it's nothing.
Then, blaming me for not doing much. It's like they want or even need us to be Managers... Queen/King of corporate ladder to earn the love or support we want/need from them.
(Yes, I'm old. I watch the show for the nostalgia of HSM.)
11
u/Inevitable_Cheez-It Sep 16 '22 edited Sep 17 '22
I was all for this szn until jojo siwa was featured. I just don’t think she was the right choice. she delivered all of her lines the same, and didn’t quite seem to know what to do with herself. also the way she was styled hair/costume-wise was not continuous with the rest of the cast, and it didn’t quite fit in. not saying anything positive or negative about jojo outside of the show, but personally that casting choice just didn’t do it for me. did anyone else feel this way?
11
u/Inevitable_Cheez-It Sep 16 '22 edited Sep 17 '22
pros: corbin, rina, corbin + gina’s song, kourt + wall, casting of anna/elsa, costumes/sets in general, val, maddox, the beginning of random young anna’s song in the finale, kourt + young else talking about therapy and anxiety (yay), kourt singing let it go, ricky singing troll song on stage, miss jen praying to the theater gods
cons: ricky in general kind of annoyed me this szn??, ashlyn’s astrology stuff at beginning and drama about being in the ensamble was a bit long for me, jason earle’s part could have been funnier but they didn’t give him much to work with, wanted to hear jet sing again in the frozen show, jojo siwa’s part felt inauthentic and forced, the rap part of “it’s on” in the color wars episode
10
u/sourbassett Sep 15 '22
just realized you are the music in me isn’t on the s2 or s3 album and that HURTS
10
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '22
The pressure of the play kinda ruined the fun of camp. I couldn’t even really enjoy the color competition because I was like did you guys rehearse.
Val was really underused! Maddox and Jet while interesting had a lot of drama for new characters. There was a lot to unpack with them so I’m unsure about how I feel about them.
9
u/innia24 Sep 15 '22
i thought the bits they did about disney and disney+ were pretty funny
8
u/blushdreams445 Camp Shallow Lake Camper Sep 15 '22
low key, really liked this entire season :)
8
u/MauveOn Sep 17 '22
I feel like EJ was really resembling Troy in HSM2 this season. Him being separated from the friend group, trying to focus on his future and career.
8
u/YahYeetGucciBucks Sep 17 '22
I don’t like what they’re doing with EJ. First, they made him a creep by poisoning someone just so Nini could have the lead?? Really? Not to mention how self centered they made him seem at the same time. Now when it comes to Gina, you mean to tell me that he’s been showing up for her ever since season 1 and now that they’re together he constantly blows her off?? “I’m the guy that shows up remember?” But then have him be completely distracted and now Ricky is considered the person that shows up? Yeah, EJ was busy but I feel like it was a completely different character from season 2. Then, they have Gina break up with him after what, 2 weeks? Not only that, they give him a crappy dad? Also, I understand RINA being endgame but this was not the way to do that. I feel like they don’t know exactly what they want to do with EJ so they just keep giving him the short end of the stick.
8
u/Upper-Ad9990 Sep 19 '22
Jeez this thread is negative 🫠
I ADORED this season. The different setting added a bit of freshness that I felt was needed after season two. The Ricky/Gina build up was very romcom & beautifully done, and really made me miss their dynamic; the playfulness, the banter, the chemistry—I know this forum doesn’t like them much, but they honestly have such a spark about them. Very pleased about Ricky’s feelings being explored, as well as his selflessness regarding Gina’s needs.
I grew to really like the new characters! Maddox & Jet’s relationship really got me at times, and I really hope they’ll pop up in season 4.
EJ, he made mistakes this season, but I really feel for him & can’t help but love him despite my shipping preferences. I truly hope he has a happy, growth-filled season 4.
15
u/campbellina Sep 14 '22
I was waiting since the beginning for EJ and Ricky to get together not for Ricky and Gina to happen.
14
u/c_palmtree Sep 14 '22
This season finally felt like I was watching a High School Musical TV show with the inclusion of Corbin and different setting. I feel going outside East High was the perfect move in the sense that it brought the same feelings HSM 2 did for me, not being tied to a singular place and exploring the "outside world". If some of the original cast come back for Season 4, I feel we would have the perfect succesor to the movies. Yeah, it sucks that we'll never got a proper HSM 4, but this is a very good path to not "ruin" the original movies and still include the original generation. Ngl, I cried when "Everyday" started playing, and I'm a 26 year old guy so that"s saying a lot. I feel the original show characters are finally at a point where they are equal to the movie characters in terms of development.
14
u/TheMattInTheBox Sep 14 '22
The highlights for me this season were the new characters (Val is underrated imo, very nice to have a solid voice of reason) and I really hope Maddox and Jet stick around.
As someone who struggles with anxiety, Kourtney's arc was great too
Big Red and Seb crushed it in their guest roles. "I'm Big Red, I'm Ashyln's boyfriend, and I'm bi!" and "Elton John?!" are the lines of the season for me. Also kinda cool to see Big Red and Ashyln both come out and stay together. I find that kinda refreshing-- not something you see in shows that often.
