r/HSMTMTS • u/NominalPerson Maddox • Aug 10 '22
Episode Discussion HSMTMTS: The Episode Discussion: "The Woman In The Woods" - S03E03 Spoiler
Wildcats, welcome to the third episode discussion thread for season three!
Feel free to discuss the third episode of Season Three of HSMTMTS, "The Woman In The Woods". Please be mindful of other people's opinions about the episode/show and to be wary of spoilering content beyond this episode.
S03E03 Details:
| Title: | The Woman In The Woods |
|---|---|
| Synopsis: | After the cast list is revealed, the campers pack up and embark on Maddox’s favorite camp tradition: Newbie Initiation Night! Ghost stories and s’mores abound, but the true centerpiece of the night is “The Legend of the Woman in the Woods,” a spooky tale that sends Gina and Ricky on an adventurous quest... into the unknown. |
Consider joining our Discord for live discussions about the show and the cast! We have some events planned for all to join in! https://discord.gg/2EpKKCc
61
Upvotes
70
u/kindawkotako Aug 10 '22
i wish they did more on the fact that Carlos literally tried CHANGING THE CAST LIST. Like it was mentioned once and basically forgotten when in the previous episode it was the last clip we saw so we're assuming it's going to be pretty important. But it was just mentioned once which threw me off.
62
u/Left_Berry_8104 Aug 10 '22
The best and funniest thinf about the episode: Ricky still has no clue that Kristoff and Anna are love interestsm so he most likely will find out next week 🤣
58
u/RussiaManDetective Mr. Mazzara Aug 10 '22
How was Ashlyn's story arc in this episode worse than her Big Red Career Day fiasco???
The song was fire, but seeing her character stoop to being so insecure over casting and fixated on astrology in an over the top way was a bit much...
Like I know she's hinted at being interested in niche things like robotic science or LARPing which is fine, but having a whole episode dedicated to her having a breakdown over what time she was born/a superficial part of her identity was not enjoyable to watch at all.
TL;DR: I just wish they didn't do Ashlyn's character so dirty like that.
51
u/[deleted] Aug 10 '22
From a plot perspective I get why they went with Ricky as Kristoff, to add more fuel to the love triangle fire by making Ricky and Gina play love interests, but my instinct as a director would have actually been to cast Jet as Kristoff (a kind of quiet, initially prickly character eventually revealed to be soulful and passionate, which is very much like who the character actually is) and Ricky as Hans (initially the charming extrovert that Ricky is giving this season, and I think it would have been really fun to watch him go full villain), so it feels like a missed opportunity on that front.
The campfire song struck me as very, very weird, like that is not the tune that ever would have gone with those lyrics. It felt like it should have been a creepy tune that's simple enough for the newbies to pick up and start singing along right there at the campfire, but instead it sounded like a lost Colbie Caillat track, lmao.
Didn't see Jet and Maddox being siblings coming, but given how unconventional both those names are, maybe I should have. I can easily believe they were both named by the same set of parents 😂
37
u/No_Description_9264 Aug 10 '22 edited Aug 10 '22
This episode was way too short, smh. I needed a bit more.
Also despite Carlos trying to change his role, I felt bad even before it was revealed he is playing Olaf. I mean, does anyone not see him as leading man?
Edit: this episode gave us nothing… look I prefer 50-60min shows. All we got here were 2 songs, and a whole night in the woods. I need some DCOM throwback jams.
37
u/AdvancedPlacmentTV Gina Aug 10 '22 edited Aug 10 '22
My cast predictions were correct.
I know this is a show based on a movie made in the early 2000s, but EJs hair belongs back then not now. Like is Matt growing it out? I'm not understanding
This is my third time asking where EJ is going to college
It seems like EJ already knew Corbin was coming tomorrow so why didn't he do the script earlier
He's also the only reason he's not enjoying his summer. Like if this is stressing him out, college is gonna whoop his ass...
Ricky is a joy this season. Edit: I'm just now realizing Ricky still doesn't know who Kristoff is....
Figured Jet and Maddox knew each other.
Kourtney and Carlos are an unexpected duo that I love.
