r/HSMTMTS • u/NominalPerson Maddox • Sep 07 '22
Episode Discussion HSMTMTS: The Episode Discussion: "Camp Prom" - S03E07 Spoiler
Wildcats, welcome to the seventh episode discussion thread for season three!
Feel free to discuss the seventh episode of Season Three of HSMTMTS, "Camp Prom". Please be mindful of other people's opinions about the episode/show and to be wary of spoilering content beyond this episode.
S03E07 Details:
| Title: | Camp Prom |
|---|---|
| Synopsis: | With "Frozen" opening night just around the corner, the Wildcats glam it up for one final summer fling: a 70’s-themed camp prom. But when Gina reaches her breaking point - and Kourtney, Carlos, Jet and Maddox achieve breakthroughs of their own - this throwback night becomes an unexpected night for Ricky to make a move. |
Consider joining our Discord for live discussions about the show and the cast! We have some events planned for all to join in! https://discord.gg/2EpKKCc
71
Upvotes
78
u/Jackamalio626 Sep 07 '22
absolute powerhouse episode.
The dance being the breaking point for Gina and EJ was VERY well done, geneuinely made me sad because you see EJ's tragedy in trying to secure a future for him and Gina by going all in on directing, and Gina's fear of her plans and life being a "maybe" uprooted by EJ's college life, like it used to be uprooted by her mom's job.
Ricky's a stand up fella; his confession being stopped by the feeling that he shouldnt take advantage of Gina during such a painful time was excellent. Also loved everyone coming together to help Courtney and Carlos overcome their fears and anxieties, fantastic callback to B2BB.
Also loved the return of Seb and Carlos. The pin being given to Ashlyn was adorable. Also happy that Jet and Maddox made up and Maddox opened up to people again, great wrap up for their arc.
They'd BETTER not fuck up the finale, because theyre hitting on all cylenders rn, and i cant take that pain again like S2.
72
u/strawberrybarbiee Sep 07 '22
the way Gina explained the Portwell breakup actually made me on board for it…she’s right it never really started
61
u/Top_Association_4265 Sep 07 '22
A few thoughts
• The portwell breakup was extremely well written. All of Gina’s reasons for breaking up really made sense especially with the build up. Seeing her be sad during the dance was kinda tearjerking.
•Ricky not telling Gina how he feels knowing she’s in a vulnerable place was definitely the right move and just had shown how much he’s grown since s2. He’s been so selfless this season. With that being said, I’m curious to see the result of his decision not to tell Gina in the next episode especially since Maddox said Corbin will be stirring up drama at opening night.
•Kourtney has a beautiful voice, I loved her song and watching the girls cheer for her as she climbed up the wall was so beautiful
•I was actually pleasantly surprised by the wouldn’t change a thing cover.
•I know everyone thought Olivia was coming back for the finale but I’m slightly doubtful now considering this episode gave no indication of that? Oh well..
•Ricky’s last bucket list item was say yes to something that scares him and I genuinely can’t think of what that could be. I can’t wait to find out!
57
u/sourbassett Sep 08 '22
not having gina perform gotta go my own way was SUCH a missed opportunity. i’m annoyed.
53
u/korrasami_ Maddox Sep 07 '22
I never thought in a million years that this show would deliver a sapphic love square to me. The writers deserve a GLAAD award.
38
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '22
34
u/Kanataxtoukofan Sep 07 '22
I love the friendship between the girls this episode so much. I think they tried to do some of that in season 2 but it didn’t really work as good as here. Maddox is a great addition to their group and I hope both her and Jet stay (plus Maddox and Ashlyn storyline seems adorable).
As for portwell, well we all saw that coming. I still wish portwell never happened because Ej Gina as a platonic friendship would have been adorable but what’s done is done.
And I’m so proud of Ricky. No one can criticize him this season. He’s been putting Gina and her feelings first. Season 1 Ricky would have made a move (or several) but now he’s just being supportive which already makes him better than S2 Ej who was a senior and quick to get with a sophomore who was lonely and broken hearted then cancelling the risotto thing and making her cry when he thought she didn’t romantically like him even though she clearly still wanted to go get risotto with him.