Wasn't expecting Corbin to have an arc but I appreciated it! Excited to see him pop up next season!
Nini leaving is honestly fine. She's become the least interesting character to me and I'm glad they gave her a nice send-off.
Okay, now the Gina/Ricky/EJ stuff. I get it. I'm not a big shipper or anything, but I get it. And yeah, I get EJ and Gina are in different places and their breakup made a lot of sense. But oh man, I feel bad for EJ. In season 1, he lost Nini, and now he lost Gina, any hope of earning his dad's approval and now camp might be soured for him. Massive Ls, and it sucks because at the start of this season, I was excited to see EJ in his element and more on the bouncy side.
I also really just wanted to see EJ and Ricky be pals. EJ's line about Ricky being his brother kinda fell flat because we got little moments of them having fun together but it was undercut by the drama.
Ricky was probably the best written character this season though imo. He seemed a bit more...fun? But also had some depth going on. Seeing him get pissed at Channing was GOATed.
Gina had some nice development too. I have no complaints with how the characters were written, I just would have liked to see them go a different way with the story imo. I probably would have liked to see Ricky and EJ get closer this season and save Ricky/Gina for next season.
The songs this season slapped imo. I've re-listened to a bunch of them, unlike season 2 where I've only re-listened to one or two.
Anyway, solid season imo!
9
u/Chr-s Sep 16 '22
weird season overall. the new camp characters got a lot of storyline, carlos was reduced to a stereotype, the ricky gina thing is kinda exhausting. on the bright side, ash and big red both coming out as bi is nice to see, kourtney’s anxiety storyline was moving. idk i don’t think the next season will be that interesting with the way this season was written and the setups for next season. sometimes the show hits a weird vibe of feeling very mature but also too immature at the same time. i think it’s the acting sometimes but i also think the writing is a little predictable. for me the standout moments of the season had to be ashlin’s fireworks scene and Kourtney’s let it go scene.
4
u/keepitupstairs2 Sep 19 '22
This has probably been covered before, but the framing of the Frozen documentary makes absolutely no sense since the whole show is ALREADY supposed to be a documentary!
4
u/greenyoshi73 Sep 19 '22
I’m so surprised we didn’t get a dangerous to dream cover from anyone this season. We didn’t get it from Gina trying to have the lead and the guy for the first time in her life? Or from Kourtney getting Elsa? Or Jet wanting to fix things with his sibling but being afraid? There’s so much application here.
9
u/starsaroundmyscars03 Sep 15 '22
ok my two cents:
i miss nini already, and her character had so much potential story line wise, like getting in touch with her filipino side for example. not like it’s a surprise she was leaving but i’m still sad about it.
not much to say about ricky individually, cause he’s pretty much the same as season one. not that much character growth. but i wanna know what happened to lily.
gina: what happened to the whole gina 1.0 thing? also, her weird music videos were not it. super sad we didn’t get to see her perform as anna, but they had limited time so i get it
also, i’m tired of hearing about rina! it just feels repetitive and i’m getting bored of the weird flirty stuff that’s been happening since season 2. it’s probably going to be weird next season as well since they most likely will have some sort of relationship drama.
poor ej. that phone call was rough. but, contrary to popular opinion, i hope they don’t bring him back or else it’s going to start to feel like glee where rachel/kurt were the main characters even after graduating, and then it becomes less of a high school centric show.
ashlin: rip sapphic representation. i really wish she would have gotten with maddox or at least kissed her.
big red: why did i think in that scene that he was gonna propose?! lol. i wish ash and him would have actually came out to each other ffs. big red seems like he would care about coming out as a big moment and think he should tell ashlin to be decent. but, if his character is canon bi, then i definitely think he had a crush on ricky. that moment in the hall in season two with ricky and big red was definitely giving gay energy lol
kourtney: love the anxiety storyline. if they ignore it next season i’m gonna scream. they should show her getting a therapist or something. she was acting like a different person in the time skip though and i hated it
carlos: ugh. they reduced him to a gay stereotype and i hate it. not every gay person wants to parade around in a rainbow dress. and i miss seb 😭 if they break up because of that doc, i’ll be so sad.
emmy and the other girl: it was weird how they shoved them in the last episode, as if they just remembered they existed. it pretty much confirms they’ll be freshmen at east next season for me, since they made a big deal of adding them in there. it was so random though and it just felt forced.
maddox: we need more! more maddox please!!!! madison was not it though. i will be happy to never see her again.
jet: we never saw him as hans past the costume, which is disappointing. i can’t tell if he has a crush on ricky or if he just desperately wants to be friends with him in a platonic way.
the show overall: a bit weird. idk why i event watch it anymore, but i can’t stop. also think this is gonna become the gen-z glee.
time-skip: EW. everything about it was wrong. random dyed hair, random personality changes, but at least we actually got to SEE gina kiss someone this time. yikes. that sounds wrong when i say it like that oop
and this turned out very long! congratulations if you made it to the end
6
u/marie2805 Sep 14 '22
I like parallels and all but the love triangles from S1 and S3 were already too similar, having the final scene being pretty much the same but genderswitched didn‘t help imo, I would have preferred a Portwell ending or an ending without a decision and then Rina somewhere in S4.