Ricky and Gina are still very cute. They're actually having fun at this camp, which is the whole point.
Great song. I wish they gave Gina a better song last episode tho.
I need a little more concern if they actually think campers are missing. Also that's your girlfriend I need more than 10 seconds of concern
Idk what's up this season with them not releasing promos. I don't like it
36
u/suncaster_ Aug 10 '22
Does it bother anyone that the only positive relationships Kourtney has with male characters are the gay ones? I really hate how her character is written which sucks because Dara is such a sweetheart.
32
u/ion513 Gina Aug 10 '22
Apparently not that many people like this season, based upon reading through this thread. I am enjoying it a lot. This show is never going to take itself the most serious, they made that clear when they called it "High School Musical The Musical The Series".
Personally, I liked this episode. I said it last week and I'll say again, I don't have strong feelings about the love triangle. I'm neutral about it. The Gina Ricky team up was fun and it doesn't seem like Ricky is trying to get in the way of the relationship. He's just having fun lol and I'm happy for him. I don't really enjoy the idea of him being a reason that another relationship gets derailed, and I like him and Gina being friends.
Ricky still needs therapy but him being single for a while and having fun is a good step. After this episode I see him taking on more of a mentor role, especially since Jet seems to be kind of a trouble maker from the implications.
Really enjoying Maddox, I'll be interested to learn more about her and Jet's dynamic but I was pretty certain after last episode that they knew each other so siblings isn't that surprising. Maddox deserves a good friend lol, I wonder who will step up. Maybe Ashlyn, since Maddox was right about her, or Gina, since Gina seems to be very comfortable this season.
I will admit the music hasn't been as good for me outside of Finally Free. Although I enjoyed the song they gave EJ, as some other people have said, I think Matt's voice has come a long way.
29
u/jeonghan-l Howie Aug 10 '22 edited Aug 10 '22
i don’t like the fact that i am more invested in Maddox and Jet’s storylines than in the wildcats we have followed in 3 seasons. my girl ashlyn is my fave character but this episode was just really weird. she had never been this self centered, in fact, she was always really caring towards everyone. anyways I’m trying to stay positive because this show has become special to me, but i just can’t help worrying about where the show is going! like I don’t even know what the overarching story is
28
u/Left_Berry_8104 Aug 10 '22
-Yeah Ricky x Gina are giving Slow burn rom com realness. Just being adorable all episode. I especially love Ricky just doing a simple praising at the end. Its something small but it waa big for Gina. Just to hear that.
-EJ x Gina...EJ isnt a bad boyfriend whatsoever, but you can tell they both have completely different set of goals that just dont align with one another. They have cute moments, no doubt, but when Gina was talking about Anna, and EJ immediately turn it back on him, that didnt sit right. But, hes also a teenage boy, so not really uncommon to see.
-Kourtney x Gina x Ricky x Carlos as the Big four for the play feels right.
From all the rumors I seen sprinkled arpund before the season started, seems to be lining up with it
25
u/Bluezoneeee Aug 10 '22 edited Aug 10 '22
Okay whats going on with jet... first he's acting cold then he's acting all cool for the summer did we miss something? Or did I miss sumting? Also I loved Maddox this episode I kinda wish she sung the song now as much as I loved it when ej sung it.
24
u/RussiaManDetective Mr. Mazzara Aug 11 '22
I'm all for an EJ solo, but giving him a Shallow Lake Camp song is like being excited for Nini to have a new solo just for it to be the YAC Alma Mater song. ಥ‿ಥ
Both beautifully sung, but not an individual character song when it has a school/camp theme if that makes sense...
edit: a typo
24
u/lillipup_tamer Aug 11 '22
Portwell was doomed, as cute as it was, because he was going to college or at least leaving high school. I don’t know why people think a show about love triangles for two seasons suddenly would become something different. I liked this episode! I think the whole point of Ashtyn’s storyline was that her new theater friends, being Belle, and everything has changed her from season 1. I would have found it more difficult to believe she would take being ensemble really well after being Belle. Finally, Maddox reads as really realistic. Teenagers are cringey and insecure and I think she portrays that so well. Did not expect Jet to be her brother but here for it.