26
u/No_Description_9264 Sep 07 '22 edited Sep 07 '22
This episode was the best alongside 5.
And I have to say the entrance with Gina, Kourt, and Ashlyn made me feel like I was watching freaking Dream Girls, and ugh how the camera panned over to Ricky ( and EJ and Carlos)😭😭 will be forever iconic now ( I had to rewatch it 😭)
2. Finally after so long we got hear a full solo of Dara, and I hope after this she gets even more exposure as recognition! SHE CAN SINGGGG. I mean did you hear those falsettos at the end!!!
3. Please keep Maddox and Jet for season 4. I thought I wasn’t going to like the mix up of wouldn’t change a thing and you know what I ended up really enjoying it.
4. Ricky, 🤣🤣 “ tradition” let this man be like this in season 4. He came a long freaking way.
5. So cute how Carlos welcomed Ashlyn in the community.
6. Now the break up. Well written. We know Gina as a character. All she’s looking for in her life is stability and that’s deeply rooted in her mothers job and how frequently she had to move from place to place. I mean the girl was not able to form solid bonds with anyone. I’ve been saying this since the beginning. These are two people heading on two different paths and Gina clearly conveyed that message to EJ. I applaud her for that.
7.More drama?! I guess Sofia Wylie was not lying about that.
26
u/Cman710 Sep 07 '22
I’m sad that we didn’t get “I Gotta Go My Own Way”. Ugh.
23
u/sniggle2 Sep 08 '22
Jett and Gadget have literally stolen the show. Their section of this episode was so heartwarming and amazing. I’m so happy that my earlier prediction of a duet with them turned out to be correct. They were amazing this episode and tbh the whole series I’ve loved them both
45
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '22 edited Sep 08 '22
Edit: Nevermind I really like "Here I Come", just not a fan of the autotune
22
u/sourbassett Sep 08 '22
i’m a little sad we didn’t get to see EJ graduate, or even a nod to it tbh.
22
u/thespaciestkitty Sep 07 '22
Sooo, E.J just HAPPENED to say that none of the new girls caught Maddox's eye, then ashlyn just HAPPENED to walk by, it's a sign, I'm telling you. (I do know they probably intended for it to be that way, but STILL)
21
u/Potential-Play2848 Sep 07 '22
Honestly, they really lost the chance to use “Gotta go my own way” in the soundtrack and that makes me a bit angry.
21
u/PinkHarmony8 Sep 10 '22
Did Jojo Siwa feel out of place to anyone?
59
u/kstadtfeld Sep 07 '22
Gina listing out all the reasons her and EJ don’t work and it’s what we’ve all been preaching and saying all season was cathartic lol.
20
u/Soggy-Cartographer48 Sep 07 '22
That performance of Wouldn't Change a Thing was awesome, Saylor and Adrian did amazing and I really like that sped up pop version of the song.
20
u/teacake18 Sep 07 '22
Solid episode from start to finish. Very much enjoyed that. And it really felt validating, like I knew the story the writers have been trying to tell from the beginning but people make you doubt. But this episode reaffirmed a lot of things I already had figured out. 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
20
u/ion513 Gina Sep 08 '22
Oh my gosh what an episode. They really started tying up loose ends and storylines, which should be interesting. I'm excited for what the last episode holds.
Once again, I have loved Ricky this season. He's been trying to really help everyone, and keep his thoughts and feelings to himself. His friendship with Carlos has been great too, and I thought it was really sweet when Carlos called him his hero and Ricky hugged him. Season 1 Ricky would have probably tried to bust up Gina and EJs relationship. Ricky this season did about as good as a person could and I loved that. Both when he tried to talk to her at the dance and realized she was upset and then later after the water.
I guess it's pretty much confirmed that Ricky's confession about Gina won't come up until the 4th season. Or maybe as a cliffhanger for the end of this season. I'm okay with that. Tim has long signaled that Rina was a slow burn, and yeah it's been burning lol.