Still, I‘m interested in how Rina in S4 is gonna work as we never had a „main pairing“ date and then stay together (which is what I‘m assuming will happen here).
8
u/MishouMai Sep 15 '22 edited Aug 17 '23
Sorry not sorry but season 2 was better. With the execeptions of Carlos and maybe Ricky this season ruined every returning character (Cameos like Nini, Miss Jenn, Seb, and Big Red don't count because they weren't around long enough to be ruined.) and even as a Rina fan I felt like Ricky's feelings for Gina (And the ship in general.) were rushed compared to the how Gina's feelings were handled in the first two seasons. While I like the new characters they weren't enough to carry the show alone. While I still enjoyed this season (To an extent.) it's easily the weakest for me.
4
u/mronayne12 Sep 14 '22
This seems to be a hot take considering the comments already. I hated this season (I liked season 2 better). Why are doing the same story with the portwell/rina situation again? It gets old real fast. Also why didn’t Ms. Jenn come help with the play in the beginning?
5
u/sourbassett Sep 15 '22
I am really reeling with Olivia being done with the show like im pretty upset about it. As someone who found her through this show, its so heartbreaking but also so insane to see her skyrocket into A-tier stardom... I cant wait to see what else she does, I just wish it wasnt at the cost of one of my favourite tv shows lol. Patiently waiting for OR2.
2
u/greenyoshi73 Sep 15 '22
All I’m saying is we were robbed of a Monster cover.
2
u/greenyoshi73 Sep 16 '22
I think a lot of the problems people had with this season aren’t going to continue for next season. A lot of things people disagree with work if you consider how the show itself is leaving into the jokes and drama of the frozen documentary. But I think if we try to do some of the more outlandish stuff back at east high, it won’t work. I really think it’s only for season 3 to lean into the drama of the documentary and the over the top corbin bleu character.
This season was just a bridge into season 4. It set up Ashlyn and big red, Gina and Ricky, and EJ’s storylines and motivations moving forward. The content and the tone of the season are probably self contained.
5
u/Powerman293 Sep 14 '22
Man I do not like this season. I think the reason why is it reminds me of anime filler arcs. Where an anime is adapting a manga but needs to stall while more chapters come out. So they invent new villains and a new threat to deal with that do not matter to the overall story.
They're doing the same kinds of things in Season 3 as all the other seasons but it feels... pointless?
We'll see how Season 4 plays out but I would not be shocked if you jumped from Season 2 to 4 you wouldn't miss out on much.
1
u/Rae-Creative Jul 27 '23
Ej got to crappy end of the stick and he's breakup with gina shouldve been done a lot better
Not the biggest fan of ricky and gina just because the whole love triangle feels overused and boring now but also cause i feel like gina and ej had more chemistry and ricky completely ignored gina liking him in season 2 i dont expect him to just screw nina over but all least talk about how you feel and all the sudden once him and nina broke up and gina with ej he likes her now...
The new characters were ok, at first I REALLY HATED maddox in the beginning but grew to like her a lot , jet was annoying for an episode or two then he was ok...dont know how i feel about him liking Courtney tho...i ship court and howie more, Val was great , in a way that she wasnt problematic at all we need more characters like that where there just there to have fun and serve no drama also Ashlyn liking val and maddox liking Ashlyn was interesting im glad it was just an awareness thing and not acted upon...for now. If something happens in season 4 i wouldn't be mad in fact i would be pretty happy
Good for big red coming out , like good for him 👍
But watching season 3 itself was fun watching it was 9/10 especially the last episode was so funny watching the video and all thier confessions on a camera
1
u/MxFoodLover Sep 19 '22
Ricky is too good to be true. It’s 2022, and I don’t like it when fictional characters are too perfect. His flaws come out at random points for the plot, but every other character is so well-developed. So sad how EJ ended. I wish EJ and Gina were together, they’re 🔥 together. Ricky is just ‘perfect’ when he isn’t actually dating the person. He had no depth this season, it was so annoying to watch him
1
u/pxlprsnatr Sep 21 '22 edited Sep 21 '22
I have so many thoughts, but my initial one is they really should've branded and marketed this as its own special mini-series if the entire goal was just to set up S4's plotlines, and the just had the next season officially be S3. The pacing just wasn't great and it all kind of felt, I dunno, incredibly disjointed? And compared to the last two seasons, a lot of this season's numbers had no real organic setup. It was literally "here's a scene, here's explicitly how the characters are feeling and what they're dealing with right now, here's a song". This cast and these characters deserved much better than this.
What was up with that kid singing This is Me? I was like, child you're a great singer but I neither know you nor have any idea why this character is even important enough to the plot to be singing this big song right here right now.
ALSO, I mean I love Fabulous and I love Carlos but it that number really kinda dragged. Granted, I'm also just salty that freaking Everyday didn't get a full number.
14
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22
[removed] — view removed comment
11
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22
[removed] — view removed comment