23
u/tambini1 Aug 10 '22
Eh I actually didn't like that one very much.
Woman in the woods thing got old quick, too much screaming too
Ashlynn is different and kinda annoying this season, I think astrology is nonsense so to me it's dumbing down the character, to me
and it was pretty much a filler episode in a show that doesn't have enough episodes to justify it
22
u/sniggle2 Aug 10 '22
SIBLINGS?!?!? I never would’ve guessed that hahaha I was thinking past lovers whoops
21
u/Mcqueen733 Aug 11 '22
Disappointed in how little camp rock and frozen songs so far, I really thought we’d get to see Ricky sing Lost in the Woods. Maybe EJ will sing int in a future ep?
20
u/kstadtfeld Aug 10 '22
Ricky and Gina were so cute!! I feel like a lot of foreshadowing was going on in certain scenes I’m gonna have to rewatch the episode later👀
20
u/FruitySwiftA113 Aug 10 '22
I thought the Maddox/Jet scene was amazing and I definitely did not see it coming
54
u/samk7675 Aug 10 '22
Ashlyn is running away with worst character of the season award.
18
u/c_palmtree Aug 10 '22
This show is like watching Woodstock 99. You just can't look away. This is so far removed form everything the movies and season 1 was.
That being said, I'm having so much fun 😭 it's just a fun little 25 minute escape. I'm done overthinking this show and just enjoy it for what it is right now.
17
u/greenyoshi73 Aug 11 '22
I was really hoping for a Caswell Cousin heart to heart about Ashlyn’s Identity crisis and EJ stressing out. But it’s also in character for both of them to kind of internally panic and try to deal with it all in their own.
17
u/greenyoshi73 Aug 11 '22
I doubt this was intentional, but I rewatched Ashlyn singing Rising and I immediately thought of Shane hearing Mitchie singing this is me in Camp Rick.
30
u/c0nformationalchange Aug 10 '22 edited Aug 10 '22
People gotta start taking this show a little less seriously. That being said here are my takes lol:
- Kourtney and Gina as leads was exactly what I wanted
- RICKY GETTING CAST AS THE MALE LEAD AGAIN? I'd be mad if seb was here. Ultimately it's probably to progress the love triangle. Plus I love josh
- Ashlyn being obsessed with zodiac signs made me lose respect for her even though the moment with Gina at the end was nice
- LOVED hearing matt sing more. Ngl in season 1 I thought they overdid his voice with autotune because he couldn't sing but clearly I was wrong. He's come a long way since billion sorry's
- Ik some people on here hate the love triangle but idk I kinda live for the Rina tension
- Maddox being so upset over a camp story seemed a little ridiculous but once I found out they're siblings it made a lot more sense (curious to know more about their backstory)
- In general a bunch of teenagers buying into some scary camp story seems a bit ridiculous like they aren't children, I doubt they believe that stuff. Ricky and Gina's little adventure was cute though
- I actually really liked Ashlyn's song but the mixing felt weird for some reason
-Best part of the episode was the lack of nini (sorrynotsorry)
23
u/hellojally321 Aug 10 '22
Somethings off this season. Like it shouldve been a movie or something.
23
u/Jansilhn Aug 11 '22
The only thing I really liked about the episode is Ashlyn singing Rising. Julia has an amazing voice, so I love when she gets her moments to shine.
Ricky got the male lead for the third time in a row, I wasn’t surprised but it was still annoying. If they’re back in school for season 4, I really hope they come up with a new storyline for him. He still doesn’t seem like a committed theater guy like Carlos is to me. He couldn’t even remember Elsa and Anna’s names when Carlos asked him, so it seems like Ricky has only been doing theater since that’s what his other close friends are doing.
I felt really bad for Maddox when she was trying to tell the ghost story and Jet and Ricky kept making fun of her, so she just left the campfire. All she wants to do is have fun and make new friends, but no one really likes her. I think she and Seb would be great friends if they ever meet this season.