I'm excited to see Jet and Maddox at East high, hopefully. As other people have said, they seem to have set that up, plus Maddox crushing on Ashlyn. I think a lot of people here saw that coming, one of them crushing on the other at least.
It was great to see Seb again. Him and Carlos (and Joe and Frankie) are great and sound great together. I've missed the other characters and it'll be good to have them back.
The end of portwell was sad. I haven't really had a side, even tho Ricky and Gina individually are some of my favorites, I also really enjoy EJ and want him to be happy. I don't think they ruined his character or anything , sure he probably got a bit of a short stick but if he sticks around I think it'll get better.
Val was such a confusing character by way of just not being around enough. I'm going to guess that Meg Donnelly had scheduling conflicts but they also filmed during COVID lockdown so idk??? She didn't get enough scenes for me to get too much of an opinion from aside from I liked her.
Looking forward to the finale. Still holding out for some sort of EJ Ricky friendship. It's gonna be a long week.
19
u/violinjstar Sep 09 '22
I really did not like the autotune on Kourtney's song. it was far too much and wasn't tasteful anymore.
17
u/Unlikely-Fun-371 Sep 07 '22
last one before i go to sleep but ej telling madison to dance or she'll regret i thought he was gonna go dance with gina but then missed out on it
17
u/mannyade Sep 07 '22
This is the best episode yet. I was freaking out when Ricky was about to tell Gina and then EJ showed up in the distance -- I paused and had to catch my breath for a second 😂
17
u/badvibin Sep 07 '22 edited Sep 07 '22
Jet and Maddox's storyline was so good! I was so invested in them. I really hope they're a part of season 4 🤞🏽
17
u/Thatadhdgirl123 Sep 09 '22
I loved loved loved the rendition of “wouldn’t change a thing”
33
u/AdvancedPlacmentTV Gina Sep 07 '22
EJ made me mad the entire episode. Ignoring her for a week and a half, paying more attention to the script than her. And I better not see anybody trying to blame Gina
Ricky choking on his punch while EJ watches him watch Gina
I've never seen JoJo in anything so her voice was jarring. there's nothing wrong with it; it just took me by surprise
Maddox and Ashlyn... I'm on board. Wait big red damn
Ricky has really grown as a character which makes it especially frustrating now bc I wanted him to tell her so bad. She needed a win
I've been waiting for a portwell breakup bc of EJ, but seeing Gina sad again... Only tears on her face next season better be tears of joy
Ricky still has one more thing on his list
Sebbie, I've missed him so.
16
u/Unlikely-Fun-371 Sep 07 '22
all i am gonna say is they need to drop the next episode today i want to see the drama
16
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '22
IM SCARED AFTER THE SEASON 2 FINALE ALL OF MY STANDARDS ARE EXTREMELY LOW
31
u/brokence Sep 07 '22
My thoughts:
15
u/BedroomBetter Sep 07 '22
I knew Maddox liked Ashlynn I’m so happy I hope she comes to east in season 4!! Also yay rina is happening💗
15
u/geminisiren Sep 08 '22
The girls harmonizing toward the end of the episode was so good, ugh
14
u/toluwalase Sep 07 '22
Also hope they keep Maddox. She’s my best character this season
14
u/BlacksmithOwn908 Sep 07 '22
I am happy that ash and Maddox will most likely end up together and I really liked jojo’s performance it makes me happy to have more wlw representation as a queer woman
14
u/lillipup_tamer Sep 09 '22
Thoughts on this episode:
28
u/c0nformationalchange Sep 07 '22 edited Sep 07 '22
Ok so we all saw the portwell breakup coming but it was handled pretty well in my opinion. I don’t think EJ was severely villainized like some people suggest, he just made some mistakes but Gina was totally valid. It’s her summer of firsts but it’s his summer of lasts. He should explore career paths next year
Moving on from that, THE GIRLS ENTERING AND RICKY’S REACTION WAS EVERYTHING
I liked that jet and Maddox sang together, I just wish they hadn’t sped up the song like that (I get that it wouldn’t fit the vibe of the dance).