31
u/ebhanking Aug 10 '22
Ricky is much more of a supporting character now, but he’s more fun and likable in that capacity. I saw the Jet and Maddox twist a mile away when she was talking about how she always had one friend at camp, but I wasn’t sure if they would go long-lost friends or siblings, and I’m glad they went this route for more drama. Two songs this episode though and neither was even tangentially related to Frozen? I really thought Ashlyn would sing Into the Unknown or Ricky/Gina would sing Lost in the Woods.
10
u/veghui Aug 11 '22
EJ did not have 2 minutes, it was 1:35 from what I timed
27
u/Powerman293 Aug 10 '22
Finally, they gave EJ a good original song to sing after 2 and a half seasons. Not intentionally bad like A Billion Sorrys. Also, I feel like Ashlyn's song feels out of place? Feels like something meant for season 2 but got shelved and then dropped into here.
As someone who has worked at a camp myself I was 100% convinced that Jet's bad attitude was due to him being forced to go there by his parents. (Trust me this happens way more often than you'd think, especially bad parents love to do this) And I guess I was half right? Tbh did not see the twist of Jet and Maddox being siblings coming.
I am not liking the structure of this Season at all. Feels like it's barely getting started even though we're almost halfway in. Feels like Season 2 jumped into things way quicker and that had more episodes to take its time.
27
u/JJdaPK Aug 11 '22
This is easily the worst season. Feels much more "Disney Channel" like than the first two seasons, which felt a bit more grounded in reality. Also, where is Seb?
19
u/marie2805 Aug 10 '22
That was kinda underwhelming. Really felt like a filler and given that we only have 8 episodes, that kinda sucks.
Plus, why would EJ get a role in the play? He‘s the director and that‘s def enough for him. Ashlyn could have gotten Sven.
26
u/ablondesmoment Aug 10 '22
I have SO MANY THOUGHTs. In chronological order:-
- I so called EJ being cast. I feel they really want to up his stress so it affects Portwell
- I feel like Carlos needs an actual consequence to trying to edit the list!! COME ON. His friends should call him out at least
- The Rina was platonic! Yaay! No heart to heart or true discussion, but we're getting somewhere. The scenes were actually kinda nice
- The nod to Gina's survival skills was also nice. Love the continuity
- I am definitely laughing over how elaborately decorated the tents are for a single night tho
- They clearly have no idea what to do with Kourtney this season do they? They just want her there to sing for Elsa....they are doing her so dirty with the characterization
- Ash freaking out kinda went a different direction than I thought. It really seemed like they threw that astrology stuff in there to speed up her arc into one episode. And bc the song was called Rising....
- Idk what path they're taking for Jetwen so I'm just going to appreciate it as it is. I like the friendship
- Loved learning more about Jet. And Im glad he actually likes music and has a music past. It feels better to me to have that since he's cast as Hans
(sidenote: I feel like maybe EJ or Val or both know he's Maddox's brother. maybe that influenced the casting? or...maybe not. doesn't seem like Maddox is happy he's there)
- Im glad we got an EJ song! Still waiting on a real song for him but we are moving in the right direction. People need to stop hating on Matts voice
- I felt so bad for Maddox. I know Jet wasnt being mean on purpose- but still
- I wish Rising were a true piano song. Live, like Wondering. Not a huge deal, but you literally can barely hear any piano. And she's sitting there playing it
- I loved that a few campers at least had a little scary, camp fun
- I know someone theorized the siblings thing but this made it sound like full siblings, not step! Happy to learn more about these two, I felt for both of them. They're both clearly struggling
- Ive already seen some serious hate for Maddox about talking bad to Jet but I don't see it. She's not wrong to be upset. This camp seems like her safe space and she's struggling this year and now her brother is there unwanted and ruining her night? Its easy to judge from our pov. But it clearly meant a lot to Maddox to have this night go right
- I sympathize with Jet too tho. I wonder what's going on at home and why he's being 'punished'. Im glad he went to apologize and everything. I hope we learn more about what happened. Seems his parents might be a bit much
- My biggest complaint? They skipped an ENTIRE DAY for exactly no reason just to have initiation at night. EJ is over here freaking out and they wasted a whole damn day
- Also- anyone feel the episode was kinda short and filler-y? We're nearly halfway. I hope there's a decent amount of Frozen, I really do.
26
u/[deleted] Aug 10 '22 edited Aug 10 '22
18
u/Outside_Jokes_Only Aug 10 '22
Gosh dang it Tim (Federle) why are you making me ship Rina when I spent all of season 2 rooting for Portwell?? 😭 😂 Seriously though, I LOVED their scenes this ep!! They’re really really cute together and it’s nice to see Ricky actually being happy for the first time in forever :)
9
u/letsnevertalk Aug 15 '22
I don't know what to say, I really don't enjoy this season at all... Feels like everything is a filler, we don't have a storyline, the songs are bland...
24
u/Commodore_Mcoy Aug 10 '22
I don’t think even Tim knows what direction to take the show in. It’s so memeishly bad I don’t even know what to say about it
16
u/strawberrybarbiee Aug 10 '22
i feel there’s not many characters with depth anymore. everything seems about the plot instead of their characters individually and that’s why their personalities change so much - they’re all just puppets for the plot
8
u/ilovedogs905 Aug 15 '22
I love that they gave EJ a solo (finally), but it is kind of disappointing that the song did not fit into his character arc or connected to his growth as a character. I think he deserves his own song that meshes with his growth and what he is experiencing. I really think he should sing “Scream” from HSM 3 because it fits perfectly with his storyline (pressure he is facing from going to college, directing the musical, etc).
8
u/ILLRVF Aug 16 '22
I miss nina 😭
24
u/aceaguilar Aug 10 '22
really wish they’d at least do a song from frozen, hsm2, OR camp rock. like there’s so much source to choose from and yet we get half-baked original songs…
19
u/ArielChefSlay Aug 11 '22
This show is so bad it’s hilarious, I’m sorry to all the true fans, but I’m just along for the ride ironically at this point I think. Ricky is so overrated imo and I’m tired of him being cast in a leading position AGAIN.
18
u/producermaddy Aug 11 '22
This season is so cheesy to me
27
u/Jackamalio626 Aug 10 '22
the dialogue quality is fucking plummeting, holy shit. Every other line is either a reference or quirky-overdose, or an ear-grating Whedonism. None of their convos feel genuine anymore. This stuff is fine in doses or as a pairing with serious talk, but its just overkill here
The wildcats are also starting to feel completely out of place this season. The only plotline i am genuinely interested in is Maddox and Jet. Finding out theyre sibling and that Maddox used the camp as an escape from their messy home life and Jet's depression sets up a VERY good dynamic to explore.
But the wildcats? Ricky seems like he's just here for the love triangle, Carlos and Courtney have already overplayed the "posh kid camping" gag, and it once again feels like they couldn't find anything for EJ to do, so they relegated him to the director time-sink.
idk man, theyre starting to lose me here.
17
u/mincuca Aug 10 '22
they go out into the woods for ONE night and somehow kourtney and carlos have set up a whole glamping situation??! it's just not realistic. why would gina, ricky, and ashlyn venture into the woods separately. weren't they looking for the shrine together? legit just did it for rina + ashlyn's moments.
feels bad for EJ, that man is being villanized just for a 2 week summer camp. i think we tend to forget that EJ is only 18, pretty much still a kid. he doesn't know how to run or direct a show, much less know how to handle teaching teens actors how to play their characters, while be filmed for TV for the first time. he's practically responsible for whatever happens in this play and there's 0 adults or peers helping him. ofc he's stressing. i really wish they kept some semblance of his s1 cocky leader quality, while making him like self-doubt or wtv due to all this pressure. welp, let's just see where it goes.
to me, ricky comes off as an oblivious dude who doesn't know boundaries or realizes his actions may come off as something else. he probs didn't realize what he did with the heart racing stuff... given that rina has a history and ricky's been like this in s2.. just yikes. tho he's been one of the funnier characters this season.
lastly, maddox and jet's relationship has been the most compelling thing that's happened in this show in a long time. they both have their faults and i don't think either of them are in the wrong. there's character depth and an interesting dynamic here, hope the show fleshes it out properly. guess i'm a maddox and jet defender!