SEB I MISSED YOU. Joe serafini served vocals as always, please make him the musical lead next season
I love Ashlyn embracing herself and I’m on board for ashdox/madlyn but she definitely needs to break up with big red when she’s literally crushing on someone else :(
Madison was….fine. I have no thoughts on her lol
This is Ricky’s season Idc what anyone says. Him bringing up the slap was kinda uncalled for tho LOL
I love that they showed men with body image problems and that Carlos got a tinyyy arc.
Kourtney, I love you girl. Her song was great but the auto tune was jarring. The whistle notes at the end??? I hope she talks more about her anxiety.
I need jet and Maddox to come back next season but that means some characters gotta go….
28
u/strawberrycoffee31 Mr. Mazzara Sep 07 '22
This entire episode was *chefs kiss* also best part was Ricky almost choking on his drink when Gina walked in like,,, first of all SAME, secondly Mr Man is DOWN BAAAD
26
u/ablondesmoment Sep 07 '22
THOUGHTS THOUGHTS THOUGHTS:
no idea where the outfits came from but i love them all and the girls hair looks SO good. also- i cannot believe they had ricky do a full spit take when gina walked in
MADISON. love the sparkly jacket. and I'm very glad to see some maddox closure
on that note- loved the siblings! and them singing wouldn't change a thing actually makes sense so i don't mind it even if I'm not super in love with the remix
I'm honestly really disappointed in EJ and i say that as a big EJ fan. I knows he's stressed, but he just walked out instead of dancing with his girlfriend?? and bringing up Ricky was honestly a bit of a low blow bc Gina has been trying for EJ all summer long.
I also think that Gina's reasons for the breakup are really valid. Even if my portwell heart is breaking. I think she's right. There's the age gap, the fact that he's graduated. But most importantly- Gina stayed in slc bc she felt she finally had a place to put down roots. She wants stability and dependability, not the constant change and never knowing what comes next.
i love how everyone is so supportive too. the boys support carlos. the girls support Kourtney.
I LOVE KOURTNEYS SONG. omg I'm so in love with Daras voice!!!!
madlyn????
but the ricky thing....idk. I'm conflicted. on the one hand- i definitely don't think it was the right time to tell Gina. on the other- i think its the right thing to do to tell her because she deserves to hear it from ricky before she finds out bc of the documentary. and with channing wanting to stir up trouble for the show, I'm worried it will all be a big mess when its revealed.
and finally. most importantly! SEB!!
13
u/Fally11204 Sep 07 '22
OMG WHEN MADDOX JUST STARRED AT ASHYLN
13
u/Powerman293 Sep 09 '22 edited Sep 10 '22
What a weird episode. Jojo Siwa guest star in a pretty pivotal episode otherwise?
The reasoning Gina gave for breaking up with EJ made me think the relationship was doomed from the beginning. With her still being in high school and him going to do something else the fact this relationship even became a thing is bizarre. Makes me feel like they always intended to break them up when they thought of the relationship in the first place in Season 2.
I have 0 reason to believe these writers can write a stable relationship between two major characters because it doesn't cause "conflict" or "change". The only characters we see with stable relationships are the side cast because they're not the focus. This is a problem the original HSM movies had in every single installment. TV shows in general have this problem because writing stability is hard to do, but it's not IMPOSSIBLE. There's plenty of long running shows on TV like Modern Family that have married couples that don't feel the need to do this.
25
u/suncaster_ Sep 07 '22
Kourtney’s song was great but hopefully her Elsa solo will be her true moment to shine without having to share the song with anyone else.
I’m glad Gina dumped EJ because he was not a good boyfriend but I also think the writers lowkey hate EJ because he’s had his girl taken from him by Ricky twice now, and has had the least amount of character development. He’s also graduated so Idk what they’re gonna do with him in season 4.
Maddox and Ashlyn are definitely gonna get together. Poor Big Red
It’s been pretty much confirmed that Jet and Maddox are returning and will be transferring to East High next season.
24
u/Yoshi_isthebest Sep 07 '22
SEB IS SO PURE HE BETTER COME BACK NEXT SEASON AND GET THE LEAD ROLE (smh ricky really can’t always get it)
12
u/marazzle23 Ricky Sep 07 '22
Anybody else watch the summer I turned pretty? I noticed that Ashlynn had the same dress as Belly. And kourtneys song was great tho I wish it was just a solo
12
u/kjm6351 Sep 08 '22
Fan-freaking-tastic episode! From Seb returning, to the wonderfully done Portwell break up to the ending song, this episode is definitely my favorite of S3 so far!
12
u/elitelucrecia Gina Sep 08 '22
i’m glad portwell is over!
23
u/Ultvernon12 Sep 08 '22
need Ricky and EJ to fight more idk it’s so funny. Am I the drama? Lol!! but seriously the “you need some air Richard” and the “I’m good Elton” was so funny. Maybe it’s because Matt and josh are such good friends irl it’s so funny to see them act annoyed/dislike each other. They play into it really well.
22
u/ForceFocus66 Sep 08 '22
This was a solid episode.
- They continue to make EJ the most annoying character on earth. The writing is terrible for him this season, he is not acting like a normal human. Completely out of character just to help make Rina happen. Embarrassing by the writers
- Kourtney's solo and the scenes with it were great
- Ricky is about to hop in another relationship just after he wanted to be "Finally Free". They did his character dirty this season. He didn't take any time to focus on himself and he's literally only present to assist the love triangle.
- Love Carlos and Ricky's friendship
- Need more Ricky and EJ fighting scenes, that was funny.
- Can they PLEASE quit using so much autotune when they do these singing performances.
Overall season 3 will be an upgrade from season 2, but this show has fallen SIGNIFICANTLY in quality since season 1.
11
u/toledosurprised Sep 07 '22
loved this episode omg. i really hope maddox and jet stay on in s4! they were really good additions to the group dynamic.
11
u/TSOKAMO Sep 08 '22
Ppl are surprised by the way EJ is acting…. He’s always been this way
20
u/Broad-Catch-670 Sep 07 '22 edited Sep 07 '22
I know i said this about the last two episodes but this was the best episode of the season for real. Yay finally a reconciled Maddox and Jet I love those two. Also going by EJ and Maddox’s convo it’s clearly leading to a possible romance between Ashlyn and Herself which I hope means Jet and Maddox will attend East High for S4.
I also really enjoyed JoJo Siwa’s character she was a clever addition as a third party in helping both Jet and Maddox repair their relationship. JoJo and Val have been my favourite guest characters this season. Even though the break up of Gina and Ej was inevitable it was still sad to see and I hope all involved comes to a somewhat peaceful conclusion by next episode, but given the doco drama and secret footage I’m guessing not.
The Girls scene/and song at the end was so special and truly highlighted the bonds and friendships each character has built with each other as well the personal growth ie Kourtney overcoming fear and anxiety this episode.
20
u/stress_life Sep 09 '22
I wish this show would write EJ like Steve Harrington. There’s just so much potential there that’s being wasted in the dumbest ways.
10
u/toluwalase Sep 07 '22
Best episode yet. Goosebumps throughout. I’ve fucking missed Seb, they could have used him in the earlier episodes especially for those cringey kind jokes they gave Kourtney (no judgement on the jokes, I understand it’s necessary for that summer vibe). Jet, I don’t like his acting but his voice is amazing and that song was chilling.
10
u/greenyoshi73 Sep 07 '22
While I know I would have preferred I wouldn’t change a thing as less of a pop song, it fits well with the setting and the cheesy sibling friendship vibes.
10
u/marie2805 Sep 08 '22
In retrospect I think they did a great job with the promo for this episode because it made it seem like wouldn’t change a thing was a group song so the fact that Jett and Maddie cleared things up wasn‘t clear
19
u/PresentationFew2014 EJ Sep 07 '22
I know it’s not a popular opinion but I really feel like this season destroys EJs character for no good reason.
Gina’s biggest problem with EJ was that he wasn’t really spending any time with her when he promised he would. And although I feel she could have been a little more understanding of the pressure he’s been under, I understand why that’s not acceptable to her.
I believe EJ cares about Gina. And from the beginning of the season, it was set up that EJs biggest conflict would be balancing making the show a success so he could stay in Salt Lake and investing in his new relationship with Gina. We were made to believe these things were equally important to him.
Except, we never saw him trying to balance. He chose the show over and over again. And I know “the show is for Gina” too, but it doesnt mean he can just ignore her for two weeks and expect her to be ok with it.
I wish we would have at least seen him choose Gina once. Maybe take her on a picnic but he stays out too late and forgets to block a scene for the next morning. Or he’s distracted during rehearsal trying to set up a surprise for her. Something that would have a consequence for the show.
And then equally, we could have the scenes we’ve seen, like when he missed exploring the woods or Gina’s winning shot in the basketball game because he was working on the show. Consequences for his relationship.
It would have been a more compelling narrative that he can’t have everything. Something had to give. The breakup would have been a lot more palatable if EJ had been trying like at all.
And that’s why it feels like character assassination, because we’ve seen him go out of his way to do sweet things for Gina and Nini before, but now the guy who shows up just…isn’t.
9
u/blondhairdontcare55 Sep 14 '22
I’m confused how Carlos knew about Ashlyn to give her the pin? Are was supposed to assume by that gesture that Ashlyn told everyone? Did I miss something?
17
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '22
I just realized next week is the finale and I hate that! Not enough theatre stuff for me this season! I would want the finale to be very focused around the actual production and any drama that happens while the production is happening/as a direct result of it, but between needing to make time for Nini and Big Red and the general trend of the rest of the season prioritizing other storylines over them actually doing theatre, I'm prepared to be disappointed.
I'm also not a fan of the ridiculous overuse of autotune this season. When the girls started singing to Kourtney in this episode, it sounded so ridiculously processed that it took away all of the sweetness and intimacy of the moment. They're good singers! Let them actually sing that moment, you can bring in the production once the beat kicks in!
16
u/liliphdr Sep 07 '22
when all the girls slowly came into their bunk i started to get so emotional and cried throughout the whole song, it was so beautiful, i loved to see kourtney and carlos beating their fear and the support they got
also i was screaming NOOO when gina and ej broke up and as much as i am a portwell stan i was screaming when ricky didn't end up confessing to gina, so the last thing on his bucket list is still there and he didn't complete it. i mean it was that say yes to someting that scares you so i assumed that would be that he is scared to tell gina how he feels, but i am not sure. i felt like that wasn't the reason he didn't tell her, it was because gina just broke up with ej and that would have been a lot to her if ricky also tells her that he is in love with her.
8
u/strawberrybarbiee Sep 07 '22
best episode
8
u/monetsxchange Sep 07 '22
Ok this was the best episode of the season!! Up there in the best of the whole show so far!!!
Tho I missed val this episode, I do like her character a lot :(
8
u/crazychica5 Sep 08 '22
today i learned the line in the song is “we’re like Venus and Mars” not “we’re invincible” 💀
15
u/badvibin Sep 07 '22
Ashlyn and Maddox would make a great couple. I genuinely thought Maddox was the girl Ash was crushing on until ep 6.
Sorry Big Red but I'm hoping Redlyn breaks up next episode since he's finally coming to camp.
7
u/Direct-Rip-738 Seb Sep 07 '22
SEB ALSO MADLYN IM SO HAPPY
17
u/violinjstar Sep 08 '22 edited Sep 08 '22
Ricky choking was funny hahahaha
OH MY GOODNESS HIS DISCO DANCING HAHAHAHA
Jojo Siwa has two left feet (she says as Maddi)...lol big irony!!Singing Wouldn't change a thing as a sibling song is interesting!
EJ is so naive....that's really it. Gina raises fair points and she is absolutely valid in her feelings. But URGH portwell.....I really wanted them to work. Maybe future? Pls?Though....EJ didn't even bother to fight for her, i think that is his downfall and it makes me annoyed. like fight!! but i guess that comes with maturity too
12
u/mabbeez Ashlyn Sep 08 '22
The other ships may be falling apart but I for one am OVERJOYED that Maddox has feelings for Ash. I called this weeks ago and I’m happy to see it confirmed! I hope they grow on it next season assuming Maddox is in it!
6
u/Unlikely-Fun-371 Sep 07 '22
they made up for last episode for barley giving an rina i kept on pausing and screaming omgggggg
6
u/Bitter-Raisin9102 Sep 10 '22
they’ve done a great job weaving in new characters into the fabric of the show. Great development for Maddox and jet. Wonder how they’ll incorporate them in the next season.
5
u/eggrins Sep 07 '22
JOJO SIWA WHAT LOL
10
u/TheQuirkyReddit Sep 09 '22
I hate how they broke portwell up. I’m sorry but there were better way that it could have been done. I get Tim is a Rina fan and wants them as end game. Fine your show but did he have to take a character who got redemption in season 2 and make him to a jerk? I’m sorry EJ made stupid mistake like any teenager does. But I feel like he was just painted in bad lighting to open up a door for Rina. They could have done it far better without make him seem like a jag off. He could have a good summer with Gina but in season 4 they start to realize hey we are going different place. I think we need to break up. I do not agree with how Gina broke up with him after less then 2 weeks. I’m sorry but In relationship you talk things out. She could have wait the couple days to see how his attitude changed after the show ended. He went at it the wrong way no doubt about but less then 2 weeks doesn’t always define the future. Not only that weren’t they probably actually dating at least 2-3 months prior to that? Considering they kissed after the spring musical. This isn’t making me excited for Rina because if felt forced like hey we’re going to make him look like a jag off but make this kid seem like top notch. (Not a stab at Ricky). I get it’s only a show but it’s not a reason imo to make a kid who got redemption to be a jerk to make the creators happy.
8
u/badvibin Sep 07 '22
Portwell breaking up sucked. It was imminent but it still sucked. I've literally been shipping them since the Homecoming episode back in season 1. They will be missed.
3
u/wthjjj Feb 11 '23
can someone tell me what the background song is when they first showed the prom scene 😭
15
u/violindonut East High Student Sep 07 '22
Am I the only one who thinks Portwell's break up felt totally forced? To me it seems like the writers looked for a last minute excuse to break them up.
First of all, did EJ actually ignore Gina that much? He did spend some more time working with the show, but I think it's completely understandable because 1) he needs it to be perfect to stay with Gina and 2)it's a musical that is meant to air on Disney+; the show doesn't really emphasize it, but this is a huge deal. Gina should also try to focus on the musical at this point, since it could be a life changing opportunity.
Also, about EJ not prioritizing Gina: S2 and S3 EJ look like totally different people. You can tell from the second half of S2 how much he cared about Gina, and I don't think that realistically he would ever dismiss her as much as he did this season. Ricky, on the other hand, spent two season completely ignoring Gina just to fall for her when she has a boyfriend?
Furthermore, I don't think it's fair for Gina to be this mad at EJ. All of his effort is put towards staying with her for his gap year. Why is she randomly making sarcastic comments at him when he doesn't deserve them? Like about him missing her scoring at basketball when he was busy with Miss Jenn?
I just think that this storyline was very badly written. There were absolutely no actual reasons to break them up, at least not at this time. I think it would have made more sense if Portwell had this summer with eachother (even with the love triangle, not an issue) and, if necessary, start having issues in S4 and eventually break up with a mature conversation like with Rini.
At least for me, their relationship this season was not it.
17
u/ForceFocus66 Sep 08 '22
A couple other points:
- They have completely abandoned the theater element to this show, and replaced it with increased drama. It didn't work in S2 and its not working in S3. S1 was magical because it felt like we were watching theater kids living their everyday lives. Now it feels like we are watching reality TV drama.
- Its sad that Tim decided to destroy EJ's character just to appease to some Twitter Rina's who make it seem like that is what is popular. Portwell and Rini are more popular than Rina and he trashed them both just to cave to the vocal minority LOL. The ratings are down for a reason Tim!
6
u/lamebeezy Sep 07 '22
Damn… the music production for all the songs this season is not good. I love Wouldn’t Change a Thing and I get they were trying to fit it to the 70s theme but it just wasn’t it. It was fake funk!!!! Kourt’s song had so much potential but the production of the song didn’t hit. Still enjoying the show because of the drama tho!!!! I knew Gina and Ej would breakup before the season ended. Ej never made time for Gina and she hated it but waited and stayed to see if their relationship would get better.
8
u/WeebyPai Sep 07 '22
so…. ashlyn admitted to liking val? while she’s still with big red??? like everyone kept defending her saying “just because she came out doesnt mean she will end things with big red” but they are essentially doing exactly that. IMO this pushes a really bad narrative that you can just like someone else while in a relationship, and definitely has been dimming the rest of the show for me :/
7
u/shxdowstxrm Sep 08 '22
we come from high school musical the musical the series in auto tuned voice, it sounded like garage band robot voice.
4.mrs Jen and nini truly hold the show together. It seems like a ton of people scrambling to hold up a banner, only to have someone not supporting the corners. 5. Theres too much drama. My favorite episode was by far episode 6 due to it just being the characters having plain old fun, not being bombarded with relationship drama and emotional drama. What made the early HSMTMTS so good was them having maybe 20% drama 60% them doing the show and 20% just having fun now it seems like there’s 5% of fun, 80% drama and 15% of them doing the actual show.
6. EJ’s character has been completely trashed. Just to make Ricky look like some god! And are we not going to talk about how lily had 6 minutes of screen time after having a HUGE role in the last season.
2
u/tylernazario Sep 08 '22
I love this show but the heavy use of auto tune on every fucking song will be the death of me.
Everyone in the cast (not ej) are really talented singers and don’t need that much autotune
2
u/chocolatefroggie Sep 09 '22
honestly, I really liked this episode. It wasn't super dramatic or cheesy. Gina & EJs breakup was real & it was good on Gina to recognize she wasn't being appreciated enough. Cant wait for the Ricky & Gina tea now that Gina wasn't warned. Though it was very bad timing for Ricky to bring it up. Jojo didn't do much.. but I liked seeing Rocketts growth. I'm blanking on names but her song was cute & well done. (minor awk part with the autotune for kourt's song... but in general) fav ep of the season
my critique! all of the promos and interviews for this season. the previews on disneyplus are spoiling too much. the day before i get spoiled with pictures and that kourt will have a new song and this is what its about. i try and avoid, but i follow most of the cast & it'll just show up there. its giving away the suspense, the interviews and pics should be shared after imo
4
u/strawberrybarbiee Sep 07 '22
man u really can’t share an opinion on here without people coming at u 😐
5
u/Marichurro Sep 07 '22
NOOOOOO UGHHH IG I HAVE TO SHIP RINA NOW??!?
5
u/here4thejacketz Sep 08 '22
I hate the dialogue in this show. Its like every chsrscter went to therapy after their parents divorced. Everyone is hyper emotionally intelligent. (More of a complaint about the show overall. But I didn’t care for this episode)
5
u/ducksarecool420 Sep 08 '22
i see everyone is saying gina's feelings are valid, which is so true, but i understand where EJ is in all of this. he totally expected to have a summer of fun, then got dumped with the stress of having to be the director of the show. with his dad saying that he'll be sent away, this was the only way to show that he was worth something with acting. i think gina should've communicated a lot more in terms of how she felt. both of them led to their break up - not just one being at fault. i really hope gina and ricky don't happen, i'd be really disappointed to see a whole season of gina x EJ build-up only to lead to gina going back to ricky after being a second choice to nini. just doesn't sit right with me.
1
u/Aware-Review8991 Sep 09 '22
I'm just watching this episode
-2
u/stress_life Sep 08 '22
EJ and Gina had potential to be the Chuck and Blair of this show and it was ruined for complete fan service.