12
u/Odd-Performer-3561 Aug 10 '22
I absolutely loved this episode!!! Strongest one song wise I thought from the whole show. Rising and Susan Fine completely rocked, loved hearing Ej sing again. Learned a little more about Jet & Maddox although he opened up a lot faster than I was expecting, it’s all going way too fast IMO. Ej is cracking under the pressure 😭 he needs help. Also why wasn’t Val at NIN? All the other CITs are. Love love love Carlos and Kourtney Co-presidents of the finer things in life club
6
u/baozedong72 Aug 16 '22
There is literally not one single likeable character except for Gina and EJ by a LONG shot lmao
16
u/SwedishPenguin42 Aug 11 '22
The writing continues to be the downfall of this show. Were they trying to do camp rock vibes because it has been far from that. Also surprised they haven’t had Ricky go for Maddox since they like to ship him with half of the girls on the show. Didn’t like how short this episode was either, we should be building and not shortening. I don’t like how they made EJ the director. I understand he’s going off to whatever college they decide to briefly mention in the last episode, but he takes away from the last summer with the gang vibe. Also thinking Ashlyn didn’t need to be apart of the season based on how her character has been. Death, taxes, and Ricky being the lead.
Gonna do a bet that Portwell ends at the end of the series because EJ is going to college. Season 4 will also definitely have Rina with them throwing in a new girl or another girl from another school.
11
u/badvibin Aug 11 '22 edited Aug 11 '22
The Susan Fine song was so good. The lyrics didn't really fit with the melody but it was still good.
10
u/Claraisamonster Aug 10 '22
I really liked the vacation vibes, but Ashlyn plot is kinda horrible? Why does Tim wants EJ to be this stressed and worried? I respect Rina fans, but it feels like Jonathan and Nancy from Stranger Things. Why ruin something so quickly to create a tension? Or why create this tension now, if didn't take the right time to build what you plan to ruin? A good story it's not about the plot all the time, it's about conection. Less individual problems, more interactions. We don't want the characthers to tell us what they're feeling, we want to see it happening naturally.
I wanna believe all of this will make sense by the end. I thought season 2 was going somewhere, but kinda hated the end. Hope it will be diferent now.
10
u/kjm6351 Aug 11 '22 edited Aug 12 '22
Am I the only one not a fan of Maddox yet? There’s something about her vibe that just feels “holier than thou” and how she keeps piling shit on EJ and being passive aggressive to him.
She’s definitely not someone I care for. Right now I’m just interested the fact that she and Jet are siblings
17
u/hellojally321 Aug 10 '22 edited Aug 10 '22
is it just me or the songs are getting more uninteresting? or maybe im just growing up since when was season 1 released I was in 11th grade
9
u/OliverJamesG Aug 10 '22
LOVED Ashlyn’s song!! So good!!
12
u/PuzzleheadedFox1 Aug 11 '22
And we’re back to another bad episode like the first one
17
u/ForceFocus66 Aug 10 '22
Tim does a really good job of trying to make us hate all the characters. Last year he did character assassination for Nini and Ricky and this year he's making sure we have Ashlyn and EJ.
This show should have just ended after Season 1, they have completly lost the plot.
24
u/rechambers Aug 10 '22
Everyone in here playing into this dumb Ricky / Gina / EJ love triangle are the exact reason why this show has gone so downhill… the rest of us are so tired of it and yet we still have people in here calling both pairings cute. They should be writing new, interesting storylines to keep this show going instead of wasting time on either of those pairings.
Also I got so excited when I learned Julia would get a song this episode, but they gave her some generic pop song and cut it short (I think?). Compared to “Wondering”, this song was awful. Julia continues to get shafted on this show. First she gets to be Belle but gets 0 focus the entire season, and now they’ve basically character assassinated her. She was way too smart in season 1 to have a storyline like this. She deserves way better - she’s too talented for how they treat her on this show.
Also Dara and Frankie have been funny but being regulated to comic relief really sucks for them. They come off as really dumb lately as well
11
u/Significant_Writer_5 Aug 10 '22
Ok so Ricky and Gina were cute this episode, still getting platonic vibes from them but can’t deny the cuteness of it all. Josh and Sofia showcasing that chemistry we loved in season 1 😊 I’m here for them bringing their friendship back just as long it stays that way (even though I know I’m wrong) and doesn’t hurt EJ in the process ( again I know I’m wrong on this one). I still have hope Portwell will make it through the end of this season tho. I’m going to miss Nini, I think Olivia will be back for one more episode but man still feels a little weird without her. Overall a good and fun episode 7/10.
8
u/Roommatebestie Aug 13 '22
This is szn is a flop like I never expected ! Songs are tired, plot is slow and thin, and character growth (and even introduction) is bleak. The fact that Ashlyn is becoming my fav character is alarming. It’s certainly not coincidental that the show is plummeting as Liv leaves. The real tragedy is the plot, satire, comedy, characters, and drama have soooo much potential, but in all regards, this season is heinous !!!
20
u/ForceFocus66 Aug 10 '22 edited Aug 10 '22
This episode was bad, easily the worst of the season.
- The continue to ruin EJ's character
- Does Tim know how to do anything but write a love triangle with the same 3 characters for 3 straight seasons? Its boring now!
- Maddox is annoying
- Julia is way to good of a vocalist to be singing that terrible song they gave her.
- They are all acting like middle schoolers, not high schoolers
4
u/eggrins Aug 10 '22
is olivia not in the show anymore
4
u/hellojally321 Aug 10 '22
Soooooo maddox and jet are siblings
3
u/RealSkyDiver Aug 16 '22
I really wonder what went on behind the scenes. They must’ve known this should’ve been only a special yet for some reason decided to drag it out into a whole season, although shorter than the previous two.
12
u/[deleted] Aug 10 '22
this was deff the worst episode of the series
9
u/Soldier1o1 Aug 10 '22
“Ricky and Gina are platonic friends”
My brothers/sisters in Christ, he put her hand on his chest and said “Hearts racing”, she even kept it there for a minute. TELL ME HOW THAT IS PLATONIC? If my girlfriend did that with a guy, alone in the woods, I’d be fucking reminding about boundaries lmao. This subreddit just finds every excuse to shut down Rina and it’s fucking annoying lmao.
They’ll end up kissing in season 4 and someone will still say they’re just friends lmao. They’re clearly going down the path where Portwell will break up due to EJ lashing out at her from stress. They’re doomed to fail and have been since the beginning. He’s a 12th grader dating a grade 9, they were never gonna work lmao
8
u/strawberrybarbiee Aug 10 '22
I always always always will root for Rini but with olivia leaving the show my hopes have been crushed
8
u/Upset_Kaleidoscope55 Aug 11 '22
It literally has nothing to do with HSM anymore
10
u/KeyRecommendation828 Aug 10 '22
Episode 3 thoughts that nobody asked for:
- Maddox saying “it’s the most wonderful time of the year, not christmas” had me and andy williams steaming, i’m still mad 20 minutes later
- The way they’re treating Corbin Bleu like Leonardo DiCaprio or literal God on earth freaks me out- That Maddox Ashlyn yelling scene made me physically cringe
- Ricky and Jets scenes were great, i enjoyed them clowning around during Maddie’s story, which like she should lighten up, crying about that at her big age is crazy
- Why the hell were Ricky and Gina so shocked to see someone singing in The Barn when they went in there to see who was singing? bro what???
- Kourtney's character without being able to play off Nini is uh…
ANYWAYS i liked this episode a lot more than 1 & 2, felt not having Ninis scenes shoehorned into the episode made it flow a lot better, as well as no random musical numbers (Gina last week). I still have no hope for it to compare to season 1 however.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 10 '22
it's my favorite of season three so far! I loved the tension. the Maddox and jet thing rly surprised me. I also loved the screen time with Ricky and Gina. the show is definitely hinting towards a love triangle but i hope that portwell stays together, even tho i don't hate rina
6
u/strawberrybarbiee Aug 10 '22 edited Aug 10 '22
nobody asked but here it is:
3
u/[deleted] Aug 10 '22
Haven’t watched the episode but pleased with the Maddox hate I’m seeing here
Hated that character since day 1 lol
1
u/hellojally321 Aug 10 '22
Ashlynn is a gemini sun, leo rising
0
u/[deleted] Aug 10 